Working with Practices: The Practice Level Key Drivers

Practice Key Driver Diagram
Starting with the End in Mind:
Creating a Reliable System for
ADHD Care
Chapter Quality Network ADHD Project
Jen Powell MPH, MBA
Edward Lewis MD
Commercial Interests Disclosure
Jen Powell MPH, MBA
Edward Lewis MD
I have no relevant financial relationships with the
manufacturer(s) of any commercial product(s) and/or
provider of commercial services discussed in this CME activity.
I do not intend to discuss an unapproved or investigative use
of a commercial product/device in my presentation.
3
Session Objectives
 Articulate the six key drivers that provide a framework to
improve ADHD care
 Describe characteristics of a reliable system of ADHD care
 Describe decision aids and resources to be used at point
of care to support parents
Handouts
 Practice-level key driver diagram
 Understanding ADHD booklet
 Model for Improvement (MFI) Laminated Card
 Parent Conversation Checklist
Frameworks:
Key Driver Diagram
Model for
Improvement
Elements of a
Reliable System
Aids and
Resources for
Parents
Practice Key Driver Diagram
 WHAT IS A KEY DRIVER DIAGRAM (KDD) AND WHY IS IT USEFUL?
 A KDD is a pictorial representation of a system that displays our
theories about how to improve an established aim or
outcome. It is useful in the following ways:
 It creates a visual road map for all organizations and stakeholders
 It creates a common vision of what we are trying to accomplish
 It documents our theories and ideas of how we think we will reach
our aim
 It allows us to keenly focus on what we have agreed to… It keeps us
focused on the vital activities we need to accomplish our goal
Practice Key Driver Diagram
Model for Improvement
The ADHD “Change Package”
 A tailored packet of resources, tools, approaches
 Organized by the practice-level key drivers
 Will include “ready made” resources that practices can
immediately test and tailor to the needs of the practice
 We will introduce today and on monthly practice calls
 Sections will be shared as they are developed
Frameworks
Reliability
Parent
Resources
Practice Key Driver Diagram
Defining “Reliability”
 The measurable capability of an object to perform its intended
function in the required time under specified conditions.
(Handbook of Reliability Engineering, Igor Ushakov, Editor)
 The probability of a product performing without failure a specified
function under given conditions for a specified period of time.
(Quality Control Handbook, Joseph Juran, Editor)
 The extent of failure-free operation over time. (David Garvin)
Definition of Reliability for Health Care
 The capability of a process, procedure or health service to perform its
intended function in the required time under existing conditions.*
 For example, how often (capability) does developmental screening (process)
occur (intended function) now (existing conditions)
 Our goal is to ensure that the right thing happens every time because our
practice has the systems in place to accomplish our goals.
*Institute for Healthcare Improvement
Quantifying “Reliability”
 “Reliability” = Number of actions that achieve the intended result ÷ Total
number of actions taken
 % of visits where ADHD care occurs when and how it is supposed to
 Failure rate = 1 – “Reliability”
 60% performance of implementing ADHD guidelines means failures
occur 40% of the time
 It is convenient to use failure rate as an index, an order of magnitude
 10-1 means that 1 time in 10, the process fails to achieve its intended
result
A System is Unreliable When:
 It is not practiced by the entire organization
 No one is keeping track of “failures” (or changes in
reliability)
 Systems are not documented
 It is not ingrained into the culture and reinforced in staff
meetings, hiring decisions and orientation to new staff
Starting Definitions of Reliability
 Chaotic process: Failure in greater than 20% of opportunities
 Level 1: (10-1 ) 80-90% Reliability.
(1-2 failures out of 10)
 Level 2: (10-2 ) Approximately 95% Reliability.
(<5 failures out of 100)
 Level 3: (10-3 ) Approximately 99% Reliability.
(<5 failures out of 1000)
Our current data indicate that our ADHD care processes are not very reliable
Level 1 (80-90%) Reliability
 Team focus on the outcome goal
 Working harder
 Feedback of information on performance
 Awareness and training
 Standardize decision-making (e.g., guidelines)
Level 1 Concepts
 Standardize using orders sets, protocols
 Work harder next time
 Feedback information to team on compliance
 Awareness and training
Examples of Level 1 Reliability
 Team focus on the outcome goal: Team aim and goals.
 Working harder: Better team collaboration
 Feedback of information on performance: Monthly
measurement and feedback of results
 Awareness and training: List of commonly used community
resources, training staff in new roles
 Standardize decision-making: Practice-wide guidelines
Level 2 (95%) Reliability
 Real time identification of failures
 Checklists and observation
 Redundancy
 Making the “right thing” the “easy thing”
 Standardization of process
Examples of Level 2 Change Concepts
 Standardize Process: Clear staff and MD roles in ADHD
care for each point of contact
 Make it easy to do right: mehealth prompts to indicate
time to initiate a follow-up Vanderbilt screening
 Default to the appropriate option: Parents and teachers
receive the Vanderbilt scales whether a physician orders
or not.
Additional Level 2 Examples
 Redundancy: Two people verify that patients have been
notified for a follow-up visit
 Checklists: Diagnosis and follow up parent conversation
checklist
 Real-Time ID of Failures: Daily review of no shows and plan
for follow-up
Level 3 (99%) Reliability
 Preoccupation with failure: Real-time awareness of failures (daily
monitoring of process), “Process Owner” (who is responsible for registry)
 Reluctance to simplify interpretations: learning from each failure and
from those doing better.
 Sensitivity to operations: staff wiling to remind each other about ADHD
processes and utility of registry
 Commitment to resilience: response to failures positively! (they are
gifts!)
 Deference to expertise and experience: Avoidance of strict “TopDown” culture. Everyone can speak up and state what is happening
Level of Reliability
Level 1
(10-1)
Level 2
(10-2)
Level 3 (10-3)
Components
Standardize decision-making
Check Lists, Vigilance
Awareness, Feedback
Decision Aids, Redundancy
Desired Action is Default
Real Time Identification
of Failure, Standardization of
process
Mindfulness, Pre-Occupation
with Failure, Resilience
Standardization of Behavior,
System is Visible
“Robust Design”
Process/control factors
• Level 1 Components
• Level 2 Components
• Level 3: Mindfulness
Situational factors
•
•
•
•
•
Severity of problem
Values/habits/lifestyle
Preferences
Support system
Resource availability
+
Outcomes
• Development
• Function
• Learning
Frameworks
Reliability
Parent
Resources
Parent Conversation Checklist
Parent Resource at Diagnosis
Local Resources
ADHD NY 1 Parent Resources can be found at
www. ny1aap.org in the Resource Section.
Summary
 Reliable systems for ADHD… important to start with the
end in mind
 mehealth portal is designed to assist your practice in
moving along the reliability continuum
 Rest of today will focus on testing strategies to implement
reliable systems
 CQN will continue to build a repository of tools, resources
and approaches to improve reliability