visualization of sulfate-reducing bacteria in

J17
204 Morrill Science Center IVN
University of Massachusetts
639 North Pleasant Street
Amherst, MA 01003
Tel: 413-545-1204
Fax: 413-545-1578
VISUALIZATION OF SULFATE-REDUCING BACTERIA IN MICROCOSMS OF
AN ACID MINE DRAINAGE SITE
Caryl Ann Becerra and Klaus Nüsslein
Department of Microbiology, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA
Indication of Sulfate Reduction Activity
Introduction
Experimental Flow Chart
Acid Mine Drainage
AMD Attenuating
AMD Attenuating
AMD Generating
™ Extracted DNA from sediment used to create
microcosms.
™Generation of AMD involves both geochemical and microbial
processes of the oxidation of iron and sulfur in minerals. See reaction
below.
Microcosms amended with Glycerol+N+P
Microcosms amended with Algae extract
™The smell of H2S, another indication of sulfate
reduction, was detected in microcosms of the AMD
attenuating zone
400
300
ORP (mV)
Effect of Different Substrates
Algae and G+N+P Amended Microcosms
200
™ The resultant product, sulfuric acid, acidifies the water, which
dissolves the metals in the ore deposits, causing elevated
concentrations of metal contaminants in the water system.
100
™ Amending microcosms of the attenuating zone with Algae or
Glycerol with N and P resulted in higher pH and lower ORP
measurements during the incubation as compared to unamended
microcosms
0
-100
™Typically, AMD is exacerbated because of mining activity, thus AMD
has become a widespread problem occurring in every industrial nation.
2) Microcosms of Davis Mine
™ Samples were incubated in the dark, under anaerobic conditions at 4 °C,
12°C, or 16°C. (incubation temperatures reflect measured average
temperatures of the sediment during the winter and summer months).
Overall Reaction for the Generation of AMD
Geochemical:
FeS2 + 3.5 O2 + H2O → Fe2+ + 2 SO42- + 2H+
™ Microcosms of AMD attenuating and generating zones were compared by
measuring:
Triplicates + Killed Controls
Biological: (ex. Thiobacillus ferrooxidans)
7 Fe2+ + 1.75 O2 + 7H+ → 7 Fe3+ + 3.5 H2O
6
AMD Attenuating Zone:
Unamended
Algae
AMD Generating Zone:
Unamended
Algae
Glycerol + N+P
K illed Control
Glycerol + N+P
K illed Control
™ Amending with Algae from the site raised the pH and lowered
the ORP faster than amending with Glycerol with N and P
5
pH
™ Microcosms are batch-type experiments of environmental samples treated
under controlled laboratory conditions to allow easier determination of
microbial activity.
Acid mine drainage is naturally attenuated at Davis Mine
™ Amending the microcosms of the AMD generating zone did not
cause the pH or ORP to change considerably as compared to the
killed controls
4
3
0
20
40
60
Days of Incubation
ƒ pH – detect changes in acidity
80
100
Iron (II) concentration suggest
reduction in (Left):
™ both AMD attenuating and
generating zones
™ unamended microcosms and
amended microcosms
™ is higher in attenuating zone
ƒ ORP (oxidation-reduction potential) – indicate whether reduction
reactions are occurring. Reduction reactions like sulfate and iron
reduction are known reactions that attenuate AMD
ƒ Sulfate, reduced iron, total sulfur and iron concentrations
Geochemical:
FeS2 + 14 Fe3+ + 8 H2O → 15 Fe2+ + 2 SO42- + 16 H+
™ Three sets of controls: unamended, standard media, and killed controls
Sulfate concentration suggest no significant
difference between (Above):
™ microcosms and killed controls
™ unamended and amended microcosms
™ attenuation and generating zone
Day 33
Day 0
Natural Attenuation at Davis Mine
3) Visualizing Bacteria in Microcosms
™ In some instances, AMD is naturally attenuated by the
system.
™ Used fluorescent in situ hybridization to detect sulfate-reducing bacteria
(SRB385), eubacteria (EUB338), and all cells (DAPI).
™ Davis Mine in Rowe, Massachusetts is an AMD site
where natural attenuation is occurring. See picture above.
™ Changes in microbial composition over time were observed and correlated to
physico-chemical changes in the microcosms
™ Within a 100 meters from the mine effluent, the acidic
leachate is neutralized and the heavy metal content
decreases.
AMD Attenuating Zone Day 33
3) Visualizing Bacteria
in Microcosms
Unamended Microcosm on Day 0
™ Sulfate-reducing bacteria are
present at both the AMD
attenuating and generating site,
however acidic conditions may
limit SRB growth.
AMD Generating Zone Day 33
™ This self-remediating phenomenon involves both
geochemical and biological processes such as
EUB
- Hydrological: by the dilution of AMD
SRB
Results
- Geochemical: buffering capacity of minerals
- Biological: iron and sulfate reduction
EUB
SRB
1) Bacterial Community Composition
Samples were taken from differing geochemical zones at Davis Mine
™ Microcosms of the AMD
attenuating zone have larger bacterial
populations than microcosms of the
AMD generating zone
™ The 16S rDNA of extracted DNA taken from
the sediment used as microcosm inoculum was
amplified
AMD Attenuating Zone (W14)
•pHavg = 4.91
™ Larger number of sulfate-reducing
bacteria is found in microcosms of the
AMD attenuating zone
™ Community analysis was conducted to
compare differences in the microbial communities
of the two zones in order to possibly reveal
potential groups responsible for the geochemical
characteristics
•Lower concentration of dissolved metals
AMD Generating Zone (W15)
W14
•Higher concentration of dissolved
metals
™Black precipitate, an indication of sulfate
reduction, appeared in microcosms of the AMD
attenuating zone only
™ The appearance of black precipitate was
enhanced when microcosms were amended with
algae or with glycerol with or without N +P
1) Microbial Community Analysis
™Acid mine drainage (AMD) is an acidic, iron-rich leachate that is
generated when sulfur-rich minerals are exposed to oxygen and
moisture. See picture on left.
•pHavg = 2.58
AMD Generating
™ Both zones contain acidophiles
W15
™ Iron oxidizers were detected in the AMD
generating zone but not the AMD attenuating
zone
™ Although sulfate and iron reducers were not
detected, a large proportion of unknown members
exist in the AMD attenuating zone
Davis Mine Average Concentration Jul 2004 - Mar 2005
All concentrations are in ug/L
Partial Map of Davis Mine
pH
W14
W15
4.91
2.98
2&3
Fe
45016.1
30543.3
SO4
2-
2) Microcosms of Davis Mine
579514.46
601257.38
AMD Attenuating Unamaneded:
AMD Generating Unamended:
7
4ºC
12ºC
12ºC
16ºC
16ºC
pH Differences with Varying
Temperature
Determine whether the geochemical characteristics of an AMD attenuating
and AMD generating zone are biologically influenced.
pH
6
Goal of Study
™ Increasing the incubation temperature
resulted in a faster increase in pH
measured in the microcosms of the
attenuating zone
5
4
3
™ Does the site possess the capacity for attenuating processes?
™ What microorganisms are potentially responsible for these processes?
™ Is there a difference between the microbial populations in the AMD generating
versus the AMD attenuating zone? How do these populations change over time?
Conclusions
™ Differences in geochemical trends are biologically influenced
2
0
20
40
Day
60
80
100
™ An increase in temperature had no
significant effect on microcosms from the
AMD generating zone
™pH and ORP data indicate that a larger effect of attenuation processes are present in the AMD attenuating zone
™ Microbial community of AMD attenuating zone possess the capacity for attenuating AMD
™ Microcosms confirm the potential for sulfate and iron reduction and suggest that sulfate and iron reducing bacteria are responsible
™ Community can be stimulated with the addition of organic carbon or an increase in temperature to produce greater attenuation effects
Future Work
™ Correlate the changes in the microbial community with
geochemical trends observed in the microcosms
™ Determine the microbial sulfate reduction rates within the AMD
attenuating and generating zones
™ Isolate acidophilic sulfate-reducing bacteria from Davis Mine
Acknowledgements
NSF- Biocomplexity of the Environment for Integrated
Research and Education in Environmental Systems
NSF-Central Microscopy Facility of University of
Massachusetts, Amherst
Acid Mine Drainage Group at UMass-Amherst
(http://www.umass.edu/biocomplexity)