CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, NORTHRIDGE Mental Health First Aid Training: Reactions of Community Social Service Providers A graduate project submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements For the degree of Master of Social Work By Cynthia Sanchez in collaboration with Melissa De la Torre May 2017 The graduate project of Cynthia Sanchez is approved: _______________________________________ Dr. Wendy Ashley __________ Date _______________________________________ Dr. David McCarty-Caplan ___________ Date _______________________________________ Dr. Judith A DeBonis, Chair ___________ Date California State University, Northridge ii Dedication I dedicate this paper to my parents and my loved ones. iii Table of Contents Signature Page ii Dedication iii Abstract v Introduction 1 Literature Review 2 Method 9 Results 12 Discussion 15 References 17 iv Abstract Mental Health First Aid Training: Reactions of Community Social Service Providers By Cynthia Sanchez Master of Social Work The present study evaluates the effectiveness of Mental Health First Aid (MHFA) standardized training that follows a specific curriculum of best practices in the Los Angeles County. It offers social service providers with tools to assist individuals when in a psychological crisis. This study uses a pre and post test to test the ability of the social service providers before and after the 8-hour MHFA training. It demonstrates whether the training increased social service provider’s mental health knowledge as well confidence on how to manage a crisis. Social Service providers demonstrate a significant overall improvement (M= 4.10, SD = .324 ) to post-test ( M = 4.51 , SD = .384 ), t ( 4.031), p < .002 (two tailed). The mean increase in post-test scores .41 with a confidence interval ranging from -.641 to -.191. Results show social service providers participating in the MHFA training are better informed and confident when to assess for risk of suicide, how to encourage self-help, encourage professional help, and listen without judgment. Keywords: mental health literacy, youth, social service providers, mental health crisis, suicide prevention v Introduction Mental Health First Aid (MHFA) is a training that was meant to increase the awareness of social services providers working with vulnerable populations that are being affected by mental health. Its purpose is to provide a better understanding on how to assist an individual that is experiencing a mental health crisis. Social service providers can then de-escalate a crisis to better link the individual to the best help needed. Just like First Aid is helpful in an emergency health crisis, MHFA can offer the same to an individual in a mental health crisis. Mental Health First Aid Training has been certified on National Registry of Evidence-based Programs and Practices. These interventions have been assessed and rated for quality in order to be ready for use. (Mental Health First Aid, 2016, para1). “In the United States, MHFA is overseen by the National Council for Behavioral Health, the Missouri Department of Mental Health, and the Maryland Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, which collectively provide instructors, training, and technical support. Their goal is to make MHFA trainings as available and as familiar as CPR” (Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, 2017, para 4). According to National Alliance on Mental Illness, in the United States 1 in 5 adults and 1 in 5 youth aged 13-18 experience severe mental illness (National Alliance on Mental Illness, 2017). Due to the lack of knowledge and treatment of mental health, there are higher rates of hospitalizations and suicides. Mental Health First Aid can help provide knowledge amongst social services providers to lessen stigmatization that can prevent an individual from seeking help. 1 Literature Review Background Mental Health First Aid (MHFA) began in Australia back in 2001 by a registered nurse, named Betty Kitchner, and her husband, Professor Tony Jorm (Bonnar, 2015). The purpose of creating MHFA was to educate adults that work with and care for adolescents on the appropriate skills they will need to recognize mental health crisis, as well as skills to better assist adolescents with early interventions (Kelly et al., 2011). Professor Jorm and colleagues coined the term ‘mental health literacy’ in 1997. Mental Health Literacy is being defined as: “knowledge and beliefs about mental disorders, which aid individuals recognition, management, or prevention, which include knowledge of disorders, when to seek help, and knowledge of risk factor” (Mental Health First Aid Australia, n.d.) This term was coined due to lack of knowledge and stigmatizing attitudes that prevented individuals from seeking help and prevented communities from supporting individuals seeking mental health aid (Mental Health First Aid Australia, n.d.). In order to improve the ‘mental health literacy’ in their community, Kitchner and Jorm developed MHFA and it has since been successfully applied throughout Australia and as many as 20 different countries (Mental Health First Aid Australia, n.d.). The program has currently trained over 1 million individuals world-wide. In 2008, there had been 250,000 individuals trained in the United States alone (Bonnar, 2015). It has now grown to 740,000 individuals in the United States (National Council for Behavioral Health., 2017). The National Council, Missouri Department of Mental Health, and the Maryland Department of Health and Mental Hygiene introduced Mental Health First Aid to the United States in 2008. 2 Populations Trained Many populations have been trained in MHFA worldwide, such as school personnel, police officers, faith leaders, health care professionals, and human resources managers (Mental Health First Aid USA, 2013b). Many trainees are also known as social services providers, who are people that carry different task in which one includes focusing on health and psychological interventions, educational and habilitation interventions, and lastly providing direct care (Bazzo, Ferrari, Minnies, Nota, Soresi, 2009, p. 112) . According to Kelly et al. (2011), many of the populations trained can include parents, school professionals, adults who are involved in recreational activities with young adults, such as sports and scout leaders. MHFA founders, Jorm & Kitchner hoped that MHFA would become a certified training that would be mandatory for these stated professions in order to work closely with the youth. In 2015, it was estimated that 2.16% of the adult population has attended a MHFA course in Australia since 2001 (Mental Health First Aid Australia, n.d.). According to MHFA the major populations trained in the United States for Adult MHFA are public safety workers, higher education professionals, rural areas, and older adults (Mental Health First Aid USA, 2013d). Rural areas in the United States have the biggest mental health disparities and are extremely underserved. More than 20% of Americans live in rural areas and MHFA wanted to take the opportunity to increase ‘mental health literacy’ to this population (Mental Health First Aid USA, 2013a). The adult Mental Health First Aid program has already been delivered to nearly 100,000 Americans through a network of more than 2,500 instructors (National Council for 3 Behavioral Health, 2017). In the United States alone, each year more than one in five Americans participate in MHFA training. Mermon et al. (2016) reported there is also a lack of mental health training and literacy in the minority and black populations. There is a high need of support to raise awareness and stop the stigma that prevents these populations from seeking help (Mermon et al., 2016). Providers need a significant way to develop open communication to break down barriers with the black and minority population (Mermon et al., 2016). Tailored culturally sensitive trainings can also improve the understanding of mental health and improve the access as well as break down the negative stigma within these communities (Mermon et al., 2016). Mental Health First Aid can ultimately be a positive training to increase knowledge of Mental health and break down stigmatization. MHFA Training Components Mental Health First Aid training aims to educate individuals on how to easily identify, understand and respond to mental illnesses and substance use disorders. By providing individuals with the necessary skills, they are more likely to identify and assist a person in crisis (Mental Health First Aid, 2013c). There are two types of Mental Health First Aid courses: adults and youth. Both Mental Health First Aid courses are eight-hour trainings provided by two instructors, which provide individuals with the necessary skills to help people who are experiencing a mental health crisis. Although both courses aim to have similar training components, the Youth MHFA course focuses on prevalent mental health issues for youth and summarizes common adolescent development (Mental Health First Aid," 2013d). The topics discussed during the course consists of anxiety, depression, substance use, disorders in which psychosis may occur, disruptive behavior 4 disorders (including ADHD), and eating disorders. However, Adult MHFA topics consist of anxiety, depression, psychosis, and addictions (Mental Health First Aid," 2013a). CPR helps one assist an individual having a physical health emergency, such as a heart attack, while Mental Health First Aid helps one assist someone experiencing a mental health or substance use-related crisis. The evidence behind the training demonstrates that it increases the individual's confidence in assisting people experiencing a crisis, increases their awareness of symptoms, risk factors and signs of mental illnesses, minimizes stigma towards people with mental illness and increases their own mental well-being (Mental Health First Aid Maryland, 2016). Participants also learn about strategies on how to help someone in both crisis and non-crisis situations, and resources that are available for people with a mental illness. Mental Health First Aid training consists of a mnemonic five-step action plan that is known as ALGEE. ALGEE refers to 1) assessing for risk of suicide or harm, 2) listening nonjudgmentally, 3) giving reassurance and information, 4) encouraging appropriate professionals help, and 5) encouraging self-help and other support strategies. The program topics cover a range of common mental health disorders including depression, mood disorders, psychosis, substance use and abuse (Mental Health First Aid, 2013a). Overall, Mental Health First Aid is a training appropriate for any individual over the age of 18 who is interesting in learning how to help a person who is experiencing a mental health related crisis or problem. MHFA Effectiveness MHFA conducted pilot programs in Canada, Sweden, and Australia (Hadlaczky, Hkby, Mkrtchian, Carli & Wasserman, 2014). A total of 15 programs used similar data and psychometric scaling measures tested to determine if MHFA training resulted in 5 changes in the individual's knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors in regard to mental health. During the training, participants were given a scenario involving an individual with depression, and a second scenario with an individual with schizophrenia. They were asked to rate their attitudes towards the individuals. The results demonstrated participants’ attitudes towards individuals living with depression and schizophrenia, and whether the training affected their perception. Results show change in all three areas and that MHFA is effective with increasing overall mental health knowledge (Hadlaczky et al., 2014). The research also stated the course effectively decreased negative attitudes towards individuals that suffer from mental health illness and increased help-seeking behavior (Hadlaczky et al., 2014). In 2014, individuals from a social services department in Maryland were provided MHFA training. There was a total of 20 training classes ranging in class size from 17–30 attendees, in which 406 individuals were trained. However, only 384 individuals submitted evaluation forms once the training was completed (Aakre, Browning-McNee & Lucksted, 2015). The study measured the participants’ likelihood in providing help, their ability to identify appropriate assistance behaviors and their MHFA knowledge. In the midst of the training, the participants were given four different vignettes pertaining to depression, depression with alcohol misuse, social phobia, and psychosis. The pre and post vignette questionnaire measured whether the five elements of ALGEE were implemented. Overall, it was determined that the individual's’ mental health knowledge had improved. The participants reported feeling confident and able to respond to a young person in mental health crisis by implementing ALGEE elements accordingly (Aakre, Browning-McNee & Lucksted, 2015). 6 During 2010, Mental Health First Aid Training was provided to staff from the Swedish social insurance agency, employment agencies, social services, schools, police departments, correctional treatment units, rescue services, and recreation centers. After the training was completed, the participants agreed to a six month and two-year follow-up (Svensson & Hansson, 2014). A pretest assessment was mailed out to the participants a month before the training was conducted. Six months after the training, they were sent the same assessment as a follow-up. A new questionnaire was created for the two-year follow-up in order to measure whether the participants had improved their skills in: making contact with a person with mental health problems, taking time and listening non-judgmentally, being aware of how a sad and depressed person communicates, asking if someone has suicidal thoughts, giving information about effective treatment, giving information about how to get right kind of help, recognizing signs of mental disorders, assessing the seriousness when a person is in a crisis. (Svensson & Hansson, 2014, para 18). In order to participate in the two-year follow-up, the participants needed to have come in contact with an individual with a mental health disorder since the training was completed. The results demonstrated that after two years the individuals who participated in the Mental Health First Aid training continued to have knowledge of mental health and treatment. The participants also continued to feel prepared and confident to come in contact with individuals with mental health problems (Svensson & Hansson, 2014). 7 There are not many published Mental Health First Aid training evaluations within the United States. Studies evaluated were conducted in Canada, Sweden and Australia. Only one published study found was in the United States. Overall, the studies analyzed demonstrated that the individuals who obtained the training had a greater knowledge of mental health and acquired the skills on how to recognize and assist a person in a mental health crisis. Aims and Objectives The present study evaluates the effectiveness of Mental Health First Aid training in the Los Angeles County. As of July 1, 2016, a total of 1 0,137,915 people reside in the Los Angeles County (United States Census Bureau, n.d.). In Los Angeles County alone 1,419,709 individuals live with a mental illness. Due to the immense number of individuals living with a mental illness, there is also a high need to educate social service providers on how to support individuals with a mental illness. The intention of the study is to investigate whether individuals completing the training will demonstrate skills in identifying an appropriate response to people in emotional distress, and have an increase in self-confidence to responding to individuals in a mental health crisis 8 Method Participants A total of 16 individuals participated in the MHFA training. The trainees had different social service provider roles throughout Los Angeles. They consisted of case managers, students, and support staff. All participants who participated became aware of the training from their employers or school campus. The trainees participated in the training and completed the evaluations in fall 2014. Measures The data collected was to evaluate the course and instructors and to determine if there was a change in the participants’ knowledge and confidence based on the training using a pre and post-test. MHFA 8-hour course evaluation form. The purpose of the evaluation was to determine the participants’ satisfaction and reaction to the training and instructors. MHFA instructors also provided the trainees a questionnaire with 17 evaluation questions, 9 practical application questions and 4 demographic questions. Twenty-one of those questions was rated on a 5-point Likert scale ranging from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree). The instructor's evaluation was measured by asking participants, “the instructors demonstrated knowledge of the material presented” and “the instructor's presentation skills were engaging and approachable”. Practical application of the training was measured by asking questions such as, “how confident are you to help someone going through a mental crisis or problem”, “how confident are you to provide a distressed person basic first aid level 9 information and reassurance about mental health problems,” and “how confident are you to recognize and correct misconceptions about mental health and mental illness”. County of Los Angeles Department of Mental Health Adult System of Care MHFA pre and post-Test. The pre and post-test was used to determine if the training changed the participants perception of mental health after the training was completed. The pre and post-test has 12 test comparison questions and 1 final question. The purpose of the questionnaire was to determine whether the trainees would assist an individual with mental health issues and their beliefs and knowledge regarding mental health. The instructors provided the trainees the pre and post -test questionnaire before the training and after. Overall, both pre and post-test compared how confident the trainees felt before and after the training was conducted. The confidence of the pre and post-test questionnaire was rated using a 5-point Likert scale. The pre and post-test questionnaire also included demographic questions. The demographic questionnaire included questions such as age, gender, primary language, ethnicity and highest education level. Also, included were questions regarding the number of individuals the trainees knew that experienced mental health issues, how often were their interactions with individuals’ mental health issues, their experience with individuals with mental health issues and their role in the community. Research Design Secondary data collected from two standardized instruments commonly used by MHFA trainers was used to explore the pre and post-test responses and course evaluation. The data was previously collected by CSUN Garrett Lee Smith Suicide Prevention Grant 10 which was funded by SAMHSA. The study used an exploratory, descriptive pre and posttest design to evaluate whether the MHFA training resulted in changes in the participants. The questionnaires were administered in paper-and-pencil format to the entire trainee group (n=17) by the MHFA trainers. Procedure Participation in this study was anonymous and voluntary, and the relevant institutional review board (IRB) determined it to be exempt from IRB review. Questionnaires were distributed by the MHFA instructors before the pre and post-test immediately after taking the 8-hour training (2 days at 4 hours each day). The MHFA trainers were certified by the program and followed a standardized training using the evidence based curriculum. At the end of the course, trainees were also asked to take a satisfaction evaluation form. No payments or incentive were given to the trainees. Written responses on the survey questions ranged from multiple choice to short answers to short sentences. 11 Results Secondary data from 1 MHFA training class had a total of 17 social service providers. A total of 17 MHFA 8-hour Course Evaluation questionnaires and 16 County of Los Angeles Department of Mental Health Adult System of Care MHFA pre and posttest questionnaires were received. Only 13 of the pre-test were completed, however all 16 of the post-test were completed. Both pre and post-test had missing open ended question data. A total of 33 questionnaires were received by the research team. Participants Characteristics The majority of our participants were 16 (94%) women. There was only 1 (6%) male who participated. The participants ranged from 18- 50 years old, in which the majority (46%) were 26-30 years old. From the social services providers, 1 (6%) had a High School Diploma/GED, 2 (12%) had a two-year college degree, 7 (43%) had a fouryear college degree, 3 (18%) had a Master’s Degree and 3 (18%) reported having more than one degree. A total of 62% (n= 16) of participants reported knowing 11 or more individuals who have experienced mental health issues, and 37% reported frequent interactions with individuals with mental health issues. The majority of the participants 44%, described having a neutral experience with individuals with mental health issues. Course and Instructor Evaluation To keep track on how to better the training and get critical feedback, the trainees were given an evaluation after the two-day 4-hours training. The purpose was to evaluate the instructors and give the trainees the opportunity to give feedback anonymously. The MHFA training consisted of two instructors complying with the standardized curriculum of this training. The evaluation scored the instructors on how the instructors presented the 12 curriculum and how effective their delivery was; whether they had positive or negative impact. The evaluation had a unanimous positive feedback of the trainers in which ultimately affected the positive outcome of the trainees confidence in a mental health crisis. The only limitation of the evaluation was that the trainees felt the training itself was not long enough. They felt they needed extra days to explore more. At the end of the post test there was an extra additional commentary question that provided the trainees the opportunity to openly answer what improvements would they recommend for the training. Practical application. Part III of the evaluation questionnaire asked if the participants felt confident to recognize the signs of someone dealing with mental health problems as well as if they felt more confident in assisting an individual with a mental health problem. Table 1 Trainees Practical Application As a result of this training, I feel more confident that I can… Strongly Disagree Disagree Uncertain Agree Strongly Agree M(SD) Recognize the signs that someone is dealing with a MH problem or crisis 7 (41%) 10 (59%) 4.59 (0.50) Reach out to someone who may be dealing with a mental health problem or crisis. 7 (41%) 10 (59%) 4.59 (0.50) 3 (18%) 13 (76%) 4.81 (0.40) 1 (6%) 4 (24%) 11 (65%) 4.63 (0.62) 1 (6%) 5 (29%) 10 (59%) 4.56 (0.63) Actively and compassionately listen to someone in distress. Assist a person who may be dealing with a mental health problem or crisis to seek professional help Assist a person who may be dealing with a mental health problem or crisis to connect with community, peer, and personal supports. Table 1 demonstrated that 59% of participants felt confident in being able to reach out, assist and recognize the signs that someone is dealing with a mental health problem or crisis. Seventy-six percent reported that they would actively and compassionately listen 13 to someone in distress. Lastly, 65% reported that they would assist a person who may be dealing with a mental health problem or crisis to seek professional help. Pre and Post Test A paired-samples t-test was conducted to evaluate the impact of the training on the participants’ pre and post-test scores. There was a statistically significant increase in the post-test scores from pre-test (M= 4.10, SD = .324) to post-test (M = 4.51, SD = .384), t ( -4.031), p < .002 (two-tailed). The mean increase in post-test scores t = .41 with a confidence interval ranging from -.641 to -.191. The final question of the post-test asked the participants whether the presentation helped them understand people with mental illnesses. A total of 75% of the participants reported that they strongly agree with understanding an individual with a mental illness while 25% agree. The larger average score indicates that the training helped individuals become more confident with assisting and approaching an individual in mental health crisis. The participants also reported that the training was “great”, “informative”, “educational” and “helpful”. Overall, the findings were statistically significant in demonstrating the participants confidence in approaching and assisting an individual in a mental health crisis. 14 Discussion The aim of this study was to examine whether the participant’s Mental Health knowledge, beliefs, and confidence with assisting a person in emotional distress or crisis increased after taking an 8-hour MHFA training. Results indicated significant, positive changes in trainees’ ability to approach and assist a person in mental health crisis. The positive findings are reinforced by the participants’ probability in assisting an individual in crisis comparable to previous research data that indicated an increase in helping behaviors (Hadlaczky et al., 2014). Follow-up MHFA application research is needed in order to determine whether the trainees used their learned skills when assisting an individual in crisis. The fact that scores improved significantly is essential due to sample of employee’s social services providers of community services agencies, in which the majority completed postsecondary education. MHFA is a training intended for the general public whom do not have any training in mental health, and not intended for individuals with advanced training. As previously stated, the pilot studies done in Canada, Sweden, Australia, and Maryland discussed an increase of mental health knowledge and the ‘likelihood’ in providing help in a mental health crisis after the completion of the course. Overall, the trainees felt more comfortable with the practical application of the learned skills. Limitations Although the outcome of this study was overall positive, there were some negative setbacks regarding the data. In the evaluations, some of the questions were left blank. Of the 17 participants that were a part of the evaluation, one participant did not complete the pre and post-test. We can assume that the length of the training possibly 15 affected the completion of both tests. Our recommendations are to ask the participants to complete only one set of questionnaires, either the evaluation or pre and post-tests to gather information about the training due to the duplication of questions. Another limitation we came across was the lack of studies of MHFA training conducted in the United States. Most of the MHFA studies that were found were conducted in Australia since the training was developed in that country. Furthermore, the training should also focus on demonstrating ‘real life’ scenarios of how MHFA has improved individuals lives. Conclusion The study demonstrated the increase in confidence, comfort, and likelihood in helping individuals in emotional distress and crisis. Due to the significantly positive findings, it is important to continue to promote MHFA training by educating social service providers in various settings to assist and encourage individuals in distress. The overall results of this study attest to the effectiveness of MHFA training and how it can benefit other agencies nationwide and ultimately worldwide. MHFA has the possibility of becoming a training that can better educate and improve the communities perception of mental health. 16 References Aakre, J. , Lucksted, A. , Browning-Mcnee, L. , Deleon, P. , Klee, A. , et al. (2016). Evaluation of youth mental health first aid USA: A program to assist young people in psychological distress. Psychological Services, 13(2), 121-126 Bazzo, G. , Nota, L. , Soresi, S. , Ferrari, L. , & Minnes, P. (2009). Attitudes of social service providers towards the sexuality of individuals with intellectual disability. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, 20(2), 110-115. Bonnar, F. (2015). Mental health first aid: Triage for the mind. British Journal of Nursing, 24(14), 724. Hadlaczky, G. , Hkby, S. , Mkrtchian, A. , Carli, V. , & Wasserman, D. (2014). Mental health first aid is an effective public health intervention for improving knowledge, attitudes, and behaviour: A meta-analysis. International Review of Psychiatry, Vol.26(4), 467-475. Holzner, C. (n.d.). California Mental Health Prevalence Estimates. Retrieved from http://www.dhcs.ca.gov/provgovpart/Documents/CaliforniaPrevalenceEstimates.p df Kelly, C. , Mithen, J. , Fischer, J. , Kitchener, B. , Jorm, A. , et al. (2011). Youth mental health first aid: A description of the program and an initial evaluation. International Journal of Mental Health Systems, 5, 4. Memon, A. , Taylor, K. , Mohebati, L. , Sundin, J. , Cooper, M. , et al. (2016). Perceived barriers to accessing mental health services among black and minority ethnic communities: A qualitative study in Southeast England. The Lancet, 388, S76. Mental Health First Aid Australia. (n.d.). What we do at Mental Health First Aid. 17 Retrieved from https://mhfa.com.au/about/our-activities/what-we-do-mentalhealth-first-aid Mental Health First Aid Maryland. (2016). Evidence Mental Health First Aid Maryland. Retrieved April 3, 2017, from https://mhfamaryland.org/about/evidence/ Mental Health First Aid USA. (2013a). Adult Mental Health First Aid. Retrieved April 3, 2017, from https://www.mentalhealthfirstaid.org/cs/take-a-course/coursetypes/adult/ Mental Health First Aid USA. (2013b). Frequently asked questions. Retrieved from https://www.mentalhealthfirstaid.org/cs/faq/ Mental Health First Aid USA. (2013c). Take A Course Mental Health First Aid. Retrieved April 3, 2017, from https://www.mentalhealthfirstaid.org/cs/take-acourse/ Mental Health First Aid USA. (2013d). Youth Mental Health First Aid. Retrieved April 3, 2017, from https://www.mentalhealthfirstaid.org/cs/take-a-course/coursetypes/youth/ National Council for Behavioral Health. (2017). Mental Health First Aid. Retrieved April 3, 2017, from https://www.thenationalcouncil.org/topics/mental-health-first-aid/ Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. (2017). Mental Health First Aid Offers Behavioral Health Training. Retrieved April 3, 2017, from https://www.samhsa.gov/homelessness-programs-resources/hpr-resources/mentalhealth-first-aid-training Svensson, B., & Hansson, L. (2014). Effectiveness of Mental Health First Aid Training in 18 Sweden. A Randomized Controlled Trial with a Six-Month and Two-Year Follow-Up. PLOS ONE, 9(6), e100911. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0100911 United States Census Bureau. (n.d.). Los Angeles County California quick facts from the US Census Bureau. Retrieved April 3, 2017, from https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/table/BZA010214/06037 19
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz