Gardner File No. 23 -d- Rangeland soil carbon and nitrogen 'responses to grazing J.T. Manley, G.E. Schuman, J.D. Reeder, and R.H. Hart ABSTRACT: Land manag~rs. liv~stock producas, and th~ public ar~ conc~m~d about th~ ~ffict1 ofgrazing on soil quality and sustainability of rang~!4nd mourm. Pastum at th~ High P!4ins Grasslands &uarch Station n~ar Chryenn~, ~oming. graud fOr th~ past 11 y~ars at a h~avy stocking rat~ (67 st~~r-dayslha) untkr thn:~ manag~ment systems, wa~ compan:d to continuous light grazing (22 ste~r-dayslha) and to liv~stock aclosum. Th~ h~avy stocking rate mulud in slightly 1m than 50% utilization of th~ annualfOrag~produmi, a kv~1 r~commended by !4nd manag~ment agenci~s. Prior to initiating this grazing r~uarch th~ rang~land had not b~en graud fOr about 40 y~ars. Soil organic carbon and nitrogen r~spons~ wa~ roaluaud by colkcting soil sampks to 91 em (36 in) depth. Soils had high~r amounts ofcarbon and nitrogen in th~ surfau 30 em (12 in) on th~ graud pastum compar~dto nativ~ rang~!4nd wha~ liv~stock w~n: aclud ui. Howron; soil carbon and nitrogen b~low 30 em was simi!4r among ali grazing tr~atments. Carbon and nitrogen dynamics wa~ gr~aUJt in th~ JUrfac~ 30 em wha~ mon: than thr~~-fOurths ofth~ plant root biomass aists. Grazing strategi~s and stocking rat~s impoudfOr th~ past 11 y~ars on this mix~d grass prairi~ did not detrimentally affia soil organic carbon and nitrogen kv~ls. Th~ data, in fact. sugg~st that responsible grazing enhanud th~ ovaall soil quality as asms~d by there parameters. esearch on grazing lands has historically focused on the effects of v:uious man agement practices on forage production and animal response; little attention has been given to the impact of grazing on the nutri ent dynamics of soils. Recent interest in "soil health" or "soil qualiry" has directed at R u:nti0i"l rlJ gi'~zing impact.> \:;n sc-il parCiffie ters that make up soil health/qualiry. Few studies have evaluated the effectS of grazing on soil organic matter and irs relationship to water and nutrient cycling, and related plant producciviry. In general, the available data do not indicate any single or consistent re sponse of soil organic carbon (C) and nitro gen (N) to grazing. Some research has re ported increases in both soil organic C and N (Dormaar et aJ. 1990; Dormaar and Willms 1990a; Ruess and McNaughton), while other studies have found no response in soil organic C and N to grazing (Kieft; Mathews et al.; Milchunas and Laurenroth). Smoliak et al. reported that increased graz ing pressure on mixed prairie resulted in de creases in needleandthread (Stipa comata) and an increase in blue gram (Bouteloua gra cilis), which has a greater shallow root mass; hence, soil organic carbon increased. Bauer et al. found that grazing reduced soil organ ic C and increased soil organic N. These inj. T. Man/ry is a graduate research assistant. G.E, Schuman and ].D. &eder an: soil scientistJ. and R.ff Hart is a rangei4nd scientist. &zngeland Re sourCfi Raearch Unit. U.S. Department ofAgri culture-Agricultural Research Service. Cheyenne. WY82009. j. Soil and Waur Cons. 50 (3) 294-298 294 consistent findings demonstrate the com plex interaction between grazing and soil or ganic matter. Many factors determine the response of soil organic matter ro livestock grazing. Floate summarized these factors as (a) the initial status of vegetation and soil, (b) en "Iiro!!!!!enr::d f:!.c!o!~, especially !!!oistt'.re and temperature, and (c) grazing history (intensity, frequency, duration, and type of animal). Soils with inherently low soil organic C are more prone to change in re sponse to grazing (Dormaar et al. 1977) than soils high in organic C. Precipitation and temperature limit above-ground bio mass production and soil organic matter (Parton et al.), and influence rates ofliner decomposition and nutrient cycling (Charley). Year-to-year fluctuations of en vironmental conditions may affect differ ences in biomass production as much as grazing (Ashby et al.; Milchunas and Lau renroth). Grazing intensity, frequency, and dura tion all affect the plant communiry and the magnitude and direction of change in soil organic C and N. Light grazing can result in greater species diversity and pro duction compared to areas where livestock grazing is excluded Oohnston). On the other hand. high intensity and/or early season grazing have been found to have a greater negative impact on litter and live plant biomass than light intensiry and/or late season grazing of mixed prairie pas tures in Canada (Naeth et al.). Moderate grazing of mixed grass prairie in North Dakota resulted in greater litter decompo JOURNAL OF SOIL AND W,ITER CONSERVATION sition and soil N mineralization man ei ther heavy or no grazing (Shariff et al.). Most research on this subject has com pared soil C and N concentrations in me surface soil of grazed pastures and non grazed exclosures. However. animal graz ing has been reported to increase soil bulk density (Bauer et al.; Dormaar and Willms 1990b; Pluhar et al.) and increases in soil bulk density will greatly affect me results if soil C and N concentrations, nor toral mass, are reponed. greatly over-stat ing the response to grazing treatments (Simpson et al.). Soil organic C and N should therefore be reported based on mass. However. not everyone agrees how to best express and evaluate management effects on C and N changes in soil. Skene suggests that the use of soil bulk densiry to normalize data may lead to misinter pretation. He and other researchers presently assessing soil C and N dynamics are suggesting mat soil volume be consid ered and that comparisons be made on equal soil volumes even though soil depth may vary because of bulk density. Addi tienally. since root biomass and distribu t?on affect soil organic matter content and distribution, soil profiles should be sam pled sufficiently deep to ensure that a ma jority of the rooting depth is included in the assessment. The objective of our research was to ~11:m· ~~e effeCTS of!;everal erazine man agement strategies on soil or~ic -C and N after 11 years on a semi-arid mixed grass prairie. Grazing management strate gies evaluated included zero, light, and heavy grazing intensities and season-long. rotationally-deferred, and shon-duration rotation grazing. Study sites and methods Study sites. The research was conduct ed at the High Plains Grasslands Research Station near Cheyenne. Wyoming. The native rangeland is a mixed-grass prairie, with roIling topography and elevations ranging from 1910 to 1950 m (6266 to 6397 ft). The climate is semi-arid with an annual frost-free period of 127 days and mean (1871-1986) annual precipitation of 338 mm (13.3 in), of which 70% oc curs from April 1 mrough September 30. Dominant soil series are Ascalon and Alt van sandy loams [mixed, mesic, Aridic Argiustoll (Stevenson et al.)]. Dominant cool-season grasses are west ern wheatgrass (Pascopyrum smithi,) and needleandthread and the dominant warm season grass is blue grama. A survey of the plant community prior to initiating the grazing study indicated the range sites of the area were in good condition. Reprinted from the Journal 01 Soil and Water ConsefVafion May"",-,une 1995. Volume 50 Number 3 CopYright Q 1995 Soil and Water Conservation SOCI9'Y Prior to establishment of the grazing management phase of i:he research in 1982, the area had not been grazed by do mestic livestock for about 40 years. Graz ing strategies, grazing intensities, and pas ture design are shown in Figure 1. Soils were sampled where grazing management was continuous season-long at a light stocking rate (22 steer-days/ha), and rora tionally deferred, short-duration rotation, and continuous season-long, all at a heavy stocking rate (67 steer-days/ha). The heavy stocking rate resulted in slightly less than 50% utilization of the annual pro duction. Further details of the grazing strategies are given in Hart et al. Before the grazing research started, permanent 50-m (160 ft) line transects were located on near-level (0-6%) sites in each pasture on the Ascalon soil series. The experimen tal design of the grazing study is a ran domized block design with two replicate blocks (Hart et al.). Soil sampling. In July 1993, soil sam ples were collected from the continuous season-long, light stocking rate (CL); con tinuous season-long heavy stocking rate (CH); shorr-duration rotation, heavy stocking rate (SH); rotationally deferred, heavy stocking rate (RH) pastures, and the exclosure (EX). Soil sample sites were established at 10m (32 ft) intervals along the: perina";:": 50 in (160 ft) line trAr;· sectS that had been established for evaluat ing plant community response to the grazing treatments. Five cores were taken on each transect to a depth of 30 cm (12 in) and separated into 0-3.8, 3.8-7.6, 7.6 15, and 15-30 cm (0-1.5, 1.5-3, 3-6, and 6-12 in) increments. Surface plant litrer was carefully removed from the area where soil samples were taken. Cores were taken with a hydraulic soil sampling ma chine with a soil tube diameter of 4.6 em (2 in). Because of soil moisture limita tions, the deeper soil cores [30-91 em (12-36 in)] were not taken until May 1994. Soil cores were taken to the 91 cm depth, the surface 30 cm increments re moved, and samples collected for the 30 46,46-61 and 61-91 cm (12-18, 18-24, 24-36 in) depths. The individual soil sample increments were placed in sealed plastic bags in coolers and transported to a constant temperature room [5'C (41'F)] until analysis. 'Upon return to the laboratory the samples were broken up by hand and plant crowns and visible roots removed. Duplicate soil cores were col lected at the second and fourth sampling locations on each of the transectS for de termining bulk density (Blake and Hartge) (Table 1). Sample analysis. The soil samples were Table 1. 5011 bulk density of various grazing management strategies at varying soil depths Soil Depth EX CL RH SH 1.01' 1.36 1.39 1.39 1.39 1.39 1;14 1.36 1.26 1.26 1.26 1.26 1.17 1.33 1.38 1.38 1.38 1.38 1.11 1.27 1.42 1.43 1.43 1.43 cm 0-7.6 7.6-15 15-30 30-46 45-61 61-91 EX=exclosure, CL=continuous light, CH=continuous heavy, RH=rotationally deferred heavy. SH=short-duration rotation heavy 'values are a mean of four replicate samples, two samples taken on each of two transects . PASTURE DIAGRAM ...".:..,-. ..- - _. . ....... . .. '. ,'s,. '. ,,- Rep I eM I~~~~~~~~~~RM~.~.~.~.~==:.:--:=-=-~ ---------- t= Rep 11 a.Smile • Stocking rates Grazing strategies L -Ught M -Moderate H =Heavy C - Continuous R = Rotationally deferred S .. Short Duration rotation EX Exclosure Water source = Figure 1. Diagram of grazing systems and stocking rates study, showing replications, grazing strategies, and pasture design dried in forced air ovens at 60'C (I40'F) to a constant weight. The dried samples were ground to pass a 2-mm (0.08 in) screen. Soil organic N was determined on a subsample by the micro-Kjeldahl method described by Schuman et al. The digest was analyzed for ammonia by con tinuous flow colorimetric analysis (Tech nicon TRAACS 800). Soil organic C was determined utilizing a modification of the Walkley-Black procedure (Nelson and Sommers). The modification was a con version from a colorimetric endpoint to a millivolt endpoint (Raveh and Avnim elech). Soil organic C was determined on a subsample of the soil ground to 0.50 mm (0.02 in). Data analysis. Soil organic C and N concentration, for each transect and by depth increment, were convened [0 a mass basis (kg/ha) using the mean bulk density of the two soil cores obtained from each line transect. The bulk density data in Table 1 are presented for assessing C and N changes on a concentration basis because of the debate surrounding data presentation on a mass basis. Analysis of variance was used to evaluate treatmem effects on soil organic C and N and least significant-difference (LSD) procedures were used for mean separation (Steel and Torrie). All statistical analyses were evalu ated at P ~ 0.10. Results and discussion Soil organic C and N in the surface 7.6 cm (3 in) of soil were significantly lower in the exclosure compared to all of the grazing management strategies (Figures 2 and 3). No differences existed between any of the grazing strategies, except thar in the 3.8-7.6 em (1.5-3 in) soil depth the organic C was significantly lower under the continuous-light grazing strategy than "l,\ y. I UN E I <J q ~ 295 25 DEX .CL .CH.RHC3SH a ab ab -20 o o o or- x 15 ro .c 0) ~ -10 () o (J) 5 o Figure 2. Soil organic carbon as affected by various grazing strategies (exclosure, con tinuous-light, continuous-heavy, rotatlonally-deferred heavy, and short-eluratlon rotation heavy grazing), 0-30 cm soli depth Bars within a soil depth increment with the same letter are not significandy different. P S 0.10. 25 DEX .CL .CH.RHIiiillSH a I x co :E 15 0) ~ Z ::E 10 tti "0 Q; ~ 5 o Figure 3. Soil organic nitrogen as affected by various grazing strategies (exclosure, con tinuous-light, contlnuous-heavy, rotationally-deferred heavy, and short-eluratlon rotation heavy grazing), 0-30 cm soil depth Bars within a soil depth increment with the same lettcr arc not significandy diffcrent. P S 0.10. under any heavily grazed management, bur was still significantly greater than in the exclosure. In rhe 7.6-30 cm (3-12 in) soil depth, differences in soil organic C and N contents among grazing srraregies were more varied, but C and N contents 296 in the exclosure remained lower than, or at best comparable to, C and N under the various grazing treatments. These data ex hibit rhe importance of the surface few centimeters of soil as it relates to C and N dynamics under a grassland. Seventy to JOURNAL OF SOIL AND WATER CONSERVATION 90% of the root biomass is present in the surface 30 cm (I2 in) of the soil in rhis type of grassland system (Oormaar et al. 1984); therefore, nutrient availability in this zone is very important. In rhe 30-91 em (12-36 in) depth, soil organic C and N contents were not significandy differ ent among ungrazed and grazed treat ments (Figure 4). Soil organic C and N concentrations were quite low and vari able at this depth in the soil. Only a small percentage of the root system is present in this soil depth increment; therefore, it is nor surprising that grazing for 11 years had no affect on the lower porrion of rhe soil profile. The higher levels of soil organic C and N in the surface soil of the grazed range land may be due in part to the effects of grazing on litter and standing dead com ponents of the above-ground biomass. Al though grass roots are the primary source of organic matter in rangeland soils, above-ground litter provides a secondary source (Aandahl). The grazing treatments essentially eliminated the standing dead component and greatly reduced the sur f:tce litter component. Animal traffic may be enhancing physical breakdown and soil incorporation of this residual plant mater ial. In comparison, 70% of the above ground phyromass in the exclosures was in the form of litter and standing dead plant materiaL We ~stim:l[e rhat this large component of recalciuant marerial immo bilized about 35 kg N/ha (31 Ib N/ac) and 1550 kg Clha (I ,383 lb Clac) above ground in the exclosures'. Species compo sition shifts within a plant community can also result in C changes as discussed earlier (Smoliak et al.). However, our re search did not show an increase in blue grama (Hart et al.) nor did it show a sig nificant below-ground biomass response to grazing2. In general, defoliation is thoughr ro stimulate an increase in allocarion of C and N ro regrowing leaves and a decrease in allocation of C to roots (Oeding et al.), resulting in reduced root biomass (Oor maar er al. 1990; Johnston) and reduced root exudate contributions to soil organic matter. Thus researchers have predicred losses rather than gains, of soil organic C and N with grazing (Holland et al.). How ever, multiple harvests (simulated grazing) raken throughout the growing season have been shown to result in greater plant pro duction than a single estimate obtained ar peak standing crop (Murz and Orawe). Dodd and Hopkins found thar clipping 'G.E. SchurruuJ. 1994. unpublished data. 'R.H. Hart. 1994. unpublished data. 6 .---------,-------------.80 O'EX . C L .CH.RHrnmJSH 05 o - - o 60 oo o .... ><4 - - ns .c )( CV ~3 40 .s:::. C, - o z ~ :22 ns 20° .tIJ "C Gi ~1 o o Nitrogen Carbon Figure 4. Soil organic nitrogen and carbon as affected by various grazing strategies (ex closure, contlnuous-llght, contlnuous-heavy, rotatlonally-deferred heavy, short-duratlon rotation heavy grazing), 30-91 cm soli depth No significant differences berwttn grazing m:aunenu wimin a par.une[ee weee obsecved. P ~ 0.10. blue grama five times gave greater produc tion man clipping mree or four times, in dicating mat mis species would respond [Q grazing defoliation and produce greater aboveground biomass. Grazing also stimu lates (illering (Floate) and rhizome pro duction (Schuman et al. 1973). Thus, if plant growth is stimulated by grazing, then greater CO 2 sequestration would occur. which could result in greater C allo cation to below-ground portions of the system. Dyer and Bokhari (Dyer and Bokhari) inferred that blue grama re sponded [Q defoliation by rapidly translo eating material to (he crowns and roots and by increasing root respiration and/or root exudation rates. Ruess and Mc Naughton (Ruess and McNaughton) sug gested that grazing accelerates the rate of nutrient cycling by stimulating primary production and net nutrient flux, mereby increasing the percentage of the system's nutrients that are available and which cycle rapidly near me soil surface. The resultS of this study indicate that responsible grazing strategies implemented 11 years earlier did not detrimentally af fect soil organic C and N levels in me ac tive and important upper 30 cm (12 in) of the soil profile under native mixed-grass rangeland. In fact, the data indicate that grazing enhanced me overall soil quality as assessed by these parameters, and that plant production should be sustainable. REFERENCES CITED Aandahl. A.R. 1981. Soils of [he Great Plains: Land Use. Crops and Grasses. University of Nebraska Press. uncoln. NE. Ashby, M.M.. R.H. Hart, and J.R. Forwood. 1993. Plant community and cattle tesponses to fifty yc:ars of grazing on shongrass prairie. US DA Agricultural Research Service. Rangeland Re sources Research Unit. RRRU-1. Cheyenne. WY. Bauer, A.• C.V. Cole. and A.L. Black. 1987. Soil propetty comparisons in virgin grasslands be rween grazed and nongrazed management sys tems. Soil Science Society of America Journal 51:176-182. BI:t.ke, G.R.. and K.H. Hartge. 1986. Bulk density core method. In: A Klute (ed.) Methods of soil analysis. Parr 1. 2nd ed.• Agronomy Monograph No.9. American Sociery of Agronomy. Madi son. WI. Charley. J.L. 1977. Mineral cycling in rangeland ceosysterrn. In: R.E. Sosebee et al. (eds.) Range land Plant Physiology. Range Science Series 4:214-256. Detling. J.K.• M.1. Dyer. and D.T. Winn. 1979. Net phorosynthesis. root respiration and re growth of Bou[e1oua gracilis following simulated grazing. Oecologia 41:127-134. Dodd. J.D.• and H.H. Hopkins. 1958. Yield and carbohydrare content of blue grama as affected by clipping. Transactions of the Kansas Acade my ofScience 61 :280-287. Dormaar, J.F.• A. Johnston. and S. Smoliak. 1984. Seasonal changes in carbon content. and dehy drogenase. phosphatase. and urc:ase acrivities in mixed prairie and fescue grassland Ah horizons. Journal of Range Management 37:31-35. Dormaar. J.F.• A. Johnsron. and S. Smoliak. 1977. Seasonal variation in chemical characteriStics of soil organic marter of grazed and ungrazed mixed prairie and fescue grassland. Journal of Range Management 30:195-198. Dormaar. J.F.• S. Smoliak. and W.O. Willms. 1990. Distribution of niuogen fractions in grazed and ungrazed fescue grassland Ah horizons. Journal of Range Management 43:6-9. Dormaar. J.F.• and W.O. Willms. 1990a. Effect of grazing and cultivation on some chemical prop erties of soils in the mixed prairie. Journal of Range Management 43:456-460. Dormaar. J.F.. and W.D. Willms. 1990b. Sustain able production from [he rough fescue prairie. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 45: 137 140. Dyer. M.1.. and U.G. Bokhari. 1976. Plant-animal interactions: Studies of [he effects of grasshop. per grazing on blue grama grass. Ecology 57:762-772. Floare. M.J.S. 1981. EffectS of grazing by large hee· bivores on nitrogen cycling in agricultural ecosystems. In: F.E. Clark and T. Rosswall (cds.) Terrestrial Nitrogen Cycles. Ecological Bulletin 33:585-601. Han. R.H .. M.J. Samuel. P.S. Test, and M.A. Smith. 1988. Catde, vegetation. and economic responses to grazing systems and grazing pres sure. Journal of Range Management 41:282· 286. Holland. EA. W.J. Panon. J.K. Deding. and D.L. Coppock. 1992. Physiological responses of plan[ populations to herbivory and their consequences for ecosystem nutrient flow. The American Nar uralist 140:685-706. Johnston. A 1961. Comparison of lightly grazed and ungrazed range in the fescue grassland of southwestern Alberta. Canadian Journal of Planr Science 41 :615-622. Kieft. T.L 1994.. Grazing and plant.canopy effects . on semiarid soil microbial biomass and respira· tion. Bioi. Fen. Soils. 18:155-162. Mathews. B.W.• LE. Sollenberger. V.D. N"m. and c.R. Staples. 1994. Impact of grazing manage· ment on soil nitrogen. phosphorus. potassium and sulfur distribution. Journal of Environmen· tal Qualiry 23:1006-1013. Milchunas. D.G .• and W.K. Laurenroth. 1993. Quantitative effectS of grazing on vegetation and soils over a global range of environmentS. Eco· logical Monographs 63: 327-366. Mutt. J.L.. and D.L. Drawe. 1983. Clipping fre , 'quency and fertilization influence herbage yield and crude protein content of 4 grasses in Soum TCX2S. Journal of Range Management 36:582 585. Naeth. M.A.• A.W. Bailey, D.J. Plu[h. D.S. Chanasyk, and R.T. Hardon. 1991. Grazing im· pacts on litter and soil organic matter in mixed prairie and fescue grassland ecosystems in Alber· ra.Journal of RanRe Management 44.7-12. Nelson. D.W.• and LE. Sommers. 19!1i. Tora! cac bon. organic carbon. and organic marrero In: AL. Page. R.H. Miller. and D.R. ~eney (cds.) Methods of soil analysis. parr 2. 2nd cd.. Agron. Monograph No.9. American Sociery of Agrono my. Madison. WI. Parron. W.J.• D.S. Schimel. C.V. Cole. and D.S. Ojima. 1987. Analysis of facrors controlling soil organic marter levels in Great Plains Grasslands. Soil Science Sociery of America Journal 51: 1l73-1179. Pluhar. J.J .• R.W. Knight. and R.K. Hei[schmidr. 1987. Infaltration rares and sediment production as influenced by grazing systems in the T CX2S rolling plains. Journal of Range Management 40:240-243. Raveh. A. and Y. Avnimelech. 1972. Potentiometric determination of soil organic marter. Soil Sci ence Sociery ofAmerica Proceedings 36:967. Ruess. R.W .• and S.J. McNaughton. 1987. Grazing and the dynamics of miuient and energy regular. ed microbial processes in the Serenge[i grass lands. Oikos 49:101-110. Schuman. G.E.. M.A. Sranley. and D. Knudsen. 1973. Auromated tora! niuogen analysis of soil and planr samples. Soil Science Sociery of Amer ica Proceedings 37:480-481. Schuman, G.E.• D.T. Booth, and J.W. Waggoner. 1990. Grazing reclaimed mined land seeded ro native grasses in Wyoming. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 45:653-657. Shariff. A.R.. M.E. Biondini. and C.E. Grygiel. 1994. Grazing intensiry effectS on litter decom position and soil nitrogen mineralization. JOU[ nal Range Management 47:444-449. Simpson. J.R.. S.M. Bromfield. and O.L. Jones. 1974. Effects of management on soil ferriliry under pasture. 3. Changes in [ora! soil niuogen. carbon. phosphorus. and exchangeable cations. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture MAY - J U N E I?? 5 297 and Animal Husbandry 14:487-494. J.K.M. 1966. Errors in ..coetion studies of soil organic mauer. Journal ?f the Australian Institute Agricultural Science 32:208-209. Smoliak. S.• J.F. Dortn2af. and A. Johnston. 1972. Long-term gtazing effects on Stipa-Boutdoua ptairie soils. Journal of Range Management 25:246-250. Steel. R.G.D .. and J.H. Torrie. 1980. Principles and procedures of statistics; a biometrical approach. 2nd d .. MaGraw-Hill Book Co.. New York. NY. Stevenson. A.• R.E. Baumgartner. and G.E. Schuman. 1984. High Plains Grasslands Research Station. Detailed Soil Survey. USDA-Agricultural Research Service. Cheyenne. WY and USDA-Soil Conservation Service. Casper. WY; and Wyoming Agricultural Experiment Station. Laramie. 1-841103.62. Technicon TRAACS 800. 1987. Crude protein in feeds. Industrial Method No. 825-87r. Technicon Industrial Systems. Tarryrown. NY. S~ne. 298 10 LJ RNA L 0 F SOl LAN 0 W A TE ReO N S E R V A TI 0 N
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz