OL T|4@* i?@*|it @?}i | |i 4L?| Lu
O@h4
,hU +@t4ti?
M*ti_G W?|ih?@|L?@* +ii Lu w@ @?_ ,UL?L4Ut EbbD DG ffH
Mt|h@U|
W?||L? |i**t t |@| |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|) @?_ ULh| U@hi |L @L_ ihhLh
tL*_ hti t4LL|*) | |i @h4 |L |i U|4 At t ?L| @*@)t ULhhiU|G
tL4i|4it |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|) @?_ *ii* Lu ULh| U@hi ?Uhi@ti _tUL?|?
Lt*) | @h4c ii? i? Ti?@*|it _i|ih @h4 @?_ ULh| U@hi hi_Uit
ihhLh UL?|?Lt*) At t tL? ? @ 4L_i* ? U |i tLU@* ULt| Lu
Uh4i UL?tt|t Lu |t _hiU| @h4c |i ULt| Lu ULh| U@hic @?_ |i ULt| Lu u@*ti
UL?U|L?t
Gudiw= 714 +Gudiw 414/ Mxo| 4<<4,1
L zrxog olnh wr wkdqn Mrkq Orww/ Vwhyhq Vkdyhoo dqg wzr dqrq|prxv uhihuhhv
iru khosixo frpphqwv1 Pxfk ri wklv zrun zdv frpsohwhg zkloh wkh dxwkru zdv
Rolq Idfxow| Ihoorz dw \doh Odz Vfkrro dqg rq wkh idfxow| ri XFOD*v Dqghuvrq
Judgxdwh Vfkrro ri Pdqdjhphqw1
5333= Hulf Udvpxvhq/ Surihvvru ri Exvlqhvv Hfrqrplfv dqg Sxeolf Sro0
lf| dqg Vdqmd| Vxekhgdu Idfxow| Ihoorz/ Lqgldqd Xqlyhuvlw|/ Nhooh| Vfkrro ri Exvl0
qhvv/ EX 789/ 463< H 43wk Vwuhhw/ Eorrplqjwrq/ Lqgldqd/ 7:73804:341 Rfh= +;45,
;880<54<1 Id{= ;450;88066871 HudvpxvhClqgldqd1hgx1 Sks1lqgldqd1hgx2hudvpxvh1
W?|hL_U|L?
5L*_ @ Uh4i<t Ti?@*|) hti t4LL|*) ? ThLTLh|L? |L |i Uh4i<t
@h4u*?ittq At tii4t LMLtc @?_ @t @ tL?_ iUL?L4U ?||L? Mi?_
| Ai LT|4@* Ti?@*|) t |i hit*| Lu @ |h@_iLg Mi|ii? |i Ti?@*|)<t ULt|t
@?_ Mi?i|tc @?_ i? |h@_iLgt @hi 4@_ic |i) t@**) U@?}i t4LL|*)
Wu |i @h4 ?Uhi@tit t*}|*)c |i? tLc | tii4tc tL*_ |i Ti?@*|) Wu |i
Ti?@*|) t 4ThtL?4i?|c |i? |LL tLh| @ ThtL? |ih4 hit*|t ? |LL 4U
Uh4i @?_ |LL *L?} @ ThtL? |ih4 hit*|t ? i Uitti tTi?_?} L? ThtL?t t4*@h @h}4i?| U@? Mi 4@_i |L tL |@| |i U@hi |i ULh| |@!it | @
T@h|U*@h U@ti tL*_ Mi t4LL|*) ?Uhi@t?} ? |i @h4u*?itt Lu |i Uh4i
?L*i_
At ?||L? t _iUi?}G Ti?@*|it @?_ ULh| U@hi tL*_ ?L| @*@)t
hti t4LL|*) | @h4 Ai 4L_i* Mi*L ** uLh4@*3i |i _i@ |@|
|i LT|4@* Ti?@*|) @?_ ULh| U@hi ?L*i |h@_iLgt Mi|ii? |i Ti?@*|)<t
ULt| @?_ Mi?i| Ai Ti?@*|) @?_ ULh| U@hi ** ?L| @U|@**) _iU*?i @t
@h4 ?Uhi@titc M| |i) 4@) 4T t@hT*)c ii? i? |i @h4 ?Uhi@tit
t4LL|*)
Ai hi@tL? uLh |i _tUL?|?Lt 4Tt t |@| ?Uhi@t?} |i Ti?@*|)
@t |i }LL_ igiU| Lu hi_U?} Uh4i M| |i M@_ igiU| Lu ?Uhi@t?} |i
Ti?@*|) ULt|t L? |Lti Uh4?@*t | t|** u@*t |L _i|ih At t |i _i@ |@|
wLt k@T*L Ebbf@c bbfM @t ti_ |L tL ) LT|4@* ULt|*) Ti?@*|it
** tL4i|4it Mi i|ih 3ihL Lh 4@ 4@* Nt?} @ 4L_i* M@ti_ L? L*?t!)
: 5@i** EbHec i tLi_ |@| |i tLU@* LT|43@|L? ThLM*i4 t ?L|
UL?i @?_ tL 4@) @i ULh?ih tL*|L?t Ai Ti?@*|) 4}|c uLh i @4T*ic
@i ih) i@! _i|ihhi?Ui @*ic tL ?Uhi@t?} | Mi)L?_ 3ihL L*_ ?Uhi@ti
tLU@* i Ti?_|hi |L| 4U hi_U?} Uh4i h Tih@Tt @t |i Ti?@*|)
MiUL4it 4Lhi tiihic | ?ii_t |L Mi U@hhi_ L| tL 4U *itt Lu|i? |@| |i
|L|@* ULt| u@**t @?_ |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|) t 4@ 4@* iU@ti Lu |iti ULh?ih
tL*|L?tc |ihi ** Mi tL4i @h4 *ii* @| U |i ULh?ih tL*|L? 4Tt
uhL4 3ihL |L 4@ 4@*c M| uLh |i 4Lt| T@h| |i Uh4i<t Ti?@*|) tL*_ Mi
?hi*@|i_ |L |t @h4u*?itt
Ai 4L_i* ? |i Thiti?| @h|U*i ** Mi tL4i@| _gihi?| 5|@?_@h_
@tt4T|L?t ** Mi 4@_i |L h*i L| |i ULh?ih tL*|L?t Lu 3ihL Lh 4@ 4@*
LT|4@* Ti?@*|itc |i tLU@* ULt| Lu Ti?@*|it ** @hti uhL4 u@*ti UL?U|L?tc
U U@? Mi hi_Ui_ M) }hi@|ih ULh| U@hic @?_ |i uLUt ** Mi L? L
Ti?@*|it @?_ ULh| U@hi U@?}i | @h4
2 Ai L_i*
wi| @ Uih|@? |)Ti Lu Uh4i U@ti @h4 Ai @4L?| ?ER Lu |t
Uh4i _iTi?_t L? |i i TiU|i_ Ti?@*|)c R Ai ThLM@M*|) Lu UL?U|L? **
Mi @tt4i_ |L Mi i L}i?Ltc tL R hiThiti?|t |i Ti?@*|) |ti*u2 wi| |i
_i|ihhi?Ui u?U|L? ?ER t@|tu) ?R fc ihi u6E?R ' 4 @t R $ fc
@?_ ? : 0 : f uLh tL4i UL?t|@?| 0 N?_ih |iti @tt4T|L?tc @__|L?@*
T?t4i?| @*@)t _i|iht 4Lhi Uh4i M| ?iih _hit | Mi*L 0c @?_ |i
4@h}?@* _i|ihhi?Ui t ??|i*) } t|@h|?} uhL4 3ihL T?t4i?|
6Lh i@U @h4 *ii* c tLUi|) ULLtit |i T?t4i?|c Rc @?_ |i U@hi
|@| ULh|t |@!i |L @L_ u@*ti UL?U|L?tc S #iTi?_?} L? |i T?t4i?|
@?_ ULh| U@hic tLUi|) ?Uht @ u@*tiUL?U|L? ULt| s ERc S Tih Uh4ic ihi
sR : B : f uLh tL4i UL?t|@?| Bc sS fc u6EsS ' 4 @t S $ fc @?_ sRS f
uLh @** R : f N?_ih |iti @tt4T|L?tc }hi@|ih T?t4i?| ?Uhi@tit |i ULt|
Lu u@*ti UL?U|L? M) @| *i@t| Bc }hi@|ih ULh| U@hi hi_Uit u@*ti UL?U|L?
@?_ @t ??|i 4@h}?@* Mi?i| t|@h|?} uhL4 @ *ii* Lu 3ihL U@hic @?_ |i
4@h}?@* Mi?i| uhL4 U@hi t }hi@|ih u |i Ti?@*|) t }hi@|ihe Ai ULt| Lu
4
Wkh kdup k frxog eh wkh gluhfw kdup wr wkh ylfwlp/ ru lw pljkw dgg wkh suhfdxwlrqv
ri srwhqwldo ylfwlpv dqg wkh hruw ri wkh fulplqdo dqg vxewudfw wkh fulph*v ehqhw wr
wkh fulplqdo1 Vhh Hkuolfk +4<;5, iru d glvfxvvlrq ri wkhrulhv ri wkh remhfwlyhv ri fulplqdo
sxqlvkphqw/ dqg Iulhgpdq +4<;4, dqg Vkdyhoo +4<;8/ s1 4577, iru glvfxvvlrqv ri zkhwkhu
shqdowlhv vkrxog lqfuhdvh zlwk wkh ehqhw wr wkh fulplqdo ru wkh kdup wr wkh ylfwlp1
5
Li s zhuh dvvxphg wr kdyh d gluhfw vrfldo frvw/ lw frxog uhsuhvhqw wkh hqirufhphqw ohyho
dv zhoo/ dqg wkh prgho zrxog eh olwwoh fkdqjhg1
6
Lw lv dvvxphg wkdw q A % ehfdxvh rwkhuzlvh wkh rswlpxp pljkw vshfli| lqqlwh shqdo0
wlhv wkdw holplqdwh fulph frpsohwho| lq zklfk fdvh wkhuh zrxog eh qr idovh frqylfwlrqv
hlwkhu1 Wkh dvvxpswlrqv wkdw qs dqg if ehfrph lqqlwh zkhq s dqg f duh }hur h{foxgh wkh
rssrvlwh h{wuhph= wkdw sxqlvkphqw dqg frxuw fduh duh vr lqhhfwlyh wkdw wkh| vkrxog eh
dedqgrqhg dowrjhwkhu1
7
Iru glvfxvvlrqv ri frxuw huuru/ vhh Sqj +4<;9,/ Srvqhu +4<:6,/ Vkdyhoo +4<;:,/ dqg
2
u@*ti UL?U|L?c sERc Sc ?U*_it tU |?}t @t |i _t|*|) Lu |Lti u@*ti*)
UL?U|i_c |i ht! MLh?i M) |Lti L ui@h |i) 4}| Mi u@*ti*) UL?U|i_c
|i _i|ihhi?Ui |L iUi?| Mi@Lh Uhi@|i_ M) ui@h Lu u@*ti T?t4i?|c @?_
|i TM*U<t _tUL4uLh| ? !?L?} |@| tL4i T?t4i?| t 4t|@!i?D
5LUi|)<t ThLM*i4 t |L ULLti R @?_ S |L 4?43i 7c |i t4 Lu |i
tLU@* ULt|t uhL4 c |i _hiU| @h4 uhL4 |i Uh4i( s c |i ULt| Lu u@*ti
UL?U|L?( @?_ S |i ULt| ULh| U@hi |L Thii?| u@*ti UL?U|L? 544?}
|iti )i*_t i^@|L? E
7 ' ?ERE n sERc S n S
E
#i|ihhi?Ui @t |L ULt|t ihiG 4t|@!i? T?t4i?| @?_ ULh| U@hi
iU@ti Lu _4?t?} hi|h?t |L ULh| U@hic ?L| i?L} ** Mi tTi?| |L
UL4T*i|i*) i*4?@|i u@*ti UL?U|L?t Bi? |tc |i _i|ihhi?Ui Mi?i|
uhL4 i@ih Ti?@*|it 4t| Mi i}i_ @}@?t| |i u@*tiUL?U|L? ULt|
Ai _i|ihhi?Ui Mi?i| t }hi@|ih u |i Uh4i U@tit 4Lhi @h4c tL uLh 4Lhi
@h4u* Uh4it |i |h@_iLg ** *i@_ |L }hi@|ih Ti?@*|it At t @ t4*|@
?iLt t)t|i4c tL |i }hi@|ih Ti?@*|it *i@_ ? |h? |L 4Lhi tTi?_?} |L @L_
u@*ti UL?U|L?t i? |i Uh4i<t @h4 t }hi@|ih W| U@? Mi tL?c |L}
W ** ?L| _L tL ihic |@| ?L| L?*) _Lit |i 4Lt| tiihi Uh4i ?L| hiUii
@? ??|i T?t4i?|c M| |ihi t ?L RM?U?} Lu Ti?@*|it @| |@| 4Lt|
tihLt Uh4iG Ti?@*|it @?_ ULh| U@hi hti | @h4S
Udvpxvhq +4<<7,> iru pruh vshflf glvfxvvlrq ri huuru dyrlgdqfh dv d jrdo ri mxvwlfh/ vhh
Hkuolfk +4<;5,/ Uxelqihog dqg Vdsslqjwrq +4<;:,/ dqg Ndsorz +4<<7,1 Qrwh wkdw lq wkh
suhvhqw sdshu/ xqolnh vrph ri wkhvh vwxglhv/ _frxuw fduh% lv wkh uhvxow ri wkh frxuw*v ghflvlrq/
qrw ri wkh olwljdqwv* ghflvlrqv rq krz pxfk wr vshqg1
8
Wr irfxv rq wkh frvw ri idovh sxqlvkphqw/ wkh prgho dvvxphv wkdw wkh sxeolf h{shqvh
ri fruuhfw sxqlvkphqw lv }hur wkh sxqlvkphqw wdnhv wkh irup ri Ehfnhuldq qhv zlwk }hur
wudqvdfwlrqv frvw1 Wklv dvvxpswlrq lv hdvlo| uhod{hg e| dgglqj dqrwkhu ixqfwlrq lqfuhdvlqj
lq q+s, dqg s/ exw wklv zrxog pdnh olwwoh glhuhqfh wr wkh uhvxowv1
9
Wkh surri wkdw shqdowlhv dqg frxuw fduh ulvh zlwk kdup udwkhu wkdq vwd|lqj frqvwdqw
lv dydlodeoh iurp wkh dxwkru1 Wkh dqdo|vlv kdv lpsolflwo| dvvxphg wkdw hdfk fulph lv
lqghshqghqw/ dyrlglqj wkh lvvxh ri pdujlqdo ghwhuuhqfh= d kljkhu shqdow| iru fulph k
fdxvlqj fulplqdov wr vxevwlwxwh wr ohvvhu rhqfhv/ dv ghvfulehg lq Vwljohu +4<:3,1 Vlqfh
pdujlqdo ghwhuuhqfh surylghv dq lqfhqwlyh wr vwhhshq wkh sxqlvkphqw vfkhgxoh udwkhu wkdq
@|i4@|U@**)c |i _U*|) | |t LT|43@|L? ThLM*i4 t |@| |i
4?4@?_ t ?L| UL?i Ai }Lih?4i?| t |h)?} |L 4?43i |i ULt| Lu
Uh4ic 7ERc S( Wu 7ERc S( ihi UL?i c LT|43@|L? |iLh) |i**t t |@|
RW E @?_ SW E L*_ Mi UL?|?Ltc M| L?i UL?_|L? uLh |i UL?i |) Lu
7ERc S( t |@| 7RR Mi TLt|ic ic |@|
?RR d n sERo n ?sRR n 2?R sR : f
E2
Wu ?i^@*|) E2 t u@*tic |i? |i tiUL?_Lh_ihUL?_|L? uLh |i ThLM
*i4 t ?L| t@|ti_ @?_ |i 4T*U| u?U|L? |iLhi4 U@??L| Mi ti_ |L tL
|@| |i _ih@|i R i t|t @?_ t TLt|i. W?i^@*|) E2 U@? i@t*) Mi u@*ti
?_ih |i 4L_i*<t @tt4T|L?tc U t@_ ?L|?} @ML| |i t}? Lu ?RR Lh
sRR Aihi t ?L }LL_ hi@tL? uLh tTTLt?} |@| i|ih ? Lh s t UL?U@i Lh
UL?i ( |i) @hi 4Lhi *!i _i4@?_ u?U|L?tc U 4}| @i @?) Uh@
|hic |@? *!i ULt| u?U|L?tc U @hi t@**) UL?i __?} @hM|h@h)
UL?i |) @tt4T|L?t |L ? @?_ s L*_ hi^hi @__?} |i @tt4T|L?t
2
: f Aiti @tt4T|L?t
|@| ?RR : fc sRR : fc sSS : fc @?_ sRR sSS sRS
4T*) |@| |ihi @hi _4?t?} hi|h?t |L _i|ihhi?Ui @?_ U@hic |@| u@*ti
UL?U|L? ULt|t hti 4Lhi |@? *?i@h*) | |i Ti?@*|)c @?_ L?igiU|t
@hi t|hL?}ih |@? UhLttigiU|t | ii? |iti i |h@ @tt4T|L?t L*_ ?L|
}@h@?|ii |i @*_|) Lu ?i^@*|) E2c MiU@ti |L} |i ht| |L |ih4t
L*_ |i? Mi TLt|ic |i *@t| |ih4 L*_ t|** Mi ?i}@|i Ai ht| |L
|ih4t L*_ Mi TLt|i MiU@ti |i 4@h}?@* _i|ihhi?Ui igiU| L*_ i@!i?
@t |i Ti?@*|) ?Uhi@ti_c @?_ |i 4@h}?@* ULt| Lu i@U u@*ti UL?U|L? L*_
MiUL4i }hi@|ih Ai *@t| |ih4 L*_ Mi ?i}@|i MiU@ti i? Uh4i ui**c
|ihi L*_ Mi *itt u@*ti UL?U|L?c U 4}| L|i} |i u@U| |@| |
@ }ih Ti?@*|) i@U ?t|@?Ui L*_ Mi 4Lhi ULt|*) t @ hit*|c |i ULt|
u?U|L? L*_ t|** u@* |L Mi UL?i c ii? |L} |t UL4TL?i?| u?U|L?t
vprrwk lw/ glvfrqwlqxlwlhv zrxog yhu| olnho| frqwlqxh wr h{lvw lq wkh sxqlvkphqw vfkhgxoh1
Wkh mxu| uhvsrqvh wr kljkhu shqdowlhv lv vwloo dqrwkhu frqvlghudwlrq +vhh Dqguhrql ^4<<4`,1
D vrphzkdw glhuhqw lvvxh lv krz wkh vhyhulw| ri kdup vkrxog eh uhodwhg wr wkh dprxqw ri
hqirufhphqw hruw> iru dqdo|vlv ri wklv/ vhh Vkdyhoo +4<<4, dqg Prrnkhumhh dqg Sqj +4<<5,1
:
Wkxv/ wkh dssurdfk xvhg lq Ehfnhu +4<9;, iru frpsdudwlyh vwdwlfv/ zklfk uholhg rq
vshfldo dvvxpswlrqv/ zrxog idlo khuh1
e
L*_ Mi i**Mi@i_ ?_ih |i @__|L?@* @tt4T|L?t AL }@h@?|ii @
UL?|?Lt LT|44 | L*_ Mi ?iUitt@h) |L @tt4i _hiU|*) |@| E2 t
|hic U @t ?L t|U@|L?
Ai ?i | tiU|L? Lu |i T@Tih ** UL?t|hU| @ t4T*i i @4T*i |L tL
M) UL?t|hU|L? |@| |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|) @?_ ULh| U@hi U@? Mi _tUL?|?Lt
? @h4 @?_ |L _ii*LT |i ?||L? Mi?_ |i L|UL4i
? , @4T*i | #tUL?|?Lt i?@*|) @?_ Lh| @hi
Ai uL**L?} i @4T*i ** tL ) |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|) @?_ ULh|
U@hi 4}| Mi _tUL?|?Lt ? |i Uh4i<t @h4 wi| |i tLU@* ULt| Lu u@*ti
UL?U|L? Mi
R2
E
s ERc S ' R2 n c
S
U t@|tit @** |i @tt4T|L?t 4@_i i@h*ihG |i ULt| Lu u@*ti UL?U|L?
t ?Uhi@t?} @| @? ?Uhi@t?} h@|i ? |i Ti?@*|)c | u@**t ? ULh| U@hic @?_ |
U@??L| Mi UL4T*i|i*) i*4?@|i_c ?L 4@||ih L 4U ULh| U@hi t ti_
Ai |L|@* tLU@* ULt| Lu Uh4ic t?} i^@|L?t E @?_ Ec t
#
$
R2
nS 7 ' ?ER n R n
S
2
Ee
Ai u** LT|43@|L? ThLM*i4 t |L 4?43i 7 | hitTiU| |L R @?_ Sc
Ti?@*|) @?_ ULh| U@hi W| ** Mi UL?i?i?| |L tL*i |t ? t|@}it ?
43?} Ee | hitTiU| |L S )i*_t |i ht| Lh_ih UL?_|L?
#
U 4T*it |@|
$
Y7
R2
' ?ER 2 n ' fc
YS
S
ED
SW ' RW ES
Ai LT|4@* Ti?@*|) _iTi?_t L? |i tTiUU u?U|L?@* uLh4 uLh |i
_i|ihhi?Ui u?U|L? ?ER wi| | Mi t@Ti_ @t ? 6}hi c U t _h@?
D
t?} |i uL**L?} u?U|L?G
?ER ' f n Hf*R
' f n Hf*R n ER S2
' f n Hf*R n ER S2 DER 22
' n 2*ER be
s
s
s
s
RS
S R 2
2 R 2f
2f R
E.
At _i|ihhi?Ui u?U|L? t@)t |@| tL4i Uh4i t _i|ihhi_ M) @ t4@** Ti?@*|)c
ih) *||*i 4Lhi t _i|ihhi_ M) @ 4L_ih@|i Ti?@*|)c @?_ @*4Lt| @** Uh4i
_t@TTi@ht i? |i Ti?@*|) t }
6WBN+, B,5 O,+,
,^@|L?t ED @?_ ESc t|** @TT*)c tL SW ' RW 5Mt|||?} |t ?|L |i
LMiU|i u?U|L? Ee }it @? LMiU|i u?U|L? @*hi@_) LT|43i_ uLh S @?_
?L t|@|i_ L?*) ? |ih4t Lu RGH
7ER ' ?ERE n R2 n 2R
EH
6}hi 2 tLt |i t@Ti Lu |i LMiU|i u?U|L? }i? |i _i|ihhi?Ui u?U
|L? uhL4 E.
6WBN+, 2 B,5 O,+,
Ai 7ER u?U|L? @t |L *LU@* 4?4@ 6Lh ih) *L @h4 E ' 2c |i
}*LM@* 4?44 t U*i@h*) @| @ *L Ti?@*|)c @?_ uLh ih) } @h4 E ' Df
| t U*i@h*) @| @ } Ti?@*|) 6Lh ' D @?_ ' Sc |i |L 4?4@ @hi
ih) U*Lti ? |ih tLU@* ULt| Wu ' Dc |i |L 4?4@ @hi @| E2fc 2cfbS
@?_ E2bfc 2c2 uLh ETi?@*|)c tLU@* ULt|c tL 2f t |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|)
Wu ' Sc |i |L 4?4@ @hi @| E2bc 2cS2 @?_ E2bc 2c2Dc tL 2b
;
D vxevwlwxwlrq ri wklv nlqg zrxog pdwkhpdwlfdoo| lqfruuhfw li wkh dqdo|vlv wkhq sur0
fhhghg wr wdnh d ghulydwlyh zlwk uhvshfw wr s/ exw khuh wkh plqlpd zloo eh irxqg e|
qxphulfdo phwkrgv1
S
n(p)
50
40
30
20
10
0
5
10
15
20
25
p
Figure 1: Crime as a Function of Expected Penalty
S(p)
8000
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
.
.
..
h=50
h=15
h=16
h=2
5
10
15
20
25
p
Figure 2: The Cost of Crime as a Function of
the Expected Penalty
t |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|) t4@** U@?}i ? |i @h4 ?_Uit @ 4T ? |i
LT|4@* Ti?@*|) uhL4 2f |L 2bc @?_ |i U@hi |L @L_ u@*ti UL?U|L?
@*tL 4Ttc t?Ui SW ' RW M) ES #itT|i |iti 4Ttc |i tLU@* ULt| Lu @
Uh4i t @ UL?|?Lt u?U|L? Lu |t @h4 Ai tLU@* ULt| ?Uhi@tit L?*)
uhL4 2cfbS |L 2c2D }L?} uhL4 ' D |L ' S Ai 4Lhi @h4u* Uh4i
@t 4U }ih u@*tiUL?U|L? @?_ ULh| ULt|tc M| t Lgti| @*4Lt| i @U|*)
M) @ _iU*?i ? |i @4L?| Lu Uh4i
T*@tM*i }i?ih@* Ti?L4i?L? *it Mi?_ |i i @4T*i 6Lh *L *ii*t
Lu @h4c @| 4@||iht 4Lt| t |L @i @ t4@** Ti?@*|) |@| _i|iht tL4i
Uh4i M| !iiTt |i ULt| Lu u@*ti UL?U|L?t *L W?Uhi@t?} |i Ti?@*|)
Mi)L?_ |@| *L *ii* @t *||*i @__|L?@* _i|ihhi?| igiU| Wu |i Uh4i<t
@h4 MiUL4it }hi@| i?L}c Liihc |i Ti?@*|) t _h@t|U@**) ?Uhi@ti_c
MiU@ti } i?L} Ti?@*|it hit*| ? @?L|ih *@h}i _hLT ? |i @4L?| Lu
Uh4i T|4@* ULh| U@hi t _tUL?|?Lt MiU@ti | t M@ti_ L? |i Ti?@*|)G
u |i Ti?@*|) t *Lc U@hi @t *||*i Mi?i| @?_ tL*_ @*tL Mi *Lc M| L?Ui
|i Ti?@*|) 4Ttc |i Mi?i| uhL4 ?Uhi@ti_ U@hi @*tL 4Tt Ai t)t|i4
t t4*|@?iLt M| hiUhtiG ?Uhi@ti_ @h4 _Lit ?L| ?Uhi@ti ULh| U@hi
_hiU|*)c M| | ?Uhi@tit |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|)c U ?Uhi@tit LT|4@* ULh|
U@hi @?_ uii_t M@U! |L |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|)
At t|Lh) U@? Mi M@ti_ L? i|ih Lu |L ?|ihTi|@|L?t Lu |i _i|ihhi?Ui
u?U|L? ? 6}hi
W? |i ht| ?|ihThi|@|L?c |ihi @*@)t i t| 4@h}?@* Lgi?_ihtc ?_u
uihi?| @ML| UL44||?} |i Uh4ic M| 4Lt| TL|i?|@* Lgi?_iht u@** ?|L L?i
Lu |L Uh4?@* }hLTtG U@t@* Uh4?@*t L @hi _i|ihhi_ M) @ hi*@|i*)
*L Ti?@*|)c @?_ tihLt Uh4?@*t L @hi _i|ihhi_ L?*) i? |i Ti?@*|)
MiUL4it ih) } `i? |i @h4 t t4@**c |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|) @?_ U@hi
@hi t4@** M| TLt|ic _i|ihh?} @ *@h}i ?4Mih Lu Lgi?tit |L| ?Uhh?}
4U ULt| uhL4 i@U u@*ti UL?U|L? Ai ?4Mih Lu Lgi?tit @?_ u@*ti UL?
U|L?t t }c M| t?Ui |i @h4 Tih Uh4i t t4@**c |iti @hi |L*ih@|i_
t |i @h4 ?Uhi@titc |i Ti?@*|) @?_ U@hi ?Uhi@ti t*}|*)c M| |ihi t
t|** ?L @||i4T| |L _i|ih |i tihLt Lgi?_ih | tL4i TL?|c Liihc |i
.
Uh4i @t MiUL4i @h4u* i?L} |@| | Lh| 4@!?} |i 4T |L ?Uhi@t
?} Ti?@*|it tL _h@t|U@**) @t |L _i|ih |i tihLt Lgi?_ih @*tL 5?Ui |i
Ti?@*|) ?Uhi@tit _h@t|U@**)c | t @*tL Lh| ?Uhi@t?} ULh| U@hi _h@t|U@**)
W? |i tiUL?_ ?|ihThi|@|L?c @ t?}*i ?__@* _iU_it L 4@?) Uh4it
|L UL44| Oi ** @*@)t UL44| 4Lhi Uh4it u |i Ti?@*|) _iU*?itc M| t
Uh4it }i?ih@**) u@** ?|L |L U@|i}LhitG Uh4it Lu LTTLh|?|)c U hi^hi
*||*i |L}|c @?_ T*@??i_ Uh4itc U hi^hi UL?t_ih@M*i igLh| t4@**
Ti?@*|) ** _i|ih |i T*@??i_ Uh4ic M| ?L| |i Uh4i Lu LTTLh|?|) Wu
|i Uh4i ?U|t *||*i @h4c |i? |i LT|4@* Ti?@*|) t ti| *L @?_ Uh4it
Lu LTTLh|?|) @hi |L*ih@|i_c M| Mi)L?_ tL4i |hitL*_c |i 4T t 4@_i
|L@h_t _i|ihh?} ML| |)Tit Lu Uh4i
e L?U*_?} +i4@h!t
hLTLh|L?@*|) @?_ LT|4@* _i|ihhi?Ui @hi ?UL4T@|M*i @4t Lu T?
t4i?| T|4@* _i|ihhi?Ui 4@) hi^hi |@| @ t*}|*) 4Lhi tihLt Uh4i
hiUiit @ 4U 4Lhi tiihi ti?|i?Uic u @ t3i@M*i ?Uhi@ti ? |i Ti?@*|)
L*_ @i *||*i @__|L?@* _i|ihhi?| igiU|c M| L*_ t|** ?Uhi@ti |i ULt|t
uhL4 u@*ti UL?U|L? t |i Uh4i MiUL4it 4Lhi @?_ 4Lhi @h4u*c | t
ii?|@**) Lh| ?Uhi@t?} |i Ti?@*|) tMt|@?|@**) uLh |i t@!i Lu |i @__
|L?@* _i|ihhi?Uic Liihc @?_ |ihi 4t| i t| tL4i T@h Lu @*4Lt| _i?|U@*
Uh4it |@| tT@?t |i Mhi@!TL?|
ALh| *@ t @*tL UL?Uih?i_ | ULLt?} Ti?@*|it |L _i|ih @h4u* Mi
@Lh t ?} EbHS @?_ 5@i** EbH. ?L|ic i Uitti 4TLt|L? Lu *@M*
|) ?L| L?*) Ti?@*3it |i ??LUi?|c M| _i|iht |i4 uhL4 tiu* Mi@Lh |@|
ULh|t 4}| UL?uti | hL?}_L?} ALh| *@ M@*@?Uit |i u@*ti*@M*|)
ULt|t Lu Ti?@*|it @}@?t| |i Mi?i| uhL4 _i|ihh?} |Lh|Lt Mi@Lh At
M@*@?U?} U@? hit*| ? LT|4@* _}i4i?|t i|ih M}}ih Lh t4@**ih |@?
|i @h4 ?U|i_ L*?t!) @?_ i Ebbc uLh i @4T*ic t}}it| |@| |i
Ti?@*|) tL*_ Mi }hi@|ihc M| tL tL*_ Mi |i Mh_i? Lu ThLLuc |L hi_Ui
|i ?4Mih Lu U@tit MhL}| @?_ |t |i |h@?t@U|L?t ULt| Ai ^it|L?
hi4@?t Lu i|ih |i _}i4i?| tL*_ ?Uhi@ti t4LL|*) | |i @h4
H
Ai Thiti?| 4L_i* @TT*it |L U* *@M*|) ?tLu@h @t _i|ihhi?Uic ?L|
UL4Ti?t@|L?c t |t @4 ALh| *@ tit U@t |h@?tuiht @t Ti?@*|it |L _i
|ih @h4u* Mi@Lhc M| } Ti?@*|it @hi ULt|*) MiU@ti i? hL?}*)
?U|i_ |i) _i|ih ??LUi?| Mi@Lh Ai 4L_i* tLt |@| |i LT|4@*
tUi_*i uLh *@M*|) ?ii_ ?L| Mi UL?|?Lt 6}hi U@? Mi hi*@Mi**i_ @t
|i hi*@|L?tT Mi|ii? *@M*|) @?_ @4L?| Lu @h4u* Mi@Lhc ihi @
t4@** @4L?| Lu @||i?|L? ** i*4?@|i @ *@h}i ?4Mih Lu @UU_i?|tc M|
uh|ih *@h}i hi_U|L?t hi^hi tMt|@?|@* U@?}it ? Mi@Lh t4@**
Ti?@*|) ** Thii?| 4@?) @UU_i?|tc M| |i Ti?@*|) 4t| MiUL4i 4U
}hi@|ih u |i ?4Mih Lu @UU_i?|t t @}@? |L Mi tMt|@?|@**) hi_Ui_ O}
*@M*|) uLh *Lih *ii*t Lu @h4 L*_ ?ii_*itt*) _i|ih ??LUi?| Mi@Lhc
M| @| tL4i TL?| |i @h4 MiUL4it }hi@| i?L} uLh _i|ihhi?Ui Lu @h4u*
Mi@Lh |L |@!i ThiUi_i?Uic @?_ @ 4T LUUht ? *@M*|)
`i|ih |i Lgi?ti Mi Uh4?@* Lh U*c @ _tUL?|?Lt 4T ? |i
LT|4@* T?t4i?| t ?L|c Lu ULhtic @ ?iUitt@h) UL?U*tL?c L?*) @ TLttM*i
L?ic U _iTi?_t L? |i _i|ihhi?| hi*@|L?tT Mi|ii? Uh4i @?_ Ti?@*|)
Ai i @4T*i tLi_ |@| tU @ 4T L*_ LUUh u |ihi t @ *@h}i }hLT Lu
TL|i?|@* Lgi?_iht L @hi _i|ihhi_ M) @ t4@** Ti?@*|) @?_ L|iht L **
?L| Mi _i|ihhi_ i UiT| M) tMt|@?|@**) }ih Ti?@*|it `i|ih |t t |hi
_iTi?_t L? |i T@h|U*@h |4i @?_ T*@Uic M| _}it tL*_ T@ti MiuLhi
t|h!?} _L? t|@||it t4T*) MiU@ti t4*@h Lgi?tit @i ih) _gihi?|
Ti?@*|it( @ 4T ? Ti?@*|it @| tL4i @h4 *ii* 4@) Mi @TThLTh@|ic ii?
|L} |i T@h|U*@h |hitL*_ *ii* 4@) tii4 @hM|h@h)
b
+,6,+,,5
?_hiL?c a@4itc bbc R+i@tL?@M*i #LM| @?_ |i T|4@* @}?|_i
Lu 6?itG 5L*_ |i i?@*|) 6| |i h4iq +# aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Utc
22G HDbD
iU!ihc B@h) EbSH Rh4i @?_ ?t4i?|G ? ,UL?L4U TThL@Uc
aLh?@* Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4)c .Sc @hU%Th* bSHc Sb2.
,h*Uc Wt@@U EbH2 RAi T|44 ,?uLhUi4i?| Lu w@t @?_ |i L?
UiT| Lu at|UiG Lt|i ?@*)ttc W?|ih?@|L?@* +ii Lu w@ @?_ ,UL
?L4Utc 2G 2.
6hi_4@?c #@_ EbH R+iiU|L?t L? T|4@* ?t4i?|c LhG 5L*_
|i +U @) O}ih 6?itq +iti@hU ? w@ @?_ ,UL?L4Utc i_ +U@h_
~ihMic G HD2fD
k@T*Lc wLt Ebbf@ R L|i L? |i Nti Lu L?4L?i|@h) 5@?U|L?tc
aLh?@* Lu M*U ,UL?L4Utc e2G 2eD2e.
k@T*Lc wLt EbbfM RT|4@* #i|ihhi?Uic N??uLh4i_ W?__@*tc
@?_ U^h?} W?uLh4@|L? @ML| `i|ih U|t @hi 5MiU| |L 5@?U|L?tc
aLh?@* Lu w@c ,UL?L4Utc @?_ h}@?3@|L?c 5Th?} bbfc SG b2H
k@T*Lc wLt Ebbe RAi V@*i Lu UUh@U) ? __U@|L?G ? ,UL
?L4U ?@*)ttc aLh?@* Lu wi}@* 5|_itc G f.ef2
LL!ihiic #*T @?_ W@? ?} Ebb2 RL?|Lh?} t@t W?it|}@
|L? ? ,?uLhUi4i?| Lu w@c 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +iic Ea?i bb2c H2G
DDSDSD
?}c W@? EbHS RT|4@* 5Mt_it @?_ #@4@}it ? |i hiti?Ui Lu
a_U@* ,hhLhc W?|ih?@|L?@* +ii Lu w@ @?_ ,UL?L4Utc a?i bHSc
SGffD
L*?t!)c |Ui** @?_ v i Ebbc R#iULT*?} w@M*|)G T|4@*
W?Ui?|it uLh @hi @?_ w|}@|L?c +@?_ aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Utc `?|ih
f
bbc 22G DS2D.f
L*?t!)c |Ui** @?_ 5|ii? 5@i** EbHec RAi T|4@* Nti Lu
6?it @?_ W4ThtL?4i?|c aLh?@* Lu M*U ,UL?L4Utc 2eG Hbbb
Lt?ihc +U@h_ Eb. R? ,UL?L4U TThL@U |L wi}@* hLUi_hi
@?_ a_U@* _4?t|h@|L?c aLh?@* Lu wi}@* 5|_itc 2G efeD
+@t4ti?c ,hU Ebbe R#@4@}i @h_t `i? Lh| ,hhLh t hi
_U|@M*ic Lh!?} T@Tihc W?_@?@ N?iht|) 5ULL* Lu t?ittc a?i bbe
+M?ui*_c #@?i* @?_ #@_ 5@TT?}|L? EbH. R,Ui?| @h_t @?_
5|@?_@h_t Lu hLLu ? a_U@* hLUii_?}tc +@?_ aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Utc
544ih bH.c HG fHD
5@i**c 5|ii? EbHD Rh4?@* w@ @?_ |i T|4@* Nti Lu L?4L?
i|@h) 5@?U|L?t @t @ #i|ihhi?|c L*4M@ w@ +iic U|LMih bHDc VL*
HDc 222S
5@i**c 5|ii? EbH. RAi T|4@* Nti Lu L?4L?i|@h) 5@?U|L?t @t
@ #i|ihhi?|c 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +iic 5iT|i4Mih bH.c ..G DHeDb2
5@i**c 5|ii? Ebb R5TiUU Vihtt Bi?ih@* ,?uLhUi4i?| Lu |i
w@c aLh?@* Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4)c U|LMih bbc bbG fHHfH
5|}*ihc BiLh}i Eb.f RAi T|44 ,?uLhUi4i?| Lu w@tc aLh?@*
Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4)c @)%a?i b.fc .HG D2SS
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz