MSM(Men who have Sex with Men)

ῌ,**0 The Japanese Society for AIDS Research
The Journal of AIDS Research
MSM Men who have Sex with Men HIVῌAIDS HIV/AIDS Studies on MSM (Men who have Sex with Men)
from the Perspective of Cultural Anthropology
Akitomo SHINGAE
ῌ
Doctoral Programs in Modern Cultures and Public Policies, Graduate School of
Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Japan.
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science.
: MSM Men who have Sex with Men
2 : .1῍/, ,**0
hZG<U7;!a2)
<Y"@AB #
`)*#+. O#
@5A HIVῌAIDS
$
H
6I@i%<Y";K<LMN#.
!"# HIVῌAIDS !$% &'()*#+,-#. /)& 0
12)345
67%891%:; HIV ῌ AIDS
+ῌ+ "#$%&'()*
OUOU+$I& O\KBj%
k&'
!"#+l$Zm<U7;)*7
<=>?@AB CA@D
;. n Medical Anthropologyo +$I(p&
HIVῌAIDS <E+? F
G
+30* )R*qrsteuv
?%H6I@J<87;K<LMN#. O
yA O(p,z-{.& /0<&|}
P) QR
+N#k&' !"#<1~N#2$+?%
!"# HIVῌAIDS H6I@
S<'T0+A):#K<LM?;$.
!$%w+x1;U
+_@A[<U7;U)*7;,.
031<X5& +32* )z€ u
+
HIV ῌ AIDS !
6# HIVῌAIDS !$% O1~2‚<
; 4I0++@7;. 5-ƒ „…q†‡ˆ‰†qŠ
‹Œq6 !"#78Ž9<}‘#&
)& 34 !"#5 5UV
WX
6# HIVῌAIDS Y< MSM Men
6<87%:; Gilbert Herdt & ’:
!aKB 5&8“5++U
who have Sex with Men +Z9[KB\ LM
0”•–—+?% ˜[;X™:y
?%$T. /&+$I(KBLM)
+š™%$#-. 2; +320 ) › œž
*#A O]^V_)*#+& `@
Medical Anthropology QuarterlyŸ ) 8“
!aKBA891%$#bcde@")*#. O
5)*# Ron Stall & 6# HIVῌAIDS 1& 6[f$!aKB Cg
A<=)*#+ >?;. Stall & ¡‹¢£‹¤¥¦
!"#§C¨©ª¤«¬7 N#“?­<87
E5FGH : ¶-*/῍2/1+ _Tƒ·I¸J +῍+῍+
ῌ
¹Kº
Fax : *,3῍20.῍,-+/ E-mail : [email protected]
,**/ ) , » +* ¼L ; ,**0 ) + » +1 ¼M
%:;A §7A HIV ®@<A‘;} nB?$o C
¯A*# UZ9B°©ˆ¢±ˆῌ©²ª¥<89@$a
e OD³=´Aµ)*#K<N#0+A
52‚)*#+,I..
.1
.1 A Shingae : HIV/AIDS Studies on MSM from the Perspective of Cultural Anthropology
+,00- ™ š 2' x / ,**+ # ›# { Ž
89 &Annual Review of Anthropology'œ ^BS=T
| } x ] B ^ _ Richard Parker3' Brooke G.
! "
Schoepf+*' Ž89~B
!"#$% &Health Belief Model' ()*+
+ῌ,
,-./
012 34
Douglas Feldman +32* #$56
" !"#$% ()*/
0789:9;%<=ῌ>?87@A&'
/(
dU (!7€
)* " !"#$% )*+.B/'
€./ ž9Ÿ9n 4 &practice' #$% ῌ +,-3
! "12 ‚X ‹ƒ|9’%4
!C*DE & F9GH9ῌFI;JKJ
„0 HIVῌAIDS (!¡…*DU]B
;.FI;J!L12
/M
+/6†v6 |9’%¡…t‡4
' ῍ ,0N0OP0 & Q$AR1

ˆ<UM/¢E_
B 34£=9%1
BS=T20UM' ῎ ,0N3
HIV ῌ AIDS 46Œ,-! Schoepf
45(VW XE & +( B637
‰Š‹˜
.Bt>}
Y5789(' ῏ :;Z[<=>2
9¤ŒD]
1+!t:¥!
\?E & @<UM' !2]
¦Žg
Mm taƒ6]/§ž¨}
0ABU]B^_ Feldman <=C( (`9a
©9}
B HIVῌAIDS ‘(!ª«
b9Dc0
EdFefGHD
’3†6†.B++' x/ ¬­®%
1+gDhIiG(jJ4
.
^ D HIV ῌ AIDS † “ ” • , - . / R.
B S=TKkl(cL1+ MmB
Parker S|@AI;¡…(!tA–
/!#$%)*X nN
U]4U]B—˜/+,' ™
(
o^B 2nOBp/0]
¯š›0°tA–U]/
#$%)*/PQRS
12_ œ”^B\?U]BN(¯
(+E.BqOU]
šžN
_!
!
¬­®%1
+^+ rT12
sO
)*
[0/ ]±Ÿ
.B R.
U]B t20' " !"#$% +
Parker >}9¤&B ^DH¡
!j
ῌ!"ῌT1(UVuWX_^
¢=Q9®&£!S|@AI;=Q9®
B rYT1Z[1+Y\vw(
’3
_ F9GH9ῌFI;JS|J¦
6]]!
Ž
_ ]
€5
1+
6
x_ y=KJ;(N
!E (N.B^_+3
3/
Ez6
12 {
MSM †6Œ“”•]²(‚X
=|}ῌ~I €5,-.B+/
¤j¥t³6
‚¦12 g
,-Bp`
‚Baƒ2
/]X ,-1§ 4¨c…
„bc…
†_dUB ,-eO
(,-dU0­=G´JaK97©5
#$%4f+ovw
ghB^_
B µ9Ja­KR<=ῌ>?87@A
F9GH9ῌ
TUV,0ij^Dkl‡m0
F I ; J 4  † ¶ [ 0 B . / Gray
+
!rneO ˆ$cE‚B/6
Dowsett+-' ¬­®%^D<=ῌ>?87@Aª
‰opq12
Šq*D0]!
(t B“”•«¬R
!~|9{%
1'
‹rsx1 S=T6Œt
,-
S06†/ Richard Parker+.' RQK’T^
X Ž89
Bx
60]B^_ n ,-u
D<=ŽTR}†6}
B Martin P.
Bx
x_‘Mv6B +33. # RQK’
Levin eds.+/' ·}G­}¸J>^D­@}¹RQK’
“” &American Anthropological association' S
<=C(†3t,-./ Rafael M.
=T,-
•–†—˜” &Commisson on AIDS
Diaz+0' RGK’¹RQK’t^D­(º&
Research and Education' wx-yS=
Z » ¬ 9 HIV ῌ AIDS † ¼ . /
T,-Ž89.B zS1tD
Bronwen Lichtenstein+1' RQK’T^DR®R
.2
& .2 '
The Journal of AIDS Research Vol. 2
No. +
,**0
ῐ
Joseph Carrier et al.+2 , HIVῌAIDS ῐ !"#$%&'()*+
Roger N. Lancaster , ῎-
ˆ{|E HIV :}{‰gŠ~‹
./012ῌ34
M) , "Π" ujY#M
'()*+ cochon 5!67
M ^€ŽaB‡G6
89:;:<=>
HIVῌAIDS 0€2CD῍ >Ab
6?+3 @
Kd*‘‚ƒa„…&CYs
!"
MSM Neil McKenna,* A, #
z{: ^€Ž0€ |E;:2
&BC# Dunbar Moodie †,!… ;:^€Ž>G>6
A,+ Moodie ; &BC#8$D1
z{:? FK ^;:CD?G HIV ῌ
%&'E78 ()*+F+?G,-<H
AIDS 0€’“Y8A
.7-.IG6 A/JKFL
,ῌ+
8&MῌNOP)QRS6?
HIVῌAIDS +32* st|‡ u68S6yˆ‰”
TU01VW:28 XNYBῌNOP)Z :
=fῌK῏gaŠCŠy!, HIVῌAIDS [345 A
C)P6\&M ῌ
u~TUaK῏gHE45l
NOP)7]>6^8 ^6G\8G7
+I‹Œ)Y•–ῌ—–˜% HIVῌAIDS 9:>6:;<=_^7]
~=yKb =Œfg‹M)z8
# ^6G01>?@`aA b Bc l ™{TU:šΐ;,›ŽœG6
ῌ3CDdEFG῎e0;:HG
^,0 u6F‘XlH HIV ῌ
XIJfῌK῏g hCritical Medical AnthropologyZ
AIDS 0€’S,1 u<“”,2 ˜BžY,3
,,
5!6LiM=G6 ^;:N5
X•–*qgZ-* —“”ῑ˜-.-+ H Paul Farmer
,.
y HIV ῌ AIDS ™Ÿ>6A b Y ^N5H K7O%jY
Kb¡š¢ u^?G HIVῌAIDS ~=y
kMῌ32M^: l XPQ
Kb£›dœn=n$y ^6G¤¥¦§
RmZ SH;TU>6 V
¨<E ©”ª«>G>6Kbf
Scheper-Hughes N5 Oῌ3CD
ῌ«-?G¬­Bc~sS6
-.nGo Wῌp7ῌq῎rPj-.X
-,
,-
d Nancy Scheper-Hughes
YZ[?GI0;:a[8 Farmer G\]
HiMs ?^6G HIVῌAIDS 0€Y ®že
yŸ¯ ^€ŽI>6‹M).
? IJfῌK῏gH^ EFG῎t]
>68Ab°ῒ<=y‰gH :n Kb7_`abc uvwK7
¡8A -- +32+ s&C#‰".
Od+>/ HIVῌAIDS %jYkMxefg0
±H?G#C"¢²£¤>6Fu ^€Ž
?^8yz{:? ^[ h|
³c.±H$B)˜M-.A8
iBajBCD[8A ^CD l
?ŠS6¥0 ‰g¦§´¨N8
0}MY kHlm8 HIVῌ
l u®žµ©Abœn<§dªI«,¬
AIDS 01]:n ~:
o6pq;:
R8l-.
r: u^8 +32* st?G^y HIVῌAIDS
u¦®žjB9w C)
0€2CD ,-~ +2 R‚FuK
P % M Y ¶ E  8 A + K ῏ g H Nina G.
vƒq„wx;:Cy…?
Schiller C)P%MY¶E­·a0
? 2Ab>?zM?6†
N?CS¸!G®¹ uEC)P%
K HIVῌAIDS ;:z
MY¶+—Ha^; º}2œ
,/
u6‡
? MSM -.?Ga
+2¯°±=²;:zs:-/ X³Z d X´2Tµ¶·HZ ¸»C)P%
MY¶E u¹ºœH»¼ 01]:¼
–a8?:~S6
.3
h .3 A Shingae : HIV/AIDS Studies on MSM from the Perspective of Cultural Anthropology
~
G; HIVῌAIDS zi,r
!
#€ῌ‚sU8B 5I ƒ‚„
"#$% &
Ronald J. Frankenberg t…†‡ῌƒˆsU8k'‰@=#?H
&
HIVῌAIDS &&
$.*/%
'&()*
)€ῌ‚qŠ?r
u,9? `ˆ
$+!#$,- HIVῌAIDS . …‹ŒŽa ,$OcJ"C% |} 9,
$-0/% 01" U
`‚YƒYa ?‘v\!? 0g `ˆ…‹
Melissa Parker #( 234 HIV ῌ AIDS ŒŽa ,$OcJ?’.Q\!% 0) `ˆ…‹
5
+
+0678
ŒŽa “w”#xI? • ῌ –—
9:;""#< ,=>?
†˜„
,y%,#<% `ˆ…‹ŒŽL.a
@#$,
+ 1!
"9#A
B $%
`ˆ…‹ŒŽxIa `ˆ…‹ŒŽῌp„™š›„œa
?C"#$,&'9-1/% &
DE
,$OcJ +32* ^z{Rž •ῌ –—
()*+F
G;HI,
-J
#G5
†˜„|}#cJ1T,#.+/%
HIVῌAIDS #HK L./0#(M1
)•ῌ–—†˜„1Ÿ,~>
"+N23)O,9?4#HK53
`ˆ…‹ŒŽa , 01" `ˆ…‹ŒŽa
$%

€xI9 S QR
‰@O),%m9
,ῌ, % `ˆ…‹ŒŽa 
F,‚ƒ?„O% •
6P HIVῌAIDS .QR7 S89,0
ῌ–—†˜„?9 `ˆ…‹ŒŽa L.,p„
T$:<;<=>U% ?@
™š›„œ– ‡œ QR[…j†‡9
"+-,G5 HIVῌAIDS "S?(O
),
#% 00¡¢ Hzi?"U
&M"M"#< ,VW!
#$P `ˆ…‹ŒŽa ePHEF\!ab\
SXY#89)AB
=>U
!),,#.,/% 4
Q $ _ sˆ£R¤/
ZC,[D8,$O"EF
\H\!U
`¥Yῌˆ…‹ŒŽa ¦‰&+ HIVῌAIDS ?Od/
%
0&$<DŠ‹U
i=H!#$:*O% 
",(O
!F\! @S]
€ῌ‚qŠr#ZC HIVῌAIDS Od/0
,G^9:*O% &
Mary
&
g ,$OcJ§
`ˆ…‹
Douglas $ _ `H!a ,,Bb
T$
ŒŽa ,$OcJ“,95Œ= ‚ƒ+j,
I$ cJ?K!$+5
k5l{0O,,o=%
+LM"C,+N% T@5, OdeP
¨g#pYq
G$+ ¨©
"9Ž)Od
QR
fS\!+,Bb?C5 g#h
ª,08?+N\!5 C$$ _‘
T
G$!F\!#;!W#H#$,i=H!% C
# `ˆ…‹ŒŽa ,#’¨gmB?«“p„™
S?G^9), #U#j"C
š›„œ9),? ¬­
,y%"C,
#HKQR#+"+C % )O# Douglas k
o
'.V\l#?H W
Elizabeth Miller Ža `­Y¯„ŽŽa +,°<#A ±Y²
-2/
!®$.-/% $
_ `¥Y ῌ ˆ…‹Œ
XY
G;WmB HIVῌAIDS "9"M,Z
Ž±Y²Ž&\H
@³<´µ?C5 +,
XY
n[
QH!,o ! `pYq\r] sAIDS
+,OdwBb|"”¤JJ¶$ MSM ?
Neurosis/a 2I$-3/%
\H
`¥Yῌˆ…‹ŒŽa |H+”¤\!,$
,ῌ- O•y”¤h‡9),+C5–% )),? —
t^ HIVῌAIDS #A9uQ, _
`,ab\!cd\!:;"#
g8—˜
(O#·¸¹º$
+ »$%
#<"C*O%
$% R?
3!S 23 eHῌe
fHvw g hxH!1" y9
Hzi9+j,k5l{O
%m\!$
-
!"#$%& MSM '()
"C% T@5 3!S|
}n +<*#?H hῌZC sbio-power/ ?op
&
W
MSM q\!$,i=H!% *i Tim Brown Y
HIVῌAIDS :™"C,\!? Y¼"0!H
/*
s /* /
The Journal of AIDS Research Vol. 2
No. +
,**0
gy Quarterly +1 (,) : -0ῌ-1, +320.
/ R Feldman D : AIDS health promotion and clinically ap-
HIVῌAIDS plied anthropology, (Feldman D, Johnson T eds), The
!"#$%&
Social Dimensions of AIDS : Method and Theory, New
'()*)+,) -
York, Praeger Publishers, p +./ῌp +/3, +320.
.
*'/012
0 R Jonathan M, Daniel T Q Q¢£¤RῌS¥T¦UR :
3% - 4151)6. 7
_X` ῌ §u¨m‰| “ O 1F'@AV
8.%9:;.<)'%
Wž XŸ ©YZ‡j[}uª‹ p ++,
.3= >?'
MSM ')?@2
.A$ B'151)C
+332.
1 R «X¬uῌ­‰® Q¯°±² ³SJ\ ´8]
D.E% .EFG
µ¶· ¸^¶(UR : ’Bῌ¹ῌº»“«X
$H&
AI 7FG$J D.
¬u ῌ ­‰®’B¼·ž XŸ _`ab
KLMN I MSM OP(!'"#
,**+.
:; QB(!DCR S-J.$%'%
,) &TF Q'UV BWXC ')(
)*R .A$Y# QsubjectR '
Z+$
2 R Bolton R, Orozco G : The AIDS Bibliography : Studies
in Anthropology and Related Fields. Arlington, American Anthropology Association, +33..
+[.9:;.\, Qsubject toR Y#%
3 R Parker R : Sexuality, culture, and power in HIV/AIDS
Eῌ-]8^U. _X`ab.
research. Annual Review of Anthropology -* : +0-ῌ+13,
A$ MSM Y#]cde/G$0JfI 3
,**+.
=_X`12g&
433h
2O
i4%'5cU
6DOP 3=-].A$
+*R Schoepf BG : International AIDS research in anthropology : Taking a critical perspective on the crisis. Annual
Review of Anthropology -* : --/ῌ-0+, ,**+.
:7jk%..R BDlmnopqC ++R Schoepf BG : AIDS, sex and condoms : African healers
48r-]j'.9%2J:;
and the reinvention of tradition in Zaire. Medical An-
<&% 2s BWXῌlmno
thropology +. : ,,/ῌ,.,, +33,.
pqC '3=(2
3=>.cU.k
+,R Parker R : Sexual diversity, cultural analysis, and AIDS
tuv'%,) ..A$ MSM j
education in Brazil, (Parker R, Aggleton P eds), Cul-
''. w?@AxyBz{|}~
ture, Society, and Sexuality, London, UCL Press, p -,/ῌ
C'€%.:2‚ @ADz'
p --0, +333.
ƒ„… .A$ MSM +-R Dowsett G : Practicing Desire : Homosexual Sex in the
†‡D 7ˆ‰vŠ‹| HIVῌAIDS ''
Era of AIDS. Stanford, Stanford University Press, +330.
.(4E0 Œ‡F'
0<)G
+.R Parker R : Beneath the Equator : Cultures of Desire,
'./
S-Ž#.H
Male Homosexuality, and Emerging Gay Communities
V+,)
in Brazil. New York and London, Roultedge, +333.
῍
ῌ
+ R Brown P : Understanding and Applying Medical Anthropology. London, Mayfield Publishing Company,
+332.
, R IJ‘K : D’B“”{•–—ῌ˜™~
š{›~pœ.A$’B8LMž ŸN O
¡PŒ p +*ῌp 0+ ,**+.
- R Herdt G : AIDS and anthropology. Anthropology Today - (,) : +ῌ-, +321.
+/R Levin M, Nardi P, Gagnon J eds : In Changing Times :
Gay Men and Lesbians Encounter HIV/AIDS. Chicago
and London, University of Chikago Press, +331.
+0R Diaz R : Latino Gay Men and HIV : Culture, Sexuality,
and Risk Behavior. New York and London, Routledge,
+332.
+1R Lichtenstein B : Secret encounters : Black men, bisexuality, and AIDS in Alabama. Medical Anthropology
Quarterly +. (-) : -1.ῌ-3-, ,***.
+2R Carrier J, Nguyen B, Su S : Sexual relations betweet
. R Stall R : The behavioral epidemiology of AIDS : A call
migrating populations (Vietnamese with Mexican and
for anthropological contributions. Medical Anthropolo-
Anglo) and HIV/AIDS infections in southern Califor-
/+
Q /+ R
A Shingae : HIV/AIDS Studies on MSM from the Perspective of Cultural Anthropology
nia, (Herdt G ed), Sexual Cultures and Migration in the
-, Songwathana P, Manderson L : Stigma and rejection :
Era of AIDS : Anthropological and Demographic Per-
Living with AIDS in villages in southern Thailand. Social
spectives, Oxford, Clarendon Press Oxford, p ,,/῍p ,/*,
+331.
+3 Lancaster R : “That we should all turn queer?” : Homosexual stigma in the making of manhood and the breaking of a revolution in Nicaragua, (Parker R, Gagnon J
eds), Conceiving Sexuality, New York and London,
Routledge, p +-/῍p +/0, +33/.
,* McKenna N : On the Margins : Men who have Sex with
Science and Medicine ,* : +῍,-, ,**+.
-- Murray S, Payne K : The social classification of AIDS in
American epidemiology. Medical Anthropology +* :
++/῍+,2, +323.
-. Patton C : Inventing AIDS. New York & London,
Routledge, p /+῍p 10, +33*.
-/ Schiller NG : What’s wrong with this picture? The hegemonic construction of culture in AIDS research in the
Men and HIV in the Developing World. London, Panos,
United States. Medical Anthropology Quarterly 0 (-) :
+330.
,-1῍,/., +33,
,+ Moodie D : Migrancy and male sexuality on the South
-0 Frankenberg RJ : The impact of HIV/AIDS on concepts
African gold mines. Journal of Southern African Studies
relating to risk and culture within British community
+. (,) : ,,2῍,/0, +322.
epidemiology : Candidates or targets for prevention.
,, Singer M ed : The Political Economy of AIDS. New
York, Baywood Publishing Company, +332.
Social Science and Medicine -2 (+*) : +-,/῍+--/, +33..
-1 Parker M : Anthropological reflections on HIV preven-
,- Farmer P : Pathologies of Power : Health, Human
tion strategies : The case for targeting London’s back-
Rights, and the New War on the Poor. Berkeley, Univer-
rooms, (Ellison G, Campbell C, Parker M eds), Learning
sity of California Press, ,**/.
from HIV and AIDS, Cambridge, Cambridge University
,. Scheper-Hughes N : An essay : AIDS and the social
body. Social Science and Medicine -3 : 33+῍+**-, +33..
,/ ῌ : ῌῌ !"
#$%& p 0῍p ,, ,**+.
,0 '()ῌ*)+, -./01 : 234567
89ῌ:;<4=723 !" >?@%& +33,.
,1 AB)ῌLῌC)D EFGH : 8I4JKL
MIN:;<9O87;PQ !" RST
%& +331.
,2 Paula AT : How to Have Theory in an Eqidemic : Cultural Chronicles of AIDS. Durham and London, Duke
University Press, +333.
,3 Taylor CC : AIDS and the pathogenesis of metaphor,
(Feldman D ed), Culture and AIDS, New York, Praeger, p //῍p 0/, +33*.
-* Farmer P : AIDS and Accusation : Haiti and the Geography of Blame. Berkeley, University of California Press,
+33*.
-+ Berridge V, Strong P eds : AIDS and Contemporary
History. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, +33-.
/,
/, Press, p +12῍p ,*3, ,**-.
-2 Douglas M : Risk and Blame : Essays in Cultural Theory. New York and London, Routledge, +33,.
-3 Miller E : A borderless age : AIDS, gender, and power
in contemporary Japan. Ph.D. dissertation, Harvard
University, +33..
.* Brown T : AIDS, risk and social governance. Social Science and Medicine /* : +,1-῍+,2., ,***.
.+ Farrant W : Addressing the contradictions : Health promotion and community health action in the United Kingdom. International Journal of Health Services ,+ (-) :
.,-῍.-3, +33+.
., Lupton D : The Imperative of Health : Public Health
and the Regulated Body. London, Sage Publications,
+33/.
.- Altman D : Power and Community : Organizational and
Cultural Responses to AIDS. London, UCLA Press,
+33..
.. UVWX
YUZ[\ : ]^_`7:'a,bc
LdSῌefgcῌh;i)gcgc "j klm ,**,.