Citation of ICCPR in domestic case law
CASE
COURT
INTERNATIONAL
REFERENCE
Department of Labour v Latailakepa
[1982] 1 NZLR 632
Court of Appeal
Art.15 ICCPR
Broadcasting Corporation of New
Zealand v A-G [1982] 1 NZLR 120
Court of Appeal
Art.14(1) ICCPR
R v Uljee [1982] 1 NZLR 561
Court of Appeal
Art.14(3) ICCPR
Police v O’Connor[1992] 1 NZLR 87
High Court
Art.19(2) ICCPR
Noort v Ministry of Transport [1992]
1 NZLR 743
High Court
ICCPR
Ministry of Transport v Noort; Police
v Curran [1992] 3 NZLR 260
Court of Appeal
ICCPR
Parkhill v Ministry of Transport
[1992] 1 NZLR 555
Court of Appeal
Art.14(3)(a) ICCPR
R v Goodwin (No.2) [1993] 2 NZLR
153; [1990-92] 3 NZBORR 314;
(1992) 9 CRNZ 1
Court of Appeal
Art.9(1) ICCPR
R v Jefferies [1994] 1 NZLR 290;
(1992/3) 1 HRNZ 478; (1993) 10
CRNZ 202 (CA)
Court of Appeal
Arts. 9(1), 17 ICCPR
Vaematahau v Minister of
Immigration [1992] HC WN CP
834/91
High Court
Art.13 ICCPR
Re M , a committed patient [1992] 1
NZLR 29; (1991) 7 CRNZ 390
District Court
Art.10 ICCPR
R v L [1994] 2NZLR 54; (1993) 1
HRNZ 310; 11 CRNZ 8 (CA)
Court of Appeal
ICCPR
1
STATE REPORT IN
WHICH REFERENCED
Second periodic report
Third periodic report
Third periodic report
Third periodic report
Citation of ICCPR in domestic case law
Re “Exposing the Aids Scandal”
(1993) 2 HRNZ 170
Indecent
Publications
Tribunal
Art.20(2) ICCPR
Re Bennett (1993) 2 HRNZ 358
High Court
ICCPR
S B v New Zealand (1994) 7 HRNZ
746
UN Human
Rights
Committee
Art.26 ICCPR
Tavita v Minister of Immigration
[1994] 2 NZLR 257; (1993) 11
HRNZ 508; (1993) 1 HRNZ 30 (CA)
Court of Appeal
Art.23(1), 24(1) ICCPR
Auckland Unemployed Workers’
Rights Centre Inc v A-G[1994] 3
NZLR 720; (1994) 1 HRNZ 106 (CA)
Court of Appeal
Arts.2(3), 17 ICCPR
Simpson v Attorney-General
(Baigent’s case) [1994] 3 NZLR 667;
(1994) 1 HRNZ 42 (CA)
Court of Appeal
Art.2 (3) ICCPR
R v B[1995]2 NZLR 172;also reported
as R v Accused (1994) 12 CRNZ 417;
(1994) 1 HRNZ 1
High Court/
Court of Appeal
Arts.23(1),24(1),(3)
ICCPR
R v Barlow (1995) 14 CRNZ 9; (1995)
2 HRNZ 635
Court of Appeal
Arts.(1)9,14(1),14(3)(b)
ICCPR
Bailey v Whangarei District Court
(1995) 2 HRNZ 275
High Court
Arts.14(3)(b)(d) ICCPR
Re TVNZ (search and seizure)(1995)
1 HRNZ 439
High Court /
Court of Appeal
Art.14(3)(c) ICCPR
Martin v Tauranga District Court
[1995] 2 NZLR 419
District Court
Art.14 ICCPR
Martin v Tauranga District Court
(1994)(1995) 1 HRNZ 186
High Court
Arts.9(3),14(3)(c)
ICCPR
Court of Appeal
Art.14(3)(c) ICCPR
2
Fourth periodic report
Fourth periodic report
Fourth periodic report
Fourth periodic report
Citation of ICCPR in domestic case law
Re J [An Infant]; Director-General of
Social Welfare v B (1995) 2 HRNZ 99
High Court
Arts. 3,5,6,9 ICCPR
Court of Appeal
Arts.18(3),(4) ICCPR
Rajan v Minister of Immigration
(1996) 3 HRNZ 209
Court of Appeal
ICCPR
Rajan v New Zealand (2003) 7 HRNZ
653
UN Human
Rights
Committee
(No.820/1998)
Arts.9(1),13,24(3),26
ICCPR
Whithair v A-G (1996) 2 HRNZ 389
High Court
Art.2(3)(a) ICCPR
Puli’uvea v Removal Review Authority
(1996) 14 FRNZ 322; (1996) 2
HRNZ 510
Court of Appeal
Arts. 23,25 ICCPR
Lawson v Housing New Zealand
[1997] 2 NZLR 474; (1996) 3 HRNZ
285 (HC)
High Court
Preamble , Arts.2(1),
11(1) ICCPR
TV NZ v R [1996] 3 NZKLR 393 also
reported as R v Bain (1996) 3 HRNZ
108
Court of Appeal
Arts.14(1),19(3) ICCPR
Brannigan v Davison (1996) 3 HRNZ
381
Privy Council
Art.14(3)(g) ICCPR
TVNZ Ltd v R [1996] 3 NZLR 393;
(1996) 3 HRNZ 108 (CA)
Court of Appeal
Art.14(1) ICCPR
Patel v Chief Executive , Dept, of
Labour (1996) 2 HRNZ 590
High Court
Art.23 ICCPR
Re New Truth and TV Extra, 4
November 1994 (1996) 3 HRNZ 162
Film and
Literature
Review Board
Art.40 ICCPR
Drake v New Zealand (1997) 7
HRNZ 605
UN Human
Rights
Arts. 2(3)(a), 26, 28
ICCPR
B & B v Director-General of Social
Welfare (1996) 2 HRNZ 324
3
Citation of ICCPR in domestic case law
Committee
R v Gibbons (1997) 3 HRNZ 596
High Court
Arts.9(2), 14(3)(a)
ICCPR
Quilter v A-G (1996)3 HRNZ 1;
(1996) 14 FRNZ 430
High Court
Art.1OP ICCPR
Quilter v A-G [1998] 1 NZLR 523
(CA); (1997) 4 HRNZ 170 ; [1998]
NZFLR 196 (CA)
Court of Appeal
Arts.2(1),3,6(5),8,10,14
18,23,26,55,56 ICCPR
Joslin v New Zealand (2002) 7 HRNZ
616
UN Human
Rights
Committee
Arts.2(1), 23 (1)(2), 26
ICCPR
Lange v Atkinson [1997] 2 NZLR 22
(HC) (1997) 4 HRNZ 652
High Court
Arts.17, 19 ICCPR
Lange v Atkinson [1998] 3 NZLR 424
(CA); (1997) 4 HRNZ 683
Court of Appeal
Art.19 ICCPR
Tangiora v Wellington District Legal
Services Committee (1996) 3 HRNZ
267
High Court
Arts.1,14,16,26,27,28
ICCPR
Art.1 OP ICCPR
Wellington District Legal Services
Committee v Tangiora (1997) 4
HRNZ 136
Court of Appeal
Arts. 1,2,14,14(3)(d),
26,40, 41,42 ICCPR
Art.1,3,4,5,6 OP ICCPR
Tangiora v Wellington District Legal
Services Committee (1999) 5 HRNZ
201
Privy Council
Art.26 ICCPR
OP ICCPR
Shortland v Northland Health Ltd.
(1997) 4 HRNZ 121
Court of Appeal Art.6(1) ICCPR
R v Gardiner (1997) 4 HRNZ 7
Court of Appeal
Art.7 ICCPR
Potter v New Zealand (1997) 7HR NZ
647
UN Human
Rights
Committee
Arts. 2,5(2)(b), 9(3)
ICCPR
R v N (1998) 5 HRNZ 72
Court of Appeal
Art. 6(1), 9(1) , 12(1),
17(2), 24(1) ICCPR
4
Fourth periodic report
Fourth periodic report
Citation of ICCPR in domestic case law
Nicholls v Registrar of the Court of
Appeal (1998) 4 HRNZ 537
Court of Appeal
Arts.14, 14(3)(d)
ICCPR
Auckland Healthcare Services Ltd. v L
(1998) 5 HRNZ 748
High Court
Art.6(1) ICCPR
Northern Regional Health Authority v
Human Rights Commission [1998] 2
NZLR 218; (1999) 4 HRNZ 37
High Court
Preamble ICCPR
Mendelssohn v A-G [ 1999] 2 NZLR
268; (1999) 5 HRNZ 1
Court of Appeal
Arts.6(1), 17(2),
18,18(3), 20, 23(1),
24(1) ICCPR
A v New Zealand (1999) 7 HRNZ 700
UN Human
Rights
Committee
Arts. 2,3,5,(1),5(2)(b)
5(4) ICCPR
A-G v Hewitt (1999) 5 HRNZ 468
High Court
Art.17 ICCPR
Police v Beggs (1999) 5 HRNZ 108
High Court
Art.21 ICCPR
Air New Zealand Ltd. v Kippenberger
(1999) 5 HRNZ 327
High Court
Art.22 ICCPR
Manga v A-G [2000] 2 NZLR 65;
(1999) 5 HRNZ 177; (1999) 17 CRNZ
18; [1999] NZAR 506 (CA)
Court of Appeal
Art.9 ICCPR
Fourth periodic report
Dunlea v Attorney-General (2000) 3
NZLR 137
Court of Appeal
Art.2(3)(a) ICCPR
Fourth periodic report
Toala v New Zealand (2000) 7 HRNZ
687
UN Human
Rights
Committee
Arts.2(3),1294),
14(3)(d),
12(4),17,17(1),23, 26
ICCPR
Mahuika v New Zealand (2000) 7
HRNZ 629
UN Human
Rights
Committee
Arts.1, 14(1), 27
ICCPR; OP ICCPR
Art.5(4)
Tamihere v New Zealand (2000) 7
UN Human
Arts. 2,14,26 ICCPR
5
Citation of ICCPR in domestic case law
HRNZ 726
Rights
Committee
R v Poumako [2000] 2 NZLR 695;
(2000) 5 HRNZ 652; 17 CRNZ 530
(CA)
Court of Appeal
Art.4, 15(1) ICCPR
R v Pora [2001] 2 NZLR 37; (2000) 6
HRNZ 129; (2000) 18 CRNZ 270
(CA)
Court of Appeal
Arts.14(5), 1591)
ICCPR
Singh v New Zealand (2001) 7 HRNZ
713
UN Human
Rights
Committee
Arts.2,7,10,14(1),14(2)
14(3)(d), 14(3)(e) ,
14(3)(g), 14(5) 16, 23,
26 ICCPR
Drew v A-G (2001) 6 HRNZ
368
Court of Appeal
Art.14 ICCPR
Taito v R (2002) 6 HRNZ 539
Privy Council
ICCPR
Chief Executive, Department of
Labour v Taito (2006) 8 HRNZ 53
Court of Appeal
Arts.17, 23 ICCPR
Moonen v Film and Literature Board
of Review [2002] 2 NZLR 754;
(2009) 6 HRNZ 623
Court of Appeal
Art.19(3) ICCPR
Re X (2002) 6 HRNZ 751
High Court
Art.14(1) ICCPR
Tunstall v Police (2002) 7 HRNZ 188
High Court
ICCPR
Wilding v A-G (2002) 7 HRNZ 87
High Court
Art.2 ICCPR
Zaoui v A-G (2003) 7 HRNZ 494
High Court
ICCPR
Brown v A-G (2003) 7 HRNZ 100
High Court
Art.14(6) ICCPR
A-G v P F Sugrue Ltd (2003) 7 HRNZ
137
Court of Appeal
ICCPR
6
Fourth periodic report
Fourth periodic report/
Fifth periodic report
Fifth periodic report
Citation of ICCPR in domestic case law
Rameka v New Zealand (2003) 7
HRNZ 663
UN Human
Rights
Committee
Arts. 2,5,7,9(4),
10,14(2),15,28,31
ICCPR
Sahid v New Zealand (2003) 7 HRNZ
730
UN Human
Rights
Committee
Arts. 6,7, 9, 17(1),23(1)
24(1),28 ICCPR; Arts.
1,5(1),5 (2)(b), 5(4) OP
ICCPR
Wolf v Minister of Immigration (2004)
7 HRNZ 469
High Court
ICCPR
Hopkinson v Police [2004] 3 NZLR
704; (2004) 8 HRNZ 204
High Court
Arts. 19(2),19(3), 21
ICCPR
Fifth periodic report
Taunoa v A-G (2004) 7 HRNZ 379
High Court
ICCPR
Fifth periodic report
A-G on behalf of the Department of
Corrections v Taunoa [2006] 2 NZLR
457; (2005) 8 HRNZ 119 (CA)
Court of Appeal
Arts.7, 10, 10(1)
ICCPR
Taunoa v A-G [2007] NZSC 70;
[2008] 1 NZLR 429; (2007) 9 HRNZ
104
Supreme Court
Arts. 7, 9 ICCPR
Child Poverty Action Group Inc v AG
[2005] NZHRRT 28; (2005) 7 HRNZ
939
Human Rights
ICCPR
Review Tribunal
Ransfield v The Radio Network [2005]
1 NZLR 233 (HC); (2004) 8 HRNZ
186
High Court
Art.19 ICCPR
Hosking v Runting [2005] 1 NZLR
(CA); 7 HRNZ 301
Court of Appeal
ICCPR
A-G on behalf of the Minister of
Immigration v Udompun (2005) 7
HRNZ 811
Court of Appeal
Arts.14(1),14(3) ICCPR
Zaoui v A-G (No.2) [2006] 1NZLR
284
Supreme Court
Arts.6,7 ICCPR
R v Mist [2006] 3 NZLR 445 ; 8
HRNZ 10
Supreme Court
Arts. 4(1), 4(2),4(30,
4(4), 15 ICCPR
7
Fifth periodic report
Fifth periodic report
Fifth periodic report
Citation of ICCPR in domestic case law
R v Hansen [2007] NZSC 7; [2007]
NZLR 1; (2007) 8 HRNZ 222; (2007)
23 CRNZ 104 (SC)
Supreme Court
Arts.4,12,14,14(1),14
(2),14(3), 18,19 ICCPR
Fifth periodic report
Brooker v Police [2007] NZSC 30;
[2007] 3 NZLR 91
Supreme Court
Art.19 ICCPR
Fifth periodic report
Combined Beneficiaries Union v
Auckland City COGS Committee
[2009] 2 NZLR 56; (2008) 9 HRNZ
12
Court of Appeal
Art.14(1) ICCPR
Rogers v TVNZ [2007] 1NZSC 91
Supreme Court
Art.17 ICCPR
A-G v Chapman (2009) 8 HRNZ 857
(CA)
Court of Appeal
Art.14(6) ICCPR
A-G v Chapman [2011] NZSC 110 ;
(2008) 9 HRNZ 257
Art.2(3), 14(6) ICCPR
Petryszick v R [2010] NZSC 105;
(2008) 9 HRNZ 35
Supreme Court
Art.14(5) ICCPR
Atkinson v Ministry of Health [2012]
NZCA 184
Court of Appeal
Art.2 ICCPR
8
Fifth periodic report