Crawling a Country: Better Strategies
than Breadth-First for Web Page Ordering
Ricardo Baeza-Yates
Carlos Castillo
Center for Web Research
Universidad de Chile
Center for Web Research
Universidad de Chile
[email protected]
[email protected]
Mauricio Marin
Andrea Rodriguez
Center for Web Research
Universidad de Magallanes
Center for Web Research
Universidad de Concepción
[email protected]
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
!"#$%!&'!()
*+,$.-/%0!1%#2/34567,98'$7(:0
'
!4;/#.-/%0#<0='?>@A%BC/! >D.
E2C
#21%0!F0?-/G5IH JK
3! (L9#2%M.N%0!%
/M;0.#MO7P7(LK*Q,;R%#NS /AST
,7%0#UO(*Q,V(WJ,AX0.0%0#X.
%R4SK?%BKN%#$UYK.'<O'<A%B
0!5
*+<10<#0F()Z10[*Q,N!\X,10#N*+,!0
%#]U212^"-/$MO10%]0^!05_H X
*+,`63EX#2E2%R-/%0!FX1a
%6\%EO-\EX
%01`0V60`'
!O%#.#+#b10%2T
#2?0F7%#2%05\*QF2AFL0!V#%!
'
!`0XNMc%9O%&,.#2Ted'O
%#'
!?,.#%
Lf:!%0gN.1%5
Categories and Subject Descriptors
hV5 i25 jlk [email protected])qAnxw;uq0rtyz{tnL|~}z9urv)z92t€ae‚„ƒBE'
%#Fƒ9()@-\
$…‡†ˆ$‰)Š‹‰ŒŽAˆ ˆ$‘ ’0“G”e‹ŽL•hO5 i25 –<k mn4o—qrsbt0uv)qAn
w[uqr
t0yz„tn4|˜}z2urvaz22t€—‚+™K%%šD%2(WM%›ƒ29D…
œ ˆž@Ÿˆ NŸˆ$‰.”eˆ$Ÿ
General Terms
¡1%B.RfL()M%0R0¢:UA$%9
%
Keywords
*+,$.-/.R[ƒ20.#210%0!XA$EBR*+,0!7A%0
1.
INTRODUCTION
* ,$.-//-gM,9E#2
-/%3#2%0!`%0/?,% (
+
*+,!R913SEX().-/%!X%0g9IF 7ASE
(\!5N<ASEb(!F7%0#U2.#b%0#1.#()
*+,M.pR2S\.%N,A %0SE2P.#(W*Q,M
P.
%p5
š—(=`-/ ,F`#.-/%03#^SEXd%0S7?(
0!RA0%"%BE^-/%0!N#$<K!B9#;R[,A.10X?0F%#
I00!V-/J,AM#2.-/%03#.#[5^FV%0F`.()
£_£_£¤2¥¥¦
Copyright is held by the author/owner(s).
, May 10–14, 2005, Chiba, Japan.
.
.=*+,"-/Rp-/$1010SEX%F,0O#.-/%#
p(L<*Q,;RM%0SE#10 X0K().-/%!.%0‚
§¨<© z9u$ªVqr«Q¬Ltn4|4ªvW|4u­®tn4|®|Lv)¯.«_¯°4t±z^q0o\u.­4z^²³z9¬
±r
t9ª€)z9rtr
zQn4z2v)u.­pz2rvWnp´=n4v)uz&n4q0r^o@r
z9z ¨ O12%BKP
(`µKB!¶ Y%0#U‡(V0%¸·¹»º¼½!5¾š@(F0
.3!"!"P",A1"º
–+g2¿ RI0%_0Y-/%0!]'
10#,AO10%0#"jN%+#2K()V`(W1=-/\k Àj6(6-
%SEM%a#2\%D-Jg'5IµK%N0J%0\[!\
<(
.ÁB1ÁB1@EBR30$?JF
%`(W\#.-/%#2%!\8'10'I0
'/A%B/%5
Â;¨‡Ã tyz2¯^±­ptn4yz_q2Az2rYuvGsbzAÄKt0nL|lt®²³z9¬Å±r
t9ª€)z9rBƯ
±q°;Ç]qo/u.­4z"²³z9¬_¬6z2±qAsbz2¯`ÈpÉ4vW±«;€)Ç_q¬:¯qA€az2uz ¨/Ê .-/%0!
0V*Q,"O,0R[XU9%B.RA-0%0!N0XgBE"%+
.
:%0!BJk ·
e5:0I';-6J%3pU2'.#7O10S%1SE
-Q
+%!_^R b!B^g3#SË[%B
Y.&12`E35šD%+NN-EBR=!`
$.-/.#]
#SË[%9VR6%0#Q0M.]%0!%0¶ X%®O%0`
%0<(=0F*Q,;5 ƒ2F0!K.%b#20A<<%0!
,BEY0VV0E
%9#"10$V7.
$+10SR
%Y0F7-\E"KV'
-JOV%Y0FgBE-$O!%0
%!!5
šD%0.M(\'
V-J
S.#b,9E"`A.#+(/!B
%0#F!/#'%R,01L%V*Q,V-/%0!K-J.%VT—-/
*Q,7!LS(9-I610%%V,A1;0S41%Bp'15=ƒ22R
KVA%B -JO%"%0M%!7%B%21V#.-/%03#%0!N%SE
%0$-Ì!M%#Q-^0.3N'#.-/%03#%0!"ÍBN.'
3S(aE%!Í&(K0!`-0.3S.#9E®%p5_H?2R
0/\0<%0SE-EVd%#N%0-„Î ÏKÐ;5
Ñ;¨ Ò ­4zXtsbqAÉLn[u/qo:vWn4o—qrsbtu.v)qAnqAnYu.­4zX²lz2¬vW¯\´=nLvauzAÄ
¬:É4uXu.­4znpÉLs"¬=z9rqo?°Lt0yz2¯`v)¯vWnp´=nLvauz ¨
š@(:-JV#d0%0^>—*Q,Y0!CMK3E90%0!V
K0 %^Î ÏKÐ=R
0%O0J%21X,AL(*+,X0!I=%d%S<k Ó
eR9#1J7#9E%0
!R%#`0%NF-/%!X2B\%03%#54*»
-K#
7^S710%BF(/#9E2%O!O#.-/%03#.#()
%BEN!3%^3/%Y%Y`Mg3 <*Q,Nd%5
™K14%VLK#23O/$.#1%! AEF()6#.-/%2T
3#%0!N!?()Z07*+,^-/0Y!1
%B?
.RA3%YS(
-I#\%L#.-/%03#FB(90=g9%0.-/%70!R-JI'9#.-/%#
0'">D1,0CY%05H 70%91X,A7(/!V!.-/R
S7-/6,A`%0$.%0!SE+A%B<^#2
-/%3#0+>@,AC
%Md0'.R?NS-/<,AYA,Y]#2
-/%3#‡ÔG5
0<%7%0SE^KN%0PF-/%!7-/"A$
`1O(\0!ÁB1SDEBRp,0127^#10K0O.
' (:-/%0!25
7M%%B,01%0/(L?0A <0K()
-/%!‚
4<?,A'J([1Ig9%0.-/.#!RB066?'62T
0%03/0%M(p$.-/%0!V'!10,00#`
(G
.5
š@"2Ab%- '!-/S³,A$A(WM%0
%+0-JT—g9%0.-/%&,2.#9Ted0'O%0#+
\f:!T
%gM%05
š@JA\'
!\-/01K'.[%()M%
%0#10$O-/%0!bB5&¿IE >D'.Cb-J
.%X!,0f:!%gO%()M
%`.10.#X(a³
210/-/%!(L7K*+,p5
7%0U9/$%^12%/91\-gN%0K10,98'?(
*+,+$.-/X%0#*Q,Q-/%!Y$.#1%!5ƒ2%&i^#2T
$,AFXA%0X`%0#"X-/%0!(a-Jg
-JX1.#Y%"1<$UA$%95<ƒ2%jN%B9#1?0V!
#%!'
!R;-/0b
V%Y'.#Y%bƒ2%+–B
5 LST
%0SEBR4ƒ2
% N%B 1<%10%O%#"#S$%0<()
()112<-gA5
2.
PREVIOUS WORK
* ,›-/Q%B 0(F.
$›%0!%R %#
+
#2/%M0S/-/%0!!S/<g3/\,010%\T
$5˜*»%„!Yb01,00.#[R b^()% %
A%BX$gQ( #X0O%BO0V() 2T
#210%!V?-JgA5I0K<X%0%/,A1>@.%T
!%0`0%0!CR[-/0b23%B<M.8'7.
$b%0!%<()
10,%!X0/%0g9%0!`%#$.-/%0!M!S5
2.1 Web crawler architectures
ƒ97#2%0?(=-/
G%$2%0!.L#2 %T
10#‚^ÏK¿\ƒ2¢ k iÀ
eR\0N*Q, Ê .-/k j
eR\0*+#_*»#2
*+,]*Q k j2ºeR\0-/N(<šD%B%MH/$+kSº
–.—R
7A%0L"!%9<ƒf=hKš {k jjeR;%^.SE3%Y(
µKB! -/$<kSº.i
—R9 Ê ,*+,Yk À —R¡$..R0<9#9T
1<$.-/`k i·eR4ƒ1XkSºjeR;V*+, 10%B%%%2T
4-/Ok i2ºeR0FfLSE¿J 04-/$Xk –À.eRAX-/
9#210N%B.#+%&*Q,ÏKH Ê ¢ k –·eRJ#2%BP#
Î ,0-/FkSº.¼
—R20?-//(p0
9H<ƒ®.%0!%Xk –9º$—R
7*»šDÏ ¢‡-/`k L-/0^-\ 10.#() 0?.%#
<%\-/Ok i–
e5
š@%¸##S%»&0ASd-/%!›
$1'#
,A
3R=0N
!%0-/M0S$1`%QST
1R[%1#%!
=-/F0S$1X,BE Ê 0"k À9º
%#`<!%0$0$.-/J0S$1?#$,A#X,BE Ê 0gB,0
kSº.Ó
e
5 L%SEBR0<-/?..#Y1%#$\0V
µ KÎ 01,0
%F%1#2FÐ4,%+k jeR0*+,¿Jk ÀÓ.:%0#h<K‚ <!Yk À
e5
¿I#V0S$1610RL'1#F,A127*Q,-/%!
0.3J(WB10.#X%X0 k ÀBºR9–À
eR9#2EO%#V%B(
$.-/<()<*+,YSX#%0'
`k –j2Rp–i9R6ºR[j3¼
—Rp'T
%!V%B%BJ,A0%#X()
WM>D0##%C<-, ?k –¼
—R#2%0!
S<k ÀieR2g30%0!70\(a0%\([0?.
$N%0!%0?BE
!k i¼2RÀ¼9RÀ–9R0–
eR9(WB10.#N-/%!k i3ÓBRpº·2R2jBÀBRÀ·2R2j3i
p%#
*+,$3?BA$%&kSº
ÀBRj·e5
2.2 Web crawling ordering
Ê "ˆ$“\‘ ?k ÀÀ.LM#2K0 d0'?'1#9EM%^A/(WK$.-/ST
%!b0.#210%0!25_0SN#0
$`-\M]º·¼2R ¼¼¼T—0!-/
(ax !#"%$'&#"#(_#2M%;RJ%]-/0‡"-/%!Q`T
1%¸-\"#%-/S #SË[%B'!5 0+#%!
X'.#Q-^,2.#9Ted0'.R6,0g2%0gBT—10%B`%#]
T
;f:!%gAR2-/$ U20%0#N$\%N5J™K%0
(A\%10%I-=6S([0\-/6-\%9=F#.-/%#
!=-/S0!`f:!$%0gO.SE`#1%! 0\$.-/%0!F2BR
0%X0\0Af:!%0gO'!E6\,A.R3()
-J.#M,9E
,#22Ted0'6%0#X,$g9%0gBT—1%B.5LhK.-J3.R31I
(WI8D10'?X%!V#M%p5
<.8'g„%#»*»%]k jB–
VA().#„%l10F-/V%
i3À·`%!R010%0!O,.#2Ted'/#$%!5I0$EN()1%#
V,2.#9Ted0'7$.-/6.1V0!7-/b0!+f:!T
%gOSE`%`0\$.-/GR9,1=0EX##X%J2:70
S/`/'!5
H ,S,A1:ˆ$“I‘ k i;#!%0.#M7-/%0!V'!E,.#%
%!S0 ..#b™<f6š Ê —™K%2T@%0Vf:!VšDA%0 Ê `T
012% $5]šD%‡™<f6š Ê R=._!^!3%®%_%0S/10 (
>D0C\-/F4#2',1.#<.ÁB10SE7%0!60!4SpA%B
5Jš@? ?f:!%g012%;R0,1?S /(G'
%0#X6#%L8'1'I%`%0/';5:H %™<f6š Ê TD#93%X$.-/J#.-/%2T
3#d'0"0!^%¸b$.-/%0!]()%B$^-/S„!0$
10%B\(F>@.C5/¢:U2A%B-F.
.#^%Yº.¼¼2R ¼¼¼T
!F'E2%B0`!+-/S&A.-$T@- #',01%Q(\%2T
%0g956hK.-.RK-/%0`
%-/S^0/'
T
!?%0?U2A%B%0K[*Q,;5
¿Ja#2Fˆ$“F‘ QkSºº$\10#+X10
%&%&1,0V(/0`*+,
(Kj3¼%®!`()x0)
$+*&#2M%®%0#¸º¼¼%
!6(){/*+,¿J?-/eRB'%!F,.#2Ted'J!3%'
%0# #2%0!%0#%b%0%B<'
!EB570O-/%%0%0!
'!E-\,#22Ted0'.R91!F%#¾#%!X
A().#12%0!E-G5?™K%0F2,0Z//F*+,T
¿7-/p\,0.#NV0<-/?10#MO!3/0K#095
0$EX<0.-#V
=f:!%gF.1a
%06.
#O%O
T
:1,0!0 (IF*+,Y!3O,#Y02.UM
%Y(60
$1pf:!%g105
00AM0%BX1SN2%B.#]%lkS,º ?Í
-/0b%1#O%1
%(O$.-/%0!'!F%
0 Ê 0.%*+,2Í`,BEM0%0!F-/#/%!7(:'!
%‡"!N#0
N%#&,BE&%01#2%0!"N%_%E2R
A%0!?'!L-/0O1I'.9%()M
%pR;-
\
-7%#G¶ .<%0<10%;5
3. METHODOLOGY
*QJ#.-/%0##O10,L(006*Q,V!0/GJ10%2T
EM#2M%6O.3#,0%!V -/.#N#0
61%0!O7*+,
-/.R0%#`%MO10##2Ë[$%B'!5IšD%0JT
%;RA-`#2d%70VA%O$V%#^0V-/%!^
T
0S125
3.1 Page importance metric: Pagerank
™K1/!3L?#2.-/%03#›>DA%9C0!?d'.5I*+710
0 f:!%g`<F$?(pA%0/(;*Q,!5
0 f:!%g!S0{-\J%B9#210.#`,BE`f:!`ˆ$“6‘\k j3Ó
eR
%0#b0F13#2d%%+'%!^%+0O$<
>'^0!`-/+0!&f:!%0gX0!`(W%0.#b,9EM%9E
!/-/S^0!^f:!%g9C5
4V.1 Kf:!%0gAR2.M!K%0/*Q,M9#2T
.#" 'F%`'E'^RA%0#^.YBE2A%g<X%0ST
%&,A@-%+D-JY'5^0Mf:!%g+10(?^!M
02,0,0SDE+(?,A%0!Y%&^!%&!-/0%QV'E2'
.$S`'%0E_'5‡HÌ!B9#®00X()M10%0#T
'%0#%0!^OF^0%0g%+F( ›>@%#2 1()CR6
A%X-/079S60!J
=%#2^R%0#O10A%9<.$
!R0B:%F1!%0!?%gK10%S(WSEF
4%#»()„0
%0g97%0F!5X0`f:!$%0g(0!X<O(a%
(:K0K%#2Ì1()?A%#2/?.$^0!5
h .-3$.R01;*+,N!0/%010#KM%BEM!\-/S%0
1T—%0g9R-/$O67>@%0g7%0g9C<L0E71X1a
I%0g
,17%3<#',012XS<0<!5XH R;-V-1#b%0
g3 !JO10X1/%0g9%0!2R9,BE%0%0!`A(4S
YQM!5 0M0^.%R/'M(7^`T
%B%I(Lf:!%0g#0#Q>—%#2¸8'10C<() E
0!FX40! %N0<%pR%1#2%!`SS(D5
š@%+7(\0`%0# 12(WV9#2GRL-M.%Q'
-/%˜0B%!Å0›%U9®'pRN0›%0# 1(W$‡S
0B+!%# ()Ô^$%»-/®,T
,0SDE R47$B7N(W.-¾%0g^() 0O1%9<!
-/SY2,,0SDE+º 5\0K/079#410#(W<.10T
%!7f:!%gV%O$RB%#OS==#,A.#X,BE706(W.-/%0!
Á910%;‚
%& (' 'º,
'º ) *"+ (' )
"! #$
-/,x70O%21X,AK(\0!F%0O%;R6%0#"
0 [email protected],A@-%¼95ºK%0#¼95 À W-JK10#N¼95º
#– $R
,0.#_%_0S.?2#2%05‡f:!%0g]Mb!,eR'
17(6ÁB1SDEN(6O*Q,!R03ENc%B?%\(
012%QR:XSX%0SE+F",AM.1a
.#&%
%0#U2%0!X7%#N/$K1.#NA.#2E?ÁB1EM5
F
<f:!%0gY.%,AVM1SEYM%10#Y%#
%(GJ?/010%0#6J%J([*+,!I.#
ASd.SE()J/,98'3?(p#29%0!70/
3%0g9%0!
()10%%k iie5Jf:!$%0g,BEMSS(L%0%\,A 10.#NI0K%0SE
ÁB10SDEFJ%F.9*Q,VpRB%#FI9#Sd.
%0L
/!S0{.%`,A/M#J<.#210\$=([1%
k – e5H?R0f:!$%0gN!B\<0!ÁB1SDEM0!?
S//,0#N.-\
#/#$ 0!Fk e5Ih .-3$.R0f:!%0gN/
!B9#.1 (L0!7ÁB1SDEBR3,A0%F8'10'1%9%!V
%91X,A(7%T—%0g9R/N1.#®%›!,ST@b›%0!%0R
%#&%]1X.R\%0#Q%®!%0GRJSX-`2.!
91M%^8'10#!%B GXa,0Y!Nc'' X(W
!%0Sd.%B (a%(:0K!5
3.2 Crawling simulator
H]#X#.-/%#V#$:(WI/*Q,V-/6X10'4,AEV
'$%056I'LA%9pS()T—A#F'%V()
*+,Y-/< 0 0EX1' %K3#^F*+,YS
EN9SVk j3¼
—5
*+,Q-/`A-/S]^0!]#!(/
^R
A%0%!<910%#9.#4=010%0#=(h<\\f+%0%%6O10ST
%010SEBR ®Q*+,»-/Y10#»A%BSE»
33#¸
*+,›SY-/S›.ÁB10'5³4].3#‡
3#%!]*+,›SR
*+,‡$.-/1010SE›#2
-/%3#»
N'M%Y!Y()Ô
!3%Q*Q,QS
`^!%QR=%0#b-\S^%&A9#
(/,A$D-%+D-JO^MS5"0MU
-S%0!].-~1010SE¸+(W$-~%#25 H?%0#K9ST
#2%0`()~`-/V(/g9%0.-/%+Q%0!%0F%Q
!d7
-/7E2%0!F%9$R[(a À¼N%#<
i.ÍBj7%91R%0#V-J\10-/lº.– %#6J<#2(G10S6%X,A
O10%^%#10;*Q,-/5
p 0SEK-/S706'%0RLp10'ME</M%2T
%YXÁB1010<(L*Q,NSRA%#(W *Q,NSF`ÁB101K(
0!?`#.-/%03#;5I0/K#20#% L!12º5
<-/%0!X1a
//?%%0012?V*+,!0
%B%0!V%0g9,A@-%N!•2Î ÏKÐ;JA%B%0!FO%%NU9T
'%B\0!R9F0!J-/S\ %0%010#.#%0
!p5^*+.3,3.#V0$EQ
,A12Nº.–0 (\
%0g9:(W10%0#;5=\-/%!VO10I1:0=%(WM%`
1/v)yAÉ4r
z §32,4 °=z9r
t0u.v)qn qo t&±r
t9ª€)z9r ¨NÒ ­4z9r
zbvW¯t]ÈpÉ4z2É4z
o—qr&z9t±­{²³z9¬¾¯.v)uz›ª`v)u.­ tuQsbq¯u+qAn4z›±qAnLn4z2±uv)qAn uq
z9t±­›t±uv)Az"²³z9¬¸¯.v)uz65'¯.v)uz2¯  Ä874Ä6tnL|:9<; ¨ w;q[sbz"²³z9¬
¯.v)uz2¯Xtr
z6=Bv)|L€)z
>LÄ:¬=z±tÉL¯z^u­4z9Ç®­pt2Azur
tnL¯o—z9r
z|_°Lt0y0z¯
uq[qrz2±z2n[u.€)Ç:5'¯.vauz2¯ § Ä?;ÄptnL|A@3;Kqr`¬=z2±tÉ4¯zu.­4z9Ç&­pt2Az
zB4­ptÉL¯uz2|_t€W€qo/u.­pzvar°Ltyz2¯Xuq&|pqªn4€)qt|C5 Ñ ; ¨
,01a#X0^2SDEÁB101K-/S^%09#2\%9%!`S5
H`.$_X1a
%]'pR60N0.#2100B`0M2T
'K*Q,SX() 0XÁ9110O(I*Q,SF%0#%0#K
S¶ /%2(WM%XO9#210 0\-/pX17#2
-/%3#9T
%0!Y0!O() 0*Q,bS50M!MPRI#',012%
(6A# %#a
%0K.%"M,AV2
2#2.#^K%^%01/
0FX1.RS010!"() 07U2A%B\-/S^0FX1T
<#2,A.#^%0/A?-<-$V%0SE%B'.#^%0
-/%0!#2.RA%#N%0/%K4-/%0!`5
0O-/Fg3<N'7(\
7'D10O%0%%
<*Q,XSR2%0#XX1a
GA,0 :,%#2-/#9`12%
10%!`07%910O,A\(612%B\%'(WRAS A.# %0#0
,%#9-/a#9](KX1.#]%gA5 KN
.R\X0.-/%‡%
L!12NºRE`<,A1%#,BEF%21X,A?(J3F*Q,YSR[
-/%0!A$(WM%0V.%b#9"#9M.E^(60VK
BMG5J¿J%0!.
(W1L,A1/?.#2\%07(:07,A'
01'RA?.-/%^.5
4. PAGE ORDERING STRATEGIES
07'?A%B/,0Z(6O!F#$%!'!E
7FSFO10'<-Jg"-/+I%()M
%pR4,A.1`0
>D0CO!0N%SEMg2%.-/%N,BE` %#(;0 -/%!5
hK.-J3.R(0-/\A%0!7 -/eR6R3S(A-J/\-/ST
%0!NA%+(J0V*Q,Y-/b-F#2E-/.#bN(W$-g9<V(W- %B0<!2Rp-JX.3V0'6%2(WM%
.a,05/ /DE20.SEN07.7(W<X.
$Y%!%0V%#
0N0'/%(WM%_.%_,AN10#]#S$X0N-/
.-\
#\!\-/N#V!^f:!%0gM%K'/-/G5
0K$.#1K?#2%0K10%0!%'M
%(:!FÁB1S@EB5
0N'M%»%»],AYX,%.#_-/S»0!"%0!
%()M%pR,A.1<%K.?O-//!B-%B
,0F#.-/%#+0#10X.-#F,A+0!T@ÁB1SDEb%#
(G'T—$0%0!%0!!Fk e5
*Q/%0#$J?@EAI(p'
!!3#2%0!F0.-›O10
%()M%Q0Eb.%&1‚`%^U9^%()M%pR=0'
%()M%pR\%#_\0%2(WM%;5‡HÌ%0#x#2%0!
.%+,AX%0#2.#+N,%X(WV0%;5Xš@%07.R
0bf:!%g»^U2A.#›_!.- 0.U2MSE»%0SE
-/S0K%21X,A(:0! -/.#[5
4.1 Strategies with no extra information
Vr
z2t0|4u.­D ´:r¯u7ÎK%#2\'
!EBR9K-/?9S
0!<%",.#2Ted'K#%0!257š@ 'K,9E9S%0!L
0!I(;`>D.#C<*+,XSR9%#O*+,X0!?.
<g32%1$NF-\E
\%0-¸0!/##.#M!XK%0#;5
I0/?'
!E'.#`,BE <.8'g%0#X*»%0$<k jB–.—R
-/$b%0SFU2A%B<.-.#b.21`!T@ÁB1@E
0!?d'.5
Vt±«p€)vWnL« ±qAÉLn[u/0='!EV-/6d'L00!:-/
<0!0'?%910O,A\(L%g2/A%B%0!OXS.R0O07%0$U2!
],A-/.#„N0'%g3.#‡() b0!^S.#2E
#2.-/%03#.#[560I'
!EO-\#,A.#X,BE Ê Nˆ$“=‘ k ÀÀ.—5
Vt0u.±­ °4t0yz9r
tnL«+0K'
!E.1a
<%Y'M%
(Of:!$%0gAR 10%0!Q"!%»&(G.R 3$
E !
#2.-/%03#.#[570V%0$U2
0!KN#.-/%0#F0V!
-/SF0I0!':'M#Of:!%0gA5L*Q610
# lº.¼¼ $¼¼¼
0!R-/$%12\.7!3/,A1?i¼VXj¼Xf:!%0gM.ST
10%^#21%0!Q$.-/G5¾0'!E‡-\^_'1#9T
.#,BE Ê 0&ˆ$“ ‘ k ÀÀ
eR:%#"7-<()10%0#N,A`,AK%
,0g9%g9T—10%B.5/hK.-J3.R;¿J#/ˆ$“?‘ Vkºº=
-J.#^
02
U2M%04(f:!%0g71%!/B!0L%F,AIE
%U.5
à t0r
u.v)t0
€ °Ltyz9r
tnL«0g3O“— 2ž†2 Bˆ$‰Ž RA,012J%M,AT
@-%f:!%gVT—.10%0R9 AEV0!$%0gV6'T
!%0.#b%0- 0!F10%0!X1~(f:!%g"(
0!OA%9%!^SO#9a#2.#b,BE"0%91X,A7(\12T—%g2F(
70!5
4`Ã m 0^'
!E›,#¸% ™<f6š Ê k ieR<-/¸.%
,A%»-!B.#_,$g9%0gBT—1%9`'!EB5¸H ?!
'
F-/0O10%B7(`>@.C5N¢=3EY`N!
O-/#;R6S+>D0C"X`%0!^0M0!XSX%0g9F5
FSDE(6%^10%-/.#!F\0710Ì(:0Y>@.C
S ?3.#(aZ07!?A%B%0!`S.5\ '
!E
N
N]f:!%0gAR/,012MN%+%0# %g2%0#_
10
%"/%/S3KÍ?/X1$M(G'.5
6t0r
yz9r ¯.v)uz2¯ '´Lr¯u^0N!3(/O'!E&V.3a#
0.2%!BYM%BEA%#2%0!^0!O%&%9E"*+,QSRL".3a#
0.2%!"F0%0#+%SE&^M6%910X,A$F(/!N*+,QS
0VME".#+^0`#210X&>'#2^%0O
3$#2C
15:I-/:1p=%21X,A[(210%T—-/.#7!;(W10%#
V(G
?JK@E(W/0$g9%0!VF*Q,MSR%0#N'
-/
XS<-/SbX!F%910O,AK(A%0#%0!N!5V*QO%T
9#210#&X'!E]%¸kº  %0#+-\`(W1%#Q",A,A$
0%^,2.#9Ted0'.5
4.2 Strategies with historical information
X'
!K10OVf:!$%0gY(2910 -/=
%‡'M
%‡(K0f:!%g_%_0`-/GR?%0#_'
M%
!V-/]0!]f:!%0g+%+Ma'X$.-/G5"O
%0SE%0.U2M%",A10Xf:!%gY.%"%!‚ Ê %#_HK#^kS,º  A`00.3!3()
'M
%0!f:!%gY(W12V%B0K0#bV,A1OÓ· 0N5
H?R:'1#2E",B
E ?10Nˆ$“ ‘4k #j IA<0">@`%0g
'11?(;0/*Q,J!%0Sd%BSE #2E2%/0%`
%B%B%M0?*Q,;56¢6E`-gAR0,A12 À–0 %0-¸%0g9\
$..#2C5
*+<U20FX%910X,A$(L'! `#2.[-/S0K!
()1%#M%M0 1%9J-/A-/0$M-$<%0(W10%#M%N 2T
91/%0‚
vW¯uqrvW±t0
€ °Ltyz9r
tnL« q[s+n4vW¯.±3v)z2n[u - 0!»l'T
!%0.#^Xf:!$%0gMg%(aZ%F0/g9%0.-/\0 (W10
!p5
vW¯uqrvW±t0
€ °Ltyz9r
tnL« r
tnL|pq[s K-{0!X
!%0#
Nf:!$%0g"10V#b10%S(WSE"
<%0#~%0!M0
10/,%.#%2910/-/G5
^vW¯uqrvW±t€ °Lt0y0z2r
t0nL« 3z9rq K- 0! !%0.#
f:!%g®PR/G5 5R/#®0!NY-/.#®d'.R0%_%0$! 7$.-/.#[5
^vW¯uqrvW±t€ °Lt0y0z2r
t0nL« '°Lt0r
z2n;u - 0!Q
‡!%0.#
0 f:!%g(;0?
%BJ0! W0?!K%-/00?%g
-\J(W10%0# =#9a#2.#`,BEO/%21X,A6(p1T—%0g9I(p/%9
!5
š@\g3SEM
\9#$%N*+,%!%0\1<0'
%()M%V?IU9%B.R
,01p?J,A'L(1Lg2%.-/#!
%0=0$U06%³%06A()M%\.3J,A%
01,00.#NX(G
.5
4.3 Strategy with all the information
4 s+nLvW¯.±v)z2n;u 2 '!E.%ÁB10EY%„>DC-/
g9%0.-/p=$=*+,7!0F%#<4.10#FI1
f:!%g(:.$!5I¢6EM?0‹ŒXŽ0”)Ÿ”eˆ$Ž0“;'!E
%0.#JVP<X#.-/%#[RS/g9J0 <%#N#.-/%2T
3#J?0!?-/S0?0!'J%0g9%0!F%SI()%B$.5 70F'!E+F,A1%#Y0XX'%0O70
RB%#F.%O%EO#2
-/%3#X !S(AS=0=S.#2EO#.-/%2T
3#.#^O!7/A%9\`S.5
5. EXPERIMENTS
šD%`%M-K#$,A/0?U2A%BI#%?-/SM0
-/MX1a
M%#Q0N#2%0!'!M#$,A#_%
0K91?%p5
5.1 Datasets: .cl and .gr
*Q:-Jg3.#<-/SFD-?#$4
LA%0#F/!410%T
#$\0$ Ê 0 %0#)$
! —µ g IT—3p#2M%5:*Q
#.-/%#2.#+!V10%!0X*›šDÏ ¢„-/k I%+,.#2T
d0'9#RB%1#%!O,AN'
7%0#N#9E2%?!5:*»
(W.-/%0!&%0g9R6-^'0A.#_#2‡–^(WN#2E2%0!
%0#º.–F(W?'<!ÍX-<17%N012'<X#\'
(\M#2E2%X!V,.#+%Qg9%0.-/%+d%0`$U2%0%
%0#.0%0!F(W/VÁ91'%MMgO%M Î ÏKÐ=5*+KV`T
S.#V-/=<#2
-/%3#X='IÀ–9R ¼¼¼<!:()³.$
*Q,S5
*Q\M#\D-J7/-/I%.$M#2M%;R9=-?#
,A()R`
#^,0%!`0F#0
O`07$.-/%0!#.5I*Q
##N?%YH?;%#^¡^.EM() Ê 0RA%#%^¡^.E%0#Yƒ2`T
,A7()Xµ 5M01MEY(0O$0$'O(0
$%pR=<-IF`#!0X%2(WM
%&,A1
0 D-X1%9?
V2%B.#N%L,X–B5º5
Ò t¬:€)z §32 wpÉ:sQsbtr
Ç_q0oK±­4t0r
t0±uz9rvW¯u.vW±3¯ ¨
µ Ê 0
fL01a
%Qk – 
º¼25 M¡%
º.–95 ÀM¡%
µ 7f„k ––

º.ii`Î7!ƒ F,0%;5
#`Î7"ƒ V,%p5
fLT—.0S
µ 7f„k ––

º.Ó9R #Ó`Î7!ƒ
º.¼9R i3ÓiÎ<!ƒ
hK1M%#0%9<k –Ó

À$j #&%
j'i #(%
*+,$3/%B.#
À 9R ¼¼¼
TDi9ºR ¼¼¼ –¼2R ¼¼¼TD–9ºR ¼¼¼
f:!/-/S^h<\\f‡
™ i25 jTDi95 ¡G5
ÀB5 jTDÀ95 ·M¡
¿Jb#FO0,O%YK(IO%91X,A (
*Q,!R0,012\0F
<-/a#2V#SË[%/%\(=!!T
BEBR0%!10!R;#!0R00'EBRA$5 <\ˆ$“/‘ 7k À 
'1#2.#O10,T—:(0*+,pR%0#V()10%0#O
:0J*+,
!0b7(aT—V%+3=%F%0#+
73IR
%0#]0`S()T—
@E‡A3RNS#`()N
1
0.9
0.8
Fraction of Pagerank
Cumulative Pagerank
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
Chile
Greece
0
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
Omniscient
Larger-sites-first
OPIC
Breadth-first
Batch-pagerank
Partial-pagerank
Backlink-count
0.3
0.2
0.1
1
0
Fraction of documents
0
1/v)yÉ4r
z Â2 OÉ:s"ÉL€)t0uv)Az à t0y0z2r
t0nL«¸vWn³u.­4z $QtnL| $
|pq[sbtv)nIÄ/¯.­4q2ªvWn4y®t€GsqA¯uzB;t±u.€aÇ»u.­4z&¯tsbzQ|Lv)¯urv)¬:É
uv)qAn pu.­4z2¯zM±3É4r
Az2¯Kr
z9°Lr
z2¯zn[u.¯Kt0nQÉ4°L°=z9rF¬=qAÉLnL|QqAnbu.­4z
±É:sÉ4€)t0u.vaAz à t0yz9r
tn4«]q0o t0n;Ç_±r
t9ª€WvWnpy]¯ur
t0uz9yÇ ¨
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
Fraction of pages
"!#
0.8
0.9
1
0.9
1
0.9
1
0.9
1
1
0.9
%91X,AK(/#2Ë[$%B7
5 KV%Q
!10,2T—
(0O-/0`*+, e%#+%BE"%0%2T—.#+1,0F(0O*Q,
KS-\E2K,a.#^,BE7'!EY10#-/LS.5?42T—3
#2M%F1(W16,A.1`0EY2%BF!F0%0!
%+10S1%9$U2.•6-N%0#O
OE&
1(W1;0%N!7*+,S/,A10K!/%^V*+,S7
`0!%0105N™K,991EBR4#SË[%9KT—3I#2M%
#2SË[6%O\AR3()6%0'%0R.#VK02%0
(/~!R:,17-/0 !V0A.
XV%0M
%^70'!Z(6%T@#!7K1T@#!R07
34#'T
,1%^'[(W.-/7XA.-$T@-{k ije5
Fraction of Pagerank
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
Omniscient
Larger-sites-first
OPIC
Breadth-first
Batch-pagerank
Partial-pagerank
Backlink-count
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
Fraction of pages
$""%"&' (!#
0.8
1
0.9
0.8
Fraction of Pagerank
™ 12`A%0NN`f:!$%0gA5]91RI()10T
K
%!`#SË[%9'!R0-K.1a
.#N7f:!%gM1K(
3EM!<%.N*+,N!^%#M10.#0<10V.ST
10K<31%(4<f:!%0g0 X10
.#-/
!BF,BEB5V*+O60FS01!+f:!$%0g"7%070O,A'
1R< %X0?.p$5
*+I1.#KI.1p(A(WM%‚;10O1036f:!T
%0gAR0
!Ff:!$%0g%0# -7%0#0G¶ .p5
VÉ:sÉ4€)t0u.vaAz à t0yz9r
tnL« 2 -J›0.#{‡10 (^
f:!%0g„(M#2.-/%03#.#„!b#SË[%9^A%BY(`
$.-/%0!F2B560\'
!6-/0/,0\K.`ST
1<OM0F!$<:1Nº ¼N(G'F
X%0##
^'`c%BM%5»H '!E]-/0$®%0#
0!?X-/p-/49#210<`#!%04%07%?!p5
X%Q10AF,A1%#%Q
-{-60F.%+,AM#%R
%#›SN!3%›,BE®"#',01%»(Vf:!%gAR -/›
.-/%^% L!1VÀB5
10S:(W=0\#2Ë[$%B='!J
\0.-/%`% L!12
i9•9%X06O10%X-?/1%! lºR3%0,AJIKR
,A.1`-M%V%B'.#%0`O()X#.-/%0#%!
<(W1[*Q,pR2,012:8'10'?%<-/%!#2.5
™K,991EY‹ŒXŽ0”)Ÿ”eˆ$Ž0“=<0O,A'7A()M%Rp,012
SNM%‡^%^B&!#2E_,A.10Y,BE]0^'N'!
(0X-/JSFA(WF`%#^5 `
F
'
!7%A(W ,A %"‹ŒXŽ0”)Ÿ”eˆ$Ž0“:'
!E
M0Y%0#®(7^-/GR?,A.1K'
!",A1%#
V7'%0<,A12<,A%!NAF-/SY*Q,YSR
%#b()R=#2.-/%03#%0!"=0&>@!B9#2CY!FB^.SE
.#XY.#210%!^BbO10+0M'( .a,0*+,&S
%#.#1JKA()M%0 %M0 '/'!/(p0?-/e5
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
Omniscient
Larger-sites-first
OPIC
Breadth-first
Batch-pagerank
Partial-pagerank
Backlink-count
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
Fraction of pages
$"(%"*)"+
1
0.9
0.8
Fraction of Pagerank
5.2 Performance metrics
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
Omniscient
Larger-sites-first
OPIC
Breadth-first
Batch-pagerank
Partial-pagerank
Backlink-count
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
Fraction of pages
1/v)yAÉ4r
z ÑE2 Vq[sb°LtrvW¯qAnbq0o=±3É:s"ÉL€)t0uv)Az à t0yz9r
tnL«4¯/r
z urv)z9Az2|Y°Lt0yz2¯\ªv)u­u.­pzX|Lv-,Jz9r
z2n;u?¯ur
t0uz2yv)z2¯ÄzB4±€WÉL|LvWnpy
u.­4z­Lv)¯uqrvW±t0€?¯urtuz9yAv)z2¯ ¨
1
0.9
Fraction of Pagerank
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
OPIC
Omniscient
Historical-Pagerank-Omniscient
Historical-Pagerank-Parent
Historical-Pagerank-Random
Historical-Pagerank-Zero
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
Fraction of pages
0.8
0.9
1
1/v)yÉ4r
z 7 2 Fq[sb°Ltrv)¯qAn+qo6±3É:s"ÉL€)tu.v)Az à t0yz9r
tnL«"ÉL¯.v)n4y
u­4z&­LvW¯uqrvW±t€7¯urtuz9yAv)z2¯tytvWn4¯uu.­4z
\tn4|
¯ur
t0uz9yAv)z2¯ÄVo—qr&t„±r
t2ª`€Xqou.­4
z Mrz9z2«³²³z9¬¾vWn
w[z2°4uzs"¬=z9r  74ÄFÉ4¯.vWn4y à tyz9rt0nL«lv)[email protected])qn{o—r
q[s
t2Ç Â 7 ¨
™K%?0%#[R[3 ‘ ”WŽ ž@‹’9Ž0“p%0#`†2‰$“G”G‘Sž†2 Bˆ$‰Ž 7
`-'`'!E&#%0!^Y1X1a
3f:!%gAR6%#
A$(W -`%_Y%#2 -/e5Q0EQ,AQ%0#&
!?'10gM%!/?
FBSE^2MGR%#M0%N(G4
#2
3??!5
\‰ˆ3 “ 2ž 6‰Ÿ“FQY,A''
!N(W0^d'
À¼T@i¼0˜(=!R,012?(a 0/S?,A\ $c%B.5
'
!F“— 9ž†2 Bˆ$‰'Ž RL‘‰ Bˆ$‰$ž—Ÿ”W“@ˆ$Ÿž 6‰Ÿ“L%!
# "$#%
0.3F,A<A$(WM%070%^0F0K'!R;-/S%
#%B!<.-\#2O‘‰ Bˆ$‰$ž—Ÿ”W“@ˆ$Ÿž 6‰Ÿ“:-/%7#S.#
3T
!OK0!;570X'!7.%"$3X,A12<S(J(I
f:!%0g10`(0SO#M%0<#.-/%03#%0!Y%0SEb10%#
À¼T@i¼0˜(:0K!5
*+7'.#^0 9”WŸ“—‹‰”e‘Sž†2 Bˆ$‰Ž X'!7%^0Xµ g
*+,Y!0Y(ƒ9X,A.R10%0!Of:!%0g^10
.#Y%
¡^EY()7!10#%0!M0V-/LÍ-J`
X10%!f:!%0g^
<
j%B0\#[5I*+<-V,FX1070Ff:!%0g(:0<#
$.-/ —¡^E I() %E––0 (:<!R\0K0$ j3–0 (
0!?-J7%0$- 0!R?-J7%0?-/#%"¡^EB5
L!1^j0.-/10SX()N%21X,AO( -\E2(<#.%!
-/S0?,A?j3–0Å(p!J%!F-/S16(WJ0/
*+,›!0»,1N10%!Q0&
"$#%„'!E›(W
%p5
M10SX.- F0¡^E&f:!%gQ10ON%0
#2%BAX<-/4(Iƒ22X,A.5
'
"$#%F,0#A()M%<
J ,A!%0%0%!O(p
$.-/GRA,1?S?2
3??7%0gN%(WM%Y?!3
0.#
\0K$.-/;!B?,BEB5= 9”)Ÿ“—‹‰$”e‘Sž†2 Bˆ$‰'Ž že‰Ž 3‹Œ 'T
!EF:/!B9#OA$(WM%0R#20SI(20=(G$:p06*Q,
!b73E^#2E2%k j eRL%#^%b%+.3!O<<#Sc`T
10SOY'M
`0Nf:!%g+1%!Y0'.%()M%
kSº e5IH›A,0K$U%
%MJ
I?#%!O(p0!,BE
f:!%0g$0%!FX.-/SE&%#%b
10F0X!
-/S"0!"%0g9%0!M.3VF',0OAS%b%^V%0gBT
%!X%N<!\-/S^.-„%0g9%0!2R2-/$U20,0S?O
!
,0@EB5H RI`f:!%g+X,.#Q.-\
#V#&!
k —RJ––0 (?!VXS.#2E&$U'.#Q%_¡^E]1%BO()
ÓÀ0˜(40KLf:!%0gN%"ƒ22X,A$.5
Ò 0t ¬L€)z Â2 Vq[s°Lt0rvW¯qAn˜q0ou.­pz ¯.±­4z2|LÉL€)vWn4y ¯ur
t0uz2yv)z2¯Ä
±qAn4¯.vW|4z9rvWn4yt9Az9r
t0yzV±3ÉLsÉL€at0u.v)Az à tyz9rt0nL«^|LÉprv)n4yu.­pz
±r
t9ª€Kt0nL)
| (z2nL|4t0€W€@Ư .]qoVu.­4z&°Ltyz&qr|4z9rvWn4y¸t0y0tvWnL¯u
u.­4z"q°4u.vGsbt0€qr|4z9rv)n4y ¨
ƒ9
!E
H 9!56f:!%0g+*-,
.
¿g9%gBT@10%B
¼95 –.
¼ *³¼25 ¼9º
¼95 ¼2º
–Ó
f:ST—!%0g
¼95 –/
À *³¼25 ¼9º
¼95 ¼3Ài ¿I.#2Ted'
¼95 0
j *³¼25 ¼j
¼95º
À i
¿JT—!%0g
¼95 .
i *³¼25 ¼i
¼95,º #9º
™<f=š Ê
¼95 3/
Ó *³¼25 ¼i
¼95 ÀÀÀ Ð4!T—S'Ted0'
¼95 3/
Ó *³¼25 ¼9º
¼95 À
j ·
hK'.5 T—T—P
¼25 ·
¼95 i3–Ói
hK'.5 T@2Te%#2
¼25 Ó¼
¼95 #i · hK'.5 T@2T—%9
¼25 Ó¼
¼95 i3–À¼
hK'.5 T—T—%e5
¼25 ÓÓ
¼95 i·–
™K%%B
¼95 Ó0
j *³¼25 ¼j
¼95 3–¼j
1 Az2r
tyz OÉ:s"ÉL€)tu.v)Az à tyz9rt0nL« 2 00Y.3$!
$F0X%9S-/G5NH <-J`.3X%0MP.#`10O1T
3Of:!%gYK(a%b(J#2B10%9R0SKKÁ91%9
^0M
.Y10%0#F013F
-/%&% L!12Ni25"N'T
.J'
!O,A$7%Q™<f6š Ê R;'SE,A.1(
™<f=š Ê ¶ OABVA(WM%MF0X,A!%0%%0!^(\0`-/G5
0F1 K2%B.#%L,XÀBR[%^-/0$^-JO0.37.12T
.#X?
!?([0\'!\60(W1J%
G%0\60 B”WŸ“—‹‰$”G‘Sž†2 Bˆ$‰'Ž '
!I-/'.#X%M
%0! J(p%0R2VS10J
K%0.3$! ST
10 $5L*Q/.%N/060/'!J-/SM0'EXM!%0SE
3 e
X'`i0 23"4#%‡%0#›‘‰ Bˆ$‰$ž—Ÿ”W“@ˆ$Ÿž 6‰Ÿ“ G..9%0!
12/0‹ŒOŽ0”WŸ$”—ˆ$Ž“;%0 $5
(z2nL|4t0€W€@Ư Ò tÉ 2 0FX$`()V0`%_,A$T
D-J%FD-J %g3.#7'R-/0O,0.SEV.14J%910O,A
(0-/%93%0:%70I@-?'\k i e56J- a#2%B.9'
.3 . ¾ºRA-/VD-SEY10%
.#Y'<0.3 ..l¼
%0#.#+'O0.3 . 7º5M*QX.1a
.#bFB$c`T
%BX()M–¼¼¼
T—!0(/0N!#%!b%&.$
'!EBR=!3%'O``0!V-/%Q0!F-JM#2.#
,BE®f:!$%0gA5 0^10SNY0.-/%›%»4,0ÀB5 š@%_
._‘‰ Bˆ$‰$ž—Ÿ”W“@ˆ$Ÿž 6‰Ÿ“FM0Y,A'N(70Y'!M-/12
0'EBR[%0# B”WŸ“—‹‰$”G‘Sž†2 Bˆ$‰'Ž že‰ŽA 3‹ŒZ0-/ W-/S1
g9%0!X%10%B/0`‹ŒXŽ”WŸ$”—ˆ$Ž0“p% $5
*Q?
.#FF.12?'M
.#`.
$%!(W\#S(aT
(W$%BX0!MA%BR:()X%'%R=.1%0!^.- M%9E
!O#.-/%0#<X%
E^M! 0FQº¼ 0 (6!5
hK.-J3.R0=g2%0#O(.12\=3$EO%0S3<M2
ST
%0R31$V:.9%!K?%0!!T@ÁB1@E7!\#2.-/%03#.#
,BEM0<%0#(:0<-/G5
5.3 Validation
*QA$(W#bD-J"10J$.-/O10%0!^*»š@ÏK¢ k \%+@-
%01236-Jg9L%70 $<#M%pR10%0!-/‰ˆ3 “ 2ž 6‰Ÿ“%#
54(‰ Bˆ$‰žeŸ”W“@ˆ$Ÿž =‰$Ÿ“G5\*+?%M $.-//%NF%!Kš@%BAf Ê (
i25 ¼ 3µKhKP/-/Sº
µK,X([Ï H<¡ 10%0#6Ð;%212U[R%`,00=([1O
À¼¼2R ¼¼¼^!R;10%!10Y ˜º.¼¼¼O10S%1<%0@-g
%0%0%0RJ-/ - –"%#,A$D-%‡M0
7*+,^SR[%#^%0%0!M - {º
–X() -/S"
%bº¼¼`!5
šD%"0O.(\%Q$1:*+,b$.-/GRL-JX%B'.#b%
0,0RBIS6:-I7#2.-/%03#X!6%X0
Cumulative Fraction
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
PR Breadth-first
PR Larger-sites-first
Docs. Breadth-first
Docs. Larger-sites-first
0
1
2
3
Day of crawling
4
1/v)yÉ4r
z ? 2 VÉ:sÉ4€)t0u.vaAz à t0yz9r
tn4« 5 à } ;t0nL|³±3É:s"ÉL€)t
uv)AzOo—r
t±uv)qAn"qoL|4q;±3ÉLsbz2n;u.¯ 5Nq;±3¯ ¨ ;qo4t0n^t±u.Épt€[±r
t9ª€
q0ou.­4
z |4q[sbt0vWnÌÉL¯.vWn4yÅuªVqůur
t0uz9yAvaz¯ 2
\tnL
| ¨
!9L#$LS(0E<.%0%L,AJ#.-/%0##F(W'.5L*+I.10#
f:!$%0g‡(OK0!%›0"%¸-/0%›
$.-/%0!<-=0.#V%0#F%O1#V
-_O10V(0
:f:!%0g- 3.#Y#21%0!`,0p5/710S
F0.-/%% L!12V–95
¿IF-/%!/'!:6c%B4%<$;(#.-/%03#2T
%!F/10,?!J.SEBRB,1 ‘‰ Bˆ$‰$ž—Ÿ”W“@ˆ$Ÿž 6‰Ÿ“4I(W'%
,A»#.-/%#2%!]#B1%BM%0#›#.-/%0#%!]f:!$%0gA5
'!E&>D.3CV3AM0*Q,S6(WJ0?#0#2
%#%#0/(:0<-/G5
6.
º.¼¼%]!FÍB3E+!%9%0R=%0%0/#2M%R
%0#`1,0I(;0\*Q,;5:šD%M7!T—.<$%!F(p,0ST
%0K(I!R;g3%0!NN."(I*+,Y!<%"M%"`T
E]`A,R\%#&g3%0!b.]( *Q,]S!B
,AF3EU2A%035\šD%V.R[10%0!'.:%()M
T
%F!1a#2? $.-/A!9I,A F!B9#S%
?O.3#
#.-/%#2%!!/%%0#Ì#$.5
™K%0?M%%!XA%2,0 \.-»X 0 c%0E(=-/50 0?,A%#%<(W 71T
%04
3$0.#(6#2SË[%B\(WB1.#-/%0!'
!Ok jieR
,0120"#2
-/%3#2%0!]9#1N,A%‡U20SE®()12.5
07UR[<K%0<%010!"#d0%0ON.1O(I,9E9
#.-/%#2.#»A%0#»%#¸¡,(V,%0#2-/#2;R/(W
'%0#0
#P.#®f Ê %d0!1
% —µKh PY%0#_Ï H<¡ $5:*+^
%0.#MV'%#0
#P.#M\(4S/%#M7d0U2.#'%0#0#.R
-/0^%0/%E.-/ X0<-/?%0K7MT
0%0R,012?`-/S^U$EM<7%0%9@EB5
Acknowledgments
*Q"$g9%
-/.#2!Y0Y10A(70¡%0%1 ƒ2%BSd
šD%Sa
3K10!^µ %9\fI¼9ºT@¼3À T &(6¡#0%;5:*QK0%0g
¢:()0?¢=(a0#2\(aÌÎK%[5L(:*&0%0!%N(W?0K%ST
p.#\()/0Vµ g#2M%;5
7. REFERENCES
CONCLUSIONS
¡ ':(206'!L'.#<-J,0I #.-/%0#FAT
%B<!<d'.5FH 0.-/%%_kSºº$—Rp3%b%0# '
!E
%&A() -%+0`*+,pRL%b0%M0O%0#
-gY%"0F*Q,<,.#Y.-\#2<!<-/S0!f:!T
%0gMk #i —5=h .-3$.R0$\/#2Ë[$%0:%O0.-®ÁB10$g9SEF0!T
ÁB10SDE0!\?(W1%##2A%#2%0!F%0?#2%0!V(p!5
9”WŸ“—‹‰”e‘Sž†2 Bˆ$‰Ž „(GSE˜("'!®-J E
!B9#;R`%#„%³.](M%0›'.`%2(WM
%Å.,0R
,A)
"$#%›%#›‘(‰ Bˆ$‰žeŸ”W“@ˆ$Ÿž =‰$Ÿ“KN1O%#%
%#]0SMA()M%^M
.
5 /‰ˆ3 “ 2ž =‰$Ÿ“KN,#
A$(WM%0\
.#O-/SX\'!•p“— 2ž†2 Bˆ$‰Ž Á91SN]#2&+(W1<f:!%g‡012%›3?
#21%0!V$.-/GR[-/0" 1
%SEYE^U2A%3R
%#<A()M%7/%0?,A$\%0?'!5
\
=0F‘‰ Bˆ$‰$žeŸ”)“@ˆ$Ÿ$ž 6‰Ÿ“['!E=$A#2T
%B!6
3=0 "$#%M'!EB%5 LS'.R9S=.ÁB10S=J`T
1
%R%0#M#2B/%0\Á91S7g3%!`X10%B/(
-J!B.#^%T—%0g9`!%^!F0
"$#%#B57a
6%BI-/%-/0%0gV(p#',012.#`-/\J%0F`T
O10%%V,AD-J%F01$L4.ÁB10S.#7 $U%0!I0
#V#12%!<0?-/%!X2B56910 ‘‰ Bˆ$‰$ž—Ÿ”W“@ˆ$Ÿž 6‰Ÿ“40
,A$J,SDE`Mg9%0!<SI/10S,/()Ja
!?. #'T
,1.#›-/5¾šD%»Q.<%0!2R '
!E»1a#
%1#O%?N.3#" !R;1$K$$g9%0!
()O%0.
T@#10!F".3#+!2%!^BYX10"%0g9%0!
SX0^
Sd/BX-/S‡#9E2%M!`
% A<S?!71%B.5
™K12/10S V710$(W10;(W<-/K%^07# (\º¼T
!#"%$&"(')"%*,+.-/--0+ 12"%$,"'3)"(*4+ "%12576,8(9(9:8:+
8;!<>=0? @%@(A0B 57+&C:'2'3*,? @(@--/-0+ C:'DB 57+ "(15%@6,8(9(9%E+GF0HJILK2"MN'O-QP%12R(+
S;UT,+&V>$.B 'R$,"%W.XN6Y+&HJ12RD.P76P%Z.DF[+,\"($,RZ.P7+V>D.P%*7'B ]:R"%Z7^OX B ZR_*.P%5(R
B `a*,"%1b'P%Z.)R0)"%`a*.W7'3P'B "%Z,+.cdZLefghiijkmln(opg2qsrNt&iarNu#iwv qwrNt
kNl,rbiwflx%rmkdglxv/hglqifiwlhiaglzy{gfvmj|y}kdji~yi(w6&*P(5%RK/8%€(9;78(‚(97+
V#\YƒHJ12RK2Kw6&8(9%9%S+
EUT,+&V>B X X R12R'+7IP(12$B Z,+
C:''*,? @%@X P%12$.B Z,+ K2"%W.1)RMN"(15(R(+ Z.R'w@B Z.DR„^…RZ757+ C:'`aXN6%89%9%E+,F_HJI
K"Mm'd-QP%12R(+
†;!V+&V>12P%K2W46&‡.+,\QC"64<_+4F0P(1)B P(^OY}"%X B Z.P76V_+4HˆP%R*,)3‰%R(6.P(ZD
T,+&#P(5%C.P](P(Z4+,T7RP%12)wC.B Z.5s'CR0Š{R$4+,‹[ŒŽfxl&o;xh;rmkbgloUgl
 l,rbiwflirpŽGiwhtlGgvNg3n%‘~’ŽQ“  Ž,”;6ˆ:•b;–3? 8;:E:S6&V>W.5%W.Kb'089%97(+
—;!_+&˜QP%R™P(^NšJP'3RK/P%Z.D\#+G\QP%Kb'B X X "+&˜P(X P%Z.)B Z.5s]:"(X W.`aR(6›WP(X B 'dœUP%Z.D
M…12RK2C.ZRK2KB Z-QR$})12P-#X B Z5+&cdZžg2qwrŒ/gŸp ¡&rNkml.nUž‘%orbiwŸ!oa¢
£ iwowk¤n(l4¥{xlx;n7iŸ}iwl4r#xlj¦‹# v kdhx%rmkdgl&ow64*P(5%RK#†%—%†7†(§%86
T.P(Z:'3B P%5%"6,\C.B X R(6&89%9:8:+4cd¨TUHJ1RK2K/V>`aKb'3R12D.P%`U+
§;!_+˜QP%R™P^…šJP'RK/P(ZD\>+,\QP%Kb'B X X "+&\12P-#X B Z5p'C.R0B Z7©,Z.B 'R>ŠLR$,?ˆ©&]:R
X R]:RX KP%12RRZ"(W5(C4+cOZLefghiiwjkNl.n%opg2qsrNt&iarNtkmfj|ygfª(o3t&g «gl
y{i!¬>fx to’;ys‹y¦”;64]:"(X W.`aR[S(8(E%Sp"(M#­iwh;rm¡fi®sg%rbiwoskml
Œ#gŸs ¡,rdif[žhwkbiwlhwi6*.P%5(RK_†(—;.—%§:64/"%`aR(6&cO'P%X œ%6&¨_)'"($,R1#89%9(E7+
T.*.12B Z5(R1w+
€;!_+&˜QP%R™P(^NšJP'3RK/P%Z.D}˜#+4/B $,RB 12"^O¯>R'"+G{g(jiwfl  lq;gfwŸx%rmkdgl
° irNfkdiw±7xv +V#\Y²HJ1RK2K0@pV#DD.B K2"%Z7^…Š{RK2X Rœ%6,;‚%‚%‚:+
‚;!_+&˜QP%R™P(^NšJP'3RKw6&³Q+,T7P%B Z:'2^…‡:RP%Z,6P%Z.D\#+,\P(K2'B X X "7+&ŠLR$UKb'312W.)'W12R(6
D.œ7Z.P%`aB )KP%Z.D}*.P%5(R›W.P%X B 'dœ%+cdZLefghiijkmln(opg2qž4rNfwkNl.n
eJfghiwowowkml.n~xlGj  l(qgfŸ}x%rNkdgl ° i;rmfkdi±xv/’…ž4e 3°0´ ”6&]:"%X W`aR8(E%§%—
"(M#­iwh;rm¡fi_®sg%rdio[kNlµŒ#gŸs ¡,rdif[žhwkbiwlhwi6*.P%5(RK_%;§s~;S%8:6
IB K$&"%Z,6H¶"%1b'W.5%P%Xm6489%9%8+4T.*.12B Z5(R1w+
;9!Hˆ+˜"(X D.BN6&˜>+4\Q"DRZ."('2'BN6&Y+,T.P(Z:'B ZBm6P%Z.DT,+.·>B 5%Z.P7+&¸>$.B¤\Q1P-/X R1w?
PaK)P(X P%$.X R_MNWX X œUD.B Kb'12B $W7'RD!Š{R$)12P-/X R1w+žGg2qwrNu#xfi;¥Qefxh;rmkdhi
xlj ´¶¹ iwfkdilGhi6&SE•…€%–3? §:%w7§%8(—648(9(9%E7+
%!Hˆ+˜"(X D.BN6,Y+4T7P%Z:'B Z.BN6P(ZDT&+·0B 5(ZP+,A0"pœ%"%W.1/-Q"(1Kb'0'"a`aP%‰(R'C.R
$,RKb'?H¶P(12P%D.";„7B )P%XGRº4R)'K/B Z}*P(5%R12P%Z.‰!B Z)12R`aRZ:'P%X
)"%`a*.W.'P('B "(ZKw+.cOZLefghiiwjkNl.n%opg2qsrNt&iarNtkmfj|ygfª(o3t&g «gl»yi(
¬>fx toU’;ys‹y¦”;64]%"%X W.`aRS%8(E%Sa"(M#­iwh;rm¡fi_®sg%rdio[kNlµŒ#gŸs ¡,rdif
žhwkbiwlhwi6&*.P%5%RK0—(€;;€(96,/"%`aR(6&cO'P%X œ%6&¨_)'"($,R1#89%9(E7+4T.*.12B Z5(R1w+
8;U¨s+&˜Q12P%Z.D`aP(Z46‡7+4\QC."76,<+,F_P(12)B P(^OY}"%X B ZP6P%Z.D}¯+,T.C.B ]P%‰W.`aP%1w+
\12P-#X R12^NMN12B RZD.X œ¦-QR$}K2R1b]:R12Kw+&cdZLefg(hiwijkmln(osg2qarmt&iygfªowt&g gl|e/if…q;gfwŸxlGhi¦xlj!‹>fhwtk…rbihrN¡.fiag2q~yipžGif±iwfoU’de&‹[yž”6
T.P(Z:'3P¦\QX P(1P6,\P(X B MN"%12Z.B P76&¸0T7V6&‡:W.ZR8(9(9%9+
S;UT,+&˜Q12B Z}P%Z.D}I¶+&H¶P(5%R(+&=/C.RP%Z.P('"%`œ"MPaX P(15(R^OK2)P(X R
C:œ7*,R1b'3R„'W.P%X&Š{R$K2RP(1)3C}RZ.5%B Z.R(+¶Œ#gŸs ¡&rbiwfs®sirNu#gfªo!xlGj
 ž £ ®¼ž‘%orbiwŸ!o36GS9•d§%–3? 9:§;.%;§6,V>*12B Xˆ;‚%‚(€+
;E!_+&A[+&˜W.12‰%R(+,T7P%X 'B )W.Kw?J5(WB D.RD)12P-/X B Z.5pM…"(1#*,R12K2"%Z.P%X4D.B 5(B 'P%X
X B $.1P(12B RKw+cdZLefg(hiwijkmln(oag2qsrmt&i#½JfworQ‹[Œ!¾ 3´´Q´ ¢3ŒJžU¿;gkml4r
hgl(qiwfiwlhwiagl £ kmn(k…rbxv­kdfxfkdiwow6&*.P%5%RK#€%€7€%‚:64/"%P(Z"(‰%R(6
·0B 125%B Z.B P6‡:WZ.R8(9(97%+
;†UY+&˜QW12Z.R1+&\Q12P-#X B Z5a'"-QP%12DK#R'3R12Z.B 'dœ¦^Q$.WB X DB Z.5sP(ZP%12)wC.B ]%R"M
'CR_-Q"%12X DU-#B D.R_-QR$4+>yi(}ŽGihwtl&kw¡Giwow6&87•…†%–36,Y}P;œ~‚(‚%§+
;—U\#+G\QP%Kb'B X X "6,Y+4Y}P(12B Z46V_+4/"D
1 5(WR™(6.P(ZD_+&˜QP%R™P(^NšJP'3RKw+
T7)wC.RDW.X B Z.5sP(X 5%"(1B '3C.`aKQM…"(1/Š{R$)12P-#X B Z5+&cdZL­x%rNkml‹>Ÿ}ifwkbhwxl
yi(UŒ#gl(qiwfilGhi!’yi({ijkdx¾,­G‹[¢y ´ ”6&*.P%5(RK_;9;;§6
#B $,R12P%"aHJ12R'"76˜Q12P%™B XN6,¨0)'"%$,R189%9%E+4c µ\T}HJ12RK2K+
;§UT&+4\QC.P%‰12P%$.P%1b'BN+ˆ}kNlkmln}rNt&iy{i+,Y}"(15(P%
Z _P(W.MN`aP%Z.Z
HJW.$X B KC.R12Kw6&8(9%9%S+
;€UT&+4\QC.P%‰12P%$.P%1b'BN6,Y+](P(Z}D.RZ˜QR12576&P%Z.D}˜#+4A0"(`U+&³&")W.KRD
)12P-#X B Z5?QPaZ.R- P%*.*12"(P%)wCU'3"p'"(*B )^…K2*,R)B ©&)>-QR$}12RK"(W12)R
D.B K2)";]%R1bœ%+Œ#gŸs ¡,rdif[®si;rmu#gfª(o36,S•d(;—%–3? ;—%8%S;—(E%96¶;‚%‚%‚:+
;‚!‡.+,\QC"¦P%Z.D}0+,V#DP(`aK+&HˆP%5%R›W.P%X B 'Oœ&?JcdZKRP(12)wC}"MP%ZWZ$.B P%K2RD
Š{R$!12P(Z‰B Z.57+=ˆR)3CZ.B )P(X&12R*,"%1b'67¸>\IGVz\Q"%`a*.W.'R1QT7)B RZ)R(68(9(9%E+
89(!‡.+,\QC"¦P%Z.D}<+,F0P%12)B P^dY}"(X B Z.P7+&Tœ7Z)3C12"(ZB ™B Z5[PaDP'3P($P(K2R'"
B `a*.12";]%R0M…12RK2C.ZRK2Kw+cdZLefg(hwiijkmln(opg2q‹[Œ  l4rbiwflGx%rNkdglxv
Œ#glq;iwfilGhi¦gl|{xlx;n7iwŸiwl4r#g2q £ x%rbx{’Ož  ¬0L“ £ ”6,*.P%5%RK
%;§;.8%€:64A0P(X X P(K6&=R„7P%Kw6&¸0T7V6,Y}P;œ8(9(9%9+
8:!‡.+,\QC"¦P%Z.D}<+,F0P%12)B P^dY}"(X B Z.P7+HˆP%12P%X X RX4)1P-/X R12Kw+,cOZLefghiiwjkNl.n%o
g2q[rNt&iaiwvNiw±il,rNtkml,rbiwflx%rmkbglGxvhglqifiwlhipgl ygfvNj ykdjiy{iw6
*.P%5%RK>8E.S%†:64<#"%Z."%X W.X W,6.<>P-QP%B Bm6,¸>T.V6&Y}Pœ8(9(9:8+V/\Y HJ12RK2Kw+
8(8!‡.+,\QC"64<+,F0P%12
) P^dY}"(X B Z.P76P(ZD}I¶+&H¶P(5%R(
+ !)B RZ:'/)1P-/X B Z.5
'C12"(W5(C}¸>#I{"%12D.R1B Z5+cdZLefg(hiwijkmln(oag2qsrmt&ipo;i±il,rNt
hglq;iwfilGhiagl»ygfvNj|ykdji{yi
+ JX K2R]7B R1/T.)B RZ)R(6V>*12B X¶;‚%‚%€:+
8(S!‡.+,\QC"64¯+,T7CB ](P(‰W`aP(1w6P%Z.D<+,F0P%12)B P^dY}"(X B Z.P7+&³¶B Z.D.B Z5
12R*X B )P('RD¦-QR$})"%X X R)'3B "%Z.K+7cdZ~‹sŒQ ž  ¬_L“ £ 6,*P(5%RK#S%†%†7S(—%—6
‚(‚%‚:+
8E(!¯+,\Q1P(Kb-QRX XN6,³Q+,\12B `a`aB ZKw6A[+&<>P-#‰B Z564P(ZDUV+,Y}"(º4P'+
H¶R1bMN"%12`aP(Z)R0P(ZD})"(Kb'#'12P%D.R"(º4K/B Z-QR$}K2RP%12)3C4+&cdZLefghiijkmln(o
g2q[rNt&
i :rmt‹>¡.ormfxvmxowkdxl £ x%rdxxoi¦Œ#glqifiwlhiw6*P(5%RK#—:.—%‚:6
A0W.ZRD.B Z,6.¯>R
- ,RP%X P%Z.D46‡:P(ZWP(1bœ}89%9%E+
8(†!V+,\Q™W`a
P w6c+&³¶B Z.)wC,6I¶+4F0P(KB RZB R)(6V_+4F0B $.$,"(ZKw6&Hˆ+IGRZ56
Š +,œ'2'3R1w6&P%Z.DY
+ ,B '"
+ !)B RZ:'ŠLR$UK2RP%12)wC.B Z.5pWK2B Z.5
'R`a*,"%12P(X,M…P()'"%12Kw+#Žt&igfi;rmkbhwxvŒ#gŸs ¡,rdif[žhwkbiwlhwi6
8%—(8.•d8%–3? †(—%‚;†%€(8648(9%9%+
8(—!V+&T&+DPpT.B X ](P
6 /+V+.·JRX "(K2"76.Hˆ+˜#+&F0"%X 5(CR1w6˜#+V+/B $,RB 12"(^…¯>R'"76
V+&<+&³Q+&IGP%RZ.D.R16P(ZD¯
+ ,B ]7B P%Z.BN+,\Q"%$:-QR$^QPa)12P-#X R1/MN"%1'3C.R
$.1P(™B X B P(ZU-QR$,+&cdZLefg(hiwijkmln(oag2qž,rNfkmlnefghiwowo3kNl.nxlj
 l(qgfŸ}x%rNkdgl ° i;rmfkdi±xvQ’Ož,e 3°0´ ”64*P(5%RK0€(E;;‚%64\QP%Z.)WZ,6
Y R „7B )"6&T.R*7'R`s$,R1/;‚%‚%‚:+4c µ\THJ12RK2Kw+
8(§!I¶+&A0P%)wC.P%12Pœ%+ŠLR$.˜QP%K2R(+C:'2'*4? @(@MN12RRK2"(Mm'd-QP%12R(+ MNKbMd+ "%125%@-QR$.$P(KR;@:6
8(9(9:8:+GF0HJI T7"(Mm'd-QP(12R(+
8(€UY+&A0B X B 5(RZ:'BN6³Q+,\Q"R'3™RR(6.T,+&IGP-#12RZ.)R(6&\>+,I¶+4F0B X RK6&P(ZD
Y+,F0"%12BN+&³&")W.K2RD)12P-#X B Z5aW.K2B Z5a)"(Z:'R„'#5(1P(*C.Kw+&cdZ
efg(hiwijkmln(oag2
q %rmt  l,rbiwflx%rmkdglxv>Œ#glq;iwfilGhi¦g
l 4iwf‘­xfbn7i
’ ¶­ !
6 J5œ7*.'6&T7R*.'R`s$&R1
£ x%rbxxo;ioU
£ ”6&*.P%5%RK#†%8(§;7†(S(E6G\QP%B 12"
8(9(9%9+
8(‚UT&+,A0B X XN6&_+
_W`aP(1w
6 p+,T&+,Y}))W12X Rœ%67T,+&#P2P%5("%*.P%X P(Z46
A[+,T.B ](P(‰W`aP(1w6P%Z.D}V+&=ˆ"(`a‰B Z.K+,T7RX Mm^OK2B `aB X P%12B 'dœ¦B Z'CR_-QR$4+
‹sŒQ
Ž.fxl
o "  l4rdi#
f "0ŽGihw
t " 6&8.•…S%–3? 89:†78%8(S648(9(9:8+
S9(!_+&Š + JD7-QP%12DF[+,\Q"(º4`aP(Z4
6 +,IB W4+&¨0*7'3B `aP%XG12"%$,"'>K2)wC.RDW.X B Z.5
MN"%1-QR$}K2RP%12)wC}RZ.5%B ZRKw%
+ $.g¡fwlxvg2qžGht&ij¡.v kml.n%6G•d;–w? †;8%‚:6
‚(‚%€:+
S:!‡.
+ JD7-QP%12DKw
6 s+,T,+,Y});\QW12X Rœ%6.P(ZD‡.+&V+&=ˆ"(`aX B Z,+V>Z}P%D.P%*7'B ]:R
`a"D.RX,M…"(1#"(*.'B `aB ™B Z5[*,R1bM…"(12`aP%Z.)R>"(M¶P%ZB Z.)12R`aRZ:'3P(X-QR$
)12P-#X R1w+&cdZLefghiijkmln(osg2qprNt&i}ŽGiwl4rNt Œ/gl(qifiwlhi¦glzy{gfvmj
ykbjiyi(w6&*P(5%RK_9:—%;S6,<>"%Z.&
5 _"%Z.576,Y}Pœ}89%9%
+ JX K2R]7B R1
T7)B RZ)R(+
S(8!A[
+ JB )wC.`aP%Z.Z,+.=/C.R#˜
T K2*B DR1w?Q$.P%X P%Z.)B Z5[Rº4R)'B ]:R_K2RP%12)3C
P%5(P%B Z.Kb'#-QR$}X "%P%D,+&cdZLefg(hwiijkmln(osg2qsrNt&i/½Jforpy{gfwvNj|ykbjiyi(
Œ#glq;iwfilGhiw6&F_RZ.R]P76,T-#B '™R12X P(ZD,6Y}Pœ~;‚%‚E7+
S(S!¯
+ JB 12"%Z,
6 s+4T&+&Y});\QW12X Rœ%6P(ZDU‡.+4V_+,="%`aX B Z4+/P%Z.‰B Z.5p'3C.R0-QR$
MN12"%Z:'B R1w+cdZLefg(hwiijkmln(opg2qprmt&'
i (:rmtkml4rbiwflGx%rNkdglxv#hglqifiwlhi
gl ygfvmj ykdji{yi6&*.P%5%RK#S(9%‚;7S:€:+4V/\/Y HJ12RKKw6&89%9%E+
SE(!A[+&³&R'2'R12X œ%6Y+,Y}P%Z.P%K2K2R(6&P%Z.DY+&¯>#
P 2"(1‰+&T7*.P%`U6D.P%`aZK2*.P%`U6
P%Z.D}Kb'P('B Kb'B )Kw?Q¸>K2B Z.5aKb'P('B Kb'B )P%XGP%Z.P%X œ7KB K#'"aX ")P('R_K2*P(`¼Š{R$
*.P%5%RKw+&cdZLefghiijkmln(opg2qsrNt&isoiw±7iwl4rmt}u#gfªowt&g «gl«rmt&iyi
xlj~jx%rdxxoiwoU’;y{i £! ”6&‡:W.ZR89%9%E+
S(†¦š[+&<>PM…12BGP%Z.D\#+&
A R12P($P+,<#B 5%CU*,R1bM…"(12`aP%Z.)R0)1P-/X B Z.5aKbœ7K2'R`U+
cdZLefghiijkmln(opg2qsrNt&)
i %rNt}‹sŒQž  ¬_~ kml4rbiwflGx%rNkdglxv
u#gfªowt&g «gl«}¡.v¤rmkNŸ}ijkdx¦kmlq;gfwŸx%rmkdgl fi;rmfkdi±xv 6&*.P%5%RK
8%‚(‚;S(9:—:+4V/\YƒHJ12RK2K6,89%9%E+
S(—UY+&<>RZ.™B Z5(R1w6.V+&<>Rœ7D."%Z,6&Y+4Y}B '3™RZ.`aP%)3CR1w6P%Z.DY+&¯>#
P 2"(1‰+
¨0Z}Z.RP%1dW.ZB M…"(12` W12XGK2P%`a*.X B Z.57+cdZLefghiijkmln(opg2qsrNt&is®0kNl,rNt
Œ#glq;iwfilGhi¦gl ygfvNj«ykdji{yi(w6&*P(5%RK#8%‚%†7S9:€6,V>`aKb'R12DP(`U6
¯>R'C.R1X P%Z.DKw6Y}Pœ89%9(97
+ JX K2R]7B R1/T.)B RZ.)R(+
S%§;UY+,<#R1K2"]7B )BN6&Y+&‡:P()"]7BN6š[+,T,+,Y}P%P(12R‰6A[+,HˆRX X R56
Y+4T7C:'P%X C.P%B `U6.P%Z.DT&+,¸#1+&=CRK2CP(12‰:^OK2RP%12)3C}P%X 5("%12B 'C.`U+V>Z
P%*.*X B )P('B "%Z,?ˆ'P%B X "(12RDŠ R$UK2B 'R[`aP(**.B Z.57+cdZLefghiijkmln(osg2qprNt&i
oiw±7iwl4rmtLhgl(qiwfiwlhwiagl ygfvNj|ykdjiLyi(w6&*P(5%RK>S:§7S%8(—+
JX K2R]7B R1#T7)B RZ.)R(67V>*.12B X¶‚(‚%€+
S%€;!V+&<>Rœ7D"(ZP(ZDY+&¯>
P 2"%12‰+&Y}R12)P('"%1w?V»K2)P(X P%$.X R(6R„'RZK2B $.X R
-QR$})12P;-/X R1w+>y{gfwvNj|ykbjiyi(UŒ#gl(qiwfilGhi6&87•NE:–3? 8;‚;8%8%‚:6
V>*12B Xˆ;‚%‚(‚+
S%‚;UY+4F[
+ _RZD.P%X XN+ ° xlªŒ#gffivmx%rNkdgl|{irNt&gjow+&F012B !Z46,IG"%Z.D"(Z46
JZ5(X P%Z.D464;‚%§97+
E%9UY
+ _"(K2'R1w+&#"($,"('K#B Z'CR0-QR$,?J'C12RP'>"%1'1RP+
' * Œ#gll-i ,_kbglow6
‚.•NE:–36&V>*.1B X;‚%‚(†+
E7U¨s+&V+,Y})˜Q1bœ:P(Z4+,+
F J¯#·0I{P%Z.DŠµŠ Š Šz?&=""%X KM…"(1/'P%`aB Z5p'C.R
-QR$4+cdZ{eJfghiijkml.n%osg2qsrNt&i/½JforaygfvNj|ykdji{yiUŒ/gl(qifiwlhiw6
F_RZ.R]P76,T-#B '™R12X P(ZD,6Y}Pœ~;‚%‚E7+
E:8;!V
+ p+,Y});\QP%X X W`U
6 s+&¯>B 5(P%`U6‡.+&#RZ.Z.B R(6P%Z.
D s+,T.Rœ7`a"(1R(+
V>W.'"(`aP('B Z.5s'CR)"%Z.Kb'312W.)'B "%Z!"(M¶B Z:'R1Z.R'/*,"%1b'P%X K-#B '3C`aP%)wC.B Z.R
X RP%12Z.B Z5+  l(qgfŸ}x%rNkdgl ° i;rmfkdi±xv 6S7•…8%–3? 8(§;.—%S:6G89%9(97+
E:S;!³Q+,Y}RZ)™R1w6F[+&H¶P(Z:'6,Hˆ+&T712B Z.B ]P%K2P%Z,6&P%Z.DY
+ /+#W.B ™(+
](P(X W.P('B Z.5s'"%*.B )^OD.12B ]:RZ!-QR$})12P-#X R12Kw+&cdZLefg(hwiijkmln(opg2qprmt&i
#.rNtLhglq;iwfilGhiagl fiwoixfhwtxljjiw±ivmg Ÿiwl4rJkmlLkml(qgfŸ}x%rmkbgl
firNfwkbiw±xv/’…ž  ¬ 3° ”6,*.P%5%RK#8(E78E:‚:+4V/\/Y HJ12RKKw6&89%97(+
E%E!_+,Y}B X X R1P%Z.
D s+&˜QCP(1P'+4T7*.CB Z7„&?VzMN12P%`aR-Q"(12‰!MN"%1/)12RP('B Z.5
*,R12K"(ZP(XN6K2B 'R^OK2*,R)B ©,)>-QR$})12P-#X R1Kw+&cdZLefghiijkmln(opg2qsrNt&i
oiw±7iwl4rmtLhgl(qiwfiwlhwiagl ygfvNj|ykdjiLyi(w6&˜12B K2$.P%Z.R(6V>W.K2'12P%X B P76
V>*12B Xˆ;‚%‚(€
+ JX K2R]7B R1#T7)B RZ.)R(+
E:†;UY+,¯##
P 2"%12‰¦P%Z.D}‡.+&I¶+Š B RZR1w+˜Q12RP%D7'3C7^N©,12Kb'>)12P-#X B Z5pœ7B RX DK
CB 5(C.^…›W.P%X B 'Oœ¦*P(5%RKw+cdZ{efghiijkmln(osg2q[rNt&i}ŽGiwl4rmt{Œ#glqifiwlhiagl
y{gfvmj|y}kdji{y{i6*.P%5(RK_(;E.%;€6,<>"%Z.
5 "(Z56&Y}Pœ8(9(97(+
JX K2R]7B R1#T7)B RZ.)R(+
E:—;!V+&¯#'"%W.X P%Kw6&‡.+,\C."76,P%Z.D}\#+4¨_X K2'"(Z4+ŠµCP
' / K#Z.R- "%Z'C.R0-QR
$ *(?
'3C.R_R]:"(X W.'B "(Z"M'CR0-QR$MN12"%`¼PaK2RP%12)wC}RZ.5%B ZR0*,R12K2*,R)'B ]%R(+.cdZ
eJfghiijkml.n%opg2qsrNt&)
i (:rNtLhglqifiwlhiaglzy{gfvmj«y}kdjiy{i6
*P(5%RK__;86&¯>R- šJ"(1‰6¯/š[6&¸0T.V_64Y}Pœ}8(9%9(E7+&V/\/Y HJ1RK2Kw+
E:§;!I+&HˆP%5%R(6&T&+&˜Q1B Z46&_+,Y}"'d-QP%Z.BN6&P%Z.D=>+,ŠµB Z."%5(1P(D4+=C.RHˆP%5(R1P(Z‰
)B 'P('B "%ZUP%X 5("%12B 'C.`U?J$.12B Z5(B Z.5a"%12DR1Q'"p'CR_-QR$4+&=R)wC.ZB )P%X
1R*&"%1b'6&T7'P%Z7MN"%12DA0B 5%B 'P%XGIGB $.12P%1bœ=R)wC.Z."%X "(5%B RKQHJ12#
" 2R)'6,;‚%‚%€:+
E:€;UFs+&HˆP%Z:'6,T,+&˜Q12P%D.KC.P-_6,P%Z.D}³J+4Y}RZ.)™R1w+T7RP%12)wCURZ5(B ZR^…)12P-#X R1
K2œ7`[$B "%K2B Kw+&cdZLefg(hiwijkmln(oag2qsrmt&i ´ ¡.fg ixl|Œ#glq;iwfilGhi¦gl
£ k¤n(k…rbxvQ­Gkbwfxfkdio!’ ´ Œ £ ­”6&]:"%X W`aR8%§(—%‚p"M#­ihrN¡.fi®sg%rbiwoskml
Œ#gŸs ¡,rdif[žhwkbiwlhwi6*.P%5(RK>8%8:8%S%8:+GT7*.1B Z5(R16V#W5(WKb'089%9%S+
E:‚;!˜>+&HJB Z.‰%R1b'"%Z,+³¶B ZD.B Z.5s-#C.P('#*,R"%*.X R0-QP%Z:'0
? „7*&R1B RZ)RK-/B 'C'CR
ŠLR$\12P-/X R1w+cdZLefg(hiwijkmln(oag2qsrmt&i#½Jfworaygfvmj ykdji{yi
Œ#gl(qiwfiwlhwi6&F0RZ.R](P6,T7-/B '™R12X P%Z.D46.Y}P;œ‚(‚(E+
†(9UT,+&#P(5%C.P](P(ZP%Z.D<+4F0P%12)B P^dY}"(X B Z.P7+&\Q1P-/X B Z.5a'3C.R_CB DD.RZU-QR$,+
cdZLefg(hiwijkmln(oag2qsrmt&i~Žˆu#iwl4rm‘¢Oo;i±il,rNt  l,rbiwflx%rmkbglGxv
Œ#gl(qiwfiwlhwi!g1
l 4ifw‘­xfbn.i £ x%rdxxoiwo2
’ ¶­ 3
£ ”;6,*.P%5(RK
8%‚;S%€6,#"(`aR(6cO'P%X œ%6,89%97(+,Y}"%125%P(
Z _P%W7M…`aP(ZZ,+
†)
p+,Y+&#B K2]7B ‰UP(ZD}0+,Y}B )wC.RX K2RZ4+.T.RP(1)3CRZ.5%B Z.RKP%Z.D-QR$
D.œ7Z.P%`aB )Kw+Œ#gŸs ¡&rbiwf[®sirNu#gfwª(o36GS(‚.•…S%–36&‡:W.ZR8(9(9:8:+
†%8;¦·[+,T.C.‰;P%*,RZ:œ7W.‰aP%Z.D}=>+GT7WRXm+A0RKB 5%ZP(ZDB `a*X R`aRZ:'3P'B "%Z¦"(M¶P
CB 5(C.^…*,R1bMN"%12`aP%Z.)R>D.B Kb'1B $W7'RD!-QR$})12P-/X R1w+,cOZLefghiiwjkNl.n%opg2q
rNt&)
i 4:rNt  l4rdiflGx%rNkdglxv>Œ/gl(qifiwlhiagl £ x%rdx ´ ln(kNlGiiwfkmln
’  Œ £_´ ”6,*P(5%RK>S(†%§sUS%—(€64T.P(Z‡:"(K2R(64\QP%X B MN"%12ZB P76&³&R$.12WP(12œ!89%9%8+
c \/T}HJ12RK2Kw+
†%S;!‡.+&=ˆP(X B `U
6 +,IB W46Hˆ+&¯>P(B Z46&P(Z'
D /+4F[+4\>+&‡:1w+,\Q"%Z:'12"%X X B Z5p'C.R
1"($,"('K/"(M¶-QR$KRP(12)wC}RZ.5%B Z.RKw+cdZLefg(hwiijkmln(osg2q[‹[Œ5
 $.gkml4r
 l,rbiwflx%rmkdglxv>Œ#glq;iwfilGhi¦gl|{ixo3¡fiwŸiwl4r/xlGjLgjiwv kmlng2q
Œ#gŸs ¡,rdif[ž&‘%orbiwŸ¦o’Ož  ¬_ ´ Ž °# ŒJž7¾,e/iwfOqgfŸ}xlhib”6&*.P%5%RK
8%S%—78E%E764\QP%`s$.12B D.5%R(6&Y}P%K2K2P%)3CWK2R'2'Kw6,¸>T.V6&‡:W.Z.R[89%9%+
†(E!Hˆ+ ^O¯_+,=P%ZP%Z.DU·[
+ _W`aP(1+A0B K)"]%R12œU"(Mˆ-QR$}12"%$,"'K#K2RK2KB "%Z
$P(KRD"%Z'C.RB 1/Z.P]7B 5%P'B "%Z.P%XG*.P('2'R1Z.Kw+ £ x%rbx}kml&kmlnxlj
6 lGgu#vNiwj;n.i!jkmohg±ifw‘%6&—.•d;–w? ‚;7S(†648(9(9:8+
†%†;!=/C.7
R J)"(Z"(`aB Kb'+&\"(WZ:'1bœHJ12"©,X RKw6&8(9(9:8:+
†%—;!¸>ZB '3RDU¯>P('B "(ZKw+&H¶"(*W.X P'3B "%ZA0B ]7B K2B "%Z,6&8(9(9:8+
†%§;!¸>ZB '3RDU¯>P('B "(ZKw+&<>W.`aP%ZUA0R]:RX "(*`aRZ:'#R*&"%1b'K6,89%9:S:+
†%€;!A[
+ ,RB ZP(X B *,"(W1b^NšJP%™'B,P(ZDY+&A[+&A0B ‰;P%B P%‰%"(Kw+,A0RK2B 5(Z}P%Z.D
B `a*X R`aRZ:'3P'B "%Za"MPaD.B Kb'312B $.W7'3RD¦)12P-#X R1/P(ZD©&X 'R12B Z5[*12")RK2K2"%1w+
cdZLefg(hiwijkmln(oag2qsrmt&i#½,qwrmt®si ¹ r_¬ilGifx%rNkdgl  lqgfŸ}x%rNkdgl
ŽGihwtlgvNg3n(kbiwopxljUž&‘(ordiŸ¦o’…®p¬  Žˆž:”6&]:"%X W`aR8%S(€%8a"(M/­ihrN¡.fi
®sg%rbiwoskml Œ#gŸs ¡&rbiwfsžhwkdilGhiw6*P(5%RK>†(€;§(E764\QP%RK2P%12RP76&cdK212P%RXm6
‡:WZ.R8(9(9:8+4T7*12B Z.5%R1w+
†%‚;!<
+ ,CP(Z56,V_+4F0"RXN6&0+4F0"]7B Z.DP(Z4
6 s+,Y}P%K2"%Z,6&P%Z.D}˜#+·[+&#"œ%+
Y}P%‰B Z.5aRB 5%RZ:]%R)'"%1b^O$.P%K2RD¦12R*W7'P('B "(ZKbœ7Kb'3R`aK/12"%$.WKb'#'"
)"%X X W.K2B "%Z,+cdZLefghiijkmln(opg2qsrNt&iprNtkmfj«y{gfªowt&g «glzy{i
¬>fx toU’;ys‹y¦”;64]%"%X W.`aRS%8(E%Sa"(M#­iwh;rm¡fi_®sg%rdio[kNlµŒ#gŸs ¡,rdif
žhwkbiwlhwi6&*.P%5%RK#‚%8;9(E76&#"(`aR(6&cO'P%X œ%6&¨0)'"%$,R1/8(9(9%E+GT7*12B Z.5%R1w+