Mitigating Routing Misbehavior in Mobile Ad Hoc Networks
Sergio Marti, T.J. Giuli, Kevin Lai, and Mary Baker
Department of Computer Science
Stanford University
Stanford, CA 94305 U.S.A
{smarti,giuli,laik,mgbaker}@stanford.edu
ABSTRACT
"!$#% &(')*+# ,+-
#./++0 $123+456 7 189 :. ;+,
<8=+7(>
+4)1#18?@A/B7C&D,E %+@&GF(3E+H(,EI,* :J +H5# EDKL
&<H@@DLM&H#H (':+HBONPQ#*MR;S+TVUWX)YZ/ $[ & (': ,/:\
]/^S+T=W$_S+T`a_M
( @QE#,b+$+@<H')Ec M:B]E#,Ed&0#@"(Ed/'++@#
(
+,G
e \#,b +4)+# ,+ #HFf$,E1+8f(')HEbgh+# ,)iO &EF:+ 6 %+#L<8
& (': ,:6EABNj ># HGE,+ a*]/3+4c1Dk&:l&E @D2L$FK M2] !$# 0 +
E# ,+ #m$Lon(pEqrsd d8/t)u)qv& (': ,
:F+1 @%H+,* $+,E789(') E5 &wE38=+&x %w+ (+# ,5$E@?y 1z)q{MnHpEqMB.|Q# ,M}:&5&E@D2L$F
E,G
m
(aH+] +
23+4bE# ,+ #:Lm~EpEq/Ff1@0H,l6(')HE
&E 8"E& <w
e+# ,G+$+@?y Mn(~+q€
~(t$qMB
1.
3INTRODUCTION
1@@K&
E#J,+H70(')aJ }:OHE6
#b+8Q1@ME&&0# H(+AFK8=+&@@DG+&+
$\&/+$L<E&K\1D@7aE
@fH\ 4BK‚%;
+w7+8A1D@%+1EF:1@7E&&6# H(E ;E#@
@+<1DHcc&/:Lma,EBGƒQ +'++$+,++81D@
> @D2L„P+&D/ (c+&+ ,P#/…P+&&E
(H1 @&/ ,Q&+ @EBJ†H')aHF+7w+
:@&DHG$Lb ,E5+8. &D%+% D
(}&D2L%71@O+JE$BO‚1*$K1D@J23+4:
&D,)(KA+ @&s$L*+@@(1,QE#J8 ,E; :A7E#
6E# ,+b$&H"(* :B
‚1< $% 4K
H')*1L+8A&@(L
E&&a +@% @H(+ B‡‚1d $b +4:(GH@ˆD#
+ 1 a7w+@@ ,\+08=w# #7K .E @1H# 7 8"+w# a#Kf$1} ').+A$1'#@ @EFH .23+4
;$+$HF:+318=w# #%+wHL$H9B.‰ +3}:+&@EF9 :Q&/LG6H+>'EQ$M@,E<+]H/8hE
w+<+ 6%+
\
+3wE<&/LK$Q}')EB
‚/}& @8O\':# @ @Q8=+w##Q6&@(L/
w+M+/
@[ @fBOŠ23+4:.8h+;1@" }HDE
+ ‹+8= b&/LˆG+:MD8 aL‹a}wM8hb+ @DL…
1:b+8C&Q8h\ ,<%&': ,B.‰J
@@DL$FD8
a24<8"+w# a#%
+3MwHL$# 156+wHF
+0E0$1D@;23+45E#@67# 5*$
(7@a8
Œ9B: |‚Ž9‚5y 7.ŽŠQ;’‘nH“(”VF \(H<+8J+# ,0
EM $23+4:1
+1G+bEMHGEEB
‚1< $ +4:;&/}&I%+@ a240+# ,+ #3$L#w ,m@@('++@+@l:\8h0E# ,m+ P8h7 ,Be8hEF &+:1
( (\b
+4)7+# ,F
,+/ G+,E,,)(m
+ 1fF3G G+ @
E# ,b FJ
> <&/@@<E@D2L]81l23+4
(D+ABl†QH')HFOG:&/Lm&
H')0:Le,+,m
8h7(M +4)
< <8?+@ ,566F:H# QD33'E@)+H9F@D[
fF7&/+@E#F/E4EABk‚„(')@)+Hˆ :
@+4:A ;•.–„L@F #Œ9aC +K+J('++@+@3 a24Q +
:1…„8h7‡
a4EB—‚˜@[ ™:]b# $1@@,ˆ
] Lm@D8hEF.•K–šL@FJ0H'++@+@23+4> +
:1d>8h7ˆ
a4)a0 <8*<$w<mDHF;')
+# ,+MD7a}3 3\8h7(l
a4E3+lD +@D82B;‚
&/+@E#Q:5@"# a*/ +@O83':6a4G$LGE ,e +4)Bˆ‚›+4)„ :b&,E$< H')Gm+8"27(b8?# @D
(1'E$778"E&›8h7( , +4)B
œb
H': ,M :H+]<M,E D[ H+$E @&GB6ƒQ#&<# @ (+ *H’
(*D8nu)q5-VtEu)q836:>623+4
&
H')+Ffm H'),E0E#,E #\,++\$LdnHžEq5“)~+qMBc†H')aHFK+w<H+ME#,E #6}Hc$L
+$L6E%:1&/L073+1
+<%('E+,+EF$H# % :
(L‹eE#GE#,EjP& H',P :>} ,+M@+1 @Q+7:a}a % 5@EB;:# F:')l
8ha™& H',0 :1H+b
H')0')&
HB
ƒQK+@#E\1&
H':,7 :CC78h7(5 +4)fE @DL
E# ,+m :Q
(*
(+ˆSl^ _ Y_ #w*@E AB
^
_ Y+_ # w7@(+ %* +HMEb-V}w,6@(+. # @DKE#"7+8E$}:K+8 a24lg?+B ,BO8= FO+&
+FO
c(&iaBGE@&1e@DL,
+’SP^
_ Y+_ #w-V
+ˆ8h7( ,„(b
(>n(i<DH!$# D
4)aLcw#EfFK~Ei*# wHe :6&/L]w@@3M(')a@EEHfF
“Ei9# w* :A&/L*w@@)K+4)AF(t)i#wH* :C&/L
+&+&fF:
Ei;#:#wH< :7&/L<%@@9
H')fB
Vl&/L„+l>E @>c}
+,Em4)L#H‹d# H(b# wHd:<+#b+8Qb+ˆ$G a24c8=+
5E8=0w*
(QH!$#Qe+> $5 +4B
V84)L\( +5w#He+HE]+8&EFf e8=+,dS
^
_ Y+_ # w-V
He8h7( ,GH!$#6l#/
@.8=+
4)aL6a}
,+K1D<1E<$%23+4\8h7+# $H(+AB
.')…D854)L/Hj]a}
,+HfF%c# wk :Ey b#D2L
&/LME&E&H9F *0#wHb :&/Lb(')@EE
O+4)5+O&$EH+(')+BO‰J
@@DL$FE+@D +# ,+5@DL ,%ElS
^
_ Y+_ # w-V
HM8=+7( ,<# *:#&078O& (': ,5 :FD1+@0a}@# 3# $# wH<3@@f
H')H :
1E* *E#@l&(')EM $*23+48=+&/+EB
‚ +mE@#+’j&
H': ,k:]]…&>
%
8=+w+@@E@% % :.8=E&o1D %+a#
+@E#,
+$+@;8h\ a24Bl†H')aHFC +# @c+ e,+ D[ H$\E&@a}DL]l$E@\1 E/ H'6&6# w0')L
3@@
a[
fB 68h+HF$#$.')+ .+89&/(#7+0 $+# ,G+@,E&F. @#
,G|\:Ž€‘n(~H” FK‚ƒQ
| ‘ pH” F31ƒQŽ‚‘ H”VF
|\:
| ‘nz” F5C‚Ž ‘ z” F\
j+e‘nž”5E@Lja>D86
')Hy 4ˆ$8h+G/,c
a4EF3#<L
1\+#& 7E# ,0:10+1&
H')+B.‚@DE# ,+e#w,>+@@; :\>6@@3
H')H]H6
:# &68J:1H'++@+ @*8=+7E# ,FD%+@+&D& (': ,6 :70 *23+4B
n(p+qMB.|*#,6a}&%&+ @D2L$F)
+,<
(a7H+
+b23+4]E#,E #6$L„~+pEqMFK1 @lH+,e :,E+8J(')a H+/ &E ;8=E&€n(~Eqo<~(t$qMB.Nc
&a +&;0H#Q1(')HEMma+>žB
O&/
aC8A +AC+,E+IH\+A8=E@@H1B;+0~
D[ *E#5+#&E*++#\+]$< a24:+ ],+'E
a4:,E# <8h&/EME#3|\Ž\B::EM“\3 7(a +,+ b
(aa} EB:E>t<1 &:E@+,+LG3<# 6]E#&0#@"(E \
G 6&Q3
# <'++@#
(* *#@B.NP*:1*# @D1mE
:B‡:E/žP
…pm:@"(Hˆ3+4ˆ+ „8=##
4F')@DL$BK‰J
+@@DL$F
+
0+ @#
7 * +HB
2.
lASSUMPTIONS
E E#@lPAND
# &BACKGROUND
+ /]&/+4)>,E,
\E*8;6$LH@O+ > +4l@HL)*+83E>$
a24:J+ @#
J78 E5+8|\Ž\FK+# ,
$E@f#EB
2.1
Nc5# 5Definitions
\&` (Z WY+_</8=b/ :5 Q1D
1D@C &E*+,EK+8++C:EBA4)1EF` Z(W!
Y+_WYHYHX58=.*+@@ :J ;31D61@K w&El ,+58.0:EB
2.2
Characteristics
+# ,+Physical
E# Layer
m
# &l D+
+@E&&6# -
H(+mwL&&aLb+]')LG@ 4b23m :BQ&H+
(<D8Qm:#" <H
@b8',Pm&+,+l8"E&
:0‚o(*&MT?F9 > :0‚{E#@"> wEm
H')\')H
<&,E\8=E& :$
" (&T?B% Q+# &EGQ8=
'++@fF;b&/$Lc1D@lœG‚• @"L$a$E@F7 @# ,
wKK%
 EuE~:BnEn+ œG‚%•‚AN ‘ ~(” F$H!$# D7 E
@
+&&0# H(E<8h;@ @% &EfB. 77(a +,&a +&
@1EGDE +@A@4B
0 K
+aK31} @+%DŒ9:; E+AF:
0w+@@
}:<8?@\> 5 4bb*+
G&D,)(6+# ,e&
H':+H
B 2„ <7L$F33GHk&/+4EbE@DL„&&/+@
,E% #
@DL,<E#,/+@,E&GB7Nc\$:# c}:E <e G|QL +&>:E#GŽ+# ,P+@,ED &
g?|\:Ž*i‘n(~(”1e&,EbbŒ9a<+8*+# ,]&
H':+
1R;S+TVUWX)YZ*+ Q O^S+T=W:_wS+T`a_aBKO7
E,1$D[
A&w H', :F1 @6 5
((*H')+Q+# ,/
a4E
E# ,+e< :B<Njeb :08h75b
a4)aHFA
:Ey 3
+,6'ED[
3 ; Q}:3:/ %
(M+@
8=+7(<M +4)HBc /7
E,e$6 0$Lc@w,
^
_wY U Y 0 Q }:1 :Ey % &EB V8J *}:
:M$6 08h7(d/
+4)HFOdD<0& H',B
%#%%4:(1@H,E\+8.& H',< :7
$+* a24/
M
(11&+w1@4)@LM@'E1
a4$B
2.3
|\:ŽPODynamic
+\+-&/Source
9FHE#KRouting
+# ,1(DSR)
+$+@ BK.')LQ
a4)a
–,> / 6 +4P&6# @l‘ (”VFKl Hx 6 23
!:#0H+lE#,E #6$L…n(p+q „ bb8
# ‹t)u)q &
H':,‹:m# ,ˆ&:aP&+ @D2L$F
1@ aH+ ,<Q<8O(')HE/+ &E7 (
&E /8=+& >w+ (‹E#,c$E@?y >zEq Ncm'G|\Ž$c2P&/+k8h# + -]E#m(')L
2*E D+AFH33# &O1D@J$8?A A# +f^
_Y &
U Y &:6++AB0.+&# E#*&:6&H+ D87
:M‚—51D c+,EM+8> :'"FJ6Hˆ(')a H(0+&<&0# H(+ <d
„8=E&(—
" 'EkD8 +>E&&6# E
>+0D@DLd:')+@'E/‚5B)f # $6C E@E,+y.NdH')A ‚Š
$8?
H')5 *H
@L$B\Nj @<+&# +# *&:0
+l8h++@@%E„ $b23+4c
(+mg?
#@@DL>+&6&@DLG
(+iQD*Q#8h#@Om Q
(E
8h%&(',6E# ,<+$+@C8=+&/+0‘n(~H” B
0b+#/
(dEw,m+81 ME68:\
(
H')0+,H]l
( <mE#,l0
a4EHB<<$+@J%8=HG/++
*E-2&/+ ! ,H# E#5 Q(
(')aHb(%Q&6+#\ 10 +4)70<w EM8h+%1 b QE#
+1<
(AB
S
D
S
g Ei
D
S
g?i
D
S
A
B
C
D
:FCrtsuET7oviwFS;T
3 5 bT>c?@9;wF 4 9GUS[8
3
Ix9FE:FEOyzY${|>+7]U}@+EU8~vz 5 9GF7 5 5V5 7W7:3
>+7€}@
R<9FE:89v‚E: 5 T9G9ATb9GU3W9A: 5V5 9FE:N:>
?U9
9G2yz,8M;E: 5 __3C_j7:p
UF 5 879 5 9VE:p_79G873:83J3^n
U>+9G7
9FE:N:>
?U9 5 879zKvu9GyzYDSzE9FEN3 5 E:U3€_j7:
j73_>+T9A 5 9FE:89N{ƒ 5 S19VEj7H9A
7 5 5V5 n7HF7<1v
7:3>+78}@cE:@T19VE:J>
?@9p9GF7 5 w@q,
+ /+#&/+$
EBO‰J,+#0nQ@@#w+#'EL$B
ŠQ:;gh;+#Hi91 A%E&&0# H(.1D\ :;| gh w E
iK#3$; +34: H…$L<
( K5|6B0 D7
E#7(')aL\:L\)+Hw,t„8…†‡ˆ1„ˆU‰†ˆ8ŠG‡< +4)J
D\ ,E:\ \+$+ <w
(Ed+ 5|6BJ
,+:+7l#l MD7H1GE15 t„T…†‡ˆ
„ˆU‰†ˆ8ŠG‡> +4)+ lEEH+wDHB7 %$+$:#
# $@;„T…:†‡ˆ~„ˆ8‰:†ˆ8ŠG‡M
+4);H+ |0B$| &0#w3(k
a4*%E#;@DL\
+4)C8=+&o+8 3(')HE#EB
‹„T…:†‡ˆm„ˆ8‰:†ˆUŠG‡b +4) Ha7|sE$+ 1
(b8=+&˜/|0F
|o&/LMa$E\# ')a5 b
„ +4P M @DLjg?DE +@1@ 4:MH!$# DHd a(i
+\G(lGoE#/(')Le
a4>mBO:< a
Hl&/+$L<E#8=+&›\E#Q<5w EfF
5E#
&/L/')\&0#@D@*E#@8=+& w
(+AB7|Ž
Ha7 *+#7>6+#Ha*8h%8=##*# EB
e+
™&/ 8=# a+™™|\ŽGE#c&/+$ + EF
1 d
@6@4c+4:Bc‚—@ 4eH4c$#61d2
:Q+P/
(]0l@+ ,Ea\> &Em+ ,+EB 83+
$&H(M:l<m@4PH+4P1d8h7 ,c
a4E*l< a}* :0] 5E#0
fFCD\ +4e
&,E<G 0E#M+D8=L ,>D5+87 5@ 4mH4BG
E#/&0#w5LP++0 cmbE#M'ELPD8%D
$%+1 ('E++ a fB
3.
2] WATCHDOG
\Ec3 AND
:\0PATHRATER
7(a E,m
e<
((
g?(i
"!$# %&'%($!)%*+#$,-./1023
465 873 5 :9; "!$# %<'%($!)%*+#=>
?@9;9ACBD7:3=C89FE
9GH7:3:&IJ,-LK /NM;E:O "!$# %P$%:("!)%:*+#Q 5 RFS;T
3U3
9FE
:E:9=9VE:W7:@9XS;
?ZY[@T>+E\7:3]3^3^_7:`9 5 T3:a
3F 5V5 9Gb9FE:JT>c?@9+,d-L>@/[Ie9FET7 5 873 5 KT>c?N $!$# %
'%f^gAhi9G 4 5 _7:]9FE:T9FEO>c79Aj7:U3`j7&7[9FE:
$!$#Z%H$%:("!)%:*+#k:>
?U9l9FE:89m
@T>+E:U3On9+,<M;E:o9FE:_>c?
__7: 5 FUF 5 T79)9FE:pT9VEm9VE:1 $!$#Z%b'%f^gAh=9G? 5 KT>c?
9G9FE: 5 873@q,
Π$+@68h+< ,]+ c&,E ,>E# ,m&
H':+HB
Nc5@M5\@&D+ Q8;\& :B% +# ,E
6& @&$% 5$E@EmE]+8;|\Ž\F+&0+83E#*+H+e,E+@IH]G+\E#<E#,b+$+@B
Nc\+6E5E
(*He5,E @Ie# ,/E#
E%8J *a !$# B
3.1
7Watchdog
E,6& :/a7&
H': ,5 :BK‰J,E#5~
@@#w/(›l
+,e3+4:B‡:# +lG}w
<
(b8=+&€:5l|’E# ,+>:a&H:‚5F "F
+ <•B+ŠQ:1‚‹H O+&K@@ ;7L6 :%•FE#.D
HG@w>bE> : "y FEB7:#F 1 >‚™+&D
a4E38=+ "„58=+7(M0•F‚jH+M+8"M@@D8 "ˆ+&D
b
+4)HB V8LE‹M /8h&Hk (@DL‹8=+
Ha>@ 4F 1aG+>\} ')+F >‚sHm+@@@CD8 "
7+&H1Db Q
L@EEb1 *HEHB
S
2
A
1
B
1
D
C
C023{ 3 5 :7 T9CE:@TCv RFS[8
3k>
?@9
C9G<yzY"KZ8>c 5 v 5 9GF7 5 b
5V5 7W>+__3 5 T9l{ Sd9FE
T>c?@9prbR
9FE: 5 c>c 4 ,
S
A
1
B
1
C
2
D
: 023O{ K U_nU} 5 9FE:T9<v E 5 RFS;T
3U3
T>c?@9t 7~9G~yzYU9FE::EbyO7:@}U FU>+U}U3~9FE:[>
?@9
3Zm9GNN>c__ 5 n7<S19FE:>
?U9dr,
NP6& @&:167(a +,l$LG&/: ,l #Œ9a*+8;:@DL‹$b +4)M+ …E& ,PH+j(') …
a4E
1DP<
a4)aP <#Œ9lD8 a5M&/AB V8
F*
a4)a7b #Œ9a17&(')M
/8h+,++>$L
+,FO/5 +5P8=+7(Hc+A
B 81G +4)\ +
&/ H0<%#Œ9K8h@E,E;
+<&+#HF)
+,0 a&$\8?+@#*@@L/8=+7 :+ @
8=+*8=+7( ,lEm 5
a4)aHB 8K \+@@DLm}*/
+@"G + 1fF
D*& 1 % \ :\%& (': ,6+ M
5&,EQ\ E#* D8=L ,518C
& (': ,6 :EB
P7(a E,‹a !$# c +m+'++$+,+]+
‡H4: B
| :Ž{1e <7(a +,G
\/E'E:,E< \D5H+d\
aO&
H':+.(O ;8=+,*@')@+ 5+2# wO3@ 4
@')@ BONc
E,y 7+4: (Q
(1D1&,+$7 %a%
& (': , :0 7+8OnHiJ+&0,E# +# .+@@EF
~+i;')1E@@+ F9“Ei;@&DH/+&+bHHFt$i;8h+@
& (':+HF +i7E@@# EfF9+ bž)i +@A+ ,B
*+&6 ,E#E#3+@@EGE@&—'E$‚…8=+&—(') ,M+&+ 8=+& "BA‚\‰J,E#/“l@@#wFOl
a4E
+@@ElH+M$#7(1‚…1 @QD73@w ,68h "ˆ8=+7(
+‹m
a4EHBd‚›$< <4: H›D8% /+@@Ek+<+# $
L "‡8h7 ,b+P/
a4E*D +# @>+D8 "™ ')Q8=+jm
+4)b+ k m+@@E 7+bH+#Hj:L‹+
:*P‚5y * ,+:+ $:9B "3H+#<+8; # +$2L$Ff‚
E# @5 +J&&@DL5# "e+8& (': ,F #J E#@
wEG+::# 7(a "j(')Q:m8.&+B 8;‚sH(H@DL68?+@35a "„8=+7( ,5E +4)F$‚…H
# &Q "k& H',B
Q O'ECE@@+0+ @&GFH:K‚cHE @DL@@+1 a "s
<
a4)a*m•FA #*\+ +\@@K81•™')\D
g ‰J,E#6t)iaB 8;+@@Ec$#(\•j1 " [wQ8=+7(
] +4)HF‚˜E@DL…#" 8=+,„m
+4)b+ j+w#&K 7•‹# w8h#@@DL')DHB.:# F!ˆ
" E#@/4: &D ,Q7
+4);
0@HH')1‚kE 1HB c
" E#@
@/#Ea8h# @@DL>H# &DHb +4)1/E@@6
•„:L57D,6#$@•ˆ; &D ,\+ 0 <8=+,6+
+4)H)B 2[ wH+EF\ :Q+# @l%@D[
b+
+
+$J17+w3(3J1D6a+ &EB 23@JH+EF
+ @DLb+E "j+# @G
H')*8=+Q4:,< 5+a+ %
D
$%%H# DQ1&/+@E#B+"k+w%
(LbH3+
•.–‹&EF+*D..+.@D[
fB.‚5(')@)+H6 :;E#@6 ,)+,+\G H'HF 5D%7wQ E@DLl H
•.–…&%
<
:1":AB.:#F) 3E <H+ E#@<
6($# EB
‚+7+ @&—+b$#71b:78?@@DLl1+
: \+\& (': ,B/‚o&/+@E# \:+# @P(&*
(D+< 723+40$L6@+& ,* ;E&1 :K8=E@@H1,
DQG5 >(6& H',B1‰ Qw+ EF :5‚’E#@"
3
(: "„ 38=+7( ,6
a4)a;1 l8?7D
B*1@@KH+#M>l&/
4 "’\&
H':,M1e‚š
Q# @DHB3 1
H':+HF H'EHF1@@C\fB3 ‚o\ + ,G&+,EEe "xg +')a[ He$LeiaF P+$L
+4: H1@H,+&$J8=+&{|k\1@@,E*E# ,+<‚d\9F+

1@@f3E
71$LM7')7@78"E&›|s1l# +H@DL
" EH>
a4)aQ> \8h+eDEfB 2]+ DEfF9D8
‚s:EQa4: H1@H,E&$7<"* &—8"E&€9F l :
"k1@@Ja7 1&
H':+%
M1@@A+%D%0|0B
‚+QE@&€ Q&
H':, :5 *+>+E@D3 &EMH7+MD# &6')$;%
E,B;‚
:Q+# @/@&D7D+&+lH31# M Q,E +@
*wE,l E#,E>M6(')H>$LG6':+# *:5 #
$b3H+4]G<')P$L> <# < $HBl 53E#@"
H!$# DM
b& (': ,e :b4: H› l+ &E
H3H!$# DH<5+lHaM+8AD7 ,+ ,5 :B;ƒQ @DL
b:<1Dc&/+@E#\$$3E# @P
H')e\&/ a
Π@D[
G:%
H')*+,0<,E+G \ LMH
7wH>+ G(')@)+H> :1E#@G +%@')6+$LGE ,+wEl:LlE ,0B
œb# @D @:7bE@@# E>Hb&+# $16&*E wH
a4B5‰ }+&@EF "s
e• 8=+&‰J,E#<~M+# @mE@@#
mH+#b& 82B%2c <+EF" 8=+7(/>
a4E0P•
#M$/+/+/d‚ 1 j• :E/>
a4)aHB "3H# *8C 7@&DEfF D7&/L/Q(L/<@@H 2
+ #')<# $#wH> :5elE# ,b fB 2m \
(HF:+ @DLbH@f1Db*E @D2Ll+8.:%+a,+@+ EB
6
(\E @& +8E@@#
,b : ,lw#
Hm$L
E+ +>Q•7œb–x‘n“” B
‰J
@@DL$F;m :MH‹D#&0'):\M
+,e$LcE ,
a4E(16@H7( + %7
E,y 7E[ ,E#HM&&0#&&
H':0 +@"9Bc‚%@D E#,Ec/
E,m1@@
** :<+Q&
H':,FQ :6Q8hH]
8h7(b3 +@M +
:1AB 2 7L%+,<')168=+1& &6# & + 1fB
57(a E,M&
&€E# @m0#HmME&0,6
a@HLl(+47#3E#@"/H!$# D*&/$ ,66,+
+@*80w(e8=+&/(+ >Ha‡:]+GDb&E DbD
,+:+A7 #O CLQ1 A &DC1 +4)9
(
aLm
H')<@DHE:L]8=+fBM‚@FJD87bE@@+d
+*4)
@3(C.':,1 :+F(A+# @KL\
*
8h<G:<G &D6G
a4)aHFC1 d&/LP H(<0
@HL+40 % :Q ,5+3K7(a E,B; 8=+EF
,@HL+4:;3E# @ +/A<$ 7
Œ9')*# 8J *
E,<&
&GB
‰ \ <7(a +,GG+4]+@DL$FOD5&0# w\4:(o1M
+4)\ +# @PPGE B'cE#6&@&$EfFA
+,Q +J O8=+&/(+0+# 7|Žd.+#+# ,+$+@?B)8 E,\$;+K
H')K8=+&/+
gh8=+% w+\D8OD%3\& @&$HElEG8K0 +-V$L-VE
+# ,d+$+@=iaF% ‡c&/+@E# l+l+4)…:mE#@
)EH+w7*
a4E66 +-V}w+$7:
QE,>+# @ˆ H')/ >7Ld8Q4: H1 ,B "3H+#b+8% 6@&D(+AF5
+,M3+4:Qw*E>+]8+#5E#,
+$+@ B
3.2
0
(Pathrater
(HFA#m:LGH+P:0m 6 +4Ff+&0 4: H1@H,E1+8f&
H': ,*:.1D@46@+@DL/ (Q
4G 6E#6&Ew\@4)@DLmb5@" @EBMK+P:0&/]( ,e8=+/'ELd+:bD4:(1/E#ˆ
23+4
B H+@#@"(
(>&\:LGH')+,+ , \ :
(,E*G6 AB1NP6 $+5&6H+#6D*,+')
5E& EG8J Q'E+@@9@" @D2LG8.DŒ9:1 1+
@@H1< (5>&0#@"(< / w6@ ,+d d@,E+D &š1 l 6@ @Lb8h+&/(Eb +7b+@@aHfF
+
}@" Hˆ@(B V8* a>>&6# @D @b <e G&
w
+AF*3P $Ee ]
j1D‡ P,E w>&EB
Š+>
(b bDŒ9l8"E& w+ j|\:Ž5FK1 ‡a$E
7 +w3 <01+#7HaEBK‰ # .+7
(;
6 (\
Q+e4: H1 ,/ 5}+a
(e/
a4E
+0H')fFKD&0#w0l&@&$HP+ˆ+ˆ8mE#
+# ,<+$+@?B
*
(aQ,E 1,E7< :1++,<0 8hE@D@H1 ,ˆ+@,ED &GB{Njjc :m…m +4‹+&
4: H1<*% gh+# ,E<+#%(')aL
iaFE 1
((;+,E;D;
* #+@ ,K ,89uB :BK‚ˆ :1+@D7LK(
D@D811D„dn+B uB] 6 #5 51 PH+@#@"( ,]
(F9D83@@O+ a* :*(6#@J :0gh( %
m# waH&
H':, :iaF$ %
(a 4:; % w
@,+G AB3 % &$ *,E%+8. :
+…+@@+')@Lˆ#Hˆ :Lˆu:B unm(la:G:a'E@/8
~uEue&Bˆ‚%k')@DL„# ˆ „E lE„1 ‹ M :
+*$*M +4)Q1Dm 5'+# Q(0 &$Q$'++@?BM 0&/}&0# &€'E@# b#@. :0H+d(+c5uB B
NP&:3 :Ey 3 ,\$Lu:B u *1 Q\@ 4
H+4]# ,b +4)8=+7( ,m
m <:<E&#Ha +@+B. 7@H;E#
\ ,89
* #+@ ,:7KuB uB
(7$3+3&:D8=L<7 ,++8A :; 7(
+1#$@LM>')# EB
NP,El\+@
,+ @DL,)('E'++@# +F nHu+u\ 1&0#@+ F0 :#H/+8O& H',5$L7(a +,
&
&GB>Njc /
((<H@# @0 M
(d&EF ,E')e
j'++@#b
Hm m}w e80+ ]+
&Q# Hl& H',0 :7lQ
(A)B V8O0:*
&/(4)H>+&
H': ,M#5M&+(LG&/+@D8=# a+m+
J+#E\DC3E#@".a8h @;D8DA3;+C&/+$@DL0}@# H<8=+&š+# ,BK 8=+ :3
(
H')
,)')(,E5 +# @c
H')<D6(,E6@H1@DLcH+
+Ml
a4„dcE-V,)('E>'E@#m8"Gc@+ ,c&E#HB
<+& @&:P‹+#&0#@Elb#$6&6# @+d:„5$e+5m>&
H': ,
:Ey K( ,B;:E'
$B “5# K 7Œ93+<+# ,E #
+8O+# ,<@@D-V (': ,0 :B
Njl
%@H( 0:\E>6
l
%%
# .& ('EF+ *CH+ A[ *7
(*8=;+8&
H': ,
:F:D7 3+#1;„8…†‡ˆ~„ˆU‰†ˆ8ŠG‡l8f
H')%
@H/+
}:+l3H+@@O:
MŽ+#*Ž%H!$# w\gVŽ%Ž*iaB
4.
2<METHODOLOGY
3+M3Q+#3&6# @HF:&0# @(+/
&<-
F + l&H#HM&B
Nc/#l>')a+„+8"34)@aLfy 6ŠQ+4c&0#@+lg? i<‘ ”
(J @# f1D@O}: + J&/+.$LQ 3•7œb–kœbE
(a
wHB6NP+@l# M'# +@IHEe$E@O8=+& •7œb–xH@@
E:-V $4)L‡‘ ~ (”Qc':a€G# @DM+8\E#b&6# @EM+
a(')@@K *m <23+4B0Cb}#60&0#@EFA30#<;•3<g?t ul+ +uEubœb†QI0J$#& Q1DP(
@H+w\nH~ /œ "…+8.Ž‚*œ>i;# ,0Ž%Hl†Q
f:#}bž:BnEB
ƒQ#1&6# @E7+4)*@+\GžEp+u0$Llž)pu<&(%
+
[
@@HP1Dˆ>H,]8 +u>1@< :Be M $L+@
@L$
b
+u)~:Bn+n/œG‚%• @L$0#0(6@#
m> •7œb–s1D@%}: + 7< ‘ “(”VB
4.1
:Movement
\+&&0# Hand
0# Communication
,PnuGEw+$6 D\Patterns
>gV• "3ŽQi
: - +-V :/E + Bd‰E#0 :<(l+#68h+02
+ E ;H+AF
<235:Q+#38h7E+ EˆH+ABˆ.,E$8Q H w
(+ <')b+ @DL„E
H *$Mw El')
H1B; *+&<&0# H(+l l# 7+')@EHM$LG•7œb–š‘ “(” B
2…+@@+85E#G:m&(')&$/ EF m :b $+
Gw
+„+
c&(')0cGw+,E$6@/H\ Mw
(+’(]kH # D8=+&@DL w #H a2’uˆ&(E ]g?&(i3+ E&Q&/(}&6# &{fBK 7H@@
G
E& 7LE$b&:@\‘ “(” B{Nc>@&M >&/(}&6# &
H>87/ :\b~+ul&(0gwnuM&(*E]H'),E(iQ
>6
/# - &8l&6# @E0e~+u+ue+
BˆƒQ / :*H+ D%w EfF
D+D18h+% *^S `5T /`8ha$E ,Gl+ E& w
(+c
]H ,G<B\NP6#0
# 5&*+83ub
mžEuME $
B 2]+ DE
# Q0DŒ9$7'++ 7+8A D"@A: @+&$
+ M&(')&$3 B ";L/E&6 ,5230 +# &
1DP23>&(')&$* FJ/++c8=E#6Œ9a$6& @D2LM EB
4.2
ƒ8 +Misbehaving
uQ :O6 ;Nodes
&0# @(H623+4FE+&3'++@7-
$,E5+8K 5 :Q&
H')+B>E#*&0#@"(E FA&w-
H',:3O+ 3 .,+O%
( 58h+,
+4)0g?D\ *E :$2„8…†‡ˆ6„ˆU‰†ˆ8ŠG‡]
a4$i5 #0 ˆ
&
(@DLˆ+ /+@@ (] +4)<
(
(*E#M+# ,+GDHB
u +
b +# &
0
žEu<+
b +#Q&
œG}&0#&
:B ž)q
z $B u)q
œb &6# &
p $B ~+q
p+“:B zEq
M$TK^&T:jC^ 7:3_7jC^ :7 @9XS;
?9FE:FEa
Z:9 K:9Gj783=K7 5 _bnT9V7o89 | 5 KZ8E:@}j7
7:3 5 S1n9FE_"w@T9V:F 5 87:TK^U3",
NP*'E(L/ *$+,E8J Q +4M+&Hl8O& (': ,b :58"E& u)q Gt)uEq +q˜&$BlNj @M
23+4<1DltEu)qo&
H':,6:3&/HL0&—#H@wEF
D17:aw ,66w#
:L Q
H':1+8J*@,++D &7b
&Q +w@Q:'D+ &$K
+/ +0 +# $/H+@
@D8hEBNc5# 6C@?y 0‘n(pH”. # @D-V> # +- +&€:#&0%,E(+P,E G& H',e:<
+&@DL$BdNcb#
M&lH„++0 lu)q˜mt)u)q 'E(E„+8% /&w H',b :
(+&aHFC1 P&H Q <,++# c8
& (': ,% :O6QnHuEqsH+7.Q#.+8 3,E#
8O&
H': ,5 :%M +qšH++B7 #1 7
+ w+@K$.0@H;:,E& H',Q :3# (7+@Q$O5 ,E.$,E& (': ,1:;# B
( 11 ]@@C4H1>
Q @# 5# aH>&
H'$ ,\ :EB.K+/+89 78h+@@H1 ,6E @# K2\,+ +8C&0# @(+l#@D8h+76
(* +# &BK [w
,+ .8h+*
# 7&7+8Au<gh 1 :;1Ew+$3&E
iK
< 1+
;8=+1
# 7&1+8CžEu+
;8h
+ G]a2m :5&(')&$HB7NP6&0#@23bŒ9a$
:&E@D2L] 5# ,b8=E#0DŒ9:5#
+- + E&
:# &6Q,+ a+*HB6<Ha&51a] :
&
H')+BJNc*@+1 H')a+,E\8J *,+$&6# @EB
4.3
NP;'++Metrics
@# 3+#C}: EJ# ,%K8=E@@(1,QK&-
5.1
Nc/,+Network
d8=E#<#Throughput
')58=+23+4PE# ,+ #'EL: ,
+# ,E #O 3a$+,+Q+8A$1
a4$%+# +@@DLl')HM:L/*:
bw EB
ƒQ')HE M <6M(e+8%E#,+- @„ w&+ L„8…†‡ˆm„ˆU‰†ˆ8ŠG‡CF„T…:†‡ˆm„ˆ OF„T…:†‡ˆJˆU„
„T…:„AFJ
>7
E,)iG (/ &EPl&0#@EfBd‚x+&+„6El:MD 0
,m+
8h7 ,cm
a4EHBd‰ }+&@EFKE M
a4E<,
8h7Hj+aEmnHuc :+# @k+# $M+mnHuP w&+ BdNPl+# $0 &E< wH+ˆ8*
a4E
H# 3Q7$0+&
(%+# ,-V@"(HM &wE %M 0 &EF9 #E&+# ,/
a4E
&+%} ')1 % +4< +/+ +4)-
„T…:†‡ˆ1„ˆU‰†ˆUŠG‡<
a4)a.7EEH+w.@@ ,+:+
1 #)+Hw35+@@8AD3,E:+F:H# w ,6\+8A
a4)a3+&+ BK–QH+w)„T…†‡ˆm„ˆ
OF:„T…:†‡ˆ6ˆU„„T…:„AF97
E,FC
m (M +4)E @DL
H')@f+@E,/0 ,+@\ AB
.Œ9O+87
E, S `O^Y T ` +023+4*+# ,+ #HB%‰
+@0+D'EQ$#Q1> 7(a +,l&
( &›+%
(< :6&
H':,<1 >>8?
D% HF 8hQHE*#Hb]Em“B;Ncw# L
*& +18J 1EbE#,E #HB
5.
‡SIMULATION
GE e$RESULTS
l e# @DG+80E#>&0# @(+ B
NP68h$# Em0&*83'E@# E *23+4G+# ,+#HFC+# ,>(')a H+fF.
eMaŒ9\+818?@l+')6+
E# ,+ #HB
NPmwb m#@D2Lk+86'E(E# lE&6 (E M+86E#ba}E- e
E,jghNj|\iaFK (]g KŽQiaF3+
‹
sg?a}Ei
+#1H!$# wgVŽ%Ž*iaB+Nc%# 1 Ž%Ž…}:E[
<
+ @H9F
E,ˆ+ ‡ l
@H9F*E@DL…
((
+ @H9F+
l')L: ,0 @H9BKNP* $E<,+b+
')aL , + @HM+ ')L: ,5
+@H}7Ž%Ž5F)H# dd7$ejE@(‹8=+&/ „,) PPE@&
H# HP$L]}:M+#<H!$#wB>: 0
(a6\ w@DL™‹$E@\kc#H 8=+]D#&0')$ ,ˆ&
H': ,
:F:* $+*0 @# QQ,+ M1 QE @DLM
((
6
+@HPma&D810 H023+4m+# ,E #
1D +#;+$L54: H1@H,+7+89# H6& H',Q :BONc
7+A,+ *7(a +,
:ŽŽP+'+HQ1DE#A
((HF
*1DE#% (1 8=+&/(+>++#%&
H': ,
:+# @b+%*# l8h%+# ,<EB
‰J,E#0H1 *+@A +4M+# ,E #HF H@# @]
8"+++8A (Q
a4)aK,+ aH0 ;7'EHfF$'E# / >8"+E +85& (': ,P :b… m a24‹8=+
5+&0 E*+83}: EB$2> 6H+01604<+: 6& (': ,\:F@@8=E##')+ 'E
+# ‹z Eq E#,E #HBˆ‚18=<GuEq &
H': ,m :
HEF,+ %'E,EEB
‚.}aHfF+ 7&0#@"(E O1D/+@@7}:E ;+a'E
8=+&˜ 0w\$L]bE @&/,+P+\&
H': ,
:(EHGl623+4B6 6&a +& H
/+# ,+ #0$Ld#dc~+pEq +&
(Hc]l +G$+@ F9&/: ,M<+# ,E #,Ha*
Eu)q›8h*+
# G&F1'E‹1D…tEu)q&
H': ,c:BsJ+@„n
@w1*&/}&0#&x
M&:#&0# &{E# #1a')HMG+$L
&0#@"(EP#c6t)uEq &
H': ,G:1D„+@@3+E
+ @H9B
Nj/5# +8f %}: E7+a'EEF:8h&/+*$
CH+3+A&0# *(')f .&0#@EA1D\ 1}: + B
Nd(a +,*+@+ 1$K+K(Œ9.E#,+ F$#ODK# @7 (1Dba}\8=+&/+l5E&6
&
H'$ ,l :&+0aŒ9')@DL$B0N… m7(a E,b\H+a'+fF
u +
b +# &
0
žEu<+
b +#Q&
œG}&0#&
“n+B “)q
~+“:B Eq
œb &6# &
n:B zEq
nEn+B uEq
M$TK^1r &T:jC^P7:3bbj7jC^ 8}@cE:@3lK9GTj7:U3
Kl7 5 jb:T9Vn7~T9 5 K 8E:@}:j7:l7:3 5 S19FE~T_
RU89F:F 5 87:KU3",
lE#G :G
< ]7Lˆ+8*a,eb&
H': ,
:6mDQ > 6w
(EAFA
GM+ &E
H‡#Œ97++@f
a4E1@EB;O+@+ H %
>
(„1Dˆ&
H': ,> :0]&$66Pg?
E>p+iaB
Throughput (percent of packets received)
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
WD=ON ,PR=ON ,SRR=ON
WD=ON ,PR=ON ,SRR=OFF
WD=OFF,PR=ON ,SRR=OFF
WD=OFF,PR=OFF,SRR=OFF
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Fraction of misbehaving nodes
0.4
0.5
g )i7u0E b
# *&
2„ˆE# ,+ #<,+ FK b')L: ,] @Hˆ#')
+ . (AE @DLQ#')A@+@DL*8h+@@HdHa\ HBC‰E&
K,+ A;E@#
K C; J+@E7$A O,+ D[ H+$@DLG(Œ9%8=+&/+EB+mE]p6\#,E,EwQ+&
&(')&:;< ((1
&/LMH5D%#@D2L
l+ 8O * %}:E B
1
Throughput (percent of packets received)
ƒQ 7aŒ9;+89 7+ +& .+8f;.
; :K&/HL5'E
E#K @J%DC+#;!:#wJ5DŒ9$JO5E
&0#@"(Ed
‹ˆ++ a&0# @(+ˆ1Dˆ@,+$@L„'+H
(+&aBj ,EbH+ˆ# @D/…] :ba$E ,d
(l1D>0& H',0 :*GEQ# fF #7+% $E,
(
(PcM&0# @(+P1DP&<&
H': ,M :
23+4B% &/HLb+a#
+@@DLG#@D*>@,+$* +
a245E#,E #O1< 7:# &6.+89& H',* :
+B<‰ +\ w +FAQ\+H @<]<
((E@DL#'E8O‰J,E# g?i.1E# ,+ #K+8=+&
)~+qš +t)qx23m~u)q—
G~ Eq—&
H': ,6 :B
0.8
0.6
5.2
‰ +#Routing
,/(')Overhead
HE9F 5,+ G8=E#Q#'E-'EL: ,+AF
0.4
0.2
WD=ON ,PR=ON ,SRR=ON
WD=ON ,PR=ON ,SRR=OFF
WD=OFF,PR=ON ,SRR=OFF
WD=OFF,PR=OFF,SRR=OFF
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Fraction of misbehaving nodes
0.4
0.5
g?
ižEu0E
l
+#*&
d}@F)7:@9XS;
?N9FE:FEZ:9z 5 .^7>+9G7
"9FE:zR
T>+9V7o' 5 KZ8E:@}_7:C7:3 5 j79FE:27:@9XS;
?Z,
((
P7(a +,e+AFKE@LP7
E,]E‡gh7(a +,+E@DL
iaF
l')L: ,5+ŒOB.– ,6*')aL ,5+Œm,+ >
E# +38h+&
(+AF:%,+ 17(a +,+-VE@L<#')
*[
6 1(')HE<,+ aH w#w3$L5 77(a +,\1D
1 [ H+ 7< B3 *
+,/+ l
((
#')1 H1 %(') E/EH$L0
+,0
((
#;1D/
((Hy 7+@D2L05
E#}:*E#%H!$#w
@HfB{ ]')L: ,cEj#')> @# / m(')HE
H(H$L<
((;1/
,\E#3}:*E#%!:#wB
‰J,E#ž6(1*&E# $3+8O(')HE/ #H/:L+'+ ,/ 0DŒ9$*+# ,l}: EB<0,Hw5Œ9E
E# ,0(')a H+M#@78"E&›# ,6 Ž%Ž‡8=H#EF1 a
7E#7E#QH!$# w8=+%<w
(+l01aM Q+ @DL
4: H1*E#f@#
;#H*& (': ,7:BJ‰ +At)uEq
&
H': ,M :e 6 ,Ee&E@D2L]
FC 0'E E]8"E& n(~+q€>~t)q€1 dŽ%Ž 5+a'+eP ((HB‚$Ll+#H!$# wQ,E (HG$LmŽ%Ž™1@@ $:
Q +4/1DC„T…:†‡ˆJ„ˆU‰†ˆUŠG‡]
m„8…†‡ˆC„ˆ P
+4$FJ1ad,H@DLcH+/ (')a H+fB>C+ @l~b@w6 &/}&0#&’
0& &6# &’(')HE58h+3+$L6+89 7&6# @E
1D>+@@fE+ 1 + @Hb%t)uEqx&
H':,0:B
O
+,1&a +&jD@D8E@L*EA')L&/+@@$+&+# $
+83}:l(')HEe+P$LmE& ,M 57
E,-+ @DL
,+ <1D< %@@D- @H,+ ABO‚@F)%E H<(')HE
* \Œ9H>$LG 5 H<e& H',M:Qm a24Bk–,Pˆl7(a +,d+ ˆ (&
( &6H /E#,E #0+8 M +4d$L…nž)q (
t)uEq&
H':,c :/1kE @DL…ž)q EDE
@Q23+4
(')HE]g?\‰J,E#\žlg )iiaB
1
WD=ON ,PR=ON ,SRR=ON
WD=ON ,PR=ON ,SRR=OFF
WD=ON ,PR=OFF,SRR=OFF
WD=OFF,PR=OFF,SRR=OFF
+# ,+k G(')a H+…EHˆ:L„>}: + /M,+ D8= H+$HF@@DLj1‡
l b+#ME#]H!$#w
>H')+"c& H',G :FJ Ma} E6w@@3&(')
alE# ,+ #HBo8hEFQm&/+jEl1Dj ,E
(')HE]:')+@')# 5# d+5 +Hc L]# ,E/E
+ @7
MK|‚B. % %@,Ew78?+a+%+E#:,58=+
0'E H+e\E#<!:#wFC<(')HEP+P,+ D8=H+$@DLmH#H]:Lm+&I ,M @HL]P
((
,%E#OE#KH!$# w.
\ +,*E&;+8 7+E+ 3'E@EH08=+&D,)( ,E#1!:#w;+
<)+Hww&7G,E+@K‘nEFtFfnt+” B
Overhead ration
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Fraction of misbehaving nodes
0.4
0.5
g )i7u0E b
# *&
5.3
Effects
NcPE&
d&0of#@"False
(E mDetection
8 c,+# @]7(a E,‹1o
7(a +,k
(P$m ]+m8?@ˆED')B ‰J,E#kp
H1*< 4GE#,E #*@+w\$L> 0
+,b +@DL*+ ,1@@D-V
H')\:BJ K# @DJHP
(
+# ,+ #.;+3+ +@DLŒ9H<$L68h+@%ED');+
( aL&/L')M
H')%[
@f*Œ9F1H
@HB
1
WD=ON ,PR=ON ,SRR=ON
WD=ON ,PR=ON ,SRR=OFF
WD=ON ,PR=OFF,SRR=OFF
WD=OFF,PR=OFF,SRR=OFF
Overhead ration
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Fraction of misbehaving nodes
0.4
0.5
g?
ižEu0E
l
+#*&
M[E: 5 BZ
5 E:8S 5 F:9Gj7:OU}@+EUT3k 5 FT9GN F:9Vj7o>
?@9[9GF7 5 5V5 7 5 9G6389Gb>
?@9
9GF7 5 5V5 7 5 , M;E 5 89Vb 5 ^ 9G9A83oTTj7 5 9;9FE:R
T>ca
9Vn7 5 KZ8E:@}_7:o7:3 5 ,
%&@"(D2L/E#,E #;HM#H<68=j8?+B]‰JDwHFOM:5 @DLP+Hd0&
H': ,
+# @M H')Q&(')H+#78C ':E# :Ey 7@w ,0 ,+
8=+<8h7( ,>+db
a4EHB 83 :\&(')0+#\8
+,EQ8"H!$# $@DL/E# ,+l0:%G# (EG8O&
H':+; L0&/HL0Q#@+@Q#1\ 3@$HEfF
< E#<+# @c5Œ‹+# ,>(E#
e&GBl <8?
(1&+%8?+@\ED')%(*+HMl *u0+
l +#
&0&0#@E\+\E& H>lžEulE e +# 6&
&0#@"(E FC+H1eeJ+@<“FA# * *+ @#+AB
J @“b(1H')+,+'E@# 088?@M+D'E+H
$L6&6# @E<# K8h+3H+/
# 1&%
<&
H': ,
:*:,EEB
‚+;8h+7
(&/LE#$8h %&@(+# ,E #
+ 8O*7(a E,y 8=+&/ 1D>+ l1D +#%8?+@5ED').+ .E 18 @&DE;8 7(a +,BK‚KH/b:El“FD8C5+@@Eb$#;1 @ %7(a E,
C7D,8=+O ; }:C :K%8=+01
a4EHFJ&/HL* ')a
(')HJ; +4)O,% &DH9B 8&/+$LQE@@+ K$#O(')O&EF( 3
E,Q&/L+a@L0+#&; O a}K:13&
H': ,BJ†QH3')HF$D8A :%E w$@L0}:*+@@EFOD&/Lm+a#
+@@DLm +0E# ,+ #Q
E#*
a4E%E#
lH8O ,EbE&&6# H(ElL$B
Ja$1&
H': ,0:
u0+
b +#Q&
žEu0E
l
+#Q&
uEq
n+nEn+B ~
“EzB u
E q
E~:B + p:B ž
nu)q
Ez u:B “
t)u:B n Eq
žEž:B žE“:Bn
~+uEq
p : B “ :B p
~ + q
žEuB p+zB “EuEq
žEp:B tEžB p
“ + q
“:nEB “
~$nEB p
M$TK^ ;
y 8
5 7PJ9FE 7^JKZUbR 5 ` 5 9V} 5 KZ@9XS;@T7Q9FE: 5 8>c73P73
5 jC89V7 5 ,;{ }@FT29G?87=RF 9FE 5 jb:T9Vn7 5 S1 9FET_$R@T9F:F 5 87:TK^U3",
t)uEq
uB t)p:B ~
5 U>+73P 5 k9Gjb
;K++ a;8h+3.
K aH+H08h+@%ED').1@@ # @D
&+1
( K @#
,\# aH<&
H': , :EB.
((31@@ / /+#7&%+#1H!$# w;\Qw
(+AB; % H1 (')HEMl a24F #1D
+@l(':"* 6
,M :61eM8" a\@w5+8;E#
8h%7+#HaEB
Throughput (fraction of packets received)
1
6.
C„E#RELATED
G4: H1@H,EEF*WORK
]l „'+# @DLj # @ H…3+4
0.8
EeaEe+83+# ,M&
H':+D[
0bEm $<4:F1+@D +# ,+k b@'++$3+4„$L…:&DAFœb#$L
+ *(- A#
(-2‚7')<+‹# ,Pw+G')a+E# ,M$E@8=+& ";LIH+$ 5E#,M8h+@#‘ ~E~H” B mD
4FfL>#,E,Ew\E#:a&H+#M#6E# ,M&w+,++
ME#,<# 9B; 74b&/L/\+ @H+@\
Ee $/ 45P
(<w+ M'E+\+# ,>+$+@F
# G1|\
| 6F: ('E*GE+Hl8hEb$ +4:B
0.6
0.4
0.2
No False Positives
Regular Watchdog
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Fraction of misbehaving nodes
0.4
0.5
g )i7u0E b
# *&
Throughput (fraction of packets received)
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
No False Positives
Regular Watchdog
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Fraction of misbehaving nodes
0.4
0.5
g?
ižEu0E
l
+#*&
y;:T
5 7QC7:@9 S[
?H9FE:F:E:Z:9€KZqa
9 S[@87C9VE:z
@:T[S[89V>+E:3m7:3~S;T9V>cE3m9VE:T9‹Fqa
ZF9 5 7:NR 5 J 5 9V} 5 ,
E#<+
<†QE;:')w,)(Qw#H6D[
H(%+#+D
>EG$\ +4:%# ,< +@bL+,++$Lf‘ ~+p(” B9E#
+ d†*E0+4El M':—
(<e+ b,E@b:b‹+ˆE
$% a24<HM1# w# 75@(… $L+@
#D2L<+
@H…H'++@+ @D2L$B.8=+EF:#,\* ,E@1 :7*(':1+
&+:J +4$- 1a'+F)# <.QD[ H1# D2L$FO')L4$L$BO +@"5L+,++$L5+@@(1KQD[
H(
+# L9y 7'E(*4)L/<*E4)b# M$<
(%+
lw #H\++O&0# @D @K :BOC%,E0%a[ H+F)1# +8 K :J1D6'+;4)L O&6# w w+$@DL5E@@+EB
:# F+&E# $.*#w8=# @(+46+< 7a[ H%# D2L$F+l:# 1&6# w7E&+&*&0#@@Q :B
C]8h#8=#w>(+4ˆ&<(')<&EF9E#‹+
†*++y9 &\#Q 6a8=,B *E @0 'E
*@E,6:+89&1 +# ,+
%')a3+# @%E&&H0\('); %D[
H(*# D2L9y 4)L$B.:
(
8" ,M@@H1# E&E&Hba')/+& #6
'+l4)Ld:+@@DL‹8"E& lE@‹'E(b4)L9y < B
:68= ,G&H %
5P(+4)\&6# w*[
@D/l@"(,E/:# &6+8 :\1Dcb 5&< +P
(')a7 D[ H\# D2L9y %%4)L$B
: 6+ M‚%
E>‘ ~+“(”A@# (QE&%+8f %#D2Lw# K8h+ ,5+0 $1 a24:3
0:')w,)(Q+0 $123+4:
+&EH…86@H˜E& #-VHM :b#a…+bE&]+ @+FO +523+4:F.+ P.|Q‚%*1 <8=# @@3# @<4EL
L+,+ $LP&/LP +6/8hH@EBdb# 0')@+‹
wLw&{<1 /Q1@7':
&: D@D8fE/*&/w5':EFO,>bwL&&0 L+P4)L>8"E& [ w7': 7
3%\4)L$BO‚%8=a': ,5
4)L$F$ @H')\'*1@@J+1+,E I6+$LM+':\Q<&/w
}J7':3 .,+
+@@DL<:.DO4)L$BC 7#+
,0#G+b$w, +@f+8Oa'\(+4 K*
(L
:+„a4Be‚x&
H': ,>:/H+„&+# $5m"@D-8=':ea4k+,) wm +l :]$L‹+# ,„&,E@DL
@,+&/(l
<l+# ,+ˆl:bˆ+‹&0>3H
(1M 1:Ey %
aB
7.
FUTURE
+/$WORK
D+@14ˆka,P& (': ,
:/
„&,E ,] D/8=+&/+G&
‹E‹$
1D@23+4:B 2GQEm06E&68=#
+7*3E# @b@4)*<a}@+EB
NPG @+kE…+
# ,e&+b,++E#lw/8* GE,G
]
\ &*G& 6E&/@.'E@#
<H+E# ,+ #7>Œ9a$1# EB7•3#$@DLM3
(7}&$,%1DDŒ9$O7(a E,* +@O8h3,b1 dG :<6& (': ,BbE&0+87 '+ @
>+&I8h+6 (6@#
/ ,m &$
&$;+&+# $F) 7( a&$ ,$'E@?F+
7@L6230
,*E#K+#H!$#wJH+7
(')HEMH+#Hb$L/ 8h#+B
ƒQ#\&6# @+ \# +0e1P// PS/^ _
Y+_ # w/@E F%#<3]a} >8=+&/ >8
(>kH+c1sDmHs&/4)P#c+8a}@@DL
#wHe:BlA#wHe:@w6(M('++@+@PE&+
$7 +45 EF
637E#@0@4E1*+
@DLI178=+&/++8JE#1+# ,<a} E7l +B
•3#$@L‡d
]+ @DL’&:m‹ :+y m,
1++3:;# #w8=# @@DL0 6DK+;89
+,G&
&˜\+')/
e&*
(5l :
3& H',BCN…E#;1
E,\+a'EEF$ 7 (
H +17& H',5:BK‚%/E:':+# &$
3E# @b*6')#9 18"E&6@+@5 +%@L$HF
#ad<1•JFJ1„‚%•58h+@3m')H9Bm 5E#@
@@Hˆ 7
((.K
E5
( K+ 6@HK 7:y
(,E%++,E@DL$B
‚%@@; M&6# @+ 0$Hdd 0 +0# b• "3Ž (
+#;1M \@+@D2L/H!$#&$B.ƒQ#3 }:3,E)@9;
+@DLI% Hk7E#,5a} E38=+&š1DM1• H1
+&&Ek„&+wG a24… @H(+ BƒQ#l8=$# lE#@
ma + ,+68"E&˜&H# ,E# ,+ #HF9+EH>
a4$F9M&H+# , 5&\ME&@a0@+ @0 &wEfFO# d0d‰O7 w8haHB>‰ 5<w\ &:[H(E>l Qae'E5E#@">&(')\8=+&/ /,E[ H+$@DL„d MH+M1 / /7(a E,]0+
')EB
‰J
@@L$FH3K3E#@"*@4)O1'++@#
(.O7
E,1
*
((
+ a,<@LlGE D+l0E#,E #HB
8. CONCLUSION
‚1P $/23+4:0(bd H ,E@DLdE& ,m(H>+81H(aP1Dd+H@+ @H+ F. # LP':#@+@
&/+$L% ,+A1 :f A&
H')J1E#,7
+4$B.‰+3+ #w38=+&/ 1/+/# $#wH0:':DE &:HF+D
1 LM0w%# bE#,0& (':+HB
2M 1
1\+ +@DLI23<E @\}:+ 7<|\:Ž &D,)M lŒ9<8Q+# ,e&
H':<‹E‹$b4:b-< m7(a +,k
… e
HBxNc] H˜
(
l2ca !$# aH+>+# ,+ #/$L nHpEqjP4]1Dc&:&+ @D2L$Ff1 @MH+,m0>8
(')HE0 &E K5 * &E ;8=E&o 1w (QE#,7$E@?y Oz)q…*n(p+qMBO|*# ,7}:&O&+ @L$F
7(a +,*+ 5 .H0 aH+723+4+# ,E #J$L
~Ep+qMF1 @0H+,M5a$+,+0+8K(')HEG &wE18"E&n(~+qš/~t)qMB
<# @D5 Ho
\3H+c,E+c [+8%+PHH\#&0f8 E# ,% :C1 @3& &I ,7;Œ9
+8C&
H': ,5 :B)2lE D+M3* Hj 7+M
+ Q1DE#6S*^
_ Y+_ #w1+%}')(')HE9B
9.
Nc3ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
E#@"@4)7
+46|Q" %J ,FJaE7œG Fœb&/
Ž%E# +E#@+FA+
>K]:14b8=+*D*+&&$+]8"
+8 O
HBJNc;E#@0+@@4)3Q +4|+"3E08hK @ePH(@LP#E 5+83 +4Bl 4]+\# +Pd
6$LcG,+ aE# 5,ED8"08=+& ŠQ7xœb+ @G•3+&<&0# H(+ 6ŠQ+4F 2EBjg?ŠQ7š|*)•3$œb$iaB ‹+ +AF
a,EmœG.7\# He$L]MŠ*+
+@K|*8= M: + b. ,+ , E# \‰ @@H1 fB
10.
‘na”59B REFERENCES
"+,EJ+ b%@ B
‚™|*w Ž%E#,<OŒ9
‚@,ED &›8h*œb+ @D2Leg?|*ŽQK‚*œ>iaB!3_YHU``X :Z Y T=W `CY _T=W# S T`a_S+T Y S KY `a_` U`0Y ]Y `KYQ^ :T $ZlS
X\`aT?R;Y+_ :Z
"!$#HFƒQ+\nHz+z B
‘ ~H” 6B "3
(,E ('++fF
‚\B|*&F
9B  4EHF+
KB 9 +,B
œG‚%•‚AN ‚sœbH#&›‚7%O+$+@C8h%N…@
C‚%ŠQB% &_wYHU``X :Z Y (')*+, $-F ‚#,E#w
nHz+z+tB
‘ “(” B "K$afF |0B ‚5B œG@I+F
|0B "B EE EfF 6B
•B†Q#fF
B +a'+B ‚sJ8=+&/+5•3E& Eb+8Kœb#@D-V†Q+
NjD@‚%M†Q$Š23+4/Ž+# ,<.$E@B _wYHU``X :Z Y *T=W `CY _T=#
W S T`a_ S+T Y S KY H`a_` U`0Y +eY `.KY Q^ :T $ZlS X
5`aT?R;Y+_ $Z "!$#HFƒQ+nHz+z :B
‘ t”Ž5B
•+w H+ G9BŽ\B|*+B%/Q# L A$+@IHE
C "!$#8hƒQ-|Q&/+ /Ž%E# ,<O+$E@Q>‚1
†Q$Š23+4:B 3_YHU``X :Z Y *T=W `0 aT=W S T`a_ S+T Y S KY H`a_` U`0Y +eY & `
KY Q^ T :ZlS X15`aT?R;Y+_ :Z 2, 34#HF‚#,E#w
nHz+zEzB
‘ H”69B •3++m+ 6B O4B C&+@@DL-2ƒH/Ž+# ,
‘n(pH” B%<B ƒQ#w +#HB.U S
X/T=W` A
YHY TCB
‚@,ED &˜g 1ƒQŽ‚*i KE]n\‰ # E +@AD[
H(+AB
‚1 +- Nc@L$F9nzEz+tB
eY ` %X ?WYHU 5`aT?R;Y+_ 0 #6Y+_ :Z*_Y ^
‘n(”59B†6BO4F ‚5B *+IEF
JB *+IEB9:#DLl+$+@
;F ƒQ+\nHz+zEzB
8h 2;K +u)~:Bn+n51D@%@$H+@JH023+4B eY `
5`aT?R;Y+_ SX3^)^ US+T Y B KE@?B “BfnHz+z B
‘ ž($
” "B OB
•;HF B<BNj w wF 6B E+ ,F+ bJB QB+4++?B
wK;O- EuE~:BnEn\NjD@%@$H+@C‚%H0Š23+4:B%
‘nHz(”5•B 1B
J4:%+
lJB "3 +,7HB †Q,E@DLb|QL +&
KY US+T Y eSZ)S 9`aF')E@?B “ $F
ŠQB !z K
,E
|*w
(E-2:H!$# Hl|Qw a- K1Ž+# ,
nEnž-n(~žF9:&0*nzEzEp:B
g?|\|i.8h+*œbE@5•3+& #B 3_YHU``X :Z Y \T=W `
')*+ $- KY `a_` U`0Y KY US+T Y ‘ pH”69B|F•B
1B J4: %+ b7BœeBŽHL$aHB
‚1/†Q$5ƒQ
%_UW T`UT :_` 3_YTVYHUY SX^E^ US+T Y F +,E
|*&/
/|*w+ ;a+\g ‚%ƒQ
| *i;Ž%E#,
~+“t+-2~t+tF9‚%# ,E#wnHz+z+tB
g 2$-V|Q8"aiaB eY ` %X hWYHU \`aT?R;Y+_ 0 #
6Y+_ :Z+*_Y (^ ;F ƒQ+\nHz+zEzB
‘ ~+u(”Ž5B O+4++AB–QDE +@ A 4:%O'E\•3Ew@DLG
NjD@%‚1M†$*ŠQ4B!3_YHU``X :Z Y ED '
‘ (” <B‰
+@@J
<B;+ +AFHB 1 +
6Y+_ WY^dY+eY & ` \`aT?R;Y+_ S XKYQ^ :T`a_ FJnHz+zEzB
$#&$EfB 2Š*jO wHF
–
• "34E@L$F
" .F –* • ! F+
QH}l9‚Ž%•F E#@L]nHz+zEz:B9‚C'++@+ @
‘ ~:na” "B9:&Db
B B *"(- A# -‚7')B
Z$
8=+
& !"$#&%(')&%*(%(+,%-./0B
#D2Lbœb
&78h+1 "3+ *HLlŽ%E#,
.$E@?BKY Q^ :T`a_KY US+T Y ` `a_ #HF KE@?B
‘ z(” B B *(- A#
(-2‚7')1+ >œeB
EAB +#a-2f
~:n+F
ŠQB
“K AB ~uE“-2~$nHuFCnHzEzFAB
Ž+# ,6bNjD@%ŠQ+4:B 2+_wYHU``X :Z 0 2143(T=W T`a_ ST Y S KY `a_` U`5Y +5`aT?R;Y+_
‘ ~E~H” "B9:&DAF9B
œb#$L$F
B B *(- f# -‚7')B
_wY+TVYHUY FCE$F•+ E :F9ƒQ+%“6n 5$Š'E&0%“:F
# ,<|Qw a- K1Ž+# ,<.$E@B nHz+zEzB
_wYHU``X :Z Y 0 T`a_9`aT'YHU `aT ' ^Y €Y&5`aT?R;Y+_
SXFD T?_ :T`X ' T` '9`U:_ T F9+G|Q,EF
•‚5F
‘nHu(” B B *(- A#
(-2‚7')F
œG@M:E fF+
M|H':"
‰ #
LmnzEz)p$B
"3L$aHB:E#A\‚1 ')*Ž%E# ,bgVJ‚ŽQi
.$E@;g 2$-V|Q8"aiaB ]Y ` %X6WYHU \`aT?R;Y+_ ‘ ~+“(”\‰3B$ w+/+
MŽ5B ‚ +AB Ž%# ,
0 7
# 6Y+_ :Z*_Y (^ fƒQEa5nzEz+zB
|*# 4:@,;:#DL# 78=+Q‚%:-V $N…@
ŠQ4B "B•3w+ +AF "B•;F+ >œeBŽ$
‘nEna”5JB +E
+m+
lQB AEfB9:
(+- "+
g ;B iaBF '9`U:_ T _wY+TVYHUY G3(T=W T`a_ST YS 6Y+_ WYa^
J8h&/+\‚ +@DL18OŽ+# ,0.$E@%8h+*œbE@
_wYHU``X :Z 8HJ`UT :_` Y+T` 2KY Q^ :T`a_ 'U ` U`aFAnzEzEz:B
‚1-V†Q$ŠQ+4:B 2_wYHUa``X $Z Y *T=W ` T='
W S T`a_ S+T Y S KY H`a_` U`0Y +eY `
‘ ~t”|0B 6B$EfBO_ ^ TVYZ+_Sa^W 1IAW `Y+_ SX1_wS)UT U`aB
KY Q^ T :ZlS X15`aT?R;Y+_ :Z 34#HF
‚%# ,E#w
•3Ž%•j.FAnHz+z :B
nHz+zEzB
‘ ~ H”\ 5•7œb–oœb+
(a>O wHB 5•7œb–oœb+
‘n(~H”\|0B EE +AF
|6B ‚\BœG@DIEF
B ";$AB
|QL +&
. wNjD@+ Gœb+ @LGO}: + 7< B
+#*Ž%E# ,O+$+@A8=+*œbE @\‚1l†$ŠQ+4:
89(8J<0('&9"!K2.%(-(./K.L0/">*BJƒQHB
g 2$-V|Q8"aiaB eY ` %X hWYHU \`aT?R;Y+_ 0 #
(
n
~$FCnHz+zEz:B
6Y+_ :Z+*_Y (^ ;F ƒQ+\nHz+zEzB
‘ ~+ž(”5•B - <B C+AB ‚$':D2L "+HlŽ+# ,‰+%‚1-V†Q$
|0B EE +ABJaE
@J•3+&&0# H+AB‰ #
Lb~uEuEu:B
œbE@\ŠQa24:BM _` ` 1`a_ Y S KY ! US+T Y N:Y:_ S 'E^`U S `6Y ]Y `05`aT?R;Y+_ :ZlSX
‘nH“(” B E# b+ B C+(B
|‚Ž9‚ Oa4E%ŽQ+
KYQ^ T :Z' T` F ;+@ BtFŠQB~$F ABnHu+“-nH“+zFfœG(a
ŠQ4lO+$E@B 2_wYHU``X :Z Y *T=W `F
nHz+z)p:B
p :gwn(i ~:na-2“E~:FJnz Ep:B
‘nt” 0B - "B)Q
MŠ6B†6!B 3L::B f$H+-‚bŽ+# , ‘ ~+p(”$KB +#]+
JB B9†*++BC# ,l‚1m†$6Š23+4:B \`aT?R3Y_ ]SHZ)S 9`aFE')E@?BnH“:F) B žF$Š'E&0 (|*&0KnHz+zEzB
g C‚%Ž*i;mœb+ @\‚1l†Q$Š23+4:B 23_YHU``X $Z Y T=W ` AY :_aT=
W S T`a_ S+T Y S KY `a_` U`5Y +eY `KY Q^ T :ZlS X15`aT?R;Y+_ :Z
, 3!$#HFƒQaE\nHz+z :B
‘n H” 0B - "B)Q
MŠ6B†6!B 3L::B Q$H+w ,/mœb+ @\‚%
†Q$*Š23+4:- A$H(E- "Hmœb# @DHw*‚%@,++D &B
2 !' + +FŠQa’ƒ@H B
‘nHž(” wK7‰ˆœG‚Š*K…Nc4, E##
:a 1|Q(8=B
89(8!:%((;,9<'=22:-&"$#+,>2=20&%(?@&*B