oev evaluation report formatting guidelines

Decentralized evaluation for evidence-based decision making
Decentralized Evaluation
[Evaluation Title]
[Period covered]
Font: Verdana 16 bold
Font: Verdana 14 bold
Evaluation Report Font:
Verdana 16 bold
[Month Year] Font: Verdana 11
[Name of commissioning office]
Evaluation Manager [Name of Evaluation Manager]
Prepared by Font: Verdana 9
[name, Team Leader]
[name, title of team member 1]
[name, title of team member etc]
Acknowledgements Font: Georgia 12pt bold
[include acknowledgement here] Font: Georgia 12pt
Disclaimer
The opinions expressed in this report are those of the Evaluation Team, and do not
necessarily reflect those of the World Food Programme. Responsibility for the
opinions expressed in this report rests solely with the authors. Publication of this
document does not imply endorsement by WFP of the opinions expressed.
The designation employed and the presentation of material in maps do no imply the
expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of WFP concerning the legal or
constitutional status of any country, territory or sea area, or concerning the
delimitation of frontiers.
Table of Contents Font: Georgia 12pt bold
Ensure that page numbering starts after the table of contents page, with format
i,ii,ii
Executive Summary .......................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
After the Executive Summary restart with numbering format 1,2,3...
All page numbers should be bottom of page in the centre in font Georgia 12pt
1.
Introduction .................................................................................... 1
1.1. Overview of the Evaluation Subject ................................................................ 1
1.2. Context ............................................................................................................ 1
1.3. Evaluation Methodology and Limitations ...................................................... 1
2.
Evaluation Findings ......................................................................... 1
2.1. Evaluation Question 1 ..................................................................................... 1
2.2. Evaluation Question 2 .................................................................................... 1
2.3. Evaluation Question 3 .................................................................................... 1
2.4. Evaluation Question 4 .................................................................................... 1
3.
Conclusions and Recommendations ................................................. 1
3.1. Overall Assessment/Conclusions ................................................................... 1
3.2. Lessons Learned and Good Practices (optional) ........................................... 1
3.3. Recommendations .......................................................................................... 1
Table of Contents body: Georgia 12pt
Only above titles and additional titles following the same sequence (e.g. 1.4, 1.5,
1.6, 2.4, 2.5) to be included in Table of Contents.
Subsequent sub-headings (below 1.1 level should NOT be numbered but can be
font georgia 12pt bold)
Ideally, main report should be maximum 50 pages in length. In exceptional cases
where the main report exceeds 50 pages the Annexes should be separated out
into Volume II. In the case of 2 volumes, the List of Annexes should still be
included in Table of Contents Vol I - as per below.
List of Annexes (in Vol II)
Annexes ..................................................................................................4
Annex 1: Terms of Reference ................................................................................. 4
Annex 2: Evaluation Matrix .................................................................................. 4
Annex 3: Documents Reviewed ............................................................................ 4
Annex 4: Stakeholders Interviewed ...................................................................... 4
Annex 5: Data Collection Tools ............................................................................. 4
Annex 6: Bibliography .......................................................................................... 4
Annex n: [Insert title] ........................................................................................... 4
Acronyms ............................................................................................... 5
[Example] List of Tables:
Table 1 Breakdown of Interviews ........................ Error! Bookmark not defined.
Table 2 Regional poverty in the Kyrgyz Republic 2009-11. Error! Bookmark not
defined.
Table 3 Declining poverty and malnutrition in the Kyrgyz Republic 1990–2008.
Error! Bookmark not defined.
Table 4 WFP portfolio 2008 – 2011 by Programme Category in Kyrgyzstan . Error!
Bookmark not defined.
Table 5 Portfolio activities vs. WFP Strategic Objectives ... Error! Bookmark not
defined.
[Example] List of Figures:
Figure 1 Food insecurity by region and season (number of people)................. Error!
Bookmark not defined.
Figure 2 Donor shares of WFP funding 2008-2012 ............. Error! Bookmark not
defined.
Figure 3 Prices of sugar and sunflower oil 2009 – 2012 ...... Error! Bookmark not
defined.
Figure 4 Uneven development trajectory ............. Error! Bookmark not defined.
Figure 5 WFP caseload figures for VGF vs. severe food insecurity by oblast ... Error!
Bookmark not defined.
Ensure Table of Contents, List of Tables/Figures or Boxes are automatically, NOT
manually generated.
To create the automatic lists of tables etc. use ‘References tab/Insert Caption’
Use the heading styles as per example ToC in this template to format your text.
Tables/Figures from the Executive Summary are NOT included in the List of
Tables/List of Figures. Only Tables/Figures in the main body of the report should
be listed.
Executive Summary
Methodology
Key Findings
Overall conclusions
Recommendations
i
1. Introduction
1.1. Overview of the Evaluation Subject
1.
Text should be ‘justified’ throughout – including the footnotes.
Font: Georgia 12pt; Suggested spacing: before: 6pt, after: 6pt. Suggested
line spacing: single
NOTE: Paragraph numbers start at 1. again in the main body of the report
(i.e., para. numbering starts at 1. in the Executive Summary and re-starts
again at 1. from Introduction until the end of the document.
1.2. Context
2.
3.
1.3. Evaluation Methodology and Limitations
4.
5.
2. Evaluation Findings
2.1. Evaluation Question 1
6.
7.
2.2. Evaluation Question 2
8.
9.
10.
2.3. Evaluation Question 3
11.
12.
2.4. Evaluation Question 4
3. Conclusions and Recommendations
3.1. Overall Assessment/Conclusions
13.
3.2. Lessons Learned and Good Practices (optional)
14.
3.3. Recommendations
15.
1

Ensure that paragraphs are numbered correctly as per above
paragraph numbering format.
[Example] paragraph with correct numbering format:
16. The country portfolio evaluation of WFP activities in the Kyrgyz Republic covers
the period from when WFP started working there in 2008 until 2012. It serves the dual
objectives of accountability and learning and focuses on: i) the alignment and strategic
positioning of WFP’s operations in the country; ii) the drivers of strategic decisions;
and iii) the performance and results of WFP operations.
Tables and Figures:

Ensure that tables are not 'broken' in two different pages. If the table is
too large to fit on one page ensure table headings are repeated on
subsequent pages.

Ensure that numbers/texts in tables/graphs are readable (even when
printed in black and white)

Georgia 11pt bold should be used for table/figure/box titles

Georgia 8pt should be used for footnotes and source references under
a table/figure/box. Ensure footnote text is justified.

Ensure correct table/figure alignment (see below examples)
[Example] table with correct alignment, title and source format:
Table 1: WFP Portfolio Overview
Number of
operations
% of overall
requirements
Requirements
(USD$)
IR-EMOP
2
997 488
1
EMOP*
2
47 411 984
59
Special
operation
PRRO
1
4 431 378
5
1
28 097 458
35
6
80 938 308
100
2011–2013
2008–2011
Project
type
TOTAL
WFP Strategic
Objectives
1 – Save lives and
protect livelihoods in
emergencies
2 – Prevent acute
hunger and invest in
disaster
preparedness and
mitigation measures;
3 – Restore and
rebuild lives and
livelihoods; and
5 – Strengthen the
capacities of
countries to reduce
hunger
Activities
GFD
GFD, VGF
and FFW
Logistics
augmentation
VGF, FFW,
FFT and
capacity
development
Source: Standard Project Reports.,FFT: food for training, GFD: general food distribution, PRRO: protracted relief and recovery
operation, VGF: vulnerable group feeding
2
[Example] figure with correct alignment, title and source format:
Figure 1: Percentage of beneficiaries by activity
2009
2010
VGF/GFD
FFW
2011
2012*
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
Vulnerable group feeding
No. of
beneficiaries
Men/boys
Women/girls
2009
2010
196 845
488 730
204 905
529 455
2011
2012
319 925
n/a
339 910
n/a
Total
401 750
1 018
185
659 835
407 559
* 2012 data from country office.
Note: n/a = not available
Source: Standard Project Reports.
3
80%
90%
100%
Food for work/assets/training
Men/boys
Women/girls
Total
20 350
18 050
38 400
48 775
n/a
32 500
n/a
81 275
94 345
Annexes
Annex 1: [title for first annex mentioned in main body of text]
Annex 2: [title for second annex mentioned in main body of text]
Annex n: [etc.]
4
Acronyms
5
[Place, Month and Year, Report number]
– the month, year of completion of ER and Report
number will be provided by OEV KM focal point
[Name of commissioning Office]
[Link to the website]
Style requirements:

Use italics exclusively for book title and words and expressions in
languages other than English

Use bold in headings and sub-headings but NOT in bulleted lists.

Do NOT use italic or bold fonts in text to denote emphasis, which
should be instead reflected in the phrasing.

Do NOT use capital letters for headings.
Abbreviations and Acronyms:

Acronyms should be spelled out in full at their first occurrence in
the text. Yet they should not be used in the Executive Summary.

For dollars use US$ with no space between the letters, symbol and
numerals (e.g.US$246.1 million). Use a hard space before million.
For the Euro use € (e.g. €356,128).

In text, always write out percent with a hard space between the
numeral and percent (e.g.42 percent). In tables, use % with no space
between the numeral and the symbol.

World Bank and United Nations are never abbreviated (NOT “WB”
or “UN”)

When acronyms are spelled out, we rarely use capital letters. Eg
non-governmental organization rather than Non-Governmental
Organization (except for title of a report and names of an
organization/ institution). Check if a word is capitalised under the
list of frequently used acronyms in the WFP English Style Guidelines

Never use acronyms for governments (e.g. the Government of
Pakistan, not "GOP")
Hyphens:

Use a hyphen to form a compound adjective (e.g. long-term effects,
private-sector partnership, civil-society organization, two- or threeyear period).
Tables and Figures:

A table or figure must be placed immediately after the paragraph in
which it is mentioned and should have a brief, accurate title.
Number tables and figures separately, each in consecutive order.
Footnotes and References

In the body text the footnote number goes after the punctuation (not
before).

Footnotes should be brief, limited to providing references or extra
information that would interrupt the flow of the body of the text.
WFP Editoral Style Guide:
A WFP Style Guide that sets out the style conventions used in WFP and
advises on usage is also available http://cdn.wfp.org/guides/editorial/