International Journal of Management Excellence
IJME Review Form
Instructions: Peer Review acts as a filter by ensuring only good research is published. It helps to determine validity,
significance and originality of the articles and helps the authors to make the paper better. A reviewer should provide a
critique that is positive, critical yet objective, balanced, contains no personally offensive comments, and is returned
promptly.
Reviewers are expected to return their reviews within one week (7 days), unless otherwise specified by the Editor.
Manuscript Number
Manuscript Title
Journal Name
International Journal of Research in Business and Technology
Overview (Please rate each item by typing letter x in the appropriate box)
Poor
1
The title is clear, specific, relevant, and timely.
2
The paper satisfies the academic standards
3
The topic is novel and interesting.
4
The abstract is concise and informative.
5
The introduction clearly states the problem being investigated.
6
The research methodology is appropriate and applied properly.
7
Research problem answers an important question
8
The results of analysis are correctly interpreted and conclusions are sound.
9
References are complete and appropriate.
10
Tables and figures are relevant and justified.
11
Language is easy to understand and free from errors.
Avg
Good
Excellent
Comments
Suggestions for
improvement
Recommended Action: check one. (type letter x in the appropriate box)
Accept
Accept with minor revisions
Accept subject to major revisions
Reject
TechMind Research Society (www.ijmeonline.com)
1|Page