1. No category

ﾉ{Z診«Y | ﾉZﾅ ﾂ険 G77 ﾃ

'< 9<"=8>, ?4' $3 25'"6 7.-8*# 9',:; !"#$% & '"( & )*( +,'$-# $./01 2%'$3
G77 9"@'AB(
1
!"#$ %&'( )*+,& ,-$(
2
('4./0'!1 !"23
C?.DE
?='HI56*&,3 GH+ 56*&,3 %"&EF ?*C '= 4' 896 .>3' ?(*@-A' !B= ?*C4*"D."7 4' 896 )':;<50 56*&,3
=*$RML$ ?*NO ?',0 %&' 8P"Q& !;&4*"D 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 GH+ .!B*08& 8+=*1 J"K-L&
R %"D':A !;&4*"D %&' 8P"Q& %-B'( ?',0 .!;$8& ,6H7)*9&' '= 56*&,3 8C(4*0 R 56*&,3 >#I4*0 ',64 !B*08&
.J"B*08& =*$RML$ ?',0 >3=( S'=,K&
=( ?(*@-A' !B= R =*$RML$ S'=,K& U8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 %"0 5P0'= !B 823 .CRT7 %6' =(
.>3' 5-O,I S=:X *-6( YD*7 V!& 4' (*Z-3' *0 52[*P& %6' .(,"I =',A 83=,0 (=:& 2010 *F 2004 ?*CV*3 8W
>3!0 ^6*-D .!B*08& G77 ?*C=:#$ 4' M/-;& =:#$ 19 Y&*B U.CRT7 %6' =( !B (*Z-3' ?=*&\ 5D:]D
?(*@-A' !B= ,0 ,"1EF =R( R( *0 G77?*C=:#$ =( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 )'_"& 5$ !C(8& )*#D !&\
!B= ,0 ?='(*;2& R >`a& ,"bEF ,"1EF =R( c6 *0 %"D':A >"]$*d %";e]C .(='( ?='(*;2& R >`a& ?,"bEF
.(='( ?(*@-A'
*-6( YD*7 U?(*@-A' !B= U=*$ R ML$ ?*NO U%"D':A >"]$*d U8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 :9?.F( G";H,&
M21UK23UF21UC23: JEL 9?I3 -JK
U?_$,& )',hF !d'R 8&g3' ('4\ *f#D'( ?='!0*Ld R (*@-A' !9#D'( =*6(*-3' .1
E.Mail:[email protected]
E.Mail: [email protected]?(*@-A' i:j< !B=' k*;B=*$ .2
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…82
#?-# .1
=( ?(*@-A' )g$ R (,1 ?*NO 8W*`F=' 5Kjd )':;<50 «=*$RML$ ?*NO» >"]C' U?(g"& 90 5C( =(
5X,< =( =:0_& ?*Cm1*B (:`h0 R =*$RML$ S'=,K& lgX' >3' JjL& 5eD\ .!B l,P& ?(*@-A' S*"0('
R n*KF=' R (*@-A' 5X,< =( 8X:@1 ./0 >$=*#& 5`;+ >6:KF >h+ =( 83*3' R >`a& 8&*I *h;F 5D 8D*h+
8j$ =:W 50 R *C *f;0 (,9j]< (:`h0 !0*"D (:`h0 =*$RML$ ?*NO 5$8&'(*& .>3' =:#$ 50 ?=R*;O (R=R Y"hLF
?*C!&*"7 4' 8]3=,"o ./0 p,-LI R *C *f;0 ?,6H7>0*A= .C*$ >L"D ,6H7)*9&' 8X:@1 ./0 !B=
U8F*"[*& !&\=( .C*$ i:hZ& 50 >[R( ?',0 U(*@-A' 8]3=,"o ./0 p,-LI .>3' =*$RML$ M3*;&*D q"Q&
50 8]3= ?*C *f;0 ?',0 R 8]3= 8[*& %"&*F s0*;& 4' )!D*& iR,Q& 8;2& 50 8]3=,"o ?(*@-A' )r*2O ?',0
?',0 T6R 50 =*$RML$ S'=,K& >[:h3 >"]C' .>3' 8]3=,"o )r*2O *0 J[*3*D >0*A= =( %-O,I =',A i:hZ&
?',0 5"3R= R ?_[*& U%"t U80:;+ ,$ ):t 86*C=:#$ 5$ >3' ?!d 50 (SMEs) q3:-& R ct:$ ?*C *f;0
.!D' ('( =',A (:1 ?*C5&*D,0 =*]B =( '= %"D':A %6' lgX' ?(*@-A' q6',B (:`h0
?='HI56*&,3 ,"b*F 83=,0 R ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 =*$RML$ S'=,K& ,"b*F 83=,0 5[*K& %6' 8jX' u'!C'
Up(gf;0 U%"-D'v=\ U,6'_w[' Y&*B G77 M/-;& ?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 (FDI) 8+=*1 J"K-L&
UgxR_DR U5x:IR=R' UyD:F U!;j6*F U)*-L0,< UR,7 U)*-L$*7 U.$',& U)',6' U?_DR!D' U!;C U,@& U%9";"&R( U*"`]j$
c6 =( %"D':A >"]$*d )'_"& R =*$RML$ ?*NO =( ?!;0 5`F= )'_"& =( 8;f]C 4' ',64 .!B*08& =:7*f;3 Ui*;-6R
4' 5-3( %6' 5`F= 5-L+,0 )*D'(*@-A' %]wD' 2010 V*3 p='_I k*3' ,0 ?=:W50 .!;B*08& ='(:1,0 zP3
.!B*08& 3/96 *F 5/42 %"0 =*$RML$ ?*NO =( ?*C=:#$
R %"D':A >"]$*d )'_"& .(:B ('( |3*7 V':3 %6' 50 5[*K& %6' =( *F !B %6' ,0 823 =:{;& %"]C 50
5[*K& %6' ?',0 ,64 ?*C5"},O k*3' %6' ,0 ~(:B8& ?(*@-A' !B= M+:& 5D:ft 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3
:!B*08& ,{D !&
.(='( ?='(8;2& R >`a& G77 M/-;& ?*C=:#$ =( %"D':A >"]$*d )'_"& *6\ -1
G77M/-;& ?*C=:#$ =( =*$RML$ S'=,K& )(:0 >/3 )'_"& R 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 )'_"&
-2
.(='( ?='(8;2& R >`a& ?,b' *6\ ?(*@-A' !B= )'_"& ,0
. (:B 5-1'(,7 *-6( YD*7 pR= 4' "KQF S*"},O R V':3 83=,0 50 !B 823 =:{;& %6' 50
83..........G77 ?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 R =*$RML$ S'=,K& ,"bEF 83=,0
9$LM 2M"J# .2
€*1 V*3 c6 =( =:#$ c6 !"[:F .6'_O' 4' >3' S=*`< ?(*@-A' !B= U (*3 ,"0*2F R c"3g$ (*@-A' =(
,b' =( 5$ !D'(8& ?='!6*7 !;6',O '= ?(*@-A' !B= R='(:F Y96*& .(19901,#"O) 56*7 V*3 =( )\ ='!K& *0 5L6*K& =(
,{D 4' *&' .(:B8& 8j& !&\=( zP3 .6'_O' M`3 R !0*68& .6'_O' )*&4 8W =( ?(*@-A' !"[:F >"O,‚ )\
=:{;& 50 ?!"[:F >"O,‚ S!&!;j0 .6'_O' :4' >3' S=*`< R (='( ?,F"A( i:hZ& ?(*@-A' !B= y-D4:$
.( 77 € U ('4!]Q&) i(,& 50 ?(*@-A' ?*Cr*$ ,Fƒ:;-& 5t ,C ?5},<
8P"Q& q6',B )':F8& .!0*6 KQF ,&' %6' ?',0 4*"D (=:& q6',B !6*0 ?(*@-A' 523:F R !B= .6'_O' ?',0
?*NO U,f6( S=*`<50 .(,$ „6,2F =*$RML$ ?*NO 50 '= =*$RML$ p,-LI R !"[:F .6'_O' ?',0 4*"D (=:&
8[R >3' *C *f;0 )\ S=!A R qjLF 4' †=*1 5$ >3' ?(*@-A' ?*C *f;0 =*$RML$ ,0 ,b:& ?*C,"…-& =*$RML$
.>3' ,b:& =*"L0 *hD\ pgF 5w"-D ,0
4' !D':F8& 5$ >3' ?(*@-A' !B= !;6',O =( 83*3' ?*C4*"D."7 4' 896 )':;<50 56*&,3 >B*`D' %";e]C
%6,FJh& 4' .!B*08& 8j1'( 4'!D'y7 ?',0 8j]9& )':;< 50 8+=*1 8[*& s0*;& .((,I %"&*F 8+=*1 *6 8j1'( s0*;&
.>3' 2(FDI) 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 8+=*1 8[*& s0*;& (R=R ?*C '=
)(,0r*0 U!6!+ .D'( U4R= ?T :[:;9F U56*&,3 GH+ Y&*B (FDI) 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 !6':O
US*2[*P& k*3',0 .>3' >0*A= S=!A .6'_O' R *C>1'(,7 4',F (:`h0 UV*…-B' .6'_O' U>6,6!& 86*D':F
!B= U*C>1*3,64 U(*@-A' )(:0 4*0 U56*&,3 >#I4*0 ‡,D Y"`A 4' ?(*64 Y&':< s0*F 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3
R >[R( 8[*& s}R U8+=*1 8C!0 U4=' ‡,D Ui=:F U8D*LD' 56*&,3 U82"`W s0*;& U8j1'( ?='HI56*&,3 U?(*@-A'
.!B*08& ='4*0 4'!D'
%"D':A >"]$*d )'_"& R S'=,K& >"2}R (FDI) 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 ,0 ,b:& =*"L0 (=':& 4' 896
56*&,3 (R=R ?',0 82D*& S=:X50 !D':F8& 8`LD =:W50 S'=,K& .!B*08& ?='HI56*&,3 )*0_"& ?*C=:#$ =(
8+=*1 )'='HI56*&,3 JC R 8j1'( )'='HI56*&,3 '= ,3 ,0 !D':F8& JC 5$ 82D*& .!B*0 !"[:F 5X,< 50 )'='HI
?',0 ?' _"fD' ,f6( U!B*0 ƒ:;]& =:#$ Y1'( ?*C86'='( ,0 )*"+=*1 >"9[*& ,I' ga& .!B*0 (,F!6!B S=:X50)
.!D*&8]D 8A*0 )*D\ ?='HI56*&,3
5$ !B !C':1 ‰<*0 =*$RML$ 50 †R,1 R (R=R =:{;&50 ,"I *7R>3( %"D':A .C*$ R S*`b*0 %"D':A ˆ*/F'
.(='Hf0 )*0_"& ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 8-`a& S',b' R !B ,-#"0 )*0_"& (*@-A' 50 !B (='R 8+=*1 )'='HI56*&,3 ('!2F
-8& ?4'!D' '= )*0_"& =:#$ (*@-A' =( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 )':;< >QF 5$ 8+=*1 ?*C *f;0 Šr:X'
!;6\,O =( 8j1'( ?*C *f;0 50 >`LD ..... R %6:D 8-6,6!& ?*CpR= R ,F5-O,#"7 ?=R*;O 4' 8`LD =:W50 !D:B
1. Fisher 1990
2 .foreign direct investment
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…84
?*C *f;0 )*"& !D4*3 Y&*2F R )*0_"& (*@-A' =( 8+=*1 ?*C *f;0 Jh3 .6'_O' *0 R !;B*08& !;& ,h0 !"[:F
50 ,w;& >6*hD =( 5$ (='( .... R *C(_]-3( zP3 U='4*0 =*-1*3 U=*$?R,"D S=*h& ,0 8-`a& S',b' 8+=*1 R 8j1'(
.(44U45mX U1390U*"D8[R) (:B8& =:#$ )\ ?(*@-A' !B= R )*0_"& =:#$ =( !"[:F (:`h0
!;6',O i*wD' =( 5$ >3' 86*C5;6_C U8[*& ?*C5;6_C .!B*08& 8D*&4 R 8[:7 S=:X R( 50 S'=,K& ?*C5;6_C
!;D*& ((,I >1'(,7 !6*0 !"[:F Y&':< 4' ,"o 8j&':< 50 U?='HI56*&,3 4' ?='(,0 ,h0 V:W =( *6 R ?='HI56*&,3
,-#"0 !"[:F Y&':< 50 !6*0 ):D*A k*3',0 5$ 86*C5;6_C *6 R ((,I >1'(,7 !6*0 >$,B >`b ?',0 5$ 86*C5;6_C
... R %9L& d S=:X 50 !6*0 =*$ ):D*A k*3',0 5$ 86*C5;6_C !;D*& ((,I >1'(,7 !"[:F J"K-L& 5;6_C 4'
Y"]QF )*&4 )('( >3( 4' Y"[( 50 U)'='HI56*&,3 50 5$ >3' 86*C5;6_C UJC 8D*&4 ?*C5;6_C .((,I >1'(,7
:(,]B ,0 5D:I %6' )':F8& '= =*$RML$ ?*NO =( S'=,K& )(:0 r*0 8Z;& S',b' 4' 8N20 .(:B8&
4' _6,I *6 S'=,K&4' 8B*D ?*C5;6_C 4' =',O ,W*1 50 5$ *"3 ='4*0 (*w6' R (*@-A' 8]3=,"o ./0 )!B ‹=_0 .!6\8& (:+R50 US'=,K& J1RŒ"7 ,7 Yd',&
.=:#$ ?(*@-A' !B= .C*$ R =:#$ =( ?=*9"0 )'_"& %-O= r*0 )\ s`F 50 R (*@-A' =( ?='HI56*&,3 .C*$ -.[*t 86*3*;B R =*$RML$ ?*NO S'=,K& (:`h0 G:t=*t €:@1=( p*9;$ 50 1=*$RML$ ?*NO p='_I
5 M[*A =( 2003 V*3 =( =*$RML$ ?*NO p='_I %"[R' .(4'(,78& =*$RML$ >"2}R *KF=' >h+ (:+:& ?*C
?*C=:#$ ('!2F R !"3= m1*B 11 50 p('!2F ,}*d V*d =( 5$ U!B 5"hF =:#$ 133 (=:& =( R m1*B
.>3' 5-O*6 *KF=' =:#$ 183 50 83=,0 (=:&
=( Y6ˆ l,B50 >"9[*& Ž:Kd 4' >6*]d R =*$RML$ S'=,K& 50 :0,& 8]$ ?*Cm1*B 2010p='_I =(
:>3' 5-O,I =',A 5L6*K& (=:& )*h+ ?*C=:#$ )*"&
2
3
(>$,B >`b !;6\,O) =*$ R ML$ ƒR,B -1
((:B8& Y&*B '= *I=*$ c6 ?4'!D' '= *F 4:w& y"3*F H1' S*&'!A' 5<:]w&) *C4:w& H1' -2
4
5
(=*$ ='4*0 %"D':A) =*$?R,"D †',1' R i'!/-3' -3
(!B*08& 8]3= (*;3' ,-O( =( 86'='( >`b >h+ i4r !;6\,O) >"9[*& >`b -4
6
1
1. doing business report
2. starting a business
3. dealing with construction permits
4. Employing workers
5 .Registering property
6. Getting credit
=*`-<' H1' -5
n_+ )'='!&*h3 4' 86*NA >6*]d -6
85..........G77 ?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 R =*$RML$ S'=,K& ,"bEF 83=,0
2
3
4
5
S*"[*& >1'(,7 -7
?4,&',O S=*wF -8
>"[*2O c6 VgQD' -9
*C('(=',A )(:0 =R\ i'_[' -10
50 R 5`3*Q& '= =*$RML$ ?*NO m1*B 5`F= UŽ:O m1*B 10 50 (*;-3' *0 8D*h+ cD*0 U=:0_& p='_I=(
.!C(8& p='_I 83=,0 (=:& ?*C=:#$ 8&*]F ?',0 ?'5L6*K& S=:X
50 )':F8& (='HI8& ,"b*F )\ 50 (R=R R =*$RML$ ?*NO ,0 5$ 8;"D':A 4' 8N20 r*0 ?*Cm1*B k*3',0
R 8f-L9B=R ):D*A U>"9[*& 50 :0,& %"D':A US*"[*& ):D*A U8<*]-+' %"&*F ):D*A U?=*9"0 ):D*A U=*$ ):D*A
!"[:F ?*NO 50 8X:@1 ./0 (R=R '= ,3 ,0 82D':& S=:X 50 %"D':A 8D'R',O %6' .(:]D =*B' S=*wF ):D*A
R 8j1'( )'='HI56*&,3 U?='HI56*&,3 ?',0 '= '= U%"D':A %6' 4' 81,0 lgX' *6 uHd *0 )':F8& 5$ >3' =:#$
i*wD' 8D:D*A Yd',& ('!2F 59;6' VR' .(,"I,0=( '= Jh& 8IT6R 53 !6*0 (:+:& %"D':A lgX' .(,$ =':]C 8+=*1
!0*6 .C*$ %9]& !d *F ):D*A (*w6' 4' 8B*D ?*C5;6_C !6*0 !20 5jd,& =( .!0*6 .C*$ )*9&' !d *F >"[*2O c6
.!0*6 .C*$ 8D:D*A !;6',O c6 ?',+' )*&4 S!& 5]C 4' ,FJh& R
R (:0 =*"B:C =*$RML$ ?*NO S',""…F 50 >`LD !6*0 =':]C 8-0*A= >6_& Zd R ML$ ?',0 *f;0 c6
R !C( i*wD' !6!+ ?_6=5&*D,0 iR_[ S=:X =( R ('( ,""…F 8-3=(50 '= (:1 ?*C?TF',-3' !D':-0 *F !;$ !X= '= )\
.(='( (:+R *f;0 q3:F =*$RML$ ?*NO 83=,0 ?',0 86*CpR= *-3'= %6' =(
>3' ('( =*#-D' =*$RML$ ?*NO (:`h0 5;"&4 =( 86*];C'= =( OECD ?*C5-"]$ 4' 896 5$ 8Z6,2F =(
?*C>"[*2O ,0 5$ >3' (,$ „6,2F 8F'=,K& R ?(*hD U8A:Kd q6',B U*C>3*"3 4' 5<:]w& '= =*$RML$ ?*NO
.>3' J$*d =*$RML$
%6' 5$ !;-1'(,7 86*Cm1*B 8d',W 50 „j-/& 8jj]['%"0 ?*C)*&4*3 U=*$ R ML$ q"Q& 80*64=' ?',0
.>3' ='HI,"b*F 8jj]['%"0 ?(*@-A' )r*2O R )'='HI56*&,3 ?,"IJ"]@F ,0 *Cm1*B
?!;0 5`F= U=*$RML$ ?*NO U=*$RML$ i*wD' :Y&*B =*$RML$ ?*NO 83=,0 ?*Cm1*B %6,F8jX'
>$,B q3:F !B 8d',W m1*B U=*$RML$ ?*NO ?=:O y9< U?(*@-A' ?('4\ m1*B U83*"3 cL6=
!B*08& ?(*@-A' k*Ld' ?*C,I*]D U?,6H7M"3\ m1*B U8F*`b80 m1*B U(*LO m1*B U)',6' s6*;X ?4*3:D
.!B*08& 86*Cm1*B ,64 ?'='( =*$RML$ ?*NO ?*Cm1*B 4' i'!$ ,C 5$
1. Protectinginvestors
2. Payingtaxes
3. Tradingacrossborders
4. Enforcingcontracts
5. Closing abusiness
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…86
8D*h+ cD*0 =( 2004 V*3 =( )*h+ ?*C=:#$ =( =*$RML$ ?*NO >[:h3 83=,0 vR,7 :=*$RML$ i*wD'
?',0 '= 8X:@1 ./0 523:F ?R4*0 .KD vR,7 %6' ?,w& )':;<50 (IFC) 8jj]['%"0 8[*& 5L3:& (=:1 !"j$
)'='HI56*&,3 ?',0 5L3:& %6' q3:F !B ig<' ?*C=*&\ 5$ 86r*0 =*`-<' Y"[(50 R !;$8& *Z6' 8D*h+ cD*0
U>3' ='(=:1,0 ?' (*2[' Ž:O R ?(,`C'= >"]C' 4' U5L3:& %6' ?*C?!;05`F= =( M3*;& *f6*+ ML$ U(='(
%]P& 86*];C'= 8+=*1 )'='HI56*&,3 ?',0 U5L3:& %6' ?:3 4' !B ig<' ?*C=*&\ R *C?!;05`F= 59;6' %]}
.(:B8& 8KjF )'_"& =:#$ G*/-D' ?',0
1
5$ (EIU) ?(*@-A' S*<gW' !d'R q3:F 2001 V*3 =( =*0 %"[R' m1*B %6' :=*$RML$ ?*NO m1*B
R ?(*@-A' cL6= ,0 ?(*64 !"$*F m1*B %6' .!B ,#-;& !;$8& >"[*2O )!;[ 2>L"&:D:$' 56,#D S=*{D >QF
m1*B %6' 8jX' =:-$*O ( .(4'(,78& *C=:#$ !;6\ q6',B 8;"0 ."7 50 R 5-B'( ?=*wF ?*C>"[*2O 8<*]-+'
U>0*A= R ('4\ S=*wF 50 u:P2& ?*C>3*"3 U='4*0 ?*C>X,O U)g$ (*@-A' q"Q& U83*"3 q"Q& : 4' !;F=*`<
U=*$ ='4*0 U*CS*"[*& 8[*& ?*C='4*0 U4=' ‡,D J6v= R 8+=*1 S=*wF U 8+=*1 ?='HI56*&,3 50 u:P2& ?*C>3*"3
%6' 4*"-&' !;;$%""2F *hD\ %"fD*"& 5$ >3' 86*C5<:]w&,64 ?'='( 8jX' =:-$*O ( %6' 4' i'!$ ,C .*C>1*3,64
!X=( 50 5$ (:B8& (*Z-3' 8`"$,F m1*B %6' 5`3*Q& =( m1*B 70 ƒ:]w& =( R !B*08& *C=:-$*O
.((,I8& 5"hF )*&4*3 %6' 8#6*]"7 S*2[*P& k*3',0 _"D !X=( 50 R *C=:#$ 8]3= ?*C=*&\ 4' *hD\ S*<gW'
q"Q& ,-#"0 >"Z"$ !;C()*#D !B*0 ,-#"0 =:#$ c6 4*"-&' 5t ,C 5$ !B*08& ( *F ,ZX %"0 m1*B %6' ,]D
%6,-h0 R %6,F!0 VR!+ 5&'(' =( .((,I8& „6,2F )*h+ =:#$ 82 ?',0 m1*B %6' .!B*08& =:#$ )\ =*$RML$
.>3' !&\ >L"&:D:$' =*$RML$ q"Q& m1*B ,{D 4' *C=:#$
3
5"hF =:#$ cL6= 8jj]['%"0 ?*];C'= )*&4*3 q3:F m1*B %6' :2%".% O*!' 9?I3 J1' N6"4
%6' .>3' *C)\ )*"& 5L6*K& R *C=:#$ 83*"3 S*`b 80*64=' ?',0 ?='_0' )(,$JC',O )\ u!C R ((,I8&
>"Z"$ UJ{D R ):D*A U(*LO U?='HI56*&,3 q6',B :4' !;F=*`< 5$ >3' !B Y"9#F n_+ 12 4' U8`"$,F m1*B
?*C.;F U8&*{D ˆ:ZD U8+=*1 S*Og-1' U8j1'( S*Og-1' U8<*]-+' ?(*@-A' q6',B U*C>[R( S*`b U83',$R=:0
c"F',$:&( 86:f/3*7 P8`CH& ?*C.;F U8&:A
U!"[:F ?R= ,0 '= 4*"D !d 4' ."0 >[R( >6(R!Q& *6 =*`+' (:+R i!< m1*B %6' :9<"=8>, 9<,QR N6"4
%6' =( .((,I8& %6R!F 4^"-6,C (*";0 q3:F m1*B %6' .!;$8& 83=,0 '= S*&!1 R *Cr*$ u,@& *6 R s64:F
5$ !D,"I8& =',A 8jX' 5-3( ( =( *C,"…-& %6' .!;C(8& =',A 52[*P& (=:& '= YK-L& ?(*@-A' ,"…-& 50 m1*B
1. Economist Intelligence Unit
2. Economist
3. International Country Risk Guide
4. The Heritage Foundation
87..........G77 ?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 R =*$RML$ S'=,K& ,"bEF 83=,0
?*C )*6,+ U8[:7 >3*"3 U(*@-A' =( >[R( >[*1( U>[R( 8[*& =*0 U?=*wF >3*"3 :4' !;F=*`< *C5-3( %6'
R S'=,K& U?:;2& >"9[*& Ž:Kd U*C>]"A U*C(_]-3( P8[*& %"&*F R ?='!9D*0 P8+=*1 ?='HI56*&,3 R 56*&,3
8]3= ,"o ?*C='4*0 >"[*2O
=*$RML$ ?*NO 4' ?=:O 8L9< *F (='( pgF m1*B %6' :'"(&)*( 9"UV 9, LST $!A=1 N6"4
S*<gW' 4' (*Z-3' *0 m1*B %6' .!;$ 86*3*;B '= lgX' ?',0 ='(>6:[R' ?*C./0 R !C( )*#D '= *C=:#$
.!;$8& 5Xg1 '= =:#$ c6 (=:& =( =*$RML$ q"Q& „j-/& S*2[*P& U?='('= ='(:]D c6 5x'=' R „j-/& s0*;&
5`F= UŒ"-6,C (*";0 ?(*@-A' ?('4\ m1*B :4' !;F=*`< 5$ ((,I8& (*Z-3' m1*B %6' %6R!F =( ,I*]D >#C
?='HI56*&,3 5L3:&)=:#$ =*`-<' ?!;0 5`F= P(=:#$ cL6= 8j]['%"0 ?*];C'= m1*B 4') 83*"3 cL6= ?!;0
4') 2S'=,K& >"Z"$ m1*B P(>L"&:D:$' 56,#D ?(*@-A' S*<gW' !d'R) =*$RML$ ?*NO m1*B P(1?(*hD
P(8D*h+ cD*0 R,I 8D',]9d ?*Cm1*B 4') 4(*LO V,-;$ m1*B P(38D*h+ cD*0 R,I 8D',]9d ?*Cm1*B
i*wD' 5`F= P((*@-A' 8D*h+ s]w& 8D*h+ ?,6H7>0*A= p='_I 4') 8j& =*$RML$ ?*NO >"Z"$ ?!;05`F=
(8D*h+ cD*0 R,I =*$RML$ i*wD' p='_I)5=*$RML$
=( Ž:O ,I*]D >#C >"2}R 5L6*K& ?',0 ?='('= ='(:]D 4' =*$RML$ ?*NO ?=:O y9< m1*B =(
,I*]D ,C (!< ='(:]D %6' =( .(:B8& (*Z-3' ?!&\=( 5K`W JC ?*C=:#$ .G .5KP;& ?*C=:#$ .„[' *0 5L6*K&
?*C=:#$ )*"& =( m1*B )\ YA'!d R >"2}R %6,F!0 !;C()*#D ,ZX (!< 5$ !B*08& c6 *F ,ZX %"0
?!&\=( R,I *6 5KP;& ?*C=:#$ )*"& =( >"2A:& %6,-h0 !;C( )*#D c6 (!< R >3' ?!&\=( 5K`W *6 5KP;&
:!B*0 8& ,64 S=:X 50 2009 V*3 =( )',6' ?='('= ='(:]D V*a& )':;< 50 .!B*08&
s6*;X ?4*3:D >$,B 1384 V*3 =( :G,$!, W!"IX 9Q"%AM Y($4 Z%A1 C?4 2[,$K N6"4
=( 5$ (,$ 5"hF «)*h+ =:#$ 70 *0 5L6*K& =( =:#$=*$RML$ ?*NO 80*64=' R 5`3*Q&»)':;< *0 8B='_I )',6'
R =:#$ =*$RML$ ?*NO 80*64=' ?',0 8[!& 8d',W 50 =*$RML$ ?*NO ?*Cm1*B 4' i*h[' R 83=,0 *0 )\
>&g3 :>3' ('( =',A 83=,0 (=:& ,64 =:Q& ( k*3',0 '= =*$RML$ ?*NO m1*B %6' .>3' 5-1'(,7 )*h+
?*C*;0,64 P>[R( 86'=*$ R 8I=_0 P(*@-A' )(:0 4*0 )'_"& P)g$ (*@-A' q"Q& P8[*& ?*C='4*0 8I(,-LIR
_ 83*"3 q"Q& P?=R*;O R 8]j< ?*;0,64 PS*<gW' R S*W*`F=' ?=R*;O P=*$?R,"D ?,6H7u*P2D' P896_"O
.>0*A= R =*@QD' P8<*]-+'
1. Institutional Investor
2. Regulatory Quality Indicator
3 .World Bank Group Governance Indicators
4. Control of Corruption
5. Doing Business Rank
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…88
.(,"I8& =',A 83=,0 (=:& ,"…-& 150 ƒ:]w& =( 5$ >3' 86*Cm1*B ?'='( *C=:Q& %6' 4' i'!$ ,C
8w;3,{D *0 _"D 8j1'( .6*]"7 R 8jj]['%"0 ?*C.6*]"7 R 8jj]['%"0 8]3= ?*C=*&\ k*3',0 8+=*1 S*<gW'
.(,"I8& S=:X =:#$ s6*;X 4'
†'R= .!;;$8& „6,2F 8@/B (:3 R sO*;& %"&*F ?',0 (:+:& %"D':A mKD '= ?(*@-A' (*LO :<"*V N6"4
->"[*2O *F ((,I8& ‰<*0 (*LO .>3' >[R( ?*C>3*"3 ?!&\=*$*D M+:& R ?(*@-A' 523:F sD':& 4' 896 (*LO
.!;$ '!"7 Ž:3 ![:&,"o R 8;"&4,64 ?*C>"[*2O R *C>D'= >]3 50 ![:& Y9B 4' ?(*@-A' ?*C
=( .>3' (CPI)1(*LO 4' =:@F *6 ‘=( m1*B U(:B8& 80*64=' ?(*@-A' (*LO 5;"&4 =( 5$ 86*Cm1*B 4' 896
R 83*"3 S*&*K& ?:3 4' 50*#& Jx',+ R kg-1' G*9F=' )'_"& U :B= >O*6=( R >1'(,7 )'_"& Um1*B %6'
?=:#$ 50 10 ,]D k*3' %6',0 R !B*`"& ( *F ,ZX k*"K& =( m1*B %6' .(,"I8& =',A 80*64=' (=:& ?='('
%6,Fr*0 ?'='( 5$ >3' ?=:#$ 50 :0,& ,ZX ,]D R (='!D (:+R )\ =( ?(*LO 5D:I Œ"C 5$ (:B8& :0,&
m1*B %6' .(:B8& %6R!F ):;$*F 1995 V*3 4' U28D*h+ >"O*ZB )*&4*3 q3:F m1*B %6' .>3' (*LO )'_"&
8;-`& m1*B %6' !6\8& ,0 m1*B %6' )':;< 4' 5$ =:W)*]C .>3' !B 5x'=' =:#$ 178 ?',0 2010 V*3 =(
.!B*0 SR*Z-& (*LO 50 :0,& ?*C>"2A'R *0 !D':F8& S'=:@F %6' R >3' (*LO 4' (',O' =:@F R >";Cˆ ,0
=( 5-3:"7 ƒ:AR 50 ?*C)',Q0 R *C‘:B ƒ:D R S!B 4' 83*"K& )':;< 50 ?(*@-A' 8F*`b80 :21"J/23 N6"4
?(*@-A' ,F!<*L&*D ?*NO R ,-#"0 8F*`b80 !;C()*#D ?(*@-A' ?*C)',Q0 )(:0 ,Fr*0 R (:B8& „6,2F (*@-A'
=( 8F*`b80 !;;$)*"0 8-]"A 8F*`b80 . (*-3 8F*`b80 R >]"A 8F*`b80 !;$8& =:h‚ Y9B R( =( 8F*`b80 .!B*08&
.!B*08& 52&*+ !"[:F ,6(*K& S*D*3:D R S',""…F !;C()*#D (*-3 8F*`b80 R >3' *C>]"A 8&:]< zP3
*0 (*@-A' c6 5h+':& V*]-d' 5$ !B*08& ?=*-1*3 8IT6R c6 ?(*@-A' ?,6H7M"3\ :9$!:\).%R N6"4
,"{D) 86*"O',…+ ?*C8IT6R 4' 8B*D !D':F8& ?,6H7M"3\ %6' .!C(8& )*#D '= ?(*@-A' ?*C‘:B *6 )',Q0
.!B*0 ?(*@-A' *6 R 8<*]-+' U83*"3 U(5[_[4 50 >`LD ?,6H7M"3\
5$ ?(*@-A' 8F*`b80 ug1,0 .!;$8& ?,"I 4'!D' '= (*@-A' =( )',Q0 c6 ƒ:AR V*]-d' ?,6H7M"3\ m1*B
.(,"I8& ,{D =( '= :K[*0 ,6(*K& ?(*@-A' ?,6H7M"3\ U!;$8& ?,"I 4'!D' '= Y2Z[*0 ,6(*K&
*Cm1*B R *C,I*]D 4' (='!D*-3' 5<:]w& c6 ?(*@-A' k*Ld' ?*C,I*]D :9<"=8>, ]"*[, 9"@$;"^M
Y6*]F 4' 5$ (:B8& 5`3*Q& 86*C8w;3,{D 4' 8Z"$ ?*C ('( k*3',0 R 86*7R=' ):"L"]$ q3:F 5$ >3'
?(*@-A' k*Ld' ?*C,I*]D !;C(Y"9#F ?*Cm1*B R *C,I*]D .!6\8& >3( 50 =*$RML$ Y6*]F R !;;$u,@&
1.Corruption Perception Index
2.Transparency International
89..........G77 ?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 R =*$RML$ S'=,K& ,"bEF 83=,0
(*]-<' ,I*]D P(CCI) 4*3 R >1*3 (*]-<' ,I*]D P(ICI) 8-2;X (*]-<' ,I*]D :4' !;F=*`< 86*7R=' ):"L"]$
. (SPI) i*h3 >]"A m1*B P(CSCI) !;;$u,@&
>h+ ,f6( =:#$ 50 =:#$ c6 4' (':& *6 :+R V*K-D' 50 8+=*1 ?='HI56*&,3 :25'"6 9',:; !"#$%
U!j"D=) «)\ !6':< =( J"K-L&,"o R J"K-L& >$=*#& n'4' 50 ,"1' =:#$ =( ?(*@-A' *f;0 c6 y"3*F =( (*Z-3'
8K"Kd (',O' R 8X:@1 ?*C>$,B ?:3 4' 5D*f"0 ?*C=:#$ =( ?='HI56*&,3 ,C 50 Šr:]2& U(246 € U1985
?='HI56*&,3 5-3( R( 50 8+=*1 ?='HI56*&,3 .!;6:I8& 8+=*1 ?='HI56*&,3 (8-[R( ?*Cc]$ 4' ,"o)
.(:B8& J"LKF 8+=*1 ?:"jZF,7 ?='HI56*&,3 *6 8+=*1 J"K-L& ,"o ?='HI56*&,3 R 8+=*1 J"K-L&
S!& 8Dr:W sO*;& ML$ u!C *0 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3» V:7 8j]['%"0 ŽR!;X „6,2F k*3',0
)*&4*3 „6,2F `W %";e]C «(,"I8& S=:X %"2& (*@-A' c6 =( ,K-L& 8A:Kd *6 8K"Kd m/B c6 q3:F
4' ='!6*7 8F=*{D R >2Z;& !;;$y92;& 5$ >3' S!&!;j0 ?'5P0'= Y&*B 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3» Yj&
.>3' ,f6( =:#$ (*@-A' =( ,K-L& 8-$,B =( =:#$ c6 (*@-A' =( 8X:@1 86'='(
=( (56*&,3) 8[*& %"&*F ?=*w& 4' 896 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 ‰Q0 :25'"6 7.-8*# 9',:; !"#$%
’:<g0 ?*Cc]$ Y&*B 8+=*1 8[*& s0*;& U523:FV*d=( ?*C=:#$ =( .(:B8& G:LQ& 8jj]['%"0 zP3
?='HI56*&,3 U?'5KP;& ?*CcD*0 U8D*h+ cD*0 ,"{D (!2-& s0*;& 4' 8B*D 8[*& )*6,+ U5-O*6523:F ?*C=:#$
'= )\ %6,-]h& 4' 81,0 (='( 8f-L0 8j&':< ?,3 c6 50 ?='HI56*&,3 ,C .>3' 8+=*1 J"K-L&,"o R J"K-L&
:>B'( )*"0 5D:f;6' )':F8&
1
U(*-9D\) !B*08& *C)\ (:3 =( 8+=*1 )'='HI56*&,3 ?',0 *C?='HI56*&,3 >"0:jP& : !"#$% YB;Q"3 _$M
.(='( 8f-L0 (*@-A' )\ =( 56*&,3 (4*0 R cL6= ='!K& 50 ?='HI56*&,3 50 J"]@F %6',0*;0 .(17 € U1999
‡,D .!0*68& )*6,+ (4*0 ?r*0 ?*C‡,D R J$ S',P1 *0 ?(*@-A' =( 56*&,3 5$ !;$8& !"6EF :jZF=:7 ?=:F
GH+ >h+ 8KP;& S=:X 50 8-L6*0 UcL6= ?'='( (*@-A' c6 =( ?='HI56*&,3 (4*0 *0 !B J"{;F cL6=
*0 (R=8& =*{-D' R (:B8& ?,"I 4'!D' 56*&,3 (86*hD !"[:F) ?=R ,h0 5j"3R 50 ,"…-& %6' .!B*0 r*0 8+=*1 56*&,3
.!B*0 5-B'( >`a& 5P0'= 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 )*6,+
*0 .!D' (,$ >0*b '= 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 R 83*"3 Ž:Kd %"0 *`F=' )*D'((*@-A' : 22%".% `A-[
)R!0 R !`-L& ?*C=:#$ 4' ,-#"0 (83',$:&( R 83*"3 ,{D 4') ='!6*7 ?*C(*@-A' Uq6',B ,6*3 )(:0 >0*b ’,O
S'=:-3( U8D!& ?*C?('4\ c"F',9&( ?*CJ6v= .(1985 U3... R =!6*;B') !;;$ GH+ 8+=*1 56*&,3 !;D':F8& S*`b
1. Rate Return to Investment
2. Political Rights
3. Shneider and Frey
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…90
.!;3*;B8& >"]3= 50 U!;$8& JC',O 8+=*1 56*&,3 )*6,+ ?',0 8`3*;& q"Q& 5$ '= >"9[*& Ž:Kd R 8D:D*A
R 83*"3 8F*`b80 R r*0 cL6= >j< 50 523:FV*d=( ?*C=:#$ 4' ?=*"L0 >3' !K-2& (2001) «1?:I:D»
4' 83*"3 Ž:Kd ?,"I 4'!D' ?',0 5[*K& %6' =( .!D' (,$ GH+ 8$!D' 8+=*1 56*&,3 U8;"0 ."7 Y0*A,"o ?=*-1*3
5+:F Y0*A 5-9D .>3' !B (*Z-3' 83*"3 Ž:Kd m1*B ?',0 Freedom House 5L3:& S*<gW' R =*&\
i(,& ?*Cp4=' 6:#F u!C *0 1941 V*3 =( 5$ >3' 8-[R(,"o 8D*&4*3 Freedom House 5$ >3' )\
?('4\ >"2}R €:@1 =( 5D*"[*3 8B='_I 1972 V*3 4' 5L3“& %6' .>3' !B ?='HI56*7 *C=:#$ =( 5D'=r*3
=',A 5+:F (=:& «8D!& ?*C?('4\» R «83*"3 Ž:Kd» 5[:K& R( 5L3:& %6' 80*64=' =( R !C(8& 56'=' *C=:#$ =(
=( =:#$ ,C 50 Freedom House 5$ >3' S=:X %6' 50 *Cm1*B %6' 50 ?(!< ,6(*K& €*@-1' .(,"I8&
%6,-h0 !;C()*#D c6 ,]D .!C(8& €*@-1' 7 *F 1 (R!Q& =( ?' ,]D m1*B R( %6' 4' c6 ,C (=:&
Ž:Kd ,"…-& (R=8& =*{-D' .(1383 U8;6,Q0 ('4 %"Ld) >3' >"2}R %6,F!0 !;C()*#D >ZC ,]D R >"2}R
.!B*0 5-B'( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 )*6,+ *0 8Z;& 8f-L`]C 83*"3
‰<*0 UM3*;& ?*C>1*3,64 .(='( 83*3' >"]C' )\ ?(*@-A' q"Q& ?',0 =:#$ c6 ?*C*;0,64 : 2"@"I3 $!Q
896_"O Y9B 50 *h;F V:]2& =:W50 *C>1*3,64 .(:B8& !B= >]3 50 Jh& S*O',QD' )R!0 ?(*@-A' >$,d
8+=*1 )'='HI56*&,3 .(:B8& Y&*B _"D '= =:#$ ?*C(*hD (:1 (,$=*$ 59j0 ”!;-L"D ... R =(*;0 U*C (*+ Ya&
)R!0 5},< UG\ 5},< U*C *I(R,O U*C (*+ 4' ?'5-O*6 523:F 59`B ?'='( 5$ !;C(8& z"+,F '= 86*C(*@-A'
(4*0 ‡,D R .6'_O' '= ?(*@-A' ?*C>"[*2O 5;6_C U„"2} ?*C>1*3,64 .!B*0 >D,-;6' R %ZjF U?v,D' 5ZAR
->1*3,64 *0 86*C=:#$ =( !"[:F ?*C5;6_C Uq6',B ,6*3 S*`b ’,O *0 V*a& )':;<50 .!C(8& .C*$ '= 56*&,3
.(2000 U>L6=:&) !;;$ GH+ ?,-#"0 8+=*1 56*&,3 *C(*@-A' %6' (R=8& =*{-D' R >3' ,-]$ U?:A ?*C
R >3' 8K"Kd 8j1'( m[*1*D !"[:F Y$ 50 8-[R( ./0 8K"Kd ?='HI56*&,3 >`LD INFR ?,"I 4'!D' m1*B
%6' 50 %"#D*+ %6' (,0=*$ 5"+:F .!B*0 ,b:& 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 ,0 >`a& S=:X 50 5$ (R=8& =*{-D'
.!;6*]D GH+ '= 8+=*1 56*&,3 !;D':F8& ,-h0 ,FM3*;& ?*C*;0,64 ?'='( ?*C=:#$ 5$ >3' S=:X
82D':& !;D':F8& 83',$R=:0 R (*LO U!<*L& ?(*@-A' q"Q& (:+R *0 8-d :32%,$(&'A3 a#$> Z6 & <"*V
5;6_C .6'_O' %]} (*LO .(191 € U2001 U4%"[:6=) !D=R\ (:+R50 =:#$ c6 =( 8+=*1 )'='HI56*&,3 ?',0
5+:F *0 .!C(8& .6'_O' '= )*0_"& (*@-A' =( S*"j]< ?',0 i4r ?=*wF ?*C4:w& %-O,I !;6',O U?=*wF >"[*2O
=( «5>"O*ZB 8j& 5L3:&» U(='!D (:+R (*LO 8D*&4 ?,3 ?*Cm1*B 523:FV*d=( ?*C=:#$ ,a$' =( 59;6' 50
1. Ngowi
2. Infrastrure
3. Corruption and Buraucratic Red Tape
4. Rivlin
5. Transparency International institute
91..........G77 ?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 R =*$RML$ S'=,K& ,"bEF 83=,0
=R( ?',0 *h;F 8D*h+ cD*0 S=*{D 5L3:& ?*Cm1*B 5$ (:]D *C=*&\ ?=R\s]+ 50 ƒR,B 8[*d =( 1995 V*3
8D*&4 ?,3 ?*C ('( (:+R i!< >j< 50 U)*h+ ?*C=:#$ ,6*3 S*K"KQF ):e]C .(:0 (:+:& 2002- 1996
%"#D*+ )':;<50 U!B*08& 8j1'( m[*1*D !"[:F 4' ?!X=( S=:X50 5$ 8-[R( †=*/& 4' 1382-1338 =R( ?',0
U>[R( ‹=_0 4'!D' :>L/D 5$ >3' %6' %"#D*+ %6' 4' (*Z-3' P;& .>3' !B (*Z-3' 83',$R=:0 *6 (*LO
(*w6' ‰<*0 ‹=_0 >[R( :iR( ”(:]D !C':1 JC',O '= 8-[R( )'=:&*& q3:F 56*&,3 4' (*Z-3' n:3 ?*C>X,O
R !B !C':1 (*@-A' k*Ld ?*h#/0 =( 8+=*1 R 8j1'( 8X:@1 ./0 ?='HI56*&,3 ?,`+ 8;"#D*+ !6!7
J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 GH+ ?',0 8`3*;& q"Q& 5$ !;$8& (*w6' '= 8j9#& R !"e"7 =*-1*3 ‹=_0 >[R( : i:3
*0 8Z;& S=:X 50 83',$R=:0 _&,A q1 R (*LO m1*B 5$ (R=8& =*{-D' %6',0*;0 .(:0 !C':/D 8+=*1
.!B*0 5-B'( 8f-L`]C 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3
?='HI56*&,3 GH+ =( 8]h& Y&*< 8D*LD' ?R,"D S=*h& 4' 83*92D' )':;< 50 p4:&\ :12M"*M, !"#$%
50 R (='( !"e"7 8j"1 ?*C=*$ i*wD' ?',0 ?(*64 86*D':F !6( p4:&\ >"2]+ .(:B8& G:LQ& 8+=*1 J"K-L&
.6'_O' !6!+ ?v:[:;9F GH+ =( '= =:#$ 86*D':F Up4:&\ %";e]C .!C(8& OR !6!+ „6*‚R *0 '= (:1 8D*3\
->$,B =( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 ?=*-1*3 ,""…F M`3 Y&*< c6 )':;< 50 p4:&\ %6' ,0 )R_O' .!C(8&
R !6( p4:&\ =*96R,"D (:+R ,f6( S=*`< 50 .(:B8& ,0 ?v:[:;9F S'!"[:F 50 ,0=*$ S'!"[:F 4' 8jj]['%"0 ?*C
U%"[:6=) !B*08& 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 )*6,+ ,0 ,b:& R Jh& Y&*< )=!& ?=*wF ?*C)*&4*3 =( ,`1
?='HI56*&,3 Jh& )*I!;;$GH+ 4' !6( p4:&\ =*$?R,"D (:+R >j< 50 !;[,6' ?=:h]+ V*a& ?',0 .(2001
?,"I 4'!D' )go*B Y$ 50 8[*< Sg"@QF *0 )go*B >`LD 5j"3R 50 8D*LD' 56*&,3 .>3' (:0 8+=*1 J"K-L&
.!B*0 5-B'( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 )*6,+ *0 >`a& *`F=' m1*B %6' !6*0 ?=:F `W 5$ (:B8&
J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 )*6,+ ,0 )*0_"& =:#$ ?='HI56*&,3 ‡,D J";$ ’,O ,I' : 22F6,< 9',:; !"#$%
=*$RML$ ?',0 i(,& .6',I 4' 80*F4*0 8j1'( ?='HI56*&,3 ‡,D .J6' (:];D 8KP;& ,"o ’,O >3' ,b:& 8+=*1
5x'=' =:#$ =( ?='HI56*&,3 q"Q& 4' 8F*<gW' %";e]C ,"…-& %6' .!B*08& (*@-A' !;6\ 50 *C)\ (*]-<' R
)*6,+ zP3 ?,6H7,""…F 4' 8Q"}:F 5$ YK-L& ,"…-& c6 )':;< 50 8j1'( ?='HI56*&,3 %6',0*;0 .!C(8&
=( 8j1'( ?='HI56*&,3 8-AR J6='( =*{-D' UR= %6' 4' .(:B8& (*Z-3' U!B*08& 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3
.!B*0 r*0 _"D 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 )*6,+ (='( =',A 86r*0 zP3
1. Human Capital
2. Domestic Investment
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…92
b.-S1 9"@$.c8# ?M&' 2%'$3 .3
50 ?(*@-A' !B= )'_"& ,0 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 R %"D':A >"]$*d ?*C,"…-& ,b' )('( )*#D ,-h0 ?',0
.J64'(,78& 2010 *F 2000 ?*h[*3 8W =( G77 ?*C=:#$ R )',6' =:#$ =( 5]$*d !DR= 83=,0
G,$!, & G77 9"@'AB( '< d.M,A> Y.^("[ *!"-# .1-1 ',<A^M
0
!0.1
!0.2
!0.3
!0.4
!0.5
!0.6
!0.7
!0.8
!0.9
!1
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
G77 !"#$ %&'(#) &*"#&' !0.2823 !0.3047 !0.3115 !0.3253 !0.3223 !0.3374 !0.3243
+,&+ ,- !"#$ %&'(#) -"!, !0.5073 !0.7471
G77 !"#$ %&'(#) &*"#&'
!0.828
!0.8715 !0.8075 !0.8785 !0.9014
+,&+ ,- !"#$ %&'(#) -"!,
wdi 2010:s`;&
J6g& =*"L0 !DR= c6 G77 ?*C=:#$ =( ):D*A >"]$*d !DR= 5$ (:B8& !C*#& 1-1 ='(:]D 50 5+:F *0
8[R_D S=:X 50 )',6' =( %"D':A >"]$*d !DR= *&' .!B*08& )*&4 50 4*"D ):D*A >"]$*d S',""…F ?',0 ',64 .>3'
,f6( 4' .(:`h0 50 R= *F !B*08& )!B ,F!0 50R= )*&4 8W =( )',6' =( %"D':A >"]$*d !DR= 8F=*`< 50 !B*08&
?*C=:#$ =( .(,$ =*B' =:$H& ?*C=:#$ =( %"D':A >"]$*d ƒ:D 50 )':F8& ='(:]D %6' =( 5+:F Y0*A S*9D
%6' ?',0 i4r ?*C(*hD R >"]$*d ƒ:D ,-h0 8F=*`< 50 .!B*08& 8Z;& %"D':A >"]$*d )'_"& )',6' =( R G77
.!B*08& 8Z;& *C=:#$
93..........G77 ?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 R =*$RML$ S'=,K& ,"bEF 83=,0
G,$!, & G77 9"@'AB( '< 25'"6 7.-8*# 9',:; !"#$% ?M&' *!"-# .2-1 ',<A^M
4
3
2
1
0
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
!1
!2
!3
!4
!5
!6
+,&+ ,- ./,#0 1&234' 5,+67 8&#',4 -9,
G77 ./,#0 1&234' 5,+67 8&#',4 -9,
wdi 2010:s`;&
V*3 8W )',6' =( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 !B= )'_"& (:B8& !C*#& 2-1 ='(:]D =( 5$ =:W)*]C
8BgF Œ"C *CV*3 %6' 8W =( *h-D 5$!B*08& ƒ:}:& %6' !;C()*#D 5$ >3' 8Z;& =':]C 2004-2001
4' 8+=*1 J"K-L& )'='HI56*&,3 †R,1 ‰<*0 59j0 5-O,fD S=:X 8+=*1 ='HI56*&,3 GH+ ?*C5;"&4 >h+
)'_"& 2005-2004 V*3 8W =( %";e]C .!C(8& )*#D '= 8Z;& !B= U!B= )'_"& 5$ ?=:W50 !B JC =:#$
?='HI56*&,3 )'_"& !X=( 8 V*3 c6 %6' 8W =( 5$ ?=:W50 !B*08& G:1 =*"L0 ?!B= 5$ >`a& !B=
*0 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 !B= )'_"& 2006-2005 V*3 =( 5$ 8[*d =( .>3' 5-B'( !B= 8+=*1 J"K-L&
Š*`6,KF )',6' =( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 !B= )'_"& 2009 -2006 V*3 =( .>3' !B R=50R= :K3 !X=(4
?='HI56*&,3 GH+ >h+ 8&'!A' Œ"C *CV*3 %6' 8W =( !B*08& ƒ:}:& %6' !;C()*#D 5$ !B*08& ,ZX
2005-2002 ?*h[*3 8W ?(*@-A' !B= )'_"& G77 ?*C=:#$ =( .>3' !#D )',6' =( 8+=*1 J"K-L&
5-B'( 8Z;& ?!B= 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 !B= )'_"& 2009-2005 ?*h[*3 8W R !B*08& ?(:2X
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…94
%6' =( 8D*h+ (*@-A' )',Q0 )':F8& '= )\ Yj< 4' 896 .!D' !B 5+':& ?='HI56*&,3 †R,1 *0 ,-h0 8F=*`<50
5+':& .C*$ *0 *"D( ?*C=:#$ ,a$' =( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 !DR= ?=*"L0 !B ‰<*0 5$ >LD'( *CV*3
=( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 8Z;& R J$ =*"L0 )'_"& 50 )':F8& ='(:]D %6' =( ,f6( 5+:F Y0*A S*9D 4' .(:B
=( ?='HI56*&,3 (:`]$ !]< Yj< 4' 896 1-1 ='(:]D 50 5+:F *0 .(,$ =*B' )',6' R G77 ?*C=:#$ (*@-A'
-)*;"]W' (:`D R ?(*@-A' S*`b i!< (:+R ‰<*0 5$ %"D':A >"]$*d !0 ƒ:D )':F8& '= G77 ?*C=:#$ R )',6'
.>LD'( 56*&,3 >#I4*0 R ?='HI56*&,3 ?',0 i4r ?*C(*hD (:`D ,-h0 8F=*`< 50 *6 R i4r ?*C
G,$!, & G77 9"@'AB( '< 2F6,< NT"6"M ?.TA1 *!"-# .3-1 ',<A^M
0.09
0.08
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
0
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
G77 5#:,!9( ,- .;0+- <=#0#" -&=!3 &*"#&'
2007
2008
2009
2010
+,&+ ,- .;0+- <=#0#" -&=!3
wdi 2010:s`;&
V*3 =( G77 ?*C=:#$ =( 8j1'( m[*1*D !"[:F !B= )'_"& (:B8& !C*#& 3-1 ='(:]D =( 5$ =:W)*]C
.C*$ 50 ƒR,B 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 !B= .C*$ R *"D( =( ?(*@-A' )',Q0 ƒR,B *0 )*&_]C 2007
)!B ,-h0 *0 2010 V*3 =( .>3' 5-B'( .C*$ 8+=*1 ?='HI56*&,3 )'_"& 5$ 2009 V*3 *F R >3' (,$
!C*#& ='(:]D =( %";e]C .>3' 5-O*6 .6'_O' !DR= %6' 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 .6'_O' R ?(*@-A' ƒ*}R'
*F 2005 V*3 =( R >3' 5-B'( .C*$ ?!DR= 2005 *F 2002 V*3 4' )',6' =( m[*1*D !"[:F !B= )'_"& (:B8&
)',6' =( S*D*3:D %6' !]< Yj< 4' 896 .8#C*$ ?!DR= 2010- 2007 ?*h[*3 8W =( R ?(:2X ?!DR= 2007
(='( ,b' >ZD ='!6,1 ?*C=:#$ !"[:F )'_"& ,0 ?(*@-A' )',Q0 .!B*08& >ZD 50 )',6' (*@-A' )(:0 5-L0'R >j< 50
95..........G77 ?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 R =*$RML$ S'=,K& ,"bEF 83=,0
)'_"& R (:B8& )',6' (*@-A' (='R ?(*@-A' )',Q0 6,W %6' 4' R (='( ,b' ?='HI56*&,3 )'_"& ,0 !"[:F )'_"& R
.>3' !B ,""…F 5]C %6' =*t( )',6' =( 8j1'( m[*1*D !"[:F
b.-S1 I.B.\ .4
52[*P& Y&':< Y$ ?=R ,h0 ,0 =*$RML$ 50 †R,1 R (R=R >[:h3 S',b' Y"jQF 50 U(1390) *"D8[R p=\
%6' 50 *-6( YD*7 V!& 4' (*Z-3' *0 .CRT7 %6' =( ?R .>3' 5-1'(,7 523:FV*d=( M/-;& ?*C=:#$ ?(=:&
ƒR,B ?*C5;6_C U=*$RML$ ƒR,B )*&4 U=*$RML$ ƒR,B Yd',& m1*B )*"& 5$ >3' !"3= 5w"-D
)*&4 m1*B U=*$RML$ 8j"P2F 8D*-34*0 ‡,D U=*$RML$ ƒR,B ?',0 4*"D (=:& 56*&,3 YA'!d U=*$RML$
5P0'= !"[:F Y&':< ?=R ,h0 R =*$RML$ )(:0 4*0 5+=( U=*$RML$ 8j"P2F ?*C5;6_C U=*$RML$ 8j"P2F
-56*&,3 6,W 4' =*$RML$ †R,1 R (R=R >[:h3 5$ !B )*"0 5[*K& %6' =( %";e]C .(='( (:+R ?='(8;2&
.!B*08& ='HI,b' !"[:F Y&':< ?=R ,h0 ,0 8+=*1 ?='HI
?('4\ U8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3")':;< >QF (2002)1_j0R= _eD*3 *9Dg0 R ':f;0 *F=*& ?'5[*K&=(
?(*@-A' !B=R (FDI) 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 U?(*@-A' ?('4\ %"0 Y0*K-& ,b' 83=,0 50"!B= R ?(*@-A'
>3( 5w"-D %6' 50 5[*K& %6' =( .(4'(,78& 1970-1999V*3 ?',0 %"Fr ?*96,&\ =:#$ 18 4' 5D:]D c"6',0
%";e]C R (='( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 GH+ =( 8-`a& ,"b*F )*0_"& =:#$ =( ?(*@-A' ?('4\ 5$ !;0*68&
='4*0 R ?(*@-A' S*`b U8O*$ 8D*LD' 56*&,3 V*d %6' *0 .(='( ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 >`a& ,"b*F 8+=*1 ?='HI56*&,3
.!B*08& ,b:& S!& !;j0 =( 8+=*1 J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 sO*;& 4' ,-#"0 ?!;& ,h0 =( ('4\
%6' .(,$ =*B' )':F8& U>3' !B i*wD' 4)R,3 y"x:[ R3'!6R' *6=*& ',]C 50 (2005)2'_6:[ %&=:D
5$ !"3= 5w"-D %6' 50 *-6*hD "8]3=,"o ./0 R ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 S'=,K& ,"b*F 83=,0")':;< >QF .CRT7
.(:B8& 8]3=,"o ./0 c6,QF R ?(*@-A' !B= .C*$ 50 ,w;& !"[:F R =*$ ='4*0 =( €:@1 50 (*64 S'=,K&
%6' 50 !D('( i*wD' (2005U2008) >0:D R( =( 5$ ?'52[*P& =( 2(='_6R,I y"x:[ 4:1 R 5k:0 k*"F*&
J"K-L& ?='HI56*&,3 4' 8B*D ?(*@-A' !B= Ur*0 S'=,K& *0 ?*C=:#$ =( 4'!D' 4'."0 S'=,K& 5$ !D!"3= 5w"-D
1. Marta Bengoa, Blanca SanchezRobles
2. Norman V.loayza
3. Ana Maria Ovieda
4.Luis Serven
5. Matthias Busse
6. Juse Luis Groizard
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…96
5$ 8Zj-/& 8w;3(*@-A' ?*CV!& k*3',0 ^6*-D 5$ ('( )*#D 52[*P& %6' .!;$8& (R!Q& '= (FDI) 8+=*1
k*"F*& q3:F 80*/-D' V!& 4' !B 5-O,I,0 .CRT7 %6' =( !B G*/-D' V!&) !B*08& SR*Z-& U(:B8& (*Z-3'
.(!B*08& (='_6R,I y"x:[ 4:1 R k:0
9<"=8>, ?4' _$M W3"1 e?# f!$=1 .5
,b“& ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 ?=*"L0 Y&':< 5$ !C(8& )*#D M/-;& ?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A' !B= q6',B 83=,0
UV*…-B' )'_"& U896_"O 56*&,3 U8+=*1 J"K-L& ?'=HI56*&,3 )'_"& 50 )':F8& Y&':< %6' 5j]+ 4' !B*08&
.(,$ =*B' =*$RML$ ?*NO =( S'=,K& )'_"& R ):D*A >"]$*d
?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A' !B= ,0 ,b“& Y&':< %6' (=:& =( 80,wF S=:X 50 ?'52[*P& *F !B i4r %6',0*;0
.(,"I S=:X G77
!B= s0*F (=R\,0 =:{;& 50 !B (=R\ 5-BHI Y@O =( 5$ !B i*wD' S*K"KQF k*3' ,0 .CRT7 %6' =(
.>3' !B (*Z-3' ,64 S=:X 50 (='_6R,I y"x:[ 4:1 R k:0 k*"F*& V!& 4' M/-;& ?*C=:#$ =( ?(*@-A'
log GDP it ! c "1DBit
"2 log EMPit
" 3 log CAPit
"4 RULit
"5 log FDI it U it
(1-1)
.0*t -&./ $ 0*i !"# $ %$&'()* +, ! GDPit
.2*+3. /* 451 =c
.0*t -&./ $ 0*i !"# &#<67# %&89 :3; ! DBit
. &#<67# %&89 $ !"# :3; $ =*5>>?; %*/* :A GDP $ =*5>>?; 5@* ! "1
.0*t -&./ $ 0*i !"# $ B&?(,* -*C>. ! EMPit
.B&?(,* (G"#) E>F&7D -*C>. ! "2
HIJC>9 :J&.5F ! CAPit
HIJC>9 :J&.5F (G"#) E>F&7D -*C>. ! "3
.0*t -&./ $ 0*i !"# $ -!K&) E>L#&D -*C>. ! RULit
-!K&) E>L#&D -*C>. $ =*5>>?; %*/* :A GDP $ =*5>>?; 5@* ! "4
.0*t -&./ $ 0*i !"# $ HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F -*C>. ! FDI it
.HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F (G"#) E>F&7D -*C>. ! "5
.0*t -&./ $ 0*i !"# $ BSN* :TLM = U it
97..........G77 %&V !"# $ %$&'()* +, 5A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F < &#<67# =* 5P. 5>@U; HF 5A
" 5 $ 0 a " 4 $ 0 a "3 $0 a "2 $0 a "1#0 :# $< H. &`(K&V+, :(95R = !W =&XY&Z. < [>P\; :]>">^ _&F* 5A
.+],&A
G77 !"#$%& '() *!+,-' ./# 0.1 *#23() .6
:+,&AH. G77 %&V !"# %*5A 2010 -2004 HK&./ b/&A $ %$ <c5A B+. 5J/ %!dY* EJ&eK $
log GDPit ! 9 / 4 %0/00014DBit 1/01log EMPit 0/ 21log CAPit 0/0024RUL
0/0076log FDI
it %1
it %2
(9/7)
(-1/69)
(16)
(6/6)
(4/65)
(3/89)
R2 ! 0/ 99
2
F ! 3411
D %W ! 1/ 17
R ! 0/ 99
4.13 56.) *'.7' (89:; .1-6
2
B+. ( R ) f+, gJ+X; h>>X; 6J5i h>]jLV .EF* % !k; &A [A&Z. f+, $ <c5A 6J*5i 0&L; E.S1
.EF* 6F&]. B+. HR+]V$ l>i!; = +) +V$H. -&"K :# EF* f+.c EF$ :A 0/99
:J&.5F aB&?(,* a &#<67# %&89 $ !"# 5V :3; H]XJ gP(7. %&V5>?(. :# +V$H. -&"K R
2
*+P.
o5K H]XJ :(7A*< 5>?(. =*5>>?; +W $ 0/99 m!Ln. $ HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F < -!K&) E>L#&D aHIJC>9
.+V$H. l>i!; * %$&'()* +,
!"#5V :3; g.&, HA&q(K* %&V5>?(. p; p; 6J*5i :# EF* hJ* f+]]#-&>A t- Statisticf &.c -*C>.
.EF* B!3) gA&) a HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F < -!K&) E>L#&D aHIJC>9 :J&.5F aB&?(,* a &#<67# %&89 $
/* 5(R CA &J & 2 +J&A $+1 hJ* .+],&AH. 5@!. :(7A*< 5>?(. 5A HA&q(K* gP(7. %&V5>?(. p; p; 5dJ$ H; &31:A
$ 6J*5i :>T# :# +V$H. -&"K !#Q. :Y$&X. $ tf &.c Prob .+K!, B!3) gA&) &V5>?(. p; p; &; +,&A 2
.+],&AH. *$H]X. %95
+],&AH. 5@!. :(7A*< 5>?(. 5A HA&q(K* gP(7. %&V5>?(. 0&L; 6J*5i :# EF* hJ* f+]]# -&>A F f &.c -*C>.
f &.c %$ <c5A -*C>. $!,H. f+V&". :# !s-&LV .$!, r)*< B!3) $ !. &; +,&A 5(R CA 4 /* +J&A $+1 hJ* .:K &J
%$ <c5A 6J*5i H.&L; EuR -*!;H. +,&AH. 5(R CA 4 /* -*C>. hJ* -!t hJ*5A&]A .+,&AH. F=3411
.+](7V *QR5>@U; %$&'()* +, o5K 5A HT# EY&D $ gP(7. %&V5>?(.
!dY* $ *< gP(7. 5>?(. = !W :A :# !dY* $ 5@w. g.*!1 -*C>. f+]V$-&"K (v+3. /* 451) C5>?(. 6J5i
-*C>.) +,&AH. 9/4 HT# !s :A -c %$ <c5A -*C>. .EF* f+.c &ZN 2CM $ EA&@ =*5@* = !W :A &.* +K*f+"K
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…98
:(95R 5`K $ :# HT.*!1 5J&F :# EF* H]X. hJ* :A (EF* f+.c Fixed effects5J/ $ !"#5V $ -c 5>@U;
.+,&AH. 9/4 -*C>. :A f+.c EA&@ =*5@* = !W :A &ZN 2CM $ < f+"K
f &.c +](7V :M*!. HKy!s -&./ =+. &A :# %$&'()* %&VB+. 5x#* $ :(-!7;*< h>A <$) D-W f &.c
f <$ -*C>. :# &(J$ gK&^ %&VB+. $ &.* .+V$H. -&"K * &V5>?(. -&>. Hd(73LV$!N -*C>. -!7;*< h>A <$
+K*!;H. zP9 < +,&AHLK HA&q(K* %&V5>?(. -&>. Hd(73LV$!N f+]V$-&"K 5dJ$ f &.c hJ* +,&AH. f&;!# HK&./
B+. .( !L>; a%+L\.) +,&A f+"K {&\Y :# :(,*$ $!M< !dY* $ HLe. 5>?(. &Jc :# +,&A 6TZ. hJ* f+]V$-&"K
Hd(73LV$!N f+]V$-&"K 5>?(. hJ* hJ*5A&]A f$!A =+.f&;!# HK&./ f <$ pJ :# +,&AH. :Y&F 7 &. HK&./ f <$
.+,&AHLK HA&q(K* %&V5>?(. -&>.
<='(> (89:; .2-6
5dJ$ H; &31 :A .+]V$H. (E>F&7D) G"# H]X. 6J*5i +,&A log gA$ = !W :A B+. H()< :# O>K*$H.
5R* &.* .+,&AH. gP(7. 5>?(. $ 5>>?; +W $ pJ 5V %*/* $ :(7A*< 5>?(. $ =*5>>?; +W $ f+]V$-&"K 6J*5i
pJ 5V %*/* $ H]XJ $!,H. f$*$ -&"K +D*< = !W :A 6J*5i +,&A log -<+A H]XJ f$&F = !W :A B+.
=*5>>?; +,&A log :L>K B+. 5R* < +]#H. 5>>?; +D*< pJ C>K :(7A*< 5>?(. -*C>. gP(7. 5>?(. $ 5>>?; +D*<
.$!,H. f$*$ -&"K 5@* = !W:A zP9
(DB) #!&2<9& !?@ #* #$%& (" AB;# .1-2-6
log -<+A &#<67# %&89 $ !"# 5V :3; gP(7. 5>?(. %*5A [>P\; hJ* $ &. rA&; :# hJ* :A :M!; &A
hJ* 5@* O>J!dA O>K*!;H. zP9 |^ +,&AH. log = !W :A B+. :(7A*< 5>?(. -*C>. 5dJ$ H95s /* < +,&AH.
$+1 hJ* < +,&AH. -0/00014 5A*5A f+.c EF$:A 6J5i :I]J* :A :M!;&A .+,&AH. :K!dt %$&'()* +, 5A 5>?(.
$ *$ %$&'()* +, 5A |I1 %5@* &#<67# %&89 $ !"# 5V :3; :# EuR -*!;H. EF* Hu]. $+1 pJ
/* :# % !k; &A f+.c EF$:A 6J5i .$!,H. 5(L# %$&'()* +, +,&A 5;y&A :3; -*C>. :t5V 5dJ$ H; &31:A
.+,&AH. &R/&F f+.c EF+A [>P\; :]>">^ < =&XY&Z.
(EMP) 0!C,/' .2-2-6
5>?(. -*C>. h>]jLV +,&AH. log B&?(,* gP(7. 5>?(. %*5A [>P\; hJ* $ &. rA&; :#hJ* :A :M!; &A
-H. -&"K * (G"#) E>F&7D -*C>. gP(7. 5>?(. hJ* 6J5i hJ*5A&]A +,&AH. log = !W:A C>K B+. :(7A*<
99..........G77 %&V !"# $ %$&'()* +, 5A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F < &#<67# =* 5P. 5>@U; HF 5A
*+>^ GJ*C9* +W $ 1/01 a %$&'()* +, -*C>. +]# *+>^ GJ*C9* B&?(,* -*C>. +W $ pJ 5R* 5dJ$ H; &31:A .+V
.+,&AH. &R/&F % !k; &A 5>?(. hJ* 5@* :# +]#H.
(CAP) DE=F8@ A=!1(6 .3-2-6
-*C>. h>]jLV +,&AH. log HIJC>9 :J&.5F gP(7. 5>?(. %*5A [>P\; hJ* $ &. rA&; :# hJ* :A :M!; &A
-&"K * (G"#) E>F&7D -*C>. gP(7. 5>?(. hJ* 6J5i hJ*5A&]A +,&AH. log = !W:A C>K B+. :(7A*< 5>?(.
+W $ 0/21 a%$&'()* +, -*C>. +]# *+>^ GJ*C9* HIJC>9 :J&.5F -*C>. +W $ pJ 5R* 5dJ$ H; &31:A .+VH.
.+,&AH. &R/&F % !k; &A 5>?(. hJ* 5@* :# +]#H. *+>^ GJ*C9*
(RUL) G$H!- 58I&!J .4-2-6
H95s /* < +,&AH. log -<+A -!K&) E>L#&D gP(7. 5>?(. %*5A [>P\; hJ* $ &. rA&; :#hJ* :A :M!; &A
%$&'()* +, 5A 5>?(. hJ* 5@* O>J!dA O>K*!;H. zP9 |^ +,&AH. log = !W :A B+. :(7A*< 5>?(. -*C>. 5dJ$
EF* E3x. $+1 pJ $+1 hJ* < +,&AH. 0/0024&A 5A*5A f+.c EF$:A 6J5i :I]J* :A :M!; &A .+,&AH. :K!dt
.+,&AH. &R/&F % !k; &A f+.c EF$:A 6J5i .$ *$ %$&'()* +, 5A E3x. %5@* -!K&) E>L#&D :# EuR -*!;H.
E>L#&D m!K -*!;H. * +,&AH. E3x. -c 5@* < f+, :3F&\. 5>NU; f <$ pJ &A 5>?(. hJ* -*C>. :#hJ* ET1
-&./ :A /&>K +K!, *5JQ^ * HK!K&) :I]J* %*5A &V !"# /* :(F$ hJ* $ *5J/ .E7K*$ &V !"# /* :(F$ hJ* $ &V$&eK
*5J/ .+,&AH. :Y&7IJ OV -c -&./ :A /&>K $!, B&L1* &V !"# hJ* $ HK!K&) :I]J* %*5A 5dJ$ H; &31:A +K *$
%&V$&79 {&\Y :A OV -!K&) B&L1* {&\Y :A OV +,&AH. }>Xi &>7A &V !"# /* :(F$ hJ* $ :L#&D &V$&eK
.$!,H. &V !"# /* :(F$ hJ* $ -!K&) -$/ <$ :A 5n]. :# :L#&D
(FDI) DK#!L M8N,91 #'OPA=!1(6 .5-2-6
+,&AH. log HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F gP(7. 5>?(. %*5A [>P\; hJ* $ &. rA&; :#hJ* :A :M!; &A
E>F&7D -*C>. gP(7. 5>?(. hJ* 6J5i hJ*5A&]A +,&AH. log = !W :A C>K B+. :(7A*< 5>?(. -*C>. h>]jLV
*+>^ GJ*C9* 0*t B&F $ HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F +W $ pJ 5R* 5dJ$ H; &31:A .+VH. -&"K * (G"#)
%<5>K $!3K -*!;H. * -c ET1 .+]#H. *+>^ GJ*C9* +W $ 0/0073 a%$&'()* +, -*C>. :Y&F <$ %5>NU; &A +]#
:I]J* %*5A 5dJ$ H; &31:A .E7K*$ &V !"# /* :(F$ hJ* $ HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F $< < &A 6F&]. 5V&. &#
+]./&>K +,&A :(,*$ &V !"# /* :(F$ hJ* $ %$&'()* +, 5A %5>@U; +K*!(A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F -*C>.
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…100
5>?(. hJ* 5@* .+]# *+>^ = &e. a:J&.5F -c &A 6F&](. < 0/y ~/!.c &A &#%<5>K &; +,&AH. :Y&F <$ OV -c -&./
.+,&AH. &R/&F f+.c EF$:A :(,QR =&XY&Z. /* :# % !k; &A
(8PAQ8,H .7
E>L#&D $!,H. f+V&". :I]J* hLi %$&'()* +, -*C>. 5A gP(7. %&V5>?(. 6J*5i =*5@* :7J&P. $
:3; a+K *$ %$&'()* +, 5A *$H]X. < E3x. %5@* HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F aHIJC>9 :J&.5F aB&?(,* a-!K&)
6J5i 2 h>A :7J&P. $ h>]jLV .$ *$ %$&'()* +, 5A *$H]X. < _!IX. %5@* &#<67# %&89 $ !"# 5V
-*C>. :A E37K %5(">A &>7A 5@* B&?(,* -*C>. %$&'()* +, 5A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F < B&?(,* -*C>.
-H. !#Q. %&V !"# $ B&?(,* lZF %y&A &>7A E>LV* f+]V$-&"K hJ* .$ *$ HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F
B&?(,* -*C>. 5A %5>@U; &.* $!, % !"# $ *< HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F 5R* :# EF* hJ* -c ET1 .+,&A
&J +,&A +>u. +K*!;HLK !"# -c $&'()* :XF!; < +, %*5A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F -c +,&A :(,*+K
%*5A y<* :# +,&A +>u. +K*!;H. HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F HK&./ hJ*5A&]A .$ *$ HL# &>7A 5@* 5dJ$ H; &31:A
hJ* $*59* h>]jLV +]# $&nJ* €'q; < = &e. !"# -c $*59* %*5A &.<$ +]# $&nJ* B&?(,* !"# -c $*59*
$ = !W hJ* 5> $ +],&A /&>K $ !. GK*$ < = &e. %* *$ +J&A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F -c %*5A &V !"#
< HIJC>9 :J&.5F -*C>. E>F&7D h>A :7J&P. $ &.* .+,&A :(,*$ +K*!;HLK -*+]t %5>@U; !"# -c %$&'()* +,
:J&.5F -*C>. &; $ *QRH. 5@* %$&'()* +, 5A 5(">A a5A*5A 4/8 B&?(,* -*C>. a%$&'()* +, 5A B&?(,* -*C>.
:ITA E7>K :J&.5F $!3K G77 %&V !"# $ %$&'()* +, 0+1 gI". :# +]V$H. -&"K $!N hJ* :# .HIJC>9
O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F < HIJC>9 :J&.5F 6J5i h>A :7J&P. $ .+,&AH. &V !"# :K!R hJ* $ 5V&. $*59* 0+1
-H. ET1 .+,&AH. HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F /* 5(">A HIJC>9:J&.5F -*C>. y<* :# $!,H. f+V&". HM &N
:J&.5F &>K&@ .E7K*$ &V !"# /* :(F$ hJ* $ HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F %*5A 0/y %&V:]>./ $!3L# +K*!;
B&F<$ &A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F :# HY&D $ $ *QRH. 5@* B&F -&LV $ &V !"# /* :(F$ hJ* $ HIJC>9
&#<67# %&89 :A $< < H(qF :M $ -*C>. $!, 5(">A &#<67# */&A 5A O#&D h>K*!) :t 5V h>]jLV .5>NU;
.$!,H. O# HTN*$ €Y&N&K +>Y!; -*C>. < f+, &89 hJ* $ *< %5(L# $*59* hJ*5A&]A $!,H. 5(">A C>K
&V€N&, hJ* $ -*5J* :3; < -*5J* $ &#<67# %&89 $ -!K&) E>L#&D %&V€N&, -*C>. :A :M!; &A
/&c :]JCV < -&./ $ 48 :3; aHK&L(N&F :K*<5^ QN* 141 :3; a &#%<5>K ‚*5N* < 0*+q(F* $ 137 :3; )
-*5J* :# $!,H. f+V&". (-* *+.&eF /* HJ&8) EJ&LD $ 113 :3; a &3(1* QN* €N&, $ 113 :3; a &#<67#
:ZA* :A :M!; &A H95s/* +,&AH. 5>REqF &>7A %&V !"# ƒ2CM ~ &#<67# %&89 5A h>K*!) +A :3; {&\Y :A
-%$&'()* +, %*5A %+A &#<67# %&89 /* -*5J* EuR -*!;H. %$&'()* +, < &#<67# =* 5P. :3; |I1
.$ *+K $!M< -*5J* $ &#<67# %&89 ~ <5^ < +, %*5A 0/y %&V$&eK r)*< $ .+,&AH. *$ !N5A ~*
101..........G77 %&V !"# $ %$&'()* +, 5A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F < &#<67# =* 5P. 5>@U; HF 5A
< 5>NU; f <$ pJ &A -*5J* $ h>K*!) E>L#&D B&L1* hJ*5A&]A +,&AH. G77 %&V !"# ƒ2CM -*5J* -!t h>]jLV
.+V$H. „*!M 5>NU; f <$ <$ &A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F
:J&.5F -*C>. y<* :# f+, …1&A G77 %&V !"# $ h>K*!) E>L#&D +A -*C>. :EuR -*!;H. HT# !s:A
0+1 g>Y$ :A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F -*C>. :# f+, …1&A &>K&@ .+,&A O# &V !"# hJ* gN*$ $ HIJC>9
$ B&?(,* -*C>. :# f+, …1&A &xY&@ .+V$ „*!M 5>NU; B&F <$ &A < O# :J&.5F E"R/&A %*5A $!M!. %&V-&]>Ls*
$ &#<67# %&89 $ &V !"# /* :(F$ hJ* :3; :# f+, …1&A h>]jLV .+,&A h>J&^ &>7A &V !"# /* :(F$ hJ*
.EF* O# &>7A G77 %&V !"# $ %$&'()* +, -*C>. ~5(7R hJ*5A&]A .$5>dA *5) +A < h>J&^ %&V:3;
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…102
R)!S1
-*5e; f&d"K*$ =* &"(K* a"Hn]F $&'()* HK&3."a(1387) +>LD aHL"J5A* .1
-<&X; =&P>P\; :7F!. a"&(J$ gK&^ Hn]F $&'()*"a(1387) -&R5e. $&K < &i +>LDa f$*/ †5,* .2
-*5e; f&d"K*$
<$ a"-*5J* $ % *QR :J&.5F E>].* 5A 5@!. g.*!1" a(1383) h>7D +L\. aH]J5\A f$*/ h>7D .3
156-109 ‡ a 0<$ f &L, a %$&'()* %&V &(7M :.&]T'9
% <f5eA 5A &# < 67# :A ‚<5N < $< < EY!eF =*5@* HF 5A"a(1390) &>KHY< ~ c a&i5>T1 aH]>.* .4
$*/c f&d"K*$ a+, * HF&], &# :.&K -&J&^ ":XF!; B&D $ 6q(]. %&V !"# %$ !. :XY&Z. :g.*!1 g#
C#5. -*5e; +D*< aH.SF*
+, 5A %$&'()* %$*/c 5>@&;" a(1388) H#5e, * &F < $*!M+L\. +>F aH./ a53#* HT1 +>F aH./
.5
B&F (H"V<ˆ^-HLT1) :XF!; < GK*$ %:Tn. a"HT1 HF 5A :*5R$&eK 6(I. $5IJ< &A %$&'()*
.1388 C>J&^ a28 %f &L, aOV$CK&,
$&79 5A %$&'()* %$*/c 5@* HF 5A" a(1385) HK&3, -&PV$ *5V/ < ‰* Š< a%/&]e, .H8;5. aH(.&F .6
. 87-105 a1385 C>J&^ a28 %f &L, aO("V B&F a-*5J* %$&'()* %&VGV<ˆ^ %:.&]T'9 a"HY&.
< 67# %&89 %&V GY&t HF 5A" a(1388 f&. ‹c) .H.SF* %* !, |Tn. %&V GV<ˆ^ C#5.. .7
." &#
"%$&'()* +, 5A &#< 67# %&89 5@* HF 5A" a(1390) f$*/+L\. %+e. < 0+P. HK&)59 .
9. About doing business 2009 a world banka 2008
10. Busse, mattias and Juseluisgroizard(2005), ‘FDI, Regulation and
Growth’ , An Amprical Analysis.
11. Busse, mattias and Juseluisgroizard(2008), ‘FDI, Regulation and
Growth’ , An Amprical Analysis.
12. Doing business 2010(islamicrepablik of iran)aworld banka2009
13. Loayza Norman V; Oviedo, Ana María And Servén, Luis, (2005) , The
Impact Of Regulation On Growth And Informality: Cross-Country Evidence
, World Bank’s Latin America.
14. Morrisset P. (2000), “Foreign Direct Investment to Africa: Policiesalso
matter”, Trans-national Corporation, Vol. 9(2), PP: 107-125.
15. Ngowi H. P. (2001), “Can Africa Increase its Global Share ofFDI?”,
West African Review, Vol.2(2): PP:1 – 22
103..........G77 %&V !"# $ %$&'()* +, 5A HM &N O>P(7. % *QR:J&.5F < &#<67# =* 5P. 5>@U; HF 5A
16. Rivlin P. (2001). Economic Policy and Performance in the Arab
World,London: Lynne Renner.
17. www.worldbank.org
18. WWW.UNCTAD.org
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…104
:56$8T
Redunda
nt Fixed
Effects Test cross-section fixed effects
Tests
Pool:
FIXED
Prob.
0.0000
d.f.
Statistic
Effects Test
(18,71)
839.51075
8
Cross-section F
Cross-section fixed effects test equation:
Dependent Variable: LOG(GDP?)
Method: Panel EGLS (Cross-section weights)
Date: 06/24/12 Time: 12:42
Sample (adjusted): 2006 2010
Included observations: 5 after adjustments
Cross-sections included: 19
Total pool (balanced) observations: 95
Use pre-specified GLS weights
White cross-section standard errors & covariance (d.f.
corrected)
WARNING: estimated coefficient covariance matrix is of
reduced rank
Prob.
Coefficien
t-Statistic Std. Error t
Variable
0.0000
0.2258
0.0000
0.0000
13.61823
-1.219732
25.62202
5.346622
0.384098
0.021181
0.029417
0.000545
5.230732 C
-0.025835 LOG(EMP?)
0.753730 LOG(CAP?)
0.002913 RUL?(-1)
105..........G77 41@!AB+ !; 4;1<7=- >?! "# $9!1: 8(.7*/ 4!-56231/" 0 !1+0)*+ ,-!"./ "(%&' $ !"#
0.8277
0.5635
0.218259 0.000325 7.10E-05 DB?
-0.579887 0.008372 -0.004855 LOG(FDI?(-2))
Weighted Statistics
32.1677
Mean
dependent
8
var
0.806688
10.6400
S.D. dependent var 0.795828
5
15.7070
Sum squared resid 0.420099
2
0.03435
6
Durbin-Watson stat 74.27916
0.000000
R-squared
Adjusted
squared
R-
S.E. of regression
F-statistic
Prob(F-statistic)
Unweighted Statistics
25.4541
Mean
dependent
0
var
0.819495 R-squared
0.02728
9
Durbin-Watson stat 12.47493 Sum squared resid
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…106
Correlated Random Effects - Hausman Test
Pool: FIXED
Test cross-section random effects
Prob.
Chi-Sq.
d.f.
Chi-Sq.
Statistic
0.0004
5
22.582591 Cross-section random
Test Summary
Cross-section random effects test comparisons:
Prob.
Var(Diff.)
Random
Fixed
Variable
0.0049
0.0000
0.1270
0.6814
0.0359
0.027284
0.000281
0.000000
0.000000
0.000018
0.344935
0.214719
0.004905
-0.000136
0.027822
0.809817 LOG(EMP?)
0.138020 LOG(CAP?)
0.003945 (RUL?(-1))
-0.000119 DB?
0.018959 LOG(FDI?(-2))
Cross-section random effects test equation:
Dependent Variable: LOG(GDP?)
Method: Panel Least Squares
Date: 06/24/12 Time: 12:43
Sample (adjusted): 2006 2010
Included observations: 5 after adjustments
Cross-sections included: 19
Total pool (balanced) observations: 95
Prob.
Coefficien
t-Statistic Std. Error t
Variable
0.0000
0.0000
0.0035
0.0043
8.645931
4.474369
3.020682
2.949771
1.532234
0.180990
0.045692
0.001337
13.24759
0.809817
0.138020
0.003945
C
LOG(EMP?)
LOG(CAP?)
RUL?(-1)
107..........G77 41@!AB+ !; 4;1<7=- >?! "# $9!1: 8(.7*/ 4!-56231/" 0 !1+0)*+ ,-!"./ "(%&' $ !"#
0.6843
0.0459
-0.408272 0.000291 -0.000119 DB?
2.031523 0.009332 0.018959 LOG(FDI?(-2))
Effects Specification
Cross-section fixed (dummy variables)
25.4541
Mean
dependent
0
var
0.998737
0.85745
4
S.D. dependent var 0.998328
3.64910
Akaike info criterion 0.035066
1
3.00391
1
Schwarz criterion 0.087304
Hannan-Quinn
3.38839
criter.
197.3323
6
0.92992
6
Durbin-Watson stat 2440.613
0.000000
R-squared
Adjusted
squared
R-
S.E. of regression
Sum squared resid
Log likelihood
F-statistic
Prob(F-statistic)
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…108
Dependent Variable: LOG(GDP?)
Method: Pooled EGLS (Cross-section weights)
Date: 06/24/12 Time: 12:45
Sample (adjusted): 2006 2010
Included observations: 5 after adjustments
Cross-sections included: 19
Total pool (balanced) observations: 95
Linear estimation after one-step weighting matrix
White cross-section standard errors & covariance (d.f.
corrected)
WARNING: estimated coefficient covariance matrix is of
reduced rank
Prob.
Coefficien
t-Statistic Std. Error t
Variable
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0950
0.0002
9.710560
16.35630
6.616970
4.656715
-1.691927
3.898599
0.969514
0.062341
0.032503
0.000533
8.77E-05
0.001875
9.414526 C
1.019661 LOG(EMP?)
0.215070 LOG(CAP?)
0.002484 RUL?(-1)
-0.000148 DB?
0.007309 LOG(FDI?(-2))
Fixed
Effects
(Cross)
-0.053821 _ALG—C
1.163930 _ARG—C
-1.772855 _BAN—C
0.232141 _COL—C
0.857574 _DOM—C
-0.130446 _EGY—C
-1.920893 _IND—C
-1.216988 _INDO—C
-0.242673 _IRA—C
-0.089990 _MOR—C
0.103411 _PER—C
109..........G77 41@!AB+ !; 4;1<7=- >?! "# $9!1: 8(.7*/ 4!-56231/" 0 !1+0)*+ ,-!"./ "(%&' $ !"#
1.272737 _SAU—C
2.157784 _SIN—C
-0.504056 _THA—C
0.664001 _TUN—C
1.552409 _URU—C
0.786650 _VEN—C
-1.688020 _VIE—C
-1.170894 _PAK—C
Effects Specification
Cross-section fixed (dummy variables)
Weighted Statistics
32.1677
Mean
dependent
8
var
0.999096
10.6400
5
S.D. dependent var 0.998803
0.07345
4
Sum squared resid 0.032165
1.17003
5
Durbin-Watson stat 3411.578
0.000000
R-squared
Adjusted
squared
R-
S.E. of regression
F-statistic
Prob(F-statistic)
Unweighted Statistics
25.4541
Mean
dependent
0
var
0.998594 R-squared
0.80174
Sum
squared
3
Durbin-Watson stat 0.097197 resid
(1391 7"$8,9 61 /3"45 /012) !"#$%& '()* +,"-)#. …………….……….……….…110

 Download  Report

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz

© Copyright 2024 Paperzz