XVIII Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Mechanical Plants New pick-to-light system configuration: a feasibility study Andriolo Alessandro, Battini Daria, Calzavara Martina, Gamberi Mauro, Peretti Umberto, Persona Alessandro, Pilati Francesco, Sgarbossa Fabio Department of Management and Engineering, University of Padua, Stradella San Nicola, 3, 36100, Vicenza – Italy ([email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]) Abstract Purpose Warehouse order picking has often been described as the most labor-intensive operation in manual warehouses, as well as the most expensive and time consuming. These factors have inevitably become even more crucial due to manufacturing and warehousing recent trends, requiring high flexibility and efficiency in processing orders that are always smaller and needed in very few time. For this reason, in the recent years more efficient and performing systems have been proposed and developed, employing various technological solutions that can support pickers during their work. The aim of this study is to present a new pick-to-light design solution capable of driving a number of different operators in their picking activities, preventing the possibility of human errors by a new real-time control and alert system. The new solution has been analyzed from a technical and economical point of view, developing also a cost and benefit analysis in comparison with other existing solutions. Design/methodology/approach The most widespread techniques adopted to facilitate picking operations generally rely on led displays or digital screens, voice-activated devices, RFID technology, wireless appliances or lighting systems. As far as the latter are concerned, a pick-to-light system supports the picker during his activities by using different kind of lighting devices that can send evident light signals. In particular, the pick-to-light system here described drives an operator through the various storage locations he has to visit with a set of different coloured lights. These lights can be turned on or off according to the picker’s picking list. Furthermore, they are linked to a control system that it is able to recognize whether the operator is accessing the right storage location or not and to alert him with a set of visual (or also acoustic) signals, preventing him from completing the wrong picking action. A prototype of the new pick-to-light system is under development and implementation too, in order to directly understand its strengths and weaknesses. Originality/value The benefits that such support device can typically provide can be summed up in three main points: - Increased accuracy: picking errors are strongly reduced, since pickers can quickly understand whether they are collecting the right item or not - Increased productivity: picking is made easier and more focused on other activities, and the time needed to look for the right picking location or to remedy errors is reduced - Reduced training: finding the various locations is more intuitive and immediate and pickers don’t have to learn to use complex devices The new presented pick-to-light configuration is designed to be easy-to-use, inexpensive, modular and with a low energy impact. Furthermore, the different coloured lights allow multiple operators to work simultaneously in the same area, as every picker can follow the lights of a specific colour. Finally, comparing this solution with other systems already available on the market, its economic sustainability emerges, making it applicable in every kind of industrial environment. Keywords: Warehouse manual picking, Pick-to-light, RFID system. 243 XVIII Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Mechanical Plants 1. Introduction This feature generally helps to understand whether the scanner has correctly read the barcode, but it could be used also to notify that the product scanned is exactly what the picker has to take. Such system can be combined with paper picking lists, but picking lists can be also integrated directly in the handheld: once an item has been picked, the screen of the handheld shows the following product to take. Recently, handhelds RFID scanners are also available. The operating principle is similar to what just presented, except that the SKUs are tagged with RFID passive tags instead of barcodes. The working frequency is LF (Low Frequency) or HF (High Frequency), with small reading distances of the handhelds. In addition, and sometimes also alternatively, to such systems other devices have been developed. They are often referred to as Poka-Yoke solutions, because they perfectly reflect the principle according to which, in order to avoid mistakes, it is important to eliminate every chance of their happening (Baudin et al., 2005). The most widespread techniques are pick-to-voice and pick-to-light. A pick-to-voice system is a voice-directed system that uses speech recognition to allow warehouse operators to communicate with the warehouse management system. Pickers are equipped with a headset and a microphone to receive instructions of the picking by voice, and to verbally confirm their actions back to the system. The warehouse operator reads back the last digits of the item he has picked so that the system can check whether the correct item has been selected, then it can give the following instruction. On the other hand, in a pick-to-light system operators are guided by lights that are installed on the warehouse shelving. Each stock location has one light that turns on if the operator has to pick the corresponding product. In order to complete every single pick, the picker has to press the button of the interested stock location and, in some cases, he has also to scan the barcode of the picked item. If the simultaneous work of more than one picker in the same warehouse area is needed, such system has to be integrated with paper picking lists, with digital displays or with handhelds, so that every picker can understand which are the lights turned on for his order. An example of pick-to-light using RFID has been presented in 2011 in the RFID Journal (Friedlos, 2011). In the reported test case RFID readers are installed in some points beneath the conveyor belt, while RFID passive tags are attached to the plastic buckets in which workers place the products required to fulfil the orders. When the bucket reaches a RFID reader point of the conveyor belt, this sends the signals of turning on of the lights of the required products, so that the operator can easily and quickly identify them. Some companies are also proposing automated pick-tolight configurations, in which picker’s activities are fully assisted: also the progress and the stops of the picking cart are guided by the composition of the order. Another frontier for picking is represented by special glasses worn by the operator reporting on the lenses all the information he needs (Banker, 2013). The evolution of customer orders, always more frequent and smaller, has inevitably changed the way of their processing performed by suppliers, which are facing the need of being very rapid and flexible. Consequently, such trend heavily affects the configuration of picking warehouses and of the activities that have to be carried out within them, with a large pick volume that has to be satisfied in a short time window (De Koster et al., 2007). One of the priorities for warehouse managers is, therefore, improving picking performances. According to De Koster et al. (1998) paperless order picking systems can be a useful strategy to obtain some benefits in this sense. Paperless order picking can be via mobile, handheld or with terminals and printers that are vehiclemounted. Pickers and warehousemen are connected online with the warehouse information system, warranting updated stock information, immediate reaction to particular situations and real-time monitoring of operations status. As pickers don’t need to leave the storage area to do their work, mistakes are reduced and the overall productivity increases. A new frontier of paperless picking is represented by the use of important devices that have been developed to speed picking activities and to avoid picking errors. Some examples are led displays or digital screens, voice-activated devices (voice picking), wireless appliances or lighting systems (pick-to-light). RFID (Radio Frequency Identification) is a technology that has recently achieved great success in various warehouse applications, above all as far as managing and controlling the flow of products through the whole supply chain is concerned (Lee et al., 2010). This paper describes a new pick-to-light system that relies on RFID technology. In particular, next section illustrates the currently available technology able to support warehouse picking activities and summarizes some important concepts concerning RFID. In the third paragraph the RFID pick-to-light system configuration is presented, while in the fourth paragraph such system is compared to other already existing solutions, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses. Finally, in the paragraph of the conclusions, some further general considerations are emphasized. 2. Technological framework 2.1 State of the art of the systems supporting picking activities As warehouse manual picking is considered one of the most critical warehouse activities, many support systems have been developed, able to drive and control pickers during their work. One of the first devices adopted to facilitate picking process and one of the most widespread, too, is the handheld barcode scanner. All the stock keeping units are tagged with a barcode, that are scanned by the operator during the picking of the particular SKU. In this way, the picking information are immediately communicated to the warehouse information system. Handhelds are often able to emit acoustic signals, too. 244 XVIII Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Mechanical Plants 2.2 The RFID technology Finally, Baudin et al. (2005) point out that the current success of barcodes is going to end soon, exactly as RFID is perfectly able to overcome barcodes limits. For example, the amount of data that can be stored in a barcode is much smaller than in an RFID tag and it cannot be updated, too. A RFID (Radio Frequency Identification) system is a wireless communication system in which the radio link between the base station and the transponders are provided by the modulated back-scattered waves. Initially created for military purposes, almost since the beginning of its development the RFID technology has been used also in manufacturing and logistics applications (Raza et al., 1999). A basic RFID system consists of an antenna or coil, a transceiver, and a transponder tag (Lee et al., 2010). Such tags consist of an antenna and a chip, electronically programmed with unique information, that are often attached to objects in order to allow their identification. In fact, they can store data related to the products but also, more simply, a unique serial number that creates the connection to actual data in a database. According to their application, the transponders can be of two types: active or passive. The first ones have an own power supply (a battery) that enables them to transmit at higher power levels, hence to be read and written at greater distances (also over 100 m). Due to their characteristics, they are typically larger and more expensive. On the contrary, passive tags obtain their energy from the electromagnetic field of the reading device, so they are very small and economical. A RFID system can differ in terms of the frequency range in which it operates, too. In particular, there are three worldwide established frequencies: Low Frequency (LF), < 135 kHz, High Frequency (HF), 13.56 MHz and Ultra High Frequency (UHF), between 850 and 960 MHz. Every working frequency is more suitable for some applications than for others: when a RFID project is being developed it is important to perfectly understand what are its needs. Low Frequency systems are well-suited to industrial use, above all when working near metals and water is needed. High Frequency systems are characterised by greater ranges and higher reading speeds. The simultaneous reading of multiple tags is possible, but it could be influenced by the presence of metal objects. For warehousing and goods tracking UHF systems are more suitable. In fact, they enable very high data transfer rates and long ranges (up to six meters), even if signals typically do not pass through most of the materials. The basic principle, however, is that full advantages of RFID are obtained when the application, the manufacturing process and the supply chain are considered as a whole (Weinstein, 2005). In warehousing and manufacturing passive tags and UHF readers are the most widespread; this certainly happens because passive tags are very cheap and versatile. They are often used as an alternative to barcodes, but with better performances. In particular, they have a high reading capacity without needing of line-of-sight and a good writing/modifying capacity for storing data. According to Baudin et al. (2005) it is possible to obtain more benefits in the contexts in which a high rate of scanning is needed, hence, where warehouse operators or workers have to scan a lot of tags in very few time, as in the case of warehouse order picking. 3. New RFID Pick-to-light system 3.1 Presentation of the general configuration The background idea of the solution presented in this paper is the will to create a pick-to-light system able to drive the picker through the locations he has to visit in a smart as well as simple way. In particular, the main objective is to exploit the benefits of RFID technology, according to which there is no need of direct contact between the reader and the tag to obtain the information stored in the tag. Another important aspect that has been considered is to give the picker a RFID reader that doesn’t need to be kept in hand, so that he can perform the picks using both hands. To do this, a wearable RFID reader is needed. The best found solution is to provide the operator with a particular glove containing the RFID reader. Recently, some examples of similar solutions have been developed, for various applications. Among the first there are the iGlove and the iBracelet, invented by the Intel Research Seattle group (Fishkin et al., 2005). These devices are able to interact with unobtrusively tagged objects. Furthermore, the glove can also report whether the grasp of the object is with the palm or with the fingerprints. Medynskiy el al. (2007) use a wearable RFID reader for gaming applications. Muguira et al. (2009) propose the RFIDGlove system, consisting of a glove with an integrated RFID reader, an organic micro display and a communication system. They also highline the usefulness of such device for inventory and warehousing activities, as all the movements performed by warehouse operators are completely traced. Lee et al. (2010) created a wireless RFID glove for interactive learning and for a meal aid system useful for blind people. Most of the already existing devices can be used with passive tags and work at high frequency (13.56 MHz), which means that the read distances cannot be much larger than 1 meter. As far as the new RFID pick-to-light system is concerned, the lights that are installed on the shelving units to signal the picker the locations he has to visit are of different colours: every single operator can focus only on a particular colour and pick the items his order is made up by following that specific coloured lights, that are turned on or off according to the picker’s picking list. Red lights are used instead to alert the operator if he makes some errors during his picking activities. If the picker enters the wrong stock location and tries to pick the wrong product, the corresponding red light is turned on, in order to make him understand his mistake and to give him the possibility to immediately collect the right item. The proposed configuration is composed of three main units. The first one is a system of lights and tags installed 245 XVIII Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Mechanical Plants on the shelving, so that every stock location has one passive tag (or more, depending on the available storage room and on the kind of product stored) that identifies that particular stock location, one red light useful to alert the picker if he enters the wrong location and as many different coloured lights as the number of the pickers that are working at the same time in the same picking area, so that every picker follows only the lights of a particular colour to make up his order. Even if there are several pickers working in the same area, it is sufficient to have only one red light in every stock location. This because the red light turns on only if the corresponding location is entered by a picker by mistake. In this way, the picker understands unequivocally that who is wrong is exactly himself. The second unit consists of a wireless UHF RFID reader that every warehouse operator wears thanks to an appropriate glove. In this way, the picker has both hands free and he can pick the items he needs in a better and faster way. The system of lights installed on the shelving and the reader are managed and controlled by the third component of the configuration, a centralized control system. It takes as input the various picking lists (one for each picker) coming from the warehouse information system and sends the signals to turn on and off the appropriate lights of the shelving. Furthermore, such system is able to monitor the pickers’ picking activities, in order to highlight possible picking errors by turning on the red lights. Figure 1 shows a scheme of the proposed RFID pick-tolight configuration, useful to understand its general operation. Picking list A Picking list B Items to pick Items to pick B-1 G-1 R-1 B-2 1 RFID G-2 R-2 B-3 G-3 2 3 Tag 2 Tag 3 R-3 Wifi signal (read tag) A Tag 1 B-4 B-7 G-4 R-4 B-5 G-5 R-5 B-6 G-6 4 5 6 Tag 4 Tag 5 Tag 6 G-7 R-7 B-8 G-8 R-8 B-9 G-9 7 8 9 Tag 7 Tag 8 Tag 9 Centralized Control System Lights turning on/ off signals R-6 RFID B R-9 Figure 1: Scheme of the new RFID pick-to-light system configuration. The centralized control system receives the picking lists and it extracts the information of the products to pick to send the signal of turning on of the lights, each colour corresponding to a specific operator. According also to the routing policy that is adopted in the warehouse, the light of the first location the picker has to visit is turned on, so that the picker can easily and immediately understand where the item he has to pick is located. When the picker, wearing the glove that includes the RFID reader, reaches the particular location there are two possibilities: he enters the right stock location or he enters a wrong one. In both cases, the reader reads the tag corresponding to the stock location and sends via Wi-Fi the read code to the centralized control system, that acts accordingly. In case of correct access, once the system has verified that the code received from the RFID reader is the right one, corresponding to the item the operator has actually to pick, it sends the signal of turning off the coloured light of that location (for example, the blue one) and of turning on the coloured light of the following location, corresponding to the following line of the picking list. In this case, it could be useful to associate an acoustic signal to confirm the correct picking. If the picker mistakes the stock location and tries to pick the wrong item, the centralized control system receives from the RFID reader a code corresponding to a product different from what it expects. Then, it sends the signal of turning on of the red light of the wrong stock location, so that the picker immediately realizes that he is not in the right one. When the operator pulls out his hand from the wrong location the centralized control system doesn’t receive the wrong code from the RFID reader anymore, so the red light is turned off. It is important to underline that every picker can perform his work independently. As every operator wears his own RFID reader, the centralized control system can perfectly recognize the different signals coming from the various pickers. Hence, it is perfectly able to manage separately the turning on and off of the different lights. 3.2 Prototype design In order to properly assess the potential of such configuration and to test the various technologies that 246 XVIII Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Mechanical Plants have been used, a prototype of the new RFID pick-tolight system is being developed. Such prototype is designed to manage two operators that work simultaneously. It is composed of a shelving with nine stock locations, each of which has three leds, one green led for the first operator, one yellow led for the second one and one red led to indicate the picking errors. All the leds are connected to a microcontroller that sends the signals of turning on and off of the lights. Every stock location has also one passive tag, in which the code of the product stored in that stock location has been wrote. The UHF RFID readers are composed of a wireless reader unit, of a linear polarized UHF antenna and of a 12 V lithium battery. This device is worn by the operator through a glove, where the antenna is on the upper part of one of his hands and the reader unit is on his forearm. The battery, instead, can be hooked, for example, at his waist. The data read by each reader are sent to a personal computer via Wi-Fi. The PC represents the centralized control system: in addition to receive the information of the RFID readers it has a Labview project that has been developed to manage all the control logic. In particular, the program is able to read two different picking lists from an Excel file and to send the appropriate signals to turn on the green and Ease of use yellow leds according to the order lines. The RFID readers are interfaced with the Labview project through a TCP/IP Socket, that receives the information of the read tags as a Wi-Fi input and transmits them to the rest of the Labview project. The remaining logic is necessary to compare the tags read by the RFID readers to the order lines of the picking lists, in order to understand whether the picker is picking the right product or not. If the operator picks the right item the system sends to the microcontroller the command of turning off the led corresponding to that product and of turning on the one that refers to the following line of the picking list. Otherwise, it makes turning on the red led of the stock location the picker has erroneously entered. 4. Analysis of the solution Table 1 reports a qualitative comparison of some of the supporting devices used for manual picking already described in Section 2: handhelds, pick-to-voice system, traditional and fully automated pick-to-light system and the new RFID pick-to-light system presented in this paper. The criteria used for the analysis are focused on the usability of the devices, as well as their efficiency and effectiveness. Picking Cheapness Flexibility Modularity time Reading distance Pickers Environment simultaneity influence Errors interception Handheld and barcodes High Medium Medium High High Few centimetres Possible Medium After barcode scanning Handheld and RFID High Medium Medium High High Up to 20 cm Possible Low After tag scanning Low High High Not applicable Possible High After code communication Medium Medium Medium Medium Not applicable Difficult Low At the end of picking Fully automated Medium pick-to-light system Short Very low Very low Medium Not applicable Not possible Low Immediate RFID pick-to-light system Short High High High Up to 2 m Possible Medium Immediate Pick-to-voice system Traditional pick-tolight system Medium Medium High High Table 1: Comparison of some manual picking supporting devices. As the new RFID pick-to-light configuration does not require for the operator the using of any particular device, it proves to be very easy to use. In fact, the RFID reader is directly integrated within the glove, so the picker has only to focus on the physical picking of the products he needs, without scanning barcodes or, as in the case of the pick-to-voice, without reading aloud the product code. This implies that the picking time is short, because the picking action is just limited to take the required item and to put it in the picking cart. In other systems, instead, every pick is associated to other operations, for example the scanning of the barcode or of the tag. It derives that using the new RFID pick-to light system improves warehouse overall performances. The new RFID pick-to-light system is inexpensive, too. This is specially due to the fact that in this case instead of tagging or barcoding all the SKUs, as in the case of handhelds or other picking systems, the RFID tag are put only on the stock locations. Furthermore, the UHF RFID reader is a device commonly available on the market, and the proposed configuration requires just one reader for every picker, as with handhelds and pick-to-voice. These systems, in which each warehouse operator has his own device, warrant great flexibility as well as great modularity, too. According to the configuration, the reading distance varies from the few centimetres of the barcodes to the two metres of the UHF RFID pick-to-light system presented in this paper. RFID handhelds can read the tags only up to 20 cm as they generally work at LF or HF. The new RFID pick-to-light system allows also simultaneous work of more pickers in the same warehouse sector, because every stock location has as many different coloured lights as the number of operators working in such area. This is possible also for barcode and RFID handhelds and for pick-to-voice systems. Working at the same time is quite hard, instead, in a traditional pick-to-light system, as for the pickers it is difficult to 247 XVIII Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Mechanical Plants understand which are the lights that are turned on for him and which that are not. In some cases operators’ activities can be influenced by the environment they work in. This is particularly true for voice picking, as surrounding noises could prevent a correct communication between the system and the operator of the code to pick and of its following confirmation. Besides, for such systems a wrong pronunciation of the numbers could cause a useless delay in picking activities. Also the scanning of barcodes could have some problems: it requires a clean, high-contrast environment, and often more than one attempt (Baudin et al., 2005). On the contrary, pick-to-light is generally not affected by its context of application. For the RFID pickto-light system the only issue concerning the environment of application could derive from the interference of RFID waves with the shelving, the products stored and with the body of the operator. It is therefore fundamental to carefully study the configuration of the whole system, in order to prevent some side effects and to exploit some other ones. Another great strength of the new RFID pick-to-light system is the immediate interception of errors. In fact, the picker can understand right away whether he has picked the right product or not. In case he puts his hand in the wrong stock location, the red light turns on in order to prevent him from completing the wrong picking action. The same behaviour is performed also by the fully automated pick-to-light system, but requiring at the same time the installation of a complex as well as expensive hardware. In some other configurations, instead, there is the risk for the picker of discovering picking errors only once the order is complete, or, even worse, when the order is delivered to the customer. According to Frazelle (1989) and Tolliver (1989), a computer-aided system can be used for manual order picking to simplify the tasks of human pickers; furthermore, it has been estimated that a light-directed picking system with automated data entry can reduce human errors of 95% as well as increase productivity of 10%. As the new pick-to-light system uses RFID technology and it is real time connected to the centralized control system, it is quite easy to obtain useful data about all pickers’ activities, for example the number of picks per hour, that could be used as a starting point for possible improvements of the whole system. When the RFID reader reads the tag the signal is sent via Wi-Fi to a centralized control system that checks whether the picker has taken the right item or not and that sends the signals of turning on and off of the appropriate lights. Thanks also to the creation of a prototype, that is still under development, such system has been compared with other manual picking supporting devices, showing its potentialities as well as its economical sustainability. Next steps of the project will concern the setup of the full prototype. Subsequently, smart ways to communicate the quantity to pick of every item to the operator will be investigated. A solution could be integrating a display in the glove (Muguira et al., 2009) showing the number of pieces to pick. 6. References Banker, S. (2013). Google Glass, Augmented Reality, and the Warehouse. Baudin, M., Rao, A. (2005). RFID applications in manufacturing. De Koster, R., Le-Duc, T., Roodbergen, K.J. (2007). Design and control of a warehouse order picking: a literature review. European Journal of Operational Research, 182(2), 481-501. De Koster, R., Van Der Poort E. (1998). Routing orderpickers in a warehouse: a comparison between optimal and heuristic solutions. IIE Transactions, 30, 469-480. Fishkin, K.P., Philipose, M., Rea, A. (2005). Hands-on RFID: wireless wearable for detecting use of objects. Proceedings of Ninth IEEE International Symposium on Wearable Computers, 38-41. Frazelle, E. A., Sharp, G. P. (1989). Correlated Assignment Strategy Can Improve Any Order-Picking Operation. Industrial Engineering, 21, 33-37. Friedlos, D. (2011). Korean warehouse deploy RFID-enhanced pick-to-light system. RFID Journal. Jane, C. C., Laih, Y. (2005). A clustering algorithm for item assignment in a synchronized zone order picking system. European Journal of Operational Research, 166, 489-496. Lee, C., Kim, M., Park, J., Oh, J., Eom, K. (2010). Design and implementation of the wireless RFID Glove for life applications. International Journal of Grid and Distributed Computing, 3(3) 41-52. Medynskiy, Y., Gov, S., Mazalek, A., Minnen , D. (2007). Wearable RFID for Play. Proceedings of the 12th international conference on Intelligent user interfaces. 5. Conclusions and further research Warehouse manual picking is one of the most critical activity in a warehouse: every improvement made on this area can lead to great results in terms of time and costs saving (De Koster, 2007). In this sense, it could be interesting the development of devices able to support and help the pickers during their work. In this paper a new RFID pick-to-light system configuration has been presented, that combines the benefits of RFID to the simplicity and effectiveness of pick-to-light. Every warehouse operator wears a glove in which a UHF RFID reader is installed, while every stock location has a RFID tag to identify the corresponding product stored. Muguira, L., Vazquez, J.I., Arruti, A., Ruiz-de-Garibay, J., Mendia, I., Renteria S. (2009). RFIDGlove: a wearable RFID reader. IEEE International Conference on e-Business Engineering, 475-480. Raza, N., Bradshaw, V., Hague, M. Applications of RFID technology. The IEE Savoy place. London WG2R. Tolliver, R. (1989). Order Picking Basics at Avon Products. Material Handling Focus 1989, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia. Weinstein, R. (2005). RFID: a technical overview and its application to the enterprise. IT Professional, 3(3), 27-33. 248
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz