What is 3-PG?

Just what is
this 3-PG?
Peter Sands
CSIRO FFP and CRC SPF
Hobart
An overview
of Landsberg & Waring’s
model of forest productivity
1
A quick answer …
T
LAI
LUE
FR
GPP
SLA
VPD
ET

gC
CO2
f

R
H20

3-PG is

Soil H20
NPP
F/S
Rain
DBH
Roots
Foliage
C,N
Litter
Stem
Stocking
wSx
Dead trees
gN
Stress
tree growth model based on
Physiological Principles that Predict Growth




bridges gap between mensuration-based growth &
yield models and process-based, C-balance models
provides fully dynamic predictions of biomass pools,
stand attributes, stocking and soil water usage
maintains an admirable level of simplicity
applicable under changing conditions, “at the edges”,
and to novel situations
2
Comparison with empirical model

Advantages

based on wide range of conditions

HS  H x 1  e  tS / t 0



B
 i
B
 x




d

1/ d 

ln  1  H H

i
x


H /b
B b e S 1
x
0
H x  60, t S  15, d  0.9113,
t  t
0
i
applicable under changing conditions,
“at the edges”, to novel situations
 provides explanation, aids understanding

 t ti 
c
-t / t d

0  , B(t )  B
H  H  1- e

x
x


b0  34.183, b1  29.053
Disadvantages
not as widely understood as empirical growth models
 not necessarily as accurate, either
 can require data not readily available

3
Forest management & 3-PG

3-PG applied worldwide to many species and
wide range of forest types


currently more widely used for spatial predictions
than for plot-level management
3-PG is default choice PBM for “day-by-day”
plantation management systems

e.g. Aracruz (Brazil) and a South African consortium
implementing 3-PG for routine forest management
4
Why 3-PG?


Not necessarily best model for intended uses
Choice of 3-PG is based on perceptions:





3-PG is an inherently simple distillation of sound
physiological and observational knowledge
freely available  lots of exposure
3PGPJS = good implementation & documentation
open lines of communication
Potential problems with further adaptation of
3-PG for management


desired generalisations to go against current strong
points – e.g. simplicity
balance when simple models married to complex
5
Management system structure

Modular structure for both management system and
3-PG highly desirable
clearly delineates roles of components
 isolates biology from support services
 aids development and maintenance
 share components between systems

Weather
data
generator
Site
factors
T
VPD
Rain
NPP
Max ASW
FR
Stems
3-PG
Soil
water
Initial
stand
conditions
Biomass
Stem mass
DBH
Product
conversion
Height
volumes
etc
Biomass
ASW
stocking
6
A quick summary of 3-PG
Attribute
Comments
Model type
Dynamic; process-based & empirical relationships
Time frame
Monthly
Processes
NPP, biomass allocation, water usage & soil water balance,
stem mortality, litterfall & root turnover
Inputs
Monthly climate data, soil texture & water capacity, fertility
Outputs
Biomass pools, stocking, available soil water, NPP & ET,
DBH & standard stand attributes, and others
Strengths
Fully dynamic, can be adapted for range of species,
provides management-related outputs
Weaknesses Naïve treatment of soil nutrition, allocation based largely on
size, poor predictor of canopy development & of mortality
7
Input data for 3-PG is …

…of a quality and quantity
that is readily obtained by
the forest manager



mean monthly weather data
very basic physical site & soil
factors
simple (naïve?) ranking of
site fertility
8
Input data

Climate data



monthly mean temperature, radiation, rainfall, VPD
observed or long-term average data
Site & soil descriptors




(continued)
latitude
soil texture & water capacity
fertility rating
BUT also need stand initialisation data



foliage, stem & root biomass
stocking
available soil water
9
Main Components of 3-PG
 Production of biomass – environmental modification
of light use efficiency; constant ratio of NPP to GPP
 Biomass allocation – affected by growing conditions
and tree size
 Stem morality – probability of death; self-thinning
 Soil water balance – single soil layer model; evapotranspiration determined from Penman-Monteith
equation
 Stand properties – from biomass pools and
assumptions about specific leaf area, branch+bark
fraction, and wood density
10
3-PG growth modifiers
Each environmental factor is represented by a growth
modifier, i.e. a function of the factor which varies
between 0 (total limitation) and 1 (no limitation).
Factor
Modifier
Parameters
Vapor pressure deficit
fD(D)
kD
Soil water
f()
max , c , n
Temperature
fT(Tav)
Tmin , Topt , Tmax
Frost
fF(df)
kF
Site nutrition
fN(FR)
fN0
Stand age
fage(t)
nage , rage
11
How does
3-PG do?
a comparison of
predictions of 3-PG
with observed data
12
How does 3-PG do?

Examples are based on sound parameterisation
of 3-PG against observed data for E. globulus



get good predictions of LAI & stem growth when
stand is initialised with observed stand data
prediction of early canopy growth depends strongly on
initial stand conditions but stem growth rates at a site
are similar for all initial conditions
Conclude that 3-PG has capability to predict
stand growth sufficiently accurately for use as a
management tool
13
400
8
400
300
6
300
6
200
4
200
4
2
100
2
100
8
0
0
10
0
0
15
Woody biomass (t/ha)
8
300
6
200
4
100
2
15
7
200
6
8
300
6
200
4
100
2
150
5
4
100
3
2
50
1
e) Esperance 2
0
0
d) Northcliffe
0
0
Stand age (years)
10
400
c) Manjimup
10
5
Stand age (years)
400
5
a-d) good predictions
e) a poor one
0
Stand age (years)
0
Performance of 3-PG
for E. globulus in WA
and SE Tasmania
Woody Biomass (t/ha)
5
(continued)
b) Esperance 1
a) Forcett
0
Leaf area index

Leaf area index
Woody biomass (t/ha)
How does 3-PG do?
15
0
0
0
0
5
10
Stand age (years)
2
4
6
8
10
Stand age (years)
15
14
(concluded)

Figure shows affects of stand initialisation on predicted stem biomass
and LAI.

Stands were initialised with (a) seedlings at planting, (b) different
foliage biomass, and (c) different stem biomass..
400
8
400
8 400
8
300
6
300
6 300
6
200
4
200
4 200
4
100
2
100
2 100
2
b) Effect of initial
foliage biomass
a) Seedlings
0
0
0
5
10
Stand age (years)
15
c) Effect of initial
w oody biomass
0
0
0
5
10
Stand age (years)
Leaf area index
Woody biomass (t/ha)
How does 3-PG do?
15
0
0
0
5
10
Stand age (years)
15
15
Structure &
processes in
3-PG
a diagrammatic overview
of the processes in and
of structure 3-PG
16
Conceptual PBM of forest growth

Next slide represents the majority of processes
involved in forest growth



not all of these are explicitly included in 3-PG
Later slides in this section present causal loop
diagrams that portray the structure of 3-PG
Final section gives more detailed on relationships
on 3-PG
17
Conceptual PBM of forest growth
Assimilation,
respiration
Transpiration
Light
interception
Defoliation,
disease
Biomass
allocation
Understory
evaporation
Silviculture
Rainfall
Soil
evaporation
Litterfall
Decomposition,
mineralisation,
OM cycling
Water
uptake
Root
turnover
Nutrient
uptake
Nutrient
volatilisation
& leaching
Watertable access
18
Causal loop diagrams
I’m using “causal loop diagrams” in the following slides to
illustrate the structure of 3-PG

They are:


Powerful tools to
communicate and
explore system
behaviour
They summarise
structure, causal
influences &
feedback loops
an increase causes
a decrease
causal
influence
C
-
+
A
A influences B
+
B
+
D
an increase causes
an increase
ABCA
negative feedback (odd number of '-')
ABCDA positive feedback (even number of '-')
19
Conceptual PBM…

(continued)
McMurtrie & Wolf (1983) model
is a common basis for many implementations of
the conceptual model
 3-PG follows in their mould

Light
interception
“Listen mate, I didn’t make these rules, I’m
just telling you what He said … ”
P  Y (1  e
 k WF
Photosynthesis
LAI
)Q0
CO2
Net primary
production
WF  F P   FWF
WS  S P
WR  R P   RWR
 F  S   R  1
Stem
Leaves
Roots
Litter,
turnover, etc
20
3-PG causal loop diagram

This is the full picture – except for some internal details, and
Key to colours & shapes
stand properties, e.g. H & V
Carbon
Water
Trees
State variables
T

VPD
+
f
_
Soil H20
Subsidiary variables
Subsidiary variables

Material flow s
Influences
CO2
_
R
+
H20
Losses
SLA
+
gC
+
+
GPP
_
ET
LAI
+
FR
+
+
Climate & site Inputs
+
+
+
LUE
F/ S
NPP
Stocking
_
+
Rain
_
_
wSx
DBH
+
Roots
_
+
Stem
+
Foliage
+
C,N
+
_
Dead
trees
wS
_
+
w S >w Sx
+ 
N
+
Stress
_
Litter
21
3-PG as a carbon flow model

3-PG is essentially a McMurtrie & Wolf (1983) carbon balance
model



GPP

radiation is intercepted by
the canopy,
converted to assimilates,
allocated to foliage, stem &
roots, and
lost to respiration,
litterfall & root turnover
CO2
NPP
Roots
Stem
Foliage
C,N
Litter
22
Assimilation & allocation

Assimilation & allocation are based on simple, well established
principles and sound
 radiation interception via
observations

+
LUE
+
LAI
+

+
GPP
SLA

CO2
R
Beers law
assimilation via light use
efficiency
simple foliage, stem & root
allocation ratios
foliage:stem allocation
depends on tree size
F/ S
NPP
_
+
DBH
+
Roots
+
Stem
Foliage
C,N
Litter
23
Site & environmental effects

Site & environmental factors affect growth (and water use) via
simple empirical modifiers


T

+
LUE
+
+
LAI
GPP
_
VPD
SLA

+
f
_

+
+
FR
+
temperature affects only
LUE
VPD and soil water affect
LUE and root allocation
site fertility affects root
allocation and maybe LUE
CO2
_
R
F/ S
NPP
_
_
+
DBH
+
Roots
+
Stem
Foliage
+
C,N
Stress
Litter
24
Soil water balance

Soil water balance via simple single layer model with transpiration
determined using a Penman-Montieth equation


T

+
ET
VPD
gC
f
_

SLA


and affected by VPD and soil
water
ET driven by radiation
feedback from soil water
status into growth modifiers
CO2
_
R
+
Soil H20
+
+
+
+
H20
LAI
GPP
_
+
+
+
FR
+
+
LUE
canopy conductance scaled
for canopy LAI
F/ S
NPP
_
+
Rain
_
DBH
+
Roots
+
Stem
Foliage
+
C,N
Stress
_
Litter
25
Stocking and mortality

Stocking an essential component of 3-PG as it affects allocation
through stand-mean DBH


T

+
ET
VPD
gC
f
_

SLA

probability of death age &
(potentially) stress related
density dependent mortality
implemented via selfthinning law
CO2
_
R
+
Soil H20
+
+
+
+
H20
LAI
GPP
_
+
+
+
FR
+
+
LUE
mortality model very simpleminded
F/ S
NPP
Stocking
_
+
Rain
_
_
wSx
DBH
+
Roots
_
+
Stem
+ w
S
Foliage
+
C,N
+
_
Dead
trees
_
+
w S >w Sx
+ 
N
+
Stress
_
Litter
26
3-PG in more
detail
a detailed,
process-by-process
look at 3-PG
27
Light interception


Light is absorbed as it passes
through canopy
Intercepted radiation varies
with LAI via Beer’s law:
Qint  (1  e kL )Q0
LAI determined by SLA and
foliage biomass
Note diminishing returns
from high leaf area indices

Intercepted radiation (%)

100
80
60
40
20
0
0
1
2
3
4
Canopy LAI
5
6
28
Production
&
solar radiation
Observation shows


above-ground and gross production
linearly related to intercepted
radiation
Slope of these relationships is a
measure of light use efficiency
(LUE)


daily canopy-level LUE varies
seasonally
annual stand-level LUE stable
This finding is the basis for many simple
growth models
E . g lo b u lu s
a g e x n u t rit io n
14
G ip p s la n d , V ic .
12
10
8
6
4
y = 4 .3 6 7 3 x - 1 .4 3 6 6
2
R 2 = 0 .9 8 7 3
0
0
1
2
3
Inte r c e pte d r a dia tion (GJ m
16
Above-ground production (t ha -1 yr -1)

Above-ground production (t ha -1 yr -1)
16
-2
4
-1
yr )
A s s o r te d s p e c i e s
fo u r s i te s
14
E s p e ra n c e , T a s .
12
10
8
6
4
y = 4 .2 9 0 8 x - 0 .6 2 1 1
2
R 2 = 0 .9 8 3 9
0
0
1
2
Inte r c e pte d r a dia tion (GJ m
3
-2
4
-1
yr )
29
Light use efficiency
Light use efficiency (LUE) a powerful, simplifying
concept

annual stand-level LUE quite stable

species-specific


varies with climatic and site
factors through use of simple
modifiers
early use of this concept by
Fitzpatrick & Nix (1970) in
GROWEST, and by Monteith
(1972)
30
-1 -1
 ==0.43
0.43g gMJMJ
-1 -1
 ==0.43
g
MJ
0.68 g MJ
-1
 ==0.43
0.55g gMJMJ-1
Esp 2, 3 species
Above-ground NPP (t ha-1 yr-1)

WA, E. glo, 3 spacings
Vic, E.glo, 4 fertilities
25
20
15
10
5
0
0
1
2
3
4
Intercepted radiation (GJ yr-1 )
30
Gross primary production

Use of LUE a key simplification
in 3-PG


also known as “canopy quantum
efficiency” denoted by C
GPP proportional to intercepted
radiation:
Intercepted
light
T, VPD,
H2 O, N
Pg  C (1  e  kL )Q0
aC depends on site & climatic
conditions
C  fT fF fN min{fD , f }fageC x

LAI
Light interception
Photosynthesis
Gross primary
production
CO2
Respiration
Net primary
production
31
Net primary production


3-PG assumes constant fraction Y (=0.47) of
GPP is lost as construction & maintenance
respiration
Net primary production is then
Pn  YPg  Y (1  e

 kL
)Q0
Y probably varies seasonally with temperature

this would be an issue for a daily version of 3-PG
32
3-PG growth modifiers
Each environmental factor is represented by a growth
modifier, i.e. a function of the factor which varies
between 0 (total limitation) and 1 (no limitation).
Factor
Modifier
Parameters
Vapor pressure deficit
fD(D)
kD
Soil water
f()
max , c , n
Temperature
fT(Tav)
Tmin , Topt , Tmax
Frost
fF(df)
kF
Site nutrition
fN(FR)
fN0
Stand age
fage(t)
nage , rage
33
Effects on production
All modifiers affect canopy production:
 C  fT f F f N min{ f D , f } f age Cx
where Cx is maximum canopy quantum efficiency.
In 3-PG the combination of modifiers called “PhysMod “
  min{ f D , f } f age
also affects canopy conductance.
34
Temperature growth modifier
 Ta  Tmin  Tmax  Ta
fT (Ta )  
 T  T 
 T  T
opt
min

 max opt



(Tmax Topt ) (Topt Tmin )
where
Ta = mean monthly daily temp.
Tmin = minimum temp. for growth
Topt = optimum temp. for growth
Tmax = maximum temp. for growth
Temperature modifier (f T)
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
Tmin = 7.5,
0.2
Topt = 15,
Tmax = 35
0.0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Mean temperature
35
Frost growth modifier
f F (d F )  1  k F (d F / 30)
1.0
dF = number of frosty days
in month
kF = number of days of
production lost for each
day of frost
0.8
Frost modifier (fF )
where
0.6
0.4
0.2
kF = 1
0.0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Days of frost in month
36
Soil-water growth modifier
f ( ) 
1
1   (1   /  x ) / c 
n
where
water
c = relative water deficit for
50% reduction.
n = power determining shape
of soil water response
Soil water growth modifier (f SW )
 = current available soil water
x = maximum available soil
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
Sand
Sandy-loam
0.2
Clay-loam
Clay
0.0
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Relative available soil water
37
VPD growth modifier
f D ( D)  e
 kD D
where
D = current VPD
kD = strength of VPD response
VPD growth modifier (f VPD )
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
k D = 0.05
0.0
0
2
4
6
8
10
Vapor pressure deficit (mBar)
38
Age-related growth modifier
1
f age (t ) 
nage
1  (t / raget x )
where
nage = power determining
strength of growth
reduction
Age-related modifier
t = current stand age
tx = likely max. stand age
rage = relative stand age for
50% growth reduction
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
nage = 4,
0.2
rage = 0.95
0.0
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Relative stand age
39
Biomass Partitioning
NPP is partitioned into biomass pools (tDM ha-1)
 foliage (WF),
 above-ground woody tissue (WS)
 roots (WR)
Partitioning rates (F, R, S) depend on site & growth
conditions, and stand DBH.
Litter-fall (F) and root-turnover (R) also taken into
account. Thus:
WF  F Pn   FWF
WR  R Pn   RWR
WS  S Pn
40
Allocation in 3-PG

A simple-minded approach reproduces well-established
responses to site conditions

H2O, FR
Net primary
production
F/S

DBH
Roots
Foliage
Stem
Stocking


root allocation determined
by fertility & ASW
poor conditions favour
below-ground growth
foliage:stem allocation
determined by tree size
large trees have more
allocation to stem wood
Dynamic changes in allocation typically observed in thinning or pruning
responses are not reproduced because allocation depends on tree size
41
Root allocation
Root allocation affected by growth conditions
through  and by soil fertility through m
RxRn
R 
Rn  (Rx  Rn )m
m = m0 + (1-m0)FR
Rx = root allocation under
poor conditions
Rn = root allocation under
optimal conditions
Root partitioning
where
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
Rx = 0.8
0.2
Rn = 0.23
0.0
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Growth conditions
42
Foliage and stem allocation
Above-ground allocation is based on foliage:stem
partitioning ratio
pFS   F / S  a p B
np
 B is diameter at breast height determined from an
allometric relationship between stem mass and B
 ap, bp are coefficients determined from pFS at B = 2 & 20
cm
Then
1  R
S 
, F  pFSS
1  pFS
43
Tree-size and allocation
Increasing DBH decreases foliage allocation and increases
stem allocation. Graphs show response when
pFS(2) = 1, pFS(20) = 0.2, R = 0.4
Ab o ve-g ro u n d p artitio n in g
0 .6
1 .0
p artitio n in g
R atio o f fo liag e:sh o o t
1 .2
0 .8
0 .6
0 .4
0 .2
0 .0
0 .5
S te m
0 .4
0 .3
0 .2
F o lia g e
0 .1
0 .0
0
10
20
S te m d ia m e te r
30
0
10
20
30
S te m d ia m e te r
44
Litter-fall & root-turnover
Litter-fall an age-dependent fraction of foliage biomass
 Fx F 0
1   Fx 
 F (t ) 
, k
ln 1 

 kt
 F 0  ( Fx   F 0 )e
t F   F 0 
where
(may be stress-related)
tF = age when F=½(F0+Fx)
Root-turnover constant fraction of
root biomass (R=0.015 month-1)
Litter-fall rate/month
F0 = litter-fall rate at age 0
Fx = maximum litter-fall rate,
0.03
0.02
F0 = 0.002
 Fx = 0.027
0.01
t  F = 12
0.00
0
1
2
3
Stand age (years)
4
45
The basic C-balance equations

These are equations for
the 3-PG carbon balance
submodel



includes light interception,
assimilation, biomass
allocation & mortality
C & R determined from
site conditions
, F, S, R & N possibly
age-dependent and/or
stress-related
PN  C (1  e  kWF )YQ
WF  F PN   FWF
WR  R PN   RWR
WS  S PN
N   N N
S  (1  R ) (1  pFS )
F  pFS (1  R ) (1  pFS )
w s  WS N  as B ns
pFS  aFS B nFS
46
Water balance


Soil water balance model has a single soil-layer
Simple balance between rainfall, irrigation and
evapotranspiration
Transpiration
W  max Wx ,W  R  I  ET 



No understory or bare soil
Excess over maximum storage
lost as runoff or drainage
Canopy interception a % of
rainfall and depends on LAI
up to a maximum
Understory
evaporation
Rainfall
Soil
evaporation
Watertable access
47
Water balance…

(continued)
Evapotranspiration determined from a PenmanMonteith equation and canopy conductance



driven by incident solar
radiation
driven by LAI through
canopy conductance
conductance affected
by site & environmental
factors through growth
modifiers
Conduct-_
ance
+
_
VPD
PhysMod
+
+
Rain
+
Relative
ASW
_
+
Actual
ET
48
Water balance…
(concluded)
Boundary layer conductance is constant (0.2 m s-1)
gC = gCx  min{L/LgC , 1}
where
 = min{fVPD, fSW} fage
gCx = maximum canopy
conductance
LgC = LAI at maximum
conductance
Canopy conductance (m s -1)
Canopy conductance affected by VPD, soil water and
stand age through , and increases with canopy LAI
gCx
LgC
Canopy leaf area index (L)
49
Stem mortality in 3-PG

3-PG includes density independent mortality through
probability of death


potentially age and stress related
Stem mortality in 3-PG is based on the self-thinning law

driven by stocking via single-tree stem mass
_
_
max stem
mass
mean stem
mass
+
Stocking
_
_
+
Mortality
Growth
+
+
Live stems
Dead stems
50
Modelling mortality


Two types of mortality:

density independent

density dependent or self thinning
Density-independent mortality

due to random or stress-related effects

modelled by probability of death N so that
N = - NN

N increased in times of stress, e.g. in response
to low long-term average f
51

Self thinning-line gives
maximum single-tree stem
mass (kg/tree) at current
stocking
wSx(N) = wSx0(1000/N)3/2
where wSx0 is max. stem
mass at 1000 trees ha-1

When wS > wSx(N), stocking
is reduced. Thus


at 1: no mortality
Average stem mass (kg tree-1)
Self thinning mortality
self-thinning
line
2'
wSx(N')
2
mortality reduces
population to selfthinning line
wSx(N)
1
no mortality
N'
N
Stocking (trees ha-1)
at 2: mortality reduces
population to 2’
52
Calculation of stem volume

Stem volume calculated either from


allometric relationship w.r.t stand DBH,
or from density using
V = (1 - pBB)WS/r
where pBB is fraction of stem biomass in branch and
bark and r is stem density

Note that pBB and r can vary widely across a
site and calulcation of stem volume from WS
can be error prone.
53
Final comments

Some areas I have not covered in detail, e.g.





details of Penman-Monteith equation
rainfall interception by canopy
an attempt to account for partial canopies (which
does not work well)
However, the above gives a good coverage of
the basics of 3-PG.
See a separate PowerPoint file for a discussion
of assigning species-specific parameters.
54