縦書きと横書きはどちらがしっくりくるか? -文字種

Þ©¶©$ / 01Ĕ
Ď¡}ÔCfïCæÐ|U #’ ĆĎ
Which writing fit better,
vertical writing or horizontal writing?
‚† çzčT­ Ž˜čt± žg
Yuta Terashima, Yasunari Sasaki, Toshihiro Bando
k•Ñy~
Doshisha University
[email protected]
Abstract
!ď¥»§O"!1č 4æë1ú
Japanese is a rare language because of two types of
writing direction (vertical and horizontal writing).
However, there is little reason for our switching between
the writings. Therefore, we examined which type of
writings fit better for sensibility estimation of Japanese
words consist of three types of characters (kanji, hiragana,
or katakana) on two kinds of medias (paper and computer
screen). As a result, there is a difference of writing
direction across each word presented.
Keywords Writing direction, Emotion and
notation, Sensibility estimation
j/č ~Ąí!
‡¶©#,#Ä2
1čæڇó¶©ċ‡/ñ){+1¶©Č
½û&
čIĀÊ"$(ĉ²)#!,
#ďčy¹§O# 1920 Œčr«ý
øýø`×4‡¶©æëć/čą
ìŠ-¢à,iÞ©‡¶©WÆ
21wď#ć"$č
iÞ©ē
¤¯q«CRÜÊč
‡¶©ē¸ÙµZC>:B
5=D7˜Öč€Í1ď#“¦o"
Đď$+"
[,‡¶©XÆ21|Uw
¤¯ïÆ/21¡}#©}£l$č¡}å
ďz‹¾™N$(č¸ÙÊ5=D
22F/Gi/‡"ö*iÞ©
7#‡¶©$X3!.".č
č‡/iF/G"ö*‡¶©# 2 Ô
÷d,,##čX32!!1$
Ĉ1ďÄsč¤¯ï#©}£l#X_$·
!č1949 Œ]ĂYnõù\Æ
#."!1ďĐČ
iÞ©
Ēv-¼³č
¡V˜#uÀ"".č
iÞ©"ª
„ð-pã©!
#©Ø-¢àčÂÇ#m^!
30‡¶©\Æ¡"
M"X321
čđȇ¶©
Ē6B;?D9-‰ąìč !ď´!,#‡¶©EâÊ
~-Ò~!
#ƒÿ©črïPx#ŸÒ©!
č
!0č
‡¶©$iÞ©K%©}£l#
1ď
iÞ©$čLr/Á}R°
895@![1]ď
ć/Äs(þX321E£č‡¶©
‡¶©#bÃ"$č1951 Œ#rï
$R°‘a$X32!©}£l0č¨h
òQò\Æ¡#‡¶©" 9 #b
#$É eŒ#Ā1ď
঩X
Ü/21趩"#ÌÒ~C
32$+#$čºš§O®¬"[/
”Å~ÏÕ".1čñ*ă"$¡}4è_1é
1ďä~cáčxrï#¶©¡}#ā30
ü¶þ1Px$&'ˆ$!č¡}4›
/č¤¯ï,‡¶©Ä2$+č¿I
©1ă"$¶©--«bӍčÞ
Ý-xrï#ô©"
‡¶©æë21
©C¶©#«bHb$—2".1,#yč
,#Ä21ď2$xrï#æë4ËS
Jß"«–!ˆÈ$!
0čۅ‡¶©
0čEâÊ!î΍,(Ċ$ê
#bÃ$©-
}CAD<}#©
±Yï/[2]Ě
ç·
½·
«×ʘĔxsë0-!v
·•±€!cm
Ă
Č"Ę
½·
"®
•+UXN•!ãY….+_Ž
ÍĚ'|ç·
³ÖÊ
"Ù¼Ò
›!,z¤2/ą&̘Ĕ
pÆcÌvĂ"[
÷š nvĂ\ù
Ì
ÿĔÌďŒDX@>CE(FW03)[3]+mēĂ
/Ê͖†Ę¨é-c10ä/
¡òę‹ó­úÇę[4]-Ĉlʏ—Ë-#
ê-0/ĚĘ0'|ç·
#.
Ą)
Ę'ĘvĂ!§Êù
/
œă!mĊĘ
½·
0/9X@5œ
ê-0/vĂ2ĈlĚvĂ!‚þ"ĘîÛĂ
ăЊĘ!£Đ2{½·
0/
!‚þ/þWtþW¢™þ! 3 ØēĚ
·ß*ЊĚ^
,"Ę
|ç·
,.
þ"Ęŕ!('"ŕ$-Ä.òü
½·
0¯Ü!±Ą(+Œ'
/vĂ 22 g0-!¯•j2$-ò
ì0//Ě[
½·
0/:V
ü 22 gĘ,%Ćd7@7Fòü0
JQX@+¬žčĀ!“aŸ´yĘč”
/vĂ 6 gĘû 50 gĚtþ¢™þ"Ę
·ß*¹»Ò
ŕ$-Ä.òü/vĂ200 25
ĉf"'/ʦ‰u!ć)
ÈÁ!Z|ç·
½·
"vá¨
g0-!¯•j2$-òü 25 gĘ
dcm-0''Ę¯Ü!k™+
û00 50 gĚ
òדa
ÏhpÆ pÆ" PowerPoint2007ĖN58U?
¤±Ą(+!"
ê-0/Ě
KEėb©Ěwoâº`"ç 15cmĘ½ 30cm
¹ÕÚ"Ę·•±€!cmĘv
wo*!2pÆĚD4<LT5º`"
/¨d
RCLECLI?:VĖStudio17 DELLė! 17 5
,/*!"Ę¯Ü!k™+vĂ!§
Ę/"¯•!òדa
¥
¤Ę·•!±€
āÔÒ,%¦åÒô„Č1/
ą&/2ÓÒĚ
VBöPG@
ç½!ÀÉ 1Ĝ2 ò×0
/*!2pÆĚpÆ!öø"à 30 Ěíµð"ÑĘÏh!Z‘
|2¾±¢
ĕçæ2i0Ę
mrʝ|}đˆ!Z‘
·•±
ě̱Â
€ç½!~vĂ2ĉèĖ… 1ėĚK6VE
2.1 ̘ Ĕ xs ë
" MS ³¸Ę;5=" 60 M5VE•Ě
˜Ĕxsë"Ę²¹^—Ë 11 Ė’” 2 Ę
}vĂ!ç·
½·
!|!ĉè"vĂċ‡
Δ 9 ėĚ]q3V9XE"Ę°ì+
Ý
¹2Ą)Ē "xsë¿
RVAOĚ
''Ę5V
@XHCE" 10 ^,õ/
ƒÞĖò 1ėĚ
%& %&
%&
%&
#
"$! 2.3 Ěª ä ˜Ĕ"Ęwoâº`*D4<LT5º`**
2.2 Ě p Æ
00gnñĘpÆ"˜Ĕxsë!¾Ď
vĂS<E ˜Ĕ"ĘŕĘ$-Ę7@7
Ě1 ÿñ" 1 vĂ!ýe-Ě}ÿ
FòüîÛĂ2woâöD4<LT5
ñ"ʝ|
è
ĉè0ç·
½·
!vĂ!
)*+¸v”,lW
ux˜Lœ~.¸¥”fD”
®žr 5 ƒ±\—Xµ1¾l¸2¾
¥ 3 +ºux‚Sª¸$*|
.
)l¸3¾Z¸4¾)W¸
­t+“Ž´Sª+ºTMš}C81
5¾W¶¨GŒ_\—š|º»
6;A2}C|gz[°¥§yg¬
©¤NŠv”{¯ 7 •ºTMš}C
#/ºyg–(m`H‘
i³¡{¯„š.%º816;
+&¸KD)}C&€|
z
A2}C PowerPoint 6>294=B¢.
c­
E£P«%º¸\—¯Y-
'!)…"¸ˆg|
oº
aY¸\—0|º
ˆgc),+Vy'¸ˆg.Ÿ²hŸ
,ºyg–¸373:
9?@|
),+º,)h
¼ºœ~ j
Ÿ(+2<B5‰^’+)¸ˆg
Sª„|
¨Go.¥u¸™
|
o+¦›+ ]¹1 )·1 +(ux.˜Lº
),+º
ux˜Lz‡¸UO¡\— 5 ƒ±\
v”NŠk+lW®ž­eso.
—X¸NŠ„lW®ž|gz[
¥ulux.†%ºlux˜Lz‡
)Y-¸|gz[¨Gbw
¸œ~q), 5 ƒ±\—X.¸¥½.&
p¸¥ 2 (‹xQ¸n 1 NŠ„ux
‹xQ¸n 2 ˜Lº
.˜LºF
¸lI|
Sª®ž
,aY1\—,
¸|gz[
(% - / ¨G|
*+*¸q‹
4,6?
46?
q‹·0.7 ‹+º
0A@-
6?
&% " - / :39
/6?
,6?
;6?
:3
D:
;:
D:
;:
9/
. E(
6?
.6?
%
.
6?
D6?
lux·1 l®ž­eso¸¹1 W
®ž­esoº¥ 5 ¥”fD„lux
˜Lœ~+ºlux‚Sª¸$*NŠ
l®ž,&c­
,Sª+º
816;A2}CzTMš}C(*&lux
''´+J[ºi³UO¡dR0
'%
/ .) + 2
+)C
! , - / / 3 4 )1 0 * - $/ # D78
52HI
B1
*F8
$"&'
D78
<
G
52HI
B1
*F8
<
G
>3=
!#!%
# $ % " ! #!/
')*
(%23
.$
"0*
')*
+
1
(%23
.$
"0*
+
1
-&,
E4F>2E;F@<>0*¿-c²
àÏ}
-+à.
‘¸)–´µ–m
¼Å,à3;3?¼Å[Èw,
qO*,(à&/B:5EŸ–qO0
bÚ'à[ÈÒs)r®ADE8
• *¿
,à$¼­qO
¤‡0‹…¾-â.+¾d0žÄà
|+¿
"+¼Å[È("+
p'-m(ƒÙ-]¹†-â
+ÆQvÌ0[È+±#³e0-
àŸ–0§sqO¿-+
*,àrª+.-=62E)^®¼­qO
*,(à|+Ê%p'-|Ÿ–(m
‘—ѼŢ0à$à‘
Â.-ƒÙ-]¹†(¶+.-â
rPª©j)º
ÑX–r’`
†0¿V]¹†(Œâ
ãây˜
L„ËÚàš¬¯tܛN0½Hà
\¶¨
tÜ\Z·~Ýz0IMÕÐ-
[1][2] x_¡É, Þ2003ß“Ÿ–«iᓚȼÅÎMá”, {
£–€à[1]pp21-31, pp44-82, pp115-186, [2]pp179-182
[3] oӉ”àλUJàhšRGàԙÖGà
Þ2006ß
Àu
Y[ÈKÁÇܪØl=F;9<>ÞFW03ß
àNØlÍ
¥5E:F71C
[4] g°gȬ¯Šà
Þ2004ßWÛȂ¼ák½ŽÃ¦áàn
“šf–
à$àr¼­qO)¼­©j)º
*|-[ÈÒ!.)S,¿
+.-tܛN0à+à
[ȇa)Pªi×0¶ˆT.Wœ
…¾-âštÜ
àr®0 3 ®Ûª