Bürokratizm Hastalığı ve Çözüm Önerileri

!
!
"#$%&'!"('!)%*('!+,-./!0#12&31&%1(!456(-717!8*9(*7:;179;<!)'%(9(=!>(%?@$!0(AB'1(9B<!CDDE.!
!
!
!"#$%#&'()*+,&-'&./0/+12+34)"*+452#(.2#(+6+
!
F1%7G;3-7! H59#%9(2;';'! I797%! J9I5*271! AJ'-7'! K7! I797%27! L#'%2;A#'1(9B!
AJ'5'-7'! 6;--;! 2#9&'1(9B! H&1&'G(%*(-B9.! M&! %B2(! A(3BGB3-(! J'67! 51%7G;3-7!
H59#%9(2;';'! A53! A537! H&1&'-&N&! 2#9&'1(9<! -(O(! 2#'9(! -(! H59#%9(2;!
O(2*(1BNB'B'!#9*(-('!%(1-B9B1G(2B'(!AJ'71;%!PJ35G!J'79;179;!2&'&1(6(%*B9.!!
!
!789:8;<=>?=?+$8@;A;+3B:;8CBDB+-98E?F;8+
!
M59#%9(2;';'!J9I5*271!2#9&'1(9B!;P79;2;'-7!($B9B!G79%73;A7*P;1;%!K7!I;31;1;%!J'7G!
*($BG(%*(-B9.! ! Q(G&! AJ'7*;G;'-7! IJ97K! K7! A7*%;179;'! R7%! P#N&! G79%73-7!
H59#%9(2;';'! 71;'-7! *#R1('GB$*B9.! M59#%9(2;';'! A(RB2B'-(! J*7-7'! H79;! I;31;1;%!
O5%5G! 259G7%*7-;9.! >(17'! A595915%*7! H&1&'('! S7K17*! 47G&91(9B! Q('&'&! -(!
H&'(! ;G%('! 2(N1(G(%*(-B9.! 8J3%#'&2&! %('&'&'! ET.! G(--72;U! G7G&91(9B'!
-7K17*;'! IJ97K179;! ;17! ;1I;1;! #1(9(%! H(2B'(<! O(H79! (:('21(9B'(! <! 9(-A#! K7!
*717K;3A#'!%&9&1&$1(9B'(!H(%('!A(!-(!K(1;';'!;3';!#1G(-('!-7G7P!A(!-(!H;1I;!
K79G72;';!A(2(%1(GB$*B9.!V37*17<!H59#%9(2;-7!WA(2(%PB1B%X!K7!XI;31;1;%X!6;--;!H;9!
2#9&'!-&9&G&'-(-B9.!!
!
M59#%9(2;';'! J9I5*271! 2#9&'1(9B! -B$B'-(! L#'%2;A#'71! 2#9&'1(9B! -(!
H&1&'G(%*(-B9.! QB9*(2;A76;1;%<! I797%2;3! L#9G(1;*7179! K7! %&9(16B1B%<!
2#9&G1&1&%*('! %(PG(<! ;$179;'! 2595'67G7-7! HB9(%B1G(2B<! (-(G! %(AB9G(6B1B%! <!
O;3G7*2;3! G7G&9;A7*1;%! +(9R(1B%1(9/! K7! 2(;97! 2#9&'1(9! H&! %#'&-(! J9'7%!
K79;17H;1;9.!!
!
3GH7I+4?J8=FJ8=+
!
F1%7G;3-7! *5G! %(G&! %&9&G! K7! %&9&1&$1(9B'-(! G7K6&*! #1('! WH59#%9(*;3GX!
O(2*(1BNB'-('! ! %&9*&1G(%! ;P;'! '7! A(RB1G(1BY! M&! %#'&-(%;! J'79;179;G;3;!
A(3G(A(!P(1B$(1BG=!
!
• M59#%9(2;';'! 7*%;'<! K79;G1;! K7! (-;1! ;$17G72;! ;P;'! A(2(1(9B'! O79%727!
&AI&1('(H;1;9! *(93-(! WI7'71X! #1(9(%! -537'17'G72;<! (A9B6(1B%1(9! I7*;9G7G72;!
2(N1('B1G(1B-B9.!0(2(1(9U!H(2;*<!('1($B1B9<!(PB%!K7!'7*!#1G(1B-B9.!
• 479%73;A7*P;! A(RBA(! 2#'! K79;1797%! ;-(9;! K7! G(1;! (-7G?;! G79%73;A7*P;1;%!
+A79;'-7'!AJ'7*;G/!&AI&1('G(1B-B9.!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"
!"#$%&'!"('!)%*('<!WM59#%9(*;3G!>(2*(1BNB!K7!ZJ35G!V'79;179;X<!M('%(!K7!,%#'#G;%!0#9&G1(9!
S79I;2;<![;2('?E\\\.!2.!]T?]^.!
!
!
!
!
• Q(G&! IJ97K1;2;! #1(9(%! (*('G(A(! ;1;$%;'! &2&1! K7! 72(21(9! (PB%! K7! '7*! H;9!
$7%;1-7! *72R;*! 7-;1G71;-;9.! 47G&91&%! A(3B1B! 2B'(K1(9B! AB1-(! H;9! %(P! %73! #1G(%!
53797! G79%73;! H;9! #9I('! *(9(LB'-('! A(RB1G(1B-B9.! 8J315! 2B'(K1(9<! H59#%9(2;-7!
%(AB9G(6B1B%!7N;1;G179;'7!'7-7'!#1G(%*(-B9.!8J315!2B'(K1(9B'!H(3B!J371!G7217%!
(1('1(9B!-B$B'-(!*(G(G7'!%(1-B9B1G(2B!I797%1;-;9.!
• M59#%9(2;! I797%! ;2*;O-(G! AJ'5'-7'<! I797%27! (9(P?! I797P! K7! O;3G7*!
H;9;G179;! H(%BGB'-('! 2597%1;! H5A5G7! 7N;1;G;'-7-;9.! M59#%9(2;';'! H5A5G72;<!
O('*(1!H;9!-7K17*!A(RB2B!#9*(A(!PB%(9G(%*(-B9.!M59#%9(2;';'<!2;A(2(1!;%*;-(91(9B'!
H(2%B2B!(1*B'-(!2597%1;!A7';!%(-9#1(9!*(O2;2!7*G7179;!G&*1(%(!7'I7117'G71;-;9.!
•
S7K17*!AJ'7*;G;'-7!K7!H59#%9(2;-7!(PB%1B%!+$7LL(L1B%/!2(N1('G(1B-B9.!!
• M59#%9(2;';'! ;$17A;$;! %#'&2&'-(! G5$*79;179;'! +K(*('-($1(9B'/! $;%(A7*179;';!
PJ35G7! %(K&$*&9G(%! (G(6B'(! O;3G7*! 7-767%! _GH&-2G('! H59#1(9B!
#1&$*&9&1G(1B-B9.!
• M59#%9(*1(9B'! 7*%;'! K7! K79;G1;! P(1B$G(1(9B! ;P;'<! (*('('! H59#%9(*! ;17!
O5%5G7*! (9(2B'-(! R79L#9G('2! 2J317$G72;! ;G3(1('G(1B-B9.! M59#%9(*<! IJ97K-7!
H&1&'-&N&! 2597! ;P79;2;'-7! H71;91;! R79L#9G('2! K7! H($(9B! 2*('-(9*1(9B'(!
&1($G(AB!*((OO5*!7*G71;-;9.!!
• M59#%9(2;-7! H71;91;! O;3G7*179;'! A79;'7! I7*;9;1G72;'-7! +! ;$A79;! (PB1G(2B! ;17!
;1I;1;! #1(9(%! 9&O2(*! K79;1G72;! K2./! J'67-7'! H71;91;! H;9! 2597! *72R;*! 7-;1797%!
K(*('-($1(9B'! G(N-&9! #1G(1(9B! J'17'G71;-;9.! >(17'! H59#%9(2;-7! ;$A79;! (PG(!
;17!;1I;1;!#1(9(%!P#%!I797%2;3!L#9G(1;*7179!;2*7';1G7%*7-;9.!`&O2(*!;$17G179;!&3&'!
259G7%*7<!($B9B!H59#%9(2;!K7!%B9*(2;A76;1;%!;$17*G7179;!%(P(%!#1(9(%!+9&O2(*2B3/!
P(1B$G(A(! 27K%7*G7%*7-;9.! )A9B6(! L#9G(1;*7179! K7! &3&'! 2597'! ;$17G179! 95$K7*!
K7!*#9R;17!LB92(*!A(9(*G(%*(-B9.!!
F1%7G;3-7! H;9! ;$A79;! (PG(%! ;P;'! %(RB! %(RB!-#1($G(%!I797%G7%*7-;9.!a797%2;3!!
L#9G(1;*7179! 3(G('! ;29(LB'(! A#1! (PG(%*(-B9.! @$17G179! ;P;'! I797%1;! L#9G(1;*7179!
'7! %(-(9! L(31(1($B92(! 95$K7*! K7! A#12&31&%! -(! #! -79767! (9*G(%*(-B9.! ! M&!
%#'&-(!(1B'(6(%!*7-H;9179!2#'!-79767!H(2;*!K7!&AI&1('(H;1;9!#1G(2B'(!9(NG7'!
H&I5'7!-7N;'!H;9!(-BG!G((1727L!(*B1(G(GB$*B9.!!!
M&! (1('-(! H59#%9(2;! K7! %B9*(2;A76;1;N;! (3(1*G(%! ;P;'! A(RB1G(2B! I797%7'!
;$17G179;!($(NB-(!J37*17G7A7!P(1B$(1BG=!
• @$A79;! (PG(! K7! P(1B$G(! 9&O2(*B! K79;1G72;! ;17!;1I;1;!;$17G179!H(2;*17$*;9;1G71;!
K7!%B9*(2;A76;1;%!(3(1*B1G(1B-B9.!
!
!
!
!
• @$A79;! (PG(! K7! P(1B$G(! 9&O2(*B! K79;1G72;! ;17! ;1I;1;! #1(9(%! J371! H;9! A(2(!
A595915N7!%#'&1G(1B<!!!G7K3&(**(%;!-(NB'B%1BN(!K7!P#%1&N(!2#'!K79;1G71;-;9.!
• @$A79;! (PG(! K7! P(1B$G(! 9&O2(*B! K79;1G72;! A7*%;2;! G7217%! #-(1(9B'(!
-7K97-;1G71;-;9.! 47217%! #-(1(9B'-(! `&O2(*! @$17G179;! M($%('1BNB! (-B! (1*B'-(!
H;9;G! #1&$*&9&1(9(%<! 9&O2(*!K79G7!;$17G179;!H&!H;9;G!(9(6B1BNBA1(!A595*517H;1;9.!
`&O2(*! K79G7! ;$17G179;! J'67! #-(! ;P79;2;'-7! #1&$*&9&1(6(%! `&O2(*! @$17G179;!
Q#G;2A#'&b'-(! 717! (1B'G(1B! K7! H71;91;! H;9! 2597-7! 2#'&P1('-B9B1G(1B-B9.! M&!
%#G;2A#'-(! #-('B'! J3711;N;'7! IJ97! I797%1;! &3G('1(9! IJ97K17'-;9;1G71;-;9.!
`&O2(*! ;$17G179;! %#'&2&'-(! IJ97K17'-;9;1G7! ;P;'! H71;91;! %9;*79179! G&*1(%(!
#1&$*&9&1G(1B-B9.!
• `&O2(*! %#'&2&'-(! -7K17*;'! 2(-767! -7'7*;G! IJ97K;! #1G(1B-B9.! Z(1B$G(!
9&O2(*B! K79;1G72;! A7*%;2;! A&%(9B-(! H71;9*;1-;N;! 53797! *(G(G7'! #-(1(9(!
-7K97-;1G71;-;9.!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!