which support for RES going forward?

Hans ten BERGE
Secretary General,
EURELECTRIC
The voice of the European Electricity
Industry, standing for
...a secure and reliable, low-carbon generation
mix
...a well-functioning, integrated European market
...a smarter use of electricity
...a sustainable business environment
EURELECTRIC is a pan-European and
internationally oriented association
Our vision
-
Decarbonisation with a diversity of
technologies (including RES)
-
Cost-efficiency for customers and
competitiveness for our industry
-
Well-functioning and integrated
markets
Which instruments do we use to
implement this vision?
Content
1. The 2020 & 2030 horizons: which support for RES going
forward?
2. Powering Investment in Europe’s energy sector
3. Europe in a global context
4. Recommendations: Action is needed now!
Content
1. The 2020 & 2030 horizons: which support for RES going
forward?
2. Powering Investment in Europe’s energy sector
3. Europe in a global context
4. Recommendations: Action is needed now!
Key short-term and medium-term challenges
to make RES development a success
How to ensure the move to a more dynamic and cost-efficient support which
uses the forces of a European market ?
How to deal with volume growth in RES support design and system integration?
How to reconcile RES support with the ETS in the medium term?
RES are part of the mix, but the way they are
supported should be revisited
• RES are part of the European energy mix and their
share is set to grow to meet the 2020 RES targets.
• As RES installed capacity grows massively and
technologies mature, MS should come up with “RES
2.0” policies, i.e. a market-compatible methodology
for their support
• European approach: foster learning effects among
MS and enhance use of cooperation-mechanisms.
• RES support should be phased out long term
investments should be driven by price signals
including by the EU ETS
We believe that robust RES development can go hand in
hand with market integration and demand/supply dynamics
But where is the market approach ?
Where are defenders of the European single market
generally?
What is the follow-up to the 2010 Monti Report that had
outlined the following?
“Two mutually reinforcing trends are at work: an ‘integration
fatigue’, eroding the appetite for more Europe and for a single
market; and more recently, a ‘market fatigue’, with a reduced
confidence in the role of the market”.
Do’s
1. Ensure full participation of RES technologies in the market:
a clear roadmap is needed
• Use market oriented scheme (e.g. feed-in premium, tradable
certificates, …) as much as possible
• Ensure and enable that renewables are subject to price signals in
handling power production and are exposed to market risks
• In parallel, develop and integrate intra-day and balancing markets
Do’s
• A level playing field for all technologies will enable variable
renewables to deliver flexibility to the market:
• All technologies to carry out balancing, scheduling
and operation obligations
• All producers should be – directly or through
aggregators – obliged to become Balancing
Responsible Parties. This would incentivise
producers to improve forecasting even further.
• Ensure that RES generators are subject to the same
grid access conditions as other generators and that
prosumers covering part of its consumption pay
relevant grid fees.
• There should be no obstacles for RES to take part in
ancillary services provision
• Build up relationship with customers
Dont’s
1. NO RETROACTIVE CHANGES. They destroy the investment climate.
2. NO OVER REMUNERATION/OVER-COMPENSATION. Right support level is key:
support too high  excessive cost for consumers, support too low  no investment
3. AFTER 2020, NO MWh-BASED FINANCING FOR ANY TECHNOLOGIES THAT
ARE ONLY AT THEIR INCEPTION. R&DD funding should be favoured instead.
4. NO WINNERS-PICKING! Hydro and biomass are part of the solution too. NREAPs’
projections should not lead to a tunnel view which would privilege PV and wind.
Resources and potential vary in Europe. Every MS should contribute best, based on
their resources.
5. REFRAIN FROM INJECTING RES OUTPUT WHEN PRICES ARE NEGATIVE
Examples
Features of RES
support
Belgium
RES-E has to be sold to
the market by the operator
YES
Nominating, scheduling,
balancing responsibility
YES
Priority of dispatch
YES
Incentives to react to
low/negative market prices
Germany
(except when RES is
locally consumed)
NO
Not for small PV
NO
Not for majority of RES,
only under Feed-inPremium scheme.
YES
Feed-in restricted only
in exceptional cases
Feed-in restricted
only in exceptional
cases
limited
Mainly by TSOs, only
partly by RES operators
themselves,
limited
Snapshot on Germany – variable RES boom in 10
years time
Peak load set to
decrease by 2020
at 74 GW
2020 (higher)
PV
2020 (conservative)
Wind
There will be times when
demand is low and vRES
generation is high….
What is going to happen?
2011
0
10
20
Source: EURELECTRIC, Power Statistics 2012
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
~ 34% of RES-Electricity by 2020 will require
profound changes in the power system to manage variability
Integrated wholesale
markets
Flexible and back-up
generation capacity
Smart Grids and demand
side participation
Extensive new
infrastructure at T&D level
Storage
Policy makers must switch to a system wide market
approach, in their commitment to decarbonisation
Looking beyond 2020, what do we want for Europe?
• Re-run of 2020?
• EU RES Quota Obligation?
• Nothing?
EURELECTRIC stands for:
Reformed ETS as a key driver + R&DD support for
immature RES technologies/CCS + indicative EU target for
RES
Content
1. The 2020 & 2030 horizons: which support for RES going
forward?
2. Powering Investment in Europe’s energy sector
3. Europe in a global context
4. Recommendations: Action is needed now!
Content
1. The 2020 & 2030 horizons: which support for RES going
forward?
2. Powering Investment in Europe’s energy sector
3. Europe in a global context
4. Recommendations: Action is needed now!
EURELECTRIC Investment Action Plan
Objectives:

 Assess today’s investment needs and capability
Inject realisms into the figures usually quoted (i.e. €1 trillion up to 2020)
 Undertake a risk-mapping exercise
 Formulate policy recommendations to move ahead
How:


High-level Task Force to steer the work
 CEO interviews
 Brainstorming workshop
Involvement of broader structure of expertise
Deliverables:
 Final report structured in Findings & Recommendations
 Full report
Utilities challenged: underperforming the European
Blue-chip index…
Source: Eurostoxx.com, retrieved 5 November
… and losing attractiveness vis-à-vis US and Asian
peers
Source: Eurostoxx.com, retrieved 5 November
Regulatory risk is on the rise
Which risk do you rank highest when making
your investment decisions?
Source: EURELECTRIC, own survey
Companies do not want to be shielded from all risks.
But how could they hedge regulatory risks?
Taxes and levies are piling up…!
Recent tax developments in Europe in the electricity
sector
Spain – new taxes on generation introduced: 6% levy on all forms
of power generation + “green cent” levy on fuels (coal, natural gas,
fuel oil)
Hungary – “Robin Hood’ tax increased by 23 p.p., boosting
corporate tax rate to 50%
Netherlands – coal tax of about €14/tonne
Source: EURELECTRIC
Taxes and levies can also act as a barrier for further demand
side participation as it weakens the price signal for flexibility
Source: BDEW
Electricity on the roller coaster:
The economic recession has hit companies’ balance
sheets and ability to invest
Source: EURELECTRIC, Power Statistics 2012
W-shaped GDP
W-shaped electricity demand
From the vicious to the virtuous circle
Companies need an empowering political /regulatory framework to
build the confidence necessary to underpin the investments
needed to the energy transition
The empowering framework for investments should be built on the
above principles to de-risk the industry
Content
1. The 2020 & 2030 horizons: which support for RES going
forward?
2. Powering Investment in Europe’s energy sector
3. Europe in a global context
4. Recommendations: Action is needed now!
Content
1. The 2020 & 2030 horizons: which support for RES going
forward?
2. Powering Investment in Europe’s energy sector
3. Europe in a global context
4. Recommendations: Action is needed now!
Europe is set in a global context. Is it on top of
things or lagging behind?
- US: shale gas has brought down energy prices and is
attracting energy-intensive industries.
- China: going for nuclear + RES on top of coal; cheap labour
cost for technology manufacturing.
- Commodities markets:
- high gas prices
- low coal prices
- low CO2 prices
- Are we close to squaring the circle of decarbonisation
and competitiveness in Europe?
Keep the door open for CCS. The technology needs to be
demonstrated NOW.
Technology
Demonstration
and Full-Scale
Integration
Business
Case
Low-carbon, competitive
electricity mix
+
Decarbonised industry
Political and
General Public
Support
European Policymakers and industry
must renew their commitment to
demonstrate CCS and make it happen
EURELECTRIC is committed to
“Energy Access for All”
- 1,3 billion people in the world have no access to electricity.
- According to UN & EC, there is a need
of 36 bn euros/year to provide energy
access to all in the world
- Governments can provide 1/6 of this
- The rest will have to come from the
private sector
- EURELECTRIC acts as a facilitator in this
process, together with policy-makers
Content
1. The 2020 & 2030 horizons: which support for RES going
forward?
2. Powering Investment in Europe’s energy sector
3. Europe in a global context
4. Recommendations: Action is needed now!
Content
1. The 2020 & 2030 horizons: which support for RES going
forward?
2. Powering Investment in Europe’s energy sector
3. Europe in a global context
4. Recommendations: Action is needed now!
Recommendations:
Action is needed now!
1. Do not micro-manage the energy sector with multiple, conflicting
policies, instruments and targets.
2. Integrate wholesale electricity markets by 2014
3. Price CO2 correctly and make out of ETS the key driver for Europe’s
decarbonisation
4. Ensure competitive retail markets that put customers at the center
5. Ensure that economic regulation schemes drive investments and
innovation in regulated electricity networks, alongside costefficiency
EURELECTRIC takes its responsibility seriously. We
are committed to innovation.
Our Innovation Action Plan
relies on two work-streams:
1.
Technologies driving change
in the power sector
2.
The methodology needed for
a consistent EU innovation
strategy
Results of our Innovation Action Plan (which includes a Mc Kinsey Study) will be presented
at a high level conference May 14th 2013, in Brussels
Thank you for your attention!
[email protected]
www.eurelectric.org