Australian Population & Migration Research Centre Policy Brief Vol. 1, No. 11 November, 2013 THE REAL VALUE OF VOLUNTEERING By Lisel O'Dwyer Background Several ways to estimate the value of volunteer work have been developed. The most commonly used method in Australia is the market value of volunteers’ time, based on average weekly earnings. It relies on data collected by the Australian Bureau of Statistics in the volunteering component of the General Social Survey for formal volunteering (i.e. volunteering through a formal organization). Data on the time spent on informal forms of volunteering (any other type of volunteering, such as helping out a neighbour) is available from Time Use Surveys (ABS 1992, 1997, 2006). From a strategic perspective, we have to attach monetary measures to the value of volunteering. Therefore, we need to develop ways to account for the impact of volunteering everywhere it is felt. For example, the social and economic values flowing from even modest increases in social capital (of which volunteering is a significant component) are likely to be quite large. Previous research has estimated for example that a 1 unit increase in organisation memberships per capita would have resulted in 1671 fewer deaths in South Australia in 2001 than actually occurred; and that reductions in sexual assault might save a relatively modest $20,000, while savings in vehicle theft and theft from vehicles might be $76,000 and $42,000 respectively. Research Findings Data limitations mean that an up-to-date estimate on the value of all volunteering for Australia must be based on conservative assumptions and past trends. On this basis, if we use the standard method of valuing volunteers’ time, we assume that: the number of average annual hours spent in formal volunteering in 2010 is the same as for 2006 (the lowest rate on record); the ratio of time spent on formal and informal volunteering is 30:70 (based on the average ratio for 1992, 1997 and 2006 which has hardly changed over time); the time spent travelling is 18% of the time spent on all volunteering (based on the lowest share for travel over 1992, 1997 and 2006) other inputs account for an extra 12.7% of the value of time inputs; the average wage rate in 2010 was $27.45 per hour then the value of volunteering in Australia in 2010 was approximately $100 billion. This represents about 8 per cent of GDP in 2010. If we use less conservative assumptions, based on extrapolating trends in the above parameters since 1992, (rather than minimum annual average change), the value of volunteering would be well over $120 billion. Other bases for comparison include national government expenditure in 2010 on: Health : $21 billion; Education : $8.5 billion Recreation and culture: $2 billion Defence : $19.4 billion Consumption in all sectors in 2010: $91 billion (ABS Cat No. 5204 Table 35). Then there is the value of other industry sectors’ annual production in 2010: Mining: $98 billion Agriculture: $29 billion Retail: $58 billion (ABS Cat No. 5206 Table 6). The trend over time in the value of volunteering, both in constant dollars (accounting for inflation) and in actual or current dollars is shown in Figure 1. Table 1. Total value of volunteering, Australia, 2006 and 2010 ($millions) Source: ABS Time Use Surveys 1997 and 2006 and Voluntary Work Survey 2006 and 2011 20061 20102 $17,179 $33,648 $8,973 $59,800 $22,547 $52,609 $13,528 $111,230 A. Volunteer time inputs Organised Unorganised Travel Total value of time B. Other volunteer inputs (car, phone etc.) Organised Unorganised Travel Total value of other inputs $2,182 $4,273 $1,140 $2,863 $6,681 $1,718 $7,595 $11,263 $19,361 $37,921 $10,113 $25,410 $59,290 $15,246 $67,395 $99,946 C. Total volunteer inputs Organised Unorganised Travel Total value of volunteering Notes: 1. Based on complete data 2. Based on assumptions for number of hours Figure 1. Estimated values for all volunteering, Australia, 1992-2010 110 100 Current dollars Billions of dollars 90 80 Constant dollars (base year = 2010) 70 60 50 40 30 20 Year Source: 1992 and 1997 estimates from Table 5.5 , Ironmonger (2000: 70). 2006 and 2010 estimates based on the 2006 and 2010 ABS Survey of Volunteering Cat No. 4441.0 and 1997 and 2006 Time Use Survey Cat No. 4513.0. Dollar conversions based on All Groups CPI for Australia Cat No. 6401.0. In real terms the value of volunteering has more than doubled since 1992, with an average annual increase of about 7 per cent per year. The ensuing retirement of the first wave of babyboomers is likely to increase the time and number of people involved in volunteering and so we are likely to see this trend continue, perhaps at an even more rapid rate. But the value of volunteering is attached to a multiplicity of outcomes, not just volunteers’ time, as conceptualised in Figure 4. One hour of a volunteer’s time needs to be valued not just once but up to 9 times – and at different rates. A very conservative estimate using an hourly value of only 25 per cent of the average hourly wage ($6.86), assuming that only 4 of the possible 9 other entities benefit from a single volunteer’s time and that they benefit to an equal extent, produces a value of around $200 billion, double the value of just volunteers’ time of $100 billion. The true value may well be much higher still. In this light, the estimates we currently have of the economic value of volunteering represent a small fraction of the true value of volunteering. Figure 2. A multidimensional model of the real value of volunteering. Source: Graff 2009 p. 5: http://www.lindagraff.ca/musings.html Implications The real value of volunteering goes way beyond X dollars per hour of a volunteer’s time because volunteering has more beneficiaries than just government and the economy, including the volunteers themselves. Volunteering is clearly valuable and it is politically (and even morally) necessary to quantify its worth. Using monetary measures is understandable in the light of our familiarity with notions of economic worth and how to value workers’ time. However, current estimates of volunteering’s economic value are likely to be gross under-representations. On the other hand, a focus on monetary value may even be damaging if it reinforces the notion that volunteering is all about saving money. We need to develop a new model of valuing volunteering which accounts for all the benefits of volunteering. Other issues associated with the characteristics of the age groups involved in volunteering, particularly the babyboomers and older people, such as productivity and particular skills, will also be important in developing a new model of valuing volunteering. Policy Recommendations Volunteering makes a large economic contribution (via volunteers’ personal expenditure and savings to government) but also has positive social and personal benefits. It must be encouraged and supported through: o making it easier for people to become volunteers (eg reducing red tape for police checks). o making it easier for organisations to recruit and manage volunteers by including policies on OHS and bullying for volunteers as well as paid workers, and subsidising training for volunteers o ensuring that volunteers do not replace paid workers as a cost saving measure Governments at all levels should continue to recognise and appreciate volunteers’ efforts (this is already done through several channels but an expansion of these may be warranted). Edited by Arusyak Sevoyan Australian Population and Migration Research Centre http://www.adelaide.edu.au/apmrc/ School of Social Sciences Room G17, Ground Floor, Napier Building The University of Adelaide South Australia 5005 Telephone +61 8 8313 3900; Fax: +61 8 8313 3498
© Copyright 2024 Paperzz