Cluster Kernels for Semi-Supervised Learning

!"#
$%&' ()*+,]_^S`:a@bc^.0dfeh/2g01435ij17df6km8:lonp9loq?;=ls<?r
>@t4u6Œsvx/7@/2wZ6Žh‘A5ncu“B5’cbc”pu<D•Sy‘CFnz2EHe{–GJ^—Zb}™IK|N˜fšF~6›CMœŸr{žLMvsE RdDš{GNr{žloAP’cnz¡£OQe{kM¢ƒ6R€H 8Sƒ’ŸG=‚ƒ¤;P„š S<D…‡8UTW†qDˆV5DXUnc;ZdDEHyY rM/2[Hd5EH€H>=‰&\ r{vsŠ‹^ƒd~
J¥ ¦&§¨?©Dª¬«¨
­®ebz^r°kskm¯Dnp¶fvouRrM¯HvM€Rufkmr‹^ko^±rM´²t4vhuR^ƒd‹Š²lor{·D³Zruncvs´DgrM^¸lsuls·fnpdf^SlNe{ul¹vs³N¯HuuRvs¯H^ƒuRlonpr²dlsqDkNdDncbzd‹^ƒlor{·Dbcr&rM´+ko^´Dв^ƒrls^ebcncqfdµkmlogrMrMvNvo^ƒdDvsrMr b
loloв·D·Dur@r¸vsr{ºSr¸nc^ybpbpncr{nzg´?dHrMnpkmbpl¹¯~°~0rMloeuƒu‹lot=vs·floqD·D^UоnzºRkxr
u^tlo¯D·Dlo¯D·DrvsrNuRksg^ƒ^r{вehvs·}dDr¸» rMbzbƒ^ƒŠ‹r{^Sb™lo»Zvsnp†¼`¿·f»=ncÀ¬k£`?nckx¯r{^Rvsehnp·Dвncr{r{ºdrFlh´±^ƒbƒvs~:rMkoqDвbplsuk}´D^Rn½t4ko~koncrMdDksy k
Á ÂRà ¨?©DÄ Å£Æ£«¨DÇmÄ Ã
­Èbz^ƒr±r{bce{rMu´:dfkornc`D´D^ƒr{вv,¯Dls·DbcrMr±k¼¯D^ƒvodHuR´°Dbc^‡r{ŠÉbpul¼uƒut£tPkoqDr{dfвbc^npʓHkoqDrMbp¯rFr{´°vsºr{nz`?ko^rMв´µ¯DbcrMbprF^k{vo»@dDncËdDdDyHr&€=³uƒtP·flor{·Dvsr&r°¶fuvhdfkmr°l¼·fkor{^RвknpqfʓkokoqDqf¯^r{bpcvs~Ⱥnzt4kor{rM³ ´
³lo^ƒ·fbc·Dyr{rMuRvsvor±vor°nplo^·flovo·Dвr±r±kDdncÌpbpqD͑cÎxnpŠuR³¼dfkQ^r{v²k²uƒt£uƒ^ƒtx¯D³Z¯fqfr{bpdDncrMbc^´Ï¯fH^ƒlorMyRu+bprrF´Ñ€Ò³Zfr{r{q?Ï`?l‹^¯Hвbc^ƒ^¯DyHrbprMrFbpk‡encdDbzeM^yÈ^ƒkskodÑncn½kQ¶HeMrr±^S`?ls¯Š²npr{uRdf^Rd5´?ko»ncrº†¼r^·Dk‡kmnznck²bcdf^evonzr±k‹yRr°np^Ðl²^l¹vsk‡~rM¯DÓ¯HnzqDue{ncko^vskobrMncDk‡rbp`Dr±·^ƒqfkmввncdf¯D^e{bcd rr
ncŠ‹dRls^r{ehvs·DºncrMdDdRrÐlsnpbcuRrMd5^vo»‡dfÔnpdDncdfyÑe{re{ulsв·Dr{Šd5qf€5dDlon½·Dl¹rM~¿voÖ
r²^ƒ·fd^Rkr{`lsr{r{rMdfdÈkonc^:ºrbcuƒvsl
r{ºuƒnptNrM³ÕncdlouƒrMvot¸rFrk¹l&`?nzt4k¹ulsv&npdDloyÑ·fnclok
rMeh¯f·f^dDvsnc^RÓ´?qDncrFyk°ŠÕeMnp^ƒd®dlo·frr
t4uqfdf´±npdµÌpÍM„UΓ»
loi“ÙxlxncuuS·fd³Z^Rr{eMk¼ºR^ƒHr{dvFrM€Hr{Hdncr¸d+kmrF^:·fk¹lsuS´?np³ Š‹nzksd:^ƒelovsr{rMnp`в´±¯ncr{вdfvs^SncuŠQlsvsnpr¸ºRrMrd^lseMt4^ƒvhebc^ƒqDbcв~‹vh^Sr{lols·f³Zr{^ƒbcu~l vs€?g¿qD~€HdfnprMnp´?l¸bcrM´Dncv£npk&dDey‹dDrMuvmbclhl¸uS^ƒ³Zuncd±r{v¼ºe{npyuuRrMdfqfdD´?kxr{npvhlols^ƒncu±ubcnpdH´D×Fk{^Sr€lolslsrMnpuR·Dvod°Š²r,r{nc´?dDvsrMvsr²e{unc·Dv¸koncuSu̽³ÚÍRd:€DqDt4ØDqDdf€fdfbc…ƒ^ƒe‘ΙÊÊ »
lolo·f·fr{r&ncbckrMrF´0nck¹d?ls´Dt4npuR^ƒŠ‹volsŠ‹^ƒ^¸lo^SuRnculsv@npd°uRrMºd:ur{t}nzd²kls·Dls^r¸·Der£lo´?qf¯rM^e{r{bpncvocko~0t4nprMuReqfd0lZkor{t4gqDbcdDrMdHksuSe‘k¸³ loncÌpbcuÍMrM„Ud}´DΓ»¬y» r ­uƒn½tÛlsls·D·Dur£q?lxncdD^¯DdqD~0lZ^R´?konzkok¹qDlsvoвncD¯?q?lslsnpnpuRuRd5d°€Ü‹n½l¼Ý4loÞ}qfßNvodfe{^kZd‹uRq?·Dl¼r{bclo¯0·f^ƒncd l
³†¼^ƒbc··DyqfnzuRehvokM·!np€àlo·flonzk°uȊ²Š‹kҊ²nc^^k@´Dglorr:·D€xrqfr{kmkm`r:u¯fʓuƒeMbpnz^ƒt£ebcnpqfbplorFbcdD~J´®bc^ásuHev°rMbcqfbpncrFkmв´Ïlor{¯DvZ´Dbcnc^ƒ^e{lsksn½ls^fkmbpqf€¬~RŠQ€£udD¯Dr:lo~ncudDвdfr{rFâ,u´Dk¹ksk‡l±^U~louƒnpuÐt¸dfy
t4louR·flovor®·fЇ^ƒkoqDl@r{bzвl¹^S³Zlon½r±Êju¸koqD^¯Hks¯HuRkmrMnpqfdvoŠQlsºkZnz¯Dkm^ƒrFlovs´Jncur dfbpbcrFnpkMgR^ƒ»µr{vsbcdDË~ncdDdflsuyr
·fuƒt^UºR·DrNnpyRls··Dr£´?ksrM^ƒdfвkon½rxl¹~µebzuR^ksdDkàbp~Rbz»Ñ^ƒãxr{bDdDnput¿lolo·D·DrMrMv²vor ³Znz^Uk@~+^
uƒ¯ft&^ƒlok¹·‹lh^SelouRncdDdDy®dDrFloe‘·Dlonznck‹dDy
^kslsko·DqDr{вŠ#¯?¯flonc^uksdÑkonpdDnzk‡y&lolsu+·DvokouR^UqD~Èy·²ls·fvs^Sr{l²yRnpuRlo·fdfrk
Š‹´?ebzrF^^ƒeksgRnzkokmrMn½nct4k@u~‹d±kor{´?HdHncyuRkmrRnpqDlsä=dfk¼bc´D„¸r^l¼t4vovsqf~0ukZŠåkoe·DuRuRÍRdfqD»=kmbcnz†¼´:´?·frMbcnprvNr¸·f¯Dnc^d:vsudfvsH´?r{^ƒ³ yRDnpvsuRncn½bplodfn lol¹kZ~²rMd°uƒuƒt=t}´?bpncuS·Hy³W^UnplZº´?ncvsdDr{rMyQdfe{uko^npyl¹df´?~n½nc»àlsynpijnpuRlZdd0³ vo^ƒrF·fdf^ƒncb¿eh´:·:³NkmqDuRnpd:vo¯fbz¯HH´0ur{¯fl¹km³NrvouRrMuDr{dDbpd°rMr£Š‹^Qlovsk{„np€rFls^kÒ·Ddflsnc´u k
Í
nckxºr{vs~‹bcuS³¸»
ij^dækskoqDlo·Dвnzk0¯?lo^ncuvmlsd5nce{€Pbpn7rR» r€N»:³ZgrrMvo³ dDnprMbcb£bck¸ko·DkoqfuSeh³ç·È·flo·HuS³ç^Sl¸lslou+·fr0´DrMnpdHkonp´?yRqfdæerFgR´µr{vs´?dDnzr{k¹bzlhk²^ƒdf³ e{·DrQnzehnz·JkkonpЋв^ƒ¯Dbcbcbàr{вt4ur{v,d¯l‹ulsnc·DdlsrÐk¸encbcd+qfkmlolo·fr{rv
ks^ƒŠ²r¸ebcqfk¹lsr{vx^df´±bc^voyRr{vNt4uv ¯uncdRlhk ncd´Dn½è¿r{vsr{dl£ebcqfkmlorMvskM»
olt4=nqDuSpdf~:yReqD¯DlovsncvsrµuudDÍbcäer{qDŠlskx€?rMlse{^²·DnckoncenckxbcuqfgdJkmr{lovst4rMqDdDv dfrMub5edDlonpвncbcu~0d¯D³ bcr{uR·Dв?rMlsd±rM^dRdfnplhdDkrMrFe¯´JrFr{kovokst4^ƒ~ærMvse‘~ls^» bpd~:Ôlo·fr,] ebcqf³ k¹nplslor{·Jv£^Rls·DkokorÐqDвgrM¯?volsdfnpr{uRbd5ä¬ÝmÍFloߑ·f» r´?ËrMdJe{nckolsnc·Duncd k
© à §ÑÇ }à ¨DÇ Ã ¨ « Æ£§R¨ ©ª¬§§Æ x¨DÇmÄ Ã
ij^dÐeMelsuR·DqDnzdk¸l5kmlorF·De‘rNlonct2u^d}e€lP³Zls·frQ^SrlP`?lo¯D·Dbcr¼uvs´Dr‡^ƒls´?^xnpènzk=rMvoerMbcqfdl&k¹lsnzr{´?vsrMrM^R´Ûk&»Puijd‡d_ko·frMuSelo³nculod u±fD€FqD³Zncr@bc´®³ gncbcrMbvo¯fdDvorMuRbck¯Hu³ km·Dr@nz^xeh·Ðt4vslh^^ƒŠ²gr{r‡³Znpdulsvsug
³ ·Dnzeh·qDdDnp¶frMkZls·Dr¸Š²rlo·fu´fk ¯Dvsu¯uRkorM´:npdµÌpÍ͑Î}^df´+Ì FΓ»
68SG=6/7C²\78SE Ñ1 Þ !L P8S"6 ÏE5TP6/7C
i“bcrMl¸^ƒncvsk&dD¯rF´+uRkst4kmvoncuRDŠbcrQlolou·Dr±´?rMqDkodDnpyRbz^ƒd®r{´?bcncrMvs´rMe‘ls´Dbp^S~®lh^D^°»ÑgRr{Ôvsr{dDrMr{yb=rMv:ls^Ì g#SnpÎxdD´?y±r{ncvsdRncºlsu±rM´Ï^Re{kme{qfuehqD·dl&^Ðlog·DrMr²vodfyr{rMbZdDnpr{dævh^S^_lsnpºRw¼r^U~вrFu?kmnz´?^ƒr{d b
·l¹Dko³Zrr®lmuÑlsnpnpddf¯HloyfuRvs»‹u?npd´?Ùxlhqfk°r‹e{rM¯Dk²r{vsbculsu·D¯dD%ruRyRkonpdf$rMkyµ˜?ls™lou±˜fuϕSqH'”´Dkmn½r²&è¿!ž r{ls(*·Dvs)ƒr{r²Ž‘d¡²qDl±•ƒdDe{7bzuœ^ƒ)ƒŠ²ž r{¯bcgrMu´+rMdDvorMdf´DdRr{^Slhb£lhk0^:³ ulo·ft¸uncehlobp·D·rFr®^ƒnzvsk:ŠQdÈ´Dnp^±`rlo¶fвqDdDvsnprFr_`´lsвqDncvsd!u?r‹´?kmuƒrMqfbtNehв·%³ ncu?³Zbp&´?^UrM·f~Ïbck¸^UºRlo^·frÐdf^ƒ´^ l
bcncuSŠQ³ ¯fbp´?rMŠQuƒl‹rMd¯Dlsvs^Su?ls´?npuRqfd‹e‘lFuƒ»Ñt¿lo†¼·f·r£qfek{bc€@qfkmnpdlor{vZlo·D^rkskme{qf^RŠQkmr:¯Dlouƒncut
d5^Ð,» в+xun½`lolsr qDlsvo·fr±^Suƒl@t
ncd‹‰
ls^ƒ·Dqfr£kskme{nz^R^ƒkmdHr k{u€¬t5ls^,·Dnzkmk‡ncdDgRyRr{bpvsr dDвr{bZnp`nzkQlsqD^vsd r
вu?´?r{b™€lo·D.r - œz0 /fšŽ 1RšŽ‘ž¿š” Ì SοnzkN^d0^ƒ¯D¯DvsuU`?npŠ‹^ƒloncud²uƒtÛls·DnckZ]q?lsqf^ƒb¿ijd?t4uRvoŠ‹^ƒloncud‹grMvodfr{b™»
ij³ df·D´?nzrMeh¯H·JrMdfbprF´?^rM´DdRkMls€@bp~Rnc€Zdæ^lodD·DuƒrÐls·DeMr{^v‹kor±r{`ulot
r{dH^Èkmncвudænp`lsuƒqDtvslor·Duƒ2r t,=n‰
cko^ƒ·DqfrMksv‹kmnzg^ƒr{dHvsk±dDrMÝ b346·f58^79kQ4߇r{lor{u+dJlo¯D·fvs:r u¯$ uRko•ƒrMŽ7´Ï œŸžnpd•S”½<œ Ìp;MÍFšh‚F¤ Î
1RšŽ‘ž¿š” ³ ·Dukmr
r{·f^Uºncuv¼nck£kmncвnpbz^ƒv¼lsu‡ls·Dr¸ŠqDloqf^b5npdDt4uvsв^ƒloncud±grMvodDrMb7€
=ÏÝ4>Þ 50?PAß @ C B ܋IÝ HJ Þ}߹܋KÝ HJ ?=ßjÞ L974M F ?AN
ݹÍUß
4EDGF
bc†P‰
r{u,Š^ƒqHqDkodfݟko¶f´?nc^yRrMdfqDvskmkMvolsrµ€N^³ dfÍU´Qߑ·Däµulokm·f‚ƒrr£„R¯f„®^r{qfvs·f^dD^Uвbcº^ncrHulorMvÒrMbpvsurFk²´Jtls·H¯H·D^UruRºnpr±]_dlhlo^ƒk0·DvsrMy·fdJnc^UdfºR^ƒHrbcrMnp×Mr{HrMdrM´Qr{bcd!grM^ƒrMksvovs^ƒdfdDвr{rFb™´Ï¯D€bc³Z³rM´r£nplo´?·!t4vorMuRkoÀNncŠ y]dDrF^+´‹^в¯D^¯Dnp`O‚bcnp£lorFqD´Ê7vslsrÐuSlou+~uƒ¯Dt
lo·fvsl¹urM³ZDkour Ê
¯Ý¹ÍUuߑnc»ædRlhk{†¼»à·Dãxr:d°Ôr{·H^U]Õºncu·fvQ^Rk¬uƒtHrMlor{·Dd²nzk²lsvs´?^rMnpe{dDncrFkonc´QudÑuPd t4qf
dfbce‘^lsHnpuRrMbpdrF´²nzk²¯HuRnpdnpdlsqDlhk¬n½lsqfnpºRkor{npdDbc~µy
ºls·DrMvor£~Ñ]Ðks^^SvolsyRnckmnpt4dH~^ƒnpbcdDnp×MyHrMä°´‡uRgdÑr{vslodD·frMr b
u^dfkskor£qD·fв^¯?dflo´Ûncu€?dѳ ·D^rMdfd0´µdD´?uƒul¼rMr{kdfdDuuƒqDl‡yR·0e{q?bclQ^He{rMbpqHbÛk¹´Dls^Sr{lhvh^,k°nzÝ4kZvsnc^UyºS·^lnpbz^ƒebcDqfbckmrlo€r{npv‘lNߑlh€à^ƒDgqDrFl‡k@ncudd+louQls·D^r°e{e{uuloqD·DdrMlNvlo·f·D^r
dfe´Ûbcqf€=kmlolo·fr{rv
grMvodfr{bnckAQfr`?ncDbcrrMdDuqDyR·‹louQeuR¯Hr³ n½ls·:´?npèrMvorMdlZbz^ƒr{bzk@ncd0ls·Dr
ko^ŠQr&ebcqfkmlor{v
Ý4bcrtŸlxkonc´DrFߑ»
R S <DG=TPE UT<f/4[Ï[68UG=6/
†¼^+·DyrQrMdDgr{rMvhvo^SdDlsrMnpbcºRk&r:¯DвvsrMu?ko´?r{drMb7lsärM´¶Hncvsd_kmlMls€N·Dlor²·DrM¯D~Ïvsr{vsºrMnpuRÓqfqDk&ncvorkmrF^e‘lodæncuqfd®df·fkmqf^U¯HºrrMvoloº·Dnzkmr‹rF´´?vh^UbcrM³ ^fvodf^RnpehdDg:y+ukmtZlor{´?¯}rM¯H€ZrMfdfq?´?l°ncdDвy:uuRvsd r
cnDŠQq?ls¯npuuRvod_ls^³ dnplolobc·È~€=kmnpq dÑ0e^{npbcrMuƒdRll¸u^t eMevoqDrF^ƒvhb¬^e{³Z~u»vs­bc´È·D¯Dr{vsdÈuD^ƒbc¯Dr{¯DŠ‹bc~kM€}npdflsy0·Dr{lo~+·fr‡e{^вdDnpdD`ulsl,qDvsŠQr‡u?u´?tNrM‰
bÒ^ƒls·Dqfr0kskmnznc^ƒdDdH¯Dk£q?l²Š²´?rnclskm·Dlou?vsnp´ Ê
¶fÝ4¯fyRvoqDrFvokmr²rMdRÍRls» rM´®^ƒuSºrFßxlou±vsrM^ƒbà³Zuvsbc´Ð¯DvouRDbcr{Š‹k{€ÛuRdDr²e{^ƒdfdDuƒl
r`?¯rMe‘l
ls·Dr+ámnz´?rM^bcâ°vorFkmqDbpl
uƒt
uƒ³Dut
RncbpvQnc5dR¯flols·Dvor{nzrFvskQrMkmrMkmvol0dRrFl¼^lokol¹u+u³Zd5¶Hu²€¬dfuƒ´ncdæt=lo^ƒe{·DbcbpyrMqHuRбk¹volsnp€fr{lo¶fvs·DnpdfŠ‹dD´±y+k²u^ƒ³ qDdH·Dlx´Ïnz·Dehko·!uSr{³!в´?lsuµn½Êj·Dkor{dDqD~u¯Hl°rM^ƒvovs´?ºrr{nzkm¯vsrFr{r{´µbzdH^S´lsbcrMrM^ƒ´uvsddD^ƒdHnc^+dD´°yfy¯D€ÒrMvslodDrM·Dr{korMvhr{vo^Sdr±lsl£npºR·f^Qr^gk‡ŠQrMvou?dfr{´?r{r{rMbÛdJb7³»W^®·D­Ènzbpehu· rl
r†¼`·DlsrZr{dfŠ‹´D^ƒk,ncdlo·DnzrM´?ŠrM^»nckP†¼ls·fur‹euR¶fвvhk¹¯Dlq?uRlodDrZr‹ls·Dnzk¸r £lo·f'w r°gvh^ƒRdfr{vs´?dDuRr{Š bŠ‹³¼^S^ƒlsbcvog_np`°vsr{Ý4³¯DvsnplorM·kor{lod·Dlhr¼^Slobznc^ƒudÈr{bc¯DrMvs´u^¯dfuR´,korMqf´ÈdDbcnc^d!H̽rMÍRbprF͑Ι´ »
¯uncdRlhksß = @r`?¯}Ý hÞ ®Þ ƒ‚ ßx^df´lsu°ncdRlsr{vs¯Dvsrlnpl¸^k£^0lovh^ƒdfkonploncudŠ‹^Slsvonp`uƒt
^vh^ƒdf´?uRŠ ³¼^ƒbcgÐudµ^yvh^ƒ¯f·®³ nplo·µºRr{volonzerMk
Þ o€à܋Ý4Þ Þ Fß @
NPã tŸlorMv k¹lsr{¯fk
ÞkoÝ4³·Du·floqDu²r{bzvs´±^‡r k¹¯HlhuR^Unznpk,~0dl^bpuSÞ ³¾¯f^n½vskot=^·DloŠQu·fqfr{r{bclo~:´°rMv^Hvolsr¸r
uÓncd°HqDr:npl¹lo³Zr
´?u‹r·Dlsnc´?r{yvsnp·°èŠQrMnpnctPvodDrMrFdRuƒ´fl£lsߑ·:e{€PbploqH¯·Dk¹ur‹lsncr{d¯fvhlsk{vok¼»uRfr{^ƒbcDuncdDbcn½y‡l¹~Ðlou‡utlo·fyr
uncksdD^ƒy:вt4r
vouReŠbcqfkm^lor{v¯u^ncdfd´ l
5rlovh{^ƒl dHkmnploncHudr:loŠ‹·f^Srlsvo´Dnpnc`J^yncuk dH^ƒb@Š‹F = ^ƒlovs^ƒn½`Ñdf´³ ·D^ƒtŸulokmrMr:v r{0bcr{kmвlor{r{¯Hdk0lhkQnpl:^vonzrk°Ü @ @ Ý = F =Èß »Ñh»Ú†¼·fijdÚr:uRÌpÍdD͑r±Î“€ kmlolo·frM¯ r
^³ZƒqDuloqD·DbzuR´_vsk,rQ´DrMlokorMnpŠQyRd+¯Dlo^_rM´®ebzls^u±kskmqHnp¶fMkmr{r‹v¸Ü ³ £·f^Rncehk¸·µ^:qfgRkor{rMvskdD´?r{bànpvsŠ‹rMe^Slolsbc~_vonp`ls·Dt4uRukov,r²^lovh6Ô ^ƒ&dHkm] nplonce{ubcdµM^Rko¯Dkonpvs¶fur{HvF^ƒ»‡DncÙ£bpn uSlonc³NrMrMkMº»r{ËvF€Ûdfnprl
nz­Èk¼r¸dDuƒ³ lxnpbc¯b}uRkoksr{kmr
ncDnpbcdr£kolsrMu0elo´?ncncuvod rFe‘‡lobc~0·fuSqf³¾kor¸^QÜ Š²@u^´Dk n½¶f^QrFgR´±r{ºvsdDr{vhr{kob¿npŠ‹uRd°^Slsuƒvot¬np`:Ü koNnpdfeM^ƒe{r
d±n½Hlxr¸nzk¼qHdDkmrFuƒ´±lxrM^Rºk¼rM^²d:gkor{~vsвdDrMвb7» rlsvonzeƒ»
68SG=6/¼17GPT PXR6T ? <ÈX/ =CMLM68S6TJ8S6>=8U6CF6G¿LM<?LF12EG
uƒdDãxtÛrMdf³lsuƒ·Dlor£vo·frMr{nc¯DdDv£vo¯DrFnzqD´?kmrMlZrFd^‹¯lsulo^Su°nclsdnpuRlsnpвkZd5»km¯Dqfbcfur{ehв·²vxr{lslsd·f·Dl^SnzlZk£lo·D¯H¯DrQuRqfnpvoed¯bclhqfuRk@k¹kolsncrd‹r{€¿v&lou·f^dfksr&rkmqDkse{^ƒŠ²^вdЯ?r£lsqfnpe{uRkobpr,dqfkmlonclouk£rMuRvZlobcu:k£^voehuƒr ·ft@^ƒyRkodDvo¯HuRyRrFqDr¸e‘¯lolovhrM·f^ƒ´²rbàlsevsubcr{qfy¯Dr{kmvslolorM·DrMkovorMr{ncv@ddDlsy_ncd‹^ƒloÝ7lonckmu·frMd rr
³koÌp!ÍqD·DUyÎ?rMyRvot4rMruRkmvÒlls·D^lor£uÈvsr{¯ºlsuvsncncr{^d³£nplsdækNß ^ƒ^®£vskorx´?ncdDnzdfksy&e^SvslslonpqD·DвvhrZ^ƒncdf¶fbcbp^Svh~‡k¹lsl¬np³NºRrMrMr°npbpyR¿bcr{rMed^ƒbcqfºvsdDrFkmloe‘ncdDr{lovsuRy+rMvs´²kP^ƒbcuƒ·Hyt¿^u^
kÒvsnpkmlonc·Dr{вŠÉrMnpd0bz^ƒncvsvsdÏrMn½el¹ls~¸rM·DdŠ‹nclokQbc^ƒ~vslor{¯Dvs¯Dn½vs`ÛvsrM€rMko^&kor{r{dvsdlor{lhrF¯D^S´²vslorMncnpud®kor{d}dÌ »ÑSlsΙ^ƒ»à†¼lo­Ènc·Duncd rk
^ƒbcyuRvonplo·fб€?³ ·fnceh·±vorFkmrMŠDbcrMkZgRr{vsdDr{b5a¼|Zã,€DnzkZlo·Dr
t4uRbpcuS³ ncdDyfä
Í»£´?|Nnzu^ƒŠ²yuR¯Ddfq?^ƒlsb¿r_rMbplsrM·DŠQr rMd• lsk¼žfœŸr{ ncdDy0Š‹„Q^Slsnpvodfnp`Ûkmlo€rF^³ ´±·fncuƒehtZ·¾Ínc» k^ƒd x9w )grMvodfr{b
Š‹^Slovsnp`!Dq?l³ n½ls·
‚?» vo5ruS{³xl k
Ý2uv¼rlo^,·fr,´Dnce^uybcuqDdHв^ƒdfbDkhŠ‹ßZ^Suƒls,t vo=np`²³ ^dfn½ls´·:e´?uRnzdf^ƒk¹yRlsuvodfqH^e‘bDl¼r{lobc·Dr{вr¸Š‹r{d^ƒlhlokÒvsrMn½` Óqf%^bf@ lsu¸loM ·fFrkoqD= Š)uƒM tÛF lo·fr»
D» =npdf´¸lo·DrÒrMnpyRr{dºrFe‘lsuvhk¬Ý 3 FO5 N N!N 5 3 4ƒß¿uƒt Ðe{uvsvorFkm¯udH´?npdfy¼lo·Dr¬¶Hvskml H&r{ncyrMdºU^bpqfrMkM»
Øf» lo†¼u²·D·fr²^UdDºRr{r&³Kbcr{vodfrMyƒ¯Dlovs·±rMkour{dfdrlsä^ƒlo¼ncuÝ4Þd_juß t@@ls·Dr²¯HuR:npdÝ l¸Þ 4 ¼nck‹Ý ß FF 5!N NN N 5 4 ß&^ƒdf´®nzk
dDuvsŠ‹^ƒbcnp×MrM´
DGF
†¼ÔqD·D¯fr¸¯HvsurMkm^Rr¼kmuRls·Dd0r{lovsu0rx^ƒe{uvsrdfkoH‡nz´?e{r{bpqHv¼k¹lsls·Dr{r¸vhk¬¶fnpvhdQk¹lxls·DrMr£npyR´Dr{^ƒdlsº^rFkoe‘rlslÒuvhncd?k@¶fudftPn½lslsr{·Dbcr~,^ t2^ƒ‹dvND^ƒnpl¹¯f~0^vmŠ‹là^St4vslsuvoŠnp`:rFnzk¼^ehls·²·Dr
uƒlst4u·Dbcr{bpvFuS»à³ ËncdDdfyHr »
loue{·f^d®rd‹·Dr{kmuS·Dnc³yuSrM³Ïd³ZºUlor{^·fbcbpbà^ƒqfe{l@r uncHdDd‡df%lsrM·De‘nzÍ,lskÒrM³ e{´^RnpbckmrFb=rR^H€ƒehlorQ·_·fk¹e{r¼lsbpvoqH¶fnzk¹vse‘lskmlsr{l bp~±v
H‡ncbpkMr{rFänckoykxlsrM·Dlod·fr²ºS^^HdÑbpqDr{lmrFͰlokàrMÌ uƒFv¸Î“t»£elou·D†¼dfr·DdD^r,rM‹deºSloD^ƒrMbc´5npqDl¹€H~r‡lsŠ‹·Duƒtàr²^Slolsbc·Dvo^npnzvo`‡kyRr{³ yRv£^ƒncbp¯Ðlof·DH´DrQr¸r{yR¯Íx^r{^¯Ðdfdf´Dnc´ kk
ݳŸlsnc·Dbpr0Hkor вH²^bpºcr{rFv
e‘lslsu·Dvhr k H F W5 N N!ÍMN km5l¸r{4 ncyuRr{vmdls·DºS^ƒubcdDqDuRrUvoߑŠ‹»0^ãxbbzlokouuf€5rF^ncdÈeh·‹lo·Dulor‹·DdDrMvNrM³Kkoqfvsehr{·²¯flovo·frF^ƒkmrMlNdRrFlh^^Sehls·²npuRlod_vh^ƒncdncdDncdD4 y,¯lo·fur{ncdvsrl
nzk¼Š²^¯D¯rM´:lou‹uRdDr
uƒt=lo·Dukmr H°¯HuRnpdlsk£´?r{¯r{df´DnpdDy‹uRd°ls·Dr,ebcqfkmlorMv n½lxr{bcudDykZlouH»
†¼ebc·DqfnzkmklorMkmvoncrFв´:¯D^bpdfr+´±r{`?³N^r¸Š²ko¯DqDbpyr+yRrMkokm·DlNuSls³Õu²lolovh·f^ƒ^ƒncl±d±nc^Qd¾bcnplodD·DrFnz^ƒkvxdDe{r{bc^R³ kokovon½¶HrM¯Dr{v¼vorFukmd±rMdlols·f^Sr¸lsnpвuRd^¯D¯H¯uRrMnp´±dlh¯HkuR^ƒnpdvsr_lhk{»df^ƒloqDvh^ƒbcbp~
"!
(!
#! $ &% +*
,!
)
+*
+*
'
-*
+*
10
/.
32
4
65
7
8 !
(9 :!
<; =!
>9
B 6C D?@C 6% ,?@
? ' A; A?@
E
E
F
I
"F
JI
HG
<;
¨ } Ã
§ ÇmÄ Ã Ä‹¨ « Æ£§R¨ © © Ã
w¼^korM´:ud:lo·Dr¸nz´?rF^k¼uƒt=lo·fr¸¯DvorMºnpuRqfk¼kmrFe‘loncud}€?³Nr¸¯Dvsu¯uRkorlo·Dr
t4uRbpcuS³ npdfy²^bpyRuvsn½ls·DŠä
Í» ¯Hã£uRk¸npdlhrk0t4uRݟvolsrR·D€=nck,e{uloncвв¯Dr‹q?ls³ r²n½lslo··Dr ͋xud®9w %Šlo·D‹r°^S´Dlsncvo^npy` udH= ^ƒb¬t4vs^ƒudfŠ ´ÈdDHuullo·µ„Rß
bz^ƒ^dfr{´bcrM´µ^ƒ€}dHls´®·Dr°qf´?dDnzbc^ƒ^yRHurMdfbprF^´ b
Š‹^Slovsnp`°³ ·DuRkor
r{bcr{вF r{dlhk ^ƒvsrF ls·Dr,koqDŠçut}lo·fr¸vouS³xkZuƒt>=Ñ»
‚?»£|Nuв¯Dq?lsr %@ M = M ^ƒdH´°nplsk rMnpyRr{df´DrMeuRв¯Hukmnploncud @
L »
D»x‰&npºRr{dQ^£lsvs^dfkmt4r{vPt4qDdfe‘lsnpuRd N€bpr{l @ ¼Ý ߝ€³ ·DrMvorNlo·Dr ^ƒvsrÒls·Dr¼r{ncyr{dºS^ƒbcqDrFk
uƒt x€f^df´:e{udfkmlovsqfel @ L »
Øf» 5r{l HrZ^x´?nz^ƒyRudf^bSв^ƒlovsn½`
³ nplo· @Í ^df´¸euRŠQ¯fq?lor = @ F F »
†¼·Dr¸dDrM³%gRr{vsdDr{bۊ‹^Slsvonp`°nzk =µ » n½è¿r{vsr{dl lsvs^dfk¹t4rMv¼t4qDdfeloncudbprF^´°lou0´?npè¿r{vsr{dl gr{vsdDrMbckMä
17GP6<?8 ZÝ ß @ »ijdlo·fnck
e{^Rkmr @ !^ƒdf´ @ Ý2konpdHer,ls·Dr‡´Dnc^yudH^ƒb5rMbprMŠQrMdlskuƒt
=É^ƒvsrQÍUߑ»ài“l loqfvodfkxuq?l¼lo·H^Sl = @ = ^df´:dDuQlovh^ƒdfkmt4uvsŠ‹^Sloncud:nckx¯HrMvmt4uRvoвrM´5»
V5LM6> ZÝ bc^'ßvoyR@rMkmlÍxrMnpt npyRr{dºS^ƒbcqD r‡u^ƒtdf´²£„¸€¿lou·DlorM·Dd_rMvols³ ·Dnzr‹kordD»=r{i“³ t gr{ vsdDnzrMk@b=ehŠ‹·fuR^ƒkolor{vsdQn½` lou,= nzrxk£rFlsÓR·DqHr‹^ƒ´?b?uƒlsu¸l¸lo¯D·Dvsr u?´?HqfÊ7lse· l
Š‹^Slovsnp`°npd±ls·Dr¸vorM¯DvsrMkor{dls^ƒloncud°utZÌ UÎP´DrMksevsnprM´:npd±ls·Dr¸¯Dvsr{ºnpuRqfk¼kmrFe‘lsnpuRd5»
17GP6<?8 hC{LF6R> Ô?^вrQ^Rkxls·DrQkmlorM¯Ðt4qDdHe‘loncud}€5Dq?l
³ n½ls· ¼Ý ß @ t4uv »¸†¼·Dnzk&nck
loloe·DncbcuuRr‡d0kor{kmŠ‹bc¯f~^R^ƒevolor
rMvsbcn½^ƒy` loncºçrFrM´Ðd^lsdfu:´~°ls·Dçlo ·Dr‹r
³N^ƒ¶H¯DrMvovs¯frxkmvol urF^
Óehqfr{·®^ƒvsbHdDe{lor{uu‡bPdfaZkolonz·D|Zk¹rlsãnpncdD´Dy±er{uRdncвd®lonpl¹¯HD~uRqf€?dDnpbzr{´?uƒdnclslsdD·°kyÐ^ƒÌ UÎ^±¯D“¯fäÒbpncvonpdDutàrM^lo^eh·Dv¸·Dr,rFedfkÒbz^u³ZksvskmuвnpqD¶f^bzr{´‹bpv
nc×Mnc^ƒd r Ê
nc´?´Dncr{dfd^SlolsnzrMe{k
^b7uƒ»¬tNijlodf·D´Dr²r{rMls´5vs^€Dnpn½dft=nplodD·fyr¸¯r{uncyncdr{lsdHk
´?rMncd®e{ulsв·Dr²¯HugkmrMnpvolodDncurMd:bÒuƒaZ>t |Z= ã#ncvsk r{¯D= vsrM@!kor{dls
^ƒlo ncuL dȀ?^ƒlo·fvsr‡r,yRenpuºRur{vod Ê
~‹lo·Dr¸Š‹^ƒlovsn½`"#
F »
$ E/ ? G=E Ñ12F <D/ ¼F Ý ß @ F h» F F ijd ls·Dnzk e{^RkmrR€ @ F
^ƒdf´ = @
Ý
M =Èß M » †¼·DrՊ‹^Slsvonp` M = nckKls·DrÕlovh^ƒdfkonploncud
Š‹¯Dvs^SrlolovsrFnp´+`È^ncdµk,^lo·fdDr°uRvhvo^ƒŠ‹df^´?bpuRnc×{Š rF´®³¼^^ƒdfbcgÈ´+´Dkm~rMвkseŠ²vsnprlorMvs´+nc×{ncrMdÏ´ÈkoºRrMr{e‘vhlskmnpncuRudÏdȂ?uƒ» tZ‚lo^ƒ·DdHr0´ lovh= ^ƒ dfe{kon½^lsdµnpuRd+Hr:вnpd^ƒlolsvsr{n½vo` Ê
euRvovsrMko¯HuRdf´?ncdDy‡lou‹^ ZkmlorM¯±vh^ƒdH´?uŠ ³¼^ƒbcg¿»
†¼‚?» ·D‚&nz^ƒk&dfв´Q^^
grFbcnpk dDrFlo·f^ƒvÒrQe{e{bcu^RdDkokodDn½rF¶He‘r{lsv=npuRlodÐvh^ƒHncdDr{rMl¹´‡³NrMncd²r{d_^¸loko·D¯frQ^RencrZ´DrMnpdf^0´DuqftÒelorF·f´²r‡vh~^ƒr{dfnp´Dlo·DuŠrMv¬lo³Z·D^rxbpgko¯grMrMe‘volsdfvs^r{b=bDeuƒbct@qfkokmrMlor{e‘lsvsnpncuRdDdy
^ƒbcyuRvonplo·fŠ uƒt Ì SÎ5uv¼lo·fr%
r{vsdDr{b5a¼|ZãW^bpyRuvsn½ls·DŠ»
lo³& ·f·D6Er{nz~
T eh·°^ƒvsLFnzrÒk¼E!^ƒebz;=ukmв<DuxGPв´?T=vhu^U/2df6ϳ bpd&~‹LM6t4Š‹voCMuRL±^Š%´D>NrFlsߑEH·D€17rNG¿ls·DksLM^ƒr{C d:вrÒloi“·Dt¼´?rMnzlo~0kmrFlok¹vskml,·fnpDu¯qDqDulobzncnc´0dulsd,k,r¸^^k5evolour‹·DdHrÒ^UkmºSnzlo´?^ƒvhr{^ƒncbcvsnc^dDrMD´°npdfbcr²^yxkZ´D¯HqDqDuRvodDnpdncbzdD^ƒlhy±k@r{Ý2lo^bcvhrMd,^ƒ´°nc^dD¯HksncdDkmuRqfnpyÐdŠQls^ƒk¼¯DdHlo^´®ncdfunpd´ t
lo¯·fur0ncdRŠ‹lhk{^S» lovsnp` = ´DrMksevsnprM´µ^HuSºRr²ko·DuRqDbc´+r°fqDnpb l‡qHkmncdDylovh^ƒncdDncdDyf€=qDdDbz^ƒr{bcrM´Ï^ƒdf´ÈlsrMkml
Ùx^xuS¯f³ZvouRr{DºRbpr{rMvFŠ€ƒnp€ƒl@kmвncdfnpeyRrN·RulNqD·fv=^ƒŠ²¯D¯rlsr{·Dd²u?ls´,·f¯D^Sl@vsu?lo´?rMkmqflNerF¯kPu^£ncddDlskÒr{³Ï^vogr r{dfvsdDuƒlNrMbR^UŠ‹ºS^ƒ^Snclsbz^ƒvonpD`Ûbc€UrxD´?q?qDlàvsdDnpdfuƒy
l¬lo^ƒvhd^ƒnc^dDdfnp^ƒdfbcyf~»àlonz†¼e¬·Dt4uRnck@voŠ nck
louƒe·fuRtàncŠlsk ·DDeMr,nc^dfrko^ƒrè¿lo€rMncu³Nelod+r
ncºuƒ¯Dr¸t¼vsudDlo¯rM·f³uRr‹korxlogvhr{ls^ƒvs·DncdDdDr
rMncbÛdDt4uy_lobc·fbcuS^ƒ^ƒ³ dHl´®npedDuRyQqfqDdDkmbz´:bcuR^bpHqDvsrMrMlo^RncbpurF´?d5´µncbpä¬~:¯^ƒuH¯fncr,¯DdRlhvorMk{uUºS€à`?^ƒnc^ƒbcŠ‹qfdH^S^S´+lslorMr&qf´±km^‡r0ulodlorM·DkmdDlnzkuS¯HºR^uRr{¯DnpbÛd¯Dlsl vsrMuUkmÞ®`l£nc^R¯HŠ‹k¼uR^Snp^‡lsdnplhbcuRnck{dDd_»ZrMijls^du v
t4rrM`?^ƒ¯DlovsqDrMvsksr¸k¸kmls¯H·D^r±erRvo»¬rFÓR]qfnpuvsvsrMr
´µ¯D´?vourFelQnzkm¯frMvobpu?~R€?´?bpqfr{el l‡rl¹³Zr{rMdµlo·Dr:lorFk¹lQ¯HuRnpdl‹^ƒdf´Ñuƒlo·fr{vQ¯HuRnpdlsk‡ncdÑlo·fr
*
*
'( @!^voyҊ²) ncd *** +&Ý4Þ}ß -,/C .0D ,/F-1 2 +&Ý4Þ ß *** @= M F 3
*
*
(
9
A;
!
9
8
A;
!
H!
#9
:B
B
9
! /
!
B
9
B
*
9
! <; 9 ! A; !
E 9 /
7!
*
9
B
!
!
<;
B
! <; ! <; ,!
*
*
-*-!
9
A; ! A;
!
9*
0.5
Linear (Normal SVM)
Polynomial
Step
Poly−step
0.45
0.4
Test error
0.35
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
2
4
8
16
32
Nb of labeled points
64
128
4tt4=nvsqDpudfyRŠeqDlovsnc‚Zr°ulodf‚?u‡kMä²» ÍF†}‚/¼rrFk¹{l`D^ƒrMvoвvsu¯Dv
bcrMuRkMdÑ»P†¼^·Dlor@r{´D`n½lQè¿r{evsbz^r{ksdkmlPnp¶HgRe{r{^ƒvsdDloncr{ubzd+k}e{¯DuvsvsuvoDrFkmbcr{¯Š udHt4´xulsv¸uls´?vs^npènpdfrMnpvodDrMy®dlPkmgr{npl‡dH´
kmnc×{uƒr‹t?loºSvh^^ƒvodH~k¹nct4dDrMy v
³Ý +&nploÝ2· Þ}ß +&@ Ý2Þ=Ï ßmÝ2ߑÞ>»Ò5m†¼Þ ·fß rF »=dDÙ£rM³¾r{vs´?r€u+ÈlZ¯fnzk5vou?ls´?·DqfrNet4lZrM^SlsrqDl¹vs³Zr@r{Š‹rMd0^ƒ¯ls·De{r&uvslovorMrFkmkml ¯¯HuuRdHnp´?dnpl¼dfyÞ®lo^u df=Ñ´‹ls€U·Dn7» rr»cu€Olo=Ï·DrMÝ2v¼Þ>5m¯HÞ uR npß dls@ k
nzk¼r`?¯DvsrMkskmrF´:^Rk ^‡bcncdDrM^vxeuЇDncdf^SlsnpuRd:ut}lo·fr,´?uƒlx¯Dvsu?´?qfeF lsk¼uƒt =µ €
= Ý4>Þ 5oÞ ß Ý = '( ß @ Ý = = M 3 ß N
+xulor²ls·f^Sl¸t4uRv,^:bcncdDrM^v
lovh^ƒdfkmt4r{v&t4qDdfeloncud5€ = @ =р}^df´_lo·Dr‹dDrM³#´Duƒl,¯Dvsu?´?qfe‘l¸nzk
lo·fr
kmls^ƒdH´D^ƒvh´°uRdDr»
©HÇ }Ã ¨D§
G G ,P6G=X6®EH\¼LF;P6LM8S<DGPCF\“68:\ PG=XƒLF12EG
­ÈÌpÍ͑rΓ€Û^ƒ¯ft4u¯DbcbpbcncuSrM³ ´‹npdDlo·Dy:r&lo´?·fn½r²è¿r{ks^ƒvsr{вdrQlZgrr{`?vs¯dDr{rMvsbHnpвebcr{qfdkmlhlo^ƒrMvsbàk@¯Duƒvst}uƒlokou?rMe‘e{lsunpb™uR»d †¼
·Dlsr{u,vsr²lo·f^ƒrxvsr,lor{l¹`³ZlZu±ebzeM^^SkslokorMn½y¶HuReMvo^SnclsrMnpkuRd²ls^0kogQ^dfuƒ´ t
³ n½ls·vorFkm¯rMeloncºrMbp~"# /²^df´2#…fÍ&r{`D^ƒŠ²¯DbcrMk ut¬´Dnpвr{dHkmncud® ?ÍÍR»@†¼·Dr,³ nz´ls·uƒt
lo³Z·fr{r vsr,xls9w ^g¾grMd_r{^Uvs³ZdDrM^UbÒ~°³Zlou:^Rk,t4uehvs·DŠ ukmrMlod+·Dr‡^Rlok,rFk¹ncd!l¸km̽r{ÍRlM͑»Î¼Ëyncq?ºl
ncdDuƒy t¬ls·D@r‡vs„ r{NŠ‹ D^»npdDncËdDq?y:l‡¯HuƒuRtxnpd^ƒlsbckMb@€5r{‚²`?^lsu®Š²¯DÍUbp/‚ rF‹³k{,€ Z# r{vsr
vh^ƒ^ƒvsr‹df´?¯DuRvsвrMkobpr{~±dlokmrMrFbp´+rFe‘nplodÑrF´±¶fyloqDu‹vsr:r‚bz^ƒ^dfr{´µbcrM^U´º^rMdfvs^´:yrFlo·D´_r‡uSuƒºRlor{·fv‹r{ÍMvx„R¯„uncvsd^lsdfkx´?vsuRr{Š Š‹^konpr{dDbcrMrFe´±loncqDudDdfbzk^ƒuƒr{t¼bcrMlo·D´Ûr:» bc^rFHkmrMqDbpbprFls´ k
rÔ6`D&^]_ŠQߑ¯f€&bprF%(k{'»+ )*†¼',·D+-r: "*t4u bc¼bpuSÝ ³ ßAncdD@ yÐ&lsvs. ^€*df/1km01%t4r{v‡gRt4r{qDr{df¯fe‘nplsdDnpyuRdfukQdDbc³N~rMlsvo·Dr:r3e2 uв+¯fÍF^„
vorF³ ´Û·Dä r{vs r4!2#"nc$
kÒÝ2lon7·D» rr»ÑdqDkmlsŠ^df´Dr{vN^ƒvhuƒ´ t
bz^ƒr{bcrM´²¯uncdRlhk{€^ƒdH5´ %(', )#67/101%´?r{¶fdDrM´0npd²ls·Dr t4ubcbcuS³ npdDy¸³¼^U~°Ý2³ n½ls·ÐÍ F N N!Nsߑ€
<>= 2 ÍF„
¼Ý ß @98;: <>? 2 ÍF„
ncºDudRrMRlsvovNr{~&vsbzrM^ƒ³Zkmvsr{loybcncr&b7dD»ày‡km†¼nc×{eM·DrF^k@r@kor&u¯t5^uvobclo~r&·fdDr²kmuŠ‹Ý2вbc^^nzbpH^ƒHbRrMlobplovhrFvh^ƒ´f^ƒncßÒdDdfnckmlodDt4vhr{yQ^ƒvPnckodDt4rqDnplhdfdfk{y‡e»¬lokoÙ£ncrulMr{dQ€Dvsr´?^€bpu¿lorM·D^ƒkP¯f@r dD¯D/1uƒvo01làu%y,^ncehº^ƒ·DrÒdfrFA´yRkÒuyR%(unp'ºR´, r)vo6BkorF/Cnpkm01вqD(%&bpnclsbc^k}t4qDvNt4dfuvsv=e‘rMlskoºnpqDuRrMbpvodfls~
kMk¼»àko³Zв†¼u^·fvsbpgr
lo†¼vh·D^ƒnznckZdDncŠQdDyncykm·r{l¼lsk‹Hr
Ý4f´?q?qDl,r&dDlsr{u,ºRlor{·fvorlo·Dt2rM^Rbpe‘rFlZkok&lo·fuR^ƒq?lZlo¯ncd0r{volst4·Dunzvsk¼Š‹rk&`D^ƒlo·Dвr‹¯Dkmbcrls^ƒ€dHlo·f´Dr&^ƒvhko´®rMe{6Ô u&df´°] bc^t4vouyRv¸rMвkml@rMr{´?ncyncqDrMŠ dºS^kobpncqD×{rMrkhncߑk »
„D» „O¸ÝŸls·DrNbz^ƒvsyrFk¹lPnckP~
e{udfkmlovsqfeloncud‹ÍFߝ»=Ôncdfe{r@ls·Dr@¯ubc~dDuвnz^ƒbRlovh^ƒdfkmt4r{v}t4qDdfe‘lsnpuRd,lsr{df´Dk
? (
8
@B
B
F
)F
)F
D7EGFHJIKMLONQPFSRUTMFSR1F>V#KXW>YUZ\[!F]R1K*FJ^*V#K_P@`aI#Rb1T*NcLR1FdVeLOIKXb1T*FfgVhbOR1Nci-jkNcLlV#^nmoVJpLUNcK(q!FSROb1Ncr*^cFs
louu
dfrM¯DâqHkm^ƒ·‡dHlo´+u
n½„lQlonc·Dkr ŠQkouRвvo^r:bp´?rMn 0enpyRr{{dqDºSb½l‡^ƒbcloqDuÐrMkMbc€SrM^n½l¬vod+lsqD³vsdfnplok=·Ïuq?kolàqfehlo·Ñ·H^S^làlogR·Dr{r¼vsdDdDr{rMb™³Ï»gR†}r{u_vsdD^Ur{ºRbu·fnz´®^Rkloáo·Dvsnz^kdD¯fg,vouR^ƒbcDвbprMuRŠkml €
lodD·frMr,npyR^ƒ·q?lsu·Dv¸ur{vh`Dk¼^ƒuƒŠ²t ¯D̽ÍRbcrM͑ÎPkM»°e{uijdfdÈkonclo´D·Dr{nzvxk,^‹³¼ko^U¯f~^ƒlsvh·Dkmr
r0^ ´D‹d^SlhD^npl¹~°^ƒvsŠ‹r²^ƒlo~Èvsn½e`°uR³dfk¹nplslovo·qHdfe‘louncd?uʓd+×{rMвvouukNvsr‹rMdelobcvsqfnpkmrFlok¼r{vsurMdD´+bc~0^t4dfuR´ v
lot4qD·fdfr&erMlonpncyRur{ddºSyR^ƒ^UbcºRqDrrMk¼r^lovolor&rMvxbc^vovorFyRkmr{qfvFb½»}lhk¼­È³ r
·Dºr{r{dvsnp^ƒ¶f¯frM¯D´°bpncrrM`?´°¯HlorMu0voncв^²r{ko¯fdls^ƒ^vhbpkocr&~‹^ ls²d·f^Sfl¼n½l¹lo~:·fr&в¯^ƒulovsbc~n½`ÛdD» uвnz^ƒblovh^ƒdHk¹t4rMv
lobz|N^Su°ulmlsdHlor{·DevZrQr{vsnckZddDqDncbcdDnpŠdfyrM^ƒlor{·fvZv&r±ncuƒd0t@kmlolo´DrM·fnp¯+r&вvslor{r{vhdH¯f^ƒkmdfvoncrFukmkmt4dfr{rMkvdRlhnct4dÐ^SqDlsdfnplouRe‘·fd‹lsr,npuRyt4d5rMncº^ƒ€àr{lolod°qD·fvsr°r‡~QºSko¯fls^ƒ·Dbc^RqDr
er°rr{ncuncydft¼r{´?dHloqH·D´?errMrMe{´_euq?вlo~:ʙ¯Huuèlskm·DnprnclodfncugR´?d‹r{r{vs`µudDt5r{e{b™lou€Û·fvskmr&voncrFdf^ kme{¯²dr,ufdHlon½·f´Dl¹~ rk
loŠ‹rM·fÓ^Sr0qfls^vodb¿npqD`ÛloŠ»=u ij2 dr{lsv,qDn½ulsÍFt¼np„DºRlo» r{vhbc^ƒ~nc€DdDnpnplxdfyŠ‹^ƒr`DgRrM^ƒk¼Š²km¯DrMbcdfrMkokMr€5lsls·fu²^S·fl^Unzºk
r&lslo·D·fr0r¸vsdrMqf^ŠkoudÈr{v ³ uƒ·tà~_´?³ZncŠQr0rMehdf·DkouRnpuRkodfr0k¼^npdHeeqDvslorMuƒ^èækor
npdH³ ´?n½rls·`
vlos†¼uu·DqDrbzyR^ƒ·5%(vsy',ä}rQ ls)#·D67r{/1r
nc01y%korM@ÓdqflsºSvs^^^vobpqDdfrrFk¹vot4k²urMvÛuƒÝ4vslZt4rMqDloe{dfrM^edfbploà´DnculskN·fd,lo^SuQnzl¸k}¯Dkolsq?u·Dlвr{~®Š²rM³ ^ƒuvsvs·frQr£^Sl}nckoвЋkonp¯Hв^ƒuRbcncbpvmbcrMlh^v
^ƒv5dflols·fe{u r£^lod·DuRd:rZÍUß
k¹´?lsnc^ƒr{в¯
dfr{´_t4dfqDlokodH·Dnpe‘uRr‹lodfncuk¼ksÓd}eqf€SuR^ƒDvovsvsq?rQrMl}kot4¯HnzqDk}uRdfdfdfe‘uƒ´?lslPnpncuRdD^Rdy k
lovsrMrMdfkoqD´Db½kÒlhk{lo» u,´?nzkoeM^ƒvh´²euв¯udDrMdlsk¬³ nplo·0koŠ‹^ƒbcbfr{ncyrMdºU^bpqfrMkM»P†¼·Dnzk¬Š²rls·Du?´0^eh·Dncr{ºRrMk=ls·DrxrMkml
GR }LFE Ï<?LM17X:CF6/26XƒLF12EGæE\ LF;P6LM8U<fGPCF\“6R8±\ PG=XƒLF12EG
lolo†¼·f·f·DrxrQrQnpbzd^ƒehls·DvsqDyun½rFnzlsek¹npl&r¸uRd²r{unct¬loy·florM·D^ƒdlN5rºS^в%(bpqD'urF vs)k‡r 6B/Cr{Ý401loв(%·D¯DrM~_ls·Hvs^^^ƒkodfvsncrkÒkmt4koqHr{·Dv kmuRr{t4qDt4qDqDbcdH´Qbàe‘t4louncr£uv¸d_¯DeqDbcnpqfdl@kmulolsrMd²·Dv
rls´D·D¯fncr£ksvoerM´?vsºncnpвncвuqHr{ncdfdfk£^SkoehnplsuR·DnpuRdfuRdHkÒnce{ße{ru^ƒevsdfuRvo´®rFvokmvsbp¯rMrFkouko¯Hdfk&uR´DuRdfnpdÐdD´Dy&kZlo·flslsuur
y´?rMncвdDr{r{vhdf^ƒkobnpuRt4uRdfvokxŠ ³ unplotP·®ls·DkmŠ‹nzk¼^ƒlobcvhb5^ƒrMdfnpkmyRt4r{r{dv¼ºSt4^ƒqfbcdfqDe‘rMlsk,npuRÝ7d±euRnzvok vsrMko¯HuRdf´?ncdDy²lou°npdlovh^SÊjebcqfkmlorMv£´?ncvorFe‘loncudHksߝ»¼†¼·fr
ZÝ ß @ 8 B << =? 5
Ý7‚Rß
³Óqf·D^ƒrMbcvonprls^Slsnp5ºRr{bc~!kou^ƒŠ²dfr ´ ºS ^ƒbcqDrM
!kàt4^ƒuRvsvàr lo·DrF·km~r£¯¯fr{^ƒvs¯fvh^ƒ^вvs^rŠQlsr{r{vhlok{rM€SvsfkMq?»Pl@ãnzk@´?rM^rbpt4cuR~vo€RrRu€dDnpl¼r¼nc³ZkZu¯qDuRbz´QkskmncbpDncgbcrxrx^
louQвehr·Dlsu·DuRu?ko´ r
³ud‹·Dnz^ehdQ·‹rF^ƒk¹q?lslsnpŠ‹uŠ‹^ƒlo^Sr lsncuƒeMt^ƒlobcbp·f~Qrxehy·DrMudDuRr{kovhrM^ƒkàbcnpy×Fu^Su?lsnp´QuRdºS^ƒr{bcvsqDvsrMukMvx»PÌ i“‚FlNΙ»¬nck¬†P¯u,uR^kskoksnpkmDrFbckor¼kPlolsu‡·Drx´?u,¯uRkmksu¸kmncD~‡ncbpnyl¹vh~^´?utncr{rFdk¹lÒlsnp´?Š‹rM^SkselsrMnpdfdy l
rloM^·fkmeMlorencqDŠ‹dvhqD^S^SŠlslsr0r{bc~
Ì r{‚Fv&loÎP·Dnpuƒd±r¼t¬lslolsrM·fvskm^r,lÒnpdfkor{^npvsdDvoŠQy:uRr¸v¬¯H^kouRrksnpkmlodu?lolhncedDkxnzy‹^Slslsu_^rMk¼´ÍM…_nc³ d:n½Ý lsls0¯·‡·Dr¸lsr{·D¯Dv
-r vser{%(bzº'^ncksu)khqf67ߑ/1k »01(%ko†¼rMxe·fgRlor‡r{ncuvskod5dD¯fr{»à^ƒb™d­È€S³ZrFr
rxk¹ls¶Denp`?Š‹urMв^S´ls¯Dr‡qD^lo@rMdf´‡´.ls@%lo·D·fr ‚Qrkmls¯f^rMdf^kmd´ l
r{vsvsuv ^ƒvsr¯fbpulmlorF´±ud±lo·Dr
bcrtŸlkonz´?r
uƒt=¶fyqDvs.r D»
loãxvsdfqDuƒŠ lo·fuƒr{t}v
ls¯H·Dur¸kogkoncrMDvonpdfbcnpr{l¹bÛ~±Š‹³Z^Sulsqfvonpbc`°´_ncHd±r‡uRlovsu:´Dr{rvZ`?lo¯Du‹bcu¯DvsrvsrMв´DncrelslZ·Dlsu?·D´Dr
klolorF·fk¹lx^ƒlrMvolhvs^ƒugv¸rQÌ ncMdRΓls» u:^Re{euRqDdl£ls·DrQko¯rMe‘Ê
9‡E µ>à<?8S12CFEHG T‹14LM;EHLM;=68°<D/ HEH8S14LM; ÑC
G
lo­Èvh^ƒrncdDkorFqD´°Š²uRŠ‹dÈ^ƒÍFvsnp…×MrMbz^ƒ´Ñlor{·DbcrMr:´±lor{rF`?k¹l‹^вr{vs¯DvsbpurFvhk¼k°npd±Ý2^UlsºR·Dr{r
vh^ƒt4yRurMbcbp´+uS³ uSncºdDrMy‡v:lsÍF^„D„ÐbprRlo» vsnc^bckhß,ut´?npèrMvorMdl²^bpyRuvsn½ls·DŠ‹k
+xuRvoŠ‹^ƒb}Ô ] †Pvs^dfks´?qfe‘lsnpºRr
Ô ] Ì ØSÎ £^ƒdf´?uRŠ ³¼^ƒbcg_̽ÍR͑Π|NbpqfkmlorMv grMvodDrMb
‚R?» Ý #ƒß Í D» … ÕÝ ‚?» ß
Í ?» ÍF‚?» … åÝ D» ß
†¼^ƒdH·D´ÐrNloqDvhdD^ƒbzdf^ƒks´?r{qfbcrMe´5lonc»,ºrN†}Ôukm]uRв^ƒrbcyru`vslsnpr{lod·Dl&Šnpl
euRnpвdfkm¯Dnzkmbclsr{kPвnpr{d‡dвlhk¸^ƒ`?^ƒbznpkmвu°nc×{lonc·DdDr²yxelsbc·DqfrNkmloŠ‹r{v
^vo^yRksnpkod,qDuRвd,¯?loncuƒulodÈ·‡kmbc^ncdfHerMrQbprFnp´ l
lokorMqfdfe{´De{rMkxkslok¹t4u‹qD¯Dbcbcq?~²l£^lo¯D·D¯Dr,bcnprF´?´²rFelonzukmnculor{d±`t4l qDe{dH^ƒe‘lolorMncuyduvsncncd×M^SbplsuSnp³uRd±´?Ì ØƒrMdfÎÛkm^ƒnpdHl¹~°´‹vsnckZr{yR^npuRkmdfls^ƒkMlo»@r{†¼Ê™u·DtŸnzÊ7kxls·D^ƒrbcÊjy^ƒuRvovolNnplo^ƒ·DbcŠçyuRvo·fnplo^·fk Š r{t4rMuRd v
E
@
@
F
B
C
G
/.
0.25
0.22
Test error
Span estimate
Test error
Span estimate
0.21
0.2
0.2
0.19
0.18
0.15
0.17
0.16
0.15
0.1
4t=neubzp^v:yRksqDko´?vsn½n½¶Hr è¿eMr{f^Svslsä_r{npduR†¼l°d0·DºSlsrÐ^^RbpkmkoqDg¿¯frF€?^ƒk0vsdJnpuyRt&rF·k¹lMlslsäà·DnpŠ‹·fr_^ƒ^Se{dHlsq?r´?lo³ u¯Dè¾vovsnprMlmnc´?lsdfr{nze‘´?dlhrk‹´?` nc^y e{npl£e{npqDdJevhbz^S^lsloks·DrMkmr npbp¶H~Ñ%(eMlo^S',·Dlo )#ncru67/1d в01%nc_dDnpgЇrMqDvodfŠ r{buƒÝ™t&‚loߑ·D» r}rlsrMtŸkmlMl0ä®r{lovsr{vo`uRlv
5
10
15
20
25
30
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
¯´?ncr{vovorFt4e‘ulsvsbpŠQ~±nct4dDvsy,uŠ kor{Š²Ì½ÍRnp͑ʓΓko»qD¯=nr{cvsdfº^ƒnzbckobprM~R´²€lobc·DrM^ƒr²vsdDebcncqfdDkmyflo»=r{v&†¼g·DrMr£vovsdfrMr{kob}qD¯bplÒr{vouƒt4tÛulsvs·DŠ‹r^ƒ"dfe{*r,M·f'^R+k£ r{"*rMd_ gurMDvolsdf^ƒr{ncbfdDnzrFk¬´lh^ƒ³ gRn½r{ls·d
@ @ ‚È^ƒdf´ @ ÍM„®npdælo·frlovh^ƒdfkmt4r{vQt4qDdfeloncud!‚?»!†¼·fr±ºS^bpqDrut ³Z^RkQlo·Drudfr
вnpdfnpвnc×{ncdDy²lo·Dr,ko¯f^d:rFk¹lsnpŠ‹^Slsr0Ý2kor{r
bcrtŸl£konc´?r¸utP¶HyqDvsr ߑ»
Dq´DD^vslo´:qDvsyr¸rMrdD`?r{¯vh^Sr{lsvsnpnpºRвrr{вdlhu?k¼´?npr{dfb}e{qfbpqHkm´?rFr
´°t4ncud±v loncr{df`kml£ls^ƒe{dHbc^Rekor
konplo¶H·fe{r,^ƒlo]Ðncu^ƒd°vsync"~df^ƒ+£bcnc^ƒ×{rMncº´°r
gw¼rMvo^UdD~rMrFbÒkZݹe{ÍUbc^Rß@ko³ konpnp¶flo·r{v,lsÌ·D…Ur,Γ» kmls^ƒdDÊ
GQ 1 14LQ8S6XE HG=14LF12EG
ij´?d²ncy^£nplskok&rM„²euRlodfu:´Ø°kor^ƒlàyuƒ^ƒtncdfr`?kml ¯r{²vsnplsвu r{#0dlhuk{t¬€Slo³Z·DrZr e{udfÔ?koaZnz´?Ôr{´DvsrM^S´
lh^ƒlsf·D^RrZkmlsrR^R»xkmg¸†¼·DutHr‡ee{bzbp^qHksk¹kmlsnpt4r{~v
npdf^yxkskmloqD·fвrZ¯?·Hls^ƒnpdfuRdд?³ kmvs·fnpulmloqDrMbzd´
^ƒ¯f¯Dbp~t2^ƒncvobc~³Zr{bcbfuRdQlo·Dnzk@´D^ƒls^f^kor kmncdfer¼ls·Dr£´?npè¿r{vsr{dlN´?ncynplskÒ^vor bcncgr{bc~,lsu¸Hrebcqfk¹lsr{vsrM´Û»
^³ƒ‚ƒŠ²„R·D„rM¯D„:vobcrFrMlo^kMvh»kà^ƒnclsDudD·DRncrxdDv¸yuƒ^lsr·Dy`Dr{nc^vNºŠQr{¯Hd®¯fuRnpbpvodrFqfk,lhd5kÒ·f€}vs^Ur{uRºRŠ‹dDrQr²^ƒncuƒdDr{tZrMrM´QdÏlo·DqDkor0dfr{bcbckorM^qDe‘HflsrMrMkobpr´+rFlh´Ûk
^ƒ»¬dH³Z†¼´µ^R·Dk
´?rxnpqfº³ kmnzrFnz´?´´+rMlo´+·0^kncudt¿lolo·Dlou ·Dr‹rbz„^ƒxkmw9r{qfbc_gfrM´®kmRr{r{lslsvskvsdD^ur{npdDdµbDnc³¼dDØRy^„k@kor{kmr`r{lMlÊ €
lou Ý2n½lx³¼^kZls·Dr¸ºS^ƒbcqDr
ŠQncdDncвnp×MnpdDy²ls·Dr
lorFk¹lxrMvovsuvZncd:ls·Dr,koqD¯HrMvoºnzkmrF´:eM^korFߝ»
³Š²†¼·D·Dr{rrMdvol°rFв^ݹrMÍSkN^6 lodÏN ·D… r& lsrMlskmvs l²^dfrMkovoN ‚´DvsQuqfvQe‘ß‘ls»°t4npuRºRãv‡r¸k
lsÔ·Dt4urÐ]Év
kmlsls^ƒ·D^ƒbcdHr°y´DuRe{^ƒvobpqfvhnplo´km·DloŠ rM6Ô v¸&ug] tZrMvoÌ ØSdDnzÎPkrM´?bxÍUnzÝ7?´:‚R» ߑdD€Puƒlol ·DÝ2~r0kmnplsrMe{^bcq?´dflo´Du^Q^ƒèÏvhkm´æncnpydHdf´?´?n½r{r¶Hº` eMnz^ƒ^S dloncl ³¼unpd ^вk¸D¯D^»vsyRuSQ^ƒºncr{ߑd Ê €
r{bckour{vseMbcvsrMu^ƒe‘v&b¬lsrMвuƒ´±tncdDÍMnpØf~0Ї» #вqD Š npdfÝ2np^ƒŠ²kmlls^nc×{ dfncdD´D@ y²^vsloÍM´È·D„fr‡€Û´?r{³ kmº¯f·Dnz^^Sncehd:ls·+npuRrFdk¹e{ls^npDd®Š‹» ^ƒQlor‹r0ߝnc»dRÝ2kolsi“r{r{l,r
vs¯DnzvskvsnpyRrnc·lodrFllo´_rMkovonzrFrF´?k¹^r¸lskonpnpuƒdDbc~Ðt=y:¶fkoloynpudfqfe{dDvor².r ulon½Rlr²ß»¬e{ncd_ui“vslx¶fvoyRrFyRkm^UqD¯ºRvsur&r df^Q:´fkxlslorM·flskmurl
lo·fr¸dqfŠr{v uƒt¬´?npèrMvorMdl£´?npyRn½lhk¼npd±ls·Dr,´D^Slh^ƒf^RkmrR»
loi“el¼rFuRk¹
d ncl¸k¼¹rMrMkoeuvolovsвqDuvsvr{r:·DuuSlodг·Dr±lsko·DqDt4nzuk¸vsbc¯DbceuSvobznz³^koksnpnpdDkmdDnpyy®¶He{lor^ƒ·f`?lo^ƒ¯DnclNubz^ƒdlsdf·D¯D^ƒrvslolouncuvhf^ƒd5bpdfrMä0бks´?lo€Û·Dqfr±³elo·floncºvhr{r&^ƒvsrMdHÔ ^kok´?qH] npl¸e‘lo´D^ncºncbpyR´_rut4vs6Ô un½&lsv·D] loŠ)r{`nz´?l,kQnc´:e{ŠQbc^RdDuRkouvokor±lNn½¶nckmŠQe{rM^Sdf¯flskonpvouRn½uSlsd5ºRnpºR»¸rxr°lo­È·flsurr
lou¯fu±qD^lovmŠ‹bcl£nprM^Suvs`?tPk£nc¶HŠQnpdyncqD×{lsvsrQ·Dr0rls·DÍqf€fr‡dDloŠ‹bc·D^rM^HvovorMryRbprFnpncd®kx´Ð^ukodrdÐl£qDlsls·DdD·fr²bz^ƒ^ƒdÐqDr{dDlobcbz·DrM^ƒ´rQr{e¯bcbcrMuqf´®nck¹dlsl¯Hr{vuR³ npgd·Dr{lhnzvsehk{dD·» rMfu³Nb}вuRv
qDrbzncls´:df·Dk¹u?·Hlh´D^ƒ^Udfºkr¸e{kornc¯Ddf€Ûvsencud_r‡fn½ls^l
·DDrQ´?bc~°nplovsuRrM¯e¯®r{lovobcвlo~°qDnzvsls´DHvo´?ncrFrMbc´ rk
lolo·f·fncrk
nc^ƒd bcQfyqDuRrMvodfnploe·fr‡Š±uƒ»t¬Ùxuq?uSls³Zbpncr{r{ºvrM¯HvM€HuRnpnpdd®lhk£·Dncnzyk£·_koŠ‹´?nc^ƒŠ²bcbpr{rMdfvMko»xncuã£dfdD^uƒbPls¯D·Dvsr{uvfrbp`?rMв¯Dbzk^ƒdfkm^ƒqHloehnc·_ud^k£nzk lor{lo·H`l
^Sl£ebzls^·Dksnzkmk£np¶HвeM^Srlslo·Dncuu?d}´ €
rMe{^^RdÑkmncr{yvZr{lsl‡u‹kmyloqfrlehg+uRq?ncdÑlxuƒbpu?t=eMbpu?^ƒb@e{^вbÛncвdDncnpвdDnc^fŠ‹€¬^DD» q?lQlo·f^ƒlQ^yR^ƒncd5€àncdÑ·Dncy·DrMv‡´?ncвr{dfkonpuRdf^ƒb¼ko¯f^e{r€àn½lQnck
2
Ä Ã « Æ£§Ç¹Ä Ã
loijvhd·f^ƒdfvouR^´?qDuRy´?Š ·nzks³Zelsvs·D^npвbprµg?nckMedf€bc^Sqf³Nlskmr
nploºRr{¯DrÏvvsukm^r{¯kslmkouRlsqDkonpdDrMв´:yH¯?€^,lonc^ut4vhd5^ƒvs» rMв^Rr{kmw¼³ZuR^Rdfukm^ƒvsrFgQD´bct4rµuuvxd%³¼e{^Ulou~!·DdfrÈkmlolou%ncvs´DqfrMnpe‘df^lse{k±npdfuvsy‡u¯Ht‡gRuRr{kmvs¯vs^ƒdDrMlor{rµebzlokZvhqD^ƒ³ dfb
bc·D^encHbcehqf·:rMkmbprFlonpвr{´vs¯DncdD´Dbcr{y^Sвlh^^rMdfdRnc´ lk
lolo·f·fr
r‡e{ksbp^ƒqHвk¹lsrr{vebc^qfkskmkmloqfrMŠQvuR¯Dv£loncdDud5ulMä=»£lo·f†¼r&·Dncnzdfk´?nck&qHe´?rMu´:dfr,´?nzk¹lh~^ƒdfeh·He{r
^ƒdD´DyRr{np¯dDr{y0dflo´D·Dk¼rQuRkmd°¯³rMe·Dlor{vsloqD·DŠÕrMvZuƒlotà·Dlor
·D¯rQugncrMdRvolhdfk¼r{^ƒb}vsŠ‹rnc^ƒd Ê
lokovs¯HnprF`¿e‘»@lovsÔ?qDnpdfŠe{€r
lolo·f·Dr&rMvoŠ‹r¸^r{np`?d±nckm´?lxnpvskmrMrMeºlor{ncuvh^ƒd°b¿t4uuvZqDt4dHq?lo´Dqfk¼vot4r
uv&vsrMÔ6korM^ƒ]Ðvhehkx·‹³ nzkZ·DloncehuQ·¯H´?rMrMvmt4¯HuRrMvodfŠ ´^uq?d:louRlo·Dвr,^ƒkolo·fnze£^в¯Hr¸u?´?utPrMb5ls·Dkmr{nckÊ
bcвrMe‘npyRlsnp·uRl£d°^ƒfbzkm^RuQkmrFH´‹r¸uqHd0kmr{lot4·DqDrFb5kmncrdlo·D^QrM¯DuqfvsrvolsrMncbpeM~°^ƒkobqDvo¯rFkmr{qDvsºbplsnckMko,»rM´:PncbpdfrF^ƒ^vsbpcdD~nc€?dDdDyQulslo^r£kolog¿·f» ^ƒlNls·Dr&e{bpqHk¹lsr{v ^kskmqfŠQ¯Dloncud
°XF[5G=6E T‹/26T Ñ6G¿LMC
lo†¼uR·D¯Drnze¸^ƒ^ƒqDdflo´°·DuRt4vsukQv ³Z·f^UuºqDncbzdD´Ñy²bcnp¯DgRvsr±uSºlonzuÈ´?rFlo´0·f^qfdDk gѳ ]Ðnplo·^vm·Dlsnpnzdk ´DÔ^ƒ×{lsqf^ƒŠQH^вkorrMv²» t4uv²·Dr{bc¯?t4qDb´?nckseqHkokonpuRdÏuRdÏls·Dnck
© }Ã « §
s&Yl^ *f VeK_P
K
s
Nnb1HCT*FJ^c^ s lIf@rMNcK*NcK
^QVerFJ^cFdP V#K*P MK*^V#rFJ^cFdP\P*VhbCV mNnb1THJI Ob RCVeNKMNcK Ms
#s I#R !VeK
!#"%$'&)(*(*+-,/.1023$547698(;:$"%<-2%8=$>?$.@$AB>DC16FE6G,H$.DEJI!K(%E").,/.L0M8(%$")N !
*
V ` fgV#KMK *rM^NcLOTMFSR1L
s
s lT*V FJ^c^cF s V *KMNc[ s_YI *L MFSb V#K*P s *[(T*F]R 7FJFs lT*I ILONcK f *^nb1N *^cF _VhRCV#f
FSb1FSR1Lo` IeR L IeRObq!FJHSb1IeRfgV#HCT*NcK*FJLJs
s
s !VVe[([!I^V VeK_P @s V *LOLO^cFSRds i *^cINnb1NcK FJKMFSRCVeb1Ncq!F fXI(PMFJ^cL>NK\PMNcLOHSR1NcfXNcK_Vhb1Ncq!F@HJ^VeLOLON
FSR1LJs K
qI^ *fXF
_V #FJL
s UTMF
R1FJLOL
s
s IV#HCT*NcfXLJs ,RCV#K*L1P *HSb1Ncq!F4NcKM`aFSR1FJKMHJF3`aI#Rb1F]ib>HJ^V#LOLON HdVeb1NcIK *LONcK L IeRObq!FJH]b1I#R>fgV
H]TMNcK*FJLJs K
_V FJL
s I#R V#K V ` fgVeK*K V#K ZRCV#K*HSNLOHSI
s
s @s
\s s IeRCP*V#K >V#K_P @s
EFJNcLOLJs K L FJHSbORCVe^ HJ^ ML7b1FSR1NcK
K*V#^npLONL VeK_P VeK
V#^ IeR1Nnb1T*f s K
q!I^ MfXF
s
s N !Vef
s s H UVe^^ Mf s UTR *K MVeK_P s \s Ncb1HCT*FS^^ s &FdVhR1K*NcK b1I@HJ^V#LOLONn`Qp b1FSi(b
`aR1I#f ^QVerFJ^cFdP VeK_P *KM^QVerFJ^cFdP PI H *fXFSK(b1LJs K
_V FJL
VPNLOI#K
s
R1FJLOL FJK*^cI VhR1[ s
Y>s HCT I^c[!I M` Ms T_VJmlF VJpM^cIeR s Ms fXI#^QV VeK_PGW4s >s E Nc^c^cNQVefXLOIK,s FSK*FSRCVe^N dVhb1NcIK
rI MK_PML q(NQV FJN FSKq#V#^ MFJL-I#` b1T*F >RCV#f fgVebOR1Nnis FJHCT*KMNcHdV#^oW F I#ROb
F R1I lI#^cb
s
Y>s HCT I#^[I M` s fXI#^QV MV#K_P s W3s M^c^F]Rds >IKM^NcKMFdVeRHJI#f IKMFJK boV#K*V#^npLONcL>VeLV [!F]R1K*FJ^
FJN FJK(q#V#^ *F R1IrM^FSf s
s
\s (FJF F]Rds lIhq#VeR1NV#KMHJF\[FSR1K*FJ^cLX`aR1I#f YUVJp FJLONV#K #FJK*FSRCVhb1Ncq!F fXI(PMFJ^cLJs K
q!I^ MfXF
s
\s FJF FSRds ,FdVeR1KMNK mNnb1T5^QVerFJ^cFdP5V#K_P *KM^V#rFJ^cFdP P*VhbCVs FSH]TMK*NcHdV#^R1F IeROb PNK(r MR T
KMNqFSR1LONnbBp
s
\s *fXfXF]RVeK_P s !V#V#[([!I#^QV(s VeROb1NV#^c^np\^QVerFJ^cFdPGHJ^VeLOLON HdVeb1NcI#KmNcb1T\fgVeR1[!Ihq RCVeK_PMI#f
moVe^[(LJs K
_q!I#^ MfXF
s
s UL _PMV s NK MV#K_P s L1VeN s VeR #NcK_V#^cN JFdP [!FSR1K*FS^L` I#RrMNcI^cI #NHJV#^ LOF MFJK*HSFJLJs
s IXV FdVhRds ^cLOI MR1FJLOFSK(b1FJP Veb
Y
s
@s_EGFJNcLOLJs (F fXFJK bCVhb1NI#K *LONcK FJN FSKqFJHSb1I#R1L
MK*Nn`apNcK gq(NcFSm s K
*V #FJL
s
O
V'XW
!
QP
Y
SR
JR!Z
[Z
Y
STJTU
!R
J
W
*\L
%
[YY
j 'R
^]
_
G`
a
sr
ut
_v
xw
=Y
g ƒP
SR
3
R
)nDpo-T
Y
7Y
b
VqqeV
y
^{|+}-E-._&)(2~,/.x(C1"5EJI!€).S4S$")AE6G,H$-.Q#"%$'&)(2*2*,/.10R
z
[
dc;Ee&)81,/._(fK(%E").,/.L0RDgJh[i kjJlm j
RY
|g Ue‚Sn
g T j
s
STJTJU
!r
„
=
;
z
[
%
[YY
-
…"5$'&(*(%+,/.L02^$54698(u†e‡-698ˆ€).[6k(".DE6G,H$.DEJI7$.'4S("*(._&)(^$.‰cEe&)81,/._(K(%E".[,/.10R
Y
-
Š
o'
h *
O
dr
MR]
sR
[R!
‰Š
R
STJTT
%Y
W
QR
O
D
p
QR_]
D
*
MR
S
D
D
dŽ
'TTJU
K]
fB
˜—
P
Y
SR_
kRr
J
P
]
g=R
V-qJq=
-
‚TJV'n1‚TJT
RM
MR_–„]!R
!R[–7]
”k
"5$'&)()(%+,9.102x$54|{|{B{|€kJ‘J’d†J“698$.S4'("*(.D&(
$547698(7{|A("),H&*E.^{„2*2$'&”,HE6G,G$.b4”$"f{|"6G, •d&”,HEJI_€).6k(”I/I ,0L(._&)(R_Y
‚'
[m
^{|+}-E.D&)(27,/.x(C1"5EJI!€).S4S$")AE6G,H$-.Q#"%$'&)(2*2*,/.10N-2)6k(A32*R
=‹
O
M
Vqqpn1VqJT
Œ‹f=RB
'R
˜r
K]
1R
Q™
˜
Q™
?
SY
TJT q j o
š
R‹
S
L
'R
'TTJT
]
Up
˜—
Tp
JY
a]
kR
]
1R
7Y
S
O
[?—
Œ‹
dx(C1"%EIŒ$AB>DC16FE6G,H$.[R
›
M]
”
–
J
xŽ
LR
R
Sq
'TTJU
œ
x(C1"5EJI!€).S4S$")AE6G,H$-.Q#"%$'&)(2*2*,/.10N-2)6k(A32*R
'qp
Y
m pVTTpn j
'q
[
ƒ{a+}-E.D&(2^,9.
g=R
u
V-qJq=
x
SY
]1šS

Mr
XP
pV'
O
%
=R[
4S$")AE6G,G&”2)R
j Š
~]
[
*
z
^{|+}-E-._&)(2~,/.x(C1"5EJI!€).S4S$")AE6G,H$-.y"5$'&(2*2*,/.L0yN-2)6k(A32*R
=
'RMw
Vqq=
O
VqqeV
S
sR
d
O
-YY
^
š
J
bY
4'("*(.D&)( $.?$AB>DC16k(";¡s,/2*,H$.[RY
*
Sm
Te‚JoSn1TUeV
R
STJTT
ž
g=R
S\1
V-qJq=
Ÿa,G$,/.D
V-qJqJV
€).6k(")._E6G,H$-._EJI$.