목
차
1
규제요건
2
수행일정 및 계획
3
수행절차
4
운전조건샘플링
5
세부 시나리오
6
평가 항목 및 결과
7
해외 프로젝트 18장 인허가 대응 경험
1. 규제요건
1) FANR Regulation
 FANR-REG-03 Article 35(4)
Verification and validation of aspects of human factors
shall be included at appropriate stages to confirm that the
Design adequately accommodates all necessary operating
personnel actions.
2) NUREG-0711
 Rev 0: Chapter 11 Element 10 – HFE V&V (적용)
 Rev 2: Chapter 11 – HFE V&V (반영)
3) NUREG/CR-6393: Integrated System Validation (Methodology
and Review Criteria) (반영)
•
•
•
FANR: Federal Authority for Nuclear Regulation
FANR-REG-03: Regulation for the Design of Nuclear Power Plants
FANR-REG-03 Article 35: Human Factors – Design for Optimal Operating Personnel
Performance
1
2. 수행일정 및 계획
항목
수행 일정
수행 여부
1차 사전검사
2015년 6월 (1주일)
완료
(Barakah simulator #2)
2차 사전검사
2015년 11월 (1주일)
완료
(Barakah simulator #2)
통합시스템검증
2016년 1월~2월 (6주)
완료
(Barakah simulator #2)
최종발전소확인
2016년 11월말
수행 예정
(Barakah site)
2
3. 수행절차
Plant Operational
Conditions
Simulator
Performance Measurement
Tools
- Situation Awareness (SART)
- Workload (NASA-TLX)
- Communication (BARS)
- etc.
Step 2
Develop
ISV Scenarios
Step 4
Pilot Testing
Unresolved
findings
Step1
Sampling of Operational
Conditions
Step 5
Findings &
Resolution
Resolved
Step 6
Perform ISV
Step 7
Debrief
after ISV
Step 8
HED findings &
Resolution
Step 9
Document ISV results in
HFE V&V Report
3
FANR
Issues
Step 3
Develop
Subjective
Questionnaire
3. 수행절차 (계속)
PRA/HRA
Paper Procedures
(GOP, EOP etc.)
Computerized Procedures
(GOP, EOP etc.)
Plant Crew
for Pilot Test
MMI Designs
COAs
Performance
Measure Tools
Operating
Condition
Sampling
Full Scope
Simulator
Simulator
Instructor and
Support Staff
Pilot Test
Overview of
Scenarios for ISV
Plant Crews
for ISV
Detailed Scenarios
for ISV
HFE V&V
Execution
4
4. 운전조건샘플링
5
5. 세부 시나리오
6
6. 평가 항목 및 결과
Performance
Measures
No.
Types of Data
1
System Performances
- Primary Tasks (Crew errors)
- COAs
- Major Plant Variables
-
2
Situation Awareness
Questionnaire (SART)
3
Workload
Questionnaire (NASA_TLX)
4
Crew Communication and
Coordination
Questionnaire (BARS)
5
Anthropometric & Physiological
Issues
Questionnaire
7
Observation
Simulator log data
Task completion time
6. 평가 항목 및 결과 (계속)
Primary Tasks (예시: 시나리오 3)
8
6. 평가 항목 및 결과 (계속)
Major Process Variables (예시: 시나리오 3)
9
6. 평가 항목 및 결과 (계속)
Task Completion Time (예시: 시나리오 3)
10
6. 평가 항목 및 결과 (계속)
Situation Awareness (예시)
Workload (예시)
11
7. 해외 프로젝트 18장 인허가 대응 경험
Sections
18.1
•
•
•
•
PSAR
RAI (개수)
46
FSAR
RAI (개수)
FSAR RAI 특징
31
-
Training (2)
HFE V&V (17)
Culture (1), Staffing (1)
기타 항목(10)
Display (3)
Soft Control (2)
Alarm (2)
SPADES+(3)
18.2
26
10
-
18.3
7
2
- Staffing (1)
- Soft Control (1)
합계
79
43
PSAR: Preliminary Safety Analysis Report
FSAR: Final Safety Analysis Report
RAI: Request for Additional Information
SPADES+: Safety Parameter And Display Evaluation System +
12
THANK YOU !!!