Dublin Institute of Technology
ARROW@DIT
Teaching Fellowships
DIT College Teaching Fellowships
2010
Pre-lecture Resources to Reduce In-Lecture
Cognitive Load
Michael K. Seery
Dublin Institute of Technology, [email protected]
Follow this and additional works at: http://arrow.dit.ie/fellow
Part of the Education Commons
Recommended Citation
Seery, Michael K., "Pre-lecture Resources to Reduce In-Lecture Cognitive Load" (2010). Teaching Fellowships. 19.
http://arrow.dit.ie/fellow/19
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the DIT College
Teaching Fellowships at ARROW@DIT. It has been accepted for inclusion
in Teaching Fellowships by an authorized administrator of ARROW@DIT.
For more information, please contact [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected].
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons AttributionNoncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 License
!"#$%#&'("#)*#+,("&#+)',)*#-(&#)./$%#&'("#)0,1/2'23#)4,5-)
62&75#%)8##"9:)
8&7,,%),;)07#<2&5%)5/-)!75"<5&#('2&5%)8&2#/&#+)
#
$%&'()'*#+,)-(./01..2345,'0,.#
=>+'"5&')
6&#%25.2#'%#2.57).#(&#%81.29.5#:(;#,&#<.(2#=#;.2>%2+(&).#8.'?..&#1'75.&'1#?-%#-(5#(&5#-(5#&%'#)%+;/.'.5#
)-.+,1'23#('#@.(9,&:#$.2',>,)('.#,&#(#>,21'#3.(2#)-.+,1'23#:2%7;A#(&#,&'.29.&',%&#8(1.5#%&#)%:&,',9.#/%(5#'-.%23#
?(1# ,+;/.+.&'.50# B'75.&'1# )%+;/.'.5# '.&# ;2.C/.)'72.# 2.1%72).1# 8.>%2.# (11%),('.5# /.)'72.10# D-.# 2.1%72).1#
'%%E#&%#/%&:.2#'-(&#>,9.#+,&7'.1#'%#)%+;/.'.#(&5#(,+.5#'%#,&'2%57).#1'75.&'1#'%#'-.#)%2.#'.2+,&%/%:3#%>#'-.#
/.)'72.0# F.1%72).1# ?.2.# 5.1,:&.5# ?,'-# '-.# ;2,&),;/.1# %># )%:&,',9.# /%(5# '-.%23# (&5# +7/',+.5,(# 2.1%72).1# ,&#
+,&50# D-.3# ?.2.# (5+,&,1'.2.5# '-2%7:-# '-.# G6D# H.8)%721.1# 9,2'7(/# /.(2&,&:# .&9,2%&+.&'# (&5# 1'75.&'1#
%8'(,&.5# >..58()E# %&# (# 1-%2'# I7,J# (&5# (# +(2E# ,&# '-.# :2(5.8%%E# (>'.2# )%+;/.',&:# .()-# 2.1%72).# I7,J0# D-.#
2.1%72).1# ?.2.# ,&'.:2('.5# ,&'%# '-.# /.)'72.# ()',9,'3A# ,&)2.(1,&:# ,&C)/(11# 5,1)711,%&0# K>'.2# ,+;/.+.&',&:# '-.#
2.1%72).1A# '-.# ;.2>%2+(&).# ,&# (# +,5C1.+.1'.2# .L(+# (&5# '-.# .&5# %># 3.(2# .L(+# ?(1# .L(+,&.50# M%2# '-.# >,21'#
ƚŝŵĞ͕ ƐƚƵĚĞŶƚƐ͛ ƉƌŝŽƌ ŬŶŽǁůĞĚŐĞ ǁĂƐ ŶŽƚ Ă ƉƌĞĚŝĐƚŽƌ ŽĨ ƉĞƌĨŽƌŵĂŶĐĞ ŝŶ ƚŚĞƐĞ ĞdžĂŵƐ͘ dŚĞ ǁŽƌŬ ƌĞƐƵůƚĞĚ ŝŶ
5,11.+,&(',%&# ('# 1.9.2(/# &(',%&(/# (&5# ,&'.2&(',%&(/# )%&>.2.&).1A# (&# ()).;'.5# N%72&(/# ;78/,)(',%&# (&5# (#
D.()-,&:#(&5#@.(2&,&:#(?(250#
)
?#9)@,"-+A))%:&,',9.#/%(5A#.@.(2&,&:A#>,21'#3.(2#.L;.2,.&).A#;2.C/.)'72.#2.1%72).1)
)
./'",-(&'2,/)
6&'2%57)'%23# )-.+,1'23# >%2# '-%1.# ?,'-%7'# (# 8()E:2%7&5# ,&# '-.# 178N.)'# -(1# (# -,:-# )%:&,',9.# /%(5#
OB,2-(&A#P2(3#(&5#Q%-&1'%&.A#=RRRS0#T.?# /.(2&.21#,&#)-.+,1'23#(2.#9.23#I7,)E/3#.L;%1.5#'%#(#/(2:.#
(+%7&'# %># &.?#'.2+,&%/%:3# ?-,)-# '-.3# &..5# '%# 7&5.21'(&5# (&5# ,&'.22./('.# OQ%-&1'%&.A# UVVRS0# K1#
'-.# )-.+,1'23# 13//(871# 87,/51# ;2%:2.11,9./3A# /.(2&.21# &..5# '%# )%&',&7(//3# )(//# %&# 2.).&'/3# ()I7,2.5#
E&%?/.5:.#(&5#,&'.:2('.#'-('#,&'%#.9.2#,&)2.(1,&:#/(3.21#(&5#2.;2.1.&'(',%&1#%>#'-.#178N.)'#(1#'-.3#
;2%:2.11,9./3# 5.9./%;# '-.,2# 7&5.21'(&5,&:# (&5# 8.:,&# '%# 2./('.# '-.1.# '.2+1# ('# 2.;2.1.&'(',%&(/A#
('%+,)#(&5#+()2%#/.9./1#OQ%-&1'%&.A#B/..'#(&5#W,(&&(A#=RRXS0#
6&#'-,1#>(1'#;().A#,'#,1#.(13#>%2#/.(2&.21#'%#1/,;0#K#/.)'72.#?-,)-#87,/51#%&#(#;2.9,%71#/.)'72.#,1#(//#9.23#
?.//A#87'#,>#/.(2&.21#5,5#&%'#-(9.#',+.#'%#7&5.21'(&5#'-%1.#)%&).;'1#?-,)-#(2.#8.,&:#87,/'#7;%&A#'-.3#
>(//#8.-,&50#D-,1#?(1#%81.29.5#,&#(#;2.9,%71#1'753#83#'-.#(7'-%20#K#/%&:,'75,&(/#(&(/31,1#%9.2#1.9.2(/#
3.(21#>%7&5#'-('#1'75.&'1#?-%#-(5#;2,%2#E&%?/.5:.#%>#)-.+,1'23#('#@.(9,&:#$.2',>,)('.#/.9./#'.&5.5#
'%#5%#8.''.2#,&#'-.,2#<.(2#=#;.2>%2+(&).#O1.+.1'.2#(&5#.&5#%>#+%57/.#.L(+1S#'-(&#'-%1.#?-%#-(5#
&%#;2,%2# E&%?/.5:.# OB..23A#UVVRS0#Y%?.9.2A#'-.2.# ?(1#&%#(11%),(',%&#8.'?..&#@.(9,&:#$.2',>,)('.#
)-.+,1'23#(&5#+(2E1#,&#/('.2#3.(210#D-,1#/.5#'%#'-.#-3;%'-.1,1#'-('#(#)%&1,5.2(',%&#%>#'-.#'.()-,&:#%>#
+('.2,(/# ,&# <.(2# =# ,&# '-.# )%&'.L'# %># )%:&,',9.# /%(5# '-.%23# +(3# 8.# (# 17,'(8/.# :2%7&5,&:# >%2# (&#
,&'.29.&',%&#'%#(11,1'#'-.1.#/.(2&.210#
B('%2/#),;)'7#)!",C#&')
$%:&,',9.# /%(5# '-.%23# ,1# (# +%5./# >%2# ,&1'27)',%&(/# 5.1,:&# 8(1.5# %&# (&# 7&5.21'(&5,&:# %># -%?# ?.#
()I7,2.A# ;2%).11# (&5# 2.'(,&# &.?# ,&>%2+(',%&0# 6'# ;2%;%1.1# '-('# (# 17)).11>7/# 71.# %># '-.# +%5./# ?,//#
2.17/'#,&#+%2.#.>>.)'7(/#/.(2&,&:A#(&5#'-.#2.'(,&,&:#%>#,&>%2+(',%&#,&#'-.#/%&:#'.2+#+.+%23A#?-,)-#
)(&#8.#2.)(//.5#?-.&#2.I7,2.5#,&#(#:,9.&#)%&'.L'0#D-.#'-.%23#5,1',&:7,1-.1#'-2..#'3;.1#%>#)%:&,',9.#
/%(5#OK32.1#(&5#Z((1A#UVVR[#B?.//.2A#UVV\S*#
=0
./'"2/+2&)%,5-),1#)(71.5#83#'-.#)%+;/.L,'3#%>#'-.#+('.2,(/0#D-,1#5.;.&51#%&#'-.#/.9./#%>#.L;.2',1.#
%>#'-.#/.(2&.2#ʹ#ŝŶŽƚŚĞƌǁŽƌĚƐŝƚĚĞƉĞŶĚƐŽŶƚŚĞůĞĂƌŶĞƌ͛ƐƵŶĚĞƌƐƚĂŶĚŝŶŐŽĨƚŚĞƐƵďũĞĐƚ͘#
!"#
#
$%
=%
!"#$%&'()*+,(%-#&'(')&*#+)#,-'#./012,3#+4#)0,/4'#+5#,-'#2)*,4/6,2+)01#70,'4201*%#8++4#70,'4201*#
+4#,-+*'#,-0,#4'./24'#0#1049'#07+/),#+5#:+4;2)9#7'7+43#,+#(4+6'**#:211#2)64'0*'#,-'#1+0&#0)&#
1'0<'#12,,1'#60(062,3#5+4#1'04)2)9%#
.'$/%&'+,(%-#2*#,-'#7'),01#'55+4,#4'./24'&#5+4#1'04)2)9%#>'60/*'#+5#,-'#1272,'&#60(062,3#+5#,-'#
:+4;2)9#7'7+43?#9'470)'#1+0&#@,-'#'A,'),#+5#1'04)2)9B#2*#&'(')&'),#+)#,-'#'A,'),#+5#,-'#
'A,40)'+/*#1+0&?#0)&#01*+#+)#,-'#70,'4201#0)&#'A('4,2*'#+5#,-'#1'04)'4#ʹ#,-'#2),42)*26#1+0&%#C)#
'A('4,#+)#0#,+(26#2*#0D1'#,+#&40:#54+7#(42+4#;)+:1'&9'?#0)&#4'1'0*'#:+4;2)9#7'7+43#60(062,3#
5+4#9'470)'#1+0&#(4+6'**2)9%#
E-'#6+)*2&'40,2+)#+5#6+9)2,2<'#1+0&#,-'+43#5+4#,-'#(/4(+*'*#+5#7/1,27'&20#1'04)2)9#:0*#*/77042*'&#
ƐƵĐĐŝŶĐƚůLJďLJDĂLJĞƌ͘DĂLJĞƌ͛ƐŵŽĚĞůŝƐƐŚŽǁŶŝŶF29/4'#G%#H#D'1+:#@I104;'#0)&#J03'4?#$KKGBL#
#
+
012)$'+3456+7(2&1#18'+9:'($;+%&-+<),#1/'-1%+='%$&1&2+>7,%$?'+%&-+<%;'$@+ABB3C+<%;'$@+ABBDE+
M)5+470,2+)#2*#(4'*'),'&#,+#/*'4*#2)#,-'#5+47#+5#:+4&*#0)&#(26,/4'*#@,-'4'#04'#+,-'4#6-0))'1*#,++?#
D/,# ,-'*'# 04'# ,-'# 7+*,# ('4,2)'),# ,+# 'N'04)2)9B%# E-'# /*'4# *')*'*# ,-'*'# 0)&# ,-'# :+4;2)9# 7'7+43#
(4+6'**'*#*+7'#2)5+470,2+)#0,#0)3#,27'%#M5#,-2*#70,'4201#60)#D'#4'10,'&#,+#'A2*,2)9#(42+4#;)+:1'&9'?#
2,# 2*# 2),'940,'&# :2,-# 2,?# 0)&# '55'6,2<'# 1'04)2)9# +66/4*# ʹ# ,-'# )':# 'A('42')6'*# 0)&# 2)5+470,2+)# 04'#
*,+4'&#2)#,-'#1+)9O,'47#7'7+43%#
F$(G'H#+I/J,'/'&#%#1(&+
E-2*#(4+P'6,#027'&#,+#4'&/6'#,-'#6+9)2,2<'#1+0&#+5#)+<26'#1'04)'4*#2)#6-'72*,43#D3#(4+<2&2)9#+)12)'#
(4'O1'6,/4'# 4'*+/46'*# :-26-# ,-'3# 6+/1&# 2),'406,# :2,-# D'5+4'# 6+72)9# ,+# ,-'# 1'6,/4'%# E')# 4'*+/46'*#
&'*29)'&#2)#,-'#6+),'A,#+5#,-'#(42)62(1'*#+5#7/1,27'&20#&'*29)#:'4'#&'<'1+('&#0)&#2),'940,'&#2),+#
,-'# ƐƚƵĚĞŶƚƐ͛ s>͕ !"#$%&'("()*+,)+"%# M)# &'*29)2)9# ,-'# 4'*+/46'*?# ,-'# 6+4'# ,'472)+1+93# ,-0,# :+/1&#
042*'#2)#'06-#1'6,/4'#:+/1&#D'#(4'*'),'&%#F+4#'A07(1'?#2)#0#1'6,/4'#,-0,#729-,#2)<+1<'#$K#)':#,'47*?#
QʹR#:'4'#6-+*')#0*#6+4'?#0)&#2)6+4(+40,'&#2),+#,-'#(4'O1'6,/4'#4'*+/46'%#M,#:0*#)+,#,-'#027#+5#,-'#
(4'O1'6,/4'#4'*+/46'#,+#6+<'4#011#70,'4201#2)#,-'#1'6,/4'?#40,-'4#,+#2),4+&/6'#,-'#*,/&'),*#,+#,-'#6+4'#
,'47*#4'./24'&#,+#D'92)#,+#0((4+06-#,-'*'#,'47*%#
E-'#4'*+/46'*#:'4'#)+#1+)9'4#,-0)#52<'#72)/,'*#1+)9#0)&#-0&#0#./2S#0,#,-'#')&%#E-'#./2S#(4+<2&'&#0)#
+((+4,/)2,3#5+4#*,/&'),*#,+#6-'6;#,-'24#/)&'4*,0)&2)9#+5#,-'#6+4'#6+)6'(,*#/)&'412)2)9#'06-#1'6,/4'?#
0)&# *,/&'),*# 4'6'2<'&# D+,-# 0)*:'4O*('62526# 5''&D06;# @,+# -'1(# 0&&4'**# 0)3# 72*6+)6'(,2+)*B# 01+)9#
:2,-#0#940&'#5+4#,-'24#./2S#2)#,-'#T40&'D++;%#E-'#940&'#5+4#011#,')#4'*+/46'*#:0*#:+4,-#H%!U#+5#,-'#
7+&/1'#704;%#V,/&'),*#6+7(1','&#,:+#./2SS'*#('4#:'';#5+4#,-'#524*,#5+/4#:'';*#+5#V'7'*,'4#H?#:2,-#
0)#0&&2,2+)01#,:+#10,'4#2)#,-'#*'7'*,'4%#
M)#,-'#1'6,/4'?#,-'#4'*+/46'*#:'4'#(/4(+*'5/113#2),'940,'&%#C,#,-'#<'43#1'0*,?#,-'3#:'4'#4'5'44'&#,+?#
0)&#D/21,#+)#2)#(4'*'),2)9#)':#70,'4201#2)#1'6,/4'*%#M)#*+7'#60*'*?#*,/&'),*#:'4'#0*;'&#2)#,-'#(4'O
1'6,/4'#4'*+/46'#,+#(4'(04'#*+7'#70,'4201#5+4#6+),42D/,2+)#,+#,-'#1'6,/4'%#M)#,-'#10,,'4#60*'?#*+7'#
!"#
#
#$%&#'" ()$*#$$)+," )," -.%" '%*-#/%" /%0'1*%(" 1" -%1*.%/2*%,-/%(" 100/+1*.3" 4.)$" 100/+1*." 5)''" 6%" #$%("
7+/%"),"-.%"&#-#/%3"
!"#$%#&'()*
8"*+,*%/,"6%&+/%"/+''),9"+#-"-.%$%"/%$+#/*%$"51$"-.1-"$-#(%,-$"5+#'(",+-"#$%"-.%73":,"&1*-;"$-#(%,-$"
5%/%"<%/=">%%,"-+"#$%"-.%7;"5)-."1**%$$"/1-%$"-=0)*1''="+<%/"?!@3"A/+6'%7$"),)-)1''="5%/%"-%*.,)*1'"ʹ"
&+/" %B170'%" ')6/1/=" *+70#-%/$" *+#'(" ,+-" 0'1=" -.%" C'1$." &+/71-$" )," 5.)*." -.%" /%$+#/*%$" 5%/%"
0/+(#*%(3" 8&-%/" -.%" &)/$-" 5%%>;" -.%" $-#(%,-$" $%--'%(" D#)*>'=" ),-+" 1" /+#-),%3" E%*-#/%$" 5%/%" .%'(" +,"
F+,(1=$" 1,(" 4.#/$(1=$;" 1,(" -.%" 7+$-" *+77+," (1=" -+" 1**%$$" 51$" G#,(1=" 1&-%/,++,$" 1,("
H%(,%$(1=" %<%,),9$3" I!@" +&" $-#(%,-$" $0%,-" 6%-5%%," J" 1,(" JK" 7),#-%$" +," -.%" /%$+#/*%$3" 8,"
1,1'=$)$" +&" $%7%$-%/" -%$-" 71/>$" &+#,(" -.1-" -.%" '1/9%" ()&&%/%,*%" 6%-5%%," $-#(%,-$" 5.+" .1(" ,+-"
*+70'%-%("*.%7)$-/="1,("-.+$%"5.+".1("ʹ"0/%$%,-"&+/"%<%/="+,%"+&"-.%"'1$-"$)B"=%1/$"+&"-.%"7+(#'%"ʹ"
.1("/%(#*%("-+"-.%"%B-%,-"-.1-"-.%/%"51$",+"$)9,)&)*1,-"()&&%/%,*%"6%-5%%,"-.%"9/+#0$3"G)7)'1/'="-.%"
910"6%-5%%,"%B17),1-)+,"71/>$"6%-5%%,"-.%"-5+"9/+#0$"()$100%1/%("*+70'%-%'=3"4.%"')-%/1-#/%"+,"
0/)+/">,+5'%(9%")$"&#''"+&"%B170'%$"+&".+5"0/)+/">,+5'%(9%")$"1"$+'%"0/%()*-+/"+&"&#-#/%"1*.)%<%7%,-"
LM+*.=;"G%9%/$"1,("N#%.';"OPPPQ;"$+"-.%$%"/%$#'-$"1/%"0'%1$1,-'="$#/0/)$),9"),"-.)$"*+,-%B-3"
+',-%,,'()*#).*/0,,(),*/0#1)0.*
4.%"7+(%'"(%$*/)6%(".%/%"-%*.,)*1''="(+%$",+-"*.1,9%"-.%"'%*-#/%"$-='%3"R+5%<%/;"6%*1#$%"$-#(%,-$"
5%/%" 1//)<),9" 1-" -.%" '%*-#/%" 5)-." $+7%" &17)')1/)-=" 5)-." -.%" '%*-#/%" *+,*%0-$;" 1,(" +&-%," 5)-." 0/%2
1$$)9,%("1*-)<)-)%$;"'%*-#/%$"*+#'("7+<%"-+"1"7+/%"()$*#$$)+,"61$%("&+/71-3"4.)$".1$"6%%,"&+#,("5)-."
+-.%/"$-#(%,-$"),<+'<),9"0/%2'%*-#/%"/%$+#/*%$"LS+''1/(;"T)/1/(+-"1,("M%#-$*.;"JKKJU"V1/'+*.;"T1/6),"
1,("4#/,19%;"JKKIQ3"
:-"51$"*+,$)(%/%(")70+/-1,-"-+"0#/0+$%&#''="),-%9/1-%"-.%"0/%2'%*-#/%"/%$+#/*%$"),-+"-.%"'%*-#/%$"-+"
1--/)6#-%"-.%7"1"$%,$%"+&"<1'#%" 17+,9"$-#(%,-$3"4.)$"/1,9%("&/+7"7%,-)+,),9"-.%"/%$+#/*%$" /)9.-"
-./+#9."-.%"0/%21$$)9,%("1*-)<)-=;"-+"6%"(%<%'+0%("),"'%*-#/%$3":-"51$"&+#,("),"-.%"'1--%/"*1$%"-.1-"-.%"
'%<%'"+&"0/%20/%01/1-)+,"$-#(%,-$".1("(+,%"51$")70/%$$)<%;"1,("1''+5%("-.%"'%*-#/%$"-+"),-%9/1-%"1"
.)9." '%<%'" +&" ()$*#$$)+," )," (%<%'+0),9" -.%" *+,-%,-" 1,(" )(%1$" #,(%/" *+,$)(%/1-)+,3" E%*-#/%$" )," -.)$"
*1$%" 6%*17%" <%/=" 1*-)<%" '%1/,),9" %,<)/+,7%,-$;" 1,(" -.%" ()$*#$$)+," %'%7%,-" )$" *+,$)(%/%(" -+" 6%" 1"
&#,(17%,-1'"01/-"+&"-.%"%,.1,*%7%,-"+&"'%1/,),93"
8,"+#-0#-"+&"-.%"5+/>"-.1-"51$",+-"*+,$)(%/%("51$"-.1-"+&"-.%"&)/$-"=%1/"%B0%/)%,*%3"G-#(%,-$"),"&)/$-"
=%1/" 1/%" )," 1" ,%5" %,<)/+,7%,-" 1,(" #,$#/%" +&" -.%)/"$-1,(),9" -.%/%;" '%1(),9" -+"#,*%/-1),-=" )," -.%)/"
,%5"%,<)/+,7%,-"LW+/>%"1,("E+,9(%,;"JKKXQ3"C%%(61*>"&/+7"D#)YY%$"1,("()$*#$$)+,$"),"'%*-#/%$"*1,"
0/+<)(%"$-#(%,-$"5)-."1"$%,$%"+&"-.%)/"0/+9/%$$"),"-.%"<%/="%1/'="$-19%$"+&"G%7%$-%/"O;"6%&+/%"7+/%"
&+/71'"1$0%*-$"+&"*+,-),#+#$"1$$%$$7%,-"-1>%"0'1*%3"
:-" 51Ɛ Ă ĐŽŶĐĞƌŶ ƚŚĂƚ ͞ďƵLJ2ŝŶ͟ ĨƌŽŵ ƐƚƵĚĞŶƚƐ ǁŽƵůĚ ŶŽƚ ƚĂŬĞ ƉůĂĐĞ͘ dŚĞ ůĞǀĞů ŽĨ ƵƐĂŐĞ ĂŶĚ
%,919%7%,-" 51$" <%/=" .)9.3" 4.)$" 71=" 6%" (#%" -+" <1/)+#$" &1*-+/$;" &+/" %B170'%" 1" L$71''Q" 1$$%$$7%,-"
*+70+,%,-;"-.%"0'1*),9"+&"<1'#%"+,"-.%"/%$+#/*%$"6="-.%"'%*-#/%/;"1,("0+$$)6'="-.%"&1*-"-.1-",%5"&)/$-"
=%1/$"1/%"7+/%"+0%,"-+")(%1$"+&"5.1-".100%,$"1-"-.)/("'%<%'3"8,"1(<1,-19%"+&"$%)Y),9"-.)$"+0%,,%$$"
%1/'="+,")$"-.1-"-.%$%">),($"+&"1*-)<)-)%$"*1,"%,*+#/19%"$-#(%,-$"-+"(%<%'+0"1"$%,$%"+&"19%,*="),"-.%)/"
+5,"'%1/,),9"LV)*+';"JKKZU"V)*+';"JKKPQ3"
20-(330).#&'(),*
8$"1"/%$#'-"+&"-.%"5+/>"&/+7"-.)$"0/+[%*-;"-.%"&+''+5),9"/%*+77%,(1-)+,$"*1,"6%"71(%\"
O3 E%*-#/%$"$.+#'("#$%"0#/0+$%&#'"/%$+#/*%$"-+"$#00+/-"&)/$-"=%1/"71-%/)1';"7%1,),9&#''="
),-%9/1-%("5)-."'%*-#/%$"1,("+-.%/"'%1/,),9"1*-)<)-)%$3"4.%"#$%"+&"-%*.,+'+9="%,.1,*%$"-.%"
!!"
"
$%&$'()*+,+-+./#'0#.1%2%#34(#30.%$#+4+.+3-#(%5%-'&6%4.7#3).'63.%2#3#-'.#'0#.1%#8'$9#$%:3$(+4:#
$%*'$(+4:#'0#)23:%#34(#63$92;#
<; =%*.)$%$2#21')-(#,%#%4*')$3:%(#.'#(%5%-'&#+4>*-322#(+2*)22+'47#,'.1#&%%$ʹ&%%$#34(#&%%$ʹ
.).'$;#?1+2#*34#,%#03*+-+.3.%(#,/#*-+*9%$2;#
@; A40'$63-#0%%(,3*9#%3$-/#+4#.1%#/%3$#+2#+6&'$.34.#.'#:+5%#2.)(%4.2#3#2%42%#'0#.1%+$#2.34(+4:#+4#
.1%#4%8#-%3$4+4:#%45+$'46%4.;#
!"#$%&'()*(+($,-.
?1%# 3).1'$# 8')-(# -+9%# .'# .1349# B$# C-3+$%# D*# B'44%--# 81'# 132# ('4%# 3# -'.# '0# 8'$9# .'# 2)&&'$.# .1+2#
&$'E%*.#34(#B$#F'+2+4#B'44%--/#0'$#1%$#'4:'+4:#2)&&'$.#34(#:)+(34*%;#
/(0(1($"(-.
G/$%27#H;#34(#H3327#I;#J<KKLM#A4.%$(+2*+&-+43$/#H%$2&%*.+5%2#A42&+$+4:#3#N%8#O%4%$3.+'4#'0#C':4+.+5%#
='3(#F%2%3$*1;#!"#$%&'()%*+,-.$/(*(0.+123'247#<P#JPM7#PʹL;#
C-3$9%7# F;C;# 34(# D3/%$7# F;Q;# J<KKRM# !562%7)')0+ %)"+ &/2+ 8$'2)$2+ (9+ :)-&7#$&'()# J<4(# %(4M;# S34#
I$34*+2*'T#H0%+00%$#JU+-%/M;#
C'--3$(7#B;D;7#O+$3$('.7#S;H;#34(#B%).2*17#V;D;#J<KK<M#I$'6#.1%#?%W.,''9#.'#.1%#=%*.)$%T#A6&$'5+4:#
H$%-%*.)$%#H$%&3$3.+'4#+4#X$:34+*#C1%6+2.$/;#;(#7)%*+(9+</2='$%*+!"#$%&'()7#YL#JZM7#!<Kʹ!<@;#
B'*1/7#I;[;F;C;7#S%:%$27#D;#34(#\)%1-7#D;D;#JPLLLM#?1%#F%-3.+'4#,%.8%%4#G22%226%4.#H$3*.+*%2#34(#
X).*'6%2#'0#S.)(+%2T#?1%#C32%#'0#F%2%3$*1#'4#H$+'$#]4'8-%(:%;#123'24+(9+!"#$%&'()%*+12-2%7$/7#"L7#
PZ!ʹPR";#
['142.'4%7#G;V;#J<KKLM#^')#C34_.#O%.#?1%$%#0$'6#V%$%;#;(#7)%*+(9+</2='$%*+!"#$%&'()7#RY#JPM7#<<ʹ<L;#
['142.'4%7#G;V;7#S-%%.7#F;[;7#34(#`+34437#[;I;#JPLLZM#G4#A40'$63.+'4#H$'*%22+4:#D'(%-#'0#=%3$4+4:T#A.2#
G&&-+*3.+'4#.'#34#a4(%$:$3(#=3,'$3.'$/#C')$2%#+4#C1%6+2.$/;#8&#"'2-+')+>'0/27+!"#$%&'()7#PL#JPM7#YYʹ
RY;#
D3/%$7# F;Q;# J<KK!M# C':4+.+5%# ?1%'$/# '0# D)-.+6%(+3# =%3$4+4:;# A4# F;Q;# D3/%$# J%(;M# <%=?7'"02+
>%)"?((@+(9+A#*&'=2"'%+62%7)')0;#C36,$+(:%T#C36,$+(:%#a4+5%$2+./#H$%227#&&;#@PʹZR;#
N3$-'*17# F;7# O3$,+47# C;H;# 34(# ?)$43:%7# ];B;# J<KK"M# \%4%0+.2# '0# H$%-%*.)$%# b)+cc%2;# B2%$/')0+ (9+
,-.$/(*(0.7#@@#J<M7#PKLʹPP<;#
N+*'-7#B;#J<KKYM#=3/+4:#3#I')4(3.+'4#0'$#=+0%-'4:#=%3$4+4:T#C32%#S.)(+%2#'0#Q>322%226%4.#+4#=3$:%#P2.>
^%3$#C-322%2;#C7'&'-/+;(#7)%*+(9+!"#$%&'()%*+B2$/)(*(0.7#@R#JZM7#""Rʹ"YR;#
N+*'-7# B;# J<KKLM# G22%226%4.# 0'$# =%3$4%$# S%-0>$%:)-3.+'4T# Q4134*+4:# G*1+%5%6%4.# +4# .1%# I+$2.# ^%3$#
a2+4:#=%3$4+4:#?%*14'-':+%2;#D--2--=2)&+%)"+!3%*#%&'()+')+>'0/27+!"#$%&'()7#@Z#J@M7#@@!ʹ@!<;#
S%%$/7# D;];# J<KKLM# ?1%# F'-%# '0# H$+'$# ]4'8-%(:%# +4# a4(%$:$3()3.%# H%$0'$634*%# +4# C1%6+2.$/# ʹ# G#
C'$$%-3.+'4>H$%(+*.+'4#S.)(/;#</2='-&7.+!"#$%&'()+12-2%7$/+%)"+,7%$&'$27#PK7#<<Yʹ<@<;#
S+$1347# O;7# O$3/7# C;7# ['142.'4%7# G;# V;# 34(# F%+(7# N;# JPLLLM# H$%&3$+4:# .1%# D+4(# '0# .1%# =%3$4%$;#
E)'327-'&.+</2='-&7.+!"#$%&'()7#@J<M7#Z@ʹZ";#
S8%--%$7#[;#J<KKRM#V)634#C':4+.+5%#G$*1+.%*1.)$%;#A4#[;D;#S&%*.'$7#D;B;#D%$$+--7#[;#534#D%$$+%4,'%$#
34(#D;H;#B$+2*'--#J%(2M7#>%)"?((@+(9+12-2%7$/+()+!"#$%&'()%*+<(==#)'$%&'()-+%)"+B2$/)(*(0.#J@$(#
%(4M;#N%8#^'$9T#F').-%(:%7#&&;#@"Lʹ@RP;#
^'$9%7#D;#34(#='4:(%47#\;#J<KKZM#12&2)&'()+%)"+8&#"2)&+8#$$2--+')+>'0/27+!"#$%&'();#D3+(%41%3(T#
S'*+%./#0'$#F%2%3$*1#+4.'#V+:1%$#Q()*3.+'4T#X&%4#a4+5%$2+./#H$%22;#
!"#
#