Screening and selection of growth-promoting bacteria for
ıt Dunaliella cultures
Myriam Le Chevanton, Matthieu Garnier, Gaël Bougaran, Nathalie Schreiber,
Ewa Lukomska, Jean-Baptiste Bérard, Eric Fouilland, Olivier Bernard,
Jean-Paul Cadoret
To cite this version:
Myriam Le Chevanton, Matthieu Garnier, Gaël Bougaran, Nathalie Schreiber, Ewa Lukomska,
et al.. Screening and selection of growth-promoting bacteria for ıt Dunaliella cultures. Algal
Research, Elsevier, 2013, 2, pp.212–222. <10.1016/j.algal.2013.05.003>. <hal-00852257>
HAL Id: hal-00852257
https://hal.inria.fr/hal-00852257
Submitted on 20 Aug 2013
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
"!
#$%&$!'()(&*+,!
:!
-+*((./.%!&.0!)($(+1/2.!23!%*241,56*2721/.%!8&+1(*/&!32*!!"#$%&'%%$(+9$19*()(!
;!
!
<!
)*(+'(,-'.$#/0#123()*(4$5#&'513(4*(60"7$5$#13(8*(9:-5'&;'513(<*(+"=0>?=$13(@*A6*(6B5$5C13(<*(
=!
D0"&%%$#CE3(F*(6'5#$5CG3(@*A(H*(,$C05'/1(
>!
!
?!
!
"
L!
@&82*&12/*(!0(!A,B)/2$2%/(!(1!0(!C/21(+,.2$2%/(!0()!#$%9()D!EF'GHG'D!*9(!0(!$IE$(!0IJ(9D!<<;KK!
P!
M#MNG-D!F*&.+(O!
"K!
!
:
""!
@&82*&12/*(!0IG+2$2%/(!0()!-B)1Q7()!H&*/.)!RS1/(*)D!TH'!=""P!GRU-JH!VT./W(*)/1X!H2.16($$/(*!
":!
:D!RM'-D!E'YD!EF'GHG'D!T./W(*)/1X!H2.16($$/(*!"ZD!-1&1/2.!HX0/1(**&.X(..(!0(!$IG.W/*2..(7(.1!
";!
@/112*&$D!:!*9(!0()!+,&.1/(*)D!;<:KK!-GNGD!F*&.+([!
"<!
!
;
"=!
C/2$2%/+&$!R2.1*2$!23!#*1/3/+/&$!G+2)B)1(7D!EM'E#D!CAKP;D!K>PK:!-UA\E#5#MNEAU@E-!+(0(]D!
">!
F*&.+(D!
"?!
!
"L!
!
"P!
^R2**()62.0/.%!&91,2*_!>I5&$>*%'*:-'.$#/0#J&K5'>'5*K5!/!6,2.(_!`!;;VKZ!:!<K!;?!<;!;>!/!!
:K!
F&]_!`;;VKZ:!<K!;?!<K!?"[!@&82*&12/*(!0(!A,B)/2$2%/(!(1!0(!C/21(+,.2$2%/(!0()!#$%9()D!EF'GHG'D!
:"!
*9(!0(!$IE$(!0IJ(9D!<<;KK!M#MNG-D!F*&.+([((
::!
(
:;!
!
"
:;!
Abstract
:<!
A*(W/29)!)190/()!,&W(!0(72.)1*&1(0!1,&1!8&+1(*/&!/.3$9(.+(!7/+*2&$%&$!7(1&82$/)7D!)9%%()1/.%!1,&1!1,(!
:=!
)($(+1/2.!&.0!+,&*&+1(*/a&1/2.!23!%*241,56*2721/.%!8&+1(*/&!),29$0!233(*!&!.(4!)1*&1(%B!32*!/76*2W/.%!
:>!
/.09)1*/&$! &$%&$! +9$1/W&1/2.[! E.! 1,(! 6*()(.1! )190BD! <L! +9$1/W&8$(! 8&+1(*/&! 4(*(! /)2$&1(0! 3*27! 7&*/.(!
:?!
7/+*2&$%&(!)6(+/()!&.0!/0(.1/3/(0!9)/.%!">-!*'M#!6,B$2%(.(1/+!&.&$B)/)[!N,(!*(+2W(*(0!8&+1(*/&!4(*(!
:L!
329.0!12!8(!7(78(*)!23!1,(! cA!&.0! iAH50/'0;$:/'5&$D!,I/0L-$7$AD%$.0;$:/'5&">A6$:/'50&C'?!VRFCZ!
:P!
&.0! %*&7562)/1/W(! 72.26,B$(1/+! +$9)1(*)[! N2! &00*())! 1,(! (33(+1! 23! 1,()(! 8&+1(*/&! 2.! 1,(! %*241,! 23!
;K!
!"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! /.0/W/09&$$BD! &.! (]6(*/7(.1&$! ,/%,51,*29%,691! 122$! 4&)! 0(W($26(0! 12! )/79$1&.(29)$B!
;"!
+276&*(!*(6$/+&1(0!&))2+/&1/2.)[!#!1425)1(6!&66*2&+,! 4&)! 9)(0! 12! 72./12*! %*241,! *&1(! &.0! 8/27&))!
;:!
&++979$&1/2.! 23! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! /.! 7/](0! +9$19*(! 4/1,! 8&+1(*/&D! 4,/+,! 6*2W(0! 1,(! ,/%,51,*29%,691!
;;!
0(W/+(! 12! 8(! &.! (33/+/(.1! 122$! 32*! 1,(! )($(+1/2.! 23! %*241,56*2721/.%! 8&+1(*/&[! Y(6(.0/.%! 2.! 1,(!
;<!
8&+1(*/&$! )1*&/.! /.W2$W(0D! /.,/8/12*B! (33(+1)! 4(*(! *(+2*0(0! 32*! 7&]/7&$! 7/+*2&$%&$! %*241,! *&1(D!
;=!
4,(*(&)! /.,/8/12*B! &.0! )1/79$&1/.%! (33(+1)! 4(*(! *(%/)1(*(0! 2.! 7/+*2&$%&$! 8/27&))! &++979$&1/2.! &.0!
;>!
./1*2%(.!/.+2*62*&1/2.[!U*%&./+!./1*2%(.!*(7/.(*&$/a&1/2.!8B!M%/'50>0#$?(?L[!-JKK?!&.0!)"5&:$"C$(
;?!
?L[!-J:<<!&*(!0/)+9))(0!12!(]6$&/.!1,(!,/%,(*!8/27&))!&.0!&772./97!/.+2*62*&1/2.!23!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*(
;L!
281&/.(0! 9.0(*! ./1*2%(.5$/7/1(0! +2.0/1/2.)[! N,()(! 8&+1(*/&! +29$0! 8(! +2.)/0(*(0! &)! ,($6(*)! 32*! M!
;P!
&++979$&1/2.!/.!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*!+($$)[!!
<K!
Keywords: H/+*2&$%&(D!!"#$%&'%%$D!8&+1(*/&D!/.1(*&+1/2.D!8&+1(*/&$!0/W(*)/1B!
<"!
Abbreviations: N7&]D!7&]/7&$!%*241,!*&1(O!ÄO7&]D!7&]/7&$!8/27&))!/.+*(&)(!&1!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(O!R_MD!
<:!
+&*82._./1*2%(.!*&1/2O!R,$!$D!+,$2*26,B$$!$!O!'#AYD!*&.027!&76$/3/+&1/2.!23!62$B72*6,/+!YM#[
<;!
!
:
<;!
1. Introduction
<<!
N,(*(! /)! &! 0/W(*)(! &**&B! 23! +9**(.1! &.0! 621(.1/&$! &66$/+&1/2.)! 32*! 7/+*2&$%&(D! 4,/+,! /.+$90(! 3220D!
<=!
&./7&$! 3((0D! ,(&$1,+&*(D! (.(*%B! &.0! 6,B+2*(7(0/&1/2.! b"c;d[! N,(! 8227! 23! 7/+*2&$%&$! W&$9(5&00/.%!
<>!
2W(*! *(+(.1! 0(+&0()! ,&)! 0*&4.! &11(.1/2.! 12! 1,(! )190B! 23! 8&+1(*/&57/+*2&$%&(! /.1(*&+1/2.)! /.! &66$/(0!
<?!
&$%&$!+9$1/W&1/2.!b<D=d[!C&+1(*/&!+&.!+276(1(!4/1,!7/+*2&$%&(!32*!1,(!$/7/1(0!*()29*+()! b>D?d!2*!(W(.!
<L!
6*209+(! 12]/+! )98)1&.+()! &%&/.)1! 7/+*2&$%&(! bLdD! &$$! 23! 4,/+,! +&.! 0(+*(&)(! +9$19*(! B/($0)[! #](./+!
<P!
7/+*2&$%&(!+9$19*()!&66(&*!12!8(!122!9.*(&$/)1/+!&.0!$&829*5/.1(.)/W(!32*!$&*%(5)+&$(!+9$1/W&1/2.D!891!1,(!
=K!
&00/1/2.! 23! )($(+1(0! 6*28/21/+! 8&+1(*/&! 7&B! 8(! 8(.(3/+/&$! 12! +9$19*()! 23! 7/+*2&$%&(! &)! &! 6*(W(.1/W(!
="!
&+1/2.! &%&/.)1! &.! /.,/8/1/.%! 8&+1(*/&$! 6269$&1/2.! bPD"Kd[! -9+,! &00(0! 8&+1(*/&! 7&B! &$)2! /.+*(&)(!
=:!
7/+*2&$%&(!%*241,!*&1()D!&.0!1,9)!(.,&.+(!+9$19*(!B/($0)D!1,*29%,!1,(!)B.1,()/)!23!%*241,56*2721/.%!
=;!
+27629.0)! b""c";d! )9+,! &)! W/1&7/.)D! 2*! 8B! /76*2W/.%! .91*/(.1! )966$B! 1,*29%,! *(7/.(*&$/a&1/2.! 23!
=<!
2*%&./+!./1*2%(.!(]+*(1(0!8B!7/+*2&$%&(!b"<d[!N,(!)1*2.%!/.3$9(.+(!1,&1!8&+1(*/&!+&.!,&W(!2.!7&]/7&$!
==!
%*241,!*&1(!&.0!+($$!0(.)/1B!23!0/33(*(.1!7/+*2&$%&(!)6(+/()!4&)!0(72.)1*&1(0!8B!@/9!'/($%*!V:KKLZ!8B!
=>!
1,(! &00/1/2.! 23! &! 6$:&%%"?! )1*&/.! 12! 7/+*2&$%&(! +9$19*()! b"=d[! #)/0(! 3*27! %*241,D! 21,(*! &)6(+1)! 23!
=?!
7/+*2&$%&$!7(1&82$/)7!7&B!8(!&33(+1(0!8B!8&+1(*/&!)9+,!&)!+($$!)/a(D!6/%7(.1!&.0!$/6/0!+2.1(.1D!&.0!
=L!
W&*/(1B! 23! 3&11B! &+/0)D! 28)(*W(0! /.! 1,(! &))2+/&1/2.! 23! ,-%05'%%$( ."%7$5&?! +($$)! 4/1,! MP0?L&5&%%">(
=P!
;5$?&%'#?'(b">dD!32*!(]&76$([!E.!&00/1/2.D!12]/.!6*209+1/2.!b"?dD!(]1*&+($$9$&*!)(+*(1/2.)!b"Ld!&.0!+($$!
>K!
&%%*(%&1/2.!b"Pd!&*(!&$$!6&*&7(1(*)!1,&1!7&B!621(.1/&$$B!8(!&33(+1(0!/.!7/+*2&$%&(!%*24.!/.!&))2+/&1/2.!
>"!
4/1,!)27(!,(1(*21*26,/+!6*2e&*B21()[!!
>:!
'(+(.1$BD! 1,(! +296$/.%! 23! &.&(*28/+! 0/%()1/2.! 12! 7/+*2&$%&(! 6*209+1/2.! ,&)! 8((.! )9%%()1(0! &)! &.!
>;!
(33/+/(.1! 7(&.)! 12! *(09+(! 1,(! ,9%(! &729.1)! 23! ./1*2%(.! *(f9/*(0! 32*! 7/+*2&$%&(58&)(0! 8/239($!
><!
6*209+1/2.!b:Kd[!N,(!6*262)(0!6*2+())!*()9$1)!/.!1,(!*(+B+$/.%!23!./1*2%(.!&.0!3$9]!23!&772./97!8&+e!
>=!
12!1,(!7/+*2&$%&(!+9$19*([!#00/1/2.&$$BD!1,(!9)(!23!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*(,&)!8((.!6*262)(0!32*!+&*82.!0/2]/0(!
>>!
&.0! &772./97! *(7(0/&1/2.! b:"dD! 8/239($! 6*209+1/2.! b::d! &.0! 7(1,&.(! 6*209+1/2.! b:;d[! E.0((0D!
>?!
!"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! (],/8/1! (+2$2%/+&$! W&$(.+(! 32*! 7&g2*! (.W/*2.7(.1&$! 3&+12*)! )9+,! &)! /**&0/&.+(D! 6\D!
>L!
)&$/./1B!&.0!1(76(*&19*(_!1,/)!7&e()!1,(7!%220!+&.0/0&1()!32*!$&*%(5)+&$(!+9$1/W&1/2.!b:<d!&.0!7(&.)!
>P!
1,&1!1,(B!+29$0!8(!+296$(0!12!&.&(*28/+!0/%()1/2.!&.0!.91*/(.1!*(+B+$/.%[!\24(W(*D!12!1,(!8()1!23!29*!
!
;
?K!
e.24$(0%(D! 1,(! )($(+1/2.! 23! %*241,56*2721/.%! 8&+1(*/&! ,&)! .21! 8((.! 9)(0D! 12! 0&1(D! &)! &! 7(1,20! 12!
?"!
/.+*(&)(!1,(!/.09)1*/&$!6*209+1/2.!23!!"#$%&'%%$!?L**!
?:!
E.! 1,(! 6*()(.1! )190BD! 4(! 32+9)(0! 2.! )($(+1/.%! 8&+1(*/&! 1,&1! 6*2721(! %*241,! 32*! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L[! -#h!
?;!
"P[;!/.!&!)6(+/3/+!+2.1(]1!_!1,(!+296$/.%!23!&.&(*28/+!0/%()1/2.!12!7/+*2&$%&(!6*209+1/2.[!E.!6&*1/+9$&*D!
?<!
4(! 1()1(0! 1,(! &8/$/1B! 23! 8&+1(*/&! 12! /.+*(&)(! %*241,! &.0! ./1*2%(.! /.+2*62*&1/2.! 32*! 1,/)! 7/+*2&$%&([!
?=!
#++2*0/.%$BD!&772./975$/7/1/.%!+2.0/1/2.)!4(*(!9)(0!12!(W&$9&1(!1,(!(33(+1)!23!8&+1(*/&[!N,/)!)190B!
?>!
4&)!&$)2!+2.09+1(0!4/1,291!W/1&7/.!(.*/+,7(.1!/.!2*0(*!12!1()1!32*!8&+1(*/&!&8/$/1B!12!)966$B!W/1&7/.)!
??!
12! 7/+*2&$%&([! N,(! 3/*)1! 6&*1! 23! 1,/)! *()(&*+,! +2.)/)1(0! 23! /)2$&1/.%! &.0! +,&*&+1(*/a/.%! +9$1/W&8$(!
?L!
8&+1(*/&! 3*27! W&*/29)! 7/+*2&$%&$! +9$19*()! 32*! )98)(f9(.1! 1()1/.%! /.! &))2+/&1/2.! 4/1,! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L[!
?P!
-#h!"P[;[!E.!&!,/%,51,*29%,691!(]6(*/7(.1!4(!3/*)1!)+*((.(0!&!$&*%(!.978(*!23!7/+*2&$%&(!5!8&+1(*/&!
LK!
&))2+/&1/2.)! 32*! 1,(/*! (33(+1! 2.! 7/+*2&$%&(! %*241,[! N,*((! )($(+1(0! 8&+1(*/&! )1*&/.)! 4/1,! 621(.1/&$!
L"!
%*241,!&$1(*/.%!(33(+1)!2.!!"#$%&'%%$!?L(4(*(!39*1,(*!1()1(0!/.!&!3$&)e!(]6(*/7(.1[!'()9$1)!,/%,$/%,1(0!
L:!
1,(! %*241,! &$1(*/.%! (33(+1)! 2.! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L[! -#h! "P[;! &.0! /.3$9(.+(! 23! 1,()(! 8&+1(*/&! 2.! ./1*2%(.!
L;!
/.+2*62*&1/2.!/.!7/+*2&$%&([!!
L<!
2. Materials and methods
L=!
2.1. Algal strain, maintenance and purification
L>!
!"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! -#h! "P[;! 4&)! 281&/.(0! 3*27! 1,(! +9$19*(! +2$$(+1/2.! 23! &$%&(! &1! 1,(! T./W(*)/1B! 23!
L?!
h2(11/.%(.!V-#hZ!h(*7&.BD!&.0!7&/.1&/.(0!&1!:K!iR!9.0(*!+2.1/.929)!$/%,1!4/1,!0&B$/%,1!3$92*()+(.1!
LL!
198()! V=K! j72$! 6,212.)! 75:)5"Z[! R9$19*()! 4(*(! 6(*32*7(0! /.! )1(*/$(! G*$(.7(B(*! 3$&)e)! 3/$$(0! 4/1,!
LP!
&*1/3/+/&$! )(&4&1(*! V#-kD! )&$/./1B! ;=Z! b:=d! 3/$1(*(0! &1! K[::! j7! &.0! (.*/+,(0! 4/1,! 720/3/(0! k&$.(I)!
PK!
7(0/97!b:>d[!#772./97!4&)!9)(0!&)!&!./1*2%(.!)29*+(!V"["?!7HZ!&.0!W/1&7/.)!4(*(!27/11(0[!N,(!
P"!
/./1/&$!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[(+9$19*(!281&/.(0!3*27!1,(!-#h!+2$$(+1/2.!4/$$!,(*(/.&31(*!8(!*(3(**(0!12!&)!l!1,(!
P:!
](./+!+9$19*([!
P;!
N2!($/7/.&1(!8&+1(*/&!/./1/&$$B!&))2+/&1(0!4/1,!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*!-#h!"P[;!&.0!12!281&/.!&](./+!+9$19*()D!
P<!
+($$)!4(*(!,&*W()1(0!8B!+(.1*/39%&1/2.!V=KK!%!32*!;!7/.!&1!:K!iRZ!g9)1!8(32*(!1,(!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(D!1,(.!
P=!
1*&.)3(**(0!12!&!3*(),!G*$(.7(B(*!3$&)e!+2.1&/./.%!(.*/+,(0!#-k!V&)!0()+*/8(0!&82W(Z!&.0!&!)6(+/3/+!
P>!
7/]! 23! &.1/8/21/+)! 8&)(0! 2.! R,2! '/( $%! b:?d_! ":=K! j%! &76/+/$$/.D! :=K! j%! %(.1&7B+/.D! =KK! j%!
!
<
P?!
e&.&7B+/.D!&.0!:=KK!j%!.(27B+/.!4(*(!&00(0!6(*!7@!23!+9$19*([!#!3/*)1!?50&B!&.1/8/21/+!1*(&17(.1!
PL!
4&)! +2.09+1(0D! 32$$24(0! 8B! &! :K50&B! 8&1+,! +9$19*(! 4/1,291! 1*(&17(.1[! R($$)! 4(*(! 1,(.! 4&),(0! 4/1,!
PP!
)1(*/$(! )(&4&1(*! 12! ($/7/.&1(! *(7&/./.%! 3*((! 8&+1(*/&! &.0! &! )(+2.0! ?50&B! 1*(&17(.1! 4&)! +2.09+1(0[!
"KK!
#8)(.+(!23!8&+1(*/&!4&)!W(*/3/(0!8B!(6/3$92*()+(.+(!7/+*2)+26B!9)/.%!-JC'h*((.¾!E!-1&/[email protected]&D!
"K"!
T-#Z!&.0!8B!6$&1/.%!2.!H&*/.(!#%&*!VCY!Y/3+2NH! :":"L=D!C(+12.!Y/+e/.)2.!&.0!R276&.BD!T-#Z[!
"K:!
A$&1()!4(*(!/.+98&1(0!32*!"K!0&B)!&1!:K!iR!8(32*(!28)(*W&1/2.[!
"K;!
2.2. Bacterial collection from microalgae culture: isolation and 16S rRNA analysis
"K<!
C&+1(*/&!4(*(!/)2$&1(0!3*27!"P!7&*/.(!72.2)6(+/3/+!7/+*2&$%&(!+9$1*()!7&/.1&/.(0!/.!1,(!$&82*&12*B[!
"K=!
H/+*2&$%&(! 4(*(! +9$1/W&1(0! /.! )1(*/$/a(0! )(&4&1(*! (.*/+,(0! 4/1,! k&$.(I)! 7(0/97! &1! :K! iR! 9.0(*!
"K>!
+2.1/.929)!$/%,1!V=K!j72$!6,212.)!75:)5"Z!&.0!/)2$&1/2.!4&)!6(*32*7(0!&1!1,(!(&*$B!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(!12!
"K?!
)($(+1!8&+1(*/&!1,&1!%*24!4($$!12%(1,(*!4/1,!7/+*2&$%&([!F*((!$/W/.%!8&+1(*/&!4(*(!/)2$&1(0!8B!6$&1/.%!
"KL!
](./+! 7/+*2&$%&(! +9$19*(! 2.! H&*/.(! #%&*! VCY! Y/3+2NH! :":"L=D! C(+12.! Y/+e/.)2.! &.0! R276&.BD!
"KP!
T-#Z!&1!:K!iR[!E)2$&1()!4(*(!+9$19*(0!/.!$/f9/0!H&*/.(!C*21,!VCY!Y/3+2NH!:?P""KD!C(+12.!Y/+e/.)2.!
""K!
&.0!R276&.BD!T-#Z!&.0!)12*(0!&1!5LK!iR!&31(*!&00/1/2.!23!=!m!Y/7(1,B$!)9$32]/0(!VY!L??PD!-/%7&5
"""!
#$0*/+,D!T-#Z[!!
"":!
F2*!(&+,!)1*&/.D!.9+$(/+!&+/0)!4(*(!(]1*&+1(0!8B!6,(.2$n+,$2*232*7!(]1*&+1/2.!32$$24(0!8B!/)26*26&.2$!
"";!
6*(+/6/1&1/2.! b:Ld[! #76$/3/+&1/2.! 23! 1,(! 8&+1(*/&$! ">-! *'M#! %(.(! 4&)! 6(*32*7(0! 9)/.%! 9./W(*)&$!
""<!
6*/7(*)!
""=!
hNN#RRNNhNN#Rh#RNN5;IZ!b:Pd[!N,(!AR'!7/]19*(!V:=!j@Z!4&)!+2762)(0!23!"KK!.%!YM#D!=K!
"">!
672$!23!(&+,!6*/7(*D!K[:!7H!23!(&+,!0MNAD!"[=!7H!23!H%RE:D! "]!23!h2N&fNH!C933(*!Vh2N&fNH!e/1D!
""?!
A*27(%&D!T-#Z!&.0!"[:=!9./1)!23!N&f!A2$B7(*&)(!Vh2N&fNH!e/1D!A*27(%&D!T-#Z[!#76$/3/+&1/2.!4&)!
""L!
+&**/(0!291!2.!&!1,(*72+B+$(*!VHBRB+$(*D!CEU5'#YZ!&++2*0/.%!12!1,(!32$$24/.%!6*2+(09*(_!=!7/.!&1!
""P!
P<!iRD!1,(.!;=!+B+$()!/.+$90/.%!;=!)!&1!P<!iRD!"!7/.!&1!=<!iR!&.0!"!7/.!;K!)!&1!?:!iRD!&.0!&!3/.&$!)1(6!
":K!
23!?!7/.!&1!?:!iR[!AR'!6*209+1)!4(*(!+,(+e(0!2.!&!K[Lm!&%&*2)(!($(+1*26,2*()/)!%($[!
":"!
N,(! &76$/3/(0! $(.%1,)! 23! YM#! 4(*(! 1,(.! )(f9(.+(0! &1! oA$&1(32*7(! C/2%(.29()1I! V'2)+233D! F*&.+(D!
"::!
,116_nn444[)85*2)+233[3*n6$&1(32*7()51(+,./f9()n%(.27/f9(5)8*[,17$Z! 2.! &.! #CE! A*/)7NH! ;"KK! h#D!
":;!
9)/.%! C/%YB(¾! N(*7/.&12*! W;["! +,(7/)1*B! V#66$/(0! C/2)B)1(7)Z! &.0! 1,(! -#0/*! 6*/7(*[! N&]2.27/+!
!
-#0/*!
V=I5#h#hNNNh#NR#NhhRNR#h#5;IZ!
=
&.0!
-"?!
'(W!
V= 5
":<!
+$&))/3/+&1/2.!4&)!6(*32*7(0!2.$/.(!4/1,!'/82)27&$!Y&1&8&)(!A*2g(+1!R$&))/3/(*!p(*)/2.!:[=!)2314&*(D!
":=!
,/(*&*+,/+&$! 1&]&! &))/%.7(.1! 8((/.%! 8&)(0! 2.! 'YA! .&qW(! C&B()/&.! *'M#! R$&))/3/(*! &.0! P=m!
":>!
+2.3/0(.+(!1,*(),2$0!4&)!)($(+1(0!b;Kd[!C@#-N!&.&$B)/)!4&)!6(*32*7(0!2.!698$/+!.*!0&1&8&)(!VG]6(+1!
":?!
1*(),2$0!"K!O!42*0!)/a(!:LO!H&1+,nH/)7&1+,!-+2*()!"D5:Z!&.0!+9$19*&8$(!)6(+/()!1,&1!%&W(!1,(!+$2)()1!
":L!
)(f9(.+(!4&)!9)(0!32*!)6(+/(!/0(.1/3/+&1/2.. !
":P!
2.3. High-throughput experiment (experiment 1)
";K!
2.3.1. Optical measurement for microalgae population
";"!
C&+1(*/&$! (33(+1)! 2.! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L[! -#h! "P[;! %*241,! 4(*(! &))())(0! 8B! &! )+*((./.%! (]6(*/7(.1!
";:!
V(]6(*/7(.1! "Z! 9)/.%! 7/+*26$&1()! +9$19*()[! C(+&9)(! 0/*(+1! 7(&)9*(7(.1! 32*! +&*82.! 8/27&))! 4&)! .21!
";;!
&W&/$&8$(!/.!7/+*26$&1(!4($$)D!4(!3/*)1!1()1(0!&#(.&.0!R,$!$!3$92*()+(.+(!V<=K!.7!5!>L=!.7Z!&.0!UY>LK!
";<!
/.! 2*0(*! 12! &))())! 7/+*2&$%&$! 8/27&))[! N,(! (]6(*/7(.1! &/7(0! &1! 0(3/./.%! 4,(1,(*! (/1,(*! 261/+&$!
";=!
7(&)9*(7(.1! %&W(! *($/&8$(! ()1/7&1/2.! 32*! 7/+*2&$%&(! 6269$&1/2.! /.! 7/](0! +9$19*(D! *(%&*0$())! 23!
";>!
8&+1(*/&$! 6269$&1/2.! _! 4(! 0()/%.(0! &! ::^! +(.1*&$! +2762)/1(! 0()/%.! &66*2&+,! 4,(*(! 7/+*2&$%&$! &.0!
";?!
8&+1(*/&$! +2.+(.1*&1/2.)! 4(*(! 1,(! 142! 3&+12*)[! F/W(! $(W($)! 4(*(! 9)(0! 32*! 1,(! *()6(+1/W(! 3&+12*)! 8B!
";L!
&00/.%! )25+&$$(0! )1&*562/.1)! 12! 1,(! )/76$(! V)f9&*(Z! :5$(W($! 3&+12*/&$! 0()/%.! 62/.1)! /.! 2*0(*! 12! &))())!
";P!
f9&0*&1/+!+2762.(.1[!N,*((!+(.1(*!62/.1!*(6$/+&1()!4(*(!&00(0!12!(W&$9&1(!(]6(*/7(.1&$!W&*/&.+([!N,(!
"<K!
0/)1&.+(! 8(14((.! +(.1(*! 62/.1)! &.0! )1&*! 62/.1)! 4&)! +&$+9$&1(0! 9)/.%! 1,(! &]/&$! 0/)1&.+(! cr"[<"<[!
"<"!
F/.&$$BD!""!(]6(*/7(.1)!4(*(!.((0(0!12!/.+2*62*&1(!1,/)!::^!+(.1*&$!+2762)/1(!0()/%.[!!
"<:!
#.!&](./+!+9$19*(!23!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!4&)!%*24.!2.!(.*/+,(0!#-k[!C&+1(*/&!V)1*&/.!-J"L;Z!4(*(!%*24.!
"<;!
2.! H&*/.(! C*21,! 32*! <L! ,! &1! :K! iRD! 1,(.! +(.1*/39%(0! V"KKKK! %D! =! 7/.D! :K! iRZ! 12! *(72W(! %*241,!
"<<!
7(0/97! &.0! *()9)6(.0(0! /.! #-k[! CB! 7/]/.%! 1,(! &](./+! 7/+*2&$%&$! +9$19*(! 12! 1,(! 8&+1(*/&$!
"<=!
)9)6(.)/2.D! 4(! 4(*(! &8$(! 12! &+,/(W(! 0/33(*(.1! 7/+*2&$%&(! &.0! 8&+1(*/&$! +2.+(.1*&1/2.! /.! )&76$()D! &)!
"<>!
),24.!/.!N&8$(!"[!Q#(.&.0!R,$!$!3$92*()+(.+(!V4&W($(.%1,_!(]+/1&1/2.!r!<=K!.7D!(7/))/2.!r!>L=!.7Z!
"<?!
&.0! UY>LK! 4(*(! 7(&)9*(0! /.! 7/](0! +9$19*()! 4/1,! &! NGR#M! VH&..(02*3! -4/1a(*$&.0Z!
"<L!
)6(+1*23$92*/7(1(*[!
!
>
"<P!
2.3.2. Experimental culture
"=K!
#!)6(+/3/+!,/%,51,*29%,691!(]6(*/7(.1&$!)(1596!4&)!0(W/)(0!12!&$$24!1,(!9)(!23!1,*((!7/+*26$&1()!12!
"="!
6(*32*7! 7/](0!+9$19*()!4/1,!*(6$/+&1()! 9.0(*!,272%(.29)!+2.0/1/2.)!23!/**&0/&.+(!&.0!1(76(*&19*([!
"=:!
k(! 1()1(0! &! 0/W(*)/1B! 23! 7/+*26$&1(! &.0D! 9$1/7&1($BD! )6(+/&$! 8$&+e! 7/+*26$&1()! VR2)1&*s! ;>"=D!
"=;!
R2*./.%sD! T-#Z! 4(*(! +,2)(.! 4/1,! +$(&*! 821127)! 7&0(! 23! >Km! 1,/..(*! 62$B)1B*(.(! 1,&.! )1&.0&*0D!
"=<!
*()9$1/.%! /.! $24(*! 8&+e%*29.0! 3$92*()+(.+(! *(&0/.%)[! N2! 6*(W(.1! +2.1&7/.&1/2.D! 4($$)! 4(*(! )(&$(0!
"==!
4/1,!&0,()/W(!3/$7!VH/+*2#76s!U61/+&$!#0,()/W(!F/$7D!#66$/(0!C/2)B)1(7)sD!T-#Z!)($(+1(0!32*!/1)!
"=>!
&00/1/2.&$! 6*21(+1/2.! &%&/.)1! (W&62*&1/2.D! 4,/+,! +&.! *(&+,! &)! 79+,! &)! L=! m! /.! ""! 0&B)! 4,(.! 9)/.%!
"=?!
)27(! 21,(*! 1/))9(! +9$19*(! 3/$7)[! @/%,1! 4&)! 6*2W/0(0! 8B! "K! 3$92*()+(.1! 198()! VU-'#H! @";knP=<Z!
"=L!
1,*29%,! 4,/1(! AHH#! 0/339)/2.! 6$&1()[! E**&0/&.+(! &.0! 1(76(*&19*(! 4(*(! 7(&)9*(0! 9)/.%! &! @/5R2*!
"=P!
@E"P;!f9&.197!)+&$&*!7(1(*!&.0!&!@H!;=Yt!)(.)2*D!*()6(+1/W($B[!N,(!)7&$$!)/a(!23!1,(!142!)(.)2*)!
">K!
&$$24(0!12!7(&)9*(!6&*&7(1(*)!/.)/0(!4($$)!3/$$(0!4/1,!#-k[!N,/)!)(1596!6*2W/0(0!&!7(&.!/**&0/&.+(!
">"!
23!=K!j72$!6,212.)!75:)5"!&.0!/**&0/&.+(!3/($0!,272%(.(/1B!4/1,!&!=[;!m!+2(33/+/(.1!23!W&*/&1/2.!V.!r!
">:!
""?Z[! N(76(*&19*(! 4&)! )(1! &1! "P[<! iRD! 4,/$(! 1(76(*&19*(! W&*/&1/2.! 8(14((.! 4($$)D! ()1/7&1(0! 8B! 1,(!
">;!
+2(33/+/(.1! 23! W&*/&1/2.D! 4&)! :[;! m! V.! r! ;LZ[! R9$19*()! 4(*(! 6(*32*7(0! )1&1/+&$$B! 4/1,! &9127&1/+!
"><!
),&e/.%! 6*/2*! 12! *(&0/.%)! 4/1,! N(+&.! 12! ,272%(./a(! +9$19*()! &.0! 12! 6*(W(.1! 8/23/$7! 32*7&1/2.! /.!
">=!
4($$)[!
">>!
N2! )1&*1! 1,(! (]6(*/7(.1D! 8&+1(*/&$! )1*&/.)! 4(*(! 6*(+9$19*(0! /.! H&*/.(! C*21,! 32*! <L! ,29*)! &1! :K! iR[!
">?!
C&+1(*/&$!+($$)!4(*(!1,(.!,&*W()1(0!8B!+(.1*/39%&1/2.!&1!;KKK!%!32*!=!7/.!&1!:K!iR[!#))2+/&1/2.)!4/1,!
">L!
1,(!&](./+!+9$19*(!23!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*(4(*(!7&0(596!&1!1,(!/./1/&$!*&1/2!23!&*29.0!"K!8&+1(*/&$!+($$)!6(*!
">P!
7/+*2&$%&$!+($$D!4/1,!&!+2.+(.1*&1/2.!23!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*!+($$)!23!:!"K=!+($$[7@5"!/.!821,!1,(!&](./+!&.0!
"?K!
7/](0! +9$19*()[! N,(! +9$19*(! 7(0/97! +2.)/)1(0! 23! #-k! (.*/+,(0! 4/1,! k&$.(I)! 7(0/97! 4/1,291!
"?"!
W/1&7/.)!&.0!720/3/(0!32*!./1*2%(.[!N2!1()1!8&+1(*/&!32*!1,(/*!&8/$/1B!12!*(7/.(*&$/a(!./1*2%(.D!+9$19*()!
"?:!
4(*(! %*24.! 9.0(*! ./1*2%(.! $/7/1&1/2.D! 4/1,! 1,(! &00/1/2.! 23! &772./97! 12! 281&/.! &! ./1*2%(.!
"?;!
+2.+(.1*&1/2.!23!=<?[L!jHD!*()9$1/.%!/.!&!72$&*!./1*2%(._6,2)6,2*9)!*&1/2!23!;[;_"[!-/.+(!1,(!&0,()/W(!
"?<!
3/$7!4&)!.21!6(*7(&8$(!12!%&)D!+&*82.!$/7/1&1/2.!4&)!6*(W(.1(0!8B!&00/.%!"K!7H!23!M&\RU;[!!
!
?
"?=!
h*241,!23!7/+*2&$%&(!4&)!72./12*(0!8B!&#(.&.0!R,$!$!3$92*()+(.+(!V4&W($(.%1,_!(]+/1&1/2.!r!<=K!.7D!
"?>!
(7/))/2.!r!>L=!.7D!NGR#M!H&..(02*3!-4/1a(*$&.0Z[!N,*((!7(&)9*(7(.1)!6(*!0&B!4(*(!6(*32*7(0!
"??!
09*/.%! 1,(! 3/*)1! "?! 0&B)! &.0! 2.(! 2*! 142! 7(&)9*(7(.1)! 6(*! 0&B! 9.1/$! 0&B! :K[! N()1/.%! 32*! 8&+1(*/&$!
"?L!
+2.1&7/.&1/2.!4&)!02.(!2.!H&*/.(!#%&*!6$&1()!&1!1,(!(.0!23!1,(!(]6(*/7(.1[!
"?P!
2.4. Flask cultures (experiment 2)
"LK!
2.4.1. Bacterial quotas
"L"!
A*($/7/.&*B! 7/+*2)+26/+! 28)(*W&1/2.)! *(W(&$(0! 1,&1! 8&+1(*/&$! )/a(! &.0! ),&6(! 4(*(! 0/33(*(.1! 32*! 1,(!
"L:!
1,*((!8&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)!-JKK;D!-JKK?!&.0!-J:<<[!k(!*(+2*0(0!1,&1!72*(!1,&.!P=m!23!8&+1(*/&!+($$)!/.!
"L;!
7/](0! +9$19*()! 4(*(! *(1&/.(0! 2.! 6*(+2789)1(0! hFnR! 3/$1(*)[! E.! 2*0(*! 12! (W&$9&1(! 1,(! +2.1*/891/2.!23!
"L<!
8&+1(*/&!12!121&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!R!&.0!M!*(+2W(*(0!2.!hFnR!3/$1(*)D!4(!&))())(0!+&*82.!VuRZ!&.0!./1*2%(.!
"L=!
VuMZ! f921&)! 32*! 1,(! 1,*((! 8&+1(*/&$! )1*&/.)! 1()1(0_! 8&+1(*/&$! +9$19*()! 4(*(! /.+98&1(0! /.! H&*/.(! C*21,!
"L>!
7(0/97! 32*! <L! ,! &1! :K! iR! &.0! ;KK! *67[! #31(*! +(.1*/39%&1/2.! V"KKKK! %D! =!7/.D! :K! iRZD! +($$)! 4(*(!
"L?!
*()9)6(.0(0!/.!3*(),!#-k!&.0!+($$!+2.+(.1*&1/2.!4&)!&))())(0!8B!+B127(1(*!VCY!#++9*/!RB127(1(*Z[!
"LL!
C&+1(*/&$! 6&*1/+9$&1(! M! &.0! R! 4(*(! ()1/7&1(0! _! &! %/W(.! W2$97(! 23! +($$! )9)6(.)/2.! 4&)! 3/$1(*(0! /.!
"LP!
1*/6$/+&1(! 2.! 6*(+2789)1(0! :=! 77! hFnR! 3/$1(*)! Vk,&17&.D! "[:! j7Z[! F/$1(*)! 4(*(! 1,(.! 0*/(0! 32*! :<!
"PK!
,29*)! &1! ?KiR! &.0! 39*1,(*! &.&$B)(0! 9)/.%! &! RM! G$(7(.1&$! #.&$Ba(*! VF$&),! :KKKDN,(*72)+/(.1/3/+Z[!
"P"!
-/.+(! &$$! 8&+1(*/&$! )1*&/.)! /.! 1,(! ](./+! +9$19*(! +29$0! .21! 8(! +9$1/W&8$(! /.! H&*/.(! C*21,! 7(0/97D! 4(!
"P:!
()1/7&1(0! 7(&.!f921&)!3*27! +($$!W2$97(!V&)!&))())(0!3*27! 7/+*2)+26/+!28)(*W&1/2.)Z[!E.0((0D!1,()(!
"P;!
8&+1(*/&! 0(72.)1*&1(0! )/a(! &.0! ),&6(! W(*B! )/7/$&*! 12! 1,&1! 28)(*W(0! 32*! -JKK;[! k(! 1,(*(32*(!
"P<!
+2.)/0(*(0!)&7(!f921&)!32*!-JKK;!&.0!8&+1(*/&!/.!1,(!](./+!+9$19*([!!
"P=!
2.4.2. experimental culture
"P>!
F2$$24/.%!1,(!)+*((./.%!/.!(]6(*/7(.1!"D!1,*((!7/+*2&$%&(58&+1(*/&!&))2+/&1/2.)!&.0!1,(!/./1/&$!](./+!
"P?!
&.0! &](./+! +9$19*()! 4(*(! )($(+1(0! 32*! 39*1,(*! +276&*&1/W(! /.W()1/%&1/2.! V(]6(*/7(.1! :Z[! N,(! &](./+!
"PL!
+9$19*(!4&)!+2.)/0(*(0!&)!1,(!+2.1*2$[!#$%&(58&+1(*/&!&))2+/&1/2.)!4(*(!7&/.1&/.(0!32*!)(W(*&$!72.1,)!
"PP!
&1! :K! iR! 8(32*(! (]6(*/7(.1! :D! 4/1,! )9++())/W(! 8&1+,! +9$19*()! 2.! (.*/+,(0! #-k! 9.0(*! &! +2.1/.929)!
:KK!
/**&0/&.+(!23!"KK!j72$!6,212.)!75")5"[!R($$)!4(*(!,&*W()1(0!12!($/7/.&1(!*()/09&$!.91*/(.1)D!&.0!1,(.!
:K"!
1*&.)3(**(0!/.12!3$&)e)[!N*/6$/+&1(!+9$19*()!4(*(!+2.09+1(0!/.!)1(*/$(!"@53$&)e)!4/1,!&!)966$B!23!8988$(0!
!
L
:K:!
&/*[!N,(!7(0/97!9)(0!4&)!)/7/$&*!12!1,&1!32*!(]6(*/7(.1!"!VM!)29*+(D!M_A!*&1/2D!M&\RU;!(.*/+,7(.1D!
:K;!
.2!W/1&7/.)!&00(0Z[!N(76(*&19*(!4&)!)(1!&1!:K!iR!&.0!/**&0/&.+(!4&)!)(1!12!&!,/%,(*!$(W($!V:=K!j72$!
:K<!
6,212.)!75:)5"Z!1,&.!/.!(]6(*/7(.1!"!12!+276(.)&1(!32*!1,(!,/%,(*!261/+&$!6&1,!$(.%1,!/.!3$&)e)[!
:K=!
R9$19*()!4(*(!)&76$(0!0&/$B!32*!7/+*2&$%&(!+($$!0(.)/1B!&.0!+($$!)/a(D!&)!7(&)9*(0!4/1,!&!\E#R!+($$!
:K>!
+29.1(*! V\&+,! T$1*&D! T-#Z[! R($$! 8/2W2$97(! 4&)! +27691(0! 3*27! 7(&.! +($$! 0/&7(1(*! 9.0(*! 1,(!
:K?!
&))9761/2.! 23! &! )6(*/+&$! ),&6(! 32*! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L[! N21&$! 6&*1/+9$&1(! R! &.0! M! 4(*(! &$)2! ()1/7&1(0! &)!
:KL!
6*(W/29)$B!0()+*/8(0!32*!8&+1(*/&!V)((!:[<["Z[!H/+*2&$%&$!M!&.0!R!*(+2W(*(0!2.!hFnR!3/$1(*)!4(*(!1,(.!
:KP!
+&$+9$&1(0!&)!1,(!0/33(*(.+(!8(14((.!121&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!&.0!8&+1(*/&$!M!&.0!R[!F/.&$$BD!M!/.+2*62*&1/2.!
:"K!
4&)!+27691(0!&)!1,(!6(*+(.1&%(!23!/./1/&$!M5M\<!(.*/+,7(.1!V=<?[L!jHZ!/.+2*62*&1(0!/.!7/+*2&$%&(!
:""!
+($$)!&1!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)([!
:":!
E.! 2*0(*! 12! W&$/0&1(! M! )1&*W&1/2.! &1! 1,(! (.0! 23! 1,(! (]6(*/7(.1)D! +9$19*()! 4(*(! *(5(.*/+,(0! 4/1,!
:";!
=<?[L!j72$!23!&772./97D!&.0!1,(!8/27&))!/.+*(&)(!4&)!W(*/3/(0!2W(*!1,(!32$$24/.%!0&B)[!
:"<!
N,(!0(.)/1B!23!8&+1(*/&$!+($$)!4&)!7(&)9*(0!8B!+B127(1*/+!&.&$B)/)!&1!1,(!8(%/../.%!23!1,(!(]6(*/7(.1D!
:"=!
09*/.%! 1,(! %*241,! 6,&)(! &.0! &1! 1,(! )1&1/2.&*B! 6,&)([! N,(! 8&+1(*/&$! 6269$&1/2.! 4&)! /0(.1/3/(0! 8B!
:">!
+B127(1(*! VCY! #++9*/! RB127(1(*Z! &31(*! +2$2*&1/2.! 4/1,! -JC'%*((.[! C&+1(*/&! 12! 7/+*2&$%&(! *&1/2!
:"?!
VC_#D!+($$_+($$Z!4&)!+&$+9$&1(0!3*27!+B127(1*/+!0&1&!32*!8&+1(*/&!&.0!3*27!\E#R!0&1&!32*!&$%&([!!
:"L!
#8)(.+(!23!8&+1(*/&$!+2.1&7/.&1/2.!&1!1,(!(.0!23!1,(!(]6(*/7(.1!4&)!&))())(0!8B!'#AY!&.&$B)/)!2.!
:"P!
*&.027$B! )($(+1(0! )1*&/.)! &31(*! /)2$&1/2.! 2.! H&*/.(! #%&*! 6$&1()[! G]1*&+1/2.! &.0! AR'! *(&+1/2.)! 4(*(!
::K!
6(*32*7(0!9)/.%!1,(!)&7(!7/]19*(!&)!0()+*/8(0!&82W([!#.&$B)()!4(*(!&66$/(0!14/+(!4/1,!#7(*),&7v!
::"!
'#AY! #.&$B)/)! A*/7(*! "! V=w5! hhNhRhhh##5;wZ! &.0! <! V=w5! ##h#hRRRhN5;wZ[! N,(! +B+$/.%!
:::!
6*2%*&7!4&)!&)!32$$24)_!=!7/.!&1!P<!iRD!<=!+B+$()!/.+$90/.%!"!7/.!&1!P<!iRD!"!7/.!&1!;>!iR!&.0!:!7/.!
::;!
&1! ?:! iR[! AR'! 6*209+1)! 4(*(! )(6&*&1(0! 2.! :! m! N#G! &%&*2)(! %($)! &.0! 1,(! 6*23/$()! 281&/.(0! 4(*(!
::<!
+276&*(0!12!1,(!2*/%/.&$!8&+1(*/&$!*(3(*(.+(!)1*&/.!3*27!1,(!+2$$(+1/2.[!
::=!
2.5. Estimation of growth and statistics
::>!
H&]/7&$! %*241,! *&1(D! N7&]! V05"Z! 23! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! 4&)! +27691(0! &++2*0/.%! 12! (f9&1/2.! "! 3*27! 1,(!
::?!
$/.(&*!6&*1!23!1,(!$.51*&.)32*7(0!%*241,!+9*W(_!
!
P
(N7&]!r! F$. O !!!
F/
Gf9&1/2.!"
::L!
4,(*(! O! /)! (/1,(*! R,$! $! 3$92*()+(.+(! V(]6(*/7(.1! "Z! 2*!6&*1/+9$&1(! +&*82.! V(]6(*/7(.1! :Z!09*/.%! 1,(!
::P!
(]62.(.1/&$! %*241,! 6,&)(! &.0! /! /)! 1/7(! /.! 0&B)[! -/.+(! 8&+1(*/&$! +&*82.! +2.1*/891(0! 12! &! $24! $(W($! 12!
:;K!
121&$! 6&*1/+9$&1(! +&*82.! *(+2W(*(0! 2.! hFnR! 3/$1(*)D! 7/+*2&$%&(! N7&]! +29$0! 8(! +27691(0! 3*27! 121&$!
:;"!
6&*1/+9$&1(!+&*82.!0&1&!/.!(]6(*/7(.1!:[!
:;:!
H&]/7&$! 8/27&))! /.+*(&)(! O7&]! 23! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! 4&)! +27691(0! &1! )1&1/2.&*B! 6,&)(! &++2*0/.%! 12!
:;;!
(f9&1/2.!:_!!
Gf9&1/2.!:
O7&]!r!OKA(O&(((!
:;<!
4,(*(! OK( &.0! O&! &*(! (/1,(*! R,$! $! 3$92*()+(.+(! V(]6(*/7(.1! "Z! 2*! 6&*1/+9$&1(! +&*82.! V(]6(*/7(.1! :ZD!
:;=!
*()6(+1/W($B!&1!1,(!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(!&.0!&1!1,(!8(%/../.%!23!1,(!+9$19*([!
:;>!
-/.+(! O7&]!4&)!+27691(0!3*27!3$92*()+(.+(!*(&0/.%)!/.!(]6(*/7(.1!"!&.0!3*27!6&*1/+9$&1(!+&*82.!/.!
:;?!
(]6(*/7(.1!:D!+276&*/)2.!32*! O7&]!8(14((.!1,(!142!(]6(*/7(.1)!4&)!6(*32*7(0!&31(*!.2*7&$/a&1/2.!
:;L!
&++2*0/.%!12!(f9&1/2.!;_!
FO
.2*7
7&]
!?! FO 7&] /FO 7&] !
u
Gf9&1/2.!;
:;P!
k,(*(! FO 7&] /)!7(&.!7&]/7&$!8/27&))!/.+*(&)(!&.0!u(/)!)1&.0&*0!0(W/&1/2.!/.!(]6(*/7(.1[!
:<K!
-1&1/)1/+&$!&.&$B)()!4(*(!6(*32*7(0!4/1,!-1&1%*&6,/+)s!)2314&*(!32*!1,(!3&+12*/&$!0()/%.!&66*2&+,!&.0!
:<"!
'! )2314&*(! VhMT! 6*2g(+1Z! ($)(4,(*([! -/.+(! (]6(*/7(.1)! "! &.0! :! /.W2$W(0! 2.$B! 1*/6$/+&1(! +9$19*()D!
:<:!
*()9$1)!&*(!(]6*())(0!,(*(&31(*!&)!7(0/&.!&.0!/.1(*f9&*1/$(!*&.%(!VEu'Z!*&1,(*!1,&.!7(&.!&.0!)1&.0&*0!
:<;!
(**2*[! E.! (]6(*/7(.1! :D! (33(+1)! 23! 8&+1(*/&! 2.! 7/+*2&$%&$! 6&*&7(1(*)! 4(*(! 1()1(0! 9)/.%! 1,(! x*9)e&$!
:<<!
k&$$/)! 1()1! Vgr=mZ[!N,(!+276&*/)2.!23!%*241,!6&*&7(1(*)!+27691(0!3*27!1,(!142!(]6(*/7(.1)!4&)!
:<=!
+&**/(0!291!9)/.%!-6(&*7&.I)!*&.e!+2**($&1/2.!+2(33/+/(.1!Vgr=mZ[!
!
"K
:<>!
3. Results
:<?!
3.1. Purification of Dunaliella sp. SAG 19.3 culture
:<L!
#.! &](./+! +9$19*(! 23! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! )1*&/.! -#h! "P[;! 4&)! 281&/.(0! )9++())/W($B! 12! 1,(! *(6(&1(0!
:<P!
&.1/8/21/+!1*(&17(.1[!M2!+9$1/W&8$(!8&+1(*/&!4(*(!28)(*W(0!2.!1,(!H&*/.(!#%&*!6$&1()!/.2+9$&1(0!4/1,!
:=K!
)&76$()!23!1,/)!&$%&$!+9$19*([!E.!&00/1/2.D!8(32*(!1,(!9)(!23!1,/)!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!+9$19*(!32*!(]6(*/7(.1)D!
:="!
&8)(.+(! 23! 9.+9$1/W&8$(! )1*&/.)! 4&)! )B)1(7&1/+&$$B! W(*/3/(0! 8B! (6/3$92*()+(.+(! 7/+*2)+26B! &31(*!
:=:!
-JC'%*((.!)1&/./.%[!!
:=;!
3.2. Bacterial collection
:=<!
F2*1B5(/%,1!)1*&/.)!23!8&+1(*/&!4(*(!/)2$&1(0!3*27!"P!7/+*2&$%&(!)6(+/()D!23!4,/+,!?"m!4(*(!&+f9/*(0!
:==!
3*27! 0/&127)[! E.! 1,(! +2$$(+1/2.D! &.&$B)/)! 32*! 6&*1/&$! ">-! *'M#! *(W(&$(0! 1,&1! ;?! )1*&/.)! 4(*(! %*&75
:=>!
.(%&1/W(D! 23! 4,/+,! L! 8($2.%! 12! ,I/0L-$7$AD%$.0;$:/'5&">A6$:/'50&C'?( VRFCZ! /.+$90/.%! :!
:=?!
)6,/.%28&+1(*/&! &.0! >! 3$&W28&+1(*/&D! "?! 12! M%L-$L50/'0;$:/'5&$! &.0! ":! 12! 4$>>$L50/'0;$:/'5&$[!
:=L!
G$(W(.!)1*&/.)!4(*(!%*&7562)/1/W(!/.+$90/.%!"K!M:/&#0;$:/'5&$!&.0!2.(!6$:&%%&(VN&8$(!:Z*!
:=P!
3.3. High-throughput selection (experiment 1)
:>K!
G*G*1*(0L/&:$%(>'$?"5'>'#/(K05(>&:50$%7$'(L0L"%$/&0#((
:>"!
N,(! 3&+12*/&$! &66*2&+,! 9)(0! 12! +276&*(! UY>LK! 12! 3$92*()+(.+(! &)! 6*2]/()! 32*! 7/+*2&$%&(! 6269$&1/2.!
:>:!
*()9$1(0!/.!821,!720($)!(]6$&/./.%!72*(!1,&.!PPm!23!1,(!W&*/&8/$/1B!28)(*W(0!2.!0&1&[!C21,!UY>LK!&.0!
:>;!
3$92*()+(.+(!4(*(!)/%./3/+&.1$B!VcrK[K"Z!&.0!62)/1/W($B!*($&1(0!12!7/+*2&$%&$!+2.+(.1*&1/2.!VN&8$(!;Z[!
:><!
F2*!crK[K"D!.(/1,(*!f9&0*&1/+!(33(+1)!.2*!/.1(*&+1/2.!8(14((.!7/+*2&$%&(!&.0!8&+1(*/&$!+2.+(.1*&1/2.!
:>=!
4(*(! 329.0! )/%./3/+&.1! 32*! 821,! 7(&)9*(7(.1)[! \24(W(*D! &)! ),24.! /.! N&8$(! ;D! UY>LK! *(&0/.%)!
:>>!
/.+*(&)(0!4/1,!8&+1(*/&$!+2.+(.1*&1/2.D!4,/$(!3$92*()+(.+(!4&)!.21!)/%./3/+&.1$B!&33(+1(0[!
:>?!
G*G*E*(<KK':/(0K(;$:/'5&$(0#(>$R&>$%(750S/-(5$/'((
:>L!
\/%,51,*29%,691! (]6(*/7(.1! 4&)! +&**/(0! 291! 32*! :K! 0&B)D! 9.1/$! &$$! +9$19*()! ,&W(! *(&+,(0! )1&1/2.&*B!
:>P!
6,&)([! C&+1(*/&$! /)2$&1/2.! 2.! H&*/.(! #%&*! 6$&1()! +2.3/*7(0! 1,&1! .2! +2.1&7/.&1/2.! 2++9**(0! &1! 1,(!
:?K!
8(%/../.%! 2*! 1,(! (.0! 23! 1,(! (]6(*/7(.1! /.! 7/](0! 2*! &](./+! +9$19*()[! H&]/7&$! %*241,! *&1(! VN7&]Z! 23!
:?"!
!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!*&.%(0!3*27!K[:;!05"! 12!K[;>!05"!0(6(.0/.%!2.!8&+1(*/&$!&))2+/&1/2.D!4/1,!K[;>!05"! VK[K"Z!
:?:!
32*! 1,(! &](./+! +2.1*2$! VF/%9*(! "Z[! #00/1/2.! 23! 8&+1(*/&! 12! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! +9$19*()! 72)1$B! *()9$1(0! /.!
!
""
:?;!
)$/%,1!.(%&1/W(!(33(+1)!2.!N7&]D!&$1,29%,!)27(!21,(*!8&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)!0/0!.21!&$1(*!7/+*2&$%&(!N7&][!M2!
:?<!
8&+1(*/&$!(.,&.+(7(.1!23!%*241,!*&1(!4&)!28)(*W(0!/.!1,/)!(]6(*/7(.1[!N,(!%*241,5/.,/8/1/.%!8&+1(*/&!
:?=!
4(*(!8*2&0$B!0/)1*/891(0!&+*2))!1&]272./+!%*296)!VF/%9*(!"D!N&8$(!:Z[!N,(!)1*2.%()1!.(%&1/W(!(33(+1!V5
:?>!
;>!mZ!4&)!281&/.(0!32*!1,(!](./+!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*!+9$19*([!E.1(*()1/.%$BD!;!8&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)!/)2$&1(0!3*27!
:??!
1,/)!](./+!+9$19*(!VT-0C0:0::"?(K$?:&$#?!-JKK"D!-JKK:!&.0!!&'/P&$(?L*!-J:=KZ!*()9$1(0!/.!.(%&1/W(!
:?L!
(33(+1)!V5"L!mD!5""!m!&.0!5::!mD!*()6(+1/W($BZ!4,(.!1()1(0!/.0/W/09&$$B[!)"5&:$"C$(?L[!)1*&/.!-J:<<!
:?P!
/)2$&1(0! 3*27! U-$%$??&0?&5$( ?L*D( *()9$1(0! /.! &! ::! m! 0(+*(&)(! /.! !"#$%&'%%$! ?L[! %*241,! *&1([! #.21,(*!
:LK!
)"5&:$"C$!)1*&/.!V-J"L>Z!&$)2!,&0!&.!/.,/8/12*B!(33(+1!2.!N7&]!V5"L!mZ[!N,(!&00/1/2.!23!+(*1&/.!)1*&/.)!
:L"!
*()9$1(0!/.!$())(*!*(09+1/2.)!/.!N7&]D!)9+,!&)!4/1,!V$%0>0#$?(?L[!-JKK;!V5":!mZ(&.0!M%/'50>0#$?(?L[!
:L:!
-JKK?!V5?!mZ[!
:L;!
F29*1((.! )1*&/.)! (],/8/1(0!N7&]!+$2)(!12!1,(!+2.1*2$D!)9+,!&)!1,(!)1*&/.)!&33/$/&1(0!12!M5/-50;$:/'5(?L[!
:L<!
-JKK<!&.0!12!6$:&%%"?(K05$>&#&?!-JKP?D!32*!(]&76$(!VF/%9*(!"Z[!!
:L=!
G*G*G*(<KK':/(0K(;$:/'5&$(0#(>$R&>$%(;&0>$??(&#:5'$?'((
:L>!
H&]/7&$!8/27&))!/.+*(&)(!V O7&]Z!7(&)9*(0!&1!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(!4&)!72*(!)1*2.%$B!&$1(*(0!8B!8&+1(*/&$!
:L?!
&00/1/2.! 1,&.! N7&]! VF/%9*(! :Z[! G33(+1)! *&.%(0! 3*27! 5=?! m! 12! `:>! m! &.0! 4(*(! 7&/.$B! .(%&1/W([! N,(!
:LL!
)1*2.%()1!.(%&1/W(!(33(+1!V5=?!mZ!4&)!28)(*W(0!32*!1,(!](./+!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!+9$19*([!-1*&/.)!-JKK"!&.0!
:LP!
-JKK:!/)2$&1(0!3*27!1,(!](./+!+9$19*(!&.0!&33/$/&1(0!4/1,!T-0C0:0::"?(K$?:&$#?!&$)2!0(+*(&)(0! O7&]!
:PK!
4/1,!)1*2.%!(33(+1)!V5<:!m!&.0!5<<!mZ[!
:P"!
N4(.1B52.(!8&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)!*()9$1(0!/.! O7&]!+$2)(!12!1,&1!23!1,(!&](./+!+2.1*2$!VF/%9*(!:Z[!\24(W(*D!
:P:!
O7&]!4&)!(.,&.+(0!8B!::m!&.0!:>m!4,(.!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*!4&)!&))2+/&1(0!4/1,!8&+1(*/&!-JKK?!&.0!
:P;!
-J:<<! &33/$/&1(0! 12! M%/'50>0#$?( ?L*! &.0! )"5&:$"C$( ?L[D! *()6(+1/W($B[! N,()(! 8&+1(*/&! 4(*(! /)2$&1(0!
:P<!
3*27! 0/&127! +9$19*()_! U-$%$??&0?&5$( ?L[! 32*! 1,(! M%/'50>0#$?( ?L[! -JKK?D! &.0! H-$'0C$:/I%">(
:P=!
/5&:05#"/">!32*!1,(!)"5&:$"C$(?L[!-J:<<[!!
:P>!
3.4. Flask cultures (experiment 2)
:P?!
F2$$24/.%!(]6(*/7(.1!"D!1,*((!8&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)!4(*(!)($(+1(0!32*!1,(!0/33(*(.1!&$1(*&1/2.!6&11(*.!1,(B!
:PL!
8*29%,1!&8291!/.!!"#$%&'%%$(?L**!M%/'50>0#$?(?L*!-JKK?!&.0!)"5&:$"C$(?L*!-J:<<!4(*(!)($(+1(0!32*!
:PP!
1,(/*! (.,&.+/.%! (33(+1! 2.! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L[! 7&]/7&$! 8/27&))! /.+*(&)(! V O7&]Z! &1! 1,(! )1&1/2.&*B! 6,&)(!
!
":
;KK!
VF/%9*(! :Z[! V$%0>0#$?( ?L[! -JKK;! 4&)! &$)2! )($(+1(0! &)! &.! (]&76$(! 23! &! O7&]5/.,/8/1/.%! 8&+1(*/&[!
;K"!
N,()(!1,*((!7/](0!+9$19*()!4(*(!+276&*(0!12!1,(!+2.1*2$!&](./+!)1*&/.!&.0!12!1,(!2*/%/.&$!](./+!)1*&/.!
;K:!
-#h"P[;[!
;K;!
G*W*1*(6$:/'5&$%(L0L"%$/&0#?(
;K<!
F/*)1! 23! &$$D! .2! 8&+1(*/&$! +2.1&7/.&1/2.! 4&)! 28)(*W(0! 2.! H&*/.(! #%&*! 6$&1()! &$2.%! 1,(! +29*)(! 23!
;K=!
(]6(*/7(.1[!RB127(1*B!&.&$B)/)!+2.3/*7(0!1,()(!*()9$1)!)/.+(!4(!28)(*W(0!.2!(W(.1)!+2**()62.0/.%!12!
;K>!
8&+1(*/&! /.! 1,(! &](./+! +9$19*()D! &.0! 2.$B! 2.(! 9./32*7! 8&+1(*/&$! 6269$&1/2.! 2.! +B12%*&7)! 32*! 7/](0!
;K?!
+9$19*()[!'#AY!6*23/$(!&.&$B)()!23!8&+1(*/&!/)2$&1(0!&1!1,(!(.0!23!1,(!(]6(*/7(.1!:!4(*(!)/7/$&*!12!1,(!
;KL!
*(3(*(.+(!8&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)!VF/%9*(!;Z[!!
;KP!
N,(! 8&+1(*/&$! 6269$&1/2.D! ()1/7&1(0! &1! 1KD! 1=! &.0! 1"K! 8B! +B127(1*B! &.&$B)/)D! 0(W($26(0! /.! &$$! 7/](0!
;"K!
+9$19*()!VF/%9*(!<Z[!N,(!,/%,()1!8&+1(*/&$!+($$!0(.)/1B!4&)!*(+2*0(0!/.!1,(!7/](0!+9$19*((-JKK;[!#1!1,(!
;""!
)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(D!1,(!8&+1(*/&!12!7/+*2&$%&(!*&1/2!VC_#D!+($$_+($$Z!/.!1,/)!+9$19*(!4&)!&$)2!6&*1/+9$&*$B!
;":!
,/%,_!???!8&+1(*/&!+($$)!6(*!&$%&([!Y/33(*(.+()!4(*(!28)(*W(0!&1!1,(!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(!/.!C_#!32*!)1*&/.)!
;";!
-JKK?!&.0!-J:<<D!8(/.%!;P!32*!-JKK?!&.0!2.$B!L!32*!-J:<<[!F/.&$$BD!1,(!$24()1!8&+1(*/&!/.+*(&)(!
;"<!
&.0!C_#!$(W($D!:!8&+1(*/&!6(*!&$%&(D!4&)!*(+2*0(0!/.!1,(!](./+!+9$19*()!23!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!!
;"=!
M/1*2%(.! VuMZ! &.0! +&*82.! VuRZ! +($$! f921&)! 7(&)9*(0! 32*! 1,(! 1,*((! 8&+1(*/&$! )1*&/.)! &*(! 6*()(.1(0! /.!
;">!
N&8$(! <[! F*27! f921&)! &.0! 8&+1(*/&$! +($$! 6269$&1/2.! 0&1&! 4(! +29$0! +27691(! 8&+1(*/&$! +2.1*/891/2.! 12!
;"?!
121&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!M!&.0!R!*(+2W(*(0!2.!hFnR!3/$1(*)[!E1!32$$24(0!1,&1!8&+1(*/&$!+&*82.!*(6*()(.1(0!$())!
;"L!
1,&.!<!m!23!121&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!+&*82.!/.!&$$!7/](0!+9$19*()D!(]+(61!32*!-JKK;!4,(*(!/1!4&)!"K!m!23!121&$!
;"P!
6&*1/+9$&1(!+&*82.[!C&+1(*/&!+2.1*/891(0!12!,/%,(*!$(W($!23!121&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!MD!8&+1(*/&$!M!8(/.%!&)!,/%,!
;:K!
&)!;<!m!32*!-JKK;!&.0!"=!m!32*!-JKK?!VN&8$(!<Z[!
;:"!
G*W*E*()&:50$%7$'(750S/-(
;::!
#)! &$*(&0B! 7(.1/2.(0! &82W(D! +2.1*/891/2.! 23! 8&+1(*/&! 12! 121&$! 6&*1/+9$&1(! +&*82.! 4&)! $24! /.! 7/](0!
;:;!
+9$19*()[!N,(*(32*(!4(!&))97(0!1,&1!121&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!+&*82.!*(+2W(*(0!2.!hFnR!3/$1(*)!4&)!&!)9/1&8$(!
;:<!
6*2]B! 32*! 7/+*2&$%&$! +&*82.! &.0! /.! 1,(! 32$$24/.%D! 4(! 39*1,(*! +276&*(! 7/+*2&$%&(! %*241,! +27691(0!
;:=!
3*27!121&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!+&*82.!0&1&[!!
!
";
;:>!
h*241,! 23! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L[!/.! 3$&)e)! 4&)! W(*B! )(.)/1/W(! 12! 1,(! 8&+1(*/&$! )1*&/.! &00(0! /.! 1,(! +9$19*(D! &)!
;:?!
/$$9)1*&1(0!/.!F/%9*(!<!8B!1,(!0/33(*(.1!%*241,!+9*W()!*(+2*0(0!09*/.%!(]6(*/7(.1!:[!H/+*2&$%&(!N7&]!
;:L!
+27691(0!2.!&!6(*5+&*82.!8&)/)!/.!(]6(*/7(.1!:!VN&8$(!=Z!4(*(!W(*B!)/7/$&*!12!1,2)(!+27691(0!3*27!
;:P!
&#(.&.0!R,$!$!3$92*()+(.+(!/.!(]6(*/7(.1!"[!E.0((0D!&!62)/1/W(!+2**($&1/2.!V !r!K[P"O!A!W&$9(!r!K[K<:!O!
;;K!
)$26(!r!"[KZ!4&)!329.0!32*!N7&]!*(+2*0(0!/.!1,(!142!(]6(*/7(.1)[!#)!6*(W/29)$B!28)(*W(0!/.!1,(!,/%,5
;;"!
1,*29%,691!(]6(*/7(.1D!1,(!&00/1/2.!23!8&+1(*/&!12!1,(!+9$19*()!0/0!.21!*()9$1!/.!&.!(.,&.+/.%!(33(+1!32*!
;;:!
N7&]! 4,(.! +276&*(0! 4/1,! 1,(! &](./+! +9$19*()! 23! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L[! VN&8$(! =Z[! N,(! $24()1! N7&]! 4(*(!
;;;!
28)(*W(0!/.!](./+!+9$19*()!&.0!4,(.!V$%0>0#$?(?L*!-JKK;!&.0!)"5&:$"C$(?L[!-J:<<!4(*(!&00(0!12!
;;<!
+9$19*()[!E.1(*()1/.%$BD!.2!)/%./3/+&.1!0/33(*(.+(!4/1,!1,(!&](./+!+2.1*2$!4&)!281&/.(0!4,(.!!"#$%&'%%$(
;;=!
?L[!4&)!&))2+/&1(0!12!M%/'50>0#$?(?L*!-JKK?[!!
;;>!
#1!1,(!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(!/.!(]6(*/7(.1!:D!8&+1(*/&$!&00/1/2.!*()9$1(0!/.!&$1(*(0! O7&]!32*!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!
;;?!
#%&/.D! *()9$1)! *(+2*0(0! /.! (]6(*/7(.1! :! 4(*(! )/7/$&*! 12! 1,2)(! 23! (]6(*/7(.1! "! &.0! &! 62)/1/W(!
;;L!
+2**($&1/2.!V !r!K[P=O!A!W&$9(!r!K[K<:!O!)$26(!r"[KZ!4&)!281&/.(0!32*!.2*7&$/a(0! O7&]!8(14((.!1,(!
;;P!
142! (]6(*/7(.1)[! N,(! $24()1! O7&]! 4(*(! 28)(*W(0! /.! (]6(*/7(.1! :! 32*! ](./+! +9$19*()! V5:=! mZ! &.0!
;<K!
4,(.! V$%0>0#$?( ?L*! -JKK;! V5!;;! mZ! 4&)! &))2+/&1(0! 4/1,! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! VN&8$(! =Z[! E.! &00/1/2.D!
;<"!
)/7/$&*!(.,&.+/.%!(33(+1)!4(*(!28)(*W(0!/.!7/](0!+9$19*()!-JKK?!V`;"!mZ!&.0!-J:<<!V`;=!mZ[!N,()(!
;<:!
142! 8&+1(*/&! )/%./3/+&.1$B! /.+*(&)(0! +&*82.! &++979$&1/2.! /.! 7/+*2&$%&(! +9$19*()! +276&*(0! 4/1,! 1,(!
;<;!
&](./+!+2.1*2$!&.0D!72*(!)1*2.%$BD!4,(.!+276&*(0!12!1,(!2*/%/.&$!-#h!"P[;!](./+!)1*&/.[!!
;<<!
H/+*2&$%&(! +($$! )/a(! 4&)! &$)2! )/%./3/+&.1$B! &33(+1(0! 8B! 8&+1(*/&$! &00/1/2.[! k(! 4(*(! &8$(! 12! +27691(!
;<=!
8/2W2$97(! 23! 7/+*2&$%&(! +($$)! VN&8$(! =Z! 2.! 1,(! 8&)/)! 23! \/&+! 0&1&D! &))97/.%! &! )6,(*/+&$! ),&6(! 32*!
;<>!
!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!k(!329.0!&!62)/1/W(!+2**($&1/2.!V rK[PLO!A!W&$9(rK[LLZ!8(14((.!8/2W2$97(!&.0!+&*82.!
;<?!
f921&! /.! 7/+*2&$%&([! k(! *(+2*0(0! ,/%,! 7/+*2&$%&$! 8/2W2$97(! 32*! -J:<<! &.0! 1,(! &](./+! +9$19*()D!
;<L!
4,/$(!+($$)!/.!1,(!](./+!+9$19*()!4(*(!)/%./3/+&.1$B!)7&$$(*[!
;<P!
G*W*G*(8&/507'#(&#:05L05$/&0#(
;=K!
E.!2*0(*!12!()1/7&1(!./1*2%(.!/.+2*62*&1/2.!/.!7/+*2&$%&(D!4(!+2**(+1(0!121&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!M!32*!8&+1(*/&$!
;="!
M[!E.0((0D!4(!329.0!1,&1!8&+1(*/&$!M!+29$0!+2.1*/891(!12!,/%,!$(W($!12!121&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!M!*(+2W(*(0!2.!
;=:!
hFnR!3/$1(*)!V96!12!;<!m!&1!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(!32*!-JKK;Z[!F*27!0&1&!23!8&+1(*/&$!M!f921&!&.0!8&+1(*/&$!
!
"<
;=;!
6269$&1/2.! 4(! +29$0! )98)1*&+1! 8&+1(*/&$! M! 12! 121&$! 6&*1/+9$&1(! M! &.0! ()1/7&1(! M! /.+2*62*&1/2.! 32*!
;=<!
7/+*2&$%&([!#1!1,(!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(D!1,(!*()9$1/.%!7/+*2&$%&$!R_M!VN&8$(!=Z!4&)!,/%,!V::[L!12!:P[>Z!32*!
;==!
1,(!0/33(*(.1!+9$19*()D!+276&*(0!12!1,(!R_M!*&1/2!*(+2*0(0!&1!N7&]!VR_M!r!>D!0&1&!.21!),24.Z[!!
;=>!
!E1!32$$24(0!1,&1!8&+1(*/&$!&00/1/2.!)/%./3/+&.1$B!&$1(*(0!M!/.+2*62*&1/2.!32*! !"#$%&'%%$(?L[!VN&8$(!=Z[!
;=?!
N,(!$24()1!M!/.+2*62*&1/2.!/.!7/+*2&$%&(!4&)!281&/.(0!/.!-JKK;!+9$19*()!V"P!mZ!4,/$(!&](./+!V:>!mZ!
;=L!
&.0!](./+!V;<!mZ!0(72.)1*&1(0!/.1(*7(0/&1(!M!/.+2*62*&1/2.[!E.!7/](0!+9$19*()!4/1,!)"5&:$"C$(?L[!
;=P!
-J:<<! &.0! M%/'50>0#$?( ?L*! -JKK?D! M! /.+2*62*&1/2.! 4&)! )/%./3/+&.1$B! (.,&.+(0! 96! 12! =>! m! 23! 1,(!
;>K!
/./1/&$!M!(.*/+,7(.1[!
;>"!
4. Discussion
;>:!
4.1. Microalgae culture-based bacterial collection
;>;!
E)2$&1/2.! 23! 8&+1(*/&! 3*27! &! 0/W(*)/1B! 23! 72.2)6(+/3/+! 7/+*2&$%&$! +9$19*()! 6*2W/0(0! &! 8&+1(*/&$!
;><!
+2$$(+1/2.!23!<L!)1*&/.)[!-/.+(!1,()(!8&+1(*/&!)1*&/.)!0(W($266(0!/.!7/+*2&$%&(!+9$19*()!4/1,291!2*%&./+!
;>=!
+&*82.!)966$(7(.1&1/2.D!4(!)9)6(+1(0!1,&1!1,(B!4(*(!&8$(!12!%*24!2.!1,(!2*%&./+!+&*82.!*($(&)(0!8B!
;>>!
7/+*2&$%&([!N,/)!)9%%()1(0!/.1(*&+1/2.)!8(14((.!8&+1(*/&!&.0!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*[!#!,/%,!8&+1(*/&$!0/W(*)/1B!
;>?!
4/1,!$24!*(09.0&.+B!4&)!*(+2*0(0[!E.0((0D!8&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)!/)2$&1(0!3*27!0/33(*(.1!7/+*2&$%&$!+9$19*()!
;>L!
4(*(! 72)1$B! 0/33(*(.1D! 4/1,! 1,(! )1*&/.)! 4($$! 0/)1*/891(0! &72.%! 329*! 6,B$2%(.(1/+! +$9)1(*)_! g5! &.0! 5!
;>P!
H50/'0;$:/'5&$D! ,I/0L-$7$AD%$.0;$:/'5&">A6$:/'50&C'?! &.0! %*&7562)/1/W(! 7&/.$B! &33/$/&1(0! 12!
;?K!
M:/&#0;$:/'5&$[!N,/)!)190B!&/7(0!&1!6*2W/0/.%!&!8&+1(*/&$!+2$$(+1/2.!32*!39*1,(*!/.1(*&+1/2.!)190/()!&.0!
;?"!
0/0! .21! (.+276&))! &.! (+2$2%/+&$! )+26(! )/.+(! 2.$B! 027/.&.1! &.0! +9$1/W&8$(! 8&+1(*/&! 4(*(! *(+2W(*(0!
;?:!
3*27!7/+*2&$%&$!+9$19*()[!\24(W(*D!/1!),29$0!8(!.21(0!1,&1!4(!/)2$&1(0!&.0!/0(.1/3/(0!8&+1(*/&$!%*296)!
;?;!
1,&1!4(*(!6*(W/29)$B!28)(*W(0!($)(4,(*(D!32$$24/.%!/)2$&1/2.!23!8&+1(*/&!3*27!7/+*2&$%&(!+9$19*()!/.!
;?<!
,&1+,(*/()! b;"d! &.0! /.! 8&+1(*/26$&.e12.! +2779./1/()! b;:c;<d[! M2! 7(78(*)! 23! 1,(! AH50/'0;$:/'5&$(
;?=!
4(*(! *(+2W(*(0! 3*27! 1,/)! +2$$(+1/2.D! &$1,29%,! 1,/)! +$9)1(*! ,&)! 8((.! *(+2*0(0! /.! )(W(*&$! (+2$2%/+&$!
;?>!
)190/()! b;=D;>d[! #%&/.D! 1,/)! &8)(.+(! +29$0! *()9$1! 3*27! 1,(! (]6(*/7(.1&$! )(1596D! &)! 2.$B! 027/.&.1!
;??!
+9$1/W&8$(! 8&+1(*/&! 4(*(! +2.)/0(*(0! ,(*([! E.! &00/1/2.D! 1,(! 7&*/.(! 2*/%/.! 23! 1,/)! 8&+1(*/&$! +$9)1(*! ,&)!
;?L!
8((.!0(8&1(0!/.!6*(W/29)!)190/()!b;?D;Ld[!
!
"=
;?P!
4.2. Methodological aspects
;LK!
W*E*1*(V&7-A/-50"7-L"/(?'%':/&0#(0K(750S/-AL50>0/&#7(;$:/'5&$((
;L"!
H2)1! 23! 1,(! 6*(W/29)! )190/()! +2.09+1(0! 2.! /.1(*&+1/2.)! 8(14((.! 7/+*2&$%&(! &.0! 8&+1(*/&! ,&W(! 8((.!
;L:!
+&**/(0!291!/.!G*$(.7(B(*!2*!$&*%(*!3$&)e)!b":D;Pd[!\24(W(*D!1,()(!+9$19*(!W2$97()!&*(!.21!)9/1&8$(!32*!
;L;!
1,(!)+*((./.%!23!&!$&*%(!.978(*!23!)6(+/()!&1!2.+([!N,(*(32*(D!4(!0(W($26(0!&!)6(+/3/+!(]6(*/7(.1&$!
;L<!
0(W/+(!8&)(0!2.!7/+*26$&1()[!-/7/$&*!122$)!,&W(!8((.!6*(W/29)$B!9)(0!12!&))())!%*241,!32*!7/+*2&$%&(!
;L=!
b<Kd[!\24(W(*D!/.!1,/)!)190BD!4(!,&0!12!3&+(!)6(+/3/+!+2.)1*&/.1)D!/.+$90/.%!1,(!6*()(.+(!23!8&+1(*/&!1,&1!
;L>!
+&.! &33(+1! 261/+&$! 7(&)9*(7(.1)! 32*! 7/+*2&$%&(! +2.+(.1*&1/2.! &.0! 8&+1(*/&$! +*2))5+2.1&7/.&1/2.!
;L?!
8(14((.! 4($$)[! k/1,! 1,(! 9)(! 23! 1,(! /76(*7(&8$(! 3/$7! 12%(1,(*! 4/1,! M&\RU;! &00/1/2.! /.! +9$19*(!
;LL!
7(0/97! 4(! 4(*(! &8$(! 12! 6*(W(.1! +*2))5+2.1&7/.&1/2.)! 8(14((.! 4($$)! &.0! +&*82.! $/7/1&1/2.! /.! 1,(!
;LP!
&8)(.+(!23!%&)!(]+,&.%([!
;PK!
T.$/e(!UY>LK!7(&)9*(7(.1D!3$92*()+(.+(!V<=K.7!5!>L=!.7Z!4&)!/.)(.)/1/W(!12!8&+1(*/&!+2.+(.1*&1/2.!
;P"!
VN&8$(!;Z!&.0!+29$0!8(!)((.!&)!&!*($/&8$(!6*2]B!32*!7/+*2&$%&(!6269$&1/2.!&))())7(.1!/.!7/+*26$&1([!
;P:!
#00/1/2.&$$BD!+276&*/)2.!8(14((.!7/+*26$&1(!&.0!3$&)e!(]6(*/7(.1)!*(W(&$(0!)/7/$&*!1*(.0)!32*!821,!
;P;!
%*241,! 6&*&7(1(*)D! &)! /$$9)1*&1(0! 8B! 1,(! -6(&*7&.I)! *&.e! +2**($&1/2.! +2(33/+/(.1)! 329.0! ,(*([! N,()(!
;P<!
*()9$1)! +2.3/*7(0! 1,&1! /.0/*(+1! 7(&)9*(7(.1)! 32*! 7/+*2&$%&(! %*241,! 9)/.%! &#A.&.0! 3$92*()+(.+(! %&W(!
;P=!
+2.)/)1(.1!*()9$1)!4/1,!0/*(+1!7(&)9*(7(.1)!32*!7/+*2&$%&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!+&*82.[!!
;P>!
N,(!,/%,!+2**($&1/2.!+2(33/+/(.1!7(.1/2.(0!&82W(!32*!821,!%*241,!6&*&7(1(*)!/.!1,(!142!(]6(*/7(.1)!
;P?!
&$)2! )9%%()1(0! 1,&1! 1,(! $24! +9$19*(! W2$97(! V;KK! j@Z! /.! 7/+*26$&1(D! +278/.(0! 4/1,! 1,(! 9)(! 23!
;PL!
/76(*7(&8$(! &0,()/W(! 3/$7D! /)! &! *($/&8$(! +9$19*(! )B)1(7! 32*! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! CB! 6&B/.%! 6&*1/+9$&*!
;PP!
&11(.1/2.! 12! $/%,1! &.0! 1(76(*&19*(! W&*/&8/$/1B! 8(14((.! 6$&1()! &.0! 4($$)D! 4(! 7&.&%(0! 12! *(09+(! 1,(!
<KK!
+2(33/+/(.1!23!W&*/&1/2.!VRpZ!12!=[;m!&.0!:[;mD!*()6(+1/W($B[!#)!&!+2.)(f9(.+(D!4(!*(+2*0(0!2.$B!$24!
<K"!
W&*/&8/$/1B! 8(14((.! +9$19*(! *(6$/+&1()D! 6&*1/+9$&*$B! 32*! %*241,! *&1([! F/.&$$BD! 1,(! ,/%,! 1,*29%,691!
<K:!
1(+,./f9(!+2.3/*7(0!12!8(!&!1/7(5)&W/.%!&66*2&+,!)/.+(!)(1596!23!(]6(*/7(.1!+&.!8(!&+,/(W(0!4/1,/.!
<K;!
,29*)!(&)/$B!&.0!3$92*()+(.+(!*(&0/.%!/)!3&)1!(.29%,!12!&$$24!)(W(*&$!*(&0/.%)!6(*!0&B[!N2%(1,(*D!1,()(!
<K<!
8(.(3/1)! 7&B! &332*0! 1,(! 9)(! 23! &! ,/%,(*! .978(*! 23! *(6$/+&1()! 12! (W(.! /.+*(&)(! )B)1(7! *($/&8/$/1B[! #)!
!
">
<K=!
)9+,D! 1,(! 6*262)(0! ,/%,51,*29%,691! 0(W/+(! 6*2W(0! 12! 8(! &.! (33/+/(.1! 122$! 12! f9&$/1&1/W($B! &))&B! 1,(!
<K>!
(33(+1!23!&!,/%,!.978(*!23!8&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)!2.!7/+*2&$%&(!%*241,[!!
<K?!
W*E*E*(M??'??>'#/(0K(:0>L$5/&>'#/$/&0#(;'/S''#(>&:50$%7$'($#C(;$:/'5&$(
<KL!
E.!(]6(*/7(.1!:D!1,(!9)(!23!hFnR!3/$1(*)!0/0!.21!&$$24!12!)(6&*&1(!7/+*2&$%&(!3*27!8&+1(*/&[!\(.+(D!/.!
<KP!
2*0(*! 12! ()1/7&1(! M! &.0! R! /.+2*62*&1/2.! /.! 7/+*2&$%&(D! 4(! 3/*)1! 7(&)9*(0! 8&+1(*/&$! M! &.0! R! f921&)!
<"K!
4/1,!69*(!8&+1(*/&$!+9$19*()D!&)!&$*(&0B!*(62*1(0!($)(4,(*(!b<"d[!k(!0/0!.21!,&W(!(W/0(.+(!32*!%*241,!
<""!
+&6&+/1B!2.!H&*/.(!C*21,!23!&$$!8&+1(*/&!)1*&/.)!329.0!/.!1,(!](./+!+9$19*([!\(.+(D!4(!+29$0!.2!*($/&8$B!
<":!
7(&)9*(!f921&)!32*!1,()(!8&+1(*/&[!\24(W(*D!8&+1(*/&!)1*&/.)!/.!1,(!](./+!+9$19*(!&.0!-JKK;!(],/8/1(0!
<";!
)/7/$&*! ),&6(! &.0! )/a(! &.0! 4(! +2.)/0(*(0! R! &.0! M! f921&)! )/7/$&*! 12! 1,&1! 32*! -JKK;! VN&8$(! <Z[! k(!
<"<!
62/.1! 291! 1,&1! )/.+(! 8&+1(*/&$! 6269$&1/2.! *(7&/.(0! $24! /.! 1,(! ](./+! +9$19*(! V)((! F/%9*(! <ZD! 8&+1(*/&!
<"=!
+2.1*/891(0! 12! &! W(*B! $24! $(W($! 12! M! &.0! R! *(+2W(*(0! 2.! hFnR! 3/$1(*)! VN&8$(! =ZD! /**()6(+1/W(! 23! 1,(!
<">!
&))9761/2.! 32*! f921&)[! k(! 1,(.! )98)1*&+1(0! 1,(! 8&+1(*/&$! +276&*17(.1! 3*27! 121&$! 6&*1/+9$&*! 7&11(*!
<"?!
*(+2W(*(0! 2.! 3/$1(*)! 12! +27691(! 7/+*2&$%&(! M! &.0! R[! N,/)! &66*2&+,! *()9$1(0! /.! ,/%,! R_M! 32*!
<"L!
7/+*2&$%&(! &1! )1&1/2.&*B! 6,&)(! /.! 7/](0! &.0! &](./+! +9$19*()D! &! *()9$1! /.! &++2*0&.+(! 4/1,! 1,(! Y*226!
<"P!
f921&!1,(2*B!b<:d!1,&1!M5$/7/1(0!7/+*2&$%&(!+($$)!)126!%*241,!&1!&!%/W(.!7&]/797!R_M[!CB!1,(!4&BD!
<:K!
1,/)!*()9$1!&.0!1,(!%220!+2**($&1/2.!329.0!8(14((.!7/+*2&$%&(!8/2W2$97(!&.0!uRD!&$)2!)9662*1(0!29*!
<:"!
&66*2&+,! 32*! 7/+*2&$%&(! M! &.0! R! +27691&1/2.[! F/.&$$BD! 1,(! ,/%,! R_M! *(+2*0(0! ,(*(! 4(*(! /.!
<::!
&++2*0&.+(!4/1,!M!$/7/1&1/2.!32*!7/+*2&$%&(!&1!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(!&)!&))())(0!8B!M!*(5)966$(7(.1&1/2.!
<:;!
&1!1,(!(.0!23!1,(!(]6(*/7(.1[!!
<:<!
4.3. Effect of bacteria on growth of Dunaliella sp.
<:=!
N,(! ,/%,51,*29%,691! (]6(*/7(.1! V(]6(*/7(.1! "Z! 4&)! 0()/%.(0! )2! &)! 12! *&6/0$B! 32+9)! 2.! 7/+*2&$%&(5
<:>!
8&+1(*/&! &))2+/&1/2.)! &$1(*/.%! %*241,! 6(*32*7&.+(! 32*! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L[D! 1,&1! +29$0! 8(! 39*1,(*!
<:?!
+,&*&+1(*/a(0! /.! 1,(! )9++())/W(! 3$&)e! (]6(*/7(.1[! N,(! (]6(*/7(.1! *()9$1(0! /.! &! .978(*! 23! /.,/8/1/2.!
<:L!
&.0n2*!6*2721/2.!(33(+1)!VF/%9*(!"!&.0!:Z!2.!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*(N7&]!&.0! O7&][!H2)1!23!1,(!<L!8&+1(*/&$!
<:P!
)1*&/.)! 1()1(0! /.! (]6(*/7(.1! "! .(%&1/W($B! &33(+1(0! 7/+*2&$%&$! O7&]! &.0! N7&][! \24(W(*D! (33(+1! 2.!
<;K!
7/+*2&$%&$! %*241,! *&1(! 4&)! 2.$B! )$/%,1! +276&*(0! 12! 1,(! 4/0(! *&.%(! 4(! *(+2*0(0! 32*! O7&][! -/.+(!
<;"!
+9$19*()! 4(*(! %*24.! 4/1,291! W/1&7/.! )966$(7(.1&1/2.D! 4(! (]6(+1(0! 1,&1! )27(! &))2+/&1/2.)! +29$0!
!
"?
<;:!
*()9$1! /.! /.+*(&)(0! 7/+*2&$%&(! N7&][! J(1D! 4(! 0/0! .21! *(+2*0! &.B! 7/+*2&$%&$! N7&]! /76*2W(7(.1D!
<;;!
0(72.)1*&1/.%!1,&1!)B.1,()/)!23!%*241,56*2721/.%!+27629.0)!b""c";d!8B!8&+1(*/&!0/0!.21!2++9*(!2*!
<;<!
4&)!.21!(33/+/(.1[!F/.&$$BD!4(!4(*(!9.&8$(!12!3/.0!+2..(+1/2.!8(14((.!8&+1(*/&$!1&]2.27/+!62)/1/2.!&.0!
<;=!
(33(+1! 2.! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! %*241,[! \24(W(*D! &)! 62/.1(0! 291! 8B! H&B&$/! &.0! #a&7! b<;d! 32*! &$%/+/0&$!
<;>!
8&+1(*/&D! 1,(! f9()1/2.! 23! 7(1&82$/+! 6*26(*1/()! +2772.! 12! 8*2&0! 8&+1(*/&$! 1&]&! *(7&/.)! $&*%($B!
<;?!
9.&.)4(*(0[!!
<;L!
E.! (]6(*/7(.1! :D! 4(! 32+9)(0! 2.! 1,*((( 8&+1(*/&$! )1*&/.)! 1,&1! 6*209+(0! W&*/29)! (33(+1)! 2.! 7/+*2&$%&(!
<;P!
N7&]D!4,/$(!&$1(*/.%! O7&]_!M%/'50>0#$?(?L[!-JKK?D!)"5&:$"C$(?L[!-J:<<!&.0!V$%0>0#$?(?L[!-JKK;O!
<<K!
G33(+1)! 1,&1! 4(*(! *(+2*0(0! 4/1,! 1,(! 8&+1(*/&$! )1*&/.)! /.! (]6(*/7(.1! "! 4(*(! +2.3/*7(0! /.! 1,(! 3$&)e!
<<"!
(]6(*/7(.1!32*!821,!N7&]!&.0! O7&][!#))9761/2.)!32*!1,(!9.0(*$B/.%!7(+,&./)7)!&*(!0/)+9))(0!/.!1,(!
<<:!
32$$24/.%[!
<<;!
E1!/)!4($$!e.24.!1,&1!8&+1(*/&!+&.!720/3B!7/+*2&$%&$!%*241,!8B!&33(+1/.%!(/1,(*!%*241,!*&1(!2*!8/27&))!
<<<!
&++979$&1/2.[! H&]/7&$! %*241,! *&1(! 23! 7/+*2&$%&(! /)! $/e($B! 12! 8(! &33(+1(0! 8B! 8&+1(*/&$! 6269$&1/2.D!
<<=!
62))/8$B! 4/1,! &.! (.,&.+/.%! (33(+1D! &)! 6*(W/29)$B! 28)(*W(0! /.! 1,(! $/1(*&19*(! b;PD<<dD! 891! .21! /.! 1,/)!
<<>!
)190B[!-(W(*&$!&91,2*)!,&W(!0(72.)1*&1(0!1,&1!1,(!.(%&1/W(!(33(+1)!23!8&+1(*/&!2.!N7&]!&*(!1,(!*()9$1!23!
<<?!
1,(!(]+*(1/2.!23!12]/+!8&+1(*/&$!+27629.0)O!1,/)!/))9(!,&)!8((.!3*(f9(.1$B!&00*())(0!/.!)190/()!0(&$/.%!
<<L!
4/1,!1,(!/76&+1!23!&$%/+/0&$!8&+1(*/&!2.!&$%&$!8$227)!b<;D<=D<>d[!-(W(*&$!8&+1(*/&$!%(.(*&!V,I/0L-$7$D!
<<P!
!&'/P&$D! @$#&;$:/'5D! )&:50:0::"?D! H?'"C0$%/'50>0#$?Z! *(3(*(.+(0! /.! 29*! +2$$(+1/2.! 1,&1! $(0! 12!
<=K!
0(+*(&)(0!N7&]!32*!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!/.!+9$19*(D!,&W(!8((.!6*(+/)($B!0()+*/8(0!&)!&$%/+/0&$!8&+1(*/&!/.!1,(!
<="!
$/1(*&19*(!b<?D<Ld[!!
<=:!
C&+1(*/&$!(33(+1)!2.!8/27&))!&++979$&1/2.!&1!1,(!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(!,&W(!&$)2!8((.!6*(W/29)$B!*(62*1(0!
<=;!
/.!1,(!$/1(*&19*(!b<PD=Kd[!H29%(1!'/($%[!28)(*W(0!&!)1*2.%!/.+*(&)(!V`=K!mZ!/.!7&]/7&$!+($$!0(.)/1B!32*!
<=<!
9:'#'C'?>"?(;&:'%%"%$5&?!&))2+/&1(0!4/1,!&!65'."#C&>0#$?(C&>&#"/$!)1*&/.!b="d[!N&/!'/($%*!)9%%()1(0!
<==!
1,(!2++9**(.+(!23!X&;5&0!)6(+/()!/.!&772./97!6*209+1/2.D!)9662*1/.%!9I#':-0:0::"?!?L[!%*241,!b"<d[!
<=>!
C()/0()D! /1! /)! 4($$! e.24.! 1,&1! ./1*2%(.!(]+*(1/2.! 2++9*)! 09*/.%! 7/+*2&$%&(! 8&1+,! +9$19*(! b=:d[! -/.+(!
<=?!
./1*2%(.5$/7/1(0!+2.0/1/2.)!4(*(!9)(0!/.!1,/)!)190BD!/1!4&)!&))97(0!1,&1!./1*2%(.!*(7/.(*&$/a&1/2.!23!
<=L!
2*%&./+! ./1*2%(.! *($(&)(0! 8B! 7/+*2&$%&(! 2++9**(0! /.! +9$19*()! 4,(*(! M%/'50>0#$?( ?L[! -JKK?! &.0!
!
"L
<=P!
)"5&:$"C$( ?L[! -J:<<! 4(*(! &00(0[! C&+1(*/&$! *(7/.(*&$/a&1/2.! 23! (]1*&+($$9$&*! 2*%&./+! 7&11(*! +29$0!
<>K!
6*2W/0(!./1*2%(.!&.0!0($&B!)1&*W&1/2.!32*!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!N,/)!,B621,()/)!/)!)1*(.%,1,(.(0!8B!1,(!,/%,(*!
<>"!
M!/.+2*62*&1/2.!/.!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!+($$)!4,(.!7/](0!4/1,!2.(!23!1,(!142!8&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)D!&)!+276&*(0!
<>:!
4/1,!1,(!&](./+!+2.1*2$[!F*27!1,()(!*()9$1)D!8&+1(*/&!-JKK?!&.0!-J:<<!+29$0!8(!+2.)/0(*(0!&)!,($6(*)!
<>;!
32*! M! &))/7/$&1/2.! 32*! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L*! +($$)[! \24(W(*D! 1,(*(! /)! &! .((0! 32*! 39*1,(*! (]6(*/7(.1)! 4/1,!
<><!
7(&)9*(7(.1)!32*!0/))2$W(0!/.2*%&./+!&.0!2*%&./+!./1*2%(.!&.0!7/+*2&$%&$!6&*1/+9$&1(!./1*2%(.!12!1()1!
<>=!
1,/)!&))9761/2.[!!
<>>!
C&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)!+&.!&$)2!0(+*(&)(! O7&]!23!7/+*2&$%&(!8B!+276(1/.%!32*!&!$/7/1/.%!.91*/(.1[!-9+,!&.!
<>?!
(33(+1!,&)!8((.!6*(W/29)$B!*(62*1(0!8B!H()(+e!'/($%*!32*!./1*2%(.D!&.0!8B!',((!'/($%[!&.0!Y&.%(*!'/($%[!
<>L!
32*!6,2)6,2*9)!b?D=KD=;d[!#$1(*.&1/W($BD!*($(&)(!23!12]/+!+27629.0)!8B!8&+1(*/&!+29$0!&$)2!8(!/.W2$W(0!
<>P!
/.!1,(!/.,/8/12*B!(33(+1!28)(*W(0!&1!1,(!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(!b<PD=<d[!k(!&))97(0!1,&1!1,(!$24!7/+*2&$%&$!
<?K!
8/27&))! &++979$&1/2.! *(+2*0(0! 32*! -JKK;! +9$19*()! +29$0! *()9$1! 3*27! +276(1/1/2.! 8(14((.! 8&+1(*/&!
<?"!
&.0! 7/+*2&$%&(! 32*! 1,(! $/7/1(0! ./1*2%(.[! E.0((0D! 1,(! $&11(*! ,B621,()/)! 4&)! )9662*1(0D! )/.+(! ,/%,!
<?:!
8&+1(*/&$!+2.+(.1*&1/2.!2++9**(0!&1!)1&1/2.&*B!6,&)(!/.!-JKK;!+9$19*()D!4/1,!:<!m!23!1,(!)966$(7(.1(0!
<?;!
M! /.+2*62*&1(0! /.! 8&+1(*/&$! +($$)D! 4,/$(! M! /.+2*62*&1/2.! /.! 7/+*2&$%&(! V"P! mZ! 4&)! $24(*! 1,&.! 1,&1!
<?<!
*(+2*0(0!/.!&](./+!+9$19*()!V:>!mZ[!!
<?=!
y(./+!+9$19*()!(],/8/1(0!)/%./3/+&.1$B!$24(*!N7&]!&.0! O7&]!1,&.!&](./+!+9$19*()!/.!821,!(]6(*/7(.1)[!
<?>!
T-0C0:0::"?(K$?:&$#?!V-JKK"!&.0!-JKK:Z!&.0!!&'/P&$(?L*!V-J:=KZ!/)2$&1(0!3*27!1,(!](./+!+9$19*(!23!
<??!
!"#$%&'%%$( ?L[! -#h! "P[;! &.0! &))&B(0! /.0/W/09&$$B! &$)2! 0(6*())(0! 7/+*2&$%&$! %*241,! 6(*32*7&.+([!
<?L!
E.1(*()1/.%$BD!4(!/0(.1/3/(0!T-0C0:0::"?!K$?:&$#?!)1*&/.)!/.!1,(!](./+!+9$19*(!1,&1!,&0!8((.!6*(W/29)$B!
<?P!
0()+*/8(0! 8B! -/75H&1(2! '/( $%*! &)! &! 6,B126&1,2%(./+! 8&+1(*/&! /.W2$W(0! /.! %&$$! 32*7&1/2.! b==d[! E.!
<LK!
&00/1/2.D! !&'/P&$( 8&+1(*/&! &*(! &$)2! e.24.! &)! &$%/+/0&$! 8&+1(*/&! b<Ld[! N,/)! *()9$1! ,/%,$/%,1(0! 1,(!
<L"!
9)(39$.())!23!1()1/.%!8&+1(*/&$!6269$&1/2.)!/.!7/+*2&$%&(!+9$19*()[!E.0((0D!&1!1,(!/.09)1*/&$!)+&$(!4,(*(!
<L:!
&](./+!+2.0/1/2.)!+&.!,&*0$B!8(!&11&/.&8$(D!()6(+/&$$B!/.!26(.!+9$19*(!)B)1(7)D!)9)1&/.&8$(!&))2+/&1/2.!
<L;!
23!7/+*2&$%&(!4/1,!)($(+1(0!8&+1(*/&!+29$0!/76*2W(!6(*32*7&.+(!32*!7/+*2&$%&(!+9$19*([!
!
"P
<L<!
5. Conclusion
<L=!
#! )6(+/3/+! 7/+*26$&1(58&)(0! (]6(*/7(.1&$! 0()/%.! 4&)! 0(W($26(0! 12! )+*((.! 8&+1(*/&5!"#$%&'%%$( ?L[!
<L>!
&))2+/&1/2.)!&.0!12!)($(+1!7/+*2&$%&(!%*241,56*2721/.%!8&+1(*/&[!F*27!1,(!+276&*/)2.!23!*()9$1)!/.!&!
<L?!
3$&)e! (]6(*/7(.1D! /1! 4&)! +2.+$90(0! 1,&1! 1,(! (]6(*/7(.1&$! 0(W/+(! 4&)! &! 624(*39$! 122$! 32*! ,/%,5!
<LL!
1,*29%,691!(]&7/.&1/2.!23!1,(!8&+1(*/&$!(33(+1!2.!7/+*2&$%&$!%*241,[!N42!8&+1(*/&!)1*&/.)!&33/$/&1(0!12!
<LP!
M%/'50>0#$?(?L[!&.0!)"5&:$"C$(?L[!6&*1/+9$&*$B!(.,&.+(0!8/27&))!&++979$&1/2.!32*!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!#!
<PK!
)1*2.%! /.+*(&)(! 4&)! &$)2! *(+2*0(0! /.! M! /.+2*62*&1/2.D! 4,/+,! )9%%()1(0! 1,&1! M! &W&/$&8/$/1B! 32*!
<P"!
7/+*2&$%&(!4&)!&33(+1(0!8B!1,()(!8&+1(*/&[!F9*1,(*!*()(&*+,!/)!.((0(0!32*!&!6*(+/)(!&))())7(.1!23!1,(!
<P:!
9.0(*$B/.%!7(+,&./)7)!23!1,()(!/.1(*&+1/2.)[!M(W(*1,($())D!1,(!*()9$1)!23!1,(!6*()(.1!)190B!)9%%()1!1,&1!
<P;!
+9$19*(! 6(*32*7&.+(! +&.! 8(! )98)1&.1/&$$B! 720/3/(0! 8B! 8&+1(*/&D! *()9$1/.%! /.! /.+*(&)(0! +9$19*(!
<P<!
6*209+1/W/1BD!4,/+,!/)!23!6&*1/+9$&*!/.1(*()1!32*!/.09)1*/&$!6*209+1/2.[!
<P=!
!
:K
<P=!
F/%9*(!"!_!H&]/7&$!%*241,!*&1(!VN7&]Z!32*!!"#$%&'%%$(?L*!-#h!"P[;D!+&$+9$&1(0!/.!1,(!,/%,51,*29%,691!(]6(*/7(.1!
<P>!
V(]6(*/7(.1!"Z!32*!&](./+D!](./+!2*!7/](0!+9$19*()!4/1,!0/33(*(.1!8&+1(*/&$!)1*&/.)!&))&B(0!/.0/W/09&$$B[!F2*!(&+,!
<P?!
+9$19*(D!*&4!0&1&!32*!1,(!1,*((!*(6$/+&1()!&*(!+2..(+1(0!8B!&!W(*1/+&$!$/.(!12!3&+/$/1&1(!*(&0/.%[!'(3(*(.+(!.978(*)!
<PL!
/.!1,(!+2$$(+1/2.!&*(!%/W(.!2.!1,(!y5&]/)[!!
<PP!
F/%9*(! :_! H&]/7&$! 8/27&))! /.+*(&)(! VÄO>$RZ! 32*! !"#$%&'%%$( ?L[! -#h! "P[;! ()1/7&1(0! /.! 1,(! ,/%,51,*29%,691!
=KK!
(]6(*/7(.1! V(]6(*/7(.1! "Z! 32*! &](./+D! ](./+! 2*! 7/](0! +9$19*()! 4/1,! 0/33(*(.1! 8&+1(*/&$! )1*&/.)! &))&B(0!
=K"!
/.0/W/09&$$B[! F2*! (&+,! +9$19*(D! *&4! 0&1&! 32*! 1,(! 1,*((! *(6$/+&1()! &*(! +2..(+1(0! 8B! &! W(*1/+&$! $/.(! 12! 3&+/$/1&1(!
=K:!
*(&0/.%[!'(3(*(.+(!.978(*)!/.!1,(!+2$$(+1/2.!&*(!%/W(.!2.!1,(!y5&]/)[!!
=K;!
F/%9*(!;_!'#AY5AR'!6*23/$()!32*!/)2$&1()!3*27!3$&)e!7/](0!+9$19*()!-JKK;D!-JKK?!&.0!-J:<<!V(]6(*/7(.1!:Z!
=K<!
+276&*(0!4/1,!1,(!*($(W&.1!-JKK;D!-JKK?!&.0!-J:<<!+2.1*2$)!3*27!1,(!+2$$(+1/2.[!'()9$1)!4(*(!281&/.(0!4/1,!
=K=!
1,(!142!6*/7(*)!'#AY!"!&.0!'#AY!<[!N42!8&+1(*/&!+2$2./()!VR"!&.0!R:Z!4(*(!&.&$B)(0!32*!1,(!1,*((!*(6$/+&1(0!
=K>!
3$&)e)!VF"D!F:!&.0!F;Z[!
=K?!
F/%9*(! <! _! #Z! A&*1/+9$&1(! +&*82.! %*241,! +9*W()! /.! 3$&)e! +9$19*()! V(]6(*/7(.1! :Z! 32*! &](./+D! ](./+! )1*&/.)! &.0!
=KL!
7/](0!+9$19*()!V-JKK;D!-JKK?!&.0!-J:<<Z[!CZ!C&+1(*/&$!+2.+(.1*&1/2.!/.!7/](0!+9$9*()!&1!1,(!8(%/../.%!23!1,(!
=KP!
(]6(*/7(.1!&.0!&31(*!=!&.0!"K!0&B)!23!+9$19*([!
="K!
N&8$(!"!_!F&+12*!$(W($)!/.!1,(!+(.1*&$!+2762)/1(!0()/%.D!4,(*(!c"?""30636"/)!1,(!&]/&$!0/)1&.+(!8(14((.!)1&*!62/.1)!
=""!
&.0!1,(!+(.1(*!23!1,(!(]6(*/7(.1&$!027&/.[!
=":!
N&8$(!:!_!C&+1(*/&$!+2$$(+1/2.!/)2$&1(0!3*27!7/+*2&$%&(!+9$19*()[!
=";!
N&8$(! ;!_! #MUp#! 1&8$(! *()9$1/.%! 3*27! 1,(! 3&+12*/&$! 0()/%.! &66*2&+,! 9)(0! 32*! +276&*/)2.! 23! UY>LK! 12!
="<!
3$92*()+(.+(! &)! 6*2]B! 32*! 7/+*2&$%&$! 6269$&1/2.! /.! 7/](0! +9$19*([! -/%./3/+&.1! 65W&$9()! VcrK[K"Z! &*(! %/W(.! /.!
="=!
82$0[! V`Z! &.0! VcZ! )B782$)! 0(6/+1! 62)/1/W(! 2*! .(%&1/W(! (33(+1)! 32*! 1,(! +2**()62.0/.%! 3&+12*[! M! )1&.0)! 32*!
=">!
7/+*2&$%&(!+2.+(.1*&1/2.D!6!32*!8&+1(*/&$!+2.+(.1*&1/2.D!MM!&.0!66!32*!1,(!+2**()62.0/.%!f9&0*&1/+!(33(+1)!&.0!
="?!
M6!32*!/.1(*&+1/2.[!
="L!
N&8$(!<!_!),&6(D!f921&)!&.0!+2.1*/891/2.!32*!8&+1(*/&!12!6&*1/+9$&1(!R!&.0!M!*(+2W(*(0!2.!hFnR!3/$1(*)[!F2*!(&+,!
="P!
+2$97.D!1,(!W&$9()!6*()(.1(0!&*(!7(0/&.!&.0!/.1(*f9&*1/$(!*&.%(!VEu'Z!/.!8*&+e(1)[!
=:K!
N&8$(!=!_!h*241,!6&*&7(1(*)!&.0!./1*2%(.!/.+2*62*&1/2.!32*!!"#$%&'%%$(?L[!/.!3$&)e!+9$19*()!V(]6(*/7(.1!:Z!32*!
=:"!
](./+! &.0! &](./+! )1*&/.)D! &.0! 32*! 7/](0! +9$19*()! V-JKK;D! -JKK?! &.0! -J:<<Z[! F2*! (&+,! +2$97.D! 1,(! W&$9()!
!
:"
=::!
6*()(.1(0!&*(!7(0/&.!&.0!/.1(*f9&*1/$(!*&.%(!VEu'Z!/.!8*&+e(1)[!p&$9()!4/1,!1,(!)&7(!)96(*)+*/61!$(11(*)!&*(!.21!
=:;!
)1&1/)1/+&$$B!0/33(*(.1!Vx*9)e&$!k&$$/)!1()1O!g!r!=mZ[!
=:<!
References!!
=:=!
b"d! !A[!-62$&2*(D!R[!z2&../)5R&))&.D!G[!Y9*&.D!#[!E)&78(*1D!R277(*+/&$!&66$/+&1/2.)!23!7/+*2&$%&(D!
=:>!
z29*.&$!23!C/2)+/(.+(!&.0!C/2(.%/.((*/.%D!"K"!V:KK>Z!L?cP>[!
=:?!
b:d! !G[!H2$/.&!h*/7&D!G[5\[!C($&*8/D!F[[!#+/X.!F(*.{.0(aD!#[!'28$()!H(0/.&D!J[!R,/)1/D!'(+2W(*B!23!
=:L!
7/+*2&$%&$!8/27&))!&.0!7(1&82$/1()_!6*2+())!261/2.)!&.0!(+2.27/+)D!C/21(+,.2$2%B!#0W&.+()D!
=:P!
:K!V:KK;Z!<P"c="=[!
=;K!
b;d! !z[!A&*eD!\[5F[!z/.D!C[5'[!@/7D!x[5J[!A&*eD!x[!@((D!#772./&!*(72W&$!3*27!&.&(*28/+!0/%()1/2.!
=;"!
(33$9(.1! 23! $/W()12+e! 4&)1(! 9)/.%! %*((.! &$%&! -+(.(0()79)! )6D! C/2*()29*+(! N(+,.2$2%BD! "K"!
=;:!
V:K"KZ!L><PcL>=?[!
=;;!
b<d! !-['[! -98&),+,&.0*&82)(D! C[! '&7&e*/),.&.D! H[! H(%,&*&gD! x[! p(.e&1()4&*$9D! '[! M&/09D!
=;<!
R2.)2*1/&! 23! +B&.28&+1(*/&n7/+*2&$%&(! &.0! 8&+1(*/&_! C/21(+,.2$2%/+&$! 621(.1/&$D! C/21(+,.2$2%B!
=;=!
#0W&.+()D!:P!V:K""Z!LP>cPK?[!
=;>!
b=d! !G[! F29/$$&.0D! C/20/W(*)/1B! &)! &! 122$! 32*! 4&)1(! 6,B+2*(7(0/&1/2.! &.0! 8/27&))! 6*209+1/2.D!
=;?!
'(W/(4)!/.!G.W/*2.7(.1&$!-+/(.+(!&.0!C/2nN(+,.2$2%BD!""!V:K":Z!"c<[!
=;L!
b>d! !E[! z2/.1D! A[! \(.*/e)(.D! h[#[! F2..()D! Y[! C29*.(D! N[F[! N,/.%)1&0D! C[! '/(7&..D! R276(1/1/2.! 32*!
=;P!
/.2*%&./+! .91*/(.1)! 8(14((.! 6,B126$&.e12.! &.0! 8&+1(*/26$&.e12.! /.! .91*/(.1! 7&./69$&1(0!
=<K!
7()2+2)7)D!#f9&1!H/+*28!G+2$D!:P!V:KK:Z!"<=c"=P[!
=<"!
b?d! !h[5J[!',((D!R276(1/1/2.!8(14((.!&.!&$%&!&.0!&.!&f9&1/+!8&+1(*/97!32*!6,2)6,&1(D!@/7.2$2%B!
=<:!
&.0!U+(&.2%*&6,BD!"?!V"P?:Z!=K=c="<[!
=<;!
bLd! !y[! H&B&$/D! h[z[! Y29+(11(D! H/+*28/&$! +2779./1B! /.1(*&+1/2.)! &.0! 6269$&1/2.! 0B.&7/+)! 23! &.!
=<<!
&$%/+/0&$!8&+1(*/97!&+1/W(!&%&/.)1!x&*(./&!8*(W/)!VY/.26,B+(&(ZD!\&*739$!#$%&(D!"!V:KK:Z!:??c
=<=!
:P;[!
!
::
=<>!
bPd! !@[! p(*)+,9(*(D! h[! '278&91D! A[! -2*%($22)D! k[! p(*)1*&(1(D! A*28/21/+! C&+1(*/&! &)! C/2$2%/+&$!
=<?!
=<L!
R2.1*2$!#%(.1)!/.!#f9&+9$19*(D!H/+*28/2$[!H2$[!C/2$[!'(W[D!><!V:KKKZ!>==c>?"[!
b"Kd! !'[G[! #W(.0&|2D! R[G[! '/f9($7(D! G)1&8$/),7(.1! 23! 7/](0! +9$19*(! 6*28/21/+)! &.0! 7/+*2&$%&(! &)!
=<P!
==K!
3220!32*!8/W&$W(!$&*W&(D!#f9&+9$19*(!'()(&*+,D!;K!V:KK"Z!LP;cPKK[!
b""d! !z[z[! R2$(D! E.1(*&+1/2.)! 8(14((.! 8&+1(*/&! &.0! &$%&(! /.! &f9&1/+! (+2)B)1(7D! #..9&$! '(W/(4)! 23!
=="!
G+2$2%B!&.0!-B)1(7&1/+)D!";!V"PL:Z!:P"c;"<[!
==:!
b":d! !J[!A&*eD!x[5k[!z(D!x[!@((D!-[5G[!z9.%D!N[5z[!R,2/D!h*241,!6*2721/2.!23!R,$2*($$&!($$/6)2/0(&!8B!
==;!
+25/.2+9$&1/2.!4/1,!C*(W9.0/72.&)!)6!/)2$&1(0!3*27!1,(!7/+*2&$%&D!\B0*28/2$2%/&D!=PL!V:KKLZ!
==<!
:"Pc::L[!
===!
b";d! !H[N[!R*231D!#[Y[!@&4*(.+(D!G[!'&9]5Y((*BD!H[z[!k&**(.D!#[h[!-7/1,D!#$%&(!&+f9/*(!W/1&7/.!
==>!
C":!1,*29%,!&!)B78/21/+!*($&1/2.),/6!4/1,!8&+1(*/&D!M&19*(D!<;L!V:KK=Z!PKcP;[!
==?!
b"<d! !p[! N&/D! E[N[! A&9$)(.D! x[! A,/$$/66BD! Y[#[! z2,.)2.D! C[! A&$(./eD! k,2$( %(.27(! 7/+*2&**&B!
==L!
&.&$B)()!23!-B.(+,2+2++9)cp/8*/2!/.1(*&+1/2.)D!G.W/*2.7(.1&$!H/+*28/2$2%BD!""!V:KKPZ!:>PLc
==P!
:?KP[!
=>K!
b"=d! !z[! @/9D! #[z[! @(4/19)D! A[! C*24.D! -[C[! k/$0(D! h*241,56*2721/.%! (33(+1)! 23! &! 8&+1(*/97! 2.!
=>"!
*&6,/026,B1()!&.0!21,(*!6,B126$&.e12.D!\&*739$!#$%&(D!?!V:KKLZ!"c"K[!
=>:!
b">d! !@[G[! Y(5C&),&.D! J[! C&),&.D! H[! H2*(.2D! p[x[! @(8)eBD! z[z[! C9)1/$$2)D! E.+*(&)(0! 6/%7(.1! &.0!
=>;!
$/6/0!+2.1(.1D!$/6/0!W&*/(1BD!&.0!+($$!&.0!6269$&1/2.!)/a(!23!1,(!7/+*2&$%&(!R,$2*($$&!)66!4,(.!+25
=><!
/7728/$/a(0! /.! &$%/.&1(! 8(&0)! 4/1,! 1,(! 7/+*2&$%&(5%*241,56*2721/.%! 8&+1(*/97! #a2)6/*/$$97!
=>=!
8*&a/$(.)(D!R&.&0/&.!z29*.&$!23!H/+*28/2$2%BD!<L!V:KK:Z!="<c=:"[!
=>>!
b"?d! !h[z[! Y29+(11(D! E.1(*&+1/2.)! 8(14((.! 8&+1(*/&! &.0! ,&*739$! &$%&(_! #! *(W/(4D! M&19*&$! N2]/.)D! ;!
=>?!
=>L!
V"PP=Z!>=c?<[!
b"Ld! !\[A[!h*2))&*1D!H[!-/72.D!E.1(*&+1/2.)!23!6$&.e12./+!&$%&(!&.0!8&+1(*/&_!(33(+1)!2.!&$%&$!%*241,!
=>P!
&.0!2*%&./+!7&11(*!0B.&7/+)D!#f9&1!H/+*28!G+2$D!<?!V:KK?Z!">;c"?>[!
!
:;
=?K!
b"Pd! !#[!h&*0()D!H[\[!EW(*)(.D!\[5A[!h*2))&*1D!T[!A&))24D!H[-[!T$$*/+,D!Y/&1275&))2+/&1(0!8&+1(*/&!
=?"!
=?:!
&*(!*(f9/*(0!32*!&%%*(%&1/2.!23!N,&$&))/2)/*&!4(/))3$2%//D!E-HG!zD!=!V:K""Z!<;>c<<=[!
b:Kd! !C[!-/&$W(D!M[!C(*.(1D!U[!C(*.&*0D!#.&(*28/+!0/%()1/2.!23!7/+*2&$%&(!&)!&!.(+())&*B!)1(6!12!7&e(!
=?;!
7/+*2&$%&$!8/20/()($!)9)1&/.&8$(D!C/21(+,.2$[!#0W[D!:?!V:KKPZ!<KPc<">[!
=?<!
b:"d! !H[! h/2*0&.2D! E.1(*&+1/2.)! 8(14((.! R! &.0! M! 7(1&82$/)7! /.! Y9.&$/($$&! )&$/.&! +($$)! +9$19*(0! &1!
=?=!
($(W&1(0!RU:!&.0!,/%,!M!+2.+(.1*&1/2.)D!z29*.&$!23!A$&.1!A,B)/2$2%BD!"=L!V:KK"Z!=??c=L"[!
=?>!
b::d! !R[-[!k($0BD!H[\[!\9()(7&..D!@/6/0!A*209+1/2.!8B!Y9.&$/($$&!)&$/.&!/.!C&1+,!R9$19*(_!G33(+1)!
=??!
23!M/1*2%(.!@/7/1&1/2.!&.0!@/%,1!E.1(.)/1BD!z29*.&$!M&7(_!z29*.&$!23!T.0(*%*&09&1(!'()(&*+,D!
=?L!
pEE_""=5"::O!z29*.&$!p2$97(_!?D!V:KK?Z!H(0/97_!y[!
=?P!
b:;d! !z[\[! H9))%.9%D! p[! x$&))(.D! #[! -+,$}1(*D! U[! x*9)(D! H/+*2&$%&(! &)! )98)1*&1()! 32*! 3(*7(.1&1/W(!
=LK!
8/2%&)!6*209+1/2.!/.!&!+278/.(0!8/2*(3/.(*B!+2.+(61D!z29*.&$!23!C/21(+,.2$2%BD!"=K!V:K"KZ!="c
=L"!
=>[!
=L:!
b:<d! !#[! C(.5#721aD! z[G[k[! A2$$(D! Y[p[-[! '&2D! N,(! #$%&! Y9.&$/($$&_! C/20/W(*)/1BD! A,B)/2$2%BD!
=L;!
=L<!
h(.27/+)!&.0!C/21(+,.2$2%BD!-+/(.+(!A98$/),(*)DT[-[D!:KKP[!
b:=d! !z[!@B7&.D!'[\[!F$(7/.%D!R2762)/1/2.!23!)(&4&1(*D!z29*.&$!23!H&*/.(!'()(&*+,D!;!V"P<KZ!";<c
=L=!
=L>!
"<>[!
b:>d! !A['[! k&$.(D! G]6(*/7(.1)! /.! 1,(! $&*%(5)+&$(! +9$19*(! 23! 1,(! $&*W&(! 23! U)1*(&! (09$/)! @D! F/),(*B!
=L?!
E.W()1/%&1/2.)[!-(*/()!EED!:=!V"P>>Z[!
=LL!
b:?d! !z[5J[! R,2D! z[5-[! R,2/D! E[5-[! x2.%D! -[5E[! A&*eD! '[h[! x(**D! J[5x[! \2.%D! #! 6*2+(09*(! 32*! &](./+!
=LP!
/)2$&1/2.!23!1,(!7&*/.(!7/+*2&$%&!E)2+,*B)/)!%&$8&.&!3*27!,(&W/$B!+2.1&7/.&1(0!7&))!+9$19*()D!
=PK!
z29*.&$!23!#66$/(0!A,B+2$2%BD!"<!V:KK:Z!;L=c;PK[!
=P"!
b:Ld! !H[!h&*./(*D!J[!@&8*(9+,(D!z[5@[!M/+2$&)D!H2$(+9$&*! &.0!6,(.21B6/+!+,&*&+1(*/a&1/2.!23!p/8*/2!
=P:!
&()19&*/&.9)!)98)6!3*&.+(.)/)!)98)6!.2WD!&!6&1,2%(.!23!1,(!2B)1(*!R*&))2)1*(&!%/%&)D!-B)1(7&1/+!
=P;!
&.0!#66$/(0!H/+*28/2$2%BD!;"!V:KKLZ!;=Lc;>=[!
!
:<
=P<!
b:Pd! !z[! C*2)/9)D! H[@[! A&$7(*D! A[z[! x(..(0BD! \[F[! M2$$(*D! R276$(1(! .9+$(21/0(! )(f9(.+(! 23! &! ">-!
=P=!
*/82)27&$!'M#!%(.(!3*27!G)+,(*/+,/&!+2$/D!AM#-D!?=!V"P?LZ!<LK"c<LK=[!
=P>!
b;Kd! !u[!k&.%D!h[H[!h&**/1BD!z[H[!N/(0g(D!z['[!R2$(D!M&qW(!C&B()/&.!R$&))/3/(*!32*!'&6/0!#))/%.7(.1!
=P?!
23! *'M#! -(f9(.+()! /.12! 1,(! M(4! C&+1(*/&$! N&]2.27BD! #66$[! G.W/*2.[! H/+*28/2$[D! ?;! V:KK?Z!
=PL!
=:>"c=:>?[!
=PP!
b;"d! !z[5@[! M/+2$&)D! -[! R2**(D! z[5R[! R2+,&*0D! C&+1(*/&$! A269$&1/2.! #))2+/&1/2.! 4/1,! A,B126$&.e12.!
>KK!
R9$19*(0!/.!&!C/W&$W(!\&1+,(*BD!H/+*28!G+2$D!<L!V:KK<Z!<KKc<";[!
>K"!
b;:d! !C[R[!R*976D!G[p[!#*78*9)1D!z[#[!C&*2))D!A,B$2%(.(1/+!#.&$B)/)!23!A&*1/+$(5#11&+,(0!&.0!F*((5
>K:!
@/W/.%! C&+1(*/&$! R2779./1/()! /.! 1,(! R2$978/&! '/W(*D! E1)! G)19&*BD! &.0! 1,(! #0g&+(.1! R2&)1&$!
>K;!
U+(&.D!#66$[!G.W/*2.[!H/+*28/2$[D!>=!V"PPPZ!;"P:c;:K<[!
>K<!
b;;d! !Y[\[! h*((.D! @[G[! @$(4($$B.D! #[A[! M(%*/D! -[E[! C$&+e89*.D! R[z[-[! C2$+,D! A,B$2%(.(1/+! &.0!
>K=!
39.+1/2.&$!0/W(*)/1B!23!1,(!+9$1/W&8$(!8&+1(*/&$!+2779./1B!&))2+/&1(0!4/1,!1,(!6&*&$B1/+!),($$3/),!
>K>!
62/)2./.%! 0/.23$&%($$&1(! hB7.20/./97! +&1(.&197D! FGH-! H/+*28/2$2%B! G+2$2%BD! <?! V:KK<Z!
>K?!
;<=c;=?[!
>KL!
b;<d! !H[! -&66D! #[! k/+,($)D! x[\[! k/$1),/*(D! h[! h(*01)D! C&+1(*/&$! +2779./1B! 0B.&7/+)! 09*/.%! 1,(!
>KP!
>"K!
4/.1(*c)6*/.%!1*&.)/1/2.!/.!1,(!M2*1,!-(&D!FGH-!H/+*28/2$2%B!G+2$2%BD!=P!V:KK?Z!>::c>;?[!
b;=d! !z[!A/.,&))/D!T[!t4(/3($D!#[!\&%)1*27D!Y27/.&.1!7&*/.(!8&+1(*/26$&.e12.!)6(+/()!329.0!&72.%!
>""!
+2$2.B532*7/.%!8&+1(*/&D!#66$[!G.W/*2.[!H/+*28/2$[D!>;!V"PP?Z!;;=Pc;;>>[!
>":!
b;>d! !M[! C&.2D! z[N[! \2$$/8&9%,D! Y/W(*)/1B! &.0! Y/)1*/891/2.! 23! YM#! -(f9(.+()! 4/1,! #33/./1B! 12!
>";!
#772./&5U]/0/a/.%! C&+1(*/&! 23! 1,(! ! -980/W/)/2.! 23! 1,(! R$&))! A*21(28&+1(*/&! /.! 1,(! #*+1/+!
>"<!
U+(&.D!#66$/(0!&.0!G.W/*2.7(.1&$!H/+*28/2$2%BD!>>!V:KKKZ!"P>K!c"P>P[!
>"=!
b;?d! !\[!-+,~3(*D!C[!#88&)D!\[!k/11(D!h[!H9Ba(*D!h(.(1/+!0/W(*)/1B!23!)&1($$/1(€!8&+1(*/&!6*()(.1!/.!
>">!
>"?!
+9$19*()!23!7&*/.(!0/&127)D!FGH-!H/+*28/2$2%B!G+2$2%BD!<:!V:KK:Z!:=c;=[!
b;Ld! !Y[@[! x/*+,7&.D! N,(! (+2$2%B! 23! RB126,&%&5F$&W28&+1(*/&! /.! &f9&1/+! (.W/*2.7(.1)D! FGH-!
>"L!
H/+*28/2$[!G+2$[D!;P!V:KK:Z!P"c"KK[!
!
:=
>"P!
b;Pd! !x[! k&1&.&8(D! M[! N&e/,&.&D! \[! #2B&%/D! -[! \&.&0&D! J[! k&1&.&8(D! M[! U,79*&D! \[! -&/e/D! \[!
>:K!
N&.&e&D! -B78/21/+! &))2+/&1/2.! /.! R,$2*($$&! +9$19*(D! FGH-! H/+*28/2$2%B! G+2$2%BD! ="! V:KK=Z!
>:"!
"L?c"P>[!
>::!
b<Kd! !C[!-eg($8*(0D!C[!G0W&*0)(.D!N[!#.0(*)(.D!#!,/%,51,*29%,691!7(1,20!32*!7(&)9*/.%!%*241,!&.0!
>:;!
>:<!
$2))!*&1()!/.!7/+*2&$%&$!+9$19*()D!z!#66$!A,B+2$D!:<!V:K":Z!"=LPc"=PP[!
b<"d! !x[! x2%9*(D! E[! x2/e(D! A&*1/+$(! R29.1(*! Y(1(*7/.&1/2.! 23! C&+1(*/&$! C/27&))! /.! -(&4&1(*D! #66$[!
>:=!
>:>!
G.W/*2.[!H/+*28/2$[D!=;!V"PL?Z!:?<c:??[!
b<:d! !H['[!Y*226D!p/1&7/.!C":!&.0!7&*/.(!(+2$2%B!Ep!N,(!e/.(1/+)!23!961&e(D!%*241,!&.0!/.,/8/1/2.!
>:?!
>:L!
/.!H2.2+,*B)/)!$91,(*/D!z[!H&*[!C/2$[D!<L!V"P>LZ!>LPc?;;[!
b<;d! !y[!H&B&$/D!F[!#a&7D!#$%/+/0&$!C&+1(*/&!/.!1,(!-(&!&.0!1,(/*!E76&+1!2.!#$%&$!C$227)"D!z29*.&$!
>:P!
>;K!
23!G9e&*B21/+!H/+*28/2$2%BD!="!V:KK<Z!";Pc"<<[!
b<<d! !-97/.12D!\/*&B&7&D!#66$/+&1/2.!23!&!%*241,56*2721/.%!8&+1(*/&!32*!)1&8$(!7&))!+9$19*(!23!1,*((!
>;"!
>;:!
7&*/.(!7/+*2&$%&(D!\B0*28/2$2%/&D!;=L!V"PP?Z!::;c:;K[!
b<=d! !A[-[! -&$272.D! E[! E7&/D! A&1,2%(.)! 23! \&*739$! H/+*2&$%&(D! /._! G[! h*&.X$/D! z[N[! N9*.(*! VG0)[ZD!
>;;!
G+2$2%B!23!\&*739$!#$%&(D!-6*/.%(*!C(*$/.!\(/0($8(*%D!:KK>_!66[!:?"c:L:[!
>;<!
b<>d! !#[H[! #7&*2D! H[-[! F9(.1()D! -['[! U%&$0(D! z[#[! p(.(%&)D! C[#[! -9&*(a5/)$&D! E0(.1/3/+&1/2.! &.0!
>;=!
R,&*&+1(*/a&1/2.!23!A21(.1/&$$B!#$%&$5$B1/+!H&*/.(!C&+1(*/&!-1*2.%$B!#))2+/&1(0!4/1,!1,(!N2]/+!
>;>!
Y/.23$&%($$&1(!#$(]&.0*/97!+&1(.($$&D!N,(!z29*.&$!23!G9e&*B21/+!H/+*28/2$2%BD!=:!V:KK=Z!"P"c
>;?!
:KK[!
>;L!
b<?d! !E[!E7&/D!Y[!F9g/7&*9D!N[!M/),/%&e/D!H[!x9*2)&e/D!\[!-9%/1&D!#$%/+/0&$!8&+1(*/&!/)2$&1(0!3*27!1,(!
>;P!
)9*3&+(!23!)(&4((0)!3*27!1,(!+2&)1!23!U)&e&!C&B!/.!1,(!-(12!E.$&.0!-(&D!z&6&.D!#3*/+&.!z29*.&$!
><K!
23!H&*/.(!-+/(.+(D!:L!V:KK>Z!;"Pc;:;[!
><"!
b<Ld! !H[5z[! x/7D! -[5J[! z(2.%D! -[5z[! @((D! E)2$&1/2.D! /0(.1/3/+&1/2.D! &.0! &$%/+/0&$! &+1/W/1B! 23! 7&*/.(!
><:!
8&+1(*/&! &%&/.)1! R2+,$20/./97! 62$Be*/e2/0()D! z29*.&$! 23! #66$/(0! A,B+2$2%BD! :K! V:KKLZ! "K>Pc
><;!
"K?L[!
!
:>
><<!
b<Pd! !x[!F9e&7/D!N[!M/),/g/7&D!J[!E),/0&D!-1/79$&1/W(!&.0!/.,/8/12*B!(33(+1)!23!8&+1(*/&)!2.!1,(!%*241,!
><=!
><>!
23!7/+*2&$%&(D!\B0*28/2$2%/&D!;=L!V"PP?Z!"L=c"P"[!
b=Kd! !H[! Y&.%(*D! z[! @(3$&/W(D! R[! U97&*29D! @[! N(.5\&%(D! h[! @&+*2/]D! R2.1*2$! 23! 6,B126$&.e12.5
><?!
8&+1(*/&!/.1(*&+1/2.)!8B!)12/+,/27(1*/+!+2.)1*&/.1)D!U/e2)D!"">!V:KK?Z!"K?Pc"KL>[!
><L!
b="d! !z[! H29%(1D! #[! Y&e,&7&D! H[R[! @&W2/(D! z[! M2}(D! #$%&$! %*241,! (.,&.+(7(.1! 8B! 8&+1(*/&_! E)!
><P!
+2.)9761/2.!23!6,212)B.1,(1/+!2]B%(.!/.W2$W(0lD!FGH-!H/+*28/2$2%B!G+2$2%BD!"L!V"PP=Z!;=c
>=K!
<;[!
>="!
b=:d! !H[! A9g25A&BD! A[! '&/78&9$1D! E76*2W(7(.1! 23! 1,(! 4(152]/0&1/2.! 6*2+(09*(! 32*! )/79$1&.(29)!
>=:!
0(1(*7/.&1/2.! 23! 6&*1/+9$&1(! 2*%&./+! ./1*2%(.! &.0! 6,2)6,2*9)! +2$$(+1(0! 2.! 3/$1(*)D! H&*/.(!
>=;!
G+2$2%B5A*2%*())!-(*/()D!"K=!V"PP<Z!:K;c:K;[!
>=<!
b=;d! !-[@[!H()(+eD!C[R[!-7/1,D!h[\[!k/e32*)D!z[\[!#$/]D!Y[!x&6&*(/e2D!M91*/(.1!/.1(*&+1/2.)!8(14((.!
>==!
6,B126$&.e12.!&.0!8&+1(*/26$&.e12.!9.0(*!0/33(*(.1!+&*82.!0/2]/0(!*(%/7()D!z!#66$!A,B+2$D!"P!
>=>!
V:KK?Z!::Pc:;?[!
>=?!
b=<d! !#[! H/1)91&./D! E[! J&7&)&e/D! \[! x/1&%9+,/D! z[! x&12D! -[! T(.2D! J[! E),/0&D! #.&$B)/)! 23! &$%/+/0&$!
>=L!
6*21(/.)! 23! &! 0/&1275$B1/+! 7&*/.(! 8&+1(*/97! A)(902&$1(*272.&)! )6! )1*&/.! #:=! 8B! 1425
>=P!
0/7(.)/2.&$!($(+1*26,2*()/)D!A,B+2$2%/&D!<K!V:KK"Z!:L>c:P"[!
>>K!
b==d! !R[!-/7.5H&1(2D!-[!Y(69B01D!R[@[!Y(!U$/W(/*&!H&.()D!F[!R.900(D!H[!\2$)1(*)D!x[!h2(1,&$)D!Y[!
>>"!
p(*((+e(D! N,(! 6,B126&1,2%(.! ',202+2++9)! 3&)+/&.)! 8*(&e)! &6/+&$! 027/.&.+(! &.0! &+1/W&1()!
>>:!
&]/$$&*B! 7(*/)1(7)! 8B! /.09+/.%! 6$&.1! %(.()! /.W2$W(0! /.! ,2*72.(! 7(1&82$/)7D! H2$(+9$&*! A$&.1!
>>;!
A&1,2$2%BD!?!V:KK>Z!"K;c"":[!
>><!
!
!
:?