Returning Manyeleti Game Reserve to its rightful owners: land

5HWXUQLQJ0DQ\HOHWL*DPH5HVHUYHWRLWVULJKWIXO
RZQHUVODQGUHVWLWXWLRQLQSURWHFWHGDUHDVLQ
0SXPDODQJD6RXWK$IULFD
0$,GH.RQLQJ
+PCPGYRTQEGUUHQTUGVVNKPI
NCPFENCKOUKPRTQVGEVGFCTGCU
IQXGTPOGPVCPFEQOOWPKV[NCPF
ENCKOCPVUPGIQVKCVGCOWVWCNN[
CEEGRVCDNGEQOCPCIGOGPV
CITGGOGPVCKOGFCVDCNCPEKPI
EQPUGTXCVKQPCPFFGXGNQROGPV
DGPGſVU
/KTLCO#+FG-QPKPIKU%QOCPCIGOGPV
CPF%QOOWPKV[$CUGF0CVWTCN4GUQWTEG
/CPCIGOGPV
%$04/#FXKUQT/RWOCNCPIC
6QWTKUOCPF2CTMU#IGPE[0GNURTWKV5QWVJ
#HTKEC
6JKUCTVKENGKUDCUGFQPVJGCWVJQTŏU2J&VJGUKU
ő#PCN[UKUQHCOQFGNFGUKIPGFHQTNCPFTGUVKVWVKQP
KPRTQVGEVGFCTGCUKP5QWVJ#HTKECŒUWDOKVVGF
HQTGZCOKPCVKQPKP,WPGVQVJG7PKXGTUKV[QH
5QWVJ#HTKEC
70+5#2TGVQTKC5QWVJ#HTKEC
8QDV\OYD9RO
$
GVYGGPCPFVJGGCTN[U
HQTEGF TGOQXCNU KP UWRRQTV QH
TCEKCNUGITGICVKQPECWUGFGPQT
OQWU UWHHGTKPI CPF JCTFUJKR KP 5QWVJ
#HTKEC6JG5QWVJ#HTKECP)QXGTPOGPVKU
PQYEQOOKVVGFVQTGXGTUKPIVJGGHHGEVUQH
EQNQPKCNKUOCPFCRCTVJGKF6JG4GUVKVW
VKQPQH.CPF4KIJVU#EV
0QQH
CUCOGPFGFRTQXKFGUHQTVJGTGVWTPQH
NCPF TKIJVU VQ RGTUQPU QT EQOOWPKVKGU
FKURQUUGUUGFCHVGT,WPGYKVJQWV
GSWKVCDNGEQORGPUCVKQPCUCTGUWNVQHRCUV
TCEKCNFKUETKOKPCVQT[NCYUQTRTCEVKEGU
%NCKOUJCFVQDGNQFIGFYKVJVJG%QO
OKUUKQPQP4GUVKVWVKQPQH.CPF4KIJVU
%4.4DGHQTG&GEGODGT+P
VQVCNNCPFENCKOUYGTGHKNGFHTQO
CNNQXGT5QWVJ#HTKEC
.CPF ENCKOU CHHGEV OCP[ QH 5QWVJ
#HTKECŏU RTQVGEVGF CTGCU 5VCVG HQTGUVU
CPFYQTNFJGTKVCIGUKVGU#PGUVKOCVGF
NCPFENCKOUQPRTQVGEVGFCTGCUCTG
QWVUVCPFKPI
%4.46JGCRRTQ
RTKCVG UGVVNGOGPV QH VJGUG ENCKOU ECP
JCXG GPQTOQWU KORCEV QP VJG NQECN
GEQPQOKE FGXGNQROGPV QH TWTCN CTGCU
YJGTG OQUV RGQRNG UVKNN TGN[ JGCXKN[
QPPCVWTCNTGUQWTEGUVQMGGRRQXGTV[CV
DC[
5JCEMNGVQPCPF5JCEMNGVQP
6JGNCPFTGUVKVWVKQPRTQEGUUKPRTQVGEVGF
CTGCUYKNNDGUWEEGUUHWNQPN[KHCIQQF
DCNCPEG DGVYGGP EQPUGTXCVKQP CPF FG
XGNQROGPVKUCEJKGXGF
FG-QPKPICPF
/CTCKU
6JKU CTVKENG UWOOCTK\GU VJG TGUWNVU
QH VJG PGIQVKCVKQP RTQEGUU DGVYGGP
IQXGTPO GPV CPF NCPF ENCKOCPVU QXGT
VJGHKTUVNCPFENCKOUQPRTQVGEVGFCTGCU
KPVJGRTQXKPEGQH/RWOCNCPIC1P
(GDTWCT[NCPFENCKOUGVVNGOGPVCPF
EQOCPCIGOGPVCITGGOGPVUYGTGUKIPGF
HQT/FCNC/CDWUCCPF/MJQODQ&CO
0CVWTG 4GUGTXGU CPF /CP[GNGVK )COG
4GUGTXG6JGTGUWNVUHQT/CP[GNGVK)COG
4GUGTXGCTGRTGUGPVGFKPOQTGFGVCKN
.#0&4'56+676+10#0&
%1/#0#)'/'06+0
2416'%6'&#4'#5
$G[QPF TGEVKHKECVKQP QH C JKUVQTKECN
YTQPIENGCTQDLGEVKXGUUWEJCURQXGTV[
CNNGXKCVKQPCPFGORNQ[OGPVIGPGTCVKQP
CTGKORQTVCPVRTKQTVQVJGUGVVNGOGPVQHC
NCPFENCKO+P5QWVJ#HTKECŏUNCPFTGUVK
VWVKQPRTQEGUUKVKUVJGTGURQPUKDKNKV[QH
VJG5VCVGCPFVJGENCKOCPVU
KPFKXKFWCNU
HCOKNKGUCPFEQOOWPKVKGUVQOCMGCP
KPHQTOGFFGEKUKQPCOQPIVJGQRVKQPUQH
CNVGTPCVKXGNCPFNCPFTGUVKVWVKQPHKPCP
EKCNEQORGPUCVKQPCPFQTCEQODKPCVKQP
QHVJGUG+POQUVECUGUVJGIQXGTPOGPV
RTQOQVGUNCPFTGUVKVWVKQPCUVJGRTGHGTTGF
UGVVNGOGPVQRVKQPHQTNCPFENCKOCPVU
6QCNKIPVJGNCPFTGUVKVWVKQPRTQEGUUKP
RTQVGEVGFCTGCUVJGTGURQPUKDNGOKPKU
VGTUQHVJG&GRCTVOGPVQH.CPF#HHCKTU
&.#CPFVJG&GRCTVOGPVQH'PXKTQP
OGPVCN #HHCKTU CPF 6QWTKUO &'#6
UKIPGF C OGOQTCPFWO QH CITGGOGPV
/Q# KP /C[ (QT CTGCU VJCV
OWUV TGOCKP RTQVGEVGF KP RGTRGVWKV[
VJG /Q# RTGUGPVU EQOCPCIGOGPV CU
VJGQPN[UVTCVGI[YJGPEQOOWPKVKGUQRV
HQTNCPFTGUVKVWVKQP
6JG XKCDKNKV[ QH EQOCPCIGOGPV
FGRGPFURCTVN[QPYJGVJGTVJGRTQVGEVGF
CTGCECPOCMGCPGVRTQHKV+POQUVECUGU
VJKUKUQPN[RQUUKDNGKHOCPCIGOGPVKU
GHHGEVKXG CPF GHHKEKGPV VJG RQVGPVKCN
HQT VQWTKUO FGXGNQROGPV KU JKIJ CPF
VJGTKIJVKPXGUVQTECPDGHQWPF$GTMGU
EQPENWFGFVJCVEQOCPCIGOGPV
KU HGCUKDNG QPN[ KH HQWT EQPFKVKQPU CTG
RTGUGPV CRRTQRTKCVG KPUVKVWVKQPU VTWUV
6QWTKUO
XCNWG
*KIJ
EQOCPCIGOGPV
/GFKWO
HWTVJGTCUUGUUOGPV
.QY
PQEQOCPCIGOGPV
$KQFKXGTUKV[
XCNWG
%QOCPCIGOGPV
5QEKQGEQPQOKETKUM
*KIJ
%QOCPCIGOGPV
7UGUQEKQGEQPQOKE
TKUMXCNWGCPFEWTTGPV
VQWTKUOUVCVWUVQ
KFGPVKH[TKUMCTGCU
%WTTGPVVQWTKUO
2CTVNGCUGRCTVEQOCPCIGOGPV
5QEKQGEQPQOKETKUM
5QEKQGEQPQOKETKUM
%WTTGPVVQWTKUO
%WTTGPVVQWTKUO
.GCUG
#NVGTPCVKXGNCPF
(KPCPEKCNEQORGPUCVKQP
/CVTKZVQFGVGTOKPG
VJGOQUVHGCUKDNG
NCPFENCKOUGVVNGOGPV
QRVKQPD[TCPMKPIVJG
XCNWGQHDKQFKXGTUKV[
CPFVQWTKUOVCMKPI
KPVQCEEQWPVVJG
EWTTGPVVQWTKUO
TGEQTFCPFVJGUQEKQ
GEQPQOKETKUM
.GCUG#NVGTPCVKXGNCPF
(KPCPEKCNEQORGPUCVKQP
5QEKQGEQPQOKETKUM
%WTTGPVVQWTKUO
%QOCPCIGOGPV
5QEKQGEQPQOKETKUM
/GFKWO
%QOCPCIGOGPV
7UGUQEKQGEQPQOKE
TKUMXCNWGCPFEWTTGPV
VQWTKUOUVCVWUVQ
KFGPVKH[TKUMCTGCU
5QEKQGEQPQOKETKUM
5QEKQGEQPQOKETKUM
.QY
%WTTGPVVQWTKUO
%WTTGPVVQWTKUO
.GCUG
#NVGTPCVKXGNCPF
(KPCPEKCNEQORGPUCVKQP
.GCUG#NVGTPCVKXGNCPF
(KPCPEKCNEQORGPUCVKQP
5QEKQGEQPQOKETKUM
%QOCPCIGOGPV
7UGUQEKQGEQPQOKE
TKUMXCNWGCPFEWTTGPV
VQWTKUOUVCVWUVQ
KFGPVKH[TKUMCTGCU
%WTTGPVVQWTKUO
2CTVNGCUGRCTVEQOCPCIGOGPV
%WTTGPVVQWTKUO
%QOCPCIGOGPV
5QEKQGEQPQOKETKUM
%WTTGPVVQWTKUO
&GRTQENCOCVKQP
5QEKQGEQPQOKETKUM
%WTTGPVVQWTKUO
2TQVGEVGFCTGCUCTGFGETGCUKPIN[UWD
UKFK\GF D[ VJG IQXGTPOGPV CPF EQP
UGTXCVKQPCIGPEKGUTGN[KPETGCUKPIN[QP
VJGKTQYPKPEQOGIGPGTCVKQPVQUWUVCKP
QRGTCVKQPUCPFVQHWNHKNVJGKTOCPFCVGQH
EQPUGTXKPIDKQFKXGTUKV[*QYGXGTKVKU
SWGUVKQPCDNGYJGVJGTVJG[ECPOCPCIG
VQFQUQYKVJVJGCFFKVKQPCNGZRGEVCVKQPU
QHDGPGHKVUJCTKPID[NCPFENCKOCPVU+P
/62#TGNKGFQPIQXGTPOGPV
UWDUKFKGUHQTRGTEGPVQHKVUKPEQOG
DWV KVU NQPIVGTO VCTIGV KU VQ TGN[ QP
VJGUG UWDUKFKGU HQT QPN[ RGTEGPV QH
KVUKPEQOGKP
(TQOVQ/62#FGXGNQRGF
COQFGNHQTDCNCPEKPIVJGQDLGEVKXGUQH
DKQFKXGTUKV[EQPUGTXCVKQPCPFKPETGCUGF
6*'/27/#.#0)#/1&'.
6JG /RWOCNCPIC 6QWTKUO CPF 2CTMU NQECNGEQPQOKEFGXGNQROGPVKPECUGUQH
#IGPE[
/62#KUCRCTCUVCVCNCRRQKPVGF NCPFTGUVKVWVKQPKPRTQVGEVGFCTGCU6JG
D[ VJG 5VCVG VQ OCPCIG VJG RTQXKPEKCN OQFGN YCU FGUKIPGF XKC CP GZVGPUKXG
RTQVGEVGFCTGCU1HHGPEGFCPFUVCHHGF NKVGTCVWTGTGXKGYCPFNGIKUNCVKXGCPCN[UKU
6JGſTUVRCTVQHVJGOQFGNKUVJGGNCDQTC
5VCVGQYPGFRTQVGEVGFCTGCUOCPCIGFD[
/62# CTG RCTVKCNN[ QT EQORNGVGN[ VKQPQHVJGEQPUGTXCVKQPCIGPE[ŏUKPVGTPCN
RQUKVKQP TGICTFKPI VJG NCPF ENCKO 6JG
WPFGTNCPFENCKO
DGVYGGP RCTVPGTU NGICN RTQVGEVKQP QH
NQECN TKIJVU CPF GEQPQOKE KPEGPVKXGU
HQTNQECNRGQRNG2CTVPGTUJKRUYKVJVJG
RTKXCVG UGEVQT CTG ETWEKCN VQ OCMG EQ
OCPCIGOGPVDGPGHKEKCNHQTCNNVJGRCT
VKGUKPXQNXGF6JGCPVKEKRCVGFDGPGHKVU
HQTVJGEQOOWPKVKGUKPENWFGEQOOWPKV[
GSWKV[ UVCMGU KP VQWTKUO EQPEGUUKQPU
RC[OGPVUQHNGCUGHGGUQTTGXGPWGUJCTGU
VQEQOOWPKVKGUHQTVJGWUGQHVJGKTNCPF
RTGHGTGPVKCNGORNQ[OGPVHQTNQECNRGQ
RNGNQECNQWVUQWTEKPIRTQEWTGOGPVCPF
EQPVTCEVKPICPFNQECNGPVGTRTKUGQRRQT
VWPKVKGUCPFDWUKPGUUVTCKPKPI
9QNOGT
CPF#UJNG[%CTTWVJGTU
&GRTQENCOCVKQP
CIGPE[ECTTKGUQWVCTCPMKPIGZGTEKUGQP
VJGDKQFKXGTUKV[CPFVQWTKUOXCNWGQHVJG
CTGC VQ CUUGUU VJG RTGHGTTGF NCPF ENCKO
UGVVNGOGPV QRVKQP #TGCU YKVJ OGFKWO
VQ NQY VQWTKUO XCNWG CTG EQPUKFGTGF VQ
JCXGKPUWHſEKGPVRQVGPVKCNVQ[KGNFDGPG
ſVUWPFGTEQOCPCIGOGPVCUVJG[CVVTCEV
NKOKVGF PWODGTU QH KPXGUVQTU CPF VQWT
KUOQRGTCVKQPUIGPGTCVGQPN[CPCXGTCIG
VWTPQXGT (WTVJGTOQTG VJG PGIQVKCVGF
EQPVTCEVUTKUMJCXKPIHGYRTQRQQTVQWT
KUODGPGſVUDGECWUGQRGTCVKQPUCTGTKUM[
CPF DGECWUG QH VJG NCEM QH EQORGVKVKQP
D[ KPXGUVQTU 6JGTGHQTG /62# FGEKFGF
VJCVEQOCPCIGOGPVKUQPN[XKCDNGHQTVJG
RTQVGEVGFCTGCUYKVJCOGFKWOVQJKIJVQWT
KUOXCNWGTGICTFNGUUQHVJGKTDKQFKXGTUKV[
XCNWG(QTQVJGTCTGCUQRVKQPUKPENWFGNCPF
TGUVKVWVKQP YKVJ /62# NGCUKPI VJG NCPF
DCEMHTQOVJGENCKOCPVUCNVGTPCVKXGNCPF
ſPCPEKCN EQORGPUCVKQP QT YJGTG DQVJ
VQWTKUOCPFDKQFKXGTUKV[XCNWGUCTGNQY
FGRTQENCOCVKQPQHVJGRTQVGEVGFCTGCRGT
OKVVKPICEJCPIGKPNCPFWUG
UGG(KIWTG
8QDV\OYD9RO
+PVJGHKTUVRCTVQHVJGOQFGNVJGEQPUGT
XCVKQPCIGPE[CNUQGUVCDNKUJGUKVUKPVGT
PCNRQUKVKQPYKVJTGICTFVQVJGRTGHGTTGF
UGVWRQHEQOCPCIGOGPV
6JGUGEQPFRCTVQHVJGOQFGNFGUKIP
KU VJG FGXGNQROGPV QH C EQPUQNKFCVGF
RQUKVKQP COQPI TGNGXCPV IQXGTPOGPV
FGRCTVOGPVUDCUGFQPVJGEQPUGTXCVKQP
CIGPE[ŏUKPVGTPCNRQUKVKQP
6JG VJKTF RCTV KU VJG GNCDQTCVKQP QH
IGPGTKE NCPF ENCKO UGVVNGOGPV CPF EQ
OCPCIGOGPV CITGGOGPV HTCOGYQTMU
DCUGF QP VJG EQPUQNKFCVGF IQXGTP
OGPV RQUKVKQP 6JG CITGGOGPV HTCOG
YQTMU TGHGT VQ VJG TGURGEVKXG NGIKUNC
VKQPKPXQNXGFCPFVJG[OWUVDGNGICNN[
EQORNKCPV6JGHKPCNXGTUKQPUPGGFVQDG
CRRTQXGFD[VJGTGNGXCPVFGRCTVOGPVUVQ
HQTOVJGDCUKUHQTPGIQVKCVKQPUDGVYGGP
VJG IQXGTPOGPV UVCMGJQNFGTU CPF VJG
NCPFENCKOCPVTGRTGUGPVCVKXGUVTWEVWTGU
6JGOQFGNFGUKIPYCUVGUVGFKPUGXGP
RTQVGEVGF CTGCU OCPCIGF D[ /62#
UGNGEVGF HQT VJGKT TGNCVKXGN[ JKIJ DKQ
FKXGTUKV[ CPF JKIJ VQWTKUO XCNWG CPF
VJGTGHQTGEQPUKFGTGFVQJCXGRQVGPVKCN
HQTUWEEGUUHWNEQOCPCIGOGPV
8QDV\OYD9RO
RTQXGFVQDGCIQQFVQQNHQTGCUKN[KFGPVK
H[KPIEGTVCKPTKUMCTGCUUWEJCUWPTGCNKUVKE
EQOOWPKV[GZRGEVCVKQPUCNCEMQHUVTQPI
EQOOWPKV[ UVTWEVWTGU NCEM QH CEEGUU
VQ KPHTCUVTWEVWTG UGTXKEGU CPF UWRRQTV
QTICPK\CVKQPUENCKOCPVUNKXKPITGNCVKXGN[
HCTHTQOVJGTGUGTXGCPFEQPHNKEVYKVJVJG
NQECNOWPKEKRCNKV[#NVJQWIJVJGRTQEGUU
YCUEQUVN[CPFNGPIVJ[HQTVJGEQPUGTXC
VKQPCIGPE[KVGPUWTGFKORTQXGFEQO
OWPKECVKQP WPFGTUVCPFKPI CPF VTWUV
DGVYGGP VJG HWVWTG EQOCPCIGOGPV
RCTVPGTUVJCVKUVJGNCPFENCKOCPVUCPF
VJGEQPUGTXCVKQPCIGPE[
6*'%#5'1(/#0;'.'6+)#/'
4'5'48'
1PGQHVJGRTQVGEVGFCTGCUYJGTG/62#
CRRNKGFVJGOQFGNFGUETKDGFCDQXGKUVJG
/CP[GNGVK)COG4GUGTXG6JKUJC
ICOGTGUGTXGUKVWCVGFCNQPIVJGYGUVGTP
DQWPFCT[QHVJG-TWIGT0CVKQPCN2CTM
JCUDGGPENCKOGFD[ENCKOCPVJQWUG
JQNFUQHVJG/PKUKEQOOWPKV[YJQCTG
TGRTGUGPVGF D[ VJG /CP[GNGVK %QPUGT
XCVKQP6TWUV6JG/PKUKEQOOWPKV[C
DTCPEJQHVJGYKFGT5JCPICCPUGVVNGFQP
0GIQVKCVKQPQHVJGNCPFENCKO
UGVVNGOGPVCPFEQOCPCIGOGPV
CITGGOGPVDGVYGGPVJG
IQXGTPOGPVCPFVJGENCKOCPVU
KP/CP[GNGVK)COG4GUGTXG
0$,'(.21,1*
0GIQVKCVKQPRTQEGUU
6JG PGIQVKCVKQP QH NCPF ENCKO UGVVNG
OGPVUCPFEQOCPCIGOGPVCITGGOGPVU
DGVYGGP VJG EQPUGTXCVKQP CIGPE[ CPF
NCPFENCKOCPVTGRTGUGPVCVKXGUKUHCEKNK
VCVGF D[ OGVJQFU UWEJ CU TCPMKPI QH
RTKOCT[ CPF UGEQPFCT[ UVCMGJQNFGTU
RCTVKEKRCVQT[ OCRRKPIYKVJEQOOWPK
VKGU GZRQUWTG XKUKVU TQNGRNC[KPI CPF
UQEKQGEQPQOKE CUUGUUOGPVU +FGCNN[
VJGUGCEVKXKVKGUCTGCNNEQPFWEVGFYKVJKP
C VGCO EQPUKUVKPI QH NCPF ENCKOCPVU
/62#UVCHHCPFQHHKEKCNUQHVJG4GIKQPCN
.CPF%NCKOU%QOOKUUKQP6JGRTQEGUU
GPCDNGUVJGNCPFENCKOCPVTGRTGUGPVCVKXGU
VQ OCMG KPHQTOGF EJQKEGU YKVJKP VJG
NGICNHTCOGYQTM+VOCMGUKVRQUUKDNGVQ
VCKNQTVJGNCPFENCKOUGVVNGOGPVQRVKQP
CPF CITGGOGPVU VQ URGEKHKE UKVWCVKQPU
CPFVQYKPVJGCEEGRVCPEGQHCOCLQTKV[
QH ENCKOCPVU TGICTFKPI VJG RTQRQUGF
CITGGOGPVUCPFYC[HQTYCTF
+PEGTVCKPECUGUVJGNCPFENCKOCPVTGR
TGUGPVCVKXGUPGGFCFFKVKQPCNKPHQTOCVKQP
VQFGEKFGYJKEJNCPFENCKOUGVVNGOGPV
QRVKQPKURTGHGTTGFHQTCIKXGPRTQVGEVGF
CTGCUWEJCUVJGEWTTGPVVQWTKUOTGEQTF
CUQEKQGEQPQOKETKUMCUUGUUOGPVQHVJG
GPXKTQPOGPVKPYJKEJVJGRTQVGEVGFCTGC
KUNQECVGFCPFHKPCPEKCNHKIWTGUVQOCMG
RTQLGEVKQPU QP EWTTGPV CPF HWVWTG PGV
RTQHKV ECNEWNCVKQPU 6JG OCVTKZ UJQYP
KP VJG (KIWTG KU C EQORTGJGPUKXG VQQN
VJCVECPJGNRNCPFENCKOCPVTGRTGUGPVC
VKXGUWPFGTUVCPFVJGNQIKEFGVGTOKPKPI
VJGOQUVHGCUKDNGNCPFENCKOUGVVNGOGPV
QRVKQPHQTVJGKTURGEKHKEUKVWCVKQP
6JGKPENWUKQPQHKPRWVUHTQOVJGNCPF
ENCKOCPVTGRTGUGPVCVKXGUJCUOCFGKVRQU
UKDNG VQ OCMG UQOG IGPGTKE KORTQXG
OGPVUVQVJGCITGGOGPVHTCOGYQTMU(QT
GZCORNGVJGEQOCPCIGOGPVEQOOKVVGG
KUIKXGPTGCNFGEKUKQPOCMKPIRQYGTCU
NQPICUFGEKUKQPUHCNNYKVJKPVJGCRRTQXGF
OCPCIGOGPVRNCPHQTVJGRTQVGEVGFCTGC
YJKEJKUOCFGD[/62#KPEQPLWPEVKQP
YKVJVJGNCPFENCKOCPVUCPFCRRTQXGFD[
VJG /RWOCNCPIC &GRCTVOGPV QH 'EQ
PQOKE&GXGNQROGPV'PXKTQPOGPVCPF
6QWTKUO 5QEKQGEQPQOKE CUUGUUOGPV
EQOOWPKV[CTGOCPCIGF/62#CPFVJG
/CP[GNGVK%QPUGTXCVKQP6TWUVECPCFFTGUU
VJKUTKUMCTGCVJTQWIJCRWDNKERCTVKEKRC
VKQPRTQEGUUCDQWVVJGOCPCIGOGPVRNCP
KPENWFKPIKVUſPCPEKCNRTQLGEVKQPU
1P (GDTWCT[ VJG OCLQTKV[
QHVJGENCKOCPVJQWUGJQNFUTGUQNXGFVQ
OCPFCVG VJG EWTTGPV DQCTF QH VTWUVGGU
QHVJG/CP[GNGVK%QPUGTXCVKQP6TWUVVQ
UKIPVJGCITGGOGPVUQPVJGKTDGJCNHQPG
QHVJGEQPFKVKQPUYCUVJCVVJGGZKUVKPI
VTWUV DG CWIOGPVGF D[ HQWT ENCKOCPV
OGODGTU6JGNCPFENCKOUGVVNGOGPVCPF
EQOCPCIGOGPVCITGGOGPVUYGTGUKIPGF
UKOWNVCPGQWUN[KPCPQHHKEKCNEGTGOQP[
QP(GDTWCT[
6JGUKIPGFCITGGOGPVUUVKRWNCVGVJCV
VJGNCPFKP/CP[GNGVK)COG4GUGTXGYKNN
DGTGUVQTGFVQVJGENCKOCPVUCPFVJGCTGC
OCPCIGFKPCEEQTFCPEGYKVJVJGHKPCN
K\GFEQOCPCIGOGPVCITGGOGPVCPFVJG
OCPCIGOGPVRNCPHQTVJGICOGTGUGTXG
6JG EWTTGPV NCPFQYPGT KP OQUV ECUGU
VJG &GRCTVOGPV QH .CPF #HHCKTU CPF
QT VJG 0CVKQPCN QT 2TQXKPEKCN &GRCTV
OGPVQH2WDNKE9QTMUYKNNVTCPUHGTVJG
VKVNGFGGFVQVJG/CP[GNGVK%QPUGTXCVKQP
6TWUVYKVJKPQPG[GCTCHVGTVJGUKIPKPI
QHVJGCITGGOGPVU+PVJGECUGQHCFKU
RWVGVJGENCKOCPVJQWUGJQNFUECP
TGRNCEGVJGEWTTGPVDQCTFQHVTWUVGGUQT
QRVHQTCPGYNGICNGPVKV[TGRTGUGPVKPI
VJGKTKPVGTGUVU%GTVCKPEQPFKVKQPUQHWUG
YKNNDGTGIKUVGTGFCICKPUVVJGVKVNGFGGFU
VQDGVTCPUHGTTGFUWEJCUVJGQDNKICVKQP
VJCV VJG RTQRGTVKGU OWUV TGOCKP WPFGT
EQPUGTXCVKQPCPFECPPQVDGRJ[UKECNN[
QEEWRKGFD[VJGPGYNCPFQYPGTU
/62#CPFVJG/CP[GNGVK%QPUGTXCVKQP
6TWUVLQKPVN[GUVCDNKUJVJGOCPCIGOGPV
RNCPCPFCEQOCPCIGOGPVEQOOKVVGGHQT
VJGQXGTCNNUVTCVGIKEOCPCIGOGPVQHVJG
ICOGTGUGTXGEQPUKUVKPIQHVJTGGTGRTG
UGPVCVKXGUGCEJ&C[VQFC[QRGTCVKQPCN
OCPCIGOGPVTGOCKPUVJGTGURQPUKDKNKV[
QH/62#6JG5VCVGCITGGFVQRTQXKFG
RNCPPKPICPFFGXGNQROGPVITCPVUQHWRVQ
75RGTENCKOCPVJQWUGJQNFCPF
RGTEGPVQHVJGXCNWGQHVJGNCPFVQGPC
DNGVJGENCKOCPVUVQWPFGTVCMGDWUKPGUU
%QOOWPKV[TGUQNWVKQPKP/CP[GNGVK
)COG4GUGTXGVJGOCLQTKV[QHVJG
ENCKOCPVJQWUGJQNFUIKXGVJGKT
EQPUGPVVQVJGDQCTFQHVTWUVGGUQH
VJG/CP[GNGVK%QPUGTXCVKQP6TWUVVQ
UKIPCITGGOGPVUQPVJGKTDGJCNH
0$,'(.21,1*
WPQEEWRKGFNCPFCV/CP[GNGVK
OGCPKPI
őRNCEGQHVJGUVCTUŒKPCPFWUGF
KVHQTITC\KPICPFUWDUKUVGPEGHCTOKPI
6JG[ DTQWIJV VJTGG [QWPI OCJQICP[
VTGGUYKVJVJGOCPFRNCPVGFVJGOYJGTG
VJGICOGTGUGTXGKUVQFC[
+P VJG CRCTVJGKF IQXGTPOGPV
TGOQXGF VJG /PKUK RGQRNG HTQO VJGKT
NCPF YKVJQWV VJGKT EQPUGPV CPF YKVJ
QWV EQORGPUCVKQP CPF FGXGNQRGF VJG
NCPFCUCICOGTGUGTXGHQTDNCEMRGQRNG
YJQYGTGDCTTGFHTQOVJGPGKIJDQWTKPI
-TWIGT0CVKQPCN2CTM
6JGTGUGTXGKUCRTKOGICOGXKGYKPI
FGUVKPCVKQPQYKPIVQWPJKPFGTGFOKITC
VKQPQHVJGőDKIHKXGŒŌ#HTKECPGNGRJCPV
.QZQFQPVC CHTKECPC DNCEM TJKPQ
EGTQU
&KEGTQUDKEQTPKU%CRGDWHHCNQ
5[PEGTWU ECHHGT NGQRCTF 2CPVJGTC
RCTFWUCPFNKQP
2CPVJGTCNGQŌCPF
QVJGTURGEKGUQHYKNFNKHGDGVYGGP/CP
[GNGVK6KODCXCVKCPF5CDKG5CPFU)COG
4GUGTXGUCPF-TWIGT0CVKQPCN2CTM6JG
XGIGVCVKQP KU IGPGTCNN[ QRGP UCXCP
PCJCPFOKZGFNQYXGNFDWUJXGNFYKVJ
FGPUG TKXGTKPG XGIGVCVKQP CPF HQTGUVU
HQNNQYKPI VJG YCVGTEQWTUGU 6QWTKUO
KU CNTGCF[ YGNN GUVCDNKUJGF YKVJ PKPG
VQWTKUVEQPEGUUKQPUEWTTGPVN[QRGTCVKPI
KP VJG TGUGTXG CPF KV JCU RQVGPVKCN HQT
GZRCPUKQP6JGTGUGTXGŏUJKIJVQWTKUO
XCNWG CPF OGFKWO DKQFKXGTUKV[ XCNWG
UWIIGUVGFVJCVEQOCPCIGOGPVEQWNFDG
CXKCDNGQRVKQPCPFKPVJGPGIQVKCVKQP
RTQEGUUVJGNCPFENCKOCPVUFGEKFGFVQQRV
HQTNCPFTGUVKVWVKQPYKVJEQOCPCIGOGPV
2QUUKDNGTKUMCTGCUKFGPVKſGFKPVJGUQEKQ
GEQPQOKECUUGUUOGPVKPENWFGCTGNCVKXGN[
JKIJPWODGTQHPGKIJDQWTKPIEQOOWPK
VKGUJCXKPIGZRGEVCVKQPUHQTLQDUCPFVJG
NCEM QH CEEGUU VQ UGTXKEGU #FXCPVCIGU
KPENWFG VJG IQQF TGNCVKQPUJKR DGVYGGP
VJGENCKOCPVUCPFVJGVTKDCNCWVJQTKV[VJG
IQQFTGNCVKQPUJKRYKVJVJGNQECNOWPKEK
RCNKV[UVTQPINGCFGTUJKRCPFEQOOWPKV[
UVTWEVWTGUKPVJGCTGCEQOOWPKV[EQJG
UKQPCPFVJGTGNCVKXGN[NQYGZRGEVCVKQPU
QH VJG ENCKOCPV EQOOWPKV[ 6JG UQEKQ
GEQPQOKECUUGUUOGPVEQPſTOGFVJCVEQ
OCPCIGOGPV EQWNF DG C HGCUKDNG OQFGN
CUNQPICUVJGGZRGEVCVKQPUQHVJGYKFGT
8QDV\OYD9RO
FGXGNQROGPVU
UWEJCUVJGFGXGNQROGPV
QHCEQOOWPKV[QYPGFNQFIGCPFQTVQ
QDVCKPGSWKV[KPVQWTKUOEQPEGUUKQPUQP
VJG ICOG TGUGTXG 'ZKUVKPI CPF HWVWTG
EQOOWPKV[ RWDNKERTKXCVG RCTVPGTUJKR
EQPVTCEVUUJQWNFDGPGIQVKCVGFYKVJKPVJG
EQOCPCIGOGPVEQOOKVVGGHQTOCZKOK
\CVKQPQHRTQRQQTVQWTKUODGPGHKVUCPF
VJGDGUVKPVGTGUVUQHVJGRTQVGEVGFCTGC
0GKIJDQWTKPI EQOOWPKVKGU UJQWNF
DGPGHKVHTQOVJGICOGTGUGTXGCEEQTF
KPI VQ VJG 0CVKQPCN 'PXKTQPOGPVCN
/CPCIGOGPV 2TQVGEVGF #TGCU #EV
0QQH+VYCUFGEKFGFVJCV
VJGEQOOWPKVKGUOQUVENQUGN[CUUQEK
CVGFYKVJVJGTGUGTXGCPFPGKIJDQWTKPI
EQOOWPKVKGUYKVJKPCTCFKWUQHMO
UJQWNF DGPGHKV HTQO CEEGUU TGUQWTEG
WUG CPF GORNQ[OGPV QRRQTVWPKVKGU
CEEQTFKPI VQ CP CITGGF TCVKQ +V YCU
TGEQIPK\GFVJCVGZENWFKPIPGKIJDQWT
KPIEQOOWPKVKGUOCKPN[QH5JCPICCP
CPF2GFKRGQRNGEQWNFECWUGEQPHNKEV
CPFKPUVCDKNKV[KPVJGCTGCCUOCP[QH
VJGUGEQOOWPKVKGUTGN[QPVJGTGUGTXG
HQTVJGKTUWDUKUVGPEG
$GPGſVURCEMCIGHQTTKIJVHWN
NCPFQYPGTUQH/CP[GNGVK)COG
4GUGTXG
6JG HQNNQYKPI DGPGHKVU CEETWG VQ VJG
PGYNCPFQYPGTU
Ŗ +PHTCUVTWEVWTGCPFCUUGVU6JGPGY
NCPFQYPGTUCTGITCPVGFQYPGTUJKR
QHCNNKOOQXCDNGKPHTCUVTWEVWTGCPF
HKZGFCUUGVU
Ŗ 5JCTKPI QH TGXGPWG .CPFQYPGTU
TGEGKXGRGTEGPVQHVJGPGVRTQHKV
OCFG D[ VJG ICOG TGUGTXG CU VJG
GPVKTGCTGCKUENCKOGF6JGPGVRTQHKV
KUECNEWNCVGFD[FGFWEVKPICNNEQUVU
TGNCVGF VQ VJG OCPCIGOGPV QH VJG
ICOGTGUGTXGHTQOKVUCPPWCNTGXGPWG
KPENWFKPIVJG5VCVGUWDUKFKGU
Ŗ 'EQVQWTKUO CPF QVJGT FGXGNQR
OGPVU'ZKUVKPIVQWTKUOEQPEGUUKQPU
YKNNDGTGXKGYGFVQOCZKOK\GRTQ
RQQT FGXGNQROGPV DGPGHKVU CPF VQ
GPUWTGVJGQXGTCNNUWUVCKPCDKNKV[QH
VJG ICOG TGUGTXG 6JG PCVWTG CPF
GZVGPVQHPGYFGXGNQROGPVUYKNNDG
8QDV\OYD9RO
FGVGTOKPGFD[VJGEQOCPCIGOGPV
EQOOKVVGG#NNNGCUGEQPEGUUKQPHGGU
CTGKPENWFGFKPVJGPGVRTQHKVECNEWNC
VKQP
Ŗ 'SWKV[ KP VQWTKUO EQPEGUUKQPU
'SWKV[KUVQDGQDVCKPGFXKCFGXGNQR
OGPV ITCPVU CPF PGIQVKCVKQPU YKVJ
VJG RTKXCVG UGEVQT CTQWPF GZKUVKPI
CPFHWVWTGEQOOWPKV[RWDNKERTKXCVG
RCTVPGTUJKRU
Ŗ 6QWTKUONGX[#NGX[VQCNNXKUKVQTU
VQVJGICOGTGUGTXGYKNNDGEJCTIGF
HQTVJGDGPGHKVQHVJGNCPFQYPGTU
Ŗ 7UG QH DKQNQIKECN TGUQWTEGU 6JG
NCPFQYPGTU CPF QVJGT TGUQWTEG
WUGTUCTGCNNQYGFVQWUGDKQNQIKECN
TGUQWTEGUKPNKOKVGFSWCPVKVKGUFWT
KPI EGTVCKP RGTKQFU CU FGVGTOKPGF
D[ VJG EQOCPCIGOGPV EQOOKVVGG
KPCEEQTFCPEGYKVJVJGOCPCIGOGPV
RNCP
Ŗ #EEGUU VQ VJG ICOG TGUGTXG 6JG
EQOCPCIGOGPVEQOOKVVGGECPCW
VJQTK\GCEEGUUVQUCETGFDWTKCNUKVGU
VJGWUGQHDKQNQIKECNTGUQWTEGUCPFC
TGFWEGFICVGGPVTCPEGHGGQXGTEGT
VCKPRGTKQFU
Ŗ 2TQEGGFUHTQOICOG2TQEGGFUIGPG
TCVGFHTQOVJGUCNGQHICOGCPFJWPV
KPI CTG KPENWFGF KP VJG PGV RTQHKV
ECNEWNCVKQP
Ŗ .QECNOCPCIGOGPVECRCEKV[.CPF
QYPGTUCPFPGKIJDQWTKPIEQOOWPK
VKGUJCXGCPGZENWUKXGQRRQTVWPKV[
KP C RTQRQTVKQP QH RGTEGPV
VQ DG GORNQ[GF KP WPUMKNNGF RQUK
VKQPU KP /62# LQD XCECPEKGU QP
VJGICOGTGUGTXG.CPFQYPGTUCPF
PGKIJDQWTKPIEQOOWPKVKGUYKNNDG
ITCPVGFRTGHGTGPEGKPRTQEWTGOGPV
QH IQQFU CPF UGTXKEGU UWDLGEV VQ
VJGKT NGXGNU QH UMKNN 'EQVQWTKUO
OCPCIGOGPVCPFDKQFKXGTUKV[EQP
UGTXCVKQPUMKNNUYKNNDGVTCPUHGTTGF
VJTQWIJ DWTUCTKGU UEJQNCTUJKRU
CPF NGCTPGTUJKRU VTCKPKPI RTQ
ITCOOGU EQODKPKPI VJGQT[ CV C
EQNNGIGQTVTCKPKPIEGPVTGYKVJQP
VJGLQDRTCEVKEGUQVJCVQXGTVKOG
VJGNCPFQYPGTUYKNNCNUQSWCNKH[HQT
UMKNNGFRQUKVKQPU
%10%.75+105
#NVJQWIJKVKUVQQGCTN[VQUC[JQYYGNN
VJG EQOCPCIGOGPV CTTCPIGOGPV YKNN
YQTMVJGPGIQVKCVKQPRTQEGUUCFQRVGFKP
/RWOCNCPICUJQYUENGCTN[VJCVCEQP
UQNKFCVGF IQXGTPOGPV RQUKVKQP CITGGF
WRQPD[CNNTGNGXCPVIQXGTPOGPVUVCMG
JQNFGTUECPJGNRVQMGGRVJGNCPFTGUVKVW
VKQPRTQEGUUKPRTQVGEVGFCTGCUYKVJKPVJG
NGICNHTCOGYQTM6JGOQFGNFGXGNQRGF
D[/62#OC[CUUKUVQVJGTIQXGTPOGPV
CIGPEKGU GURGEKCNN[ 5VCVGUWDUKFK\GF
EQPUGTXCVKQPCIGPEKGUKP5QWVJ#HTKEC
VQOCPCIGNCPFTGUVKVWVKQPKPRTQVGEVGF
CTGCUYKVJKPVJGKTHKPCPEKCNCPFUVCHHKPI
EQPUVTCKPVU
+V KU TGEQOOGPFGF VJCV IQXGTPOGPV
UWRRQTVCNNVJGQRVKQPUKPFKECVGFKPVJG
(KIWTGYJKEJKUPQVVJGECUGCVRTGUGPV
/QUV CNVGTPCVKXGU VQ EQOCPCIGOGPV
CTG EWTTGPVN[ UVKNN WPENGCT CPFQT PQV
HGCUKDNG 6JG NGCUG QRVKQP CRRGCTU VQ
DG FKHHKEWNV KP VJG RTQVGEVGF CTGCU VJCV
CTGEWTTGPVN[5VCVGQYPGFDGECWUGVJG
5VCVGKUPQVDQWIJVQWVYJGPVJGNCPFKU
TGVWTPGFCUKUVJGECUGKPRTKXCVGPCVWTG
TGUGTXGU $GECWUG 5VCVG UWDUKFKGU HQT
RTQVGEVGFCTGCUCTGFGENKPKPITCVJGTVJCP
KPETGCUKPIVJGTGKUCNKOKVGFEJCPEGVJCV
VJG IQXGTPOGPV YKNN CRRTQXG RC[OGPV
QH NGCUG HGGU 7PHQTVWPCVGN[ KV KU UVKNN
FKHHKEWNV HQT VJG EQPUGTXCVKQP CIGPE[
VQEQPXKPEGVJG4GIKQPCN.CPF%NCKOU
%QOOKUUKQP VJCV FGURKVG VJG RQNKVKECN
FTKXGHQTTGUVQTCVKQPQHNCPFVKVNGKVKUPQV
CNYC[UVJGOQUVUWKVCDNGQRVKQPHQTNCPF
TGUVKVWVKQP KP RTQVGEVGF CTGCU CPF VJCV
KPEGTVCKPECUGUVJGQRVKQPUQHCNVGTPC
VKXGNCPFCPFQTHKPCPEKCNEQORGPUCVKQP
UJQWNF DG RWTUWGF 6JKU KU GURGEKCNN[
VTWGHQTCTGCUQHKTTGRNCEGCDNGDKQFKXGT
UKV[YKVJNKOKVGFFGXGNQROGPVRQVGPVKCN
VJCV CTG KORQTVCPV HQT VJG RWDNKE CPF
ECPPQVDGEQORTQOKUGF+PVJGUGECUGU
EQOCPCIGOGPVECPRTQXKFGQPN[NKOKVGF
VCPIKDNGDGPGHKVUHQTVJGNCPFENCKOCPVU
DGECWUGPQPGVRTQHKVKUIGPGTCVGF
6JG OGVJQFU VJCV YGTG FGXGNQRGF
VQ YQTM QWV VJG IGPGTKE CITGGOGPV
HTCOGYQTMU JGNRGF VJG NCPF ENCKOCPVU
OCMGKPHQTOGFEJQKEGUYKVJKPVJGNGICN
HTCOGYQTM CPF VCKNQT VJG UGVVNGOGPV
QRVKQPUCPFCITGGOGPVUVQVJGKTURGEKHKE
UKVWCVKQPU9JGTGVJGHGCUKDKNKV[QHVJG
EJQUGPNCPFENCKOUGVVNGOGPVQRVKQPKU
FQWDVHWNVJGTGUJQWNFDGHNGZKDKNKV[VQ
TGXKGY VJG CITGGOGPVU CHVGT C EGTVCKP
RGTKQFCPFVJGRQUUKDKNKV[QHQVJGTOQTG
HGCUKDNGCNVGTPCVKXGUX
$KDNKQITCRJ[
$GTMGU ( 0GY CPF PQVUQPGY
FKTGEVKQPU KP VJG WUG QH VJG EQOOQPU
EQOCPCIGOGPV %QOOQP 2TQRGTV[
4GUQWTEG&KIGUVŌ
%CTTWVJGTU,Ŏ5QWVJ#HTKECCYQTNF
KPQPGEQWPVT[ŏNCPFTGUVKVWVKQPKPPCVKQPCN
RCTMU CPF RTQVGEVGF CTGCU %QPUGTXCVKQP
CPF5QEKGV[
Ō
%4.4 4GUVKVWVKQP DTKGſPI UGUUKQP
YKVJ %JKGH .CPF %NCKOU %QOOKUUKQPGT
6JQ\K)YCP[C5GRVGODGT2TGVQTKC5QWVJ
#HTKEC %QOOKUUKQP QP 4GUVKVWVKQP QH
.CPF4KIJVU
&G -QPKPI / /CTCKU / .CPF
TGUVKVWVKQP CPF UGVVNGOGPV QRVKQPU KP
RTQVGEVGFCTGCUKP5QWVJ#HTKEC#HTKECPWU
Ō
5JCEMNGVQP %/ 5JCEMNGVQP 5'
6JGKORQTVCPEGQHPQPVKODGTHQTGUV
RTQFWEVUKPTWTCNNKXGNKJQQFUGEWTKV[CPFCU
UCHGV[PGVU GXKFGPEG HTQO 5QWVJ #HTKEC
5QWVJ #HTKECP ,QWTPCN QH 5EKGPEG Ō
9QNOGT 9 #UJNG[ % 9KNF
TGUQWTEGUOCPCIGOGPVKPUQWVJGTP#HTKEC
RCTVKEKRCVKQPRCTVPGTUJKRUGEQTGIKQPUCPF
TGFKUVTKDWVKQP+&5$WNNGVKP
ŌX
8QDV\OYD9RO