Spanish American War Controversy Rubric
Name:
Category
Presentation
Listening
Summarizing
Consensus
Preparation
Advanced-5 points each
Proficient-4 points each
Basic-3 points each
Novice-2-0 points each
I Accurately synthesized and presented
sources related to my perspective using
appropriate vocabulary and relevant
evidence
Listened critically and responded
meaningfully to the speaker (with
respectful comments, arguments, and
clarifying questions).
I accurately summarized the main points of
the other issues-verbally and in writing on
my note taking sheet
I Presented sources related to my perspective
using vocabulary/evidence (minor errors)
I Presented sources related to my perspective
using vocabulary/evidence, but there were
errors or omissions
I had a lot of difficulty stating my ideas verballyI was unclear or unprepared
I Listened and responded to the other speakers Sometimes I listened and responded to the
(with comments and/or questions).
speakers
I Was not able to sum up the main ideas in sources
I Summarized the main points of the other
perspectives-verbally and in writing (minor
errors) on my note taking sheet
I was able to summarize some of the main
points of the other perspectives-verbally and
in writing (errors/omissions) on my note
taking sheet
I helped my team reach a successful result
Most of the time, I helped my team reach a
Some of the time, I helped my team reach a
by offering relevant evidence and offering to successful result by offering relevant evidence successful result by offering relevant evidence
compromise in discussion
and offering to compromise in discussion
and offering to compromise in discussion
After listening to the participants, I was unable to
sum up their main ideas on my note taking sheet
I have FIVE detailed and specific pieces of
evidence written on my Prep Sheet. I cited
my sources
I didn’t offer to help my team reach a successful
result ; I argued and/or didn’t offer any
relevant/respectful contributions
My prep work is completed with details from
sources and presentations (minor errors or
omissions)
My prep work is partially complete with details
from sources and presentations
(multiple errors or omissions)
My notes on the presentations and in preparation
for the presentation are sparse or inaccurate
Advanced-5 points each
Proficient-4 points each
Basic-3 points each
Novice-2-0 points each
I Accurately synthesized and presented
sources related to my perspective using
appropriate vocabulary and relevant
evidence
Listened critically and responded
meaningfully to the speaker (with
respectful comments, arguments, and
clarifying questions).
I accurately summarized the main points of
the other issues-verbally and in writing on
my note taking sheet
I Presented sources related to my perspective
using vocabulary/evidence (minor errors)
I Presented sources related to my perspective
using vocabulary/evidence, but there were
errors or omissions
I had a lot of difficulty stating my ideas verballyI was unclear or unprepared
Total for all categories:_________/25
Spanish American War Controversy Rubric
Name:
Category
Presentation
Listening
Summarizing
Consensus
Preparation
I Listened and responded to the other speakers Sometimes I listened and responded to the
(with comments and/or questions).
speakers
I Was not able to sum up the main ideas in sources
I Summarized the main points of the other
perspectives-verbally and in writing (minor
errors) on my note taking sheet
I was able to summarize some of the main
points of the other perspectives-verbally and
in writing (errors/omissions) on my note
taking sheet
I helped my team reach a successful result
Most of the time, I helped my team reach a
Some of the time, I helped my team reach a
by offering relevant evidence and offering to successful result by offering relevant evidence successful result by offering relevant evidence
compromise in discussion
and offering to compromise in discussion
and offering to compromise in discussion
After listening to the participants, I was unable to
sum up their main ideas on my note taking sheet
I have FIVE detailed and specific pieces of
evidence written on my Prep Sheet. I cited
my sources
My notes on the presentations and in preparation
for the presentation are sparse or inaccurate
Total for all categories:_________/25
My prep work is completed with details from
sources and presentations (minor errors or
omissions.
My prep work is partially complete with details
from sources and presentations
(multiple errors or omissions)
I didn’t offer to help my team reach a successful
result ; I argued and/or didn’t offer any
relevant/respectful contributions