Wind Energy Choice Experiment

Wind Energy in Your Community: Choice Experiment
Will Scott & Buddy Reed - EC476 Seminar: The Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity
Introduction
Methods
Why do we care?
Wind energy
produces clean,
renewable energy
for communities
Wind energy only
accounts for 4% of
energy used in the
power sector
Local communities
show resistance
against wind energy
for a variety of
reasons
What can we do?
Create choice
experiment to
survey citizens
Understand
reasons for
resistance against
wind energy
Incentivize
citizens and
communities to
adopt wind
energy
In order to test our research questions, we created a choice
experiment. A choice experiment works by asking survey
respondents to choose between choices A, B, or C, each of
which have different levels of different attributes. By having each
respondent answer multiple questions and having a large number
of respondents, we are able to use their data to determine
consumer preferences.
Results
Conditional Logit and Mixed Logit Regression Results:
46
23%
female
56-65
46-55
94
105
18-25
Respondent Education Distribution
Bachelor's Degree
61
31%
76
38%
Graduate or Professional
Degree
Associate's Degree
27
13%
35
18%
High School Degree (or
equivalent)
Willingness to Pay Results:
Conclusions
Different people have different preferences, and our research
highlights some of these differences.
• The biggest differences in willingness to pay for wind
installations can be found in the different income levels
• Major differences in the importance of
community engagement as well as major
differences in the importance of environmental
precautions exist
• Other significant differences can be found between different
age groups as well as genders
• Researchers collected data on 50,000 home sales among 27
counties in 9 states. The homes were within 10 miles of 67
different wind facilities
• Data spans period before announcement to after construction
• Used OLS and hedonic models to estimate the home-value
impacts of the wind facilities
• Researchers found no statistical evidence that home values
near turbines were affected
Though many of our results are significant, our sample size is
relatively small and generalizations of the U.S population cannot
be made. Our results supplement precious theories that people
are, in general, less willing to accept big, intrusive, and disruptive
wind installments, however the extent of such objections differs
among certain demographic groups.
• This research can be used to help assess which communities
would be most willing to accept the construction of a new wind
farm, thus creating an easier and less expensive permitting
process for renewable energy companies.
“Wind Energy Facilities and Residential Properties: The
Effect of Proximity and View on Sales Prices” Ben Hoen et. all
• Which demographic groups are more or less
likely to oppose wind energy?
37
19%
63
32%
“A Spatial Hedonic Analysis of the Effects of Wind Energy
Facilities on Surrounding Property Values in the United
States” - Ben Hoen et. all
• What incentives can best be used to motivate
local communities and residents to adopt wind
energy?
Over 65
26-35
Literature Review
• Why do people oppose wind facilities in their
local communities?
male
36-45
Use Conditional and Mixed Logit regression
analysis to understand consumer preferences
Research Questions
21
10%
25
13%
How can we do it?
• Researchers investigated 7,500 sales of single-family homes
surrounding 24 existing wind facilities in the United States
• Used four different hedonic models and various tests of
robustness to determine impact of wind facilities on housing
prices
• Results were consistent between models: neither the view of
the wind facility nor the distance of the home to those facilities
is found to have a statistically significant effect on sales prices
Respondent Gender
Distribution
Respondent Age Distribution
7
3%
For our choice experiment, we created 3 different survey versions
with 7 questions per survey. In each survey, there are six
individual questions with the seventh question identical to the
first. This was done because it sometimes takes respondents one
question to understand the process.
To find the appropriate attributes to include in our survey, we
talked to industry executives who had previous experience
working with communities in Maine. The attributes we used and
their respectively levels are listed below:
Respondent Demographics
Discussion
In addition to the questions about attributes, we added
demographic questions to each survey to determine if there were
any recurring themes between subgroups. Below is an example
of a choice question for one of the surveys:
Out of the 199 respondents, we can assume that only 102 of said
respondents were well-informed, having correctly answered a
question hidden in the description of the survey. Looking at the
results above, there are many important findings:
• In the original clogit and mixlogit regressions, all of the
attributes were statistically significant except for benefit
distribution. Out of the five attributes, environmental protection
had the largest coefficient, consistent with our subsequent
regressions.
• For the mixed and conditional logit willingness to pay, the
results between the two are fairly consistent. Noticeably, the
distance attribute is only statistically significant in the
conditional logit willingness to pay test.
• In terms of differences between genders, males are found to
be willing to pay for increased engagement and distance at a
statistically significant level, while both groups are willing to
pay for increased environmental precautions and project size.
• When looking at the difference between respondents over and
under 45 years old, it is interesting to note the different
attributes that are statistically significant. Younger people are
willing to pay for larger projects, while older people are willing
to pay to projects farther away.
References
Hoen, B., R. Wiser, P. Cappers, M. Thayer, and G. Sethi. The
Impact of Wind Power Projects on Residential Property Values in
the United States: A Multi-Site Hedonic Analysis. Lawrence
Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, 2009.
Hoen, B., Wiser, R., Cappers, P., Thayer, M. and Sethi, G.
(2011)Wind Energy Facilities and Residential Properties: The
Effect of Proximity and View on Sales Prices. Journal of Real
Estate Research. 33(3): 279-316.
Acknowledgements
We would like to acknowledge the help we received from
Professor Sahan T. M. Dissanayake in creating this project.
In addition, we would like to thank Matt Kearns, VP of
Business Development at First Wind, for his help.