Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect
Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2112 – 2118
!"#
$%"##&''(
'))
'*#+,-./0!1
2 #01 ) $ $( $$ # 0 ) 3
2,1#0)11$0)$0*
$ #$ )$ 3 0 ))) # (
0) 0 # # #3 -( # #0
0,#0)$##,)#10$,)0,$$#,
#(40)$3'##0
##$0*11))3#(#
)#)$))3'
) 0( 0 1( $ # ) 0$ # #0 )
# )# )$ ))3 2 )) #( #$ $(0)3 '( 1$ '0)) $ 15
0$ # 1( )#$ 0 # 1( 0 $ 03 #( 0)0 ( 1 $ 0 ) 0##$(1))3#(,)))$)$
60)2#*)$3
© 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
72'#3#11("83
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of The Association of Science, Education and Technology-TASET, Sakarya Universitesi,
)
#)1(2',"#2$(
2'"2,*(
Turkey.
9,2#*(3
:(&;'#$;$;'(1$
+)$#323&<=
>??@AA;6&<=
>??3
!""
#*#B3#3
1877-0428 © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of The Association of Science, Education and Technology-TASET, Sakarya Universitesi, Turkey.
doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2013.12.240
Ali Coskun and Metin Yılmaz / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2112 – 2118
2113
2 0) ) # 2#*( ) $ * ( ) $ C#( 3 2 0 $ 0$0 # 0 ( #3 0 0
000$132
0) 0*$ ) 0 3 0) # # , 0 , $ ))$ #, ( )$ 130*$$$,
0 0# # 0 C# 3 1#( $ 0 0 # 0 )) (3 '( 1 $
)))##003
#(,)00)(1)$)2#*(3
)#)#1#$)$),0)0(1$
0 ) ( $ 0 # #$ ( 1
))3#(,)))$)$60)2#*)
$3
$ 0 )# 0$ # 0 #)1 #0 )1'*,:),-#0#D.#$,&A3$)1(#
#)0$##0$)(3
00#)$3$#$#0(
0 )3 8$ # )$ $ $ 1# $
# ) #011)1)38$
#)$1(#
#)$## 00#
$,%DE5,&A?
AF3
$, 0$ 0 ) $ # #0, 0*, , , 0$,
$ ) , 0$ # , -, D , >& A3 2 #$)$$)3"# 0(11(0
#(1,)0$,$0
, 0$, 6) ), $, # ) , #(
6),0*$6),),,3
0*, ) 0 0 0)3 2 ) 0)0$0#0)1(0$3"1()
#,$!0#0*)#3 #C## 0
)390#0,6#0 $)#
)0$,1#0)0()3
2 1 )) )$ 0* 1 )$ 1 )$ $, % D
E5,&A=
?30*1)$,)0#046)
0)4 3 0* 1 ), 0$ 0# $#03"##C#$0#)0,
0 0$ 0# C#( ) 4 ) 0* 1 ) 0) 0 #3 1 )), $!
#0# 0 #) $ # 03
2114
Ali Coskun and Metin Yılmaz / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2112 – 2118
0*1)$0$)#32$#0
)#)#0)$)(3'0$
$6#$1(#1$$)0$32$
#$ 1 6 $, % D E5, & ?
?3 2$ $ 0( )
0$ # 3 2$ $ 0)! )$ $ $ 0)$ )#3 $ 0*$ ( 0)0 #$ # $$ 0 0 # ) 1# ) *#,
3
1)$)),
)#)$,0$0))$)
1($ 0*#)0)3
)#)$1#0*
#)'*,:),-#0#D.#$,&>F3-$
# $ 0*#) 0) 0( ( )$ 1 #0
$,%DE5,&?F3)#)$))0(1#,,
(13
'( 1 )$ 0 # $ 1( #$ ( 1 $
))3'(1)$11)$)#)#0(
) ( C# '*, :), -#0# D .#$, & A3 $ ) 6)(1$0*(1)$0#13
' () 1# 00 10 0 0) 0##$ 0$1#3#)#)(,1#0#(
15))(3'(1$'))0
$#$39$'0##
# # 1 0)# 0 #( 0) )).0!*#,&>3
' 0 ) , , #, )0 0#0, #0
)1(,1#,0,1,()1(
)3'0),,)#,,#0#
$ $ 1 # 0 1( ) D :), =>>; "*, ; :) D
'*,==>3
' 0 )& #0# ( 0)#$ ( ), #0# 15 # # #$ ))) 1 -, % D $, & >A; ,
==F&=?
=F3
G$( $ 1 # 1# 0##$ ) )# $ # 1( )#$1#1#1(
1$0#1($
)):),==&F3
) #( #00! 0)0 (1$ $ '*,2#*(3
H( 3 2 ? & '(
# 0,
'(
H0#0,'(
22$,'(
#G,'(
A
"# ', '(
? G(0) #, '(
F #00 , '(
> #4 #1,
Ali Coskun and Metin Yılmaz / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2112 – 2118
2115
'(
= 2 -$, '(
$0 #, '(
, '(
*$ 2) , '(
# #, '(
'0, '#$, 0, $, 2) #( , '(
A
I#,'(
?-3
(,$( )3#1#$
#0# ,FA,A 28, #$ 0 #)) 6), ( 6), #1
6), # 6), ##$ # , 6), 6 ,
)0!3#$)#(#00!213
213#$
! -#))"6)
("6)
#1"6)
G"#"6)
A
G##$9'
?
"6)
F
26'GH
>
%)''0!
& ) & '* + ! ! " #$
%& '(
,?F
,A,>A
,A=,>=
=,A
=,=?
A,=>
,>?A
=,A
,-.,./
8,$,1()038
1()$2131#(1#
)##0)##1(15#$
)3
213"#'(%
'(
#0
2#01#
'(
H0#0
2#010#
'(
22$
2#01
'(
#G
2#01=$
'(
A"#'
2#01#
'(
?G(0)#
2#01G(0)#))
'(
F#00
2#01#00
'(
>#4#1
2#01#4#1))
'(
=
2-$
2#01
20$
'(
$0#
2#01)$0
'(
2#01#
'(
$2)
2#01#
'(
##
2#01#$$
'(
'0,'#$,0,
$,2)#(
2#01620+
'(
AI#
2#01$#
'(
?-
9)620+
+2(6)31###1#3
2116
Ali Coskun and Metin Yılmaz / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2112 – 2118
# $ , 0$ , '(
? - '(
'0, '#$, 0, $, 2) #( J(K 3 $ ( 15, ( 3
$,)0(153$
#0#03'0)1(#$
3#1($(
C#(1(3H60)(
#
0 A3 28 ) #3 I $ 15 32#$$&=$,$,$$3H
$,(#0#3H(##0)#1($
$#01#$3'(15
#$ # # #00! 21 3 ) # # = $, $,$$F,=A?28,>,28,>,AA28F,F>>28)(3
0)0(1$,#0(1#5#$
#01#$$#32
))$##0)1$3#
##1>,28)#$39#1($
,FA,A28#01#A>A3
0)$(0(1$$213'4
1 $ = $ $ # , $ $
##0)$(1$3
.
" $" 20)0(1)$#$(103'#0
$L0*#)(1#3M##
# 1 >,= 28@# )), # $ ( ( 1
))32#=$,$,$$#1>,FA28@#=,A
28@#, =,> 28@#, >,AA? 28@# )(3 2 0) )# )$ ))$21A3
-*#))$0#0,),0
))#, 3 0*#) 0( 1 $ L )$ 03
0 0( ) ( 1 # $ ( 0( $( $
)$10)#03
#0, 0$0 1# )1( # $ 1( $$
#00'))3200(0*##$
032(0(0 0##(0*03H60)#
#)C#($,0$00())(#=$,1#))(
(#$C#03
# 1 0( )$ # #0 0,
# 0)$ # #, )#1 0$ , ) 0, $
$#,#(403
2 0 /0 0 0 4
'(
#
0
'(
H0#
0
A328@
#
?3A28@H0
#
'(
2
2$
,3>F28@
A6,3>F A,F28 =6,3>F ,AA28 6,3>F ,>28 6,3>F >,>28
'(
#
G
3=28@=$
>63= F>,>28
'(
A"#
'
,328@#
'(
?G(0)
#
>6A3 ,28
F>,28
A,A3??28@G(0)
#
'(
F#00
3A28@#00
'(
>#4#1
F3?28@#4
#1
>A6F3?
?6,?3
,?28
'(
=
2 ,?328@
-$
20$
,AFA28
F=328@#
'(
$
,?3A>28@#
2)
'(
#
#
3FF28@#
'(
AI#
3A=28@#
& ! %& 5& " (
,F28
6A3
,A28
A6?3A >,>28 6?3A F,=>A28 A6?3A F,?F28
?6
,3
?A?,A28
6
,3
A,>28
A6
,3
F,F=28
6A,A3?? ,=28 6A,A3?? A,A?28
63A
,=28 A63A F,?28
,=28 ?6F3? ,>?28
=6F3?
,28
>6,?3
>6,?3
,>28
6,?3
?,28
,>28
'(
3?28@
>63? A,>28 ?63? ,=?28
$0#
)$0
'(
6A3
>6F=3
,?28
?6F=3
,?F?28
6F=3
,==28
A6F=3
=,28
>6
,?3A>
A,>28
?6
,?3A>
?=,A28
6
,?3A>
==,>AA28
A6
,?3A>
?A,A?28
>63FF ?,>28 ?63FF ,28 63FF ?,28 A63FF ,>>28
A63A=
,F28
,,>28
3A3A28
,F,28
>=,=28
,,>28@>N
-,2 .3& '
,A,A28@?N
1,/& '
,F,28@N
1,..& '
>=,=28@AN
-,--1& '
213'$#$'
>6
,3
A6A3
Ali Coskun and Metin Yılmaz / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2112 – 2118
'
'
'
'
:('( :('( :('( :('(
6E
6E
6E
6E
2117
2118
Ali Coskun and Metin Yılmaz / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2112 – 2118
2139#$'2$
) 6
=I
I
I
I
2$-
>328@#
>328@#
>328@#
>328@#
'($-
F3=A?28@#
>328@#
>3AA28@#
F3FF>28@#
A?28@#
=>28@#
28@#
28@#
21))
21A3$#$'2$
) 6
=I
I
I
I
H ) # #$ $ 0
2 )) $ $ 0&<L0*#)
>3=28@#
>3=28@#
>3=28@#
>3=28@#
'(1)#(1
<L0*#)
>3FA28@#
=3A28@#
=3>28@#
>3AA?28@#
>28@#
AF28@#
?F28@#
21))
F28@#
#(0)0(1$0)2#*(0
##$(1))3M##0$$
$0##0)3#1))$
#3"6#$,(1)))0$#
)1(#3'(1)#))*##
, 0 , $ ))$ #, ( )$ 1 3M###0)(1(0)0$(
1)),#113
4
'*, '3'3, :), E33 -#0#, "3-3 D .#$, 3-3 (4
$--&4# 5&& 5& -& (4 "
.
4 6
-&3
),E3D:),E33=>>3-#E$&-*E$%37"/
8
9)01@G1,=?
3
*#, '3 , 5* -( .0 ' G* -(03 $"
$ 4 +:& &5 $-"
-
."
,A,A
32#*
"*,-3O3,3IP0IH(%(/-(.Q0IQ%R//0/-#1S0>4#'
)I#1##:#/0/,";<
==/
4,,F
A?32#*
,E3M3==F3(4
$--&43",-I 3
,E3M3,-,-3M3D,H3 3>3%&(4
#.
4
5&/
-&
"&-I 3
$,323,%,3-3DE5,-3T33%&$--&4#$(4
"&3
:),E33D'*,'3==>3$"-
"(4
$--&4 3
-,M3U3,%U3E3D $,'3833(4
$--&4#$.
4-$&-,#
M$3
.0!, -3 D S*#, '3 3 GQR0 :##0/ VR 0 -( )0/ - .Q03
<
.&/
4,,FF
=32#*