Download Presentation

New Generation Idea Cement Additives (PAAF Group) !
Energy Saving in Grinding Prosess and Enhancement in Concrete Performance!
Cemtech MEA 2014 Dubai
İdea New Group Cement Additives (PAAF); Cemtech MEA 2014
1 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
!   Preamble:!
!  Cement Additives General: !
!According to EN 197-1:!
!Cement additives are added to improve the manfacture or the
!properties of the cement and the percentage should be less than 1
!% by mass. !
İdea New Group Cement Additives (PAAF); Cemtech MEA 2014
2 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
!   Preamble:!
!  Cement Additives General: !
!  Liquid Products, Added during grinding!
!  Dosages between 200 grams/ton cement to 3000 grams/ton!
!  Treated Cement percentages:!
!   85 - 95 % in USA!
!   70 – 80
% in Europa!
!   55 - 65 %
in Asia!
!   50 - 60% in Middle East!
!   20- 30 % in Afrika !
İdea New Group Cement Additives (PAAF); Cemtech MEA 2014
3 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
!   Preamble:!
!  Achievements with Cement Additives:!
!   Output increase ( 5 – 10 % )!
!   Initial strength improvement ( 2 – 5 Mpa)!
!   Final Strength
improvement ( 2 – 10 Mpa)!
!  Adjusting setting times ( 20 – 60 Minutes)!
!  Clinker replacement by filler ( 3 – 10 %)!
!   Chromium VI Reduction !
İdea New Group Cement Additives (PAAF); Cemtech MEA 2014
4 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
SUMMARY
!   Summary !
!  Laboratory works in Idea and Siegen University !
!   Pre Laboratory works!
!  Advanced Laboratory works !
!   Field Trials !
!   Results !
!   Works will be completed in the near future !
!   Sources!
İdea New Group Cement Additives (PAAF); Cemtech MEA 2014
5 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
SUMMARY!
Changes in Concrete Properties!
Changes in Cement Properties!
Lab trials!
Field trials!
The works for reducing water
demand in concrete!
The works for improving
workability in concrete!
Energy Saving!
Changes in PSD!
Changes in
Morphology!
6!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
SUMMARY!
Developments in
Building
Technologies!
Improvements in
Concrete
Technologies!
Changes in
Cement
Production !
The effects of
Cements on
Concrete!
7!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
SUMMARY!
With PAAF Group developed by Idea İdea:
!   30 % Energy Saving with equal or better
strengths !   Better workability in concrete
Where did the works have been done:
!   İdea labs, Siegen University labs, Cement
Plants and Ready Mix Concrete Plants in
Turkey
8 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
SUMMARY!
Cement production with traditional
cement additives at high blaine
values Coarser cement production with
PAAF (10 milyon kWh energy saving in one
cement plant)
9 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
SUMMARY!
Cement
Cement Additives
and PAAF Group
The Effects of
PAAF on cement
Cement produced
with PAFF and
concrete
10 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
SUMMARY
Investments in Cement
Industry!
Developments in Cement and
Building Technologies!
High Performance Cements!
Daha Yüksek Dayanımlı Çimentolar:!
!   Higher MPa!
!   Higher Blaine!
!   Higher Production Cost and
Competition!
Daha Yüksek Dayanımlı Betonlar:!
!   High Performance Concrete!
!  Lower water/cement ratio!
!   New concrete admixtures!
!  Competition!
11!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
SUMMARY!
Clinker quality!
High
Performance
Cement
Production!
Finer grinding!
Cement
Additives!
12!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
Water/Cement ratio is
constant in cement tests
(0,50)!
Beton’da !
Water/Cement ration is not
constant in concrete which
is lower as far as possible!
CONCRETE!
CEMENT!
Cement and Concrete!
13!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
The results of more fine grinding
! 
!Higher water demand !
! 
!Unhydrated particules without bonding capacity and additional
!water demand!
! 
!Increase of heat of hydration and cracks in high temperature in
!concrete!
14 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
20 years ago, Blaine values!
Today, Blaine values!
=
=
3000 ± 200 !
4000 ± 200!
Increase of 100 Blaine = 1 kWh!
That means we need 10 kWh excess energy!
If cement production is 90 million tonnes!
We spent +900 million kWh excess electricity!
15!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
Cement!
More fine grinding;!
!   Strengths, !
!   kWh/ton values,!
!   Production Costs!
are increasing!
Concrete!
Concrete produced by more fine cement;!
!   Strength sometimes is not high enouhg,!
!   Because of cement PSD, water/cement ratio is higher
than expected!
!   Higher heat of hydration and some problems in hot
weather!
Cement and Concrete with PAAF!
!   Energy saving in cement production, !
!   PSD optimization, !
!   Improving in cement strengths, !
!   Higher workability and strengths in concrete produced cements treated by PAAF.!
16!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
SUMMARY!
Cement production with
traditional cement
additives!
!   %10-15 Output increase!
Cement production with
PAAF !
!   %20–40 Output increase, !
!   PSD optimization, !
!   Higher strengths!
!   Higher workability and strengths
in concrete!
17!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
LABORATORY WORKS IN TURKEY!
! 
!Initial lab tests were performed in Idea Laboratories in Istanbul with !7
!different clinkers. !
!
! 
! 
!Gypsum and lime stone was from 1 source in Marmara region.
!
!Before grinding all raw materials were crashed in the lab.!
18!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
LABORATORY WORKS IN TURKEY!
Cement Tests!
Table 1 & 2!
Flow Tests!
Table 3!
Micro Concrete Works!
Table 4!
Concrete Tests!
Table 5!
19!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
LABORATORY WORKS IN TURKEY, Table 1!
Fineness, Blaine and PSD Results!
Lab. Mill
Revolution!
32µ!
45µ!
63µ!
BLAINE!
PSD!
(%)!
(%)!
(%)!
cm2/gr!
D10 (µm)! D50 (µm)! D90 (µm)!
F1+ İdea 396 C!
6.000!
13,3!
6,8!
2,0!
3.780!
2.70!
15.69!
51.01!
F1 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
14,3!
7,2!
2,1!
2.880!
2.59!
17.37!
53.72!
F2 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
17,8!
9,8!
4,2!
4550!
2.38!
14.87!
51.54!
F2 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
19,5!
10,8!
4,2!
3.500!
2.55!
17.98!
63.44!
F3 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
16,5!
8,3!
3,5!
4.050!
2.28!
15.34!
54.68!
F3 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
22,4!
13,7!
3,6!
3.230!
2.48!
19.56!
69.21!
F4 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
17,2!
9,3!
3,3!
4.000!
2.60!
16.53!
53.77!
F4 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
18,4!
9,7!
3,4!
3.090!
2.91!
18.63!
60.24!
F5 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
17,7!
8,6!
3,6!
4.250!
2.20!
15.16!
50.44!
F5 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
18,4!
8,8!
3,6!
3.150!
2.90!
18.00!
55.76!
F6 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
23,6!
11,8!
3,5!
4.140!
2.57!
17.25!
57.49!
F6 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
28,2!
15,6!
5,3!
3.250!
2.68!
21.38!
71.03!
F7 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
20,7!
10,1!
3,3!
4.120!
2.60!
17.02!
55.86!
F7 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
24,5!
12,9!
4,1!
3.210!
2.70!
20.32!
67.95!
Sample!
20!
Bazı klinkerler ile daha iyi
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
sonuçlara ulaşılmıştır.!
LABORATORY WORKS IN TURKEY!
Compressive Strengths, Water Demand, Setting Times, Pack-Set Indexs!
Sample!
Lab. Mill
Revolution!
Compressive Strengths (N/
mm2)!
2 d!
7 d!
28 d!
Water
Demand!
Setting Times (Min.)!
Initial
Final
Pack set
index!
F1+ İdea 396 C!
6.000!
28!
50!
60!
26!
110!
150!
6!
F1 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
28!
49!
64!
26!
135!
175!
2!
F2 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
29!
46!
54!
27!
130!
170!
3!
F2 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
28!
47!
57!
26!
155!
190!
1!
F3 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
19!
29!
38!
28!
215!
295!
3!
F3 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
18!
30!
40!
28!
245!
310!
2!
F4 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
34!
44!
51!
27!
140!
175!
3!
F4 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
32!
47!
52!
27!
135!
170!
2!
F5 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
33!
45!
50!
27!
90!
135!
4!
F5 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
32!
47!
56!
27!
105!
160!
2!
F6 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
22!
35!
46!
26!
100!
155!
2!
F6 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
20!
32!
47!
26!
135!
180!
1!
F7 + İdea 396 C!
6.000!
25!
43!
51!
26!
130!
170!
4!
F7 + İdea 5668 S!
4.000!
23!
40!
54!
26!
140!
185!
1!
21!
The strengths of micro concretes that produced by treated
Grubu
Çimento
cement with PAAF
PAAF are
higher
than theKimyasalları
others!
LABARATORY WORKS IN TURKEY - Table 4!
Micro Concrete Tests!
Sample!
Water !
Air!
Weight!
(Kg/m3)!
Flow !
L0 !
Flow!
L30 !
Difference!
cm!
cm!
Comp. St.!
2 d!
7 d!
28 d!
cm!
MPa!
MPa!
MPa!
F1 + İdea 396 C!
236!
0,6!
2215,0!
20,8!
20,7!
0,1!
14,0!
26,6!
34.5!
F1 + İdea 5668 S!
228!
0,6!
2211,0!
21,4!
21,3!
0,1!
13,1!
28,9!
35,4!
F2 + İdea 396 C!
228!
0,6!
2207,5!
20,5!
20,0!
0,5!
16,2!
26,1!
35,1!
F2 + İdea 5668 S!
228!
0,8!
2206,5!
20,8!
20,4!
0,4!
15,4!
25,8!
34,4!
F3 + İdea 396 C!
252!
0,4!
2187,0!
21,5!
21,0!
0,5!
13,4!
23,7!
32,7!
F3 + İdea 5668 S!
231!
0,4!
2191,0!
21,5!
20,9!
0,6!
11,6!
24,8!
35,3!
F4 + İdea 396 C!
225!
0,8!
2227,2!
21,9!
20,5!
1,4!
22,1!
30,0!
37,5!
F4 + İdea 5668 S!
222!
0,8!
2225,5!
20,8!
20,3!
0,5!
23,0!
32,7!
39,4!
F5 + İdea 396 C!
231!
0,6!
2214,2!
21,8!
20,3!
1,5!
20,6!
30,7!
39,7!
F5 + İdea 5668 S!
228!
0,8!
2212,2!
21,5!
20,0!
1,5!
20,6!
31,8!
41,2!
F6 + İdea 396 C!
225!
0,4!
2233,2!
20,5!
19,8!
0,8!
13,1!
22,3!
32,1!
F6 + İdea 5668 S!
228!
1,0!
2219,0!
21,0!
20,0!
1,0!
11,0!
21,1!
34,3!
F7 + İdea 396 C!
234!
0,8!
2217,5!
20,5!
20,0!
0,5!
13,1!
24,6!
31,5!
22!
PAAF’lı çimento ile üretilen betonun dayanımları d
PAAF
Grubu Çimento
PAAF ile çimento
üretiminde
elektrik Kimyasalları
enerjisi daha
LABORATORY WORKS IN TURKEY – Table 5!
Concrete Tests!
PAAF TRIALS!
PAAF TRIALS!
Mix no!
2013-92/1!
Concrete Class!
Cement Dosage!
C25/30!
kg/m3!
W/C!
Source!
Natural Sand!
2013-92/2!
Source!
2013-92/1!
Concrete Class!
300!
300!
0,67!
0,67!
F1+İdea 396 C! F1+ İdea 5668 S!
%!
Mix no!
-!
-!
-!
-!
2013-92/2!
C25/30!
Temperature!
ºC!
22,0!
22,0!
Temperature (Concrete)!
ºC!
19,5!
19,6!
Air!
%!
0,5!
1,1!
kg/m3!
201!
201!
Additional Water!
kg/m3!
8,0!
Unit Weight (Calculated)!
kg/m3!
2339!
Unit Weight (Measured)!
kg/m3!
2375!
Dosage!
kg/m3!
304!
69!
67!
Water!
Crashed Sand!
%!
50!
50!
Sand 1!
%!
20!
20!
Sand 2!
%!
30!
30!
Marmara B.!
Marmara B.!
%!
-!
-!
W/C %!
Slump!
Cm!
18,0!
18,0!
2 days!
N/mm2!
13,7!
12,9!
Slump (30 Min.)!
Cm!
17,0!
17,5!
7 days!
N/mm2!
25,6!
27,3!
Slump Loss!
Cm!
1,0!
0,5!
28 days!
N/mm2!
34,1!
38,4!
Source!
Concrete Admixtures!
23!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
LABORATORY TRIALS IN TURKEY - Table 5!
Concrete Results!
24 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS!
Sample!
Cement Additives!
Lab Mill Revolution!
F3 - 1!
No additive!
6.000!
F3 - 2!
No additive!
4.000!
F3 - 3!
Idea 396 C!
6.000!
F3 - 4!
İdea 396 C!
4.000!
F3 - 5!
CSI 5668 S (PAAF)!
6.000!
F3 - 6!
CSI 5668 S (PAAF)!
4.000!
Lab mill revolution is 33 % lower with PAFF!
25!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS – Table 8!
Compressive Strengths!
Sample!
Lab Mill
Revolution!
Compressive Strengths (MPa)!
2 d!
7 d!
28 d!
F3-1!
6.000!
25,3!
44,4!
54,9!
F3-2!
4.000!
20,4!
38,8!
50,2!
F3-3 (with traditional CA)!
6.000!
27,7!
46,9!
57,5!
F3-4!
4.000!
23,2!
42,1!
52,3!
F3-5!
6.000!
33,8!
49,8!
61,9!
F3-6 (with PAAF)!
4.000!
28,6!
46,8!
57,8!
26!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS- Table 8!
Compressive Strengths!
65!
60!
55!
F3.1 (Without Cement Additive, 6000 Mill
Revolution)!
50!
45!
F3.3 (With Traditional Cemet Additive,
6000 Mill Revolution)!
40!
35!
F3.6 (With PAAF/5668, 4000 Mill
Revolution)!
30!
25!
20!
15!
2g!
7g!
28g!
27!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS - Table 8!
PSD Results!
Cement
Additive!
Lab Mill
Revolution!
D 10!
D 30!
D 50!
D 70!
D 100!
F3 - 3!
396 C!
6.000!
2,19!
6,9!
14,5!
25,3!
124,0!
F3 - 6!
PAAF 5668 S!
4.000!
2,86!
7,9!
18,5!
32,0!
158,4!
Sample!
!
D 30 is lower with PAAF that may help strengt improvement!
!
28!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS – Table 9!
XRD Analysis!
F3 - 1!
F3 - 2!
F3 - 3!
F3 - 4!
F3 - 5!
F3 - 6!
C3S!
60,70!
59,70!
60,20!
59,90!
60,10!
59,60!
C2S!
10,20!
10,00!
10,10!
10,40!
9,60!
11,30!
C3Ac!
5,80!
7,00!
6,10!
6,20!
6,00!
6,50!
C3Ao!
8,00!
7,80!
8,40!
7,30!
8,40!
7,00!
C4AF!
6,50!
6,10!
6,90!
6,40!
6,50!
6,80!
SiO2!
0,60!
0,40!
0,00!
0,00!
0,40!
0,00!
CaSO4.2H2O!
3,80!
4,50!
4,50!
4,90!
4,50!
4,90!
CaSO4.1/2H2O!
0,40!
0,30!
0,00!
0,00!
0,00!
0,00!
CaCO3!
4,00!
4,20!
3,80!
4,90!
4,40!
3,90!
100!
100!
100!
100!
99,9!
100!
Those analysis show that clinker qualities are closer each others.!
29!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS – Table 10!
Spesific Surfaces !
Specific Surface Area!
0.95!
1.40!
0.90!
1.30!
Bet Surface Area!
1.20!
0.85!
1.10!
0.80!
1.00!
0.75!
0.90!
0.70!
0.80!
0.65!
0.70!
0.60!
0.60!
0.50!
0.55!
0.40!
F 3-1! F 3-5! F 3-3! F 3-2! F 3-6! F 3-4!
0.50!
F 3-1! F 3-5! F 3-3! F 3-2! F 3-6! F 3-4!
30 PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS- Table 11!
Heat Evaluation (J/g)!
Measurement of Heat of Hydration!
The heat
evaluation of
cement trated by
PAAF is better
than the others.!
Time (hours)!
31!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS - Table 12!
Porosity Measurements!
Porosity!
Porosity Volume!
16
0,08
14
0,07
12
0,06
10
0,05
0,04
8
0,03
6
0,02
4
0,01
2
0
F 3-1
F 3-2
F 3-4
10 - 220 µm
0,002 - 0,03µm
F 3-3
F 3-6
F 3-5
0,03 - 10µm
Total
Porosity is lower with PAAF!
0
F 3-1
F 3-2
F 3-4
0,002 - 0,03µm
F 3-3
F 3-6
0,03 -10µm
F 3-5
Total
Porosity volume is lower with PAAF!
32!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS - Table 13!
ESEM Photos, Without CA, 6000 Mill Revolution, 24 hours X 50 000!
33!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS - Table 13!
ESEM Photos, With Convansiyonel CA, 6000 Mill Revolution, 24 hours, X 50 000!
34!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
ADVANCED LAB WORKS - Table 13!
ESEM Photos, PAAF, 4000 Mill Revolution, 24 hours, X 50 000!
35!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
INDUSTRIAL TRIALS - Table 14!
Output, Fineness and Blaine Values!
Cement
Sample!
Output (%)!
Dosage (g/ton)!
32 mic!
45 mic!
Blaine!
396 C
(Traditional
CA)!
100!
450!
5,1!
2,2!
3830!
PAAF (5668 S)!
130!
1.000!
6,7!
3,5!
3350!
36!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
INDUSTRIAL TRIALS - Table 15!
Strengths!
Cement Sample!
Output (%)!
Blaine!
2 d (MPa)!
7 d (MPa)!
28 d (MPa)!
396 C (Traditional CA)!
100!
3.830!
24,8!
46,2!
56,1!
PAAF (5668 S)!
130!
3.350!
23,7!
49,5!
63,0!
37!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
INDUSTRIAL TRIALS!
Strengths!
70!
60!
50!
40!
396 C (Traditional CA)!
5668 S (PAAF)!
30!
20!
10!
0!
2g!
7g!
28g!
38!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
INDUSTRIAL TRIALS - Table 16!
Water Demand, Workability and Pack Set Results!
Cement!
Outputj (%)!
Blaine!
Water Demand
(%)!
HIT!
Pack Set!
396 C
(Ordinary CA)!
100!
3.830!
30,0!
16,1!
3!
PAAF (5668 S)!
130!
3.350!
28,5!
17,2!
1!
Lower water demand and better workability with PAAF!
39!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
RESULTS!
The stregths are better with PAAF altough it is produced
with low energy.!
Water demand is lower with PAAF,!
Pack Set Index is lower with PAAF that can make the
transportation of cement easier.!
40!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
RESULTS!
Early strengths are equal but final strengths are better with
PAAF than the cements produced with ordinary cement
additives!
41!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
RESULTS!
According to BET results SSA results of cement treated
with PAAF is lower!
The photos taken by electron microscopy shows that the
hydration level of cement with PAAF is better than the
others.!
According to porosity measurements, the porosty of the
cement treated with PAAF is lower than the cement treated with
traditional cement additives in spite of the fact that cement with
PAAF is more coarser.!
42!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
RESULTS!
According to ESEM after hydration of cements:!
!   C-S-H pases are not clear on the cement without
cement additive.!
!   C-S-H pahes are more clear with PAAF. !
!  Those works explaine the results getting with PAAF!
43!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
RESULTS!
The amount of etregyte pahes in the cement produced
with ordinaray cement additives are higher than the
cement with PAAF.!
44!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
RESULTS!
Using PAAF in grinding prosses provides:
!!
!   Output increase and energy saving in Cement production,
!   Better workability and lower water demand in concrete.!
!
45!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
RESULTS!
Within these works performed by Idea Construction
Chemicals and Siegen University , all steps of cement
and concrete productions with PAAF have been analysed
to understand all the effects which is very important to
have the integration of cement and concrete.!
46!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
THE PLANNED WORKS!
!   Patent
works, !
!   Changes in concrete that produced with the cement treated by PAAF,!
!   Industrial trials in the cement plants that interested in PAAF.!
47!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
SOURCES!
!   Effects of cement particles size distrubition on performance properties of !
portland cement-based materials, Dale P. Bentz et al, 1999!
!   Durability-Critical issuses for the future, P. K. Mehta, Concr International 19(7)!
(1997) 27-33!
!  An argument for using coarse cements in high performance concrete, C. J. !
Haecker et al, Cem Concr Res29(1999) 615-618!
!   The Global Cement Report, Cemnet; !
Cement Production and Concrete in the Future, A. Yeğinobalı!
!   Turkey Cement Industry, Cemnet!
!   Cement in 21. Century, Jean Claude Rauman, Shandeep L. Sarkar;!
!   Sustainability in Cement Production, Cembureau!
!   Cements of Yesterday and today and concrete of tomorrow, Pierre-Claude Aitcin!
48!
PAAF Grubu Çimento Kimyasalları
Thank You!
49!