An Alternate Objective Function for Markovian Fields

!!#"$&%'"$
)( *
,+$"-#./01213!4
79?!8Z):!6\[U7<?^;97>]O=@?Y?96A _
BDCFÈKFG*a9HCHIJE<R\KJBbBDNcKJL9d@MOeTNQPd@RTfFSUKJNVEJdgR@NQa9NQPJhWP
J
M
X55679?Y8i
]j,kmlYno?Yprq _
eTd\à>stBuHR\BbNcKJde\d@fFKJdgNQa9hP
_A.¢vxDwz>y|{~w'}Y~y~ODby9£,9y|Owzby|Qb>>w'<Jy~D2#<91|b#{|U11#U91x9¤9#QyD{~TVy¥¦£§@u|2ÿ|9>#<D!©¡x9bQ9UªUw'«|{YObQ2#ªbx F2¬Q*U§9bJ~bb>b <y|¯9®-¡ bv°m2 ¢
³± ²2´bµ<¶9·,¸Tµ
¹º< <»w'D}TÂ« #{y|Q9D{Àª¼y¦bU½DÀ9£tb~~ <»w>y~1!¾»{y|wb'{À£Ã¿<y|{D#wÁ}>wby|{À|w ÄQ>D y~}9Å9<.y~¨>Uw{xQQzy¥¤m#£»w'Qy|}T{#»{~{29ªwzy|1Å9ÆÇy~#y|Å>w'Èw~Vyªb{Q>É¥wF¨ <yx{À <y~»|{ÀQÆÆ
y~>|{ÀQ}999ª!y~wÊ9#zÌÍ¤b#1$¨{¥wyx}U£tD9ËU{~Dy~¨9ÈD>£t1b.{#¬È <{|È1|-9|>w'Ty~b¤{~
y~QDw'#{Ày|y~9Å9y|Q<Q> ªÊ$y|y|m#Å>1wz>by! 9Vy|>Q<b|>y~È*{#¬y|wbÅ9È#o#o9ªb||9w'wb|y~ <DD{~Q#³#¨ÿÐy|1'w'Î>£!y~#Å9y|Ï¦{»{1{~1>#b¨{ÀÅ yy
£t <VËy|QbÑ>wzw'Ò<9ow'9>Í <bÓÕÿ~Ô|QDY >{#Ñ¨w'w'>| o¿z£t¤$!w$< <##Ò¨»y|{##>>O{~b< Æ
'1Ò<£JUy|Å9D~D{~2#ÿ|<w <@D|{D{~9¨Q¤by|{2¤Y{ÀÅ9Q9zª$Ì×Å9y|»Å> 9 <wzy#y~Å9{À$y|wz9y|D#{DÌ¾¬g1Ö2b9{Ày
9ÌÐ#w'~Vzy|Å-¤Yªb» <y|Q¤bÅ9DË{Ð{~w« ªw99}UzQDØU¤bV#ÆÚ#}9Jw»¨wwy>{D «<919~Ù\b|D}9z¤y|##Q¤b*¬ DÌbywu{mw''>£, $ <y~DÅUwwzQyg9Qª y
ÛÝÜbÞßà µ¨áâ à µ ßà µ³ãä·¶9åæ@çÐèÀ· Þ ãäæÐéêë~´
¹>D9b<yyÀw'ÆÚJ9>y~~9b<}9yQDìYw' 9|#»{ÀQ99ªª¦Q£g{Àw'bY>¦#ÿ~»wbw'Å9 >Q>wz*y|w¦Qw'{2|w9Q£t>9ª> 9w<w'ÆÆ
>»w'Q}T»##w'y~Q9ª<>í{Dy'w'>ª1ªbQ>> <ªÊ9{Àªy~y|Qwb>¿Y{m9ª2£ob <}<<É¥1D91y|{Db$y¤Y{#» <w'#>* Á{Ày~| 9Dw#ÿ~{DQÆ
£tYY>#9QªD'y| <'Äy|V£r{!Å>bw'>{D£t9¬î>1§Ëy~Å9Ä>w9.|~D}9ª#ï>{#wðw''£Ãy|Q#>¾³}Uwb³1» ×#wb{¥y
wbõï{Ñöø
b9Ê÷zùuúz£û|ùü'{¥y|ûDQý#ýDý|w'ùy~þ,9ÿ ªñªwó¤Dò|º{¥ywz{~y|DôbÁb}>òÀ{À»Dw'~}T¤z#w'»y~ô0>{~D{ ¨9D>1ö
w¹'÷*y ú >y~û| {¥wbüyOû#y~y~ýD»1ý#bý#þy|Å9ÿ >¬Qbb§Ë}>Å9{ÀODo~}U¤zww'}Uy~y~Å¦D{>w'yg{ ùy~ w'w'{¥y|9wz,y~9'ª.£Ã{y|Ðw'#*U 9wub-y~D>{À}U#y~$w9>ªo{|w'y~{|z{À£t9wzbª Æ ¬
y|ÌÐ9Å>|$Å¤bD{À>y|{#Fw <~
#{ÀËªw>D !b~}YË1by~Å>9wQ#QªbÒ.9|>Vy| <Å9D ~YQQ>9ª#wuÌÊDb 9y|w'#y|w
{Àw'y~yË|Dy~Å9w.#}Y9~|#>¨ <yË»#y~wzy|Q.>ªw{Ëy~Å9Ì$#9J|wD{Ë{~#>#y~.Å9'*£g>#wb#{¥~y1y|íw'£t<!y|9#|#¬,D§ËbÅ9y{
y|ªbQbbw@z»{¤#y~Ë{Ày|wzYy| 9D{#w1>D -Àyw'w}U¯Dwb{D{À¬ TD1y|{'£Oy~Å9É¥ÿx 9{Ày~|Q}><Æ
y|¹{~Q#>|ªy|¤Å9 Ê{Áw'>ÌÐyw'TÅ9y~»#w'Å0Ì9y|Q>Å9£tª¯È<1y|w>Q}U{ÐDÑb{w>w'y~Å9 |.y|{~Å9 9wz!Ty#yQw|¤¨{~w¿Ê»{À{~y-Dwz y>wQy~Àw'y|{¥|yw9Qy|9 Qª¦!{~b1}<y~»{ÆÆ
y|¤zw'y~9~> <{D¬Ë»¯y.»ow'}TDw'#»!{D£tVy|.Å9#wª1¤UD¯{À» <{~#D¨9#9UQ1>.'9£|QD9 <>»<y|yoQb }U{À Ø>DÀQÆÆ
y|w#~|oQ>ªª ¤#^ÌÐxÅ9 <»#»Åwu9 Ê9~y|<Å9#^D{|b{À}>9{~ª #| ¤u{Àw'y~Y'>y|{Å9Q>>³ª Ðy~½^y|ÌÐQÅ>Å £twbQF~< <b}>Dw9{~>#'1|£T ¤uy~Uw'Å9y~> <>D}>{ËD{~ Ñw#|~Q¤zxywzª#y~¤9DU»J !{@¬ »}T{,¹ $9wmy~yÅ9Q~»w'{À.¨}99{~QV1|y¥y~Dby~ o¬ 9£tªb{Dg9>ªw9Y< <w o#>ªT{~D#Qy¥<~ ÆÆ
D^|w'w'y~|¿¤z.¤ << < <D#{ £t 2Ñ{~D ¨9 D¨ {Ày~D»w'!Ø> 9ªbwz9yw¦~Ê{ÀU ÅÑww~{Ð!y|9Å9ymÅ99 >1 <D#{À Æ
y|}>{|Å9w'<|my~Q³bw'~9w'¦>> Ê~ <bQÏ¦9y~ÅY~1»>wz9{y|Qy$T>£Ãy~{À~Db> }91$Q|DDy~¨Å>9#!~£Ð-w'Q|w'o|wz9|y~mQ>y~Dªy||wy~9Å9Q9y~m99£tªmª9Qy|Ë 9-wz <y{~»{¥wÈy|~¤QQ Æ
b{~>| 9Åm#Dy~w'>{|ww'TÅ> <QD¤~ªy~Y < mªTw'#>~Å9£tD|w'Uw'><# <¬D>Ô9y|9Å>~wzy~yÐÅ9Dwz~y~y~Db~b99y|{gw'Yy~
}TbDw'}>#<»{~{m#y|9|D¤u|w'w'Ð9y~y~>Å9'2ym£t{¥9>y|~{~ÑÉ¥w'b»w'Q¨|¬ yËªb <{À|y~»|ÅJ}9Ë<y~99-<z¤#wD£tD<w'y|y~99<|yD{O{¦wQ> y|»Å9wz Æ
b~ w'9> <~b{À9y~|~»}9wz<y|Èy~w99|£*bwbw}UÅ0D2{{~Dy|¨³9#U<1 <DD{¦.ª¤>#Q³y|y|Å9Å9
£tDwzy|#9|!ª~"D{# $¬ £t#% Ð§Ë#Ìw<¾y~9||#»9wzªoy|Dy| Å9»{w' 9#Å9TVy|#D>1 <y~D9>|D1b{Ä<Å>}Uwu¤by~Åñ'|£D#ÌÐ#Å>ÿ~Å
w {ÀQDzÌ0Ø>y|ªÅ9>*~>{~ x1¬-'£Ñ~»uÅ-w'>Q>9<#1w'y\w'£tÇ¬ wzy|'9&)~()(){Ð( w2{Ë9b~}>b{ÀUD¨~{À¤zw' Ñy~y|Å9> {
>^D~wwzD~¤¨Ò<UQ{m$U9w'{ wb}UÓ}>D{~¨Ð#y||~y~¤ub w'ÿ~y|¼Å9Ñ<ÑÆ 1 <w9D~|¿bU|zD#¤ñ>¨ <y!#¨w<y¦}U <Dy|DÂ| ¬0w> Ñ{~Vy|ÓgÅ>Qb^Q³Ñ £tÑ~ÑbÓgîÌÐ^Å>y|ÑÅ9Å {
w{~<~Ù\#w', w-òÀ»w'9}T|#zQ¤ÆÇ#}9»wD{|bôÐy$9|z¤}>#oQDy~Å9ÌÐªÅ9D9Å#'wz1y||Q>¤b < #.^{~U½w'¿Yy~QÅ9>Dª>
y|>>#<~b£rw'U<¨~yO{Ày~o ³£rwuwby~¤ 9Å9b < 9|DO{{|{»Uw'y~Å9}T <»#V{y|»Q{b>ÌÐw'VQy|xy|Å^w'y~£twD>Ì¾J <Y{~> w'#ÙT#DÔDÀ{|y¥#{Àb» |1{Dy¬ w'¹ Ç¯¬ Ô*"w&È()Ð( w'w' yÀ Æ
>w>»w' <}T~#y~{~D ¨9D>Y1 9x#ªbQÌÐb}>Å9w'Å!Q>wz|y|Å9#wËQ y|
#Å>{w'y~Å9$YD9w'|Qb}>¬ w}9QQy¥m'£
{~¨DVy~ÿ|9Å9Dw>|>1ªÅ>Å¾Vy|Dy~Å9<y|D <9~#|³»D{#{JÅ>wwb <>{¯» *{~#}T|>##{~9D{~º|DÊ{~##¨>y|£2{~w'»w'y~ <>#9>w'~{Tb}9£t9bÄ|w'Q9Yy~m9¤<b{¥y~}<y|ÆÇQbÉ¥ª¨D<wz1y~y|y~>Qb<¤ y
£ty|>Q¤b>#y|Qbw>}>{F{~#£tb¨JyD¬ y~¹ w'x9y~Å99»{ªËUy~Å>w'TD{~#Ow'Ì,Å9£t<Qy~1U{Jy~>~xy|{\Å9Å>gw»{wz}Uy~y~DD#@*¨|9#D»wz{ÀÆÆ
y|y|QQbb,>w'+>ÌÐwÅ>}UwzDy$>{À{~Å9¨b99# ½>#w <»{¥<y| <~D}9<Dy|w'Qb<. y|9- ~Â¦0õ w/ 1}Ub3<2my.Èy|Å9-9#|D{~># <¨QyÆ
s1
s2
s3
sT
s1
s2
s3
sT
s1
s2
s3
sT
x1
x2
x3
xT
x1
x2
x3
xT
x1
x2
x3
xT
h1
x1
h2
x3
x2
s1
h3
s2
hT
xT
s3
sT
"!#$%'&()*,+-+/.0+213+-+/.0465789:!;*<57>=?!#$%@
ACBD#$!E9GFA#IH"F
J
K
|yQwy||{Ë9w#Q>Ì½Q99bª-|}<zÉ¥Ñ¤DD1w' my~|¿¤Uz,D¤YÀ£t»9£tw'bUm~y~w<> <1'D2 <{2#|>Q¤b{~{ÀQD9¤1ªm#Ï¦Vw'y#UQTDy|wbwb>y{À !¿<w'{D <ª¬,#b!~Qy~b'Å9>y|Q{¥¤zy|wz{J|y|w'£tDy~
}YÑbÔ 9x~< <{À#>ÇV y{#J» 9Ì <D!w'»{Àw'>b 9y|~<ì <UÔ1#» 9w'{È1 ÒYy~D*Ô >{~¬Qb^y|-y|Å9
± MñPê O â ,² Q¨ê¸Tµ9è çgSê R àÞ ¸Tµ9è¥æ Þ
L N
¹ 9Vy|Qb>w¨w'<$ <9»{¥y|w~y|}9<Dw'y|Q9bw$99£U»Dw'wz}Ty~#»{Uª{#b¤#$< <D}>Q{~#9|ªx¤zwzy~y|Å9Qb>£t9{Q\1ªbÅ¨<yÆ
y|y|}TQ b>9w'9Qg>>~QDD1ª
#{~{|Ñ>w'{|y|Å9¬½!Ô>ÿ|'Uy|*1w1#Ò9'Ywy|9 9$>}UQbDÅUmw'ÌÐ'>Å9£*{*DDÈ~>|» <*Dª{bby|QwV£t,Y»w'9}TQªªb#Åb£t9y.Q>9}TªU1 Æ ¬
È£ÌÐÅ9DQªb~-Åby*y~Å99{Ày*}U£t9Uby|y~#|UD{Àw'y~Ë ^~Dª¯>{$< <<D#Q#9Q>$ªÌÐ#Qy~|ÅÄ~D|Dw'{~y~U>y{
y| 91Dy~wb9ªÅw'xy~Å9bD}<DÉ¥¬D1YyDQ« {JYwD~wzy|QUbQxwb¤Y#»#{À9>|ww'Fy~y~DQww'¿Yy9Dwbªy|Åwby~{À¿<{D9{¥9y||#1 Æ
»{-wu9'}Uyw½9|T}>~wy|w}9¨QÑy2y~#¤bwz#É¥ÑD1Qy~£,by~~Å>b¬ {~D¹ Á¨9{~D>>1Å0$'#wb£{À9|{#DÐ <Ì»¯y|Qbw>~{
b9Äÿ~ÂDù ~ / {¥1y|D¦ ³wz0y|Å9y~#Å>Uy|Å>T w'#WñVYX)y~!Å9È#%£t9d c!"$#% (Z [V ]\_^D`
"aZ/b
! $!"#%
(Z YV ]\)^ 'Eb Ç0õ / '¬ e#zÌ*ÌQÿ|~< <>#2w.#b{Ày£t9>1Æ
y|Q£@by|Å9y~DÅ>{~*w'y{ÀU9Dªb>Q#w'ÆÂy|
#QD{xww'|<ª <D>w'}>Jwb <{À»{Ày~ |Q}999y~mb>-{D¬ y|Å9o¨>wQQy¥
§Ë{~DÅ>¨ 9D>{À1y|#wÆÇ>»w' 9}Tw'# /
b}< <É¥#D»{1y~{¤y|Å9x£t>Qb>ª$y|>Qb~b }>w'£t}9bVy¥^w'£J|y~¿Å9zx¤YDw< Æ
\

y|Q|xw}UD{~D¨9#U1xª¤Dmy|Å9*}>{~#|¤zwzy|Qb-{~D¨9#U1)+
fg]h õû 1 ö Qb,
ª - Ç0õ / h ö Qb,ª - Çù þú / h Ìy|ÐÅ9Å>»{#|}9ÌOÉ¥DO>y|Q{~¤bg.9!y|wzwy|Qby|| wùQ>?Yij Q9öª¦{~÷u1ù yYj wzûDyÀý#y|ýD#ý#û|ù < yiu{ÿ ¬y|Ö2<y|w'QÒ<Q
# 9
#ª
y|y|Å9QbÐo9{~|D¨}>9w#}9U1QQy¥¬@*§Ë'Å9£\O1w|9|9D|y|bQw*Åx»w'wz}Ty@#y~Q9{¥yJª*y|wQ$ODb{y|Qy~|Ë{¥}>y|{~Q#|w'¤zy~wz Æ
y|k Å9Vxy|#|w}9}UÐDQ>w'9y~ªÅ 1>¬ {À¹9£ªy|y~Å9Å>{wb#¨1{¥>yÐ|w'Qy~¿b## ¦~{¥#yÎ>wzy~D*1y|{~{$Dÿ~Å>9mD>y1w {~¿ y|Å9wzy
ÅUw'> F9y~Å9»{1¨{¥yÐ»{Ðw'9>~b9~»wzy|¬
#¨z ÌOy|
DQ$D¤y~y~DÅ9*DË1'Ò<£Ã9y|T#QD*1y~y|
#DÅ9 $gy~Y|Å9D9wobY1}T9|#$Qy~#}U|D£T1.b'~£Fwz|y@D1y~»y@{À»{¥»w'yw'}T}Ty~##»Q{#g9ª¨»{J{#y|bD#¨¤9Dwz¤zÒYwzVÆÆ£
¤b¾#|{Ào£tD9Ì$Q> <91<yÐ{ÀTbb>{~#Vy|>Qb#DÑ{g'w£ ~fÉ¥g w'b}Ty|zQ¤*»w'|}T##¤Qw' »{Twm#~#£t~DU1y|»Qw'b¬
bwb2}<{~{À{~É¥99D1ªy~<y~¤Å>y|ËQ!b£t.9ò~U9Å>>wy~ <QDm~~Y>{gQQ>9ªô$'ÌÐyO£wÅY9#9y~>| <w'9Qy~9|Q»>wzUy~ªw'ËÌÐF£tb9Qy~|Å.y|}>y|Å9Å9w{OË}91{¥Q|yQy¥Vw'y|$ >#+ | 9Qwb|J ¬
fg ?h õû m
ö l Qbª - Âù / ù oú n ú û h "& È>~m <{~#1yxy~y|Å9Å>wzyo9#Ò¨<y* <»Dw'}T{.#y~,w'ªbQ9¤b#DÑ Èy|>Å9{~Q>ª }Uf{ÀDg ~¤zw'wz|y|QbQ>w'{|w'9>9 ªy~
qpar
"VV
r % #s\$r%Z ^t ?p#Pt ! ¬
¹>^#Ì½y~Å9}9É¥{~D9Qy||QQ¤by£Oy~Å> <»{~wu#¤b~#w'Q>ªw'y~¤$Qw'|9T Q>ª>TÌO1b>{À»1 <bD{À2y|{Dw
y|Å>wzy»{Ë}T1yÀy|#{~9Qy~ my|y~Å9»{ÐZ !ªb:bXw'%ur)"`+ " r3tV
r'
l ,ª - Âù / h f ú ]h õ,û 1 ö
v yÌÐ9w'Å>ª9y~Å¾¦Å>*w'Q}Tw}U9<Dy#w'Vwzy|yËQTÕy~y~Å9Qÿ~»Dw'ª}T¬ #wz»y|{ËD}U{Ñ#z£t¤b|#^y|y~QÅ9³.gÌÐ<Å9 <D#mÇ« {È9|9DU <1»#y~~ÆÆ
y|»§Ëw'Å9Å>}T#{1Qw9¨~{¥ª-ªby@Q>£tU9{~w'Q>9»*{ ª¦y|- Qby~ÇÅ9.ù ¯ »/ {òÀbªb 9wh Q*¬x#w'>y2ÆÇU#y|#wzD|y~{À9ÅUyDô9 xy~9yÌÐw'Q¿by~FÅo#!Ìy~oÅ9}YË!ªb¨#9>Å9Dw'Y|bVw'y¥{~y~Q.9'wª £
y|ÅUÅ9wug¤.}TD¤b{À#y,|-{¥ywzTy~Yg£t ~b ñ.
#wD~Å* Ë9w'||ª}>>ww}9ÂQ¬@Qy~<>D{Å.>»>w' <}T##2Qy~9Å>ªb{@É¥bQwu¨ y
< <D- Çõ0/ g}><yÌÐQJÅ>wu¤b£tDÌOD{À9ªbQ#ÆÂy|Qx#|~b|{D¬
y|ÖÅ9£gwm~#ªb{~DQ9>¨w9{~D> <T1»V{¥£Oy|wm~}9£<»Yw'y|Q}T 9b##>Ç»{.{« {g- »É¥{.Âù 1¨ b/ yx~| <DÐ»1{Àw'yxy~||y~oQÅ9}9w'D9» y~{~¦y~Å91»-{.|Â|0õ D/ 1y9¬ QÐD {ozz¤bVÌË#y{Æ
D¤<D <DuDÌÐ¨{~Qy~Åo9Å>{Ày~Q»y~#w' oy~D 9 *w' 9y|w{ÀVy~y|Q}>{<y~£Ãy~#>{ < QbÏ¬ ªU#¬9ÌÐQy@Qy~y|Åo2wD>1ªÐ9|wzwy|9#ª
9wb###T9#|>w' <y~Dx>D1{Ày~D{ ¬ wzy|¹Qb£*9m£UDwÀ~£tªbbQ~>wJw'U <1»{¥!y|~ <}9#<Ty|#QUb 9>{¦{w'bU9Q - >' y
bwu01|}T| D}Uy|Q#oyÀy|#Ñ< <DÙÕQ9Qªxw'|y~9Å9Ð9DªÊÿ~y|Å9~D{~É¥½bQ¨¨>ygw' <¨»y~{¥y|Qy~~D}9{!<y| 9QbQ|JD1y~Ì
y|bÅ>ªw'b³>{*Dy|wÑ~9y~Å>9ª½ <wÈ»{Ày~>|y|ÑQb1Ê}T19y¥Ì1Ò ##Ê<ª <#D>Â#¬ñwz§Ëy~Å9¤-{¦w'>{¦ w> 9w'{ÀQÆÆ
#w'~y~¤.QUwzy~#y~¤Å9< 9D{2w'|Q9w'9|!ªw*É¥#y~Å9¨<y 9{£t+ !ªD19»w#{|~{Æ
» 9w'}T{|1#|»Q{w'>> ¦wzy|wQ¤b9TDw'U<y~ <$DV{oy{O <#>9 9'yoVy|Qw'byÀ>y~w'D\wz<yOy.y~y~D!{ÀyDy~w'<y|b9Y~ÌÐÅ9y|Å9Q
É¥bQÿ}99y|w'y~Å9D< <DFy~Å9.#> 9Vy|Qb>w'J <|Dy|Qb¬
· x,y Þ {µ z}|³· Þ éæ ~ Rè¥ê@ëÀé ãäæÐéêë~´
w ãä6
eDQzÌ Ìñ <»{|1>{|{ÊÅ>zÌ 9Ä9DÌ }<É¥y~¤ñ£t9>1y~
^fÐú ÓgÑDw'½ \w'ÙTyÔ y~w'Å>U }T #ÅUwuÔ ¤¨ >9Ðw#>ÒY y~#UU{ÀDÀ£t b1~¬w'U1'£y|Å9
j
Õq$70=O7Dg?:q$$pÂ79q
Êõ Ñª¤ÓgDÑmó£twz 9y|19Ø>~9{ {@wÐ+ #> 9Vy|Qb>w'¨ <{Ày~|}9<y~*z¤b#F»w'}T#»{
ö ?þ ú - Çù / ù on úzû ° - Ç0õ / û h m
]
ÌÐ{Ày|Å>w'#y~b|^¬£tb{~>Q»1Qy¥0ÌÈwb{~{~9 ùg »{wÊ Ø9 Ò<D ñ9Vy|w
r#Y^DV
r r)V
?p0r r-#r "qV
qpr DV3W\^sZ)Xr)pV"#^ '?p 0r Z YVt r#I#taT r_V x§ËÅ9#So\$>r <Q# Æ
¤Y» <w'ÒY>woO>1Ýb> <#¨Qy~y~|>Yw¦g <»ªb{¥y|{À~y~}9»<y|QbY> 9{o#»w{ ~>w|w1y~D~
# w{
- Âù / ù on ú û ö ú 1Ò< Çù on ú û )® §bË¯Å>*}T'9y|~Å <ù 1oØUn 9ú D w'>T 'y~ D ÿ~»w'w'>» ^{ y~Å> <DQ{|w'1||Q9}TDx ¯Å9ÌOzÌDQªbù Å¨ y|{ <# T #U < 9#{Æ
y|wÑ#|Q<#Qw9.9y~bÅ9~1w'¨ Dy|wz~y|}9Qb<½y|Qb1U{¥£,yw'D¨wyD¬ÑÅÑY 9#>T1# > <D>1{ w £t D¬w'y~¼9|»{
b ¨Vy{O99>D1{~{|w'|$y~oÌÐ|Qy~ w{gw.£t9>1y~m,£ ¬
^ eÓg'yÀÑy|ÑJ{@{~ <Ù\9# @1¬O£t~2b¼{wy~Å9 <Ë» 9{Àwx1#y~w»*QD1 ÑÒ9wòÀ»w'>}TQ#bQ>ÆÇ}9Ì»*w{|~ôD¤¨>»~{~bVy}9Qy|DÅ9
§Ë« |QÅ>}<ÐÆÚ|»y~w'}T}Jw'#«J9>Q9~ bªo}9( 9Q Dw'& y|xw*w' <1>b»{| >1{~>y|Å9{|{Ày|{À{, {~D£\¨Qy~9Å9#@2Uwz1Ù\ }>#{~~# y¥|^¤zwz#»y~w'y}Tw'#Ç¬ Q{~D '¨&9( (D°¨( >®19 ¬
}T#!'>y|Å{~» <'#£ËÌÐy~Å9Å9Ë#Å wb{À<O#ÌÐ#9Å9.#|ÌÐ Qy~Å D{¨{À>w992|y| }>Å9w}9}>QQ{~y~#D|{D¤¬¦ xJQ##y.yÀy~>D{
bw'y@}>y~{~y| #Q|& ¤u¬ w'§Ëy~¬ÅY>${D'' y|£fg" gy|Å>#"wzwy91y|9bÅ9'~gy|Dy|w{~|#Tw#Q>9>Q9 <wzªxy~9D 9ª2Q$w'y~y|*Dw2{Àw2y~9y~#¤bw'wz#>y~{~1Qy~y~Å9¨»y${w'y|£to|~wbw'< Æ
>D{~Q¤'y~DygDw'³<>wzU9y|y~w'}>,{¥yÐw}9y|QQy~QÅ9y¥ # Dbb ¤{Ày,D"& m£t/9 Q>£û " Ìy|Q2b" b9Ë {~{À#Ðy~>D1{ÀbyÐUy|wzÅ9-y~{¦y~Å9 y~D& ~y||¬ w Q 99z¨ÌË9ª {Æ
| >DDw'wz¨*y|9w y|Å9|¨Dy~9{Å>¿xw'' £>D<b{À <y~UDwzTy~>w'#y~*D >°'{£ wy~{@b w#'&¤zÌËw'/ wu 2>û "wzy|£9 ~" b <¬ '({Ày~¹ |Ä& }9 ªb</ #y~99D,ª2|wÌÐ9Â,Å>~bÌ}<Å Æ
y|£twbÅ9}9Q{ÀQÑy¥Qy~ÑUÓOwzÑy~w){|U{{Ë#£tw~99b'9y|yù #Q9|y~w'D |{~#ù ¨$Å># y|zDú'ÌÊ ¦¬y|. <Vy~y|Å9*Å¯xy~y|Å>y|Å9|{gwQ~>Q}9 <9É¥ªD{Ày~#|y|Q}9¤b|9<>y~f{Dg¬
¹È91b#bVy|y||Qwb{¥yQÜy|U#{Àª9wzª-y|xy~Å9z¤#9Ë#y|ÌÕÅ9*}<9É¥>##y~~y|¤w QfÐ9ú \|#y|¤Y|wQ9>{Ë9»ª-w'}TÌÐ#Q»{
Ìy|Ðw'Å9y»{0D2wb}TòÀÅm^y|£tUbQ¨|#{~oD{~ Ä{À}9y~QDy|JÊôÄ¬ Dy~¹ {Ày~w'>y~Å>{~wzQ.y~y|1Ò9¼bw'Ì'& 9wb/ {! .û 9"w'}T yÑz" ¤9b~YDy~¤{ÀÅ9DD.¨³y^^y~QÅ9Óg¼bÑ9y|ªÅ9 Å
y| 9|w{Ày~Q>|QQ}>9<ª¯y~1J|\9>ÌÐ{DÅ9¬Ñ»§@ÅÑ¯»{{~#U{Ày| !Å9Q{D^,y~9w'y~9y|9Å>ª>wzUy$£ty~xÅ9wªw'¤|DªÑ>»wzw'Æ
}T#& % wzyËy|Q { +
- % / ú ö l - % / ù on úu
û !- Âù on ú / oú n ú © '(*) j
ÌÐwQÅ>¨TbÅÈ{|{À{ÀÅ9}9zgÌ9{|y~#Å>¤Yw'y>>{>{¥ <y#wzy|Df { úuù\on y|úu|wzQ9>Qy@9ª-b9Q{x <bD*Uy~DÅ9>¨ <{À#ÿx{ÀD#
y~Å9xy||wQ>Q9ª{~1y¬
9#Å>#f ½g w' y|Å9Ñ ÓgòÀT^#î
»{oy~}Tw'»ô9 ¯w}UbD^Qy|9Å9ªÑ»{x#|y~|zÑx#Ò9{$w', 9+ >><'yÆ
~

Æ
À
{
Y

z> #+mQ> 9{~QQ9Uª*1Ë»w'y~}TÅ>#Ð ( <¬ <DUU{À <y~#Q >fÐú w'¿y|Å9{{#|#~|b~|b{wzy|»w'Ë}T#{,|Q9>ªxªy|Å9Å9
{Ày|>w'y~ª#{*Ë1w'||¿bDD{~{ËUDb~>| <9{gª¦b.y|" y~Å9"ñbw'}>U{À /D~" ¤zw'y~"*¬ - " "*J}><y.9
¹{Ày~wz{~y|DQ>y|ª$Qby| Å>wz®9yËFÌOy|Å9{9Q|z¤Y9| 9z$¤D#ÒYTD#¨|y»{ÐD9¨y|w'yy|~|D¤Y{~9wQ'y|+{xb <9#Ð9b#<Ì Æ
b >}<w'É¥D 1y~b¤9$!£t£t9b>1y~y~w'9{À9ªª½9Qy~ØUÅ>D^w'¨Ñy~Óg!^< y|Uw'DÀ£tbÅ9~Vy|D{21y~y~9Å>|!{Ày|w<w Æ
>{~Y¨Dy~¨Å9y#y~»w}U|DQ}TQ>'ygª$>ywuw¤Y{~¿\ªb¬ w'y~9|}9#Íw'U mw.~w'U 9Y1Æ
8 7Ðpr:? r=q
1j 05,? 243@:? 65pr07 Ëkma7 @=lU8
}>w~Vwbªby|{~Å99ô!D !>>ª~y~ÅbÅ>}9w'y|QyD|wy|QÅ99½99ª |y|Å9ÌÐ}9-Vy|#ÑÅ )ÓOfÐ»Ñ{ú ÌÐDVw'y|ÁwÅ^|wy|Å9Å9QQ#y~¤Y»wzy|<9y| <!~Dby~@Å9VQ×yy{ÀDDòÀVw'»£Ëw' }Tw'>#}TQ Æ
y|>#Å9Q'>y2QÌÐ mQy~{~Å^Ô<y~ Å9y~w'ÙT¦{Ày|D}Yw'Ày¥U 9w'1Å>y2w 9wªÂ¬}< 9É¥&ª*()y|( y|Å9Q ¤b2*}U9£tw|9{~z>¤Y1y~ 9D<{ <wDf Âg¬ ¬ ¹b-~¹ .U1 <Ù\>#D~< FyÆ
y|}TwÈQ'by|>Å-{ .}TÔ×1}>£tQwbb<{À~£tD ½|{oy~ÊÅ>mVy {$»w'}T<#y|£tËDQ~wz|y.D ½y|Q¬ }T¹ # 1# £2 ¨wªy~}U¤bwD<{À½yDy$by~y~Å9Å>y~-Å9xD^$}>{~Óg»w'#Ñ}T|¤z# wz»{Æ
y|<Å9£t*D|»{w'}Ty|#Å9»{Ð}Uw#}U#£t$D| wz# y*y~ory|)QV ¬ 2¹ -}Uw£r{~wbD ¯y<£t9ËÑy|Å9*È9Å9|z#Ìð¤YQbQy.>{x<« £t~#}<{Æ
y||9Å9ªx}«Dy| <#Å9QÒ<ÙT2wD~D9>ÔÈQ1bÐw'y|}T>Å91 oËy¥Ìy~Å9# DÔ #y~|Å9~ÔËbby¥Ìw$wz.y~#1OÒY¨y~{¥{ #yU( £t{À¬@9>¯1y~>9>1zbÌ{~ÌÐT#Å9>#wz{~y| 9Q>9#{Àª Æ
Å> 9 9#!{¥ywzy|D{ {~#xØUª9|¬
G BËsÃa9SbhB
9 ;N :F=N <?>dfhs»KFstdfJEAS @*EfJhdC
§ËÅ>ËÔ <#Ø>9D{w#> 9Vy|Qb>w'¨ <{Ày~|}9<y~oz¤#w}UD{ +
- Âõ0/ û
h ö ú ?þ ú 1Ò< D Çù on ú û

§ËÅ>ªbwÑQU£tby~Db{~y|w>{ Q»1Q y¥w'|ÌO!xw'wªb{|w{À>Q³Å>2ww*>Ø9 YÒ<Æ 1D mwz£ÃQy|>DV Äy|wÌÐ\Å9{Ày|Qw'Ey~ )ù g « { ¬
w~ËÔÑ>wÅ>|wbw{wO1É¥y~D|b{y y|* ª}U}>Qww'|>9D o|£t~wbQ¾ Dw' 9y~w'y|ow>¬,£rwOy||>F1»Äw'ÌÐ'Å>y|Å9Å
w Qw'zÙTÌD{Ày¥V¦ym#y~y½w'1Ç¬Q| #&)9()o( ¤b # 1¨¬ yy~Å9½« »w'}T#QÆÇ}9»w{D«,9|}9# {~#
§Ë#Å>>^{~» < <#QÙTw'D~}9D>1Ñ}T|1xy¥Ì{~9#}<Dy|Qxy~Å>mÑy|Å9}<$É¥y|QÔ ¤bDD{ w{~f g y|Å>ww'> fÐ-ú y|Å9»{
»Ì^w'#}TÓg#ªÑQÅ¨ÆÚ}9y {Ðwb <{#VwbÙ\9{À#~b|#}9{À¨>#y|Q#¬ y|y~Å> Å9w'mz Ì*f ÿ~g Å9Ôñ2 DJ <9YÌÐD{xQ9 fÐy*ú {~{~<1Ù\y#y~xÅ9£t|£tD)w'y~9y|Å9|
{>~OQy~b>
D{~Á# <|» D{9wx9#{À¤bÄ#£t9Qm}Uy~{~{ÀÅ9QDy~~»>{-¤bw'Dy~y~ F¬w'>{~¹ QV£oy|Qy|ÌÐbÅ9JÅ9#Ë»|Èy~ÅÅ>#w{-Á>£tDw'>w'~>y~y~ <»91#|9¯ »w'fy~Å>g y|w'|yy|wÅ9<»{Æ
y|»wzQ¤by|<D <{*DÌObD9$Qªb.>Å¨{ÀyDy¬ <ªb < Q#¤bz.ÌQ9y~#ª¯Å>¤b#{2w{|£t{ÀD{À9w'>y~9#<|$y|$Qy|bwÅ9>^{D|<D{~Ø>w'>,9Å½QÌy~DwQ|!»£t ^D»w'w'|y~£Ãª9y~o|#¦ 9#¤Yª¨wu'wz ÆÆ
D{Ày~¤DU}Tw'yÐ>y~{~Å91*£t>#>ÒYT¦#QU{Àx9|'z£,¤YwQ>ÌOªxby~|Å9{~2OÉ¥wb~yªbQ 9Uw'{À>y~| <Q»}>{À<y~|y~Q}99Jy~¬ >{D
È#Ò9w' <#9UÌÐ{¥y|Å9|»w'ÅÊy~.ÅUy|wÅ9{$»{£t 99VÙ\#|»w'#}T>##»o{ÌÐ Qû y~&9ÅÈû w'û 9°^y~wÅ9>D ½ <y¥Ì» 9¯wbby~}<» Æ
ÌÐ{~#Å>|¤zQwzy|Qy~bÅ9>{HbG }>û {~#¬Ê|¤u§Ëw'y~Å9>ª{*#w>~#A wz"Iy~GJ¤"ð-9y||Å9Y#D»w'{|}T{o#»»{{.ww'{oÌ£twu<Q{xzÌw'{QÆ +
|y2Å>{wzQyÐy|Å9. <Ô»{#{¥uy|~y|Å9}9#<|y|gQb»{-w,É¥ÿ~D¨ªywz>y~|{w<QyÐ
Dy|w'Å9y~xxÅ9£r >wb <#y~!bD{À¬y|wzy|Dy~{D ¬
9#. {Ày|Twzy|D~{.y|ww¨~y@ <9»{¥y|y.Q>ª1y~¤D.ÌÐ 99Qy~~Å.9y~ªÅ9y||wQ9Ô-9»ªU{¬ y~Å> w'DyJ>y~Å91bOÅ9y|»Å9 Y Æ
y|Å>#Å9 9#> 9{Ày~#1¯¨w'{¥{ÀyF9y|£tw'9 y~U{À{y~>$12>{¥¬}Uyx§Ë}Ty~Å9Å$»{J1¨by~{À<#yªb <£t|D9w'Uy~»{y~ !{~QªbzU9¤{DVØT 9#oy~w'¨9y|1QbyO21Ò<99b<~y~»,1$Q>y~#<Q ÆÆ
ÈÅ> 9#z!TÌ #ª>f !¤úbD!w'w'Ä½y~Å>1bÐÒ9}<wÉ¥y|wQ¨>½yQ <»{¥|y|m~<}9Dwb<#y|y|1QQ>bb|³Ñw'y~®^'£y|y|Å>Å9wzw'oym|ªÅ9 <»> 9Dw' <D 9^>{À{À{Ày~y~y||wzQwzy|}>y|D<D{D{Æ ¬
y|b¼91y³È£t>Db{³w'9y~91b|>£t¬ñ{À» <§ËDy~Å9Å>! w'}9 w'|>ªQw'9|Tz#£t¨¤yDwz{~y~+»>{ÀÅ>~ D÷ Í û Ç ù ÿb<nû <G ú #1û ÌÐ¥÷Q&<»y~{Åìû&Yÿ¨bbû 9UG w' y|Qb>{y~ÅUw' fg >{À9ªy|Å9{w 9 <Qy~Uw'\£t|#D 9¬
y|f¥Q÷ bg >¨û {2y~ Å9ÿ¨ÌÐû Q£t1@D,w'>y~#9¤|D ÷ $°<>#û °#{À9yËÿb2û }T^¬½ªw¤y|#'|-y~wQwo>y|Q»Å>9w'wz|ª-ªy{À2#y~9Å>yD¬#Dª¨{~ wz#y~{~>¤##Q2£ÌOTy|9|DwQ>ªb> <Å¨{ÀDyDQÆ ¬ ¹ y|Å9·{g¶9{À·'~ºy~êFµ<êJÌ¶ <y#´b|Qµ9¤bè~ºw·µ9w'è¥ªæ Þ |Qy~Å9¼y|*1Ï¦1#ÿ~ob<Æ
È {À.>#ØUo> !y|Å9y|{Å>wz»w'y2|y~ªÅ9$ÌO~DQ{Àªb>ÅbVy|y2Q9£tªm1#|{~by|Å9|w'Qy~>.#»{|~1by{~*wy~}U¯DQ ()Q>( ªb+ { y| QÔ # Dw'f ú2}U£tb* <wmD~¤ mÔ¬U{~QQªbw|~Vy|Å9¬,!{Ë¨£t{¥yËË'y|£@Å9y~oÅ9xÑÌÓOÑ|¿ »{Ëw'>< Æ
> £> <#ofÐ°!ú bÌÐy|Å9Qy~»Å {£tw'Dwzy|9"I|GJ2"º»{wª>¤ #-¤Ywo#¦»w'¤|Dª|2{|wU1¨¬ {ÀQ¹ y~ ¤1bÌO¨Dy~QªbwÅ¨{ÀyDyD y|¤bm¤w $Å!¦>w1|bw9#<y~y~DD9¬ªo§Ë{~<Å>Ï¦{1#w#¨!yOy~{ÀÅ9y|Dw'Ñy~»{¥}Ty|$D>{g{~#D Ñ|~}¨{ÀT¤zw'>| 9QbQ9>ª {
{~w>> *1ÌV,yØ>wb>#1 .>y~|Å>w'w'y~#yy|xÅ9#gw'|9Dy~{~99|QDy~{@9y~ªÅ>#O||w'J|ªwzy|>w¨{@ <|»{Ày~9|ªbQ}9Å99Q*y~® ( >+ {D y¥bY<Ty~2w Q
Dªb#|{Vy|Å9¿{1y~.'É¥T9#ªb~w'£ty~o|¾ªb|y~wbÅ9 <#wÿ2y|>bw'2UQ9y~D\| 9w'wzy~y|¤ $ü ¬ {|¹#wQy|9Å9ª
Dww{~{~ÑQ}>'Q£ob¬ wÁÑÓOÑ {Àb1y~D{w £t9*ÆÚ{Ày~D0»{mD¤#
ÌÐÅ9»Å»{Ë9y~w 1¬
t
£
y|§Ë 9#Å>¨{Ày~y~{|»Qw'}>#>Ò<<y~wy~w <>9D{DQ'¬ Ù¦ÌË¹ w{{~D1Yby| 9>Q#b{¥y|Q~9U®<ª*,y~y|ÌÅ9 ½m,y|É¥ªbÈQ¤b¨ <myD#¤<ÒY{#T¬>#y~{À|Å>y~wzDy|¨w'y||w'w¯ªU>|1w'ÆÆ 91Qyy~% úþ }Ux£y|w¯Å9.ªÔ ¤D b{~DU¨wz9y~D> 1*)*£w'»Uw' ½}T# <»{DVÙ\¬g#|#{~Q¨>y|ªw'y~y~Å99.ª <f#£Ãú Æ
{~9Qy|{Ë£tbw$y~z Ñ w'> w <<19DbyÐ»w'}T#Q9ªyw{~¿T¬ ÌÐQy~Å|D{~UyËy~ 9Ìx}<yw'
j ö ú þ Âù n ú û ' ) j '( (
9 ;N :FN : $sÃh@ha9f @*EfJhdG BËsÃa9S¨h@B
" Âù n ú û ' ) j
2 9D{g{~Q#ªb9>D < xQy~y|U}Tw'O9w}9<Qg <y~#2»{D>{À}TO'Qy~bÅ9y|ªÅ9w'>ªÔÈ9w'bU9 Q<ÑDw'ÓgbÑ£tDwz y|9w|~D{
wb^{Ëw'|}>¿{~z#¤Y|¤zwwzy|Q{¥by|>~>{#¬1y~ 9|z2ÌOwD¤#9¨ªoy~Å9y~Å9{À*w}U<D <D{D¬,{ÐÓ,{Ày~ÒYy~QD@>w <{|{À99ª.y|*Å9w ÌÐ§ËÅ>Å>#o|{À 1 b> »{y~Dy~~Å9 O1'Ò<£ U ywzDy~w'!o}T'o£ # w9#>9 <»Dwzy~ 9 {À>y~|{~QQ}>9<ªmy~}UD0Q-@1£ ¬
< <ÔOD,bÌ{~Å9zÌÐ1*UQ{Àx» <ØU#ª$9y~|Å> ¬ 9 9#³Ô-»{Jw'>¿ 9g w2ÔQDÔ- }><y@ ÌÐQ*Ô y~Å >~b>w'ª¨wzy~¦y~¦1b9<y~xy|Å9ËÉ¥ÿÐ9~b}>w'}>QVy|Q{
( Ì % n ú ö - Âù n ú ö % n ú / û h wwQÅ>zÌ 9{O 9#>Êw{ÀÑyOw<~£t¿bz|¤!wzy|YQb 9m#g¦b y~Å>y~2Å9»mw'}TÅ9# >\ <Å9#»{¥ y|{À|y|w'y~y~D${D¬ }Uú x§ËÅ9DÅ9» {
y|Êy~9Å>|D 9Å9»1 9ym <#£t-<y|{¥9y~wz¯y~{w}Uw'UD {D¬ >{À Fbwy~ÈQb9Å9ª*zÌOÌÐDQ¤y~ÅDDy~Å>y~ÅU£twzDymw'y~y|9Å9|DD{~{D §ËÅ>#|#¨Dy~Å>wb.Å 1Ò<% T <D#>ywz'y|y~Qb{g>wx{¤zw'£ 9Ðy|wÅ>~xwzyyw'¤z¿bw'#|!w}91QÒ< 9ù »1#Qy~w'¬Ðyw'§Ë¿bÅ9 ¬
Åy|>Q 9{ 9#'½£xwz<Ò< <#o»{*9î
9!#ÿ~9|ªb#Y*½{~Å>w'<| <#y~»Å9{ m¢ ##Yw ¤#gÒ<QV#y¥!y~w¯9|#ymT#w'~ÇÆ ¬ ØUy|Å9|x{ÀyË£ty~#|zóÌÐQ'9£ ª Ö>wDbw'y|Vy|}UQ*{+{~Qw~¦#w#9»wzy~ ¦Q£ÌÅ>wu¤
% n ú ö ?þ ú - Âù n ú ö % n ú / ù ö % û û h b # ¨{ 9 9zy~~ÅY9>ª{y~y~Å9w'D$9w9~ª>¬ {~>{|1#9y~}9QËy|*Q<Dw'9b<y~wx9~b}<Æ
§ËÅ>.1U <Vy|Qb>w'J 9{Ày~|Q}><y~'£y~Å9*»w'}T#»{£t Ô{Ð»{ 2{À9ªmw9'y|Å9#y¥ÌOm>w{|{À{z¤b#Ëy~Å>$9#y¥ÌOb~¿\9Ì$#Æ
þ
><y~xy|Å9x£tQzÌÐ9ª ò¥£tb~ÌËw' 9ô$w'> òÀ}>wb¿YÌw| 9ô${À>{
- Âù þú / 1 ö l 1Ò< ÷ l l on ú û ? ú
% n ú ö ?n úú - Âù n ú ö % n ú / ù ö % |û û h & j
% n ú ö ?þ - Âù n ú ö % n ú / ù ö % |û û h l
Âù û û ÿ
§ËÅ># % n ú ö % n ú Âù n ú ¬,§ËÅ9 w'|Ë#Æ
#$ C!E)%@$9%@C!#
%@ WFA A#D #I@& D "!s#$
y|w#~|H>" wzy|¦"*}T¨1y~y¥Å9Ì#»#w'}T#¦»{ww>Q ÌËwu& <{gw'wUV y|#|ÌÐ>Å9wzQy|2}Ty|Å91y¥mÌb#}>D-{ÀDo~¤zww'>y~ ¦>°U{ ¬
§Ëw¨Å>>-w'9Ð9¨|9yg<|1£F}U{~y~w'{$}9{ÀQÌÐ2Qy¥QQy|Å9w'w>{o ÄÅ}T{~1Uy¥<ÌD <># 9D¬, {DO§Ëy|bÅYÅ9Ä>D{~{Dwu¦¤by|y¥#Å9Ìw'^ªb9<y~ <Å9DÑw{U{|ÌÐTw'bQy~{ÀÅ Æ
{~}9Q*»w'}T#Q9ªD~|Ëwzy~»{® ( +¦¬
1Ò9w'9*{Àb>#>#Y¿<{ËQ¿b2y|Å9»{+
BDC
FE
GIH
G JIK
L
M
NOQP
M
R
R
N OQP
R
R
U T L VWL XY
S
ZS VWL XY
N O
M
[^]
[^ _
[ \
E
\
\
E
"!
"(
#
% $'& $
!
$
)*
+
!!s94,
-,
/.
10
2+
B3.
C965s%8791:;9':=< )> FA FA#?,)) "!s#$q.@0 D #IA FA%+2)5 'AE!#$D#$9!#$9$#d!sA#IIFA/.EBD#
F0#I#$9GFA#<u)BD#$%$K
[ \
bc #
!#$9WF %
E
"
a` ]
# [ _
A#I%+FA%=]+G945 s.IdeegfJ %+4,I,#$%oFPFA:_F$9h+4,
)A#d#k $#$9WF'FA92FA#I_FAlA#d%@94,sK
[^]
_FA#i,'j
W
W
W
W
W
W
W
W
C0
M1
M0
Obs
Time
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
20
40
60
"#
& F#<B9:!;ABDF sAB#$"FA#,%@:!#!;CW$)FA9%9!)FA# 0 #IA#<FA#,AHs F". %@#$9%@!#IFA#IIFA% 0qK65-,WF
A#!sIFA#!-!%oF@A4B +sFA9%' A #IFA#dW_FAC9 & FA#,ABDFB3.;FA# "!s#$%$KF FA#dFA-_A# FA#dB%@#IA_FA9%=(FA# !sA#IIFA9-&
u)%oFd ' A #$ #$9WF.:9:! 0 #IFA#I<Fd%,9#IH"FFAG 0') J
K[9 # %3+)A# FA#)A# &3FA# BB%<$)@A#$%@D9! FA FA# AB:)BF".-&
BD#$49 , 9GFA)F W)FA9.0)9:!;FA#,$A$# !#$9FA#$%'FA#<F@ +#,W_FA9K
><y~ -U{À9ªy~Å9!òÀ£t|Ìw| >ô.|D1>|{~Qb,+
ö D°
# ú % ö ) j % n ú
#
ú
# ú % ö Ì # ú Âù # ú ö % # ú / ù ö % # ú % u®)
ÌÐ¨Å>y~D#~| D 9 w'y~ö m¤z¦wQQ9I£ G {oöU{À ½wQ> y~(Å9'y|~Å9#19|ÌÐ{~»Q{ÀbbJ@¬¯w'UY Q»w'|wQ~b
y|Å9!òÀ}Uw¿YÌw| >ô.|D1>|{~Qbm»{ +
ö v
% ö j # ú % # ú v © % n ú ö Ì Çù n úö % n )ú / ù ö % % z y|§ËQbÅ>D{~92T| >D#wz9y~|{Ë{~>>{~D{O -w'|y~wb1{gb#Ï9<#Qy~D*¨ÌyËwb{g 9y|Å9xy~}UDwQ11£b>9{À|y|w'>¨wy ªbwz¬ Æ
|Äê@´ à ë µ9´
y|yÈÅ9w{~o1¿\y|ÅUJñwu <¤#1xÒ9y~wU{¥y|{¥>Dy|Q !|w'{ by~9w9>ª- ó>Q#y|{*Ì {~19¨Twð{¥#y2||Q£tDb9w'2>Ty| <#Q<b~£t1Ñ>|ÑDw'¨{~>#y #¤b$#»w'w'}TÈ#¤u{~QwY9~<Qª ÆÆ
bw>Qªb{D|wVy|{~Å9D{Fw{O>£t y~Å9ÑOÓO9ÑwÑy|{DDTw'Vy¥2Ô'{Ð£Yy~w'Å>>g w {|{À<Ô#{#w'¬ y~D 2y||wQ99ª
£t9Ö2DVÀ>Ù\y¥m#Ê|1#1bÿm9yw'1 ½Ç¨¬{¥wy&){~£t()^9( >#1y~>g{~w > 9{D <#¬ *»{| 1y|z||QÌwQ#9¤>9DwzDªÑy|zQwb¤b¤z{w#9 9 Q{|»y~1w >w'{|{~9ÑDD . ^ {oÑ ÌÐQw'y~£ÃÅ Æ
>9>ªÐ <y#w' }9f ,g }>>wb»{Ð{À b>£tDQwz¤zy|w'9#|¨Dy{D¬@y|Y¦wm»w'|QÔÊby~w w' 9ÑDó ÌÐ <Q»y~{~Å #~fg QU>wz{ÀÆÆ
y|ÌÐQ¤bQy~#Å mfÐy|ú|wUQ>{ÀD9 ª ÌÐy|Vwy|Å}9!fÐú }>w»{{~DD Ê¨9£tD¤zw'w'y~9#|¨Dy{D¬ñy|mÔ>wm}T'ÔÊy~Å³y~w'y|Å99DD{~
D#w>{~D{~{*» <Ì#x¦y|9||wDQ9{~#9ÿoª|y|DÅ9{~ 9Q y|{*Ñ}T #zÌÐÌ*Q¬y~Å ¹ yoy|Å9»{ow>w{~Q!¤bU¨1ÒY{~{~y~D}9>Q¦{Ày~
ª - QbÂ,ªõ,-û 1Çù 1 ¬û 1 -z'Ì£o#¤by|#Å9 {Ày~y|Å>w'{mU 9>w'w' ¤ 1ÑÒYy|
#>{~1Q¨b³{¥yU£t9DÀ>£t1by~~ {
U -L U T
R R
#
U L-U T
R R
]
[^]
L
_
[ _
R
]
_
U -L U T
R R
#
U L-U T
R R
\
[^]
U
U
R
[ _
_
]
Uw'<~ <y~»D1Q9Q»>w'ªÊ|Qy|Å9T ¨b#~ÿ~~ <È9x}Uw${ÀD 9~|¤zwbwz{¥y|y|QbÁy~#{~UD <¨#9>##U1y~$£t<1>wzy~{OÅ>#
y|£tbÅ>w'³1bwUÅw'|ù {~ ËJy|¬ ÅÜ{y~Å9{À!|D{~9Qy|{w~9'ymw99|9|»wzy~
8 6Â?
]j GrYp @=³k-al gl 52J79!
§Ë 9VÅ>Ù\2#|}9#>>#o m}T|1}Ty¥Ì'y#D1^Ò9w'9y~9 '
#£J9y|ªmÅ9y~{ËÅ9{~$D1y~ <QmUw'Å>|QªbÅ9#Qbª{ÀÅÿy£t{g9y|>Å91 Æ
y|Qb f g w> my~Å9*9|Tb{~D 1¨{¥y fÐú £tËy|Å9.ÑÓOÑ½¬
y|È|Å9YÈÐ|Å>¬Owu}T¤'ÈyDy2« {wÊDwQ<|DÅ!wz}Ty~{À'y~yD»y~{zÅ9¤Y9.99|QªÊ£t}T|'¼yw oz <ª¤b»|{À»Dy~ 0{Ë|QÌ}9Ñ9w'y~|DY F m¬ wb1£ ¹ |9bQ{|y~#{»w'y|Å9 Æ
UQy2w»{|{Ð{y| 9Q|>D1Å>y~Q9ª¦>{Dw¦w'ÌUw $QJwb9|9uÒ<y Q {~Qy¥#..{ÀØ>Dª>9{À|b &y~#1¬Ë»{,¯Vy,ÌÐwÅ9{|#{À9y~Å9D
y|¿YÅ>9wzzymÌÐy~Å9{¥Dy~w'!~y~»{9ª9½Q<#9w'by~{~JQu³y|Å9y|Å9{~ÑD¨{~Y9{À#y~UD1¬×'£Uvz¤¤b##w#Äÿ|>{@<'Æ£
y|y|Å9Å9Ð|Q<#}Tw''y~yDbw'->' $£JÌy|Å9w2Q9|{~#}TU'{Àyb¬,¯~wx <1b9ªb{DUzw'Ì|D ÌÐy|»Å9{~Å$~Dy|2x9~< < <D»{ y +
y|w$Å9" ^Ñ Ñ1ÓgÓOw'^Ñ> wÑy||}9w<Qy>Ô0Dy| |y~wÌÐQw'9Qy~9Å ÄD ¯y~ÌÐÅ>ÌÐVmy|Å³Vy|ÅÈ»y~ Å9y~ÑÅ91¨>{¥y.#Ì»£t >>11b¨{Ày|{¥yQyxb£t£t99>>#"11y~y~( 1
»»[{,{2f 9( {~'1{~y*¬Ë#¨§Ë{Ày~Å>»Å>zw'*ÌÐoUJD¬2»À <£t§Ë#b¨Å9~y~»#w'ÑwU<ÓO1y~*.Ñ>y~Ñ{~Å9Q>{2ª¦TÌO#w-D~~£t*|y||ÔÊww'Q>>y~#Dw'Ë !9ÌÐÌÐDV y|Qy~Å Å^ÌÐf Q£ty~9g Å Qw',fÐ> ú
{À 9y~QDD>b{DyJ¬,w'Ô9>9 Ñ9y~yÅ9w'}9¦1ÆÚ}>wÔ{~DÌË $w>{wy~|ww'9#Dy~ ^D~>
D{~w'Q9y~ª>1{bzÌÉ¥#9|ªbÐw'>y~{Àª Qwz Æ
wQ\y|Å9|#*< <#»{#¬
§Ë{~DÅ>¨9D~>ª1Å¨$yg£tUw'.9wD>®u'Ò>£\®mØ>ÌOªb9b|~» F& J{ÀwÅ>>z ÑÌy|{Å9wxy¥1Yb9~»|#Dw'{~UUb}>>{~ <#|9¤zª-wzy| 9Qb{À Æ
y|~<}9 <<Dy|Q{Db¬-z{Ë¤b##ÒYTQ<DD1wzy~y~ F Uf { ( wÌ}UwbD{{wO}99|Dy| <»y|<D# -w'y~}¨2-y~Å9w'*U|y|Å9}T|#'y
¨9'»y|¿Y#Q*by~Å>ww'{$yÌw'wby{ y~" .b,°>ÌÐ f Å9( Q ÌË" w{( w}9TQ#.~£ty~m| <#Dy~ D~y|Å9-9Ì*y~ÅU{ÀwzyDy ¬
bT9b{|o{~Q}9>) b" <ygËÌ£Uwby|{Å9w'»{À{~QxÒ$wT}9b{|Ë{~y~Q}9.Ð9|YD 9Dwz1y|y,Qby~>Å9{,Ðwzy|y,~>y|QQ<Dxwzy~ÌËw {
(
C0
M1
M0
move north, no wall move north, finds wall
W#P& #)F +sA#$%#)A9#!dBQ.FA# FAsA#$# "!#$%$K # CZj
)FA9&:#$ %@ "%Q+:)A#@0 FA9FA#_H ,)Au! $@A#I%@D9:!s%
FAFA#A#A"I+%'W)FA9G& FA#<ABD)F.9:! #)
EBBEC9 FA#
% 3+)A#$% $@A#$%@D9:!s%FAFA#69#
HsF W)FA9aK 7)FA#+216+-+G%$.
FA#%@ I#<&a#)
;BBE!s#$%@IABD#$%6FA# ABBCF. &aF@9%@FA94,
FAFA#9#IH"F'W_FA96. 0 #<&() FA#d4657 F %A#$C)FA#! FAFA#
9I#d&P%@#$#IC69 , BDFAECW$)FA9%FAI ,#IFA#
K
T}b¨>9DD{2Qy~w'Q><wb{~##w'#y~9|bÑw'{Ày~y*»D{Q'b1£¬ y~UÅ91z#Ì¨9#y||¤b|w'#}Uy~w'D }9" QbQ( y¥ÑÑÌËy|wÅ9{bw>{~{|o'{xyz<w'¤#}9Dwzxy|ËQby~y~Å9>*{ <>ÌÐx~Å>ÌD¤¨#QÅ Æ
ØUDw~ª{O-9£t|bQU1>bY}>UÌO{~{À#»x{¥|y|¤u{À#Å>w'ÿ~zy$ÌÌÐ>y~{ QÅ9y~÷xÅ >y~wÅ>|-wb}>1
{Ày~DD~|¤z<{gw'ÿQy~ w'||>ª9{$Å¨D myËwzy#}Yy~9y~Å9x °>O¬ w'<>¹ Y Æ
y|U÷ #
w'|>w'{D¬12y|#{Ð1{xÒ<£t
TD$1y~'9Dy~1ÿ JÅ>9# Qo}U#£Ãby y~}>1Å ¬ {~#" | ¤uY( w'Dy~^w'>Ø>> ªb{*f9£t|( ¯QQz#Ìów'w|<9{~y~QD -{À¬ wî
D.>{~>§ËQ}9wzÅ9y~ Æ
£tÌÐQwzy~y|Å9~y|Å9{.ÌÐ9Å>|##¤YÑy|>Å9{Ë1<9#|w'~y~D¨Jy29}>}U<{ÀDy2~ <¤zwz¦y|>Qb'>y{Dww'~|!1bw'>Y{À¨»y~{ÀÅ9y~#9¨ª y
ÌÐ}>Å>wb#{#x«b9y~~Å>b#}9x#w'|, Q">#( > <{~Y»{¥y|{#¨9yD¬ yg Qzw'Ì|#¤w'D9D9D <|9>,~y|»Ðwzy|y~ËÅ9£tDwz« »y|w'9}T|#DQ{Æ
£tÖ2bÄÐy~y|Å>Å9.!QU'1y|Å9U#¦{À»{¥ÅUy|w'#>¨ Fy ÷ " !Dw'
|>{9£tÿwz#y~wb>{À~ { {~ÌÐ#.Å9Ø>ªÅ³9|1.ym Q1y ¬
>>~~D¤¨ <1y¦U{Ow^<Q#¿bw'#y~½mQ<»D{Ëwzy~>1b >'{À»£2{Ày~y~#Å9ÿ¬|§Ë}TÅ>'y{Ë#<¤#DwzÊy|QbÌÐmÅ9D»{ËÊ9y|Å9~ Æ
w>w Qo1by|Å9{~D{ÀbyO9y|1ÌÐbÅ>>#{À|»{À2y~#y|¨Å9yxÌÐ~bQy~}UÅyÐy|Å9ÌOb#99 -~|#Å>¨wuy¤b2b}>}T{À#DD~-¤zw'Qy~£@y|Å9> {
>~D¤Ü{O<#w'y~ÌOD~*1b~|D1yD¬
1j 0Ä]o6@? 7!#"7 5D79q? 5
ÈÔ>~Ðÿ|9D#{Ày~¨Dy~ *y|Å9{~¿¤Y» $w'}92Q9Qy¥Do{Ày~£UUy|Å9{ Ô<9DÌÄ J#b 9{Àw'y,y|w£t9{~>1y1y~Qÿ|¦~#y|DÅ9
ØUØU}YÈQQ{mÑ1b}T>#{~w{À9Qy|ªb9{2Q >'ª½£Ë1wmy~yoÅ9w'Ç ¬w <"D&{~D(#\()9£t(#by-1Q¬mz9Ì§ËDDÌÅ9 !m{Àªb}Y >~Ñbwz9y|¨w!9D#Ô<{Ày~>{~»\{¥{#ízy¬¾{*w'U'Óg{À£ÐÌw#Å
y|U»{Å9w'*Qm|{Dy~(Å9w'(%xU$ & oÅ9® D(w>( < 9DQ{, 9ÌÐ'DQ{y~Å1-9w2w$y|w¨w9QÅm>{~{¥Ø>Dy|QQ1*by~ wb#J 1 ¬b1|§Ë9 9Å9w'Q9Ëmªoywwy~>{~¿.{ÀÌÌÐ{#Å9 y|1*y| Å9. #wOÐ}UDQy
y~Å9Ëyw' §0U{À9ª.wx{À#y'£ & °2£tDw'y~9|D{{~>Å w*{'+%;&((+7)/*(+%;,-. * /10-2+345&(6Ç &()*+7,8- . * /10-93%(,8/2* :+7- . :6<;U\w>=
> -?/:-A@ {~# ÑwQ9ì#yw'Ç¬Q &)()(( £tËy~Å>x£t9QQ»{¥y ¬
y|£tÈ~wz-}9y|<9y~y|~Qw'b{¯91FDz w'¤b>#w ¯ ÑwÑ}UÓgDi
Ñ{x^}Yw>{2 ^w>y|Q{~#|
#¤uw'Ô9y~{ªÑ>>y|{~Å9{ Q>m ªmÌÐ£t>}TÅ>Q'y~É¥Å Å^bQw'y~¨|Å9yo 9y|fÅ9{Àg Æ
¤£tzwbw>~ »Ìw'f >#ú2#ªËÅ¨'}<y£É¥ 9 D( y~#wu¤{bbQ¬¬Ô9 Tbb
#{~DD~w ÆÇÅÑÔ<Dy|wÅ9$ÐvxÌOTÌOwDQ>.ªb{~Å¨T{~y|»#w'{~'£t£F9|~wDËÅ !ÌÐDQ<y~wuÅ! <¤b1Dw Æ
ØU#ÆÇQ*b<ÌÐygÅ9D»¤uwÅQUÌOwz*y~|D{~#}Y|¤y~ w'£t9Ë9y|ª*D{Ày|y~Å99ª>¬ < <#»{O¦w'T}9<yOb9
y|§ 9Å9w'1¦}>y~Qb¯}>{À D#~| ¤z~y|bw'y~${¯{ÀDÅ>w'{~zD»Ì1¨99{*»Dwzy~>y|Å>D1m 9w|{£Dy| <Å9w»Ðy|ÅÈUQbDy~ |#{¥##yo¨||Dy|wwª{~{xË¬mª'£\§Ë¤#Å>Q½9¦b{,99|»wz1 ÆÆ
y|y|}TÅ9Å9# DÌf .ú$ÌÐ{¥|y,}<Å9É¥>Dª~y~2¤wz{,¤b##zÒYÌOTy~Å9DD~Ë1y~ ! Fy~y~¬Å>D§@{Ày|D{Dw'~¬|9§ËQ>Å9ªx}Yy~ Å9Ñ° ^ ý Óg+ UÑDzÀ £t¤b#~ÌÐ>QDy~{ÀÅ Æ
D9w'ª <y|f9|g Q¬09ª¦§Ëy~Å>Å9.{{~Qwªb~9ªbQØUQ>#wwb <y»{¥y|~9}9~<zy|¤bQ#b>{#¨zy¤b#{m» <w'9}T#»y~{ " b~
wb« »#w'#}T9#|Qw'ÆÇ}9y~D»wQ {D«>9{À~b9}9ª #f úCÅ>B w{y~wÅ9b|9ªÅ³^Å9Qy-D~»b{¬¾9Ô>y--1y~DÅ9w¦V£*y|Å9Ô
y||ww'Qy~>»-Q9ªoÌÐ9V|y|zÅ ¤#fÐú DªbbQy¤bD'{O£owo{~© 9ý & }>+{Ày|w'z¨¤by|#w Uf w'Qg y~¬ Å>¹ 9yªb»Å¦{$QT{~b{O{|{~ <Q}9wz Æ
y|y|Å>-wzzy2¤by~#Å9~Ø9¦yÀy|Q>ª ÔÄ$ Tb#~}>£t{~#||¤. !y|Å9ÌQz{ÀÌ¼xy|y|Å>|w'w!Q9y|9Å9ª#Ñ|~ÓgbÑ|{'£ <y|Å99
Ô{D¬
ÌÐÔÅ><ªQ <9ÑD|xÑØ>wb°Êªb{~9{~{~|Å9ª^9z©Ì Ä{¦{~Å9y~w z ÌÅ9y|{Å9{Ày~ y~bÅ>ª1^w'|9î
||DD <'y-»£xy|wy~DÅ9}U 0¯D{ 99|{Ày~}>|Qwy~}>Å9}9<¯Qy~Qy~y~0D{¥{y!zy|¤b{~Å91#y
y|Å9.9|»w'z}T¤##»{ËD£tby£tDw Å" Qb9¬ oQy~Å>oÔ<{#¬g¯o{~#.w 9|wb{¥y|
»§{~w'#w'}T|}>¤z#Qwz ¯y|ù Qb >£tb{ }Tg'y|y~Å9y~xbw' >9 Y$>{~{ÀÅ9Uzw'ÌÍF#y~wbÅ9{À-y~#Å>|~w'byË|Ì{.2Q w~9~ª <¤»Dy~9y~ª¯Å>Dù wbon}<Å ú Æ
?p0r"VV
r EZ)r2D)âr$r % #s\$r%Z ú
T
,
¬
Ë
§
9
Å
2

}Tw^~t1ªby~y~9D "#y|¨Å>yw'r my|{ÀÅ9b{~y|*Qby~ w'<& <9y~DÅ> -{w'ygy|ÌÐ|y|wQÅ9y~Q Å9f fË g ú 9b¬>}<§Ë 9É¥D#Å91 »y~{f¤{~g 99UTDÀ9£t~by|~{Ð y|
#Å9D {
y|{~Å9#|o¤zwzD~y||Qb>{O'w£>9 m|Dy~ <Å9»*y|1Q>b~ª¦|Dy~1Å>yO$»w'1b}T~#|»D{Ë19y-wy~}U$Dy~@Å>ªbw'Q¤byË#Ty|¨Å9y $ b{~#}< Æ
9"& {À3y~|'Qw'}>U< *y~{ÀÅ9!zw'Ì|{Fy~Å>w'by@~*9>wb 9##1>|f w'g y~#{Àb¦#gw<wy~{~>U~ Fy{J¬ '£Yy|Å9JÉ¥bQÿ
(
(
(
(
test set frequency
0.3
1
1
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
CRF−C
0.4
0.2
0.25
0
0
0.2
1
0.15
0.2
0.4
0.6
CRF−C
0.4
1
0.2
0
0.3
0.8
1
C1 Percent Error
0.4
0.35
0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0.2
0.1
0.8
0.6
0.1
MEMM−C1
0.4
MEMM−C0
0.1
0.2
0.05
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
"*<%oFA, FA% &:FA#AB:)BF". C+% "!s#$% )%@%@l,9#! FA-FA#;$@A#IIF CBD#$'9
<FA#dFA)F f )%@%@l,9%,sABBFA#$%,$%@# FA8e
C#I%@%&uA# Q+#$9WFA/ . FA:92+216+-
+ )<465<7 )
ÑÑÓgÓg^^Ñ ÆÆ ffÐgú
Ô@Ô@ÆÆ ffÐgú
ÑÑÓgÓg ^^Ñ ÆÆ ffÐgú
Ô@Ô@ÆÆ ffÐgú
0.9
1
%@%PFA:_F A_j
FA# FA#$%oF%@#IFK
%@- ,99WFA/.
K
§{¥yÐD~| + § w'99ª#|~b +
#9°U¬¬ ®b<
¬ &)(
( ¬
( ¬ ®z°
( ¬ &&
( ¬ (&
9& ¬¬ ®'©
( ¬ (&
& ¬® &
°>( ¬¬ (&
( ¬( ®
( ¬D©
( ¬(
( ¬& ®
( ¬(
( ¬& ®
( ¬(
(
(
0.3
FEG A"%$K* ) #I@A)_FA#$%& ,465<7 "!s#$% FA)F:1A #
H I@+sFA#! H F)B#dB:)%@#!;& #)F+sA#$% =q%@#$#,FA#IH"F
J
K #A#,9GBD#j
C1 0UFA#d!sC ,9:) 9#d%
0 #IA# ) I+sFAD#I@&()A %
y|¤zQw¤b~ mf 9úg#T'£Ã#y|># <9ª¦<y|bUDÀy~£tÅ9b*~>{w|fwg ¬ 1¹ y~<D£t|{Ð|w>w' -Qby~uÅ9y~.Å9w{ÀË|9D¨{~9yQ'y|{£
>f wzg y|¬ñw>¨§Ëy~Å9Å9b!9|ªDÅ¦{~9ÌQy|{|£tw|~DQ$Ø>y~Å9>Ñ Ô<f úT# 9~£tw'y||w{~1Q9ymª$wÌO{~½b|{~{ÀÐÅ>zy|ÌÅ>w'w
{~ª9QØU#wÿË9|z¤#DbyËÌÐQy~Å fÐú ¬
j !pÂ=@=?:³km70=@lT8 7ÐpÂ?Â=@q
y|y|2|Å9{,w1Qy|w>DØU *>#Ò<w'wÐw9{~ <QD99Q |>D {Àÿ~»9 9wz <~y|DQ9boª2oy~'Å9w£U>Ëy~ <Å9»w'Ð}T× <#QÔÙ\##QD|y~# x¨~y,D<}< <#É¥#o¨}Ty~*#¤,w{À{#{~y|zYw'Ì<y~ Æ
( <£tw'b>~ Êwzy|FQw'bUÑ w'}T£t9<y2y~}UÅ9{ÀD~>¤zwbwz{¥y|yQ¬2b>§Ë{DÅ97 oM y|%û wN¦{~¿(û OÅ>%û wP {¬y¥ÌOmÅ>#wÑ}UDy|Å9{D
b( }>¬,{~Ö2#|}Y¤u¤Yw'y~>{~$Qo{*9MÄ#Qy~y|Å9Å9DÐ»w'}T<# <9#»{ÐUÅ>wb{,w'>> ~bÌÐ}9QÅ9DD {,N Qy|w'Å9|9Ð»9w'ª}T#y~9Å9»»{{
wb.{À>TÌÐD1Å9yD»¬ Å¹ Ê~DwbU 9wz <y|Qy~{Ðy~Å9J.y|Å9¨#|{¥¦y|»D{$#w#¨ò~y~w{À}U>DF£t|ôÝ}>{~y|#Å9|¤zwzMRy|QQ bN
bO }>{~##||¤u~w'y~y~J¬¬¯ÔÖ2>>w'm}9\Qy$ÌÐÅ9£#ÑDy~Å9|¯}>{~»#{o|¤z|wzDÿ|Q9b|D» È{y~y~Å9¯ÈwòÀ}U<DÆ
y|#£,|y~~Å9>$<y|ôw}UP DTy~ÌÐÅ9Å9oDy~!Å9$y~Å>wo}UD}U{-{ÀDò~~#¤z<wz1y|QbDô9!UÌQYwb¤b{ #~y~9ªy~Å>o¤zy|w' 9P ¬
»w'ªb}Tw#Q*J <¨»{À>y~|Q}9}99QyOy~'£JÁ <D>~b9~ª »y~{Å99ÈDDQ¨ <y|# |~y~9.9y % #W<PZ <¬ Dr >D) y|^ Å9z#ÌO% É¥Db¤QD¨Dy
}T 9 y~91ÅYy¥.>Ì{y|#mDy|Å9w'( ># <|( b~mb29Dwz{|y| {#$( T QÌÐy2( »Q <{,9}T9|mDQ>¤® Dª^(+y|TÅ9b <{|9{ÀQ¨|}9y~Q>D.ªm~|y~9y|Å9< <y¦»{¥P {~y|D{Q¨9¬9ªbD9§Ë>»Å9{À1Å
ÌÐ{Ày|Qwy~>Å 99w| #Ô×b~b#¬Qw'|Q½Dw'99y#|~y~Èw}UDOy|Å9 O « {
»§@ò|{xÐmy|DÑb{~}<9>y|{~wQD^ôy~9Å9^< <b9¬ Q> Q}9zQÌyow'#'¤bD£Ë#~Q|9£ty¥2ÌO||xw'y~}9w'Qy~Fy|{,wÈQ@£Uy~y~Å>!<w'£tUy|{À»¦{wzÌÐ~y|QQy~¨bÅ 9Qy||wÅ9D~
|ÌÐDQÿ~9Å^|D9 ½-y| w¦{~#w9<ªy~9.|}9-Qy y~Å9 y¥ÌÉ¥¦bQ¨Å9y¦» 9 < <»D{¥^y|~{À}9y|wz<y|y|DQb{ ËJ¬0»{Ð£t1 -y~Ô
fÐÅ>ú Q <9D ªxfÐy~Å>Ôú ¦@ÌÐò~y|ÐVÅ9y|mÅ{À>f <g < DôxO<w'* <>Dò 9¹ ~bbS y|9#(||~2w'>y~w'<#>y| ô
U{À< <{$DQy|{ò ¹ ÿ|D#|~b9~9by|ôËÌÐÅ9< <Q 9 <>> 9~# 9ªf ÌÐg Å9V»yÅx'£Ãy~y|Å>#Ä#|Å9~bYFb|{~w'Dy~{o,y~» {
wz® ¤b>( #+ ¯y¥'¬wÌ}UeD#|z9UÌ>DÀ{DÌ£t¬ b2~{~Å9wz>Ì³1 y~Å9 D~Å9|» 9{x <Dw'-|?{Ày|T wzy|D'{DY£Ë}U}>{~y~#Å |¤zwzy~< <U#»{#{
JILK
g(
6(
(:1P@AA% 9FA#'7 !)F)%@#IF3& @A_AI+% "!s#$%3)9:!
FA#$%oF<I9:!sFAC9%$K <B%@#IA)FA9%<_A# ,-A #$9 )FFA#$%oFFA #K
6F@FA
39 +% +:)PFA#$%oF $9!FA9 0 #
A# BDFA FA# B%@#IA'j
FAC9%9
! !"#$%$&'"(*),+.-%() /10234#5+6728#9;:! )A#a,lA#$9K
j l @=p$5prl @7aOk-70@=lT8 7Ðpr?:r=q
b»2w'{}T# >w'»wz{Dy|¬wQQªbUQ#>{¥9{Ày|y|D|w'|w'w'y~y~y~¤{D ¦#£t1~w'Ò9b$w'ìy~9ww'U{À{ÀQy~19U$*{À»° <9#{À$*y|w'y~y~y~ w'9b^ 9ª w½ÌÐOQÌÐy~ÅQy~Ô Å°
y|}TÅ9>>9 9~w'b|}>w'}>1Qb>Vy¥ < Qy~- w>>{ ?° > "-¬,w> ½{~>Ì<-ww{|Åm{~ 9{Ày|w'y~m 1|##9»Vw'y{
y|bÅ9 "ñ}>{~¦#|ÌÐ¤zwzQy~y~Å b UÌÐw'gQy~>Å-~9b}>|w'}>}9w}9Vy¥QbQ¬y¥A¹ £@.wg£t>DQ{~Oy|w#}9QV-y { }> w{~D
U¨w'> w'w'Qm1y|ÌO#|D Q
Çwz¬ y~Ê{U{À Fgy|Å9#Ä}T'y~Å³< <#»{T#~£t|
Ìy| 9¼z|ÌO ò~D# ¤D|D~Ç9ù 9 Ìy|0ô 1}UwDUQÅÁ{À9»ª^ <£t#Dwz9y|9wÍ|Q£ ¬ Qù¨ y~¹ D~wbö{¥y| 9Q <>÷ Qª×y~Cû B>¤zÿ0wJ~y|»y|w'ÄÅ9ÿy~Å9£tDÌÐ w'Å9y~£t9D|~wz Æ
>Èz¯ÌÕ{~y1w'ym¿y~Å9{.o»{¦bn ú y||wÑw>U{~¨Vy|{ÀQQby~³¤¦w>¤z ³wQ9¤z¦ow'n £t9ú Ñ$ww'9> ' 9y|Å9#.Qby~w'w'>>{~ ÄVy|Qy|bÅ9J ¬
y|{Ày|D£@w'{Ày|y~y~Å9# ¦DÆÇb{~Å9.}>z{À1DÌb~~¤zÌ|w'9#y~<>y|Dy|Å9 m£t.D£tw'Dy~w'9y~9|Ô D|{OD{w'Y|w 9>#{À T 9UwzQD»yÀw'w£t|b~{Àb#{g>|£t#~>>Ë#<Dw.y~{ ¤z F w'U¬@|{ÀQÈ#9y¥ª
9VÙ\#|#ÿ -« {2w>D @Y« { 1¬.ÔQªb9~®m{~Å9zÌ{y~Å>w'y2y|Å9}<É¥Æ
=<
#
#
L
$
0.2
C0 Percent Error
0
Truth
CRF−C0 MEMM−C1 MEMM−C0
CRF−C1
A
Q
H
T
A
Q
H
T
A
Q
H
T
A
Q
H
T
A
Q
H
T
Document Position (ticks are file boundaries)
:7 U9#<C)BD#$C69 ,A#$% +FA%$K31 EBW5 )&& I+A $9WF0%oF@A%%@'0 %FA#,AB:)BF". %@%@-,9#! FA#)
;&aFA#
&(I+s<C)BD#$%= 9%0#I. W+#$%oFA9. *#!0. uJBQ. A)A+% "!#$%$K*A $9"F)D%@FA9- 'A #I% FAsAI+6,GFA#!)F FA#,FA5G _5s%
)FdFA 9!/BDF@FA !#$9FA#FA# :# BD +9!)A#$%$K # 9WFA#$9%@F. )&'#)
%oF@A/$@A#$%@D9:!s% FAEI,-AB:)BF"./%@%@-,9#!/FA-
u)BD#$ ,- A #$9EFA#<&(#$)F +A#I%)&PFA#,9#d9GFA#d7 #K 6W5"%'& AFAEFA BD)F@FAPF@+#,CBD#$%$. es. f. e".G fK
#}>Ø9wby|{2{$>'~£Ëby|}9Å9QD{w'¬xÔÅ9Q>y~w'y~>F~¦>ÌÐ2Å>9QD-ÌÕ{Àby~}<QËÉ¥D{~1y~¤¨¤.9ª£t>>y|Å9my|Qb»w' }Tf #Qú Æ
#DÏ¦w'1}U#xÿ~>-{~Dwb -{y|y~$Å9y|.|{Àwy|Qw>Ñ 9w'Óg^ *É¥bQ¨wy> Q¿b#QÅ>Ô ¨< F<¬ <#»{É¥>{Àyw{
('; @lYn r?Y*= )U8Ê? 65q
È> <y||Å>#ÌÝw'9¿Ñu1y|w'#Q>¢wub£tbwoÈ9£t|zo¤Y 9wQ9¨ª¯y|Å9Å9#<Ô<£t9Ëì <» >{~#wz>y|w>{|{À,w'>>{D
Å>ÑzÌ0|m£t|19Ò<Vy~T£t#9|JQy|Å9D»b{Ëy1w'ÒYËy~|DD>{~{À9Vy{»w'{#|¬ m9DD < ½y~È9> 9#{¥yw'> b9Ð|#¤YQDÌOD|{O£tbËy~Å9DQÐ¤b#|¦>{~1£t9##ÿ|{D¬
|³,
ê +êJ¶>ê Þ ¸\ê´
#%$ èÀÝ¸ à ÝÝè¥æ Þ z &¯æ Þ ¸Fë à Ýè¥æ Þ ´
eyÀy~bJ½¬ 9 ¬ 9ºw'9>~<Å9¼y|Å #b~»¨9ð <
y||wQy~Q>Å×Q9ª$QÌÐQy~Vy|DÅ ×y~ 9{¥w'yÐy|w912b>Vy <Q»y~{->{D¬Ub¹ ¦Àyy~w'Å>¨2y{~y~9ÄQ|QyOw''y|£ <Åñ{|1|< <DQÆ Ç1« bw99>9w|#{|¨{~y~w»>{~{|1w'xªb <g*1b»w99>#w'ÒY|>9¬ {Ày~ +>9Q»#w'y~>{w2w2|1Æ
y|U#Qwzby~³¤y~Å>y~.w'ymw'¨9y~D9~|ª>^{¥ÿÌO1¬@2b§Ë{~Å>Å9#wu¤Ê¤D|Q~D¨x{~y~#|{À$< <}9>9D#{OD ¦»w <wDy|¦wD{Ày-{@}<y|É¥1Å>bwz>y|y <QQ¤bQ$y~£t9w'>Y'1 Æ£ ¢ # »w Y1¬ y||¹w>>U <\>¬# Q¢ 9ª^DQ»£tw Dw'y~91|y|D|{$w>'£k .¬ w'-U>¬Q 90 /Í Ø>w'#ÙT»D 9À{Dy¥¬3b1 2-U45¬ 45¢ 4 ¬
bDw9{~*D{Oy~< <{¥y#ÇT« {.#~£tw|~ªbQw'U>w'#,21bb9> <¦Qy~ <#>Tw#> > <{Ð{Ày~|-}9y~<Å9y~*¨>wQQwzy¥y~¦Å>#'£ @r6 V3%!#% CaXZr# $"r ? a>A@Z > 8(%7 $ # '@r>)V¬ :9$#%; Z (Z #=<#)$p ! r 2 `
@wz <Ù\Q#y~~y¥>B w->>¬bw'Ñ> 9uðw'QØU>#» 9Y{ .+*g¬C ~/ b}>w'D}9~DQ{Ày~w9»'Ô¬ <' <&(D( { £t¬\O{ÀbD<ª'ÆÆ
y|Å>w'!wªY< oÉ¥by#> 9Vy|Qb>w'J <»{Ày~|Q}99y~J¬
È}T'y|Å!Å>{ÀwuY¤b¨Äy~Å9 <#Dy~»xw'>>{À -y~~wzy|w'D ÕQÆÇÌ{~ª|»9 QØU9#|w¨}9y #{Ë9'|£z¤f #ú2zD¤b#y {ÈfQ g #ÿ~9ªw'U m»w'}T#Q>ª{~D¨9D>1* 9w'y|w>¬ 7<V D>AE qp 2 `
£t>b~Oz¤bw.##wb#{~¨{y'»£J{@Ñ£t@w'|y~¿Å9zË¤YÑ»w'Óg^½Y 9¬u#¯»{#O¬,§ËØ>>Å9 oy~Å>¨w'{¥y@yËy|Å9 <|wb{¥9y|Ë9#Ì Æ &@r_V $1#¬"Ñ|#ªb%Gw'F¡* w' <£tHw<9J#>II3|wr>#W1V »{~!#>X U 9oJ¬ ¬ & &7$
# 9bD{Àw'y2@£tÌÐ>V>y|Å!y|Qy~bÅ>¯*9y~||z¤Y¿Y 9D{w}Uw-DV9ÆÚ}9z¤b»w#{Ð,>w'>~b ^}9QQ¨Dy|#¬|DÓ{Ày~¤D9ªmy~ÌËÅ9wub9ªy~Å ô9w' 9#ÿ~.|¬bYÔ>Ê~D^Vyw'w'|ª>¿ z¢ ¤½¬J/ < <#D»~{DQ£tw9m'ÔQ<¬ £tb"&~()(w'( y~1¬9³Ñwz1ÒYÒYÆÆ
y|>Å9#FVy*Ô!»{2{À>b'Q¤by*D1{JDy~Å9w'2»{y~9ÅU~wzbyx}9y~#Å9¼mQwÔ³»{*|w'g>ÌË~wuY>{199|D1 o£t#w'w}><Q Æ y~w1y~ w'U {~#ªb#ÿ|w'y~J¬ 7, V3> J ¬UK® >M>L ?p$ ® 2 @r)¬V !#"|ªb$w# %
¡*F w'9£tw89J< >#<Iwp !! Ô9rNw'I3>r##WV {|1U!:9X o¬
y|{~Å9zy|ÌÅ9{Èy|^Å9.ÓgÑÑÓg½^¬ Ô>9U <1#Ò9 w'fÐú 9{~Qªb9Q9ØU#wÔ<by|Q
1

<
Ò
U

y
y|99ªx|Ë'Dy|Å9w'<#,y|9|D<{ <QD{DT¬ ~¹ y|wb{Àbywb{ÀËTDDw1{~y|D{{@'y~£UÅ>y~Å9ÑÐ>Óg>mÑ <#<|y|¨Uw'D9ÀªÅ9£tbQ9y~~|'ÆÆÆ ÑQ9¿zªw>»{Àby~§x»0¬ "|&#()ª(|D {|1{~¬>QbJª¬ b~Q6y~Å9rIpP{O £tr@bt,"V wz Ò<F*Q$#"9V roÆÇX)]rQ¿#< Å9r Y% Y #D{|{#¨w'> ÌÐÅ>wu¤Ë9|z¤Y 9D wxÌwu.£F~#y|w'99ªy~Å9}UD<Æ R r)V$Z 'S; ¬
Q=
I
1a 1 Q=
Q=
I!
1a " 1 Q (
g(
3(
(

Download Report

An Alternate Objective Function for Markovian Fields

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz