Case 1:12-cv-02735-MHS Document 114 Filed 10/05/15 Page 1 of 10
)#(Q'(('Q '(&(Q $)&(Q
#$&(&#Q '(&(Q $Q $&Q
(!#(Q *'$#Q
($#,Q '(&
!#Q
%B->DJ>6Q
*!Q ($#Q #$Q
LQ
Q*
"'Q
&& (Q !+#&Q
B1HAQ E2Q EKHJQE2QJ=1Q 'J-J1Q EKHJQ
E2Q M>DD1JJQ EKDJOQ 1EH;>-Q
121D0-DJQ
19H1QJ=1QEKHJQ>IQ0121D0-DJIQCEJ>EDQJEQ-BJ1HQEHQ-C1D0Q@K0;C1DJQ EHQ
J=1Q 9BBEM>D;Q H1-IEDIQ J=1QEKHJQ;H-DJIQ J=1Q CEJ>EDQ
2J1HQE.J->D>D;Q-Q015KBJQ@K0;C1DJQ-;->DIJQFB->DJ>6Q(EDOQ'JH>/AB-D0Q
EDQ-Q/H10>JQ/-H0Q01.JQ ?I/EL1HQ-DAQ >I/EL1HQ8B10Q -Q;-HD>I=C1DJQ-/J?EDQ
>DQ J=1Q 'J-J1Q EKHJQ E2Q M>DD1JJQ EKDJOQ -;->DIJQ %Q "EH;-DQ =-I1Q -DAQ
=-I1Q M=1H1Q FB->DJ>34Q =1B0Q -DQ -//EKDJQ /EDJ->D>D;Q EDBOQ MEHA1HIQ
/ECF1DI-J>EDQ.1D18JIQ BJ=EK;=QIK/=Q.1D18JIQ-H1Q1N1CFJQ:ECQ;-HD>I=C1DJQ
KD01HQ 1EH;?-Q B-MQ =-I1Q :EP1Q FB->DJ>7IQ .-DAQ -//EKDJQ -D0Q IK.I1GK1DJBOQ
F-?0Q J=1Q 2KD0IQ >DJEQ /EKHJQ
Case 1:12-cv-02735-MHS Document 114 Filed 10/05/15 Page 2 of 10
/03$D >/$D . <70=/6$7>D ">087D A =D =>033D :$7#07.D :3 07>0)D +3$#D >/0=D
">087D . 07=>D 0"/ <#D D 3$B 7#$<D 3$<2D 8%D >/$D > >$D 8?<>D 8%D A077$>>D
8?7>CD
35$.07.D >/ >D $8<.0 =D :8=>1?#.6$7>D . <70=/6$7>D => >?>$D A =D
?7"87=>0>?>087 3D 7#D =$$207.D ::<8:<0 >$D#$"3 < >8<CD 7#D 071?7">0@$D<$30$%D
:$"0+" 33CD :3 07>0)D "3 06$#D >/ >D >/$D => >?>$D @083 >$#D #?$D :<8"$==D
<$;?0<$6$7>=D !$" ?=$D 0>D D (03$#D >8D 78>0%CD 1?#.6$7>D #$!>8<=D 8%D @ 03 !3$D
$B$6:>087=D D % 03$#D >8D 78>0-D #$!>8<=D 8%D >/$D :<8"$#?<$D '9<D "3 0607.D
$B$6:>087D
7#D D % 04$#D >8D :<8@0#$D
D >06$5CD :<8"$#?<$D ,<D
7D
#1?#0" >07.D
$B$6:>087D "3 06=D
%>$<D :3 07>0)D+3$#D >/0=D ">087D 0="8@$<D #0=60==$#D >/$D . <70=/6$7>D
">087D 7#D:3 07>0%&=D%?7#=DA$<$D<$>?<7$#D>8D/06D /$D8?<>D>/$7D#0=60==$#D
:3 07>0*=D "3 06=D . 07=>D <D 3$B 7#$<D ,<D 3 "2D 8%D => 7#07.D / >D <?307.D
/8A$@$<DA =D<$@$<=$#D87D ::$ 3D 7#D>/$D"8?<>D8%D ::$ 3=D<$6 7#$#D>/$D" =$D
>8D >/0=D 8?<>D >8D ##<$==D >/$D "87=>0>?>087 3D 0==?$=D D #D D D >/D 0<D D
/$D : <>0$=D +3$#D "<8==68>087=D ,<D
=?66 <CD1?#.6$7>D 7#D>/$D> >$D8%D$8<.0 D07>$<@$7$#D>/<8?./D0>=D>>8<7$CD
$7$< 3D >8D =?::8<>D>/$D "87=>0>?>087 30>CD 8%D >/$D => >?>$D
7D $:>$6!$<D D D >/$D 8?<>D 0==?$#D 7D <#$<D .< 7>07.D :4 07>0*=D
68>087D '9<D =?66 <CD 1?#.6$7>D 7#D #$7C07.D #$%$7# 7>=D 68>087D /$D 8?<>D
Case 1:12-cv-02735-MHS Document 114 Filed 10/05/15 Page 3 of 10
()'7%=)(F):=13%>F;:>?
5@(18)9?F1%=93>28)9?F>?%?@?)F
FEF
F @9':9>?3?@?3:9%7F39>:,=F%>F3?FF*%37>F?:F=)<@3=)F?2%?F5@(18)9?F()&?:=>F
&)F 9:?3.)(F ?2%?F ?2)=)F %=)F ')=?%39F )C)8;?3:9>F @9()=F >?%?)F %9(F -()=%7F 7%BF
B23'2F ?2)F ()&?:=F 8%DF &)F )9?3?7)(F ?:F '7%38F B3?2F =)>;)'?F ?:F ?2)F 1%=93>2)(F
;=:;)=?DF F *%37>F ?:F =)<@3=)F ?2%?F 5@(18)9?F ()&?:=>F &)F 9:?3.)(F :*F ?2)F
;=:')(@=)F?:F '7%38F%9F)C)8;?3:9F %9(F F,37>F?:F ;=:A3()F%F?38)7DF;=:')(@=)F
/=F %(5@(3'%?391F)C)8;?3:9F'7%38>F
=()=F :*F !);?FF F #:'F $F %?F
F "2)F:@=?F)95:39)(F()-9(%9?F7)C%9()=F0:8F3>>@391F%9DF>@88:9>F:*F
1%=93>28)9?F;@=>@%9?F?:F ?2)F)C3>?391F/=8>F %9(F;=:')(@=)>F39>:,=F%>F?2)DF
%=)F 39':9>3>?)9?F B3?2F ?23>F ()'3>3:9F %?F F "2)F 7)=6F )9?)=)(F +49%7F
@(18)9?F #:'F $F 39F%'':=(%9')F B3?2F ?2)F :@=?>F
=()=F
9F!);?)8&)=FF F ()*)9(%9?F7)C%9()=F.7)(F%F8:?3:9F?:F%7?)=F:=F
%8)9(F5@(18)9?F;@=>@%9?F?:F)(F3AF)F )-9(%9?F%>6>F?2)F:@=?F
?:F%7?)=F:=F%8)9(F3?>F =()=F%9(F@(18)9?F:*F!);?)8&)=FFF?:F7383?F?2)3=F
>':;)F %9(F %;;73'%?3:9F ?:F 1%=93>28)9?F %'?3:9>F .7)(F %1%39>?F .9%9'3%7F
39>?3?@?3:9>F2:7(391F%F5@(18)9?F()&?:=>F;=:;)=?DF@9()=F%F();:>3?F%1=))8)9?F
:=F %'':@9?F %9(F ?:F >;)'3.'%77DF )C)8;?F 0:8F ?2)3=F >':;)F %9(F ':A)=%1)F
':9?39@391F B%1)F 1%=93>28)9?F %'?3:9>F .7)(F %1%39>?F %F 5@(18)9?F ()&?:=>F
)8;7:D)=F;@=>@%9?F?:F
FEF
F %>FB)77F%>F>@'2F%'?3:9>F.7)(F
Case 1:12-cv-02735-MHS Document 114 Filed 10/05/15 Page 4 of 10
"(,-3 3 -)+,3 '*&)2+3 -)3 )&&-3 3 $. '(-3 +3 *+")"3 ,.**)+-3 )3 3
'"&23 ''+3 *.+,.(-3 -)3 3
)&&-"/&23
)(-"(."( 3 0 3 +(",!'(-,3
",.,,")(3
((-3)(-(,3-!-3-!3).+-3,!).&3&-+3)+3'(3"-,3++3(3
. '(-3 +3 -0)3 +,)(,3
"+,-3 ((-3 + .,3 -!-3 *&"(-"3 &%,3
,-("( 3 -)3 !&&( 3 -!3 )(,-"-.-")(&"-23 )3 -!3 )(-"(."( 3 0 3
+(",!'(-3*+).+,3,-3).-3"(3
3 (3 .,3 !3 ),3 ()-3 && 3 -!-3 3 )(-"(."( 30 3 +(",!'(-3 0,3
#&3 "(,-3 !",3 '*&)2+3 )(3 ((-3+ .,3-!-3-!3 ).+-3,!).&3
&"'"-3-!3,)*3)3"-,3+.&"( 3-)3 +(",!'(-,3)3(("&3"(,-"-.-")(,3.,3
-!3 *+-",3 "3 ()-3 +,,3 (3 -!3 ).+-3 "3 ()-3 )(,"+3 -!3 -2*3 )3
1'*-")(,3(3 -!3()-"3(3!+"( 3*+).+,3-!-3 **&23 -)3 )(-"(."( 3
0 3 +(",!'(-,3
(3 +,*)(,3 *&"(-"3 + .,3 -!-3 ()3 &-+-")(3 )+3 '('(-3 ",3
(,,+23)+3**+)*+"-3.,3)(-"(."( 30 3 +(",!'(-,3+&23)(3-!3
,'3 ()-"3 (3 1'*-")(3 &"'3 *+).+,3 **&"&3 -)3 +(",!'(-,3 )3
#(("&3 "(,-"-.-")(,3 0!"!3 -!",3 ).+-3 !,3 !&3 -)3 3 .()(,-"-.-")(&3
!+3 ",3 ()3 +,)(3 *&"(-"3)(-(,3 -)3 +3 0 3 1'*-")(,3 (23 &,,3
Case 1:12-cv-02735-MHS Document 114 Filed 10/05/15 Page 5 of 10
>@=B.,B7=<I C<-.@I B6.I -C.I >@=,.AAI AB*<-*@-AI .AB*+:7A6.-I 7<I I#-II-I"7@I IB6*<I.F.;>B7=<AI*>>:7,*+:.IB=I*I-.+B=@AI
>@=>.@BHI6.:-I7<I*I2<*<,7*:I7<AB7BCB7=<I !AI3@IAB*<-7<5I >:*7<B71I*@5C.AIB6*BI
6.I 6*AI AB*<-7<5I B=I ,6*::.<5.I >@=,[email protected] B6*BI *@.I ,=;;=<I B=I *::I >=AB
8C-5;.<BI 5*@<7A6;.<BI >@=,..-7<5AI E6.B6.@I ,=<B7<C7<5I =@I <=BI #7<*::HI
>:*7<B71I *@5C.AI B6*BI [email protected] 7AI <=I =B6.@I ,=;>.::7<5I @.*A=<I B=I .G,.>BI .D.<I
,=<B7<C7<5IE*5.I5*@<7A6;.<BAI3@I0;7:HIAC>>=@BI4=;IB6.I7<8C<,B7=<I+.,*CA.I
AC,6I 5*@<7A6;.<BAI *@.I =<:HI @*@.:HI 7<D=9.-I *<-I [email protected] 7AI *<I *:B.@<*B7D.I
AB*BCB=@HI>@=,[email protected]@I*<I7<,=;.I-.-C,B7=<I=@-.@IC<-.@I&"$!I I
E67,6I [email protected] B6.I A*;.I >C@>=A.I *<-I -=.AI <=BI @*7A.I B6.I A*;.I -C.I >@=,.AAI
,=<,.@<AI
)6.I "=C@BI ,=<,:C-.AI B6*BI 7BAI &@-.@I *<-I %C-5;.<BI =/I (.>B.;+.@I I
I -=I <=BI *>>:HI B=I ,=<B7<C7<5I E*5.I 5*@<7A6;.<BAI
':*7<B71I :*,9.-I
AB*<-7<5I B=I ,6*::.<5.I >=AB8C-5;.<BI 5*@<7A6;.<BI >@=,[email protected] *AI B6=A.I
>@=,[email protected] *>>:HI B=I ,=<B7<C7<5I E*5.I 5*@<7A6;.<BAI )6.I ,=C@BI =/I *>>.*:AI
3C<-I B6*BI >:*7<B71I A*B7A2.-I B6.I 7<8C@H7</*,BI @.?C7@.;.<BI 3@I AB*<-7<5I
+.,*CA.I 7BI 7AI AC+AB*<B7*::HI :79.:HI B6*BI 7BI 7AI A7;>:HI *I ;*BB.@I =/I B7;.I [email protected]
*<=B6.@I8C-5;.<BI ,@.-7B=@I A..9AIB=I5*@<7A6IB6.I ;=<7.AI B6*BIB6.I (B@7,9:*<-AI
6*D.I 7<I *BI :.*ABI =<.I =/I B6.7@I +*<9I *,,=C<BAI I #-I *BI I
Case 1:12-cv-02735-MHS Document 114 Filed 10/05/15 Page 6 of 10
"'. #*)%. ."#'. . ".'%.*&."#.)".'#.&(&'. ''.
'%. *&. ",. ##. ''. . (!"'. %'#%. *#( . . . #"'"(".
*.%"&!"'."&'.$ "'&.!$ #-%. ".'.'.#!$ "'. .
''. $ "'. *&. $%!""' ,. & . ". ''. &. #" ,. &#(%. #. "#!.
*&. # . (%',. & ',. "'&. #!$ . #. 6 456 (&.
$ "'. '%%. . "#. ##. #. ('(%. "(%,. %&". #!. .
#"'"(". *. %"&!"'. .
. &'"". '#. ". '.
#"&''('#" ',.#. '.$%#(%&. #)%"". &(. %"&!"'&.
"'. $#"'&. #('. ''.#"'"(". *. %"&!"'&. (&. '. &!.
"#'. !. ". '%)%&. $%#(%&. &. %"&!"'&. #. "" .
"&''('#"&. #*)%. &. $$ . '#. #"'"(".*.%"&!"'&. '#&.
$%#(%&. %&. %"'. #"&''('#" . &&(&.
#"'"(". *.
%"&!"'&.%.&('.'#.#" ,. !'.+!$'#"&.*.%.&'.#('.".'.
%"&!"'.&''('. *%&.%"&!"'&.#.".")( &.("&. .".
. ". #("'. %. &('. '#. . %#. %". #. % . ". &''. &''('#%,.
+!$'#"&. ''. %. "#*%. "'. ". '. %"&!"'. &''('.
%%. '. &&(. #. *'%. '. %"&!"'. &''('. '& . $%#)&.
622633#66 33633
6 &$6$1$),/'+*.6.$/6+0/6
'*66 26 33#6 6 )'--+-6/&$6%"$-(6$1$),/'+*.6.$/6+0/6'*666
26 6 6!6
6
Case 1:12-cv-02735-MHS Document 114 Filed 10/05/15 Page 7 of 10
',+2 $%+2 %2/#&+%$*2 *2($+2$2+2 %$+/+2%2%$+$,$2.2
($*#$+*2 *2 %#&(2 +%2 ($*#$+*2 %2 $$"2 $*++,+%$*2 *2
**,2 %.-(2 .*2$+(2(*202+2&(+*2$%(2(**202+2 %,(+2
$2+*2*2$%(2%,"2+2-2$2*$2&"$+*2"#*2("+2*%""02+%2+2
($*#$+2%2 2 $!2%,$+2
$2 +%$2 ,*2 +2 ($*#$+2 *++,+2 /&(**"02 /#&+*2 2
&%(+%$2%22+%(*2.*2%#2($*#$+2 +2(*!2++2$2#&"%0(2.""2
((%$%,*"02 .+%"2 /#&+2 .*2 *2 $%+2 +2 *#2 *2 +2 (*!2 ++2 2
$$"2 $*++,+%$2 .2 #02 $%+2 !$%.2 +2 *%,(2 %2 ,$*2 $2 $2
$-,"*2 $!2 %,$+2 .""2 ((%$%,*"02 )12 2 +%(*2 /#&+2 ,$*2
2 (*!2 %2 *,2 $2 ((%$%,*2 &(-+%$2 *2 %$2 +%(2 +2 %,(+2 #,*+2
%$*(2 $2 +(#$$2 +2 (',(#$+*2 %2 ,2 &(%**2
$2 %.-(2 +2(*!2%2$2((%$%,*2
&(-+%$2 $2 2 %$+$,$2 .2 ($*#$+2 .*2 $+(2 (*2 02 +2
&(+*2 $%(2 (**2 02 +2 %,(+2 $2 +*2 *2 ,*2 &"$+2 .*2 $%+2
+(+$2.+2*,2 2($*#$+2
"$+2 +*2 %+(2 **2 ++2 -2 ,$2 +2 *#2 %$*++,+%$"2
+*2$2.2($*#$+2*++,+*2++2+*2%,(+2,$2$2
%(*2&%*+
,#$+2($*#$+2*++,+2 2($2 %.-(2 *2 ++2+%*2**2
Case 1:12-cv-02735-MHS Document 114 Filed 10/05/15 Page 8 of 10
-;;I7=D>;D10I?;-8=B83AIE6>I6-0IAB-=08=5IB>I/6-;;1=51IE-51I5-@=8A6<1=BAI -=0I
B61I />C@BI -00@1AA10I B61I 0C1I ?@>/1AAI 8AAC1AI 8=I B61I />=B1FBI >2I AC/6I
5-@=7A6<1=BAI #!## !## # #"# I ) +C??I I
I %I#@7HI !I ### I ) +C??I I I$%I ';;I
"I # # "# I ) +C??I I I (%I (,I "I #
## I ) +C??I I I &%I#@:I "I # # #
## # ### I ) +C??I I I %I %1;I I
*;-8=B83I-;A>I/8B1AIB61I08AB@8/BI/>C@BAI01/8A7>=I8=I## # I
) +C??I I +%I )67>I I 8=IAC??>@BI >2I 67AI -@5C<1=BI B6-BI ?-ABI /-A1AI
6-D1I .@>-0;GI 1=9>8=10I B61I CA1I >2I C=/>=AB8BCB8>=-;I ?@>/10C@1AI 7=I ?>AB
9C05<1=BI 5-@=8A6<1=BI -/B8>=AI
# 6>E1D1@
I -/BC-;;GI AC??>@BAI
0121=0-=BAI -@5C<1=BI '=I B6-BI /-A1
I E68/6I 8=D>;D10I -I /6-;;1=51I B>I )68>AI
?>AB9C05<1=BI AB-BCB>@GI ?@>/10C@1I 4@I 1F1/CB8>=I >=I ?1@A>=-;I ?@>?1@BG
I B61I
/>C@BI1F?@1AA;GIAB-B10IB6-BI8BAI5@-=BI>2I01/;-@-B>@GI@1;812I 8<?;81AI=>I>?8=7>=I
E8B6I@1A?1/BIB>I)68>AIAB-BCB>@GI?@>D8A8>=AI4@I?>AB9C05<1=BI5-@=7A6<1=BI>2I
E-51AI>@I1F1/CB8>=I-5-8=ABI;-=0I-=0IB1=1<1=BA
IE68/6I-@1I=>BI.14@1I7BI I
) +C??I-BII =I '=I .>B6I>2I B61I >B61@I /-A1AI /8B10I.GI?;-8=B83I7=I AC??>@BI
"$)#) #) #%&#) &#)%) '')!&%) !%!)
%)#%&%) !#%) )(#
)
Case 1:12-cv-02735-MHS Document 114 Filed 10/05/15 Page 9 of 10
C2QJ9:IQ,H7KA0BJQBCQ:IIK0QM,IQH,:I0/QH07,H/:B7QJ90QEHCE0HQI.CE0QC2QJ90QH0?:02Q
7H,BJ0/Q Q /Q Q Q IJQ:HQ Q .?0H>Q
0NEH0II0/QM:??:B7B0IIQJCQ6??CMQJ90Q.CKHJIQ:B<KB.J:CBQ QQ(KEEQ,JQ
QI,A0Q
)CQ-0Q.?0,HQ J90QCKHJQ:IQBCJQ9C?/:B7QJ9,JQ 0CH7:,IQBCJ:.0Q,B/Q90,H:B7Q
EHC.0/KH0IQ,IQ,EE?:0/QJCQ.CBJ:BK:B7QM,70Q7,HB:I9A0BJIQ ,H0Q.CBIJ:JKJ:CB,?Q
!BIJ0,/Q J90QCKHJQ:IQ9C?/:B7QJ9,JQJ90Q :IIK0QC2QJ90Q .CBIJ:JKJ:CB,?:JOQC2QIK.9Q
EHC.0/KH0IQ:BQJ90Q.CBJ0NJQC2Q.CBJ:BK:B7QM,70Q7,HB:I9A0BJIQM,IQBCJQH,:I0/Q
,B/Q.CK?/QBCJQ9,L0Q-00BQH,:I0/Q :BQJ9:IQ.,I0
Q )90H06H0Q J90QCKHJIQHK?:B7Q
/:/QBCJQ,//H0IIQJ9,JQ:IIK0Q ,B/QJ90QCKHJQ0NEH0II0IQBCQCE:B:CBQCBQ:JQ
CHQJ90Q3DH07C:B7QH0,ICBIQ J90QCKHJQ '%)(Q/031B/,BJIQACJ;CBQJCQ
,?J0HQCHQ,A0B/Q<K/7A0BJQ*C.Q+Q )90Q&H/0HQ,B/Q"K/7A0BJQC2Q(0EJ0A-0HQ
Q Q *C.IQ Q +Q ,H0Q 90H0-OQ $%Q -OQ ,//:B7Q J90Q 6@@CM:B7Q
KB/0H?:B0/Q?,B7K,70Q )90QCKHJQ#'(QJ9,JQ 0CH7:,IQECIJ<K/7A0BJQ
7,HB:I9A0BJQIJ,JKJ0Q & Q Q ,IQ
,.J:CBIQ 5?0/Q
KB/0HQ,Q
,Q 5B,B.:,?Q :BIJ:JKJ:CBQ
CHQ
JCQ
,Q
/0-JCHIQ
:IQKB.CBIJ:JKJ:CB,?Q:BIC4HQ,IQ
:JQQ2,:?IQJCQH0GK:H0QJ9,JQ<K/7A0BJQ/0-JCHIQ-0QBCJ:50/QJ9,JQJ90H0Q,H0Q.0HJ,:BQ
Case 1:12-cv-02735-MHS Document 114 Filed 10/05/15 Page 10 of 10
8,/4'.-3;5-2;344;-;2+;+7;7&'&;4&;4.2;,9;;-4'4+;4.;
+',; 7'4&; 23/4; 4.; 4&; $2-'3&; /2./249;
'+3; 4.; 215'2; 4&4;
)5$,-4; 4.23; ; -.4'!; .; 4&; /2.52; 4.; +',; -; 8,/4'.-; -;
'+3;4.;/2.6';;4',+9;/2.52;"2;)5'4'-$;8,/4'.-;+',3; &;
.524; ; --4; +8-2; #.,; '335'-$; -9; 35,,.-3; .;
$2-'3&,-4; '-;
;
4'.-3; !+;
4.23;
; (--'+; '-34'454'.-;
5-2; ;
.2;.5-4;
/5235-4; 4.; 4&; 8'34'-$; "2,3; -; /2.523; '-3.
'-.-3'34-4;7'4&;4&'3;'3'.-; &'3;
-.4;
!+;
; ;;
; 4&'3;
.;
-;
4.;
4.; ;
2; 3; 4&9; 2;
;
-; 4.23;
9;.; 4.2; 26'-; &..; -'.2; 5$;
-'4; 443; '342'4; .524;
.24&2-;
'342'4; .; .2$';