NHSEB Judge’s Score Sheet
Judge_____________________________________________________
Team One_________________________________________________
Team Two_______________________________________________
Team One Presentation
A. Was Team One’s presentation
clear and systematic? (1-5)
________
B. Did the team’s presentation clearly
identify and thoroughly discuss the
central moral dimensions
of the case? (1-5)
________
C. Did the team’s presentation indicate
both awareness and thoughtful
consideration of different viewpoints,
including especially those that would
loom large in the reasoning of
individuals who disagree with
the team’s position? (1-5)
________
1. Total Team One Presentation:
_______________
(total A-C here)
2. Team Two Commentary:
(1-10)
_______________
3. Team One Response to Commentary:
(1-10)
_______________
4. Team One Response to Judges:
(1-15)
_______________
Team Two Presentation
A. Was Team Two’s presentation
clear and systematic? (1-10) ________
B. Did the team’s presentation clearly
identify and thoroughly discuss the
central moral dimensions
of the case? (1-10)
________
C. Did the team’s presentation indicate
both awareness and thoughtful
consideration of different viewpoints,
including especially those that would
loom large in the reasoning of
individuals who disagree with
the team’s position? (1-10)
________
5. Total Team Two Presentation:
6. Team One Commentary:
(1-10)
_____________
(total A-C here)
_______________
7. Team Two Response to Commentary: ___________
(1-10)
8. Team Two Response to Judges:
(1-15)
_______________
9a. Team One Civil Tone Points: __________
(1-10)
9b. Team Two Civil Tone Points: __________
(1-10)
Team One Total:
(0-60)
Team Two Total:
(0-60)
__________________
__________________