Multiple-criteria ranking of a finite set of alternatives using

 "!#$%
'&%
()
$%
*$+,
-&.&%/0,123
-
&%&%,4145&%
()
6112$+,
"7/$98:;,&<=>
? @'ACBEDFHG
I (JK1
L M;NPORQSUTVMXWYZQ\[^]UY`_Xa\SbORTVcXOXdeM;feg6h*feg/iMkj*ORQ\lnmoYZQ\igQpd-qMkr\[^[^g/O;r\s
tvuxwky{z}|~z}kz}€(‚„ƒ%†…6‡p;z}|ˆwp‰6ŠR‹|ˆ€wp‹e€†ŒUŽ/wUwv‘wk|ˆ’“€e”}y•|~zx–‚˜—9€‹š™pwp/›ˆ†‰/–XŒpœ†ž Ÿ†œ“¡¢Ž/wUwŒ
/wU£,uxwpy{z}|~z};z}€‚¤”(ŠX–;y{z}€…6y¥¦€y•€$”}‹š™ŒUŽ†›ˆ|ˆy•™P§¨‹†£k€e…o–/‚„ŠR‹|ˆ€wp‹e€yŒUR©ež«ª†ª“¬o­”}y}$®Œ
Ž†›¯/wp£\Œk€ež«…/|ˆ›`°py•›ˆ$®|ˆwpy•±k²y•†›`³ ‡p;z$³ ‡b/wUw³ ‡p›
´µ /‹ep›~zx–‚·¶¸‹†wk†…6|ˆ‹yŒk‘wp|ˆ’“€^”}y•|ˆz –6/‚·ƒzšwp|¯;Œbƒ%/”}y•¢u«zš/›ˆ|¯;ŒU¡†¡RŒkŸ†¡R©¹Ÿ;Œbƒzš/wk|¯;Œku zš/›~–XŒ
€ež«…/|ˆ›`°ky}›ˆ‰/”}€‹“²…*ºb$»¼³ pwp|ˆ‹ez$³ |~z
½n¾§(¿PŠk§¦À¶Œk‘¨wp|ˆ’“€e”}y•|~z –,‚¸·”}|ˆy¦À/k‡p™k|¯wk€†Œp¬†¡/¬†¬†¡6·”}|¯yŒbƒ%€$£k€^»7©œ;Œ µ ”š/wk‹€†Œ
€ež«…/|ˆ›`°k…6/py•y•€$b²›¯/…6y}/£k€†³ £k/p‡k™p|ˆwp€/³ ‚Z”
ÁÂg3O;f^g3iM;Q\[^YVl¼gfeYZQ¼ÃÄOÄlbg†iY¤[šYVM;QÅ[^Y¯der\OXdeYZMkQÆYZQÅWǼY¤iÇÅOÉÈ\Q¼YZd^gÊ[^gdÂMRËPORTZd^gfeQ\ORÌ
d^YVc;g/[Í«O;id^YVM;Q\[Î*ÏÐY¤[6gcXORTVr\ORd^g/lÂM;QÑOnË«O;NÒYVTVÓÂÔÕMRË(ÖÉif^YZd^g/f^Y¤O7× _“Ø × jRØÙÙ/Ù¸Ø ×;Ú9a„WǼgfeg
ÔÜÛÞÝ
Öà¸ÁágKO;[e[šr\NÒgka·WY¯deǼM;r¼dTZMp[^[¢M;ËÃkgQ¼g/feO;TZYZd}Ó;aŽdeÇ\OXd6deǼgPÃ;feg/ORd^gf*×;â^Í«ãbÎ$a
d^ǼgKä9gd^Øed^ß¼g/ØfÙÙ/ORَTZd^Ø g/f^Q\ORd^YVc;gPãÂM;QÑifeY¯degfeYZMkQ#×;âša¸ËåMkfORTVTæçèÔvà˜é<lbg†iY¤[šYVM;QêNPOR]kgfKÍ ëoq#Î
YV[,WYZTVTVYZQ¼Ã#d^MÂfeO;Q¼]#deǼg7O;T¯degfeQ\OXdeYZckg/[YZQÊÏCËåfeM;NEd^Ǽg7äg†[}d,d^M#d^ǼgnW¨Mkfe[šd/a%O;i/iM;flbYVQ¼Ã
d^M2ǼY¤[$ì“Ǽg/fí¼fegËåg/f^g/Q\ig†[à˜î(Ç\gfORQ¼]UYVQ¼Ã2iO;QÑägniM;Nví¼TVgdegKM;f,í\ORf^d^Y¤ORTxa˜lbg/íg/Q\lbYVQ¼Ã#MkQ
d^Ǽgní¼fegËågfegQignYZQbËåMkf^NPORd^YVM;QÊ[^r¼í¼í¼TVYVg/l3äUÓêdeǼgnë*qïORQ\lÊM;QÑdeǼgWO“ÓêMRËgðbí¼TZMkY¯deYZQ\Ã
d^ǼY¤[YVQbËåMkf^NPOXdeYZMkQ¸à˜î(ǼgË«ORNvYVTZÓáMRËifeYZd^gfeY¤OÔÞYV[,[šr¼í\íMp[šg†lád^M#[eOXdeYV[šËåÓ#deǼgKËåMkTZTVMXWYVQ¼Ã
iM;Q[šY¤[}degQ\iÓiMkQ\lbYZd^YVM;Q\[/ñ
ò Ëågf^ðbMkÇ\NCO;r\Ôó[}deYZ[šcUǼYZMkd}Ó-r¼T¤Ì·l7ORQUä9Óogd}iW¨MkQ\Mo[^ORYVlbTZd^g/gf^feg†Q\lKORd^YVQ\YVc;lbg/YZ[¸ô9Ç\g/f^O“g/cUQpYZQ¼d/aÃ(deǼg¨[eORNvg¨gcXORTVr\OXdeYZMkQ\[·MkQORTVTkif^YZd^g/f^Y¤O
WMPORTZd^g/f^Q\ORd^YVc;g†[a¼O;QnYVNví¼feMXc;gNvg/Qkd(MRËM;Q\g6MRË
ò d^NvǼM;g/Q¼N<M;d^M;M;QnQ\YVOXidY¯d}TVÓPg/O;̨[šWd¨MkǼQ¼gQg¢iifeMkY¯Nvdegí\feYZORMkfeQKYZQ\ËåÃ,feM;d}N<
Ôõ[^ǼMkr¼TVlQ¼MRdlbgd^gfeYVM;fOXd^goY¯d[iMkNÒíORfeYV[^M;Q
d^MvdeǼg6MRdeǼgfMkQ¼g;a
ò d}Q¼W¨M;Q¼MPÌxO;feg/älbMXr\ckQ\g*l¼iORM;QQ\ilbÓ,YZd^ÌYVM;l¼Qg[TVàgd^YVM;QMR˘ORQUÓPifeYZd^gfeYVM;QvËåfeM;NÐÔÅWYVTZT·iMkQpd^fO;lbY¤i$d¦MkQ¼g-M;˸d^Ç\g
SUr\iÇOvlbg/iYV[^YZMkQí¼f^Mkä¼TVgN<Y¤[iO;TZTVg/lÂöÒ÷bøˆù ú ûŽøZüÒýþ$ú`ù•üþ$ú«ÿ7þ^ÿ Rú 6û9þ øVüöÒà {dY¤[]UQ¼MXWQ
d^Ç\ORdd^ǼgM;Q¼TVÓ#YVQbËåM;feNPOXdeYZMkQêiM;NvYVQ¼ÃM;rbd6ËåfeM;N.d^ǼgKËåM;feNr¼T¤OXdeYZMkQáM;˨deǼY¤[í¼feM;ä¼TVgN YV[
d^Ǽg¢lbM;NvYVQ\ORQigfORQ¼]UYVQ¼Ã\à ¸gdr\[¨feg/iO;TZT\d^Ç\ORdYVQPdeǼg*l¼M;NvYZQORQ\igfeO;Q¼]UYZQ\Ã\akO;T¯degfeQ\OXdeYZckg
ãçáÏ=Y¤[-í¼fegËåg/f^feg/lndeMnO;T¯degfeQ\OXdeYZckg çáÏÕÍ«lbg/Q¼MRdOXd^YVM;QÂã ÎYZ˨ORQ\l2M;Q¼TVÓY¯Ë× â Í«ãbÎ × â Í Î(ËåM;f*ORTVT˜æç#Ôva9WYZd^Ç#ORdoTVg/O;[šd-MkQ¼g[šd^feYVid-YZQ\g pr\ORTVYZd}Ó NvM;fegMXc;g/f/a¼ã7Y¤[-YVQ\lbYZô9g/f^g/Qpd
d^
M nÍ«lbg/Q¼MRdOXdeYZMkQáã Î*Y¯ËO;Q\láM;Q¼TVÓ2YZË× â Í«ãbÎ6Ûó× â Í Î*ËåMkfORTVTæ6çèÔ ¸Ç¼gQig;a¸ËåM;fO;QpÓ
d}W¨MPORTZd^g/f^QOXd^YVc;g†[(ã Ø oçÏa¼M;Q\g*M;˄deǼg¢ËåM;r\f[šYZd^r\ORd^YVM;Q\[NvO“Ó7ORfeYV[^goYVQnd^Ǽgl¼M;NvYZQORQ\ig
feO;Q¼]UYZQ¼Ãñ㠓a 6ã9aã 7ORQ\lè㠓aWǼg/f^gnd^Ç\g2TVOk[}dPMkQ¼gNÒg†ORQ\[ÒdeÇ\OXdã ORQ\!
l 7ORfeg
YZQ\iM;Nví\O;feO;ä¼TZgk#à "-[^r\O;TZTVÓ;ad^ǼglbM;NvYVQ\ORQ\igfORQ¼]UYVQ¼ÃYV[˜c;g/f^ÓoíMUM;f†aYxà g;àdeǼg¦NvMp[}d¸Ëåfeg pr¼g/Qpd
[šYZd^r\ORd^YVM;QnYV[-㠓à
•QáMkfel¼gf¢d^Mg/Q¼feYViÇád^Ç\glbM;NvYVQ\ORQigPfORQ¼]UYVQ¼Ã\a·N,r¼T¯deYZí\TZgif^YZd^g/f^Y¤Olbg/iYV[^YVM;QÑORY¤lbYVQ¼Ã
Í«%
q $ëé*Î%ǼgTVí\[YVQviM;Q[}def^r\id^YVM;QÒMRˎORQvORÃ;Ãkf^g/ÃkORd^YVM;Q6NvMblbgTbMkQdeǼgä\O;[^g(MRË9í¼f^gËågfegQ\ig
Dagstuhl Seminar Proceedings 04461
Practical Approaches to Multi-Objective Optimization
http://drops.dagstuhl.de/opus/volltexte/2005/247
YZQbËåMkf^NPORd^YVM;QP[šr\í¼í¼TVYZg†lPäUÓd^Ç\g-ëoq3àUSUriÇKORQPORÃkÃ;fegÃkORd^YVM;Q,NÒMblbg/T\Y¤[¦i/ORTVTZg†lví¼f^gËågfegQ\ig
NÒMblbg/TÌYZdKYZQlbr\ig†[KOáí¼fegËågfegQig[}def^ri$d^r\f^gYVQÄ[šgdPÏ WǼMk[^gí¼f^Mkíg/fPgðbí¼TVM;YZdeORd^YVM;Q
íg/f^NvYZde[(deMÒWM;fe]PM;r¼d-O,fORQ\]pYVQ¼Ãví¼feM;í9Mk[^g/lKd^Mvd^Ç\gëoqÑà
î(Ǽgí¼f^gËågfegQ\igYZQbËåMkf^NPORd^YVM;QÉNvO“ÓÊäg2g/Y¯deǼgfKl¼YZfeg/idKM;fPYVQ\lbYVf^g†i$d/al¼gí9gQ\lbYVQ¼ÃÑYZË
Y¯d2[^íg†iYZÈ\g/[lbYVf^g†i$deTZÓÄcXORTVr¼g†[7M;ËÒ[^M;Nvgáí\ORfORNvgdegf[Kr\[^g/l YVQ d^Ç\gáí\f^gËågfegQ\igÂNvMblbgT
Íåg;à Ã\àd^fO;l¼gÌ{MRôÂWgYVÃ;Çpd[a9O;[^í¼YZfOXdeYZMkQTZg/c;gT¤[/albY¤[^if^YVNvYZQOXd^YVM;Q2d^Ǽfeg/[^ǼM;T¤l¼[/a\gdeiRà~ÎMkf-YZ˦YZd
[ší9g/iY¯È\g†[¢[šMkNÒgÒgð¼O;NÒí\TZg†[oM;˨ǼMkTZY¤[šd^Y¤'i &}r\l¼Ã;NvgQpde[*ËåfeM;N)WÇ\YViÇêiMkNÒíOXd^YVä¼TVg,cXO;TZr¼g†[*MRË
d^Ǽg6í¼fegËåg/f^g/Q\ig¢NvMblbgT˜í\ORfORNvgdegf[¨O;f^g¢YVQ\lbr\ig/l·à
ë-YVf^g†i$d˜í\f^gËågfegQ\igYZQbËåMkf^NPORd^YVM;Q6Y¤[¸r\[^g/l¢YVQ¢d^Ǽg¦d^fO;lbYZd^YVM;QORT;O;Ã;Ã;fegÃpOXdeYZMkQ-í\O;feOklbYZÃkNa
O;iiM;flbYVQ¼ÃÒd^MKWǼY¤iÇd^Ç\gORÃkÃ;fegÃkORd^YVM;Q7NÒMblbg/T„Y¤[(È\f[šdoiMkQ\[}def^ri$d^g†lORQ\lndeǼgQ2O;í¼í¼TVYZg†l
M;Q[šgd-Ï deMPfeO;Q¼]vd^Ç\gORTZd^gfeQ\ORd^YVc;g/[/à •Q\lbYVf^g†i$dí¼fegËåg/f^g/Q\ig*YVQbËåM;feNPOXd^YVM;QnY¤[(r\[šg†lnYZQnd^Ç\g
lbYV[eORÃkÃ;fegÃpOXd^YVM;QáÍåMkff^g/Ã;feg/[e[šYVM;Q9Îí\O;feOklbYVÃ;Na\O;i/iMkfelbYVQ¼Ã,d^MKWÇ\YViÇnd^Ç\gǼM;TVY¤[}deYVi6í\f^gËågf^Ì
gQ\ig/[MkQOP[^r¼ä\[^gdoMRËORTZd^gfeQ\ORd^YVc;g/[)Ï (+*ÄÏ ORfeg¢]pQ\MXWQ7Èfe[šd-ORQ\l7deǼgQ2OKiM;Q\[^Y¤[}degQpd
ORÃ;Ãkf^g/ÃkORd^YVM;Q#NvMblbg/T¦Y¤[6YZQ¼Ëågfef^g†láËåf^MkN d^Ç\YV[YZQbËåMkf^NPORd^YVM;Qád^M2ä9gO;í¼í¼TVYZg†lêM;QÑ[šgd,ÏÐYVQ
M;flbgf„d^M¢fORQ¼]*d^Ç\g(O;T¯degfeQ\OXdeYZckg/[/-à ,¦f^g†[šg/Qpd^TVÓ;aX%
q $ëéÉNvgdeǼMbl¼[%ä\O;[^g/lM;QÒYZQ\l¼YZfeg/id%í¼fegË`Ì
gfegQ\ig¨YVQbËåM;feNPOXdeYZMkQORQ\ld^ǼglbY¤[eORÃ;Ãkf^g/ÃkORd^YVM;Q¢í\ORfO;l¼YZÃkNÆO;f^g¨MRË\YVQ\if^g†O;[^YZQ¼ÃoYZQpdegfeg/[šd„ËåMkf
d^Ǽg/Ó,feg pr¼YVf^gfegT¤OXdeYZckgTVÓTVg/[e[¦iMkÃ;Q¼YZd^YVc;g(gô9MkfšdËåfeM;Nõd^Ǽg*ëoq3.à •Q\lbg/g/l·a;d^ǼgolbYV[eORÃkÃ;fegÃpOXÌ
d^YVM;QÒí\ORfO;lbYVÃ;NÅY¤[iM;Q\[^YV[šd^g/Qpd%WYZd^ÇÒd^Ç\'g /Rí9Mk[šd^gfeYVM;f%feORd^YVM;Q\O;TZYZd}Ó /-í9Mk[šd^r¼T¤OXdeg/l,äUÓq2ORfiÇ
Í}Ý 0132pΨO;Q\lnWY¯deÇd^ǼgYZQ\l¼r\i$deYZckg6TZg†ORfeQ¼YZQ\ÃÒr[šg†l7YVQ2ORf^d^YZÈiYVO;T·YZQpd^g/TZTVYVÃ;gQigORí\í¼f^MpO;iǼg†[
Í«qY¤iÇ\ORT¤[^]pYgd(ORTxà\Ý 0
0.2pÎ$à;î¨ÓUí¼YVi/ORT9ORí¼í¼TVY¤iOXdeYZMkQ\[M;ˎd^ǼY¤[¦íORfO;lbYVÃ;N=YZQ4
q $ëé O;f^gí\f^gÌ
[šg/Qkdeg/l¢YVQKÍ SUfeYVQ¼YZcXOk[^O;Q¢O;Q\l6SUǼMbi];g/fÝ 0135\6a ,g/];g/TZNPORQ6O;Q\l6SUgQP-Ý 01 79a 8kOk#i pr¼gdš:Ì ˜ORÃkf #g; <g
ORQ\l#SbYV[^];Mp[6Ý 0
2 ß >a =¢YV[e[gd*ORTxà˜-Ý 0.0.7\a ?(ORQOvg $¨Mk[šdeO\a\mO;Q\[šQ\YVi]áÝ 0
07\aqM;r\[e[^g/ORrO;Q\l
SUTZMXWYVQ\[^]UYÝ 0.0
2¼a¼h*feg/iMÒgd-O;T à·-Ý 0.0
0¼a ß@
@ Ý;a¼SUTVMXWYVQ\[š]UY·gd-ORTxà ß@.@ 7pÎà
•Q6d^ǼY¤[%í\ORí9gf†a“W¨gORfeg¦iMkQ\[^YVlbg/f^YVQ¼Ã-d^Ǽg(ORÃkÃ;fegÃkORd^YVM;Q*NvMUl¼gTUYZQËåM;feNÆMRËO;QO;l¼l¼Y¯deYZckg
c“O;TZr\gËår¼Q\id^YVM;B
Q AvÍ«ãbÎD
Û C ÚFâ E _G âšÍ«ãbÎa9WÇ\gfeg G âšÍ«ãbÎ @ a9æÛ Ý ØÙ/ÙÙ·Ø ÖaŽORfegNPORfeÃ;YVQ\O;T
c“O;TZr\g6Ëår¼Q\id^YVM;Q\[/à\Áág,O;f^g6r\[^YVQ¼ÃPd^Ç\YV[oORÃ;Ãkf^g/ÃkORd^YVM;QNvMblbg/T˜YVQd^Ǽg,[šgdšd^YVQ¼Ãp[MRËdeǼglbY¤[}Ì
ORÃ;Ãkf^g/ÃkORd^YVM;Q#íORfO;lbYVÃ;Na˜Ok[YZdÇ\O;[äg/gQÑí¼feM;í9Mk[^g/láYVQÑd^Ç\Hg "-î%é<NvgdeǼMbl IÍ 8pO;i pr¼gd^Ì
˜ORÃkf #g ; <g6O;Q\l#SUY¤[š]kMk[6-Ý 0.2 Î$
à •QË«O;id/a9M;r¼foNÒgd^ǼMbl#Ã;gQ\gfORTVJY </g/[d^Ç\Kg "oî„éõNÒgd^ǼMbläUÓ
r\[šYVQ¼ÃO6[^gdM;ˎO;TZT\Okl¼lbYZd^YVc;ß g(cXORTVr¼g(Ëår¼Q\id^YVM;Q\[oÍ}ݓÎiM;Nví\ORd^YVä¼TVgWY¯deÇPYZQ\l¼YZfeg/idí¼f^gËågfegQ\ig
YZQbËåMkf^NPORd^YVM;Q2Ç\O“cUYVQ¼ÃKdeǼgÒËåM;feNÞMR˨O7í¼fegM;flbg/f-YVQáO7[šr¼ä[šgd*M;˨ORTZd^g/f^Q\ORd^YVc;g†[o)Ï (L*ÅÏà
é-[¢OPfeg/[^r¼T¯d†aŽW¨g,WYZTVT„MkäbdeO;YZQ2d}W¨M7feO;Q¼]UYZQ¼Ãp[YVQd^Ç\gÒ[^gd¢MR˦O;T¯degfeQ\OXdeYZckg/[-Ïa·[šr\iÇ2d^Ç\ORd
ËåM;fORQUÓKíORYVfMRË%O;T¯degfeQ\OXdeYZckg/[(ã Ø oçÏñ
ò YZAvQnÍ«deãbǼMÎ g¢NÈ\fAv[}dÍ Í Î[}deËåf^M;Mkf*Q¼ORÃpTVΨT˜cXfORORQ¼TVr¼]Ug6YVQ¼ËåÃ\r¼abQãKi$d^Y¤YV[(M;Qf[-ORQ¼i]kMkg/Nvlní\OXOXddeYZTZä¼g†TVO;g[šdWO;YZd^[(ÇÃ;deMUǼMbglnYVO;Q\'[ lbYVofeg/Y¯Ëi$doORQí¼lf^gMkËågQ¼feTZgÓQ\iY¯Ë}g a
YZQ¼ËåM;feNvORd^YVM;Q¸a
iMkQ\l3Í«W¨g†OR]¼ÎfORQ\]pYVQ¼ÃaãY¤[ofORQ\];g/lORd*TVg/Ok[}d¢O;[oÃ;MUMbl2O;O[ 6YZ˨O;Q\lM;Q\TZÓ
ò YZY¯Ë}Q#Pa d^AvǼͫgvãb'Î[^g/N
AvÍ Î¨ËåMkfoORdTZg†O;[šdM;Q¼gcXO;TZr¼g¢Ëår\Q\i$deYZMkQ2iM;Nví\ORd^YVä¼TVgWY¯deÇd^ǼgYZQ\l¼YZfeg/id
í¼fegËågfegQig¢YZQ¼ËåM;feNvORd^YVM;Q¸à
î(ǼgÈ\f[}dÍ«[šd^feM;Q¼ÃUΎfeO;Q¼]UYZQ\ÃiORQ6ä9g¦iM;Q\[^YVl¼gfeg/l¢O;[˜f^Mkä¼r\[šd˜WY¯deÇ6f^g†[ší9g/id¸d^Md^Ǽg¨YZQ\l¼YZfeg/id
í¼f^gËågfegQ\ig¢YZQbËåMkf^NPORd^YVM;Q¸àSbr\iÇf^Mkä¼r\[šd^Q¼g†[^[(M;Ë%deǼg[šd^feM;Q¼ÃvfORQ¼]UYVQ¼Ãvf^gËågf[d^Mvd^Ç\g6Ë«O;id
d^Ç\ORdORQUÓ2í\O;YZf6M;Ë(O;T¯degfeQ\OXdeYZckg/[¢iMkNÒíORfeg/[*YZQádeǼgK[^O;NvgÒW(O“Ó2WÇ\ORd^g/c;gf*deǼgKO;l¼l¼Y¯deYZckg
c“O;TZr\gËår¼Q\id^YVM;QiM;Nví\ORd^YVä¼TZg¨WY¯deÇdeǼg¦YVQ\lbYVf^g†i$d%í¼f^gËågfegQ\igYVQbËåM;feNPOXd^YVM;Q˜à •Q\l¼gg/l¸a/WǼg/Q
Q¼M-YVQ\lbYVf^g†i$dí¼fegËågfegQigYVQbËåM;feNPOXdeYZMkQYV[%ÃkYZckgQ¸ad^Ǽg([}def^MkQ¼ÃfORQ¼]UYVQ¼ÃoiM;fef^g†[ší9M;Ql¼[Žd^Mod^Ç\g
lbM;NvYVQ\ORQ\ig¦fORQ¼]UYVQ¼Ã\à/éQ¼M;d^Ǽg/f%O;í¼íg†ORTpMRË\[^r\iÇO;QORí¼í¼feMkOkiÇ6[}degNP[¸ËåfeM;N deǼg¦Ë«Oki$d„d^Ç\ORd
Y¯d-ÃkYZckg/[[^í\O;ig¢ËåM;fYVQpd^g/feOki$d^YVcUY¯d}ÓWY¯deÇd^Ǽgë*qÑPà $¨M;Q\[^YVl¼gfeYZQ¼ÃPO;QnYVQ\lbYVfeg/i$doí¼f^gËågfegQ\ig
2
ZY QbËåMkf^NPORd^YVM;Qí¼feMXcUYVl¼g/l¢äUÓ-deǼg(ëoqÑa†deǼg¦í¼feg/[^gQpdOXd^YVM;Q6M;˼d^Ç\g¨[šd^feM;Q¼ÃfORQ\]pYVQ¼ÃY¤[%OÃ;MUMbl
[šr¼í\íMkfšd¸ËåMkf˜ÃkgQ¼g/feORd^YVQ¼Ãf^g†O;id^YVM;Q\[ŽËåfeM;N d^Ç\g¦ëoq3à-QoORNvgTVÓ;apÍ«[ΕǼgiM;r\TVl¢WY¤[šÇ¢deM-g/Q¼f^Y¤iÇ
d^ǼgvfORQ¼]UYVQ¼Ã7Mkf*d^MiMkQkdefeOklbY¤i$d6O7íORf^d*M;˨YZd/à˜î(ǼY¤[¢feg/O;id^YVM;QÂW¨Mkr¼TVl#ägPYVQpd^g/Ã;fOXd^g†l2YVQ
d^Ǽg6YVQ\lbYVf^g†i$dí¼fegËåg/f^g/Q\ig*YVQbËåM;feNPOXd^YVM;QnYVQ7deǼg6Q¼gðpdYZd^g/feORd^YVM;Q¸à
éË`d^g/fO;QPM;rbdeTZYVQ¼goMRË·d^Ç\g-í¼feYZQiYVí¼TZgoMRË·deǼg-MkfelbYVQ\O;T\fegÃ;feg/[e[^YZMkQ,cUY¤O6TZYVQ¼g†ORf¦í\f^MkÃ;fORNÒÌ
NÒYVQ¼Ãa¼O;[í¼feM;í9Mk[^g/lPYVQdeǼg¢M;feYZÃkYZQORRT "-î%é Nvgd^ǼMblêÍ«[^gOg 8kOk#i pr¼gdš:Ì ˜ORÃkf #g; <gO;Q\l7SbYV[^];Mp[
Ý 0.2 Îa\Wg,í¼feMXcUYVl¼gNvMRdeYZcXOXdeYZMkQ\[-ËåM;fod^ǼgvQ¼g/W ORí¼í¼feMkOkiǸàî(Ç\g,Q¼g/D
W "-î%éóNvgd^Ç\MUl#YV[
í¼f^g†[šß g/Qpd^g/lPd^M;ÃkgdeǼgf¨WY¯deÇYZde[YZNví¼TVgNvg/QkdOXdeYZMkQKM;QO ,S$oàUéQ7gð¼ORNví¼TVg-M;˄ORí¼í\TZY¤iORd^YVM;Q
gQ\l¼[d^Ǽg6í¼feg/[^gQpdOXd^YVM;Q˜à
TVUXWYUXZ[UX\M]RU_^
$oà é[
à ?(ORQ\O,`g $¨Mk[šdeO¼a 8aà $oàUmO;Q\[šQ\YVi]2ÍšÝ 0.0.7pÎaUq#Mé $S?Sb¨dî c ̦O;QYVQpd^gfO;id^YVc;g*í\OXdeÇ
d^MXW(ORfl¼[¦d^Ǽg6iMkQ\[šd^fer\i$deYZMkQMRËiO;felbYVQ\O;T9cXO;TZr¼goËår¼Q\id^YVM;Q\[/à•Qpd^g/f^Q\ORd^YVM;Q\O;T·î˜fORQ\[eO;iÌ
d^YVM;Q\[YZf
Q eoíg/feORd^YVM;Q\O;T¸Lg/[^g/O;feiÇÂÝ;a 72.0XhÌ g @
@ à
SŽà;h*feg/iM3a ?oàRq#OXdeO;fe.O <#</M\a/Là;SUTZMXWYVQ\[^]UYŽÍšÝ 0
0.0kÎaXî(Ǽg(r\[šgMRË9f^Mkr¼Ã;ÇÒ[šgde[ORQlËå[r <<Ó
[šgde[%YVQÒ%
q $ë*qÑà $¨ÇORíbdegf(#Ý 7Ki YVQ j{ñRî¢à h¢O;T aRî¢à~Spd^g/WO;fšd†aXî¢à coORQ¼Q¼g¢Íåg†l¼[/à ÎaRé-lbcXORQig/[
YZQ7qr¼TZd^YVí¼TZg $¨feY¯degfeYVO6ëog/iYV[^YZMkQKq2OR]UYVQ¼Ã\à =¢TZrUWgfé-iOklbgNvY¤'i ,r\ä¼TZY¤[^Ǽgf[a ?Mk[šd^M;Q˜a
í¼í¸à¸Ý 7\àVÝÌ#Ý 7à g.0¼à
SŽàbh*f^g†iM\a ?*àpq2ORdeO;fe.O <#<Ma;L6àbSUTVMXWYZQ\[^]UY apLM;r\Ã;ÇK[^gd¦deǼgMkf^Ó,ËåM;f¨Nr¼TZd^Y¤ifeYZd^gfeY¤OlbgÌ
iY¤[šYVM;QORQORTVÓU[^Y¤[[à b¦r¼f^Mkíg†ORkQ 8\àbM;lË eoí9gfOXdeYZMkQ\ORT·Lg†[šg†ORfiÇ#Ý ß 0¼aŽÝmÌ 71bà
bà 8pO;i kr\gdš:Ì ˜O;Ã;f #g ; </g;#a n,àkSUY¤[^];Mk[ÍšÝ 0
2 ÎaXé-[e[šg†[^[^YZQ\âO¢[^gdM;Ë9O;l\lbY¯deYZckgrbd^YVTVY¯d}ÓËår¼Q\i$Ì
d^YVM;Q\[¦ËåM;fNr\T¯deYVif^YZd^g/f^Y¤Olbg†iY¤[šYVM;QKNPO;]pß YVQ¼ÃñRd^Ç\g"oî„é Nvgd^Ç\MUl¸àb¦r¼feM;í9g/ORQo8kM;r¼feQ\O;T
MRË eoíg/feORd^YVM;Q\O;T·Lg/[^g/O;feiÇÂÝ @ a·Ý gbÝÌe-Ý p7\à
R
à =¢YV[e[/a 8à q3à9q2O;fšdegTxa9Là QoO;lbg†ORrÊÍšÝ 0.0.7pÎa b_bS$d$Mé q$ Ì(O;QYZQpdegfO;i$deYZckg[^MRË`dšÌ
WO;f^g,ËåM;f6NvMblbg/TZYVQ¼Ãd^Ç\gKlbg/iYV[^YZMkQÂNPO;];g-f r [oí\f^gËågfegQ\ig/[/àŽëog/iYV[^YVM;Q3SUr¼í¼í9M;f^d,SUÓb[šÌ
d^g/Nv[/a¸Ý ß ÍšÝ 0
07psÎ 1g1†tÌ 1.1
1Uà
L6à~SŽàqYViÇORT¤[š]UYxXa $qà ?¨fOXde];Ma˜qÑuà =¢r¼ä\ORdnÍåg†l¼[/à ÎÍ}Ý 0
0.2pÎ$a„q#O;iǼYVQ¼Hg ˜g/ORfeQ¼YVQ¼Ã#O;Q\l
ëoORdeOPqYVQ¼YVQ¼ÃǪ̀qgd^ǼMbl¼[O;Q\léí¼í¼TVY¤iOXdeYZMkQ\[/àbÁÄYZTVgÓka Qg/L
W nMkf^]Žà
mà¼qMkr\[e[šg†ORr¸apL6à\SUTVMXWYZQ\[^]UY%ÍšÝ 0
0.2kÎ
a •Q¼Ëågfef^YVQ¼Ã,O;vQ bwXbS$îML b3îdL NvMblbgT9ËåfeM;N
O;[e[šYVÃ;Q\NÒg/Qpd(gð¼ORNví¼TVg/[/[à 8;Mkr¼f^QORTŽMRËh*TZMkä\ORxT eoí¼d^YVNÒFY </ORd^YVM;QáÝ ß a·-Ý g
1“Ìe3Ý 1 7à
ë_à ,g];g/TZNPO;Q¸a¸SŽà =và˜SbgQèÍ}Ý 01 7UÎ$a·q2OXdeǼgNPORd^Y¤iORTí\f^MkÃ;fORNvNvYZQ¼Ã7NvMUl¼gT¤[*ËåM;f¢d^Ç\g
lbgdegfeNvYZQ\ORd^YVM;QnMRËOXd^d^feYZä¼r¼d^g6WgYVÃ;Çpde[/àbq2ORQ\O;Ã;g/NÒg/QpdS¼iYVgQ\ig ß @ aŽÝ ß Ý 1“ÌeÝ ß;ß 0¼à
?*à˜LMXÓ;a¸ë,_
à ?Mkr¼Ób[^[^M;rÉÍ}Ý 0
0.5pÎ$a·éY¤lbgqr\T¯deYVif^YZd g/; f^y
g O; T¤Onf
ë g†z iY¤[šYVM;Q¸ñ¸{
q gz deǼMblbg/[¢gd
$O;[/[
à b¦iM;Q¼MkNÒY¤iO\a ,ORfeYV[/à
3
L6à\SUTVMXWYZQ[š]UYxabS·à\h*f^g†iM\a ?*àbq2OXdORfO <<M7Í 7pÎapLM;r¼ÃkÇ7[^gdä\O;[^g/l7lbg/iYV[^YVM;Q7[^r¼íbÌ
í Mkfšd†à $¨Ç\O;íbd^g/f¦Ý-p(YZQ¸ñ-?r¼f^]kglbàVa=¢g/Q\l¼ORTVTkhÒß @
àVa@ g†l¼[ñ•Qpd^feMUl¼r\i$deM;feÓoî„rbd^Mkf^Y¤ORT¤[·M;Qeoí¼Ì
d^YVNvYJ<†OXd^YVM;Q˜a˜SUg/O;feiÇáORQ\láë-g†iY¤[šYVM;QÑSUr¼í\íMkfšdqgd^ǼMblbMkTZMkÃ;YVg/[/àR=¢TVrUW¨g/f*éoiOklbgNvY¤i
,r¼ä\TZY¤[šÇ\gf[a[?Mk[šd^MkQ¸à
màSbf^YVQ¼YVc“Ok[^O;Q¸abéà ëà9SUǼMbi];g/f¢ÍšÝ 0135kÎa b¦[šd^YVNvORd^YVQ¼ÃÒd^Ǽg6WgYVÃ;Çpd[¦ËåMkfNr¼TZd^YVí¼TVg6OXdšÌ
d^feYZä\rbd^g†[YVQêOiM;Nví9Mk[^Y¯degKifeY¯degfeYZMkQár[šYVQ¼Ãí\O;YZfeWYV[^g &}r\lbÃkNÒg/Qpde[/_à ,¦[^ÓbiǼM;Nvgd^feYZ]XO
5.2\
a 7135R|Ì 70.5\à
4