! " # Æ $ % " Æ ! !
" #
$%&' ( ) #
! " ! ! ! " "
* $% + , %,'
- ( !) . " (-) - $%/' $0' 1
* " ( #
!) 2 $3'
- " "
- !# " #
$%%' - ! ! !# * " " ! " ! # " # ! ! " " !# # " ! * " #
! - ! ! # #
!#
4 #
" - * #
5 - #
" * " 6 * " " 4 " 7 8 9
" !
- " . # #
!# " . # ! :;
$<' # !# " = # !# #
5 " ! !#
" ! > ! $:' ! ! $%:'
! * ! ( # 7 8)
" " "
! ! ! . ? " 4 ! - *
3 > + . " (-) .
? (6 >) " "#* 6 > @ 6 > - !
" - 6=>> $%/' @A-1 $%+' " A " " ? . 4 . @ B B # >
! ( !) ( ! ()( )) 4 ()
C1
# - #
" % 4 ! ( ) ( ) 9
&
& ' &
()
*+
*+
' ¼
¼
, -- *+ ( ) ( )
4 D - E ! ! " 7 D8 ( D) 4 D D
" D 4
" !
" D * #
- 7"8 D ( ) "
! #" * #
D -
4 # - #
" #
Æ # !#
! ! " ! $%3 %0 /' #
" " ! 4 " # " ! - ! $F'
#
. " . 4 & #
& * G % . 4 7 8 7!
8 . 4 4 " (#)
B ( ) " " " 4 # ( )
!
( )
" & $/' ! ¼
¼
¼
¼
? ! 7 8 H H ) B ( ) H B (H H H H ( ?) ? H H 5 Æ H $%&' 78
H ( ) - " H
H 4 H 4 ! " H ! 5 Æ H ! H H H ! !
"
" H 78 H H - H H H (H ) " H H - H 9
¼
( ) ¾
( H())
- " ! 5 " - #
$3' " ( !#
) 4 ! ? " 9
() B & () " H ! H H¼
B (H ( ) H ( ) H ( ))
- H ! H H H
" H ! H
¼
¼
¼
! $%%' ! ! #
! 5 H B ( ) " ! #
" ! Æ ! > ! " - " ! ! ! # - !#
! " ! $%%' ? " ##
Æ ! = - ! ! D ! H ! - # - !# - H() H ! 4 ! 4 ( ) # " 4 7 8 - H 4 -
H() # D ! ! # H D H # ! # H > 33 # !#
H H ! ! H 78 " ! - #
5 - D 3E: # 4 # D 3E: ! 5 # - H $ #
Æ > H " H ?
# H . / . 0 1 1 0
2 3 4 / 5 6
1
7
/ 1. 0
8 .0
9 / 5 :
1
;
1. 0 / 2 . 0 .
25 .0
22 ()
*+ . 0
23
. . 0 . 0 . 00
24 0
- .CC# >
* $%%' 7I 8 7 8 > # #
= ! ! ! ! 4 7#8 > !# " $3' " ! "! ! 4 "! ! % #
! % !#
"! ! ! * "
9 !# # " #
> 4 " " 7 8 - # # !# # ! # # 7#8 ! " * ! #
A * " " !# # , < $ 2
:8
82 :
3 3
8 27 25
3
444
346 23
9 3; 35 88 2:
4
845
736 24
6 23 49 76 62
< 4 " " > " " 3:&& " %&&& %&& , $
2
82 6 32 64 5: 29 35 72 37 68 35 75 35:
3
346 7 44 3; 24; 23 37 44 27: 63 27 37 962
4
736 4 25 2: 3: :
: 2; 6: 2;
: 2; 246
% 4 # , < $ 2
:8
82 :
3 5
5 3
3
3
444
346 23
9 23
: 44
9
4
845
736 24
6 9
4 27 23
< ! " #
* / " " ! !# * #
# 4 # #
/ - !# * # * 6 " ! #
* # , $
2
82 6 32 64 5: ; 35 6: 27 24 35 66 3;
3
346 7 44 3; 24; 9 3: 44 274 24 37 44 3:6
4
736 4 25 2: 3: 8
: 2: 44 ;
: 2: 73
9 #
" ! ! # ( - #
) #! " ! " - ! ! 10000
hybrid runtime (seconds)
1000
100
10
1
0.1
0.1
1
10
100
proof based time (seconds)
1000
10000
< $ 3 + #
( # ) 4 !#
4 " :;
> / 3 # !
4 * " #
. :F&
#
! %F; # = " > /, # #
# 10000
hybrid time (seconds)
1000
100
10
1
0.1
0.1
1
10
100
CEX time (seconds)
1000
10000
< $ !
4 !# # " !#
" #
* " A
! #
! - ! 5 7 8 - ! " "
" ! " = #
!# # > 7 8 * * "
2 # , * = * 3;>65 2;;4
3 ? < , @ A B - AA - ? $ ' 25 ? 2;;5
4 @ ? B $ = C *
&
) 3553
6 @ A D E ? F - $ = 276>28; 3555
7 @ A * E ? B D *+ - ! 3553
8 A E E B A$ < # A F = A
3554
9 E E% - E %
3555
: * E A E G F * 3554
; D B A F = A ! "! ! # 2;.40'3;2>426 3552
25 < B $ $ # %!!! ( 2;;6
22 B - AA ) * * 3554
23 A C A # A F G - G A "' @
Æ *+ ! # 745>747 3552
24 * D - %&% 2;:7
26 ? A B * E<*
> 2;;8
27 AF = C * # '( 433>442 2;:8
28 C , - $ ? E $ # H 3554
29 C $ ? - ? $ B F G $ + A < # ! # 47>65 3552