NR 58 ANT ROP OM OT OR YK A 2012 REACTIONS OF THE CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM DURING PHYSICAL EDUCATION CLASSES IN FIRST GRADE PRIMARY SCHOOL CHILDREN REAKCJE UKŁADU KRĄŻENIA W CZASIE LEKCJI WYCHOWANIA FIZYCZNEGO U UCZNIÓW PIERWSZEJ KLASY SZKOŁY PODSTAWOWEJ Paweł Chmura*, Andrzej Rokita**, Marek Popowczak***, Ireneusz Cichy**** **** MA, assistant, Faculty of Team Sports Games of University School of Physical Education in Wroclaw, Poland **** Professor, PhD, manager, Faculty of Team Sports Games of University School of Physical Education in Wroclaw, Poland ***** PhD, lecturer, Faculty of Team Sports Games of University School of Physical Education in Wroclaw, Poland ***** PhD, lecturer, Faculty of Team Sports Games of University School of Physical Education in Wroclaw, Poland Key words: early school education, physical activity, heart rate, effort intensity, Polar Team 2 System Słowa kluczowe: edukacja wczesnoszkolna, aktywność fizyczna, częstość akcji serca, intensywność wysiłku, Polar Team 2 System SUMMARY • STRESZCZENIE Aim of the study. Our study was aimed at the analysis of heart rate in school children aged 7 years in connection with the reaction of the circulatory system to running games employed during physical education classes. Material and methods. Our research was comprised of a group of 100 pupils aged 7 years attending first grade in primary school. During physical education classes, we registered heart rate by means of the Team 2 System of the Polar Company. Five subsequent games of a running nature were introduced. Between the particular games, there was a 1-minute break each time for regeneration. Prior to the research, written consent of the participants’ parents was obtained. All the children had valid current medical certificates. Results. The maximum average heart rate, amounting to 192.2 ± 14.5 beat/min, was observed during the 15th minute of the physical education class. In the cross-section of the first 3 games, we observed a significant increase (P ≤ 0.001) of heart rate in relation to the rest value. The applied physical load in the next 2 games brought about a decrease of the studied index. The lowest average heart rate, amounting to 142.6 ± 16.8 beat/ min, was registered during the break between the third and the fourth games. Conclusions. The conducted research showed a large changeability of intensity of effort during the implementation of the particular running games. This was proven by the sinusoidal course of heart rate. The highest average value of heart rate occurred during the third game, which can indicate the maximum stimulation of the cardiovascular system. The recreation processes after the first 3 running games are similar to one another, but after the completion of the fourth one they distinctly slow down, which may indicate the growing fatigue of the participants. Cel pracy. Analiza częstości skurczów serca u siedmioletnich dzieci, jako reakcja układu krążenia na zabawy ruchowe o charakterze bieżnym w czasie zajęć z wychowania fizycznego. – 57 – Paweł Chmura, Andrzej Rokita, Marek Popowczak, Ireneusz Cichy Materiał i metody. Badaniem objęto grupę 100 siedmiolatków, uczniów pierwszej klasy szkoły podstawowej. W trakcie zajęć z wychowania fizycznego rejestrowano częstość skurczów serca za pomocą urządzenia Polar Team 2 System firmy Polar w czasie pięciu kolejnych zabaw o charakterze bieżnym. Po każdej zabawie zastosowano 1-minutową przerwę w celu regeneracji organizmu. Badanie poprzedziło uzyskanie pisemnej zgody rodziców uczestniczących w nim dzieci. Wszyscy uczniowie mieli również aktualne zaświadczenia lekarskie. Wyniki. Maksymalną średnią częstość skurczów serca, czyli 192,2 ± 14,5 uderzeń/min, stwierdzono w piętnastej minucie zajęć. Podczas pierwszych 3 gier odnotowano znaczący wzrost (P ≤ 0,001) skurczów serca w stosunku do wartości spoczynkowej. Zastosowane obciążenia fizyczne w kolejnych dwu zabawach spowodowały spadek badanego parametru. Najniższą średnią częstość skurczów serca, tj. 142,6 ± 16,8 uderzeń/min, zarejestrowano podczas przerwy między trzecią i czwartą zabawą. Wnioski. Przeprowadzone badania wykazały dużą zmienność intensywności wysiłku w czasie poszczególnych zabaw o charakterze bieżnym. Świadczy o tym sinusoidalny przebieg zmian częstości skurczów serca uczestników badania. Najwyższą średnią wartość uderzeń serca odnotowano w trzeciej zabawie, co może wskazywać na maksymalną stymulację układu sercowo-naczyniowego. Tempo procesów regeneracyjnych po pierwszych trzech zabawach o charakterze bieżnym było do siebie podobne, ale po zakończeniu czwartej zabawy bieżnej zachodziło wyraźnie wolniej, to zaś mogłoby świadczyć o rosnącym zmęczeniu uczestników. Introduction In our times, human beings attach more and more significance to being healthy and competent for a long time. More and more frequently we appreciate physical activity as an indispensable element influencing the quality of our lives. Those of us who on a regular basis improve fitness by swimming, running, or practicing other sports have fewer health problems. Also, our level of self-assessment is higher, we look positively into the future, and we are happier than other persons of the same age. It seems that the formation of appropriate physical habits at a young age shall pay off in older age. Parents want their children to develop well. The recent dynamic developments of modern technologies and computerization of virtually every domain of life contributes to the fact that especially children and young people spend more and more time in front of TVs or computers, much more than the amount of time they devote to active relaxation in the open air. On the one hand, it can result in unattractive forms of spending free time as proposed by the parents, while on the other hand, there is little interest in developing physical activity and formation of appropriate pro-health customs. This is also connected to the fact that kindergartens and schools are attended by children whose physical skills are much worse than several years ago. Additionally, children’s activity is adversely influenced by sedentary behavior and their need for spontaneous movement, which decreases with age. In accordance with new criteria, school children and youth ought to engage in moderate and high intensity effort exercise for 60 minutes per day in a form that is adjusted to their developmental stage and that is diverse and constitutes a source of joy [1]. Results of research by Przewęda and Dobosz [2] carried out in the years 1979–1999 in numerous groups of children and youth (aged 7.5–19.5 years) in Poland indicate a visible regress of physical fitness and physical efficiency with youth. In an attempt to prevent this phenomenon from developing and to make children attending first grades in the integrated education better absorb new information in the educational process, we employed the research project “Educational balls – edubal,” by Rokita and Rzepa. Based on this project, the University School of Physical Education in Wrocław introduced classes aimed at familiarizing future teachers with educational balls. These balls contribute to the development of children’s skills in the scope of simple mathematical operations and basic issues of the Polish language. They teach how to apply the acquired knowledge in practice, think creatively, and they also motivate youth to engage in physical activity [3, 4]. Play (including playing with balls) accompanies a human being beginning in early childhood. It does not only add colour to life, but also introduces joy, relaxation, and motivates one to make an effort. It also supports the general physical and mental development of a child and triggers his/her spontaneous activity. As early as during early school education, i.e. in grades I–III, we can observe diverse behavior in children. Some of them are eager to cooperate and actively seek partners to play with. Some do not show any initiative and passively look at other children. Borecka-Biernat and Węgłowska-Rzepa [5] determined and described styles of functioning in a group, i.e. managing style, cooperating style, subordinating style, withdrawing style and destructive style, as relatively constant behaviors of persons during the performance of mobile activities. – 58 – Reactions of the cardiovascular system during physical education classes in first grade primary school children School education ought to ensure the extensive development of a child by carrying out tasks in the scope of acquisition of knowledge and skills in a harmonious and comprehensive way. Is this so in reality? In this study we shall attempt to answer a few key questions. This study was aimed at analyzing heart rate in first grade primary school children in connection with the reaction of the circulatory system on running games employed during physical education classes as well as answering the following questions: 1. What is the reaction of the cardiovascular system to the applied running games? 2. What is the maximum heart rate reached by children during the particular games? 3. What is the dynamics of restitution processes upon completion of each running game? Research material Our research comprised a group of 100 pupils attending first grades of the following primary schools: Primary School No. 1 and Primary School No. 2 in Wołów. The children participated in physical education classes in accordance with the class scenario previously agreed upon by the teacher. The participants were aged 7 years (born in 2003). Their body weight ranged from 18 kg to 45 kg, and their height ranged from 114 cm to 143 cm. Prior to the research, written consent of the participants’ parents was obtained. All the children had valid current medical certificates. Research method During physical education classes we registered heart rate by means of the Team 2 System of the Polar Company. Recording the data from all the transmitters took place wirelessly and in real time to the base station from which the information was recorded on the computer upon completion of the class. The class time was 45 minutes; however, due to organizational issues – special belts had to be put on each child with the purpose of transmitting activity potentials of heart rate – the effective time of measuring the effort intensity was 27 minutes. The project, which assumed the realization of pilot research, took place every month from September 2010 through February 2011 (before the research proper, the same class scenario was conducted 6 times). During the first class, an employee of the University School of Physical explained the previously agreed upon class scenario to the children and the particular class tutors. The program of a lesson unit comprised 5 running games, and it was consistent with the principles of lesson plans. The research proper was carried out in March 2011. Course of research The research examinations were started with a 3-minute measurement of heart rate at rest in a cross-legged squat position. The lowest value of the examined index was taken for the analysis. Each part of the class was started by the teacher with introductory exercises: a 1-minute trot around the classroom and 1 minute of gymnastics performed in the same place. Next, 5 subsequent games of a running nature were introduced, i.e. Little Tail, Avalanche Tag, Bewitched Tag, Tag with Ball, Tag in Pairs [6]. Each game lasted 3 minutes. After the first, second, third and fourth games were completed, there was a 1-minute break each time during which the teacher explained the rules of the next game. In the last part of the class scenario, which lasted 3 minutes, the monitored children performed breathing exercises while marching and, afterwards, while sitting. The registered research results were subject to basic mathematical and statistical analysis that determined arithmetical mean, standard deviation, as well as minimum and maximum values. Research results During the first 3 minutes of the physical education class, the lowest average value of heart rate was 103.3 ± 13.0 (Figure 1). At the initial part, we registered during the trot the significant (P ≤ 0.001) increase of HR to the value of 176.9 ± 16.5 beat/min, and then during the gymnastic exercises there was a decline to 143.9 ± 17.6. During the main part – when the running play character of the class was realized – we observed a large changeability of cardiac muscle work. In the cross section of the first 3 games we noticed a significant increase (P ≤ 0.001) of heart rate in relation to the rest value. Towards the end of the first game, “Tag Little Tail,” the examined variable amounted to 187.0 ± 16.1; in the second one, “Tag Avalanche,” it was 189.1 ± 17.5; in the third one, “Tag Bewitched,” 190.7 ± 15.1. The maximum mean value of HR, 192.2 ± 14.5, was observed during the second minute of the third game. The highest HR max amounted to 215 beat/min, and the lowest 144 beat/min. The physical load applied in the next 2 games brought about a de- – 59 – Paweł Chmura, Andrzej Rokita, Marek Popowczak, Ireneusz Cichy 200 190 180 Breathing exercises ‘Tag in pairs’ Break ‘Tag with ball’ Break Tag ‘Bewiched’ 120 Break 130 Tag ‘Avalanche’ 140 Break 150 Tag ‘Little Tail’ Trot + Gymnastics 160 Rest Heart rate [beat/min] 170 110 100 0 0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24 27 Time [min] Figure 1. Mean values of heart rate during the conducted physical class scenario crease of the examined index. During the fourth running game, “Tag with Ball,” we observed a constant decrease of heart rate, which at the end of the game was 176.4 ± 21.1. The difference of the mean value of HR between the first and the third minute oscillated around 8.0 beat/ min and was statistically insignificant. The mean values of heart rate observed during the last minute of the third and fourth game varied; this difference was statistically significant (P ≤ 0.001). The reaction of the cardiovascular system to the load resulting from the implementation of the last game, “Tag in Pairs,” oscillated from 181.8 ± 18.5 (during the first minute) to 185.1 ± 18.4 (during the third minute). The difference between the maximum heart rate in the third game and the same variable in the last fifth game was 7.1 beat/min and was statistically insignificant. Similarly, the difference between the mean value of HR during the first and the last game was also statistically insignificant. Upon completion of each game, a heart rate frequency decreased and oscillated from 142.6 ± 16.8 after the third game to 154.0 ± 12.8 after the fourth game. The greatest decrease of the examined variable, which was observed after the third game, was as high as 48.1 beat/min; the lowest was observed after the fourth game, 22.5 beat/min (Figure 1). The analysis of the final part of the implemented physical education class scenario showed a statistically significant (P ≤ 0.001) decrease of a heart rate in the cross section of a 3-minute regeneration process from 185.1 ± 18.4 beat/min after the fifth game to 123.9 ± 13.2 beat/min. During the last minute of the final part the diversity of the examined index oscillated from 62 beat/min to 153 beat/min. A heart rate registered during the last minute of the final part was on average higher by 20.6 beat/min in relation to the lowest value of the initial part. Discussion The analysis of the research results indicates a large changeability of the classes, which is evidenced by the course of changes of heart rate. Throughout the 3 sub- – 60 – Reactions of the cardiovascular system during physical education classes in first grade primary school children sequent games, i.e. up to the eighteenth minute of the effort, the studied variable is on the increase, whereas during the last 2 games intensity slightly decreases between the 20th and 25th minute of the physical education class. HR decline may be caused by emerging tiredness in organisms of the examined children. We can suppose that the highest average heart rate (192.2 ± 14.5 beat/min) that was revealed during the third running game reflects the maximum stimulation of the circulatory system. Similar values of HR were observed by Akdur et al. in Turkish children [7]. It must be emphasized that heart rate in children is significantly higher than in adults, both at rest as well as during physical effort. This results from, inter alia, sinoatrial node cells excitability and biological development. Excitability of these cells decreases with age. Heart work also shows individual personal diversity. It depends on many factors: biological development level, body mass, gender, nervous system structure, personal characteristics, level of physical efficiency, health condition, etc. [8]. Changeability of heart work, expressed by the abbreviation HRV (Heart Rate Variability), is subject to change depending on emotions, body position, digestion function, thermoregulation changes, altitude above mean sea level, climate, as well as various disease conditions such as diabetes, post-infarction state, ischemic heart disease, and arterial hypertension [9]. In the accessible literature on the subject, we have not found any publications in which the issue of a curve intensity of physical education classes of first grade primary school children would be analyzed. Therefore, our research results cannot be referred to any literature examples. There is only some research in this regard, but referring to older children [10–13]. Upon analyzing a large population of British children, Van Sluijs et al. [14] concluded that physical activity with 10-year-old children in British schools was greater than in these schools that had a good sports basis. Hobin et al. [15] emphasized the necessity to attend physical education classes at least twice a week in order to keep physical activity at an average or high level. Pate et al. [16] presented research aimed at providing information on existing methods of measuring physical activity of kindergarten children. They proved that systems of direct observation of physical activity – accelerometers – are reliable and commonly recognized methods of measurement, both in the case of older and younger children. They also stated that pedometers and monitoring of a heart rate turned out to be very helpful when controlling physical activity. Among Polish researchers who have dealt with the topic of physical activity, motor skills and health of children and young people, we can mention, among others, Raczek [17]. On the basis of his own research, he concluded that strength with children, especially with girls, is a feature that is particularly neglected, and consequently, it is unfavorable with the functioning of the circulatory system. Relatively low, but systematically applied strength exercises can lead to some favorable changes in the cardiovascular system. Our research indicates that the employed games are a significant method of increasing adaptation of the circulatory system with children aged 7 years during physical education classes in school conditions. Controlling intensity during physical education classes has thus far only been conducted by teachers occasionally, and its effects have not been fully objective. When evaluating the class intensity, a dominantly used method is an intuitional one, on the basis of which a teacher evaluates child’s reactions to the applied exercises. Measurement of heart rate by means of palpation on carotid or ray artery does not solve the problem because of difficulties in performing accurate measurement. The teacher is unable to carry out these examinations on all the pupils. Individual measurement by each child is even more error-prone, as children have neither the experience nor the necessary skills. Thanks to current technological developments, it is now possible to monitor cardiac performance in real time in an accurate and objective way. The teacher is able to control and correct children’s reactions to the applied loads and introduce modifications during physical education classes as necessary [18]. In the cross section of our research, we revealed significant individual differences in heart rates during the conducted physical education class scenario in its main part. We could ask why there is such a great diversity of the studied variable. Is it the effect of the loads applied during physical education classes or rather the children’s behavior and involvement? Our research proved that the children’s level of involvement in physical education class is varied. Within the groups, we revealed a visible diversity with regard to the functioning of individuals in a group. Some of the children are characterized by a managing style, and they are very active not only in the research process but also during the organization of the conducted research. Some of the children revealed active behaviors directed towards cooperation without assuming a managing role (cooperative style). Yet another group of children, with regard to their activity in the group, can be perceived as passive (subordinate style). These children are quiet and are – 61 – Paweł Chmura, Andrzej Rokita, Marek Popowczak, Ireneusz Cichy limited to only following the teacher’s instructions. They do not reveal their emotions connected with the performed tasks. It is also possible to notice another group of children who are not eager to take part in the class and require additional educational measures (withdrawing style) to be motivated to act. There are very few children who reveal active behaviors that are not connected with elements of integration with the group – these children disturb the class by introducing some destructive elements (destructive style). Such behaviors are not directed towards common performance of a group task [5]. All of the aforementioned behaviors directly influence an individual curve of physical education class intensity and constitute reasons for such a great diversity of heart rate during physical education classes. The physical activity of the participants was also significantly influenced by the nature and form of the conducted games as well as competition and rivalry in the particular physical games. We could even say that high motivation and desire to achieve the best results were more important than the growing tiredness. During the phase of grade one primary school, the children are characterized by various levels of awareness. Also, personal direct contacts of a pupil with the teacher had a direct influence on physical activity. Despite many messages addressed to the children by the teacher, some of the children did not perform the proposed games. It largely depended on their personality and temperament. We can assume that the effort intensity curve is a result of various levels of adaptation to the loads applied during physical education classes as well as the diversity in fitness and efficiency of the particular children. Through observation we can conclude that with some of the children who were fitter and more efficient the applied stimulus did not result in maximum stimulation. Those children who were less fit and morphologically different from their peers were quicker in getting tired and were unable to release high effort intensity in the subsequent running games. Summarizing, we can conclude that various dynamics of the young organism’s biological development and diverse levels of effort abilities have a significant impact on the reaction of the cardiovascular system on the loads applied during physical education classes. After each 3-minute running game we noticed a significant decrease in heart rate. This is the effect of the break during which the children rested in a sitting position while the teacher explained the rules of the next game. During the first 3 breaks the mean value oscillated around similar levels (146.7 ± 16.1; 143.0 ± 19.0; 142.6 ± 16.8), which indicates the organism regeneration processes are on a relatively constant level. This means that the generated tiredness still had nothing to do with dynamics of recreation processes. Upon completion of the fourth game, we observed lower dynamics of regeneration in children. This is further confirmed by achieving a significantly higher mean value of a heart rate (153.9 ± 12.9 beat/min). The difference between the third and the fourth break was as high as 11.3 beat/min. This proves the growing tiredness of the participants. It must be added that during the last minute of the final part of the physical education class, in which breathing exercises were conducted to set children’s organisms at rest, HR amounted to 123.9 ± 13.2 beat/min. The studied variable was significantly lower (P ≤ 0.001) than the highest value recorded during the fifth game by 61.2 beat/min. This dynamic post-effort restitution indicates that during the implementation of the assumed class scenario no overloading state took place. A heart rate towards the end of the lesson did not reach the value that was achieved in resting conditions. Taking into consideration organizational and didactic difficulties in executing control of physical activity of grade one primary school children, the research began only after a 6-month pilot research was completed. Children and teachers alike for the first time had contact with this sort of examinations and the newest generation control and measurement equipment. The first contact of children with Polar Team2 System, when they had to put the transmitters on their chests, was rather uncomfortable. During each subsequent class and game the children paid less and less attention to these devices and began to accept them over the course of time. We can assume that persons who reach higher values of heart rates are able to keep intensity on a high level in the cross section of the entire lesson time. Consequently, they are more predisposed to be professionally involved in playing sports in the future. Therefore, a very important aspect with children aged 7 years is connected with running numerous games of various nature that influence fluency and ease of performing movements, speed of adapting to changing situations on the pitch in team games, and ease in learning new physical structures connected with movement. Conclusions 1. The conducted research proved great variability of the effort intensity while carrying out the particular running games, as evidenced by the course of changes in heart rate. – 62 – Reactions of the cardiovascular system during physical education classes in first grade primary school children 2. The occurrence of the highest mean value of heart rate (192.2 ± 14.5 beat/min) during the third game may indicate the maximum stimulation of the cardiovascular system. 3. Recreation processes after the first 3 running games were on a similar level and on completion of the fourth one they visibly slowed down, which could indicate the growing fatigue of the examined pupils. Acknowledgements The aforementioned project is carried out by the local council in Wołów and the University School of Physical Education in Wrocław under the title: “Integrated education with the use of educational balls edubal.” LITERATURE • PIŚMIENNICTWO [1] Strong WB, Malina RM, Blimkie CJ, Daniels SR, Dishman RK, Gutin B, Hergenroeder AC, Must A, Nixon PA, Pivarnik JM, Rowland T, Trost S, Trudeau F: Evidence based physical activity for school-age youth. The Journal of Pediatrics, 2005; 146: 732–737. [2] Przewęda R, Dobosz J: Physical condition of Polish youths. Studies and Monographs, Warszawa, University School of Physical Education in Warsaw, 2003. [3] Rokita A, Rzepa T: By playing – I learn: educational balls in the integrated education [in Polish]. Wrocław, Wydawnictwo Akademii Wychowania Fizycznego, 2002. [4] Rokita A, Rzepa T: Educational balls in early school education. [in Polish] Wrocław, Wydawnictwo Akademii Wychowania Fizycznego, 2005. [5] Borecka-Biernat D, Węgłowska-Rzepa K: Styles of functioning in a social group; in: Behaviour of young people in social conflict situations [in Polish]. Wrocław, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Wrocławskiego, 2000. [6] Trześniowski R: Physical play and games. Edition 5, Warszawa, Wydawnictwo WSiP, 2008. [7] Akdur H, Sözen AB, Yiğit Z, Oztunç F, Kudat H, Güven O: The evaluation of cardiovascular response to exercise in healthy Turkish children. Turk J Pediatr., 2009 Sep-Oct; 51(5): 472–477. [8] McLaughlin D, Stamford J, White D: Human physiology. Short lectures. Warszawa, Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN, 2008. [9] Byrne EA, Fleg JL, Vaitkevicius PV, Wright J, Porges SW: Role of aerobic capacity and body mass index in the ageassociated decline in heart rate variability. J Appl Physiol, 1996; 81(2): 743–750. [10] Cabak A, Woynarowska B: Physical activity of youth aged 11–15 years in year 2002 in Poland and in other countries. Wychowanie Fizyczne i Sport, 2004; 48(4): 361–365. [11] Woynarowska B, Mazur J, Kowalewska, A: Conditions and actions for increasing physical activity of students – opinions of school headmasters. Wychow. Fiz. Zdrow., 2008; No 3: 9–15. [12] Ridgers ND, Stratton G, Fairclough SJ: Physical activity levels of children during school playtime. Sports Med., 2006; 36(4): 359–371. [13] Stratton G, Ridgers ND, Fairclough SJ, Richardson DJ: Physical activity levels of normal-weight and overweight girls and boys during primary school recess. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2007 Jun; 15(6): 1513–1519. [14] Van Sluijs EM, Jones NR, Jones AP, Sharp SJ, Harrison F, Griffin SJ: School-level correlates of physical activity intensity in 10-year-old children. Int J Pediatr Obes., 2010; Sep 20. [15] Hobin EP, Leatherdale ST, Manske SR, RobertsonWilson J: A multilevel examination of school and student characteristic associated with moderate and high levels of physical activity among elementary school students (Ontario, Canada). Can J Public Health, 2010; 101(6): 495–499. [16] Pate RR, O’Neill JR, Mitchell J: Measurement of Physical Activity in Preschool Children. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2010; 42(3): 508–512. [17] Raczek J: Developmental changes of the motor capacity of schoolchildren over three decades (1965–1995): tendencies, causes and consequences. Sportwissenschaft, 2002; 32(2): 201–216. [18] Castelli DM, Hillman CH, Hirsch J, Hirsch A, Drollette E: FIT Kids: Time in target heart zone and cognitive performance. Prev Med., 2011 Jun 1; 52 Suppl 1: S55–59. – 63 –
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz