Research Bulletin No.9 January 2017 Editorial Gerard O’Reilly This is the ninth edition of the Research Bulletin of the Central Bank of Ireland and its aim is to highlight economic research and associated activities conducted by bank staff during 2016. Nine research technical papers have been released last year. The non-technical summaries for each of these papers are included in this bulletin while the full papers are available for download from the Central Bank website. Some of the recent themes explored include: differences in wages for new hires relative to incumbents or individuals who change jobs; the effects of mortgage modification on loan performance; labour market participation in Ireland; the degree of contagion between sovereign bond markets during the financial crisis; an examination of the effects of nonstandard measures on bank lending in a model with financial frictions; factors explaining the the larger premium paid by small firms on loans in the euro area. Thirteen economic letters were released in 2016 and a listing of these is included while the actual Letters are available for download. Some of the topics covered in this series include: an examination of household savings behaviour in Ireland; countercyclical capital buffer indicators; the role of private placement in funding the wholesale banking industry; the differential impact of oil on euro area inflation. Eight of the letters are related to the recent review of macroprudential regulations in the mortgage market. Some of the areas examined include describing characteristics of borrowers and leverage pre and post the introduction of the mortgage rules; models of the housing market including rents and house prices, an assessment of the resilence of mortgages drawn down. We also published a number of signed articles with economic and statisical content in the Quarterly Bulletin which can also be downloaded. Also included in this edition are recent and forthcoming publications by bank staff in peer reviewed academic journals as well as a listing of visiting speakers who presented over the past year at the CBI. Bank staff have also presented extensively externally at a range of domestic and international conferences and institutions including: Bank of England; EEA meetings; European Banking Authority; ECB; IEA annual conference; NBER summer meetings; Society for Computational Economics; Money, Macro, Finance Meetings; NUI Maynooth and UCD amongst others. The Bank also hosted the ESCB Network on Household Finance and Consumption in June and held two history workshops one of the which was held under the auspices of CEPR. Contents Technical Paper Summaries 3 Economic Letters 10 Visiting Speakers 11 External Publications Journal Articles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Forthcoming . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Research Bulletin Non Technical Summaries of Research Technical Papers 2016 01/RT/16: Understanding Irish Labour Force Participation Stephen Byrne & Martin O’Brien ence of some structural factors. Accordingly a rise in the participation rate is to be expected in the near term as the economic recovery continues, and current measures of slack in the economy should account for this. Combining our results and various population projection scenarios, we show that policy actions to increase female participation will support trend labour force participaton but may not be sufficient to fully offset declines in the male trend. Higher immigration is another effective way of offsetting the expected decline in trend participation out to 2025. This paper explores developments in the labour force participation rate in Ireland. Given the important role of labour supply in explaining Irish economic growth, we aim to identify the relative influence of structural and cyclical factors in the recent dynamics of Irish labour force participation. Using a number of empirical approaches our results highlight the role of age, nationality and gender on the participation rate. We also find that the recent decline in female participation is entirely a response to the stage in the economic cycle given the weaker labour market, whereas the fall in male and overall participation also reflects the influ- 02/RT/16: Bank Lending, Collateral, and Credit Traps in a Monetary Union Giuseppe Corbisiero Since the beginning of the recent financial crisis, the ECB has responded to financial system impairments by complementing cuts in the policy interest rate with a wide range of nonstandard measures, so injecting a large amount of liquidity at low cost. Nevertheless, bank lending hardly reacted, notably in countries where higher perceived risks of sovereign default emerged. At the same time, banks increased their domestic sovereign debt holdings to a much greater extent in stressed countries. tably because of the high leverage of banks and their dependence on market confidence, which can disappear in a crisis. Specifically, I assume that the occurrence of sovereign default would generate a liquidity shock severely hitting a share of the country’s banks. Capturing the general equilibrium interplay between liquidity, financial frictions, firms‘ collateral, and lending, the model shows that the banking-sovereign nexus crucially impairs the monetary transmission mechanism. In This paper provides a model to explain particular, I show that lending responses to these stylized facts by studying the transmis- monetary policy across countries are asymsion of central bank liquidity injections to cor- metric, with liquidity injections mainly financporate lending in a monetary union. In this ing the sovereign rather than boosting lendmodel, countries differ in sovereign risk, and ing in the risky country. This is because the firms‘ access to external finance can be con- banking-sovereign nexus prevents banks from strained by financial frictions. The framework fully taking into consideration the risk of their takes into account that the banking sector is sovereign; hence, they respond to liquidity invery vulnerable to domestic sovereign risk, no- jections by purchasing domestic sovereign debt, 3 Research Bulletin to the detriment of private lending. This theoretical mechanism can shed light on the troubled transmission of the ECB‘s policy measures to the economies of stressed countries during the euro sovereign debt crisis. I also show that sovereign risk in one country generates negative spillover effects that, through the collateral channel, can depress lending throughout the monetary union. Specifically, the possibility of a liquidity shock due to sovereign risk can reduce the expected price of assets used as loan collateral; therefore, to the extent that asset markets are integrated across countries, sovereign risk can undermine debt capacity of firms even in economies that do not suffer from high sovereign risk. This transmission mechanism provides new testable implications briefly discussed in the paper. This theory has the following policy implications. First, it can be beneficial to promote cross-border lending in the Euro Area, as well as weakening the link between a country’s banking and the health of its public finances. Second, a timely intervention in response to sovereign market turmoil would lessen banks‘ search for sovereign yields and allow a more effective monetary stimulus to private lending in stressed countries. Third, nonstandard measures able to improve corporate sector liquidity, circumventing the banking intermediation channel may enhance the monetary stimulus. 03/RT/16: Contagion in Eurozone Sovereign Bond Markets? The Good, the Bad and the Ugly David Cronin, Tom Flavin & Lisa Sheehan Eurozone sovereign bond markets have experienced considerable and persistent turmoil in recent times. Most sovereigns have suffered downgrades to their credit ratings since 2010. Against this background, there is a burgeoning literature on how sovereign bond markets within the Eurozone have interacted with each other during periods of turbulence. In particular, there have been studies of whether contagion - an excessive co-movement between bond spreads following a shock in one market - has arisen. Results differ across studies, with some finding evidence for contagion while others do not. of the data since 2003: a good normal environment and two states of crisis, termed the bad and the ugly. There is a striking difference between the volatility increases experienced by Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain (the GIPS) and core countries, such as Finland and the Netherlands, between normal and crisis phases with the former group experiencing much larger increases. A striking feature of our results is that there are relatively few examples of contagion among the member states. When contagion is detected, it occurs more often in the ugly than in the bad regime. This highlights We shed new light on the topic by analysing the importance of differentiating between the relationships among ten Eurozone countries two phases of the crisis and not treating it as using daily 10-year sovereign bond spreads one homogenous event. Contagion does not over Germany from January 2003 to December emanate exclusively from the GIPS. There is 2014. Daily bond spreads for the United States at least as much evidence of contagion stemare also included to control for external events. ming from core countries. This is consistent We follow Forbes and Rigobon (2002) in defin- with the view that larger financial markets proing contagion as a significant increase in mar- cess information more efficiently and transmit ket dependence between normal and crisis pe- the news to more peripheral markets and that riods. The econometric methodology allows us smaller sovereign bond markets, while under define such periods and the econometric output more stress, have less ability to generate conpoints towards a three-regime characterisation tagion than core member states. 4 Research Bulletin We conclude that with most relationships remaining stable over the sample period, it was not changes to the shock transmission mechanism that caused the spread of the sovereign debt crisis. Rather, its propagation was due to pre-existing cross-country linkages that had built up during the benign economic conditions that characterised the pre-crisis period. Once shocks arose in bond markets, their transmission to other markets should not have been unexpected given the interdependencies between Eurozone sovereign bond markets that existed before the crisis. 04/RT/16: Lending Conditions and Loan Default: What Can We Learn From UK Buy-to-Let Loans? Robert Kelly & Conor O’Toole With an aim towards boosting systemic resilience in the financial system, there has been a recent refocusing of financial regulation towards the use of macroprudential instruments. Regulators globally are engaged in a process of introducing, and designing, measures to limit aggregate risk through a toolbox of macroprudential regulations. While there are a range of instruments available to policymakers such as capital buffers and risk weight management, one area of considerable focus has been the introduction of limits on mortgage lending such as loan-tovalue and loan-to-income ratios. This is mainly in response to the elevated level of mortgage delinquency in many economies following the crisis, the link between the mortgage market and the wider financial turmoil and the evidence linking looser mortgage credit conditions through credit growth to increases in house prices. In order to set the parameters of macroprudential policy appropriately, information is needed on the role of originating lending conditions in determining subsequent loan default. In this paper, we draw on a unique loan-level dataset for the UK which contains the loans of Irish banks‘ subsidiaries in that jurisdiction. This is one of the few loan-level datasets available for the UK which spans the period pre and post the financial crisis and also contains information on current and origination income and loan-to-values. Our estimation strategy uses a standard mortgage default model augmented to explore non-linearities in the relationship between original rent coverage (ORC: our proxy for the debt-service-ratio) and original loan-tovalues (OLTV) using cubic splines. We find default is increasing with LTV at origination and falling in original rent coverage. We also find threshold effects suggesting there are indeed non-linearities in the relationship between originated OLTV, ORC and subsequent default. We also extend our empirical framework to control for portfolio values of OLTV and ORC for borrowers with multiple loans outstanding and find default rates double in the case of multi-loan properties, with signifocantly greater sensitivity to OLTV and ORC increases 05/RT/16: Mortgage modifications and loan performance Christian Danne & Anne McGuinness ing a unique Irish dataset. Compared to previous studies, our dataset allows us to observe borrower and loan characteristics at the time This paper studies the determinants of receiving a loan modification and the factors explaining repayment after mortgage modification us- 5 Research Bulletin the borrower experiences payment difficulties and to directly observe the outcome of the renegotiation process. The results show that current borrower characteristics rather than loan characteristics matter for receiving a permanent modification and making full payment after modification. A higher mortgage repayment to income ratio, higher household leverage, and higher household expenditure reduce the probability of receiving a permanent modifi- cation and the probability of full payment after modification. In addition, both unemployment and divorce prior to engaging in mortgage renegotiations, reduce the probability of receiving a permanent modification and the payment performance after modification. The change in borrowers‘ mortgage repayment and thus their subsequent mortgage affordability is the key driver of a successful modification, irrespective of the modification type. 06/RT/16: Flexibility of new hires earnings in Ireland Reamonn Lydon & Matija Lozej Two recent papers that are able to distinguish between the wage flexibility of new hires, incumbent workers and job changers provide opposite results. We use an administrative tax database on earnings and the data from Household Finance and Consumption Survey in Ireland to examine this issue and find that the earnings of new hires are substantially more flexible than those of the existing workers. This is driven entirely by the flexibility of earnings of new hires from unemployment, while earnings of job changers do not appear to behave differently than earnings of existing workers. The findings are robust to different econometric specifications, including controls for compositional shifts, age, education, occupation, and sector. We find that earnings of new hires from unemployment are more procyclical for workers with less valuable outside options, i.e., less educated workers and workers who cannot afford to wait out until retirement. Overall, our results indicate that wage rigidity may not be a suitable device to generate sufficient unemployment volatility in macroeconomic models for Ireland. 07/RT/16: Banks‘ Interconnectivity and Leverage Alessandro Barattieri, Laura Moretti & Vincenzo Quadrini This paper is motivated by the observation that, in the period that preceded the 2008 crisis, there has been an increase in the ratio of assets over equity of the US financial intermediaries (their leverage). At the same time, the share of liabilities held by other financial intermediaries increased significantly (we use this as a proxy for interconnectvity). This upward trend in leverage and interconnectivity sharply reversed after the crisis. In this paper, we analyze the relationship between banks’ interconnectivity and leverage, both theoretically and empirically. We proceed in three steps. First, we develop a dynamic model where banks make risky investments outside the financial sector and, to reduce risks, sell some of the investments to other banks. The presence of an agency cost, which increases with the degree of diversification, limits banks diversification. An important implication of the model is that, when banks become more leveraged, they face higher risks and therefore have higher incentives to diversify. In order to diversify, banks sell part of the investments to other banks and become more interconnected. On the other hand, when 6 Research Bulletin banks become more interconnected, they face less risk and therefore have higher incentive to leverage. Second, we provide evidence of a strong positive correlation between interconnectivity and leverage using Bankscope balance sheet data for a sample of over 14,000 financial intermediaries in 32 OECD countries. We show that, as predicted by the model, there is a strong positive association between interconnectivity and leverage across countries, across financial institutions and over time. Finally, we extend the model to include an aggregate shock to the whole banking sector. This enables us to analyze why interconnectivity and leverage have increased before the financial crisis and reverted afterward. We interpret a negative shock that decreases investment returns of all banks as a banking crisis. We assume that the probability distribution of the aggregate shock is unknown and that banks make portfolio decisions based on their priors, which are then updated over time according to Bayes rules. We show that the model with Bayesian learning can generate the dynamics of interconnectivity and leverage observed in the data. 08/RT/16: Joining the Dots: The FOMC and the future path of policy rates Stefan Gerlach and Rebecca Stuart Given the importance of US monetary policy for global economic and financial conditions, economic policy makers and market analysts across the world devote great resources to understand the Federal Open Market Committee’s (FOMCs) outlook for monetary policy. To help them in this process, the Federal Reserve has since 2012 published on a quarterly basis FOMC members’ assessments of appropriate monetary policy. This is defined as the future path of policy that each participant deems most likely to foster outcomes for economic activity and inflation that best satisfy his or her interpretation of the Federal Reserves dual objectives of maximum employment and stable prices. The dot plots of members assessments are now eagerly anticipated and much analysed by market participants. FOMC meetings in the projected path of interest rates thus react both shifting economic conditions and changes in the forecast horizon. They can therefore not be used directly to answer the question of what factors drive FOMC members’ assessment of the appropriate level of interest rates at a constant horizon, such as one or two years ahead. In this paper we ask how FOMC members views of the future path of appropriate monetary policy evolved over time and how they responded to changes in the macroeconomic environment. To do so, we first quantify the amount of variation in FOMC members views of appropriate monetary policy. We then estimate a simple empirical model which allows us to interpolate the path of interest rates the FOMC members, on average, believe is approIt is natural to ask how FOMC members’ priate to achieve their policy objectives. We views of the appropriate level of interest rates compute the average view of the appropriate have evolved over time and how they have re- interest rate at constant maturities of one, two sponded to changes in the macroeconomic en- and three years, and end by studying how these vironment. In particular, how sensitive have views respond to current macroeconomic conthey been to changes in labour market condi- ditions. tions, indicators of economic activity and inAs one of the first studies of the FOMC’s inflation pressures? Addressing this question is terest rate projections that we are aware of, this complicated by the fact that Federal Reserve paper is interesting for a number of reasons. typically only publishes these views for four or First, we quantify the dispersion of FOMC five discrete points in time. Changes between members’ views of interest rates which is crit7 Research Bulletin ical for judging the outlook for US monetary policy. It is interesting to consider how dispersion varies with the horizon of the projection and over time, given the broader economic uncertainty during the sample period. Second, we show that a simple model can be used to in- terpolate the interest projections between the discrete data points published by the Federal Reserve. Finally, we show that FOMC members’ projections have been more sensitive to labour market conditions than to inflation rates in our sample period. 09/RT/16: Sources of the small firm financing premium: Evidence from euro area banks Sarah Holton and Fergal McCann try and the same month, so that we precisely identify which bank-level factors contribute to the disproportionate increases in borrowing for small firms. Moreover, the cross country and time series aspects of the data mean that we can assess how bank level factors interact with macroeconomic developments. We use panel fixed effects models to empirically assess the effects of four broad categories of variables: (i) banks‘ market power (ii) the stability of a banks funding base (iii) banks‘ holdings of domestic sovereign bonds (iv) bank balance sheet stress. Then we examine the interactions with macroeconomic variables that capture sovereign, financial and real economy stress. The recent financial crisis highlighted the importance of bank balance sheet strength for access to credit for the real economy. This paper analyses the determinants of the cost of bank finance faced by smaller firms, as captured by the interest rate spread between small and large loans, which became particularly elevated at the height of the crisis. This spread, which we denote as the small firm financing premium (SFFP), is a particularly relevant concern for monetary policy given that smaller firms tend to rely on bank finance and have fewer external financing choices compared to larger firms. We analyse whether bank level characteristics drive the SFFP and assess whether macroeconomic factors alter the impact of relevant characteristics. A number of our key hypotheses are confirmed. We find that banks with a greater We find that bank market power, sovereign market share charge a higher SFFP, and that bond holdings and balance sheet weaknesses the effect is particularly strong in times of real can lead to disproportionate borrowing cost in- economy stress. Secondly we find that banks creases for small firms, and that these features with impaired balance sheets, as captured by act to exacerbate the impact of a weak macroe- non-performing loans, also have a higher SFFP conomy. The results are in line with previous and the effect increases in times of high unliterature that finds that smaller, bank depen- employment. We also show that banks with a dent borrowers are charged relatively higher in- more stable funding base charge a lower SFFP terest rates during a period of bank funding dif- and that it can act to mitigate the effects of ficulties, as they have lower bargaining power macroeconomic stress. Finally, we find that as a result of their limited alternative financing in countries experiencing sovereign stress, high options. domestic bond holdings lead to higher SFFP, but the effect is reversed in the absence of Our analysis is based on monthly bank sovereign stress. Moreover, after controlling panel data from twelve euro area countries from for other indicators that capture bank balance 2007 to 2015. We focus on the difference besheet risk, the effect becomes insignificant. tween interest rates charged on small and large loans by the same bank, in the same counThe findings of this paper show that bank 8 Research Bulletin balance sheet strength is particularly important for access to finance for small firms. This is not only because loans constitute a relatively higher share of their external financing, but also because banks can extract greater revenue from these dependent borrowers. Our results show that banks with characteristics that capture impaired funding and capital positions indeed charge smaller firms disproportionately higher interest rates. This underscores the importance of having a strong and resilient banking sector. 9 Research Bulletin Economic Letters 1. Understanding Irish Labour Force Participation Stephen Byrne & Martin O’Brien 2. Indicators for Setting the Countercyclical Capital Buffer Con Creedon & Eoin O’Brien 3. Macroprudential Measures and Irish Mortgage Lending: A Review of Recent Data Enda Keenan, Christine Kinghan, Yvonne McCarthy, & Conor O’Toole 4. Private Placement Debt Securities and Wholesale Funding of Banking System Dermot Coates & Jennifer Dooley 5. Household Saving Behaviour in Ireland Julia LeBlanc 6. Macroprudential Measures and Irish Mortgage Lending: Insights from H1 2016 Christina Kinghan, Paul Lyons, Yvonne McCarthy & Conor O’Toole 7. Do all oil price shocks have the same impact? Evidence from the Euro Area Anastasios Evgenidis 8. Model-based estimates of the resilience of mortgages at origination John Joyce & Fergal McCann 9. Originating Loan to Value ratios and the resilience of mortgage portfolios Fergal McCann & Ellen Ryan 10. Assessing the sustainability of Irish residential property prices: 1980Q1-2016Q2 Gerard Kennedy, Eoin O’Brien & Maria Woods 11. Housing supply after the crisis Gerard Kennedy & Rebecca Stuart 12. Exploring developments in Ireland’s regional rental markets Fergal McCann 13. Modelling Irish Rents: Recent Developments in Historical Context Gerard Kennedy, Lisa Sheenan & Maria Woods 10 Research Bulletin Visitor Seminar Series Presenter Affiliation Title Livio Stracca ECB Marc Hinterschweiger Bank of England Ron Davies UCD Joseph Tracy NY Fed Luca Gambetti Marek Jarocinski Universitat Autnoma de Barcelona Friedrich-Alexander University ECB Michael Kumhof Bank of England Saverio Simonelli University of Naples Wouter den Haan LSE Sebasitan Gechert Jeremy Chiu Macroeconomic Policy Institute, Hans-BcklerFoundation Bank of England Anthony Murphy Dallas Fed Manfred Kremar Alessandro Galesi ECB Banque de Espana Charles O’Donnell Banque de France Stefan Ried Arsenios Skaperdas Deutsche Bundesbank Federal Reserve In and out of the eurozone: is it really so different? Macroprudential Policy in an Agent-Based Model of the UK Housing Market Knocking on tax haven’s door: Multinational firms and transfer pricing The role of investors in the housing boom and bust VAR information and the empirical validation of DSGE models Banking and the Macroeconomy: A MicroMacro Linkage An inflation-predicting measure of output gap in the euro area Banks are not intermediaries of loanable funds and why this matters Bank exposures and sovereign stress transmission Unemployment (Fears) and Deflationary Spirals Top-Down vs. Bottom-Up? Reconciling the Effects of Tax and Transfer Shocks on Output The nonlinear effects of mortgage spreads over the business cycle Housing, Consumption and the U.S. Financial Crisis Macrofinancial linkages and systemic risk Uncovering the Heterogeneous Effects of ECB Unconventional Monetary Policies The interest of being eligible: the 2012 extension of the Eurosystem’s collateral framework and loan rates to French firms? Distributional Effects of Monetary Policy Costly Unconventional Monetary Policy Christian Merkl 11 Research Bulletin External Publications Journal Articles Bermingham, Colin, Dermot Coates, and Derry O’Brien, “Estimating Commodity Substitution in the Irish Inflation Rate Statistics during the Financial Crisis,” Economic and Social Review, 2016, 47 (3), 327–337. Bover, Olympia, Jose Maria Casado, Sonia Costa, Philip Du Caju, Yvonne McCarthy, Eva Sierminska, Panagiota Tzamourina, Ernesto Villanueva, and Tibor Zavadil, “The Distribution of Debt Across Euro Area Countries: The Role of Individual Characteristics, Institutions and Credit Conditions,” International Journal of Central Banking, 2016, 12 (2), 71–128. Casey, Eddie and Diarmaid Smyth, “Revisions to Macroeconomic Date: Ireland and the OECD,” Economics & Social Review, 2016, 47 (1), 33–68. Clancy, Daragh, Pascal Jacquinot, and Matija Lozej, “Government expenditure composition and fiscal policy spillovers in small open economies within a monetary union,” Journal of Macroeconomics, 2016, 48, 305–326. Cronin, David and Kieran McQuinn, “Credit Availability, Macroprudential Regulations, and the House Price-to-Rent Ratio,” Journal of Policy Modeling, 2016, 38 (5), 971–984. , Thomas Flavin, and Lisa Sheehan, “Contagion in Eurozone Sovereign Bond Markets? The Good, the Bad and the Ugly,” Economics Letters, 2016, 143, 5–8. Evgenidis, Anastasios and Costas Siriopoulos, “An Explanation of Spread’s Ability to Predict Economic Activity: A Regime Switching Model,” Journal of Economic Studies, 2016, 43 (3), 488–503. Frisell, Lars, “Europe’s Regulatory Treatment of Banks’ Sovereign Exposures - How a Flawed Framework Was Put to Use in the Irish Financial Crisis,” European Economy, 2016, 1, 105– 117. Gerlach, Stefan, Reamonn Lydon, and Rebecca Stuart, “Unemployment and Inflation in Ireland: 1926-2012,” Cliometrica, 2016, 10 (3), 345–364. Kelly, Robert and Fergal McCann, “Some defaults are deeper than others: Understanding longterm mortgage arrears,” Journal of Banking & Finance, 2016, 72 (C), 15–27. and Terence O’Malley, “The good, the bad and the impaired: A credit risk model of the Irish mortgage market,” Journal of Financial Stability, 2016, 22, 1–9. Kenny, Oisin, Neill Killeen, and Kitty Moloney, “Network analysis using EMIR credit default swap data: Micro-level evidence from Irish domiciled special purpose vehicles,” Bank for International Settlements Bulletin, 2016, (41), 369–388. Le Blanc, Julia, Alessandro Porpiglia, Federica Teppa, Junyi Zhu, and Michael Ziegelmeyer, “Household Saving Behavior in the Euro Area,” International Journal of Central Banking, 2016, 12 (2), 15–70. and Almuth Scholl, “Optimal Savings for Retirement: The Role of Individual Accounts,” Macroeconomic Dynamics, 2016, pp. 1–28. McCarthy, Yvonne and Kieran McQuinn, “Attenuation Bias, Recall Error and the Housing Wealth Effect,” Kyklos, 2016, 69 (3), 492–517. 12 Research Bulletin McQuinn, Kieran and Diarmaid Smyth, “Assessing the sustainable nature of housing-related taxation receipts: the case of Ireland,” Journal of European Real Estate Research, 2016, 9 (2), 193–214. Moretti, Laura and Toru Suzuki, “Strategic Transparency and Electoral Pressure,” Journal of Public Economic Theory, 2016, 18 (4), 624–641. Forthcoming Byrne, Stephen and Martin D. O’Brien, “Understanding Irish Labour Force Participation,” The Economic and Social Review. Evgenidis, Anastasios, Tsaganos Athanasios, and Costas Siriopoulos, “Towards an asymmetric long run equilibrium between stock market uncertainty and the yield spread. A threshold vector error correction approach,” Research in International Business and Finance. Fasianos, Apostolos, Diego Guevara, and Christos Pierros, “ Have we Been Here Before? Phases of Financialisation within the 20th Century in the US ,” Review of Keynesian Economics. , Hamid Raza, and Stephen Kinsella, “Exploring the link between Household Debt and Income Inequality: An Asymmetric Approach,” Applied Economics Letters. McCarthy, Yvonne and Kieran McQuinn, “Credit Conditions in a Boom and Bust Property Market: Insights for Macro-Prudential Policy,” Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance. Rannenberg, Ansgar, “Bank Leverage Cycles and the External Finance Premium,” Journal of Money, Credit & Banking. 13
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz