Week #7 Understanding Power Lecture

TFTD
The 48 Laws of Power
Rule 11
“Pooh began to feel a little more comfortable,
because when you are a Bear of Very Little Brain,
and you think of things, you find sometimes that a
Thing which seemed very thingish inside you is
quite different when it gets out into the open and
has other people looking at it.”
A.A. Milne
House of Pooh Corner
1928 c. 6
Big questions about power…
Why do people want power?
Is power a good thing or a bad thing?
Where does power come from?
What is the source of power…?
What is Power?
What is it that we are talking about…?
When we say
Power
certain things come to mind.
There are
some who
seek it.
Some use it on each other…
Some have it thrust upon them
Some try to
take it.
Some are
symbols
of it.
Some play with it.
Remember that
it comes
in much subtler
forms…
It’s here…
And here…
And here…
Yes,
here too.
Power is everywhere…
The Dynamic of Power
“Power is the probability that
one actor in a social relationship
will carry out his own will against
the resistance of others.”
Max Weber
Black Well Encyclopedia of Political Thought
“ Next to enjoying ourselves, the
next greatest pleasure consists in
preventing others from enjoying
themselves, or, more generally, in
the acquisition of power.”
Bertrand Russell
Skeptical Essays (1928)
“The Recrudescence of Puritanism”
“To know Others is knowledge,
To know Yourself is insight.
To control Others is strength,
To control Yourself
is True Power.”
Lao Tzu
Tao Te Ching
Power is the process by which we
turn people into
a means to an end
rather than an end in themselves.
Eckhart Tolle
The Power of Now
Consider how you
feel
about power…
Love it or hate it…
Want it or avoid it…
Use it or judge it…
The Myths of Power
• Power is a characteristic of a person –
- certain people are powerful
• Power is in things like money, sex and
religion.
• There are types of power.
• Power is “out there.”
• We are powerless.
It is one thing to show a man
that he is in an error,
and another to put him in
possession of the truth.
John Locke
English Philosopher
1632-1704
Where does power come from?
Where does power happen?
What is the target of power?
Where does
power
come from?
Show me the money!
Can you
bribe a
rich
man?
Where does
the power
in money
come from?
Feel
the
power?
So when it comes to power…
Why and why not?
Where does the power
come from?
Violence
Force
What if
you
weren’t
afraid
to die?
Where does
power
come from?
Is it
about
your
soul ?
Why don’t all
these
symbols
matter to all
of us?
If Power isn't in the
money
or
sex
or
violence
or
religion
Where is it?
Where is the power?
Why do these things work when
they do and don’t work other
times?
Why can’t we bribe a rich man?
Because he doesn’t need the
money.
The
Source of Power
is
NEED
“In the country of the blind, the one-eyed man is
King.”
Erasmus
(1469-1536)
The Source of Power is
Need.
Requirements, Desires and Attachments
So where does power happen?
Where does power exist?
The Source of Power is Need.
Power is created inside
the Subject.
Power take place inside the mind.
Needs are explained in many ways.
Motivation Theory
Humanist Psychology
- Maslow’s Hierarchy
The following definitions of motivation were gleaned from a
variety of psychology textbooks…
-internal state or condition that activates behavior
and gives it direction;
-desire or want that energizes and directs goaloriented behavior;
-influence of needs and desires on the intensity
and direction of behavior.
Some distinguish between …
wants and needs
wishes
desires
Self –
Actualization
Esteem
Belonging
Security
Physiological
Maslow’s Hierarchy
Buddha
Desires and Attachments
The best understanding of needs
comes from the experience of those
who might find themselves subject to
power …
so I prefer…
Requirements,
Desires
and
Attachments
Requirements
“We are survival machines robot vehicles blindly
programmed to preserve the selfish molecules
known as genes.”
Richard Dawkins
(1941- )
Desires
“It is the nature of desire not to be satisfied, and most men
live only for the gratification of it.”
Aristotle
Politics II, 7
Attachments
Attachments to
things,
people
and
ideas
“I have found it impossible to carry the heavy burden of responsibility
and to discharge my duties as King as I would wish to do without the
help and support of the woman I love.”
Edward VIII
Duke of Windsor 1894In farewell address
So what is the response?
Power is a mechanical process.
It is the application
by an Actor
of a Mechanism of Power
to a need
within
or about
a Subject
Mechanisms of Power
“Of course cash, culture, and violence are not the only
Sources of Power in everyday life, and power is neither
good nor bad. It is a dimension of virtually all human
relationships. It is in fact the reciprocal of desire and since
human desires are infinitely varied, anything else’s desire is
a potential Source of Power.”
Alvin Toffler
Powershift 1990
p. 12
More than things…
Money
Love
Sex
Force
Authority
Religion
Law
An ABILITY to help or hinder
the need of the Subject
is applied to the need.
Actual or Potential
Threat or Promise
Direct or Indirect
You or someone who matters to you…
What is the target
of
Power?
What do we use power for?
What are we trying to
Control, Influence and Seduce?
Choice
The purpose of power is to
control, influence or seduce
the choice
another person makes to
do, say or think something.
A new definition…
Power is…
The application of an ability to a
Need in the Subject,
With the intention to
Control, Influence or Seduce
the Choice
the Subject is about to make.
The Mechanics of Power
Copyright Les Smith 2005-2008, All rights reserved
When you think of Power…
think of
Needs
and
Abilities
Intention
of the Actor
to Control, Influence or Seduce
the Subject
by creating feelings of
Fear, Anger or Excitement in the Subject
Need of
The
Ability of
the Subject
the Actor
Power
Equation
Power
In the form of
Control, Influence and Seduction
How does power feel?
Fear
Anger
Excitement
Control
Influence
Seduction
Is Power
a good thing
or
a bad thing?
A truth about power…
Control is an Illusion
The only thing we control is
how we respond to the
circumstances before us
A truth about power…
Power
Destroys
Trust.
Consider your experience…
Where do we go from here?
Let’s consider the way power
plays itself out in our world…
Critical Thinking
Making better use of
our minds
and our language…
Let’s talk about
• Choice
• Perception
• Emotions
• Interpretations
• Mechanisms
• Needs
• Strength and weakness
Mechanisms
• Money
• Authority
• Information
• Music
• Celebrity
• Family
• Outstanding questions…
Essay Number Two
• Next week
• Similar in format
• Pick tow relationships and consider
strategies for responding to and
preventing power dynamics
Movies
• Monday or Thursday?