European Disability Forum EDF response to the European Commission Staff Working Paper : Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04/08 EN June 2004 "States should recognise the rights of organisations of persons with disabilities to represent persons with disabilities at national, regional and local levels. States should also recognise the advisory role of organisations of persons with disabilities in decision-making on disability matters." Rule 18 of the United Nations Standard Rules on the Equalisation of Opportunities for Persons with Disabilities European Disability Forum > > Forum Européen des Personnes Handicapées rue du Commerce 39-41 — B-1000 Brussels T +32-2-282.4600 F +32-2-282.4609 E [email protected] W www.edf-feph.org E uropean D isability F orum List of contents 1. Introduction ......................................................................................................... 3 2. General Remarks ................................................................................................ 4 3. Comments on the draft Regulation ................................................................... 5 4. Accessibility of Airports and Aircraft .............................................................. 13 5. Conclusion......................................................................................................... 14 ANNEX I: About EDF and other documentation ................................................. 15 DOC EDF 04/08 EN EDF Response to the European Commission Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air The document is available in English, and on diskette or in large-print upon demand from the EDF Secretariat, and on the EDF Website at: http://www.edf-feph.org © Copyright European Disability Forum 2004. This document may be quoted and reproduced, provided the source is given. EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 2 E uropean D isability F orum 1. Introduction The European Disability Forum (EDF), the umbrella body of the European disability movement, very much welcomes the European Commission Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility When Travelling by Air, issued in January 2004. This Paper represents the important work and commitment the European Commission has shown over the years to develop measures and initiatives to secure the rights of passengers with reduced mobility (PRMs) in all modes of transport – particularly by in the field of air travel. Disabled people have the same rights as other persons to freedom of movement and freedom of choice. This applies to air travel as to all other areas of life. Discrimination towards people with disabilities in air travel must be prohibited. There are and have been a number of incidents where disabled persons have experienced discrimination when travelling by air. Disabled persons have been refused booking or refused carriage due to their disability. There have been incidents where disabled persons have been charged for the assistance they require or for the use of installations needed to facilitate access on the ground or in the air. Disabled persons have experience poor levels of assistance and infrastructural barriers in airports and on aircraft. The proposals for a draft Regulation as presented in the Staff Working Paper upholds two fundamental principles which EDF is pressing for: that disabled persons must not be refused booking or refused carriage because of their disability; and that disabled persons must not be charged directly for the assistance they require. In this paper EDF elaborates upon its response to the European Commission Staff Working Paper and identifies points on which EDF believes there should be clarification or improvement. EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 3 E uropean D isability F orum 2. General Remarks Following the consultation process of the European Commission begun in 2002, a public hearing was held by the European Commission in March 2003 between airlines, airports and consumer groups, at which EDF participated. All parties at the Hearing, including the air industry, generally expressed a positive attitude towards the need for European non-discrimination legislation where it concerned disabled air travellers. Such legislation would clearly set down rules to prohibit discrimination of disabled travellers; prohibit unjustified denied boarding of disabled travellers; prohibit direct charging of disabled passengers for the assistance they may require in the airport; and set down clear rules and guidelines to define minimum standards for assistance on the ground and on board the aircraft. EDF strongly believes that certain matters relating to disabled air travellers or travellers with reduced mobility cannot be addressed through voluntary commitments and must be addressed through European legislation. This view was shared by the European Commission and the air industry in general. Some key issues EDF has identified: EDF notes that unjustifiable reasons on grounds of safety and security are used, on a regular basis, to discriminate against disabled air passengers and deny disabled passengers the right to board an aircraft or to present restrictions on seat allocation. In some cases, disabled passengers are even required to sign a declaration that they will not trouble non-disabled passengers. This practice is unjustifiable and discriminatory. Many cases are reported to EDF of disabled passengers being provided with inadequate assistance or of disabled passengers being left without any assistance provision whatsoever. Airlines should not be permitted to charge extra for assistance services rendered to disabled people. EDF has noted that this is sometimes the case among low cost airlines. EDF regularly receives reports of damaged wheelchairs and damage to other mobility equipment or assistive devices due to poor handling during transit. Airlines must be made liable to refund disabled passengers the full cost of loss or damage of such equipment which has been damaged or destroyed during transport by the airline. EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 4 E uropean D isability F orum 3. Comments on the draft Regulation Article 2 : Definition The term "person with reduced mobility" has been widely used in European Community and European Civil Aviation conference (ECAC) documents. Some concerns have been raised by disability organisations that the term ‘persons with reduced mobility’ is not sufficiently clear. There has been some concern that the term does not, in an explicit-enough way, relate to those individuals who are blind, partially sighted, deaf, hard of hearing, or those who have an intellectual disability as such individuals do not necessarily experience limited "mobility" when travelling. Therefore, EDF stresses that the diversity of disability must be recognised in the draft Regulation and that the term "person with reduced mobility" should be interpreted broadly to include all disabled passengers whose orientation, communication or mobility may be reduced when travelling by air. EDF notes also that the term "intellectual deficiency" used in the draft Regulation is inappropriate. EDF wishes to point out that in recent European Community legislation there has been a clear move away from use of the term "deficiency" in relation to disabled persons. EDF would encourage the European Commission to work towards a consistency in its use of terms and definitions so that they are as inclusive as possible. Both the Bus and Coaches Directive (2001/85/EC)1 and the recent Proposal for a Regulation on International Passengers' Rights and Obligations (COM (2004) 143 final)2 use the phrase "intellectual impairment" rather than "deficiency". Furthermore the air passenger voluntary service commitments of the airlines and airports also use the term ‘intellectual impairment’ in their definition of persons with reduced mobility. 1 Directive 2001/85/EC (Bus and Coach Directive) relating to special provisions for vehicles used for the carriage of passengers comprising more than eight seats in addition to the driver's seat; Official Journal L 042, 13/02/2002 P. 0001 – 0102, Annex I, 2.21: "Passenger with reduced" mobility means all people who have difficulty when using public transport, such as disabled people (including people with sensory and intellectual impairments, and wheelchair users), people with limb impairments, people of small stature, people with heavy luggage, elderly people, pregnant women, people with shopping trolleys, and people with children (including children seated in pushchairs); 2 Proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on International Rail Passengers’ Rights and Obligations, COM (2004) 143 final, Article 2.21: "person with reduced mobility" means any person whose mobility is reduced due to physical, sensory or locomotory incapacity, to an intellectual impairment, age, illness, or any other cause of disability when using transport and whose situation needs special attention and the adaptation to a person’s need of the service made available to all passengers; EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 5 E uropean D isability F orum Article 3 : Prevention of refusal of carriage Disabled persons have a fundamental right to equality of access to air travel with non-disabled persons. Air carriers, agents and tour operators must not discriminate towards disabled passengers on the basis of their disability and must provide equality of access. EDF welcomes express recognition in the Commission’s Working Paper and proposed Regulation on the right to board for disabled passengers. People with disabilities and other passengers with reduced mobility must be protected against discriminatory denied boarding which continues to take place all too often. EDF supports Article 3(1) of the draft Regulation which prohibits refusal of booking or boarding by air carriers on the grounds of reduced mobility. However, EDF is greatly concerned that Article 3(4) provides that air carriers are able to refuse to accept a reservation or to embark a person with reduced mobility in order to meet requirements related to "safety, security, health, or working conditions" and that these requirements can be based on national legislation. EDF is concerned about the substantial lack of transparency in the interpretation of "requirements related to safety, security, health, or working conditions." This lack of transparency seriously undermines the prohibition of denied boarding set out in Article 3. EDF is concerned that disability is frequently equated with "illness" and that on this basis air carriers refuse to board disabled passengers. Disabled people face situations of denied boarding on the basis of arbitrary and unspecified health and safety grounds which are discriminatory. Such unjustifiable and unspecified health and safety reasons are also used to impose restrictions on seat allocation. Furthermore, different airlines exercise use of health and safety to restrict the conditions of carriage of disabled passengers in different and divergent ways which compounds the confusion and lack of transparency in the implementation of health and safety rules by airlines. EDF is concerned that national health and safety legislation could be used to justify refusal of boarding, resulting in highly diverging reasons and cases of denied boarding from between Member States. There is a risk that the same airline may refuse to carry a disabled passenger in one country but not in another. This is in direct contradiction with the principle of harmonisation at Community level of rules protecting air passengers. It is also in contradiction of the objective of a single market without barriers and of the fundamental principle of free movement within the EU for all citizens. EDF would like to see a streamlining and clarification of the diversity of rules governing health and safety in air travel which are currently far from transparent. EDF would favour EU harmonised rules in this area. EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 6 E uropean D isability F orum EDF notes that the carriage of certified service dogs is subject to national regulation as explained and confirmed by Annex 2 of the draft Regulation. EDF would emphasise the need for consistency and transparency at the national level of such restrictions. Passengers with disabilities need to have confidence in their ability to travel by air across all Member States and so must be fully informed of such national regulations. EDF also calls for guarantees within the main text of Regulation that certified service dogs shall be carried in the cabin, free of charge. EDF fully supports the obligation placed on air carriers to inform, in writing, passengers who are refused carriage. Also for the air carriers to inform the passenger concerned, in writing, of the reasons for that refusal of carriage. The air carriers must also make publicly available the safety rules that apply to the transport of persons with reduced mobility as well as any restrictions on the carriage of persons with reduced mobility caused by the size of the aircraft or the absence of cabin crew. Article 9 foresees the possibility of making a complaint to a "competent body designated by a Member State" about an alleged infringement of this Regulation as well as requiring that Member States lay down sanctions for cases of infringement. EDF urges the Commission to ensure that such competent bodies will have the mandate to address cases of unjustified denied booking or boarding on the basis of safety, security, health, or working conditions and that sanctions can be imposed. The need for disability awareness training of staff EDF would also like to highlight the lack of awareness about disability which exists among airline and airport staff. Misconceptions about disability frequently lead to discriminatory denied boarding particularly in cases of group travel (for example, EDF has received reports about staff suggesting there are security concerns when several people who are deaf, blind or who have intellectual disabilities travel together). Appropriate training of staff is crucial and it can contribute significantly to better understanding the needs of disabled passengers while ensuring their safety, independence and dignity. EDF urges that the Regulation require comprehensive staff training for those who provide assistance and services to disabled passengers. One important element of any training scheme should be to emphasise that assistance should be applied flexibly and adjust to the diversity of disabilities and the needs of the individual disabled person. EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 7 E uropean D isability F orum Article 4 : Right to assistance at airports Notification requirement EDF suggests that the notification requirement of a disabled passenger's need for assistance of at least forty-eight hours before the published time of departure of the flight is unnecessary. EDF notes there is a risk that certain disabled people may be unnecessarily denied assistance by the existence of such a notification requirement. Such a notification period should be limited only to those people who require assistance that involves significant pre-planning. For example, this would include passengers who need continuous support from arrival at the airport entry point to the departure gate, or substantial assistance to board the plane (e.g. a high-loader lift). A notification period of forty-eight hours should not apply to those disabled person who require less assistance. For example, deaf people who need help with documentation at check-in and information about which departure gate to use; or independent wheelchair users who only need their wheelchair placed in the hold at the point at which they board the plane. EDF proposes that 24 hours is a more reasonable period of time for such notification. Flight booking If pre-notification of assistance is required then it must be possible for disabled people to easily communicate their assistance needs during the booking process. This applies in particular when a booking is made on the internet. Where booking is made by phone, it should be possible to provide all the necessary information about the assistance required in the same call. This may imply prompts in the booking systems used by travel and booking agents to allow them to input the appropriate information. Flight booking is not only made in person or on the phone. One of the reasons for the decrease in air travel prices is the fact that passengers can book themselves onto a flight and arrange payment via the internet. This type of booking often causes problems for persons with disabilities. Firstly, the booking websites of air carriers are not always designed to be accessible to disabled people who cannot read print (e.g. blind or partially sighted persons or persons with learning disabilities). As a consequence, such persons cannot take advantage of reduced fares available to others and who, therefore, experience economic discrimination. EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 8 E uropean D isability F orum Secondly, disabled people who want to book over the internet are often expected to make an additional phone call to give details of their assistance needs (this may be costly and the hours may be limited). Web inaccessibility and extra cost and inconvenience may result in discouraging passengers with disabilities to travel with those particular air carriers. EDF urges that the Regulation require that air carrier and affiliated booking agencies ensure their internet booking sites to be fully accessible, ie that these internet booking sites must comply with the Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI) guidelines. In addition to the measures suggested for phone-booking, the Regulation should also ensure that it is possible to register notification of the need for assistance by internet. Certain airlines already implement detailed assistance-booking options on the internet. Article 5 : Responsibility for assistance at airports EDF welcomes the clear and strong commitment in the Staff Working Paper to the fundamental principle that passengers with disabilities should not be directly charged for assistance. EDF supports the scheme set out in Article 5 of the draft Regulation whereby costs of the assistance, to be provided free of charge to persons with reduced mobility, shall be shared among the air carriers using an airport; directly in proportion to the total number of passengers carried to and from that airport in the preceding year. EDF recognises a number of advantages in the proposal to centralise provision of assistance within airports by assigning responsibility for the service to managing bodies of airports. Such an approach would ease seamless travel for disabled travellers as provision of assistance would no longer start from the point of check-in but from the point of set-down. In order to resolve the cost issue, assistance to PRMs should be considered as part of the general running costs of the airport. Ultimately, EDF advocates for provision of assistance that contributes to seamless travel for disabled passengers who begin their journey at the entrance to the airport (or airport car park, bus stop, or railway station) and who may require assistance with, for example, flight check-in, security clearance, passport control, customs control, baggage retrieval, locating the departure gate or making a transfer to another flight (perhaps even to a different terminal). EDF considers that a centralised charging system must require the participation of ALL carriers and that any possibility for carriers to opt out of the centralise charging scheme and, thereby, not pay the central charge would lead to a deterioration in the overall quality of service for disabled persons to be supported by the scheme. The advantage of a centralised charging scheme is that it will provide a quality of the service towards disabled EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 9 E uropean D isability F orum passengers guaranteed at certain standard which ALL carriers must subscribe to. EDF believes that any possibility for airlines to opt out of the scheme would severely water down the central scheme and lead to its deterioration which will have negative consequences for disabled passengers. In relation to Article 5(4), EDF welcomes the setting of quality standards which will contribute to ensuring a reliable and high level of assistance to passengers with disabilities. EDF supports requirement in the draft Regulation that such quality standards are to be set by the managing body of the airport only after consultation with organisations representing passengers with reduced mobility and airport users. EDF is concerned that in cases where an Airport Users Committee does not exist, such consultation might not be structured or transparent. It is extremely important that, in the setting of quality standards, internationally recognised policies and codes of conduct – in particular the European Civil Aviation Conference (ECAC) guidance Document 30, Section 5 "Facilitation of the transport of persons with reduced mobility" including its relevant Annexes – be fully taken into consideration. EDF would like to see the section on quality standards further elaborated to more clearly address the issue of monitoring and reporting. Relevant and detailed performance indicators should be used for regular performance monitoring by independent competent persons and organisations. In addition, performance reports of each airport should be permanently and prominently displayed in public areas of airports and on the internet. A benchmarking system of both costs and services to stimulate competition and quality improvements should be encouraged. A uniformity of quality standards should be ensured within all airports and Member States. This will ensure that disabled passengers throughout Europe can count on high quality standards of assistance, and such uniformity will contribute to the objective of harmonisation of air passengers rights within the European Community. Article 6 : Assistance by air carriers Accompanying person EDF would like to highlight the fact that “safety requirements” have often been used as a justification for requiring a disabled passenger to travel with an accompanying person. EDF believes that this is only necessary in certain exceptional cases and urges that the Regulation require that air carriers be required to provide written justification when the airline requires that a passenger with a disability must travel accompanied. EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 10 E uropean D isability F orum EDF further submits that, in cases where an air carrier requires that a passenger with a disability must travel accompanied by a second person, and in line with the principle of no direct charging for assistance, the accompanying person should travel free of charge or at least have a significant reduction in fare. Annex 1 : Assistance at airports Assistance EDF urges that Annex 1 must represent a minimum level of service and that assistance provided should be based on the expressed needs of individual passengers with disabilities. EDF notes there is a diversity of disability and that different individuals will require differing degrees of assistance. An openness is required, on the part of the person providing assistance, to communicate with the disabled passenger to find out how best to assist. EDF has documented many examples of passengers with disabilities who have been obliged, against their will, to use assistance they do not need (e.g. a blind passenger who needs assistance with way-finding being forced by an assistance-provider to sit in a wheelchair rather than being guided to the departure gate). This type of practice is unacceptable and the Regulation should explicitly acknowledge that different passengers will require different types of assistance. The overall objective must remain to assist the passenger while at the same time respecting their independence and dignity. Temporary replacement of damaged or lost mobility equipment Annex 1 only provides for "temporary replacement of damaged or lost mobility equipment." Experience illustrates that damage to mobility equipment will often result in a disabled passenger incurring significant costs. EDF urges that the Regulation provide that, in cases of damage to mobility equipment, disabled passengers be compensated the full cost of loss or damage of such equipment. Accessibility of information needed to take flights EDF underlines that accessible information is crucial for passengers who are blind, partially sighted, deaf, hard of hearing or who have intellectual disability. Architectural barriers within an airport or aircraft are easy to identify but communication barriers are not so obvious. If adequate information is not made available in visual as well as audible format, there is a risk that a passenger with a disability could miss a flight because of a delay or gate-change. Information and communication during the whole travel chain must be accessible to all passengers with disabilities. This includes, for example, internet booking, EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 11 E uropean D isability F orum information related to departure times and delays, and information and documentation provided at check-in and ticket desks. Information announcements should be complemented by display of the same information on a monitor. Print material should be available in alternate format. Telephones should be accessible and text phones and fax should be available to the public within the airport. With the centralised provision of assistance as proposed in the Staff Working Paper, EDF underlines the need for airports to have Information Desks located near airport entrance/access points to enable passengers with disabilities to enquire about assistance upon arrival and to obtain necessary flight information. Such Information Desks should have basic information about the airport available in alternate format and should have a staff member who can communicate with International Sign Language (ISL). Annex 2 : Assistance on board aircraft Certified dogs As stated above, EDF objects to the carriage of certified service dogs being subject to national regulations. Mobility equipment EDF is concerned that air carriers seek to limit the carriage of mobility equipment, without justification in certain cases. In the interests of transparency and to avoid unjustified denial of boarding, EDF urges that air carriers be required to publicly, and in detail, outline any restrictions on the carriage of mobility equipment. Accessibility of information concerning flights Air carriers are required to provide, free of charge, the assistance/services specified in Annex 2 which includes the "communication of information concerning a flight in accessible formats." EDF underlines that the accessibility of information is crucial for those passengers who are blind, partially sighted, deaf, hard of hearing or who have intellectual disability. EDF would like to emphasise that "information concerning a flight" should be interpreted broadly within the Regulation to include, for example:providing all printed information (including safety brochures) in alternative formats such as large print and Braille as well as ensuring that they are provided EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 12 E uropean D isability F orum with pictorial content and plain language; providing a tactile map of the cabin; ensuring that at least one crew member can communicate in basic international sign language with passengers who use sign language; ensuring that all video information during the flight has subtitles and signed PIP (picture in picture); requiring that on-board alarms are active both visually and audibly. Airlines should be encouraged to include sign language as one of the language options for crew members to learn. Seating In Annex 2, the draft Regulation links seating arrangements for disabled passengers to "safety requirements". EDF has noted an inconsistency among air carriers in their restriction of seating of disabled passengers on board aircraft. Certain airlines insist that passengers with disabilities sit in the window seat so as not to block the evacuation of other passengers in an emergency situation. Other airlines insist that passengers with disabilities sit only in the aisle seat to simplify transfers from on-board wheelchairs. These practices are not only arbitrary and inconsistent but are discriminatory. EDF urges that the Regulation uphold the principle that passengers with disabilities should not be unreasonable restricted in their choice of seating in the aircraft. 4. Accessibility of Airports and Aircraft Accessibility of the built environment is a fundamental prerequisite to eliminating discrimination. EDF is disappointed the draft Regulation does not address accessibility of airports and aircraft. Article 13 of the EC Treaty enables the Community to take initiatives to combat discrimination on the grounds of disability. EDF sees Article 13 as the legal base for any regulatory provision relating to the accessible built environment or accessible design. Many of the barriers disabled people face as air passengers can be easily overcome by means of simple adaptation of existing airports. Airport and aircraft design and layout can be made accessible to all through application of a Design for All approach. Architectural and design-related barriers can be prevented in all future construction. Actions taken to improve access to infrastructure, facilities and aircraft must be undertaken in consultation with organisations representing people with disabilities. EDF urges that this Regulation includes an obligation for the managing bodies of airports to ensure that new airports are planned, designed, constructed and managed in such a way that air travel is facilitated for all passengers, and that existing barriers are gradually eliminated. EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 13 E uropean D isability F orum The poor design of aircraft means that currently, for a majority of airlines, aircraft are not accessible. Accessibility features include, for example, toilets large enough for an on-board wheelchair, tactile symbols in cabin design (including seats and in toilets), high colour contrast interiors, or visual alarms. EDF also urges that the Regulation include an obligation for air carriers to purchase aircraft which meet accessibility standards. 5. Conclusion The European Disability Forum welcomes the Staff Working Paper which includes a draft proposal for a regulation on air passengers with reduced mobility. EDF calls on the EU institutions to support the approach of this draft Regulation whilst, at the same time, taking on board the specific additional proposals presented by EDF. The most essential of EDF demands are: that disabled persons must not be charged directly for the assistance they require; that disabled persons must not be refused booking or refused carriage because of their disability; that health, safety and security reasons cannot be used as a means to discriminate against disabled passengers. provision of a system that will provide seamless assistance for disabled air passengers throughout all stages of the journey, from the point of setdown to the point of pick-up. EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 14 E uropean D isability F orum ANNEX I: About EDF and other documentation A.1 About the EDF The European Disability Forum (EDF) is the European umbrella organisation representing the interests of 50 million disabled citizens in Europe. EDF membership includes national umbrella organisations of disabled people from all EU/EEA countries, accession countries and other European countries, as well as European NGOs representing the different types of disabilities. The mission of the European Disability Forum is to ensure disabled people full access to fundamental and human rights through their active involvement in policy development and implementation in Europe. A.2 Other relevant EDF documents: EDF response to the Proposal for a Regulation establishing common rules on compensation and assistance to air passengers in the event of denied boarding and cancellation or long delay of flights (COM(2001)784 final) (DOC EDF 02-02 – April 2002) EDF response to the European Commission consultation paper On Airlines’ Contracts with Passengers (DOC EDF 02-15 – October 2002) A.3 Contact person at the EDF Secretariat: Nora Bednarski, Policy Officer (T: +32-2-282.46.05 E-mail: [email protected]) More information about EDF is available on the EDF homepage at : www.edffeph.org Should you have any problems in accessing the documentation, please contact the EDF Secretariat. EDF response - Staff Working Paper: Rights of Persons with Reduced Mobility when Travelling by Air DOC EDF 04-08 – June 2004 15
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz