COMMUNITY-BASED ECOTOURISM DEVELOPMENT IN JATIGEDE RESERVOIR REGION IN SUMEDANG REGENCY Djuwendah, E 1, Tuhpawana2, Kusnadi, E 3, M.Arief 4 1, 2,3,4 Dosen Prodi Agribisnis Faperta UNPAD email: [email protected] ABSTRACT Jatigede Reservoir region is an area with a combination of plain and water areas that have multiple functions, as power generation, irrigation water supply, fisheries, and tourism destinations. Thus, the tourism that was developed in the reservoir area must be the tourism that supports the reservoir function as well as natural conservation. Ecotourism is a tourism activity that sets forth certain natural beauty, activities and attractions as its attractiveness as well as supports conservation efforts. Community-based ecotourism development is expected to increase land carrying capacity, widen employment opportunities for local communities as well as maintain environmental sustainability. The purpose of this study were to identify Jatigede Reservoir potentials as a tourist destination and to identify local communities’ participation in the management of Jatigede Reservoir ecotourism. This research used qualitative descriptive method with case study technique. The data source was obtained through interviews, documentation and observation. The research result showed that the development of the forest around the reservoir was potential for tourism attractions, such as outbound arena, camping, hiking, and off-road driving. The utilization of fertile rice fields and the reservoir dam water was also potential for agro-tourism, fishing tourism, and water tourism. Community involvement in the management of Jatigede Reservoir ecotourism were still limited. As an implication, it is needed the policy which is based on local potential development and the full community involvement in the planning and management of the ecotourism in order to suit the needs and culture of the local community. Keywords: ecotourism, Jatigede Reservoir, development, community empowerment 1 INTRODUCTION Tourism activity is one of the sectors that have their roles in development process and regional growth, because besides becoming contributor to economic growth, tourism sector can also become the stimulus of the growth of other developmental sectors, such as plantation, agriculture, commerce, and industry. According to Nugroho (2011), tourism development has a significant role in economic, social, and environmental aspects. In economic aspect, tourism sector contributes to the foreign exchange savings from the visits of international tourists, and to the GDP with its components. In social aspect, tourism has a role in labor absorption, the appreciation for national arts, traditions, and cultures, the improvement of national identity, and others. Sumedang Regency is one of the regencies that have excellent sectors of agriculture, tourism, and culture. Based on tourism policy of Sumedang Regency announced in RIPPDA (Rencana Induk Pengembangan Pariwisata Daerah) 2013, tourism development is directed to the availability of adequate tourism objects, and is supported by reliable tourism agents. One of the new tourism destinations in Sumedang Regency that have an integration between nature and man-made elements and is potential to develop is Jatigede Reservoir. Jatigede Reservoir construction has various purposes (multipurpose) that result in community welfare. The purposes of Jatigede Reservoir include water control, power plants, raw water supply, and tourism. Since the first time it was officially announced by Minister of General Work and Public Housing, Basuki Hadimulyono, on Monday, August 31, 2015, the tourism potentials in the reservoir region began to come up. Along with the water pool heightening of Jatigede Reservoir, there have been many tourists visiting, particularly on holidays. Jatigede Reservoir tourism object sites that become the mainstays are Wana Wisata 2 Tanjungduriat and Puncakdamar, which are located in Cisitu District and Darmaraya District. Natural tourism object development in Jatigede region has automatically changed the function of forest and the land use around it, so that it is necessary that there is some regulation in the land and forest arrangements in order to make it not only increase the domestic income, but also maintain ecological preservation and local culture. Ecotourism development which involves people is the best choice to ensure environmental sustainability as well as to give some benefits for the local community. This is parallel with tourism-based community empowerment. This research aimed at inventorying the ecotourism potentials that could be developed in Jatigede Reservoir region, and identifying community involvement in the tourism development in Jatigede Reservoir region. LITERARY REVIEW The national tourism industry development attempt is stated in Undang-Undang No. 10 tahun 2009 about tourism. According to statement, tourism is a variety of tourism activities, and is supported by various facilities and services which are provided by community, company, government, and local government, while tourism industry is a group of tourism businesses which are related to each other in producing goods and/or services for the fulfillment of tourists’ needs in managing tourism. According to Copper, et al (1992:81) in Sugiana (2013), there are 4 components of tourism assets that is needed in a tourism destination. The four components are attraction, accessibility, amenity, and ancillary. Tourism attraction is an object that has attractive power over a person to enjoy/watch it, so that they are interested to visit it. Generally, there are three tourism attractions: 3 natural attraction, cultural attraction, and special interests. Accessibility covers all transportation infrastructure that connect from and to the tourism destination in relation to the duration spent and distance taken through land, sea, or air routes. Amenity encompasses a variety of activities to fulfill the tourists’ accommodation needs along the tour, such as lodgings, food and drink supplies, entertainment area that give comfort, conveniences, good services, and sanitation cleanness which guarantees health and security. Ancillary services covers various institutions that facilitate the development and marketing of the tourism destination. The organizations include governments, private companies, and tourism associations. The Ecotourism International in 1991 defined ecotourism as “responsible travel to natural areas that conserves the environment and improves the well-being of local people” (Epler Wood, 1996 in Lash, 1997). According to WWF Indonesia, 2009, there are 5 principles implemented in ecotourism development: (1) ecotourism sustainability in economic, social, and environmental aspects, (2) institutional, local community, and partnership developments, (3) community-based economy, (4) education, and (5) site plan development and implementation, and ecotourism site management. The five principles of ecotourism development can be implemented, if there is synergy between stakeholders involved, such as government, ecotourism managements, tourists, and local communities around the ecotourism regions, of course. Community-based ecotourism takes social dimension of ecotourism as a further step by developing a form of ecotourism where local community have full control and involvement in the management and the development, and the main proportion involves the rest of the benefits in the community (WWF Indonesia, 2001). 4 The pattern of community-based ecotourism doesn’t mean that the local community perform solely the ecotourism business. In the implementation level, ecotourism is considered as a part of integrated development done in a region, so that the involvement of related parties from communities, society, government, business world, to nongovernmental organization are expected to build a network and to perform a good partnership in accordance with their respective roles and expertise in order to help maintaining sustainable use of resource. METHODOLOGY This research was a qualitative research with case study approach. According to Moleong (2007: 6), qualitative research is a research intended to understand descriptively the phenomena experienced by the research subjects, such as behaviors, perceptions, motivations, actions, and others by using various scientific method. Qualitative research departs from certain case in certain social condition. Thus, the researcher chose study case approach. Qualitative research uses case study research technique, which means that the research is focused on certain phenomenon chosen and intended to understand deeply in a certain period (Haris Herdiansyah, 2010: 76). This research was performed in three districts: Situraja District, Darmaraja District, and Jatigede District of Sumedang Regency. The primary data was obtained through field observation and purposive interview with village officials and local community figures. The secondary data was obtained through literary review that is relevant to the research. The data was analyzed descriptively. Descriptive analysis is an analysis method used with the purpose to obtain the description which is deep and objective, and to analyze the data and information about the research object. The activities performed in analyzing the data were data reduction, data presentation, and conclusion as the research result that answers the research focus based on the data analysis (Gunawan, 2012). 5 RESULT AND DISCUSSION 1. Description of Natural Tourism Potential of Jatigede Reservoir Region Jatigede Reservoir has an attractiveness as a potential natural tourism object because it is supported by natural atmosphere with beautiful views and friendly local inhabitants. The region surrounding Jatigede Reservoir covers an area of 5,000 hectares. The tourism attractions developed include (1) water tourism in the form of fishing, motorboat, and water boom, (2) wildlife tourism, (3) camping ground, (4) sport tourism such as golf, paragliding, off-road driving, (5) mystical tourism, (6) agritourism such as rice fields, plantation, and fruit market, and (7) cultural tourism. Tourism attraction of Jatigede Reservoir region is fully presented in Table 1. Table 1. The ecotourism potentials of Jatigede Reservoir Region, Sumedang Regency Tourism Objects’ Location Name water tourism, “Pantai” Cisema, Pakualam Village fishing area, Banyu Bungur and Jatibungur motorboat, raft, Village of Darmaraja water bike District Wildlife Tourism Puncak Damar Pakualam Village of (Forest Tourism) Wildlife Tourism, Darmaraja District, Tanjung Duriat and Pejagan Village Wildlife Tourism of Cisitu District Waterfall Tourism Curug Cipelah and Bangbayang Village, Cikidang Situraja District Art Attraction Kuda Renggong, Sukaratu Village, Gondang, Darmaraja Village, Arawangsa, Beluk, Pakualam Village, Karinding, Custom Cimarga Village, Villages of Cisempur Sukamenak Village and Munjul of Darmaraja District Agritourisms of fruit Darmaraja Village, Darmaraja Village of market and Pakualam Village Darmaraja District, plantation and Sukatali Village Sukatali Village of Situraja District Wisata olahraga Golf Field, Hakulah Pakualam Village, Block Cimarga Village, and Linggajaya Village of Cisitu District No. Type of Attraction Note 1 Operating 2 3 4 5 6 6 Operating Operating not operating yet not operating yet not operating yet 7. Bumi perkemahan, 8. Mystical Tourism Paragliding on Batudua Hill, Mount Lingga Camping Ground of Puncak Damar Tanjung duriat and Mount Lingga Sites of Mount Lingga and Dayeuhluhur Cimarga Village of operating Cisitu District Pakualam Village of Darmaraja District and Cimarga Village of Cisitu District Cimarga Village of Cisitu District, Dayeuhluhur Village of Ganeas District operating operating . Water tourism sites in Jatigede Reservoir region were named in accordance with the names of the village where the tourism object exists such as “Banyu Bungur” and ‘Pantai’ Cisema. The attractions to enjoy are boating, charged Rp 10,000 a loop, and water bike, Rp 5,000 an hour. For those whose hobby is fishing, there are bamboo rafts, each of which is charged rental cost Rp 10,000 a day. Figure 1. Water Tourism in Cisema ‘Beach’ and Banyu Bungur The site of Banyu Bungur in Jatibungur Village of Darmaraja District is rather open; in the east, natural view of Mount Jagat/Cakrabuana and Mount Ciremai, and in the morning, sunrise can be seen from the grandeur of Mount Ciremai. The accessibility to Banyu Bungur is rather easy because of the availability of the road connecting Bandung City and Sumedang Regency directing towards Wado, Garut, Tasikmalaya and Ciamis. 7 Figure 2. Wildlife Tourism of Puncak Damar and Tanjung Duriat, Sumedang Regency The forest region around Jatigede Reservoir was being developed and managed by Perum Perhutani in the form of wildlife tourisms of Puncak Damar in Baros Block, Pakualam Village of Darmaraja District, and Tanjung Duriat, located in the Northwest of Jatigede Reservoir coastal area. This tourism site showed the beauty of mountain nature and the views over Jatigede Reservoir from the top of the hill projecting toward the reservoir. Although it was still in the phase of construction, there had been many tourists visiting. The recreation type which were going to be developed in Puncak Damar and Tanjung Duriat Block included camping ground, outbound arena, off-road route and culinary shelter providing various fish dishes menu. The access for visitors was through the road of the forest region and the street of Pakualam Village of Situraja District. In this wildlife tourism, there were parking areas for motorcycles and cars, i-Gazebo, camping ground, outbound arena and playing ground for children, small wooden mushola which looks natural. The entering charge to the wildlife tourisms of Puncak Damar and Tanjung Duriat of Jatigede is Rp 5,000 a person, while the parking cost was Rp 5,000 for cars and Rp 2,000 for motorcycles. 8 Figure 4. Tourisms Curug Cipelah and Cikidang of Situraja District of Sumedang Regency Other Natural tourism potentials in Jatigede Reservoir region is waterfall tourism. There are Curug Cikidang and Curug Cipelah in Bangbayang Village of Situraja District, which are the waterfall whose water doesn’t not drop directly to the ground, but, from 20 meters height, flows down through the naturally-arranged stones. Currently available sport tourism was paragliding on the top of Batudua Hill of Mount Lingga, while sport tourism potentials that could be developed is gold, water ski, rowing, and fishing. Like other Sundanese community in general, the people in Sundanese Regency is an agrarian community, which couldn’t be separated from farming culture lasting from generation to generation. That means that the underlying culture and tradition are the daily life and tradition of farming community. Some arts and ceremonies purposed to seek for blessing during planting season, thanksgiving during harvest, rejoicing during pounding rice, and other arts and cultures. Some of the cultures are Karinding Art, a musical instrument made of the midribs of sugar palm leaves or bamboo slats, Beluk Art, a kind of sound followed by musical instruments, Gondang Art, Jentreng Tarawangsa, and Kuda Renggong. 9 Special interest tourism in the form of mystical visit to Sumedang ancestors is located at the site of Mount Lingga and Dayeuh Luhur. Mount Lingga is the site of remains of Tajimalela, the King of Sumedanglarang, and the relocation place of the ancient tombs sites taken from the inundated area of Jatigede Reservoir located in Cimarga Village, about 12 kilometers from Cisitu District of Sumedang Regency. Other mystical visit tourism is Dayeuh Lukur, in which there is the tombs of Sumedang ancestors, Prabu Geusan Ulun with his wife and his vice regent (patih), and located at the top of Rengganis mountain range in Dayeuh Luhur Village of Ganeas District. Figure 3. The Map of Tourism Attractions of Jatigede Reservoir, Sumedang Regency The accessibility towards various tourism objects in Jatigede Reservoir region was relatively good. The strategic location made it easy to reach through Bandung-Cirebon Provincial Road. Tourists from Jakarta or Bandung could go through Padalarang-Cilenyi toll road, then go towards Sumedang District. From Sumedang town square, turn to the right and enter Jl. Sebelas April, which leads to Situraja square. About two kilometers from the Situraja square, there was a way down from Warung Ketan and turn to the left towards Sudapati Village-Pajagan and then towards Jatigede. The visitors from Cirebon, 10 Majalengka, Indramayu and Kuningan could go through Tomo-Tolengas and then go towards Cijeungjing Village of Jatigede District, then to the front areJatigede Reservoir tourism object. The existence of the tourism object in Jatigede region of Sumedang Regency was currently not supported by comprehensive infrastructure, because it was still on early development phase. Currently, the ring road of Jatigede reaching about 13 kilometers to the east, passing through Ciranggem Village, Merkasasih Village, Sarimekar Village, Jatinunggal Village, Tarikolot Village, Pawenang Village, Wado Village, Cisurat Village, until Darmaraja Village. Cisumdawu toll road reaching 60 kilometers and connecting Cileunyi, Sumedang, and Dawuan, and Kertajati International Airport in Majalengka were under construction. It’s expected that those could be the attractions for local and foreign tourists to visit Jatigede tourism objects and other tourism objects in Sumedang Regency. 2. The Zonation of the Utilization and Activity Partnership Potentials of Jatigede Based on Business Practitioners Besides being used as one of the sources of Locally Generated Revenue and giving prosperity for the local community, Ecotourism development can be made as a cultural preservation means and local genius development. By looking at the various tourism potentials of Jatigede Reservoir region, the government officials of Sumedang as one of the stakeholders of tourism should optimize the potentials for the sake of the community’s prosperity. The involved parties in the ecotourism development of Jatigede Reservoir include Balai Besar Wilayah Sungai (BBWS) Cimanuk-Cisanggarung, Local Government Official of Forestry and Plantation, Local Government Official of Tourism and Culture, BAPPEDA of West Java Province and of Sumedang Regency, local community around Jatigede 11 Reservoir, travel agents, tourists, colleges, and others. The stakeholders in the ecotourism development of Jatigede Reservoir, Sumedang, is shown in Table 2. Table 2. The Stakeholders’ Role in the Natural Tourism Development in Jatigede Reservoir Region No Stakeholder 1. Roles 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Management Offices of Jatigede 9. 1. Reservoir and Tourism (BBWS 2. Cisanggarung-Cimanuk, Badan 3. Otoritas Waduk Jatigede, Local 4. Government Office of General 5. Work, Perum Perhutani KPH 6. Sumedang) 7. Reorganizing and controlling the reorganization Producing regulation regarding natural tourism Creating plan documents Allocating funds for the tourism development Forming tourism driving groups Providing education and training Coordinating activity development Directing local community Creating the regulation Monitoring the natural tourism regions Providing infrastructure system support Coordinating the programs Preserving the region’s environment and culture Developing the programs Guiding the tourists 3. Tourism Industries (lodgings, restaurants and food stalls, travel managements, drivers, mass media, etc.) 4. Research institutions (colleges) Developing natural tourism activities Marketing Performing accompaniment and cooperation Opening employment opportunities Guiding the tourists Inventorying the potentials of the natural tourism region Providing education and training Penelitian berkelanjutan Performing natural tourism activity development Giving support and commitment Becoming volunteers Monitoring the regions 2. 5 Government Institutions (Bappeda, Local Government Official of Tourism and Culture, Local Government Official of Forestry and Plantation of West Java Province and Sumedang Regency) Non-Governmental Organization (NGO) communities 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 1. and 2. 3. 4. BAPPEDA of Sumedang Regency made the planning and mapping of the zonation area of Jatigede Reservoir region, reaching from tourism, agritourism, to non-floating net fish catching region zone. In the buffer areas of Jatigede Reservoir, there would be built golf field, Jatigede museum, culinary center, water boom, agrotourism of plantation, agrotourism of agricultural product market, and others. 12 The excellent agricultural commodities around Jatigede Reservoir varied, such as sapodilla (Acrhras zapota. L) of Sukatali from Sukatali Village of Ganeas District, Pamela orange of Cikoneng (Citrus maxima Burm) from Cisarua and Thorny Palm fruit of “Bangkok” (Salacca zalacca) from Conggeang, coconut tree and sugar palm, whose are could be processed into palm sugar and coconut sugar. The fish potentials in the inundated area of Jatigede Reservoir were the raw materials of various local processed meals that could add the value in order to increase the farmers’ income. This condition gave opportunities for the agrotourism development in Jatigede Reservoir region. According to Afandhi (2005) in Bagus Rai (2013), agritourism construction and development for business world can be performed by three economic agents: State-owned Enterprise/Local State-owned Enterprise, National Companies, Cooperatives, and personal businesses. The three economic agents must be based on company management pattern in their management system, individually or through cooperation (joint venture), sharing, and others, with the principle of mutual profitability. Figure 4. The Plans of Zonation of Utilization and Partnership Potential of Jatigede Reservoir Source: BAPPEDA of Sumedang Regency, 2015 13 Based on the plans of zonation of utilization and partnership potential of Jatigede Reservoir, there are 12 tourism activities involving participation of local community, investors, and Local State-owned Enterprise in their managements as stated in Figure 4 above. 3. The Recommendation for Community-Based Ecotourism Development in Jatigede Reservoir Region Ecotourism development in Jatigede Reservoir region can be fast implemented across sectors and by encouraging high involvement of the local community. This is the basic concept of ecotourism development. Ecotourism development involving local community is the proper choice in order to maintain the sustainability of the environment, as well as to give optimal benefits for the local community. Thus, it is needed the cooperation among stakeholders, community institution strengthening, conservation attempts around the reservoir, as well as tourism promotion which is good and right on target. Local officials can simplify the licensing for the investors that is going to make an investment and utilize the infrastructure. Local community are also given counseling and guidance of tourism awareness in order to prepare the skills in tourism service providing sector. Among the zonation plan of the utilization of Jatigede Reservoir, the wildlife tourism object of Puncak Damar and Tanjung Duriat had been implemented and the management was performed through cooperation between Perum Perhutani KPH Sumedang and Forest Village Community Institution (Lembaga Masyarakat Desa Hutan). The form of community involvement is by being the tourism service agents consisting of tour guide services, tour motorcycle taxi drivers of tourism, space providers and parking services, various culinary products sellers, homestay service providers, café, and restaurants. Community involvement around Jatigede Reservoir can be increased more through 14 creativity and innovation in providing culinary and handcraft products to sell as souvenirs for tourists. In order to establish community-based ecotourism, it is needed institutionalism of the tourism object management organization and social organization having the role as tourism service management and facilitator among stakeholders. The enhancement of human resource capabilities is important in the effort to increase the role of local community in the ecotourism development. The trainings related to ecotourism and agritourism are necessary to be given to local community, and they need to be involved in the planning and development of the ecotourism in their areas (Nurhidayati, 2013). Participation of the local community can be increase through some strategies: (1) local community who have some lands in the built region are to cultivate their lands, so that it can support the increase of agriculture products that can be agritourism attractiveness and also encourage sense of belonging and sense of responsibility in the management of the region on the whole; (2) it is to involve local community directly in the company activities as employees, both in the agriculture and in the tourism services, tour guide, and others; in order to do that, the management need to take some steps and attempts to increase the specific knowledge and skills of the employees from the local community; (3) it is to provide facilities and the place for selling agricultural products, handcrafts, and souvenirs for villagers around the region, so that it can present typical product of the region and increase their income, and (4) local community are to be involved in the attraction performance of the local art and culture to be presented to tourists routinely and wellorganized. The ecotourism development in Jatigede Reservoir region needs the developmental phases as follows: (1) arrangement and preparation of the tourism objects, (2) preparation of human resource and institutional synergy in village in the management of the ecotourism 15 through training and guidance, (3) proposing community-based ecotourism program to get program support and funding from local government office, (4) improving means and facilities of the roads, (5) creating agritourism programs, (6) increasing local community’s creativity through training and guidance of agricultural product processing technology and marketing, (8) conservation and development of traditional art and culture to support agritourism program in villages, and (9) increasing cooperation with related parties such as colleges/research and development institutions for the guidance in the adoption of innovation and technology supporting the ecotourism. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION The potential of Jatigede Reservoir region in Sumedang Regency was quite good to be developed as ecotourism, because it has various tourism objects and attractions such as water tourism, wildlife tourism, waterfall tourism, sport tourism, camping ground, agritourism, art and culture tourism, and mystical visit tourism. However, currently, the potential had not optimally developed because of the inadequate supporting facilities, being still on the planning phase. In most of the ecotourism development activities, local community had not been involved in the program planning and evaluation, as well as monitoring the implementation of the program. In general, the participation of the local community was still limited in the context of the use of business opportunities emerging along with the development of Jatigede Reservoir tourism attractions. The form of local community involvement was still limited to being tourism service agents consisting of tour guide service, motorcycle taxis drivers of tourism, tourism boating service providers, space providers and parking services, various culinary products sellers, homestay service providers, and food stalls. The ecotourism development involving local community is the right choice to ensure the sustainability of the environment, as well as to give optimal benefit for them. In order 16 to reach that, it is needed the roles of and coordination among the stakeholders and social organizations in the management, control and conservation, as well as promotion of the tourism objects. In the context of ecotourism development in Jatigede Reservoir region, there are some recommendations, such as that in the ecotourism construction, there should be an integration among sectors and among regions. The construction of ecotourism region not only depends on the management in the region alone, but also it should be integrated with the outside of the regions and the buffer areas. It is necessary to arrange a multi-parties action plan of the work implementation (Rencana Aksi Multipihak Imprementasi Pekerjaan/RAM-IP), so that the involvement of the stakeholders like colleges, business world, governments becomes clear in their roles, tasks, and responsibilities. THANK-YOU NOTE This work is part of the research of Academic Leadership Grant, Sustainable Regional Economic Development (SRED) of UNPAD. Thanks for the Rector and the Directorate of Research and Community Service of Padjadjaran University, which have funded this research. We would like to express our gratitude for the help during the research to village chiefs and local community figures in Jatigede Reservoir region, BAPPEDA, and related local government offices in Sumedang Regency. REFERENCES Anonymous, 2009. Principles and Criteria-Based Ecotourism Society. Cooperation Tourism Product Director of the Directorate General of Tourism Destination Development Ministry of Culture and Tourism and WWF-Indonesia. . awsassets.wwf.or.id/.../wwf_indonesia_prinsip_dan_kriteria_ecotourism_jan_20 09.pd. [4 September 2016]. ----------------, 2015. Zoning Plan Area Utilization of Jatigede. Sumedang district -------------.2013. Master Plan of Regional development at Jatigede Sumedang district 17 .http://bappeda.sumedangkab.go.id/berita-281-rencana-induk-pengembangan-rip-wilayahjatigede--kabupaten-sumedang.html.2013/10/25. [15september 2016] Bagus Rai Utama, I Gusti, 2013. Agrotourism as Alternative Tourism in Indonesia, Solid Solutions for Poverty Alleviation https://tourismbali.wordpress.com/ 2013/03/10/model-ideal-agrowisata-indonesia-2/. [ 3 Oktober 2016]. Damanik, Janianto dan Weber, Helmut F. (2006). Ecotourism Planning: From Theory to Applications Penerbit Andi, Yogyakarta Gunawan, Iman. 2012. Cualitative Research Methods: Theory and Practice Jakarta: PT Bumi Aksara, Jakarta Herdiansyah, Haris .2011. Qualitative Research Methodology for Social Sciences, mold 2nd, Humanika Salemba,Salemba Humanika, Jakarta Moleong, Lexy J, 2007. Qualitative Research of Methodology., Penerbit Remaja Rosda Karya, Bandung. Nugroho, Iwan 2011,. Ecotourism and Sustainable Development,Pustaka Pelajar, Yogyakarta. Nurhidayati, 2012. Sustainable agritourism development based on community in Batu City, East Java. http://lib.ugm.ac.id/digitasi/upload/ 3208_RD201302011asriendahN.pdf [26 september 2016] Sugiama, A. Gima, 2013. Tourism Asset Development Framework of M odel Triple Helix, Akademisi- relationship Industti -Pemerintah, polytechnics Business Journal oration of Sriwijaya. X Edition, November 2013, ISSN .208512375 [28 September 2016] . . 18
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz