160928 – SUMMIT 2016 DAY 2 – BREAKOUT SESSION
CROPS FOR PROCESSING
Towardsonesetof
goodagricultural
practicesforsafefood
producedsustainably
September2016,GlobalGAPSummitAmsterdam
Thejourney
1.Theambition
2.Theconfusion
3.Thesolution
2
160928 – SUMMIT 2016 DAY 2 – BREAKOUT SESSION
CROPS FOR PROCESSING
1
Theambition
Pilar1oftheDecAD:
• Showcaseanexampleofcollaboration,thatitdoableto
mergetwo‘checklists’anderadicatetheoverlap
SAIPlatformFSA
GlobalGAP IFA(5)
4
160928 – SUMMIT 2016 DAY 2 – BREAKOUT SESSION
CROPS FOR PROCESSING
Pilar1oftheDecAD:
• Showcaseanexampleofcollaboration,thatitdoableto
mergetwo‘checklists’anderadicatetheoverlap....
SAIPlatformFSA
GlobalGAP IFA(5)
5
EXTRAcomplexity:CropsforProcessing
Therewasasecondchallengeinparallel:
• IFAforfreshà IFAforprocessed
Thiseffortwasgivenpriority....Butnowwehaverestarted
thebenchmarkingprocess
6
160928 – SUMMIT 2016 DAY 2 – BREAKOUT SESSION
CROPS FOR PROCESSING
Fourneeds,fourscenario’s(1)
7
Fourneeds,fourscenario’s(2)
8
160928 – SUMMIT 2016 DAY 2 – BREAKOUT SESSION
CROPS FOR PROCESSING
‘Benchmarking’,asimplebuzzwordbuta
tremendouschallengeinpractice!
• Twomulticriteriachecklists
• Howtocomparewhat?
• StartwithStandardsmap +anexpert.....andconclude:
Xcriteriaare
identical
Zcriteria????
Unclear,
Wider/Narrower,
More/lessprecise,
Combined,
.......
Ycriteriamissing
9
2
Theconfusion
160928 – SUMMIT 2016 DAY 2 – BREAKOUT SESSION
CROPS FOR PROCESSING
Zoomingin...
• Aretheythesame?
• IsAgoodenoughtocoverP?(andviseversa?)
• Areyouwillingtoacceptaminordifference(shortcoming)?
• Ifweaccept,whatliabilityorprecedentdowecreateto
otherbenchmarks?
‘Our’
Criterium P
‘Their’
Criterium
A
n
11
Talk,communicateandexplain....
• Contacttheotherschemeandfindtherightpersons....
• Gaintrustandwillingnesstoinvesttimeandenergyforthe
benchmarking
• Discuss(inaphysicalmeeting)thecriticalquestionsonebyone:
• Discoverdifferencesininterpretation,inscopeofthescheme,in
intentionandwaytocombinecertainissues.
• Gobackandoverseetheconsequencesbeyondthebenchmark
• Agreeandconclude
• Proposetosubsidiariesandexplainchoices/tradeoffs
• Getapproval(from2sides)
• Startoveragainwhenoneoftheschemeschanges.....
12
160928 – SUMMIT 2016 DAY 2 – BREAKOUT SESSION
CROPS FOR PROCESSING
3
Thesolution
Trustandcommoninterest
• Stepbystep:IFAforprocessesfirstandnowFSA-IFA
integration
• Transparency:1)understand/mobilizetheusersneeds,
prototypingandtestingand2)foruserstounderstandthe
complexdevelopmentprocessofharmonization
• Inthefuture:trytoavoiddivergingsystemsattheroot(No
addedvalue!Foranyone!)
• Inthefuture(2):jointlydevelopatheoryofchange
14
160928 – SUMMIT 2016 DAY 2 – BREAKOUT SESSION
CROPS FOR PROCESSING
Themovementofthewingofabutterfly,can
causeastorm......
Thankyou!