What to Consider When Choosing Your Next Best Friend

What to Consider When Choosing Your Next Best Friend
The way my husband and I chose our first dog was not the way I’d planned to pick a pet. Sure, we
spent some time thinking about personality traits and how much shedding we wanted to deal with,
and we looked at a few different dogs without committing. But after the sweet, cuddly lab we’d
picked turned out to be already promised to another family, we were feeling a little sorry for
ourselves. Then we got a phone call from a rescue group, saying that a young lab mix had just been
brought up to New York from a high-kill shelter in the South.
That evening, I showed up at the daycare center where the dog was staying and sighed. My husband
was already sitting on the floor, watching a hyperactive puppy sniff his way around the room. As I
looked from my husband to the dog, I realized that he’d already decided to take this dog home. Never
mind that we were looking for a calm, floppy lab, and this was a strong young hound (more Labrador
deceiver than Labrador retriever). And ignore the fact that this dog was still a puppy, who’d need lots
of training. We had the option of bringing this dog home, today, and that was going to be too
tempting to pass up.
“Shouldn’t we take him for a walk, or see how he responds to being rolled over?” I asked. The three of
us went for a walk around the block, but it was clear that my husband was just humoring me. The 8month-old puppy, already a sizable 60 lbs, pulled us all over the sidewalk, jumping excitedly from
one trash bag to the next. And sure enough, 10 minutes later we were on our way home with the
newest member of our household.
When you look for a new pet, please don’t do it the way I did. I will tell you what I’d planned to do –
and hopefully you’ll do a better job of sticking to the plan than I was.
It might seem obvious, but make sure that everyone in your household agrees about getting a new
pet. As anyone who’s ever had a baby or moved in with a new roommate can attest to, a change in
your household is stressful. It’s hard to adjust to a different set of needs and routines! You and your
new pet are going to need time to get used to each other, and things will be much more complicated
if there’s someone around who isn’t on board with the plan for a pet in the first place.
The next thing to think about is the pet’s temperament. While there’s always individual variation,
you can make some predictions about personality and energy level by choosing a particular breed.
Thinking about dogs, terriers tend to be very strong chewers and diggers, and hounds can be
extremely energetic with a constant need to run. Herding dogs can be very smart – which makes
them easy to train, but since they can just as easily get bored, these breeds need a lot of mental
stimulation. Opposite to what you might expect, bigger breeds are usually extremely mellow, and
small breeds can be very high-energy dogs, running around the house all day and never settling
down. Cats can be harder to stereotype than dogs (no surprise there), but there are still some
common themes. Many long-haired breeds are sweet, affectionate and laid-back. Siamese and other
Oriental breeds tend to be active, and often very vocal. If you’re looking for a curious, playful cat, you
may consider getting a Bengal or Ocicat, two very energetic breeds.
Age is also important. Younger animals will usually be more playful and active than older ones.
Puppies and kittens require a lot of time and energy to train, but they also give you the opportunity
to help shape your pet’s personality and habits. (I also think they are tremendous fun, but I know not
everyone agrees.) But if you know you won’t have the time for frequent walks, appropriate training,
and socialization with other dogs, cats and people, you’d be better off choosing an older animal –
either an adolescent or an adult. With an adult pet, generally what you see is what you get. There
aren’t as many surprises; you can feel more confident that your pet’s personality is stable. On the
other hand, it’s also harder to change annoying (or maybe even dangerous) behaviors that the pet
may have been happily pursuing for years before they met you.
Once you’ve thought about all of these factors, don’t lose sight of your choices! It’s very hard to look a
dog in the eyes and turn him down, but remember, you’re making a decision for a lifetime. If you
choose the cat that jumps in your lap and immediately starts batting at your necklace, you’re going to
have to interact with her every day – not just today when you’re giving her your full attention, but
also next week when you’re trying to dust your bedroom, and a few months down the line when you
are hosting that fancy party with those expensive, easily breakable wine glasses. So steel your heart
and think critically: is this the pet for me? If not, think about all the other people who are waiting to
fall in love with this pet, and let that knowledge help you move down and look at the next one.
A year and a half after my husband and I adopted our dog Charlie, we both agree that we’d like to do
it differently next time. He can be quite a challenge, and it took a lot of hard work, stress and
patience before he grew into the dog we needed him to be. He is still goofy and can be pretty crazy
sometimes (and he’s definitely harder on the furniture than we anticipated), but he is also obedient
when it’s really important. So please, learn from my experience and try to get a pet who matches your
needs and personality from the beginning. Your housemates – and your shoes, furniture, and
anything else breakable – will thank you!