MULTIPLE CRITERIA
DECISION MAKING
Return to: [email protected]
Referee’s report form
Title: ...............................................................................................................................
Please rate all the following statements giving the overall recommendation about the paper (mark an
appropriate cell with “X”):
Poor
Below
Average Good
Very
average
good
1. The author is familiar with the MCDM state
of the art
2. The content fits the scope of the journal
3. It is a new and original contribution
4. The title is adequate to the paper’s content
5. The paper’s content is logical and
technically correct
6. The writing style and language is
grammatically correct and understandable
7. The paper presents a sufficient and indepth information
8. The references are adequate
9. An overall rating of this paper in
comparison to other similar papers
Overall recommendations:
Accept without changes
Minor revisions required:
I want to see the paper again after revisions are done
Major revisions required:
I will review the revised version of this paper
New version must be submitted
Confidential comment to the Editorial Board:
Comments and suggestion for Author(s):