Week 6 it this - KEATS

King’s College London Pre-Sessional Programme
Cohesion: It and This
Task 1
Look at these three examples and answer the questions that follow.
(i)
IT/THIS
Culture is a difficult word to define because it is a concept which means different things
to different people.
(ii)
Members of different cultural groupings are moving from one country to another. This
results in cultural intermingling.
(iii)
1.
As a result, it becomes increasingly difficult to identify the “ethnic” core of a culture due
to cultural contamination.
QUESTIONS
What does ‘it’ in sentence (i) refer to?
2.
What does ‘this’ in sentence (ii) refer to?
3.
What does ‘it’ in sentence (iii) refer to?
4.
In which sentence does ‘it’ refer forwards and in which sentence does ‘it’ refer
backwards?
Task 2
Now consider sentence 1 and the sets of sentences that follow. Which of the sentences in
each set make better sense as a follow-up? Why?
The amount of rain the Midwest received in spring was much heavier than usual…
FOLLOW-UP SENTENCES
a. In fact it was the second heaviest on record.
b. In fact, this was the second heaviest on record.
c. In fact, it was even heavier than the amount of rain recorded in 1999.
d. In fact, this was heavier than the amount of rain recorded in 1999.
e. It has led to huge losses.
f. This has led to huge losses.
g. This may be connected to increasing destruction of wetlands.
h. It may be connected to increasing destruction of wetlands.
1
Task 3
Consider the following sentences and questions, then read the notes that follow:
THIS + SUMMARY WORD
1.
ESL lecturers know students need to understand the differences between formal and
informal language. However, this understanding cannot usually be acquired quickly.
 What does ‘this understanding’ refer to?
2.
The students said they wanted more tests. This request surprised the authorities.
 What does ‘this request’ refer to?
 What other nouns could have been used instead of ‘request’? Would this
change the meaning of the sentence?
3.
In recent years, the number of students applying to PhD programmes has increased
steadily, while the number of places available has remained constant. This situation has
resulted in intense competition for admission.

 What does ‘this situation’ refer to? What is the effect of using ‘this’ instead
of ‘that’?
NOTES
‘This + summary word’ refers back to the idea in the previous sentence – it summarises what
has already been said and picks up where the previous sentence has left off. Choosing a
summary noun to follow a sentence-initial ‘this’ is an empowering device for writers. It
enables them to communicate to the reader how the previous sentence is being interpreted.

‘This’ may be unsupported (i.e. on its own), but bear in mind that if there is a possibility that
your reader will not understand what ‘this’ is referring to, your best strategy is to follow ‘this’
with a noun so that your meaning is clear.

Summary words may be expanded into phrases to add clarity. However, long and
complicated summary phrases may be unnecessary.
2
Task 4
Choose a summary word from the list below to complete each sentence. Can you think of
other possible summary words in addition to those on the list?
Process
difficulty
situation
disruption
finding
estimation
view
problem
situation
1. The traditional economic and consumer behavior models assume a rational, thoughtful
consumer who gathers information about a good and then carefully makes a purchase. This
_____________ has recently been challenged, particularly because of the growing number of
consumer choices.
2. Our pilot study has shown that wind turbines used to generate electricity can pose a threat to
flying birds. This ______________ suggests a need for further research on improving the safety
of those mechanisms.
3. In soccer, goalkeepers routinely wear gloves that may restrict heat loss from that hand and cause
discomfort. In order to alleviate this ______________, special material, called phase control
materials (PCMs), have been incorporated into gloves to reduce the amount of heat inside the
gloves, thus maintaining a comfortable temperature.
4. Normal average human skin temperature is 37°C. At any lower environmental temperature, heat
will be lost from the skin to the environment as the body attempts to heat up the air in direct
contact with the body. This ______________ is known as conduction.
5. Until adjustment of the body clock has occurred, individuals suffering from ‘jet lag’ feel tired
during the new daytime, yet are unable to sleep properly during the new night. For athletes in
particular this _______________ of sleep can affect mood and powers of concentration and
might result in poorer training performances and competition results (Reilly et al, 1997b).
6. Until recently, the support needs of frail older people in Sweden have been met primarily by the
state, with there being little expectation that the family would provide care. This
________________ is now changing as increasing emphasis is being placed on the role of the
family.
From: Swales and Feak (2004) Academic Writing for Graduate Students (2nd Edition)
3
Task 5
Read the following text and insert the word it or this where appropriate. Decide if the word
is referring forwards or backwards.
During university, working as part of a group and submitting group work to be
formally assessed, is common within certain disciplines. ______ may require group
presentations or the compilation of group reports. Having to work closely with
others may not be something you are used to at the moment although at university
______ may become an everyday experience. ______ is a reflection of organisation
life, as employees have to rely on others to provide them with information in order to
be able to carry out their duties. The overwhelming reason for the use of groups in
organisations is that they improve performance and ______ is why ______ is
necessary to understand the intricacies of group work.
Some students do not like certain aspects of group work. Occasionally, for example,
frustration occurs because less effective group members are diluting individual effort.
______ is important to come to terms with group work as groups are a fact of
student and organisational life. A greater knowledge and understanding of how
groups operate leads to increased effectiveness as a group member, both in student
life and subsequently as an employee. As well as being a fact of student life, groups
are the ‘building blocks’ of organisations, Organisations require group work in
project groups or teams to complete tasks. ______ is possible that ______ will occur
at university in the form of assessments to be completed as part of the course.
Text extracts adapted from: Payne E & Whittaker, L. (2000) Developing Essential Study Skills, London Prentice Hall
4
Task 6
Read the following sentences taken from the same text and insert it or this in each.
MORE PRACTICE WITH IT/THIS
1. When working in groups at university or college, the group will need to utilise group
cohesiveness productively, but ______ is essential to avoid the negative aspects of too much
cohesiveness.
2. A group will have a number of members, some form of structure, a purpose or goal, and
other relatively fixed factors such as the times when ______ meets. ______ will also have a
task to complete, for example to produce a product. In university or college, ______ is
likely to be an assessment.
3. The group will need to deal with how the members interact together. ______ is called group
dynamics and some assessments may require reflection about and analysis of ______ aspect
of group work.
4. Group dynamics is frequently ignored even though ______ can be the major cause of
ineffective group working. ______ is important, therefore, for students to learn to be
sensitive to the aspects of group process.
5. Group synergy is when the output of the group effort is more than the sum of the individual
parts. An example of ______ is team sports.
6. Whenever people work together on a common goal, roles emerge and ______ will occur in
student groups.
7. In some instances _______ may be a requirement to analyse the relationships between the
various students in a group. ______ may also be necessary to compare the way a group
works using a particular group model and to discuss the efficiency and effectiveness of the
group as ______ completes the set task.
8. Organisation or structure:
______ applies to certain aspects such as procedures, rules, particular tasks for individual
students or the way the group operates in making decisions.
9. Norms always exist even if ______ is not possible to identify them.
10. However, ______ is possible to influence how the group operates.
11. Individuals may not be satisfied with the progress being made in completing the set task.
______ will eventually and inevitably result in conflict about the leadership.
12. For the group to work together well, some form of conflict resolution is necessary. ______
is likely to require the intervention of those students who adopt group maintenance roles
such as mediator and peace-maker.
5
Task 7
Using the reference words to help you, order the following sentences to make a cohesive
text.
PARAGRAPH COHESION
a. Taking this as the definition was to argue that the working class had no culture.
b. The main problem is its association with notions of social class.
c. This period is recognised as the starting point for modern ‘Cultural Studies’.
d. Culture is generally agreed to be one of the most difficult words to define in the English
language.
e. This can be traced back to the Victorian era when culture started to be taken seriously and the
term was synonymous with ‘high culture’ i.e. arts enjoyed by the upper and middle classes.
f. In particular, it was argued that working class culture did exist, and was every bit as valid as that
of the upper/middle class.
g. By the 1960s a new view emerged, defining culture as ‘a way of life’, concentrating on the way
different communities of people behaved.
h. As such, it was defined through ‘classical’ notions of literature and art.
Text extract taken from: Roger Sabin 1997 Cultural Studies Reader University of Arts London
6