by
Vinay Couto
[email protected]
Anil Kaul
[email protected]
Gary Neilson
[email protected]
Joe Saddi
[email protected]
Driving Demand
Management for
Internal Services
The Role of BehaviorChanging Pricing in
Managing Demand
Booz & Company is a leading global management
consulting firm, helping the world’s top businesses,
governments, and organizations.
deep functional expertise, and a practical approach
to building capabilities and delivering real impact.
We work closely with our clients to create and deliver
essential advantage.
Our founder, Edwin Booz, defined the profession
when he established the first management consulting
firm in 1914.
For our management magazine strategy+business, visit
www.strategy-business.com.
Today, with more than 3,300 people in 57 offices
around the world, we bring foresight and knowledge,
Visit www.booz.com to learn more about
Booz & Company.
CONTACT INFORMATION
Beirut
Chicago
Senior Partner
+1-961-1-336433
[email protected]
Senior Partner
+1-312-578-4727
[email protected]
Joe Saddi
Gary Neilson
Vinay Couto
Rio de Janeiro
Sydney
Tokyo
Partner
+1-55-21-2237-8400
[email protected]
Senior Executive Advisor
+1-61-2-9321-2853
[email protected]
Executive Advisor
+1-81-3-34360-8600
[email protected]
Paolo Pigorini
Ian Buchanan
Partner
+1-312-578-4617
[email protected]
Anil Kaul
Principal
+1-312-578-4738
[email protected]
Akira Uchida
Zurich
Jens Schaedler
Partner
+1-41-1-206-40-54
[email protected]
Claudia Staub
Partner
+1-41-1-206-40-50
[email protected]
Originally published as:
Driving Demand Management for Internal Services, The Role of Behavior-changing Pricing in Managing Demand
by Ian Buchanan, Vinay Couto, Anil Kaul, Paolo Pigorini, Gary Neilson, Joe Saddi, Jens Schaedler, Claudia Staub, and Akira Uchida.
Booz Allen Hamilton, 2003.
$RIVING$EMAND-ANAGEMENTFOR)NTERNAL
3ERVICES
4HE2OLEOF"EHAVIORCHANGING0RICINGIN-ANAGING$EMAND
)NAWORDYES)TISTRUETHATINTERNALSERVICEORGANI
ZATIONSHAVEBECOMENOTICEABLYMOREEFFICIENTAND
MARKETORIENTEDINTHEPASTDECADETHANKSTOAHOST
OFSTRATEGICINITIATIVESINCLUDINGBUSINESSPROCESSREEN
GINEERINGSHAREDSERVICES%20ANDSTRATEGICOUTSOURC
ING"UTTHEYHAVEALSOGAINEDUNNECESSARYWEIGHT
$URINGTHESINTERNALSERVICEORGANIZATIONSGREW
ATARATEDISPROPORTIONATETOTHEGROWTHOFTHEIRCOM
PANIES!SMANAGEMENTFOCUSEDONMEETINGGROWING
CUSTOMERDEMANDTHECOSTOFDEMANDDRIVENSUPPORT
FUNCTIONSSUCHAS&INANCE(UMAN2ESOURCESAND
)4DRIFTEDOFFTHERADARSCREENANDSTEADILYUPWARD
(OWEVERNOWTHATGROWTHHASSTALLEDMANAGEMENT
HASREDIRECTEDITSFOCUSTOCOSTREDUCTIONnTHOUGHTFUL
LASTINGACROSSTHEBOARDCOSTREDUCTION4HEFIRSTPLACE
COMPANIESTYPICALLYLOOKTOFORTHOSESAVINGSISTHEIR
SUPPORTSERVICES
4ODATECOMPANIESHAVEATTACKEDINTERNALSERVICE
COSTSFROMTHESUPPLYSIDEAPPLYINGREENGINEERING
TECHNIQUESTOINCREASEEFFICIENCYANDPRODUCTIVITYOR
LEVERAGINGBESTPRACTICESANDSCALE/URRECENTCLI
ENTEXPERIENCEHOWEVERSUGGESTSTHATMANAGINGTHE
DEMANDFORSUCHOVERHEADSERVICESYIELDSEQUIVALENT
BENEFITSSEE%XHIBIT-OREOVERTHERESAGREATER
OPPORTUNITYINDEMANDMANAGEMENTASTHESETECH
NIQUESHAVENOTYETBEENFULLYEXPLOITED
4HE%VOLUTIONOF$EMAND-ANAGEMENT
&ORYEARSSUPPORTFUNCTIONSWERETREATEDASCOSTCENTERS
WHOSERESOURCESWEREALLOCATEDANDCHARGEDBACK
3ENIORCORPORATEEXECUTIVESDETERMINEDWHOGOTWHAT
%XHIBIT
$EMAND-ANAGEMENT$ELIVERS/VEROFTHE#OST"ENElT
""!#%& %)
&ACEDWITHSTAGNANTGROWTHANDINCREASEDCOM
PETITIVEPRESSURESCOMPANIESINMANYINDUSTRIES
AREREEXAMININGTHEIRCOSTSTRUCTURESTOEXTRACT
FURTHERSAVINGSANDSUSTAINADEQUATEMARGINS
4HISSEARCHFORSTEPCHANGEIMPROVEMENTSETSUP
ANATURALCONTESTBETWEENLINEANDSERVICEORGA
NIZATIONSONETHATPLAYSOUTINPREDICTABLEWAYS
"USINESSUNITS"5SCOMPLAINTHATTHEYBEARTHE
BRUNTOFTHEBELTTIGHTENINGANDPOINTTOSUPPORT
SERVICESASADRAINONTHEIRRESOURCES3UPPORT
FUNCTIONSPOINTTOBENCHMARKSTUDIESTHATSHOW
THEYAREPERFORMINGATBESTINCLASSLEVELSAND
HAVEALREADYSQUEEZEDOUTPOTENTIALCOSTSAVINGS
#ANTHEYBOTHBERIGHT
'#
&
!%%
&%$!&# !!) !"(%)
%!#!$%$
! %#%$
3OURCE"OOZ!LLEN(AMILTON
$%
#%$ %
# $# #!&# %!#"&#"!$
!&%! $
SERVICESBASEDONPERCEIVEDPRIORITIESVOLUMEOFWORK
ANDINTERNALPOLITICS4HE"5SHADLITTLESAYINTHEMATTER
4HESHAREDSERVICESMODELHASNOWLARGELYSUPPLANTED
THECOSTCENTERMODEL!CCOUNTABILITYFORALLOCATION
DECISIONSHASSHIFTEDDOWNTHELADDERTOTHEBUSI
NESSUNITSANDSERVICEPROVIDERSWHONOWCONTRACTFOR
SERVICESATAGREEDUPONLEVELSANDPRICES(OWEVER
WHILETHESHAREDSERVICESMODELISADVERTISEDASADIS
CIPLINEDMECHANISMFORENSURINGMARKETBASEDARMS
LENGTHTRANSACTIONSBETWEENBUYERANDSELLERITHAS
NOTALWAYSDELIVEREDONITSPROMISE-ANYCOMPANIES
COMPLAINTHATITHASNOTWORKEDASEFFECTIVELYASTHEY
HADHOPEDINLOWERINGTHEIRCOSTS3UPPLYANDDEMAND
FORINTERNALSERVICESSTILLDONOTMEETATTHEEQUILIBRIUM
PRICEPOINT4HEREASONSFORTHISIMBALANCEARESEVERAL
N
N
N
N
,ACKOFhFITFORPURPOSEv"5SDEMANDSIGNIFICANTLY
HIGHERSERVICELEVELSANDORGREATERCUSTOMIZATION
THANISOPTIMALFROMACOSTBENEFITSTANDPOINT
3ERVICEPROVIDERSEXACERBATETHEPROBLEMBYACCOM
MODATINGTHESEREQUESTSSOASTOMAINTAINHIGHCUS
TOMERSATISFACTIONRATINGS
-ISALIGNEDINCENTIVESTRUCTURES3ERVICEPROVIDERSARE
PULLEDINOPPOSITEDIRECTIONSBYCONFLICTINGINCENTIVE
SCHEMES4HEYAREDIRECTEDTOSATISFYTHEIRDEMANDING
"5CUSTOMERSWHILEALSODRIVINGDOWNOVERALLCOSTS
7EAKGOVERNANCEMECHANISMS4HEREISOFTENLITTLETO
NOCOMMUNICATIONBETWEENSERVICEANDLINEORGANIZA
TIONS3ERVICELEVELAGREEMENTS3,!SSERVEASAPOOR
SUBSTITUTEFORAMOREACTIVEANDENGAGINGDIALOGUE
)NACCURATEPRICESIGNALS4OAVOIDBEINGMICROMAN
AGEDBY"5CUSTOMERSANDTOALLOWFORCOMPARISON
WITHEXTERNALSERVICEPROVIDERSSERVICEORGANIZATIONS
SETPRICESTHATEFFECTIVELYOBSCURETHEIRTRUECOST
STRUCTURE7HILETHESEPRICESWORKFORBENCHMARKING
PURPOSESTHEYDONOTFACILITATEECONOMICDECISION
MAKING-OREOVERTHESEPRICINGMETHODOLOGIESARE
EXPENSIVETOMANAGE
4OOVERCOMETHESEOBSTACLESANDESTABLISHTHEOPTIMAL
EQUILIBRIUMBETWEENSUPPLYANDDEMANDFORSUPPORT
SERVICESMANYCOMPANIESAREIMPLEMENTINGDEMAND
MANAGEMENTMETHODOLOGIES%FFECTIVEDEMANDMANAGE
MENTISNOTANEASYENDEAVORWHICHISWHYITHASNOT
BEENEXPLOREDUNTILNOW)TIMPOSESONBUSINESSUNITS
SOMEHARDCHOICES4OMANAGETHEIRBUSINESSESINTHE
MOSTCOSTEFFECTIVEMANNER"5MANAGERSMUSTMAKE
TOUGHTRADEOFFSINTHENATUREVOLUMEANDQUALITYLEV
ELSOFTHESERVICESTHATTHEYCONSUME4HEYMUSTDIS
TINGUISHBETWEENhMUSTHAVEvANDhNICETOHAVEvSER
VICES4OPROMPTTHISPARADIGMSHIFTCOMPANIESNEED
TOTRANSFORMTHEIRSERVICEDELIVERYMODELBYLEVERAGING
THREECRITICALMECHANISMSPRICINGINCENTIVES
ANDGOVERNANCESEE%XHIBIT4HEFOCUSOFTHIS
6IEWPOINTISONTHEPRIMARYMECHANISMPRICING4HE
OTHERSWILLBEDEALTWITHINSUBSEQUENT6IEWPOINTS
!.EW0ERSPECTIVEON0RICING)NTERNAL3ERVICES
0RICESDRIVECUSTOMERBEHAVIORANDTHEREFOREARECRITI
CALTOADJUSTINGANDBALANCINGDEMAND"ASICECONOM
ICTHEORYTELLSUSTHATTHEOPTIMALPRICEPOINTISWHERE
MARGINALCOSTEQUALSMARGINALBENEFITIETHECOSTOF
ANADDITIONALUNITOFSERVICEISEQUIVALENTTOTHEBENEFIT
DERIVEDFROMTHATUNIT4OARRIVEATTHISEQUILIBRIUM
HOWEVERMARKETPARTICIPANTSNEEDTOUNDERSTANDTRUE
MARGINALCOSTSANDTHATISSIMPLYNOTTHECASEWHEN
ITCOMESTOINTERNALSERVICEDELIVERYATMOSTCOMPA
NIES(ISTORICALLYPRICESIGNALSHAVEBEENINACCURATE
OBSCUREDANDDIFFICULTTODECIPHER3ERVICEORGANIZA
TIONSSOUGHTTORECOVERTHEIRCOSTSANDPRICESREFLECTED
%XHIBIT
$EMAND-ANAGEMENT-ECHANISMS
%%)&
"!"'"&!&
(&"&&"'&
$ %)
%)
%
%
&
&
%
!# "
N "$!""
N $ !#!#%
N
" "%
N
3OURCE"OOZ!LLEN(AMILTON
!" !
N #!"
N ! ! ! " %&"!'! $!
N !!! $ !
N #% #!
N #!" "!"
N #%
N
("'#"
("'#"&
&
"'#("'"%&
"'#("'"%&
"
"
%#!!%
%#!!%%#($
%#($
"$!"# #""%
N !"" ! %
N ! N !! #"!
N
(&"&&
(&"&&
"'&
"'&
N
"
(&"&&"'
(&"&&"'
""%&
""%&
*(*%&
*(*%&
(&"&&"'#"'%#
(&"&&"'#"'%# %&
%&
THATIMPERATIVERATHERTHANREVEALINGTHEUNDERLYING
COSTDRIVERS-ORERECENTLYINTHEINTERESTOFMEETING
ANDUNDERCUTTINGEXTERNALBENCHMARKSINTERNALSUPPORT
FUNCTIONSHAVEMASSAGEDNUMBERSOFTENMERGINGFIXED
ANDVARIABLECOSTS
4HERESULT"5SDONOTUNDERSTANDTRUEMARGINAL
COSTSRESULTINGINPOORPRICESIGNALSANDSUBOPTIMAL
RESOURCEALLOCATION0RICINGSHOULDBEADEMANDMAN
AGEMENTFACILITATORNOTACOSTRECOVERYVEHICLE4HAT
OBJECTIVEISPOSSIBLEONLYIFPRICESARETRANSPARENTAND
PROVIDECUSTOMERSWITHTHELEVERSTHEYNEEDTOINFLU
ENCESERVICEOFFERINGSCOSTSANDQUALITY$IFFERENTSER
VICESHAVEANINHERENTLYDIFFERENTCOSTSTRUCTURESEE
%XHIBITANDTHEIRPRICESSHOULDREFLECTTHESEDISTINC
TIONS)NOTHERWORDSTHEPRICEFOREVERYSERVICEOFFER
INGSHOULDREVEALTHEBREAKDOWNAMONGDIRECTFIXED
COSTSDIRECTVARIABLECOSTSANDOVERHEADCOSTS
$IRECT&IXED#OSTS
$IRECT&IXED#OSTSARETYPICALLYINFRASTRUCTURERELATEDAND
THEREFORENOTEASYˆOREVENPOSSIBLEˆTOELIMINATEOR
REDUCEINTHESHORTRUN)DEALLYCOMPANIESWANTTOMAX
IMIZESHORTTERMDEMANDFORSUCHSERVICESTOINCREASE
UTILIZATIONANDREDUCEEFFECTIVEUNITCOST&ROMA
DEMANDMANAGEMENTPERSPECTIVEHOWEVERTHEREISNOT
ALOTCOMPANIESCANDOWITHFIXEDCOSTS4HEBUDGETFOR
THESEhLIGHTSONvNONDISCRETIONARYSERVICESEG,!.
7!.TELEPHONENETWORK(2)3INFRASTRUCTUREISGENER
ALLYSETATTHECORPORATELEVELANDINDIVIDUAL"5SHAVE
LIMITEDINPUTINTHATDECISIONMAKINGPROCESS
0RICESIGNALSRELATEDTODIRECTFIXEDCOSTSSHOULDNOT
CONVEYTOCUSTOMERSTHEIMPRESSIONOFFLEXIBILITYOR
EVENCONTROLLABILITY0RODUCTSANDSERVICESTHATHAVEA
PREDOMINANTLYFIXEDCOSTSTRUCTURESHOULDBECHARGED
OUTONTHEBASISOFHISTORICALUSAGE3ERVICEORGANI
ZATIONSSHOULDDETERMINETHETOTALCOSTSFORTHESE
SERVICESONCEAYEARANDMAINTAINTHERESULTINGPRICE
LEVELSTHROUGHOUTTHEYEARSINCEFLUCTUATIONSINSHORT
TERMDEMANDHAVENOIMPACTONFIXEDCOSTS4HIS
APPROACHSHOULDFREEUPRESOURCESDEDICATEDTOPRIC
INGSUCHSERVICES
$IRECT6ARIABLE#OSTS
$IRECT6ARIABLE#OSTSONTHEOTHERHANDDOFLUCTUATE
WITHDEMAND4HESEAREDISCRETIONARYFLEXIBLEAND
REDEPLOYABLERESOURCESANDTHEPRIMETARGETOFDEMAND
MANAGEMENTEFFORTSEGHELPDESKSPRINTINGSERVICES
LONGDISTANCETELEPHONEUSAGE3ERVICEORGANIZATIONS
SHOULDSENDBUSINESSUNITSVERYCLEARPRICESIGNALS
FORTHESESERVICESTOREFLECTTHEIRVARIABLENATUREAND
ENCOURAGEAREDUCTIONINSHORTTERMDEMAND
0RODUCTSANDSERVICESTHATHAVEAPREDOMINANTLYVARI
ABLECOSTSTRUCTURESHOULDBEBILLEDOUTBASEDONTHE
%XHIBIT
0RICES3HOULD2EmECT5NDERLYING#OST$RIVERS
Support Organization Overhead Costs
N %()( $+%"+ $
#$ $)('+ %'$ /) %$
N .& "". -%()(
%&"
!
N $#$)
N *) $&' $
! N
N
N
N
N
N
N
".%$( $ $)$
". $"- "
(.()#($ " ) (
$) #'()'*)*' $
%()()%)*'$%('+ %,#' $"%())%
('+ ) %$"*$ )(
)'$%()(, )
'*#$
$'()'*)*'
"&%$
$'()'*)*'
)),%'!
N
N
N
N
N
".*&%$"- "
'&"%."'(%*'(
$ $'()'*)*'
%()($
#&), ) $
#%$)((%$
"*)*) %$( $
#$%'('+ (
"&(!
' $) $
%$ ()$
)"&%$(
3OURCE"OOZ!LLEN(AMILTON
ACTUALCOSTINCURREDTODELIVERTHATPRODUCTORSERVICE
4HISSORTOFFLEXIBLEPRICINGMECHANISMENCOURAGES
BUSINESSUNITSTOOPTIMIZETHEIRSHORTTERMDEMAND
WHILEFORCINGSERVICEPROVIDERSTOADJUSTSUPPLYLEVELS
CONTINUALLYTOMATCHTHATDEMAND
&INALLY/VERHEAD#OSTSARETHOSEINCURREDBYTHESER
VICEORGANIZATIONTHATCANNOTBEDIRECTLYATTRIBUTEDTO
THEDELIVERYOFASERVICE4HESECOSTSINCLUDEMANAGE
MENTANDOTHERADMINISTRATIVEFUNCTIONS4HECOSTS
FORTHESEACTIVITIESSHOULDBESEPARATELYIDENTIFIEDAND
MONITOREDBYANINTERNALSERVICESGOVERNANCEBODY)N
THESHORTRUNTHESECOSTSSHOULDBETREATEDASFIXED
ANDCHARGEDOUTTHESAMEWAY
/BVIOUSLYTHISDISCUSSIONOVERSIMPLIFIESTHEVARIETYOF
COMPLICATEDFACTORSTHATWEIGHONTHEPRICINGOFINTER
NALSERVICES(OWEVERITDOESMAKECLEARTHEIMPOR
TANCEOFCONVEYINGTHETRUECOSTSTRUCTUREFORINTERNAL
SERVICESTOTHECUSTOMER
)NADDITIONTOEXPOSINGTHEUNDERLYINGCOSTSTRUCTURE
SERVICEPROVIDERSNEEDTOCOMMUNICATETHATINFORMA
TIONTOTHECUSTOMERxATALEVELWHEREITIShACTION
ABLEv)FTHECUSTOMERCONTACTISNOTINAPOSITIONTO
MAKEABUYINGDECISIONTHEREISLITTLEPOINTINBILLING
ATTHATLEVEL3IMILARLYIFA"5MANAGERCANNOTWEIGH
INONANEXPENSEBECAUSEITISMANDATEDATTHECOR
PORATELEVELEGCORPORATESECURITYAUDITTHESE
COSTSNEEDNOTBEBROKENDOWNATTHE"5MANAGER
LEVEL$ISCUSSIONSOFTHOSECOSTSSHOULDBEHELDATTHE
EXECUTIVELEVEL
/THER$EMAND-ANAGEMENT$RIVERS
)NCENTIVESARECLOSELYLINKEDTOPRICINGINDRIVING
DEMANDMANAGEMENT!SMENTIONEDEARLIERTOOOFTEN
INCENTIVESAREMISALIGNEDANDPROMPTSCHIZOPHRENIC
BEHAVIORONTHEPARTOFTHESERVICEORGANIZATION
-OTIVATEDTOENHANCECUSTOMERSATISFACTIONBYSERVICE
LEVELAGREEMENTINCENTIVESSERVICEPROVIDERSLOSESIGHT
OFTHEBIGGERPICTUREWHICHISTODECREASEOVERALLCOSTS
BYRATIONALIZING"5DEMAND4OACHIEVETHATGOALINCEN
TIVESNEEDTOBEDIRECTLYLINKEDTOTHEBUSINESSUNITS
COSTREDUCTIONGOALS
3OASNOTTOSTRAINDAYTODAYWORKINGRELATIONSHIPSAT
THELINEMANAGERLEVELTHESELINKSSHOULDBEESTAB
LISHEDATSENIORLEVELSINTHESERVICEANDLINEORGANI
ZATIONSWHERETHEYAREBOUNDTOBEMOREEFFECTIVE
"RINGINGTHATTOPLEVELPERSPECTIVETOTHEMATTEROF
INTERNALSERVICEINCENTIVESFOSTERSOPTIMIZATIONWITHIN
ANDACROSS"5S
4HESEPROPOSEDCHANGESINPRICINGANDINCENTIVES
CANNOTBEEFFECTIVEINTHEABSENCEOFEFFECTIVE
GOVERNANCE'OODGOVERNANCEATITSCOREISAMATTER
OFCOMMUNICATION"YESTABLISHINGCLEARINDEED
TRANSPARENTPRICINGMECHANISMSANDBYMOTIVATING
THEAPPROPRIATEBEHAVIORSACOMPANYWILLEFFECTIVELY
PROVIDETHECONTEXTFORANAFFORDABILITYDIALOGUE
$EMANDMANAGEMENTCANBEINSTITUTIONALIZEDONLY
IFBOTH"5SANDSERVICEPROVIDERSAREHELDACCOUNT
ABLE-ANYCOMPANIESSETUPBOARDSTOSERVEASA
GOVERNANCEFORUMWITHPARTICIPATIONFROMBOTHLINEAND
SERVICEMANAGEMENT4HESEBOARDSACTASAPRIMARY
INTERFACEPROVIDINGDIRECTIONALOVERSIGHTANDCUSTOMER
INPUTTOTHESERVICEORGANIZATIONANDSERVINGASA
"5SOUNDINGBOARDANDPLATFORMFORSERVICEDELIVERY
STANDARDIZATION4HISCROSSFUNCTIONALTEAMPROVIDES
THEVEHICLETHROUGHWHICHTRUECUSTOMERSEGMENTA
TIONANDFITFORPURPOSESOLUTIONSBECOMEREALITY4HE
GOVERNANCEBOARDALSOSERVESASAFORUMWHERECOST
ANDSERVICELEVELISSUESCANBERESOLVED!GAINGOOD
GOVERNANCESETSTHESTAGEFORAGENUINEAFFORDABILITY
DIALOGUEANDREINFORCESTHEALIGNMENTOFSUPPLYAND
DEMANDININTERNALSERVICEDELIVERY
$OWNLOADABLEDIGITALVERSIONSOFTHISARTICLEANDOTHER"OOZ!LLEN(AMILTONPUBLICATIONSAREAVAILABLEFROMWWWBOOZALLENCOM
02).4%$).53!
Ú"OOZ!LLEN(AMILTON)NC
BOOZ & COMPANY WORLDWIDE OFFICES
Asia
Europe
Middle East
South America
Beijing
Hong Kong
Seoul
Shanghai
Taipei
Tokyo
Amsterdam
Berlin
Copenhagen
Dublin
Düsseldorf
Frankfurt
Helsinki
London
Madrid
Milan
Moscow
Munich
Oslo
Paris
Rome
Stockholm
Stuttgart
Vienna
Warsaw
Zurich
Abu Dhabi
Beirut
Cairo
Dubai
Riyadh
Buenos Aires
Rio de Janeiro
Santiago
São Paulo
Australia,
New Zealand,
and
Southeast Asia
Adelaide
Auckland
Bangkok
Brisbane
Canberra
Jakarta
Kuala Lumpur
Melbourne
Sydney
North America
Atlanta
Chicago
Cleveland
Dallas
Detroit
Florham Park
Houston
Los Angeles
McLean
Mexico City
New York City
Parsippany
San Francisco
The most recent list of our office addresses and telephone numbers
can be found on our Web site, www.booz.com.
20030030/5/03 Printed in USA
©2003 Booz Allen Hamilton Inc.