Evidence-Based Reading Instruction Steve Schmidt [email protected] abspd.appstate.edu Agenda 8:30 - 10:00 Understanding the Four Reading Components 10:00 - 10:15 Break 10:15 - 11:45 Diagnostic Assessment, Teaching Alphabetics 11:45 - 12:45 Lunch 12:45 - 2:00 Teaching Fluency 2:00 - 2:15 Break 2:15 - 4:00 Teaching Vocabulary and Comprehension Putting it all Together This course is funded by: Please Make the Packet Your Own! You can find everything from this workshop at: abspd.appstate.edu Look under: Teaching Resources, Evidence Based Reading. This Workshop Will Help You: Understand the four components of reading Understand how to administer diagnostic reading assessments and interpret results Learn strategies for teaching the four reading components Plan reading lessons using direct and explicit instruction Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 1 How does trying to build a house of cards relate to students who struggle with reading? What is Reading? Students have not truly read something until they ___________________________________ When students do not understand what they are reading, our usual solution is to: The problem with this is that students not understanding what they read may be the result of weaknesses in alphabetics, vocabulary, fluency or some combination of these. This is especially true for students at the intermediate level (grade level equivalents 4 to 8.9) The Four Components of Reading Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 2 Alphabetics: The process readers use to identify words Basic Alphabetics Phonemic awareness - The ability to hear, identify, and make individual sounds (phonemes) in spoken words Advanced Alphabetics Syllable patterns – Breaking words into syllables Roots – Examples: rupt, ject, bene Sight word recognition – Knowing words that do not follow regular phonics rules Prefixes – Examples: dis, re, un, in/im/il/ir Suffixes – Examples: ed, ing, ly, s, es Phonics – Mapping speech to print Fluency: The ability to read with efficiency and ease Accuracy – Reading words correctly in text Rate – Reading fast enough to understand text Prosody – Reading in meaningful phrases; pausing to support meaning Vocabulary: The body of words whose meanings a person knows and understands Breadth – How many words you know Depth – How well you know words Comprehension: The process and product of understanding connected text Connecting words to understand an author’s ideas Seeing how an author’s ideas fit with what you already know Recognizing when you do not understand what you are reading Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 3 Results from the Adult Reading Components Study (Strucker and Davidson, 2003) show that for intermediate level students (grade level equivalents 4 to 8.9): Area of Biggest Need Percent of Intermediate Students Vocabulary 30 Alphabetics and Vocabulary 30 Alphabetics and Fluency 15 All Four Components 15 Fluency 10 Most ESOL This is Key: “Failure to comprehend can be the consequence, not necessarily the cause, of a reading problem.” How are the Four Components of Reading Interrelated? 1. As Student A reads, she has to carefully sound out many words in the paragraph. When she finishes the paragraph, she does not understand what she read. __________________ is affecting __________________ 2. As Student B reads a paragraph of 90 words, he has no idea what eight of the words mean. When he finishes the paragraph, he does not understand what he read. __________________ is affecting __________________ 3. As Student C reads, she stumbles over many words and reads very slowly. When she finishes the paragraph, she does not understand what she read. __________________ is affecting __________________ 4. As Student D reads, he struggles pronouncing many words. Because of this, he reads very slowly and his reading is choppy. __________________ is affecting __________________ 5. Create your own example: As Student E ________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ __________________ is affecting __________________ Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 4 Placement tests (TABE/CASAS) only measure silent reading ability and provide a very limited picture of students’ strengths and weaknesses in the four components The good news is that each reading component can be assessed using a diagnostic assessment and each component can be taught! Conducting Diagnostic Assessments Overview Alphabetics Assessment Start at the students’ TABE or CASAS reading level. Student reads aloud words from graded word lists until reaching highest level or gets less than 7 out of 10 correct. Mastery level –grade level of highest list with at least 70% correct. Fluency Assessment Start at the alphabetics mastery level. Student reads aloud graded passages until reaching ninth grade OR the passages become too difficult to continue. Mastery level for fluency is the highest level rated “3”. If student’s mastery level is at or below 4th grade, give phonics assessment. If a student’s mastery level is above 4th grade, look at error patterns. Vocabulary Assessment Start at the level recommended by the test. Mastery level – depending on test, highest-grade level where 75-80% of words are defined correctly. Comprehension Assessment Start at the level recommended by the test. Mastery level – depends on test; if using questions, highest-grade level at which at least 75% answered correctly. Teacher interviews student about what the student reads and the sorts of things they do when they read. To give each assessment, follow the directions in the EBRI Reading Diagnostic Assessments handout Use the Diagnostic Assessment Toolkit provided to assess student in all 4 components of reading and record assessment results on the Student Reading Profile Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 5 Teaching Alphabetics Fundamentals of Effective Instruction Provide rationale and clear explanation (I Do) Model the learning process (I Do) Guided Practice (We Do) Application (You Do) Provide elaborated feedback Explicit Instruction Planning Guide 1. Purpose of Instruction: What am I going to teach? Create outcome based learning objectives. 2. Materials to be used: What do I need to teach this lesson? 3. Introduction: How will I generate interest in this lesson? How will I connect what I am going to teach to students’ prior knowledge? 4. Explanation (I Do): How will I describe the concepts or procedures? 5. Modeling (I Do): What examples/demonstrations will be used? 6. Guided Practice (We Do): How will learning be supported? What will students be doing? What will teacher be doing? 7. Application (You Do): What will students do to show they know what has been taught? How will success be monitored? 8. Assessment: How will you monitor student success? What will students do to prove their understanding? Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 6 Common Prefixes and Suffixes Prefix un* re* in, im, ir, il* Meaning not again not dis* not Example unhappy rewrite inaccurate, impossible, irregular, illegal disagree Suffix s, es* ed* ing* Meaning plural past tense action en, em in enclose, embed non not nonfiction in, im in or into inhale, immerse over too much overpriced forms adverb resembling er, or one who (person) er comparative adj. or adv. ion, tion, ation, state or quality of ition ible, able is able mis sub bad under, below misbehave subzero al, ial y ly* relating to forms adj. or diminutive Example cats, boxes walked singing fatherly teacher, sailor stronger, faster suspicion, caution, ignition, combustible, comfortable maternal chewy, Billy * These 8 prefixes/suffixes account for 97 percent of use in printed school English Syllable Rules When two consonants come together, divide between them When a vowel is followed by a single consonant, try dividing after the vowel o If that does not make sense, divide after the consonant When a word ends in a consonant plus le, divide it before the consonant Each syllable has only one vowel sound, although many syllables have more than one vowel Basic Syllable Types – CLOVER Closed syllables end with a consonant, making the vowel sound short Consonant-le syllables are found at the end of words, making the e silent Open syllables end with a vowel, making the vowel sound long Double vowel syllables contain two vowels that make one sound Silent e syllables end with a vowel-consonant-e, making the vowel sound long R-controlled syllables contain a vowel followed by an r, causing the r to take over the sound of the vowel Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 7 Teaching Fluency Collaborative Oral Reading The teacher selects a longer text/novel to be read aloud in small groups of students near the same instructional level Teacher models fluent reading and each student reads 3-5 lines and then passes the turn to another group member Turns are short so less fluent readers can participate comfortably Teacher and students stop occasionally to briefly discuss the passage. Reader’s Theater The teacher selects a script/play to be read aloud and parts are assigned The students practice for the “performance,” they read, rather than memorize Scripts may have many parts, few parts, and parts that are read by all participants For free scripts, Google: the best class reader’s theater scripts and aaron shep readers theater editions Marked Phrase Boundaries The teacher marks meaningful phrases in the text and models good prosody by reading the marked text The learner practices reading the marked text aloud and gets feedback The learner marks a copy of the same text Eventually, students learn to read the text with no markings Marked Phrase Boundaries Practice “I am happy to join with you today in what will go down in history as the greatest demonstration for freedom in the history of our nation. Five score years ago, a great American, in whose symbolic shadow we stand today, signed the Emancipation Proclamation. This momentous decree came as a great beacon light of hope to millions of Negro slaves who had been seared in the flames of withering injustice. It came as a joyous daybreak to end the long night of their captivity. But one hundred years later, the Negro still is not free. One hundred years later, the life of the Negro is still sadly crippled by the manacles of segregation and the chains of discrimination. One hundred years later, the Negro lives on a lonely island of poverty in the midst of a vast ocean of material prosperity. Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 8 One hundred years later, the Negro is still languished in the corners of American society and finds himself an exile in his own land. And so we've come here today to dramatize a shameful condition. In a sense we've come to our nation's capital to cash a check. When the architects of our republic wrote the magnificent words of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence, they were signing a promissory note to which every American was to fall heir. This note was a promise that all men, yes, black men as well as white men, would be guaranteed the "unalienable Rights" of "Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness." It is obvious today that America has defaulted on this promissory note, insofar as her citizens of color are concerned. Instead of honoring this sacred obligation, America has given the Negro people a bad check, a check which has come back marked ‘insufficient funds.’ “ Source: I Have a Dream Speech, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., 8/27/1963 Repeated Reading: The student . . . . Along with the teacher, sets fluency goals Performs an unpracticed reading with a short text at their instructional level Hears a fluent reading of the text Independently practices reading the text Reads the text for the teacher Monitor Progress: Are students… Pausing at appropriate points in text? Making few repetitions? Making few errors in reading words? Reading with expression, as when speaking? Reading at an appropriate rate? ABSPD Lending Library Visit: abspd.appstate.edu, Teaching Resources, Fluency Request a classroom set of books to borrow for a semester Look at reading levels Return by media mail at end of semester Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 9 Word Tiers Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Basic Abstract Domain (content)-specific Concrete In written language Low occurrences in text In oral vocabulary Across academic areas Examples: Examples: Examples: chair, desk, car, house obvious, complex, establish, verify photosynthesis, radius, quorum Activity: Place each word in the column of the appropriate tier. friend diameter morning concurrent reform annuity precious neurosis accuracy demonstrate meager polygon prosody opinion ultimate tolerate house daughter Methods for Teaching Vocabulary • Rating Chart • Fill-in-the-blanks • Direct instruction • Yes/No/Why • Quadrant charts • Read and Respond • Sentence completions Vocabulary Rating Chart Before introducing new vocabulary words, ask students to rate their knowledge of the meanings of those words. After the words have been introduced, ask students to check their ratings. Were they accurate? Would they change any of their ratings? Why? Once students have had multiple encounters with the words, ask them to rate the words again. Do these ratings differ from their initial ones? Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 10 Vocabulary Knowledge Rating Chart I don’t know this word. Word I’ve heard this word, but I’m not sure what it means. I know this word; it has something to do with… I know the meaning of this word. considerable alter “Quadrant” Chart Vocabulary Word considerable Meaning large enough to be important or have an effect Examples Picture help amount of money effort Sentence: It will take a considerable amount of money for me to go to college. Sample Vocabulary Lessons There are 38 vocabulary lessons that each have five lessons available at: abspd.appstate.edu, Teaching Resources, Evidence Based Reading Instruction When Teaching Vocabulary . . Instruction should be direct and help students apply word meanings in meaningful contexts Instruction should provide students with multiple opportunities to learn new word meanings in many contexts Instruction should increase learners’ awareness of and interest in words Word meanings from prior lessons should be used in activities with new word meanings Students should be encouraged to look for their new vocabulary words outside of class Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 11 Teaching Comprehension Key Point: Teach the reader, not the reading Focus on helping readers understand what they read instead of teaching the content Monitor Comprehension Help students realize when they do not understand what they read (metacognition) Text Marking Strategy Active reading tool that helps students realize when they do not understand what they read ✔ I knew this before ! This is new for me ? I’m not sure what this means Fix Up Strategies Slow down your reading rate It is okay to read difficult parts slowly and speed up on the easier parts. Reread Sometimes it is difficult to understand new information by reading it once. By rereading a few times, you may understand what the author is saying. Continue reading Sometimes the author helps you understand new information by using context clues to define, explain, and give examples. Check your understanding of the vocabulary Use word parts, such as prefixes, suffixes, base words, and root words. Use a dictionary or other reference aid. Use text aids Sometimes authors use maps, charts, graphs, or marginal notes that are easier to understand than the text. Ignore what is difficult and continue reading Especially if what is causing trouble is not critical to understanding and does not involve too much of the text. Ask someone Sometimes others have more experience with the topic you are reading about and can help you understand it. However, don’t get dependent on asking other people. Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 12 Make a connection between the text and your life Connecting your own memories, personal experiences, or background knowledge to the text can help you understand. Retell Think about what you have read and retell or summarize it in your own words. Ask yourself a question and try to answer it Clarify by asking who, what, when, where, how, or why. Visualize Create images in your head to help make sense of what the words are saying. Decide that the difficulties are too frequent or too severe You need to find different reading material. Recognizing Text Structure Understanding how a text is organized can help students connect ideas in the text Recognizing text structure will also help students summarize a text Structure Cause & Effect Problem & Solution Purpose Show the relationship between two causal events, individuals, ideas or actions If…then, If…then, impact, because, as a result, caused, parallels, effect Concerns or problems that need to be solved Problems, concerns, issues, solve, confusion Describe an event, idea, or person For example, about, characteristics, traits, definition, meaning Chronological explanation, steps, order, series First, next, then, finally, following Show differences and/or similarities By comparison, unlike, opposite, on the other hand, differences, similarities Description Time Sequence Compare & Contrast Signal Words Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 13 Activity: Matching Text with Text Structures - Read the paragraphs below and then match each one with its text structure: Cause & Effect Time Sequence Problem & Solution Compare & Contrast Description 1. Even though Arizona and Rhode Island are both states of the U.S., they are strikingly different in many ways. For example, the physical size of each state is different. Arizona is large, whereas Rhode Island is only about a tenth the size. Another difference is in the size of the population of each state. Arizona has about four million people living in it, but Rhode Island has less than one million. In addition, while Arizona is a landlocked state and thus has no seashore, Rhode Island lies on the Atlantic Ocean and does have a significant coastline. 2. Yellowstone National Park lies on a volcanic hot spot. Thus, Yellowstone is well known for its hydrothermal features such as geysers. A geyser is a vent in the earth’s surface that periodically shoots out hot water and steam. As you watch Yellowstone’s most famous geyser, “Old Faithful,” you will see a little steam rising up from the surface most of the time. About every 90 minutes, a huge column of hot water and steam erupts from below the earth’s surface. The water cascades around the vent sending blasts of white steam everywhere. The height of the water column can reach about 150 feet! 3. It was a terrible Caribbean storm and the Columbian destroyer was fighting high waves. Most of the crew, including Luis Velasco, was topside to help keep the cargo tied down. Then the ship was hit broadside by a high wave, the cargo began shifting, breaking loose of its bindings. Until Luis swam to the surface, he didn’t realize that he had fallen overboard along with the cargo. Suddenly, a life raft came into view. Letting go of the crate he had been holding onto, Luis began swimming for the life raft. Finally, he was able to make it to the raft and pull himself in. Luis thought the ship had sent an SOS out on the radio and that rescue would be coming soon. Luis was wrong. Luis survived without food or water on the drifting life raft, eating only a few fish he managed to catch. He was found, half dead, on a deserted beach in northern Columbia. Luis was the only survivor of the eight-crew members who had been washed overboard. 4. I set the bottle of Diet Pepsi® on the ground. I took two Mentos® candies and added them to the Pepsi®. I only had to wait a few seconds as a shower of brown liquid blasted from the bottle. I wonder what chemicals reacted to create this geyser of cola? 5. The war in Europe and America had been a heavy drain upon the treasury of England. Her national debt doubled. The government was very concerned about this issue. It naturally desired to lay upon its American subjects a portion of this burden. The result was a new system of taxation, which the king and his ministers sought to impose upon the colonies. Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 14 Other Points about Teaching Comprehension Teaching comprehension takes time Teaching a small set of strategies well is better than many “one and dones” Select teaching materials at students’ instructional levels Putting It All Together Planning to Teach Use students’ diagnostic assessment results to identify students’ needs Plan lessons based on students’ needs Plan frequent, short (10-20 minute) lessons for each component of reading Develop a class routine and keep the same routine for each class each week Use explicit instruction EBRI Key Points Teach skills appropriate to the learners’ needs Explain why a skill is being taught Use materials at students’ instructional level Model skills being taught Provide opportunities for learners to practice Monitor students’ progress For More Information Consider attending the six- day STAR (STudent Achievement in Reading) training if you teach intermediate level readers Google: ABSPD for vocabulary lessons, the fluency lending library, and much more! Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 15 The Jklasduew The jklasduew, many fear, is doomed to disappear. The little green sprig with the dull. dhqwuet leaves and the round, tsetnmning berries may lose its place at our odjkeysd fjklcsbwp, because it is a cvmprhdkib. It grows and feeds upon trees, and foresters have dhtwrquzn it a cbnjksisdw. Among the ancient wediugn, however, the fcdswtss was the object of special rfdnkplwq when it grew upon an oak. The oak was a zxhmiyjtf tree, and whatever was found growing upon it was regarded as sent from heaven. Thus the lmbtwdcs was called “all-heal,” and was looked upon as tgbnkjmcx for dswbnjmktfk. This fhkinxrbvs gathered the pimtfvghg with great fjdwko. Five days after the new moon of the winder jdmahsd a grand jikkmgdr was formed. The throsidf came first. Then came a kpadhjfb who bore the golden knife for cutting. The priests came next, with the Prince and all the people following. The Prince climbed the tree and cut the vfjdlksd, which was gathered up and dseing to the people. In their houses as a fkeiow and offer of thnkpvfs to bplmkhtcdktsw jiptbvxxws during the season of frost and cold. Customs have changed much since then, but the trimstrbbe still holds a large place in jngtggs and New Year’s jlpgvvuw. We shall be nkpfirf to have it disappear. ______ 1. The people offered cftgbhk to the gods of the woods during (a) summer (b) April (c) winter (d) September ______ 2. We may infer that fgjkl has (a) a pleasant odor (b) kpterw leaves (c) dprjve berries (d) fcnske blossoms ______ 4. The origin of the use of tgbhnkd is (a) recent (b) unknown (c) American (d) a pagan ______ 5. The selection that states that in ancient times the oak was regarded as (a) king of the forest (b) mklphgtly (c) something to be gvdrvhning (d) a shelter from the storm ______ 6. Strvvbnokcf if tge sweefn will cause (a) general rejoicing (b) no concern (c) genuine regret (d) bhmer ______ 7. The plant was cut by the (a) people (b) priests (c) Prince (d) jfdbrest ______ 8. The brcssnplnt was led by the (a) priests (b) poets (c) herald (d) people ______ 9. That vghjkltlr which grew upon an oak was considered (a) god-given (b) wndrfl (c) beautiful (d) bhnkmlner Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 16 Quantum Entanglement Quantum entanglement is a physical phenomenon that occurs when pairs or groups of particles are generated or interact in ways such that the quantum state of each particle cannot be described independently—instead, a quantum state may be given for the system as a whole. Measurements of physical properties such as position, momentum, spin, polarization, etc. performed on entangled particles are found to be appropriately correlated. For example, if a pair of particles is generated in such a way that their total spin is known to be zero, and one particle is found to have clockwise spin on a certain axis, then the spin of the other particle, measured on the same axis, will be found to be counterclockwise; because of the nature of quantum measurement, however, this behavior gives rise to effects that can appear paradoxical: any measurement of a property of a particle can be seen as acting on that particle (e.g. by collapsing a number of superposed states); and in the case of entangled particles, such action must be on the entangled system as a whole. It thus appears that one particle of an entangled pair "knows" what measurement has been performed on the other, and with what outcome, even though there is no known means for such information to be communicated between the particles, which at the time of measurement may be separated by arbitrarily large distances. Such phenomena were the subject of a 1935 paper by Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky, and Nathan Rosen, and several papers by Erwin Schrödinger shortly thereafter, describing what came to be known as the EPR paradox. Einstein and others considered such behavior to be impossible, as it violated the local realist view of causality (Einstein referred to it as "spooky action at a distance"), and argued that the accepted formulation of quantum mechanics must therefore be incomplete. Later, however, the counterintuitive predictions of quantum mechanics were verified experimentally. Experiments have been performed involving measuring the polarization or spin of entangled particles in different directions, which—by producing violations of Bell's inequality—demonstrate statistically that the local realist view cannot be correct. This has been shown to occur even when the measurements are performed more quickly than light could travel between the sites of measurement: there is no lightspeed or slower influence that can pass between the entangled particles. Recent experiments have measured entangled particles within less than one one-hundredth of a percent of the light travel time between them. According to the formalism of quantum theory, the effect of measurement happens instantly. It is not possible, however, to use this effect to transmit classical information at faster-than-light speeds. An entangled system is defined to be one whose quantum state cannot be factored as a product of states of its local constituents (e.g. individual particles). If entangled, one constituent cannot be fully described without considering the other(s). Note that the state of a composite system is always expressible as a sum, or superposition, of products of states of local constituents; it is entangled if this sum necessarily has more than one term. Quantum systems can become entangled through various types of interactions. For some ways in which entanglement may be achieved for experimental purposes, see the section below on methods. Entanglement is broken when the entangled particles decohere through interaction with the environment; for example, when a measurement is made. Source: Wikipedia Evidence Based Reading Instruction Page 17 A Speed Limit Myth Question: Someone told me that driving five to ten miles per hour over the posted speed limit is O.K. Last week a trooper gave me a speeding ticket for driving seven miles over the speed limit. It cost me $103.00! Shouldn’t I have gotten a warning? Answer: Since I am the trooper who gave you the ticket, I’m not sure if you will like my response; but, here it is. A warning is an option, but in your case I thought a ticket was more appropriate. I was patrolling in the right lane at the 70 miles per hour posted speed limit. Your car was in the left lane passing many other vehicles. You were gaining on my squad car at well over the posted limit. Then you passed my fully marked squad car. I clocked you going between 77 and 78 miles per hour. When I stopped you, you said, “Going 75 ain’t nothing.” So why did you receive a speeding ticket, not a warning? There is nothing in Minnesota law that allows a person to exceed the posted speed limit. Speeding is not O.K. for any reason. To issue a ticket to someone who is purposely speeding is within the rules of the Minnesota State Patrol. What more can I say? When you pass my squad car while I’m driving the speed limit, chances are good that I will notice. I hope a ticket will change your mind about speeding. For every 10 miles per hour over 50 miles per hour, our chances of being killed double if we are in a crash. Speed continues to be the main cause of fatal crashes in Minnesota. Source: Reading Skills for Today’s Adults – Marshall Adult Education * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Please join us at Appalachian State University for Institute 2016 Last week of May or First week of June Exact dates to be determined. Reich College of Education Evidence Based Reading Instruction Registration will be open November. Register at www.abspd.appstate.edu. Earn 3 hours of graduate credit. Page 18
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz