Minutes of 2011 Fall Meeting of
ACI 310 Decorative Concrete, October 16, 2011,
Attendees to the meeting :
Michael Smith
Larry Rowland
Crisman, Jennifer K
Dorfmueller, Daniel P
Hoyt, David
Luke, Allyn C
Metzger, Scott C
Murray, Michael E
Reardon, Joe A
Nick Sorrentino
Jim Vermillion
Name
Status
Voting
Voting
Voting
Voting
Voting
Voting
Voting
Voting
Voting
Voting
Voting
10-16-11
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Liason
601,303
124
email
Janet White
Associate
X
US Bureau of Reclamation;
[email protected]
Bent Mikkelsen
Bonnie King
Dionne HutchingsOjeda
Duane Carey
Hiram Ball
Jennifer Grubb
Visitor
Visitor
Visitor
X
X
X
Concrete Décor [email protected]
Visitor
Visitor
Visitor
X
X
X
Scott Shafer
Visitor
X
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
522
[email protected]
[email protected]
340
[email protected]
[email protected]
303,601
[email protected]
[email protected]
WOC, [email protected]
[email protected]
dcarey@wrmeadows
[email protected]
Simpson Gumpertz & Heger (SGH)
[email protected]
[email protected]
Quorum: 17 Voting / Need 7 / In attendance: 11
1. The Meeting was called to Order and identified; ACI 310 is a technical committee which will produce a
document for TAC review to establish a document on Decorative Concrete applications, first as a Guide and
ultimately, as a Standard for practices and acceptable quality.
2. Self introductions by attendees
3. Minutes of Spring 2011 Meeting were approved as submitted – Motion/Second by Allyn Luke/David Hoyt
4. ACI Committee Liaisons Report
 124, Larry, Notable concrete call for submissions.
 302 – Scott M. reports that the Committee has not met, nothing new to report.
 303 – Dorf, has been reappointed as Chair.
 308 - Mike Murray is chair for this sub committee.
 601D - Nick reported that 601 is moving ahead with their document.
5. Curing Decorative Concrete Task Force – Mike reviewed some of the concerns of the approach the Task
Force is taking. Need to consider Interior and Exterior applications. The discussions and work of the TF
continue.
6. Comments and reviews of Integrated Document.
a. Discussed the input from Ballot #2.
b. Went through the comments and changes recommended by Dave Hoyt. (A specific accounting for how
each negative was resolved will be posted to the Committee website). A general description of the actions
taken to resolve Dave’s negatives are outlined here:
Dave Hoyt’s Comment #
1. P. 10, line 9 - Withdrawn without condition by commentator Dave Hoyt
2. P. 18, line 17 - Found persuasive, deleted lines 17-20 replaced with text from Jamey Farny
3. P. 21, line 3 - Found persuasive, resolved by adopting new text worked on in committee.
4. P. 22, lines 12-22 - Found persuasive, adopted new text suggested by Jim Vermillion & worked
on in committee.
5. Same as Item 4.
6. P. 24, lines 5-16 - Found persuasive, adopted new text suggested by Jim Vermillion & worked
on in committee.
7. P. 24, lines 19 - Found persuasive 23 removed noted text.
8. P. 33, line 18- Found persuasive added proper reference to ACI 302
9. P. 36, lines 17-19 - Withdrawn without condition by commentator Dave Hoyt
10. P. 42, line 1 – Found persuasive removed “design mix”
11. P. 43, line 5 – Found persuasive added text “cement paste”.
12. P. 43, line 15 – Found persuasive remove text “excessive”.
13. P. 44, lines 7-12 – Found persuasive, resolved by adopting new text worked on in committee.
14. P. 49 lines 1-3 – Found persuasive, resolved by adopting new text worked on in committee.
15. P. 53, line 5 - Withdrawn without condition by commentator Dave Hoyt
16. P. 64, lines 7-8 – Found persuasive, resolved by adopting new text worked on in committee.
17. P. 65, lines 20-22 – Found persuasive, resolved by adopting new text worked on in committee.
7. No new or old business was brought up.
Adjourned 5:22