© NSW Department of Education and Training (DET) 2005 All rights reserved. This work is copyright to NSW Department of Education and Training. Permission is given to trainers and teachers to make copies by photocopying or other duplicating processes for use within their own training organisations, or in a workplace where training is being conducted. This permission does not extend to the resale of this material to third parties, the making of copies for use outside the immediate training environment for which they are made, and the use of the materials for hire. Outside these guidelines, all material is subject to copyright under the Copyright Act. 1968 (Commonwealth) and permission must be obtained in writing from the NSW Department of Education and Training. Disclaimer The views expressed in this work do not necessarily represent the views of the NSW Department of Education and Training. The NSW Department of Education and Training does not give warranty nor accept any liability in relation to the content of this work. This work has been produced initially with the assistance of funding provided by the NSW Department of Education and Training, Training Development Unit, through the Training Resources & Support Program with advice from the Product Advisory Committee. Further copies of this resource are available from: Website: www.skillsonline.net.au For further information, contact: Email: [email protected] First published July 2005 Resource Development Team Performance Development Solutions Lorraine Wheeler & Assoc P/L Precision Consultancy RMIT Training Plus Solutions P/L (81919732 Product Advisory Committee Deborah Griffin NSW DET Catherine Chaffey Financial Services Education Agency Aust ltd Suellen Freeman SW Sydney Institute of TAFE Bankstown Campus Paul Tweddell Dept Aging Disability and Home Care David Makin/Neroli Sheldon AIM Justine Mercer Moore NSW Chapter of the AIPM Lorraine Wheeler/Stephen Auburn Project Team ©NSW DET 2005 Page 1 of 41 Contents 1. Introduction ....................................................................................................................................................... 4 1.1 How the learning guide is organised ...................................................................................................... 5 1.2 An overview of BSBPM504A Manage project costs.............................................................................. 5 1.3 Learning outcomes ..................................................................................................................................... 6 1.3.1 Elements of competency .................................................................................................................... 6 1.3.2 Knowledge and skills involved in managing project costs......................................................... 6 2. Project Costs: Topics and learning activities .............................................................................................. 8 2.1 About project costs .................................................................................................................................... 8 2.1.1 Definition(s) and Main Activities Involved in Project Costs ....................................................... 8 2.1.2 The Relationship of Project Costs and Project Phases ................................................................ 8 2.1.3 Responsibilities for managing project costs ................................................................................. 9 2.1.4 Stakeholder involvement in project costs .................................................................................... 10 2.2 Element 1: Determine project costs ...................................................................................................... 10 2.2.1 Determine resource requirements for individual tasks ............................................................ 11 2.2.2 Estimate project costs and implement cost management processes .................................... 12 2.2.3 Develop and implement a cost management plan ..................................................................... 18 2.3 Element 2:Monitor and control project costs ..................................................................................... 19 2.3.1 Implement financial management processes and procedures ................................................ 20 2.3.2 Select and use cost analysis methods and tools ....................................................................... 20 2.3.2 Implement, monitor and modify agreed actions ........................................................................ 21 2.4 Element 3:Conduct financial completion activities ........................................................................... 21 2.4.1 Financial completion activities ....................................................................................................... 22 2.4.2 Review of project outcomes ........................................................................................................... 22 2.4.3 Cost management lessons learned ............................................................................................... 23 3. Assessment and demonstration of competency ...................................................................................... 26 3.1 Developing an evidence portfolio ......................................................................................................... 26 3.2 Products that can be used as evidence of competency .................................................................... 27 3.3 Processes that can be used as evidence of competency .................................................................. 27 3.4 Record of your work experiences relating to project cost management ..................................... 28 3.5 Assessment Activities .............................................................................................................................. 30 4. Resources and reference materials ............................................................................................................. 33 (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 2 of 41 4.1 Project costs proformas and templates ............................................................................................... 33 4.2 Further references .................................................................................................................................... 37 4.2.1 General references ........................................................................................................................ 37 4.3 Key terms in Cost Management ............................................................................................................. 39 List of Activities Reflection: Cost Analysis Tools ...................................................................................................................... 21 Reflection: Project Completion Checklist ..................................................................................................... 22 Reflection: Personal and organisational learning ....................................................................................... 25 Assessment Activity Estimating Project Costs ............................................................................................ 30 Assessment Activity: Developing a cost management plan ..................................................................... 30 Assessment Activity: Monitoring and controlling costs ............................................................................ 30 Assessment activity: Project Completion Checklist ................................................................................... 31 Assessment Activity: Project Completion Evaluation ................................................................................ 32 Assessment Activity: Personal and organisational learning ..................................................................... 32 Index to templates Estimate of project costs ................................................................................................................................... 33 Resources Matrix i ............................................................................................................................................... 33 Resource Usage Chart ........................................................................................................................................ 34 Overall project budget : ..................................................................................................................................... 34 Budget Expenditure plan ................................................................................................................................... 35 Project Budget Format ........................................................................................................................................ 36 (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 3 of 41 1. Introduction Welcome to these materials, developed by the NSW Training Resources and Support Program (TRS) of the NSW Department of Education and Training to support delivery of the Diploma of Project Management (BSB51504) from the Business Services Training Package (BSB01). These materials should be used in conjunction with the learning guides for the other units of competency in the qualification and the relevant assessment activities from the Assessment Guide including holistic and up front assessment activities. The design of the materials is based on the assumption that project management is not an entry level qualification and learners are likely to have existing training and qualifications. This learner guide is aimed at learners who will be working as project team members in a single project or in one area of a large, complex project. This is the learning guide that applies to the national unit of competency BSBPM504A Manage project costs from the Diploma of Project Management BSB41504 and is designed for use in conjunction with other relevant components of the Kit. There are two other units of competency closely related to BSBPM504A Manage project costs. These are: (BSBPM403A) Apply cost management techniques: This unit applies to functions normally carried out by project team members under the direction of the project manager and working with other project team members (BSBPM604A) Direct cost management of multiple projects/programs. This unit applies to the functions performed by a project manager to manage costs within multiple projects and programs. The required units of competency to attain the Diploma of Project Management BSB51504 are: (BSBPM502A) Manage project scope (BSBPM503A) Manage project time (BSBPM504A) Manage project costs (BSBPM505A) Manage project quality (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 4 of 41 (BSBPM506A) Manage project human resources (BSBPM507A) Manage project communications (BSBPM508A) Manage project risk (BSBPM509A) Manage project procurement (BSBPM501A) Manage application of project integrative processes 1.1 How the learning guide is organised This learner guide is divided into four sections: Section One provides an overview of the unit of competency. Section Two contains information and activities arranged around topic areas that reflect each of the elements in the unit of competency. The activities include reflective questions, problem solving exercises and activities involving workplace research. Many of the activities draw on the five case studies provided with these materials Section Three provides information about assessment and demonstration of competency. It includes proformas for recording evidence of competency and assessment activities. Section Four contains a number of relevant templates and proformas, a glossary of terms and a guide to electronic and print resources and reference materials. The design of the materials is based on the assumption that project management is not an entry level qualification and learners are likely to have existing training and qualifications. This learner guide is aimed at learners who will be working as project managers in a single project or in one area of a large, complex project. 1.2 An overview of (BSBPM504A) Manage project costs This unit specifies the outcomes required to identify, analyse and refine project costs to produce a budget, and use this budget as the principal mechanism to control project costs. A project manager usually performs these functions. (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 5 of 41 1.3 Learning outcomes The information and activities in this Learning Guide aim to assist you to achieve the following outcomes: 1.3.1 Elements of competency The elements that are the critical outcomes of the unit of competency are: 1. Determine project costs 2. Monitor and control project costs 3. Conduct financial completion activities 1.3.2 Knowledge and skills involved in managing project costs The unit of competency identifies the required knowledge and skills listed below. Learning and assessment activities in this guide aim have been developed to reflect all items on this list. Required knowledge and understanding include: the need to link time, cost and resources to the project framework acceptance of responsibilities for cost management development of project budgets and expenditure forecasts use of the budgets and expenditure forecasts as control mechanisms the place of cost management in the context of the project life cycle and other project management functions appropriate cost management methodologies, their capabilities, limitations, application and outcomes Required skills and attributes include: ability to relate to people from a range of cultural and ethnic backgrounds, and physical and mental abilities (81919732 project management financial management ©NSW DET 2005 Page 6 of 41 planning and organising communication and negotiation leadership and personnel management monitoring and review skills attributes include: analytical abilities, ability to maintain an overview, communicative and able to provide positive leadership (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 7 of 41 2. Project Costs: Topics and learning activities 2.1 About project costs This Learning Guide is about providing you with opportunities to practice and demonstrate skills and knowledge required to manage project costs. If you think you already know how to do this, go to Section Three of the Learning Guide for advice on how to collect evidence for assessment. 2.1.1 Definition(s) and Main Activities Involved in Project Costs Project costs concerned with: determining project costs by examining resource requirements and developing estimates in order to develop and have approved a project budget and implement a cost management plan; Monitoring and controlling project costs by implementing financial management processes and procedures, selecting methods and tools to identify cost variations and to take action; Conducting financial completion activities and reviewing project outcomes to determine the effectiveness of cost management processes and to identify costs manage issue s and recommend improvements. 2.1.2 The Relationship of Project Costs and Project Phases Project costs is important at all stages of the at all stages of project operations. You must demonstrate an understanding of. The summary below provides information on considerations at the different stages that impact on learning and assessment activities. Proponent phase – ie before a project proposal is submitted (initiation/concept phase) The main task in this stage is to develop an estimate of costs for the project proposal. This is often called a rough order-of-magnitude estimate. Rather than an actual estimate of costs, this estimate often represents an amount that cannot be (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 8 of 41 exceeded if your project is to have an acceptable return on investment. This type of estimate has a low level of confidence. Approval phase – once a project is approved (planning/development) The main tasks in this phase are the development of the detailed budget estimate and obtaining approval for the project budget. Develop the detailed budget estimate after you specify the required project activities. Implementation phase – when the project is underway (delivery) At the commencement o f the project, when personnel and resources have been allocated to the project, it is important to review the budget with the project team and stakeholders (if necessary). If it is necessary to revise the budget, approval will be needed. It will also be necessary to establish appropriate controls over expenditure such as purchasing through the use of delegations, purchase orders and other forms of approval. Regular financial management reporting and analysis will also be required During a project it is necessary to regularly monitor and review costs and expenditure against budget to identify situations that may require changes to the approved project budget. Again approval will be required. Completion phase - review (finalisation) Preparation of end of project financial reports, disposal of project assets, redeployment of staff and finalisation of contracts. 2.1.3 Responsibilities for managing project costs Personnel Responsibility Project manager Provides and manages the project schedule Resources the project according to work and human and financial resources required Communicates project budget information Monitors and reviews financial performance Authorizing agent/agency Champions the project Acts a inspirational figurehead (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 9 of 41 Helps to finalise top level financial goals Works to minimise operational constraints Prioritises active projects where conflicts exist Approves financial allocation Provides clear strategic direction Project team member(s) Assists with the development of the project budget Monitors project costs Contributes to cost finalisation process Provides technical skill and application Responsible for project task performance Takes directions form Project Manager 2.1.4 Stakeholder involvement in project costs Stakeholder interest in project costs will vary from project to project. The key stakeholder in all projects will be the Project Director or higher authority. 2.2 Element 1: Determine project costs Learning outcomes covered in determining project costs include: Determination of resource requirements for each task (detailing constraints and assumptions); Estimation of project costs and implementation of cost management processes; Development and implementation of a cost management plan describing how variances will be managed Project cost estimates are an important component of the project proposal. The sorts of questions that a project sponsor or higher authority may ask when considering a project proposal include: What is the estimated budget for the project? How was the estimate determined, who determined the estimate and what ids the confidence level in the accuracy of the estimate? (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 10 of 41 Does the budget allow for continent funding and under what circumstances can it be accessed? What are the draw-down procedures for spending the budget? Have all project costs been captured? What accounting reporting and control measures need to be followed? What type of contracts will be used to manage costs? What deposits or progress payments may be required? It is essential that the processes and tools that you use to determine project costs are able to answer these questions. 2.2.1 Determine resource requirements for individual tasks Cost estimates are quantitative assessment of the likely costs of resources required to complete project activities. They must cover all projected cost areas including labour, materials, supplies, administrative costs and other categories as appropriate. These cost estimates are refined during the life of a project as additional information becomes available. There are three main methods of cost estimating: 1. Bottom up estimating: estimating the cost of individual activities and rolling these up to determine project costs 2. Analogous estimating: “top down” estimating which involves using the actual costs of a previous similar project to make an estimate for a planned project 3. Fixed budget estimating: taking the total amount of money available to the project and dividing it across project components to ascertain what you can and can’t afford. You will need the following information in order to estimate costs: Description of all project activities Description of resource requirements – this may be contained in the Work Breakdown Structure (81919732 Rates or costs of resources (e.g. labour cost per hour or per day) ©NSW DET 2005 Page 11 of 41 Task duration estimates – again from he Work Breakdown Structure Any relevant historical data Chart of accounts There are two types of resources: Variable cost resources and fixed cost resources. With variable cost resources the cost varies according to the effort expended. An example of variable cost resources are labour costs which will usually be based on the number of hours taken to perform the task. Resources such as equipment hire or licence fees are fixed cost resources since they involve a one off cost, no matter how much effort is expended. To estimate project costs you will need a worksheet that looks something like this: Activity WBS Description Code Resources required Duration Resource Resource name & rate name & rate Other costs Total costs by activity You may like to set up a spreadsheet or use project management software to estimate costs. A sample spreadsheet is included in section 4.1.2. 2.2.2 Estimate project costs and implement cost management processes A project budget is a detailed, time phased estimate of all the costs of resources required for your project. A budget is usually developed in stages: from a rough estimate at the scoping stage to a detailed budget estimate and on to a completed and approved project budget. Approved budgets may need to be revised during a project as a result of approved changes or project reviews. There are two types of cost that you will need to take into account: direct costs and indirect costs. (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 12 of 41 Direct costs are costs for resources that are directly attributable to your project. They may include: salaries for your project team, contractor costs, materials, supplies and equipment. Indirect costs are costs which are incurred to support project activities but that are not tracked individually. They normally fall in to two categories: overhead costs (employee benefits, office rental, furniture and equipment) and administrative costs (such as salaries of executive management or the finance department, accounting fees and legal services). Remember also to include an amount for contingencies to provide for unknowns throughout the project. Developing a budget is the process of allocating the cost estimates to individual activities to establish a base line for measuring project costs. It is usual, especially in larger projects, to develop a time phased budget in which cost estimates are broken down by time periods. This will help you to work out how much you should be spending and when. This will also assist you to manage cash flow. It is also recommended that whenever you are preparing budgets, you state the assumptions underlying your estimates, show the tolerance level that stakeholders will accept, key factors affecting the validity of your estimates and how the estimates were derived. You will therefore need to develop two documents: a budget for the whole project and a cost management plan. The cost management plan will be covered in the next section. Budget development To develop a budget you will need: (81919732 Project cost estimates Work breakdown structure Project schedule; and ©NSW DET 2005 Page 13 of 41 Your organisation’s policies and preferred formats for budgets. You will need to develop several tools to assist you to work out your budget: 1. A resources matrix (for non staff resources) 2. Individual resource usage charts (for each resource) 3. A summary usage chart (for all non staff resources) An example of a Resources Matrix is: Activity WBS Description Code Amount of Resources required (hours) Contractor Test Lab Statistician A Engineering advice An example of a Resource Usage Chart is: Test lab time required Week 1 Task 1 Week 2 10 Task 2 Task 3 (81919732 20 20 40 20 30 10 30 40 30 80 130 10 20 TOTAL 10 20 Task 4 TOTAL Week 3 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 14 of 41 You overall project budget may be presented in a similar manner to the following: Project Budget for …………………………………………… Cost category Direct Labour Detail Cost Total Project manager: 600 hours @ $45 per hour 27,000 Project team A: 600 hours @ $35 per hour 21,000 Project team B: 200 hours @ $60 per hour 12,000 60,000 Indirect costs @ 40% 24,000 Other Direct costs Materials 3,000 Travel 5,000 Contractors 15,000 Contingency 17,000 17,000 Total 23,000 TOTAL PROJECT COSTS $124,000 In addition to the overall project budget, you will need to know what you are planning to spend and when. To do this you will need to make and complete a worksheet with headings such as these depending on how often you want to monitor your spending: Budget Spending Plan Activity Account Budgeted Budgeted Budgeted (WBS) code January February March (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Budgeted etc Page 15 of 41 List all the project activities. For each activity, look at the project schedule and the cost estimate to work out how much will be spent in the first period, second period etc. Then list the amounts in the columns beside each activity. You may wish to list specific resource costs under each activity as they may have different account codes). Present you preliminary budget and spending plan to an expert colleague as a reality check. You will also need to consider the project risk management plan as it is wise to build into the budget an amount for contingencies. (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 16 of 41 Reflection activity: Developing a budget Read the Case Study Fred’s Shed. The following is a sample WBS for Building a Shed. Develop a project budget (based on the costs in the WBS) for presentation to the Project Steering Committee. You may also wish to develop a Budget Spending Plan to map out cashflow. Task Task Description Predecessor relationship Number/ID Time Resources (people and materials required to Costs complete the task) (sequence ) 1. Preparation phase 1.1 Design Shed N/A 3 days Designer $1000 1.2 Obtain council approvals 1.1 14 days Project manager to submit engineering, design $500 specifications and construction certificates 1.3 Sign Contract 1.1, 1.2 0.2 days Project manager $0 2 Construction Phase 2.1 Check existing boundaries 1.1, 1.2 1 day Surveyor, $1500 2.2 Check underground cable locations 1.1, 1.2 1 day Project manager to contact utilities $100 2.3 Establish site services and amenities 1.1, 1.2 2 days Fence construction team (2), electrician, plumber, $6000 require hired toilet, fencing materials 2.4 Excavate site 2.1, 2.2 3 days Excavation team (3) $7,500 2.5 Pour Concrete and wait for it to set 2.4 2 days day Construction team (4) $8,000 2.6 Install Shed 2.5 2 days Construction team (4) $15,000 3 Completion Phase 3.1 Connect utilities to shed 2.6 2 days Electrician, Plumber $2,500 3.2 Clean up site 2.5 3 days Construction team (2) $3,500 3.3 Hand over keys and warranties 3.2 1 day Project Manager $0 3.4 Final Payment 3.3 0 days (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 17 of 41 $0 Cost management controls You will also need to put in place a series of controls over expenditure. These may include: approval processes contract negotiations and approvals financial authorisations/delegations invoice and payment procedures communication and reporting processes 2.2.3 Develop and implement a cost management plan Now that you have developed a budget, you will need to develop and implement cost management strategies and processes to ensure that you keep control of your project costs. The strategies and processes that may be used include: Measurement of actual progress against planned milestones Recording and reporting of variations Implementation of financial control mechanisms; and Communication with stakeholders, dispute resolution and procedures for modifying plans and budgets. Your organisation will have financial policies, procedures and systems in place. As a Project Manager you need to be familiar with them. In particular you need to be familiar with payment processes, and importantly with financial reports that are available. You will need to discuss how your project will be tracked with the staff of the Finance Department. For example, you may need to have a cost centre or job number established within the accounting system. The following is an example of a cost management plan. Cost Management Plan 1. Objectives 1.1. This document will describe how cost variances will be managed for this project. 2. Expected Stability of Project Cost 2.1. Project costs are allocated based on performance objectives defined in the task order. The detailed project plan was developed with these performance objectives in mind. Although the Project Manager may adjust the amount allocated for a given performance objective, and ‘turn on’ partial payments for a given performance objective, the total cost is expected to remain stable. 3. Cost Variance Response Process 3.1. Once the project schedule is base lined, the Project Manager is responsible to ensure that actual (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 18 of 41 effort, start and end dates are entered for each activity, as well as actual costs for fixed cost resources. T his data is essential to establish whether cost variances exist. 3.2. Major Problems 3.2.1. On a regular basis, but not less than once monthly, the project manager will produce an Earned Value Analysis Report, which will identify cost variances for this project. 3.2.2. Any cost variance of greater than + / - 5% of the aggregate project budget will require development of a cost variance analysis report to determine the root cause. 3.2.3. Any cost variance of greater than + / - 20% for a single project activity or task will require development of a cost variance analysis report to determine the root cause. 3.2.4. If the cost variance corrective action is relatively minor, it may be documented on the Cost Variance Analysis Report in the field provided. However, if the corrective action is more detailed, a separate corrective action report – cost control should be completed. 3.2.5. It is likely that major issues will require a scope change or a request for additional funding to address the cause of the major problem. 3.3. Minor Problems 3.3.1. Minor variances will be absorbed into project budget. 4. Cost Change Control Processes 4.1.1. Identify and assess the change. These would typically be generated from a cost variance analysis, but not necessarily. 4.1.2. Fill out a “Change Request Form” and submit the “Change Request Form” along with required supporting documentation to the project manager. 4.1.3. The Project Manager will review the change request and may possibly request additional documentation prior to review with the project Director. 4.1.4. The Project Manager and Project Director will jointly evaluate the change. The Project Director ultimately decides if the cost related changes will be accepted or not. Using the “Change Request Form”, the Project Director will mark the change as: 4.1.4.1. Approved, in which case both project managers will check the approved box, sign off on the change request and the Project Manager will incorporate the change and adjust other project planning factors as necessary. 4.1.4.2. Approved pending additional supporting documentation, in which case both the Project Director and the Project Manager will check the approved /pending box, sign off on the change request and the project manager will specify and coordinate gathering of the required documentation, incorporate the change and adjust other project planning factors as necessary. 4.1.4.3. Denied, in which case both the Project Director and the Project Manager will check the denied box, sign off on the change request and the Team IBM project manager will notify the requestor of the status and reason for denial. 4.1.5. The project manager will document the Change Request outcome as necessary (update WBS, schedule and budget documentation if impacted). 5. Associated Documents 5.1. Assumptions and Constraints Document 5.2. Cost Estimates 5.3. Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) 5.4. Cost Variance Analysis 5.5. Resource Rates 5.6. Activity Duration Estimates 2.3 Element 2:Monitor and control project costs Learning outcomes covered in monitoring and controlling project costs include: (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 19 of 41 Implementation of procedures to monitor actual expenditure and control costs; Selection and use of cost analysis methods and tools to identify cost variations, evaluate options and recommend actions to a higher project authority; and Implementation, monitoring and modification of agreed actions to maintain financial and overall project objectives throughout the project life cycle. 2.3.1 Implement financial management processes and procedures In the last section you developed a cost management plan and had it approved by the higher authority. This plan required you to develop and implement strategies and processes that have included: Measurement of actual progress against planned milestones. Recording and reporting of variations Implementation of financial control mechanisms Communication with stakeholders, dispute resolution and procedures for modifying plans and budgets. A budget is not a useful document unless it is used to compare budgeted to actual results. If there is a variance in expenditure from budgeted expenditure to actual expenditure this variance needs to be investigate and action taken to correct the cause. Common reasons for discrepancies include: Incorrect initial budget figures; Unexpected rises in costs during project; Errors in documentation; Project progress not to schedule; Changes in scope; and Budget cuts. Your plan is now approved and the next step is to implement it. This means that you need to make sure that your people and systems are aligned, that all parties are aware of the reporting and control mechanisms that are in place and that all relevant parties are committed to ensuring that they are carried out in a timely and accurate manner. 2.3.2 Select and use cost analysis methods and tools It is important that costs be managed throughout the project life cycle. There are a number of tools that are available to monitor expenditure and control costs. (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 20 of 41 You need to be able to monitor income and expenditure against both the agreed project plan and milestones and to the project budget. You need to be able to identify variations in costs against budget and to understand the reasons for the variation. You will need to develop a report that allows you to you to understand what is happening in your project. This is an example of a report format: Project Budget <month> <year> Budget Actual Variance Acceptable Responsibility tolerance Corrective Assumptions action Reflection: Cost Analysis Tools What other tools may you need? Once you have identified variances to budget, describe the processes that you would use to evaluate options to deal with the variance and how you would make recommendations to the higher authority. 2.3.2 Implement, monitor and modify agreed actions In the previous sections you have developed a series of processes and reports that comprise your cost management plan. Plans are dynamic artefacts that must be monitored and changed as circumstances evolve. It is therefore necessary that you implement agreed actions, and monitor and modify them throughout the project life cycle to maintain financial and overall project objectives. It is important that you keep these records of approved changes for reference during the project and include such approvals in reports to the higher authority and other stakeholders. 2.4 Element 3 :Conduct financial completion activities Learning outcomes covered in financial completion activities include: Conducting appropriate activities to signify financial completion (such as transferring financial assets, liabilities and records to client or operational support agency); (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 21 of 41 Conducting a review of project outcomes to determine effectiveness of cost management processes and procedures; and Identifying cost management issues and recommending improvements Reflection: Project Completion Checklist Work through the remainder of section 2.4. As you do, develop your own project completion checklist for use in your own project. 2.4.1 Financial completion activities In order to finalise and transfer financial assets, liabilities and records you will need to find out what your organisation’s specific requirements are: Step 1 Assembling documentation Gather the following documentation: Work Breakdown Structure Progress Reports Change requests Any planning documents that established the performance measurement framework Detailed descriptions of the project’s finished product/deliverable/s Contractor correspondence relating to terms and conditions of performance, contract changes or clarifications Contract changes Contractor payment request and tax invoices Step 2 Inspect to determine completion of (project) phase Measure, examine and test the deliverables to ensure that results conform to project specifications. Conduct a procurement audit to identify contractor successes and failures. 2.4.2 Review of project outcomes Step 3 Conduct a project team review This review may include evaluation of agreed major milestones (for example phases and sub-contracts); provision of major deliverables; change of key personnel, (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 22 of 41 finalisation of project and other agreed milestones. The records that will be useful in such a review include: lists of potential costs invoice and payment summaries budgets, commitment and expenditure cost management plans reports to a higher authority recommended and approved courses of action project and/or organisation files and records 2.4.3 Cost management lessons learned Reflection on individual and organisational learning that occurs during projects is a useful way of capturing lessons learned so that they can be passed on to future projects and over time be used to enhance organisational capacity. There is normally a formal post project review process that encompasses all aspects of a project. In this section we will focus on cost management aspects of the project. It is important to involve both the project team and stakeholders in this process. It is suggested that you undertake this task in two phases: with your project team and with your project stakeholders. It is also suggested that you hold a team review to discuss how the project went. You may like to start the meeting with a brief overview of the project budget report. What were the planned financial outcomes for each phase of the project, and what actually happened? Can the team identify and summarize why the costs of a particular phase were greater or less than planned? You may wish to use the following table to summarise this information: Brief Overview Of The Project Budget Report Project Stage Planned Costs Actual Costs Notes on cost issues Have the team members brainstorm wins and challenges in relation to managing costs and budgets. (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 23 of 41 Summary of lessons learned Challenge Lesson Learned and Recommendations Some specific questions that you might ask about project costs and budgets follow. Each question could be used as a discussion starter and focus on how the issue in question could be improved. How was the project budget developed? How accurate were forecasts and estimates? How could this be improved? What procedures and controls were put in place? How effective were they? How did the project perform in relation to budget? Were there variances and how were they managed? Were there any changes to project scope that had cost implications? How were they managed? How were project risks managed and what implication did that have for cost and budget management? How were those issues managed? If the project were to be run again, how might costs and budgets be developed and controlled differently? Was the Project Sponsor satisfied with the financial reports provided during the project? Was the Project Sponsor satisfied with the financial performance of the project? Would the team’s performance and the project outcomes be improved by any additional training activities in relation to financial management? It is usual to undertake a stakeholder debrief and evaluation at the end of a project. Cost management issues need to be addressed as part of this process. Remember that stakeholders include the client, others with a vested interest, the Project Manager and the project team. Some of the cost and budget related questions that might be posed include: (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 24 of 41 What improvements can you suggest that would assist in how future project costs and budgets are established and managed? Were you satisfied with your level of involvement in the project? Were you always kept informed of the project’s successes and failures? What part did you play in the decision making processes? Was the project team appropriately skilled in relation to managing costs and budgets? What additional training may have been helpful? Reflection: Personal and organisational learning Describe the process that you would undertake to capture personal and organisational learning. Develop a framework for a close out report to your management. Include headings and an explanation of what you would include under each heading. Step 4 Obtain formal acceptance Obtain formal acceptance, in writing, that the sponsor has accepted the product/end result of the project (phase). Step 5 Formal acceptance of contractor deliverables Write to contractors formally accepting their deliverables Update the contractor files Step 6 Update and archive records Update paper based and electronic project records. Archive records in accordance with your organisation’s records management policy There are other project completion activities that may be required, however they do not relate to project costs and are covered in other learning guides. (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 25 of 41 3. Assessment and demonstration of competency A person who demonstrates competence in this unit must be able to provide evidence that they have taken responsibility for cost management of projects. This will include evidence of managing the work of others within the project team with respect to costs. Evidence presented must meet the performance criteria for each element and demonstrate that you have the required knowledge and understanding and skills and attributes to manage the project costs. 3.1 Developing an evidence portfolio What is an evidence portfolio? An evidence portfolio is a collection of documents and other documentary evidence (such as film or photographs) that show what work you have done and the skills and knowledge you have developed. There are a number of reasons why you might put together an evidence portfolio: So that you can demonstrate competency to a qualified assessor and apply for formal recognition of competency For your own records and as part of your curriculum vitae As a resource to use in your role as a volunteer or in other work As a reference for your own further learning and resource to assist others you may train and mentor What does it look like? What an evidence portfolio looks like depends on both the sort of evidence you are collecting and the purpose for collection. You might start with a box into which you put any documents, photographs, things you have made to be sorted out later. You could use a concertina file or a set of document folders, a ring binder or perhaps (if you are collecting documents in a large format) an art student folio. The most common and flexible format for a portfolio is probably the ring binder containing clear plastic sleeves for holding collected documents and artifacts, as this will enable you to collect and store evidence and then when presenting the portfolio, to write any explanations of what you are presenting. What does an Evidence Portfolio contain and how is it organised? Again this depends on the purpose of the portfolio. When building an evidence portfolio to apply for formal recognition against nationally endorsed units of competency, such as the unit you are studying now, then the documentary evidence you collect should be organised (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 26 of 41 under headings that relate to the elements and performance criteria for the unit of competency. 3.2 Products that can be used as evidence of competency Cost management products that could be used as evidence of competency in this unit include documentation produced in managing project costs such as: cost estimates cost management plans and strategies cost breakdown structures project budgets and expenditure forecasts financial transition plans records of project finalisation activities and disposal of project assets project finalisation reports records of cost management lessons learned 3.3 Processes that can be used as evidence of competency Cost management processes that could be used as evidence of competency in this unit include: how resource requirements were determined how cost management plans were developed how team members were managed throughout projects with respect to the costs of the project how problems and issues with respect to costs were identified and addressed how projects were reviewed with respect to costs how cost management improvements were actioned If you think that you already have some or all of the evidence required as evidence of competency, the following proforma can be used to record your work experience relating to managing project costs. (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 27 of 41 3.4 Record of your work experiences relating to project cost management 3.4.1. On the lines below list and outline any projects in which you have been responsible for managing project costs (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 28 of 41 3.4.2. In the table below record the evidence you can produce to indicate that you have undertaken the activities covered by this section of the Kit. You should identify at least two examples of each one. Work processes Examples of Evidence How resource requirements cost estimates cost breakdown Your list of evidence were determined structures How cost management plans cost estimates cost management plans were developed and strategies project budgets and expenditure forecasts How team members were financial transition plans project budgets and managed throughout projects expenditure forecasts with respect to the costs of the project cost management plans and strategies How problems and issues with respect to costs were identified cost management plans and strategies and addressed How projects were reviewed with respect to costs records of project finalisation activities and disposal of project assets project finalisation reports How cost management improvements were actioned records of cost management lessons learned (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 29 of 41 3.5 Assessment Activities Element 1 Assessment Activity: Estimating Project Costs Develop a project spreadsheet of project costs estimates, using the template provided You will need to follow these steps: 1 List all project activities 2 Assign all required project resources to the appropriate activities including both variable and fixed cost resources. 3 Summarise costs by activity 4 Summarise costs by resource 5 Consider miscellaneous costs such as contingencies, administrative costs, communications etc 6 Consult cost estimates from other similar projects 7 Complete the cost estimate 8 Present you preliminary estimate to an expert colleague as a reality check Demonstrate how you would present this information to stakeholders. In particular, how you would get approval for your budget. Element 2 Assessment Activity: Developing a cost management plan Develop a Cost Management Plan for a project. You may wish to identify the headings for you plan first. Describe the process by which you are going to get approval for your plan. You will also need to demonstrate that you have researched and applied the policies and procedures that are in place including control and audit, reports available from the finance system, financial delegations and procedures for obtaining approval for budget variations. You may wish to refer to the example in this learning guide. Assessment Activity: Monitoring and controlling costs Describe the financial management processes and procedures that by which you are going to monitor expenditure and control costs. Include discussion of how you are going to align financial reporting and controls to other organisational systems. In particular, consider people issues such as job descriptions, delegations, training and performance management. (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 30 of 41 Element 3 Assessment activity: Project Completion Checklist Using information in the Learning Guide BSBPM504A Manage project costs as a model to develop your own project completion checklist for use in your own project. Follow the steps: Step 1 Assembling documentation Assemble the following documentation: Work Breakdown Structure Progress Reports Change requests Any planning documents that established the performance measurement framework Detailed descriptions of the project’s finished product / deliverable Contractor correspondence relating to terms and conditions of performance, contract changes or clarifications Contract changes Contractor payment request and tax invoices Step 2 Inspect to determine completion of (project) phase Measure, examine and test the deliverables to ensure that results conform with requirements. Conduct a procurement audit to identify contractor successes and failures. Step 3 Conduct a project team review Evaluate agreed major milestones (for example phases and sub-contracts); delivery of major deliverables; change of key personnel and finalisation of project and other agreed milestones. The records might include: lists of potential costs invoice and payment summaries budgets, commitment and expenditure cost management plans reports to a higher authority recommended and approved courses of action project and/or organisation files and records Step 4 Obtain formal acceptance Obtain formal acceptance, in writing, that the sponsor has accepted the product of the project (phase). Step 5 Formal acceptance of contractor deliverables Formally write to contractors formally accepting their deliverables Update the contractor files Step 6 Update and archive records Update project records both paper based and electronic. Archive records in acceptance with your organisation’s records management policy (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 31 of 41 Assessment Activity: Project Completion Evaluation Questions that you will need to be able to answer to demonstrate your understanding of reviewing project costs and budget include How was the project budget developed? How accurate were forecasts and estimates? How could this be improved? What procedures and controls were put in place? How effective were they? How did the project perform in relation to budget? Were there variances and how were they managed? Were there any changes to project scope that had cost implications? How were they managed? How were project risks managed and what implication did that have for cost and budget management? How were those issues it managed? If the project were to be run again, how might costs and budgets be developed and controlled differently? Was the Project Sponsor satisfied with the financial reports provided during the project? Was the Project Sponsor satisfied with the financial performance of the project? Would the team’s performance and the project outcomes be improved by any additional training activities in regarding financial management? Some of the cost and budget related questions that might be posed include: What improvements can you suggest that would assist in how future project costs and budgets are established and managed? Were you satisfied with your level of involvement in the project? Were you always kept informed of the project’s successes and failures? What part did you play in the decision making processes? Was the project team appropriately skilled in relation to managing costs and budgets? What additional training may have been helpful? Assessment Activity: Personal and organisational learning Demonstrate: the process that you would undertake to capture personal and organisational learning and a framework for a close out report to your management (including headings and what you would include for each one) (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 32 of 41 4. Resources and reference materials 4.1 Project costs proformas and templates Estimate of project costs Activity WBS Description Code Resources required Duration Resource Resource name & rate name & rate Other costs Total costs by activity Resources Matrix i Activity WBS Code (81919732 Description Amount of Resources required (hours) Contractor A ©NSW DET 2005 Test Lab Statistician Engineering advice Page 33 of 41 Resource Usage Chart Test lab time required Week 1 Task 1 Week 2 10 Task 2 Task 3 20 20 40 20 30 10 30 40 30 80 130 10 20 TOTAL 10 20 Task 4 TOTAL Week 3 Overall project budget : Project Budget for …………………………………………… Cost category Direct Labour Detail Cost Total Project manager: 600 hours @ $45 per hour 27,000 Project team A: 600 hours @ $35 per hour 21,000 Project team B: 200 hours @ $60 per hour 12,000 Indirect costs @ 40% 60,000 24,000 Other Direct costs Materials 3,000 Travel 5,000 Contractors Contingency 17,000 Total 17,000 23,000 TOTAL PROJECT COSTS (81919732 15,000 $124,000 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 34 of 41 Budget Expenditure plan Budget Spending Plan Activity Account Budgeted Budgeted Budgeted (WBS) code January February March (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Budgeted etc Page 35 of 41 Project Budget Format1 Project Budget Format Notes: Column A is the high level work breakdown for the project. It is a good idea to have to have your budget follow the same format as the project schedule's high level work breakdown to ensure that all the costs associated with executing all the project tasks. This column can have another level of indented detail if needed for smaller projects, and will most certainly have more detail for larger projects to ensure an accurate bottom-up costing is accomplished. The non-salary labor column is used to show where contractors are required. The labor columns especially can be driven by an underlying breakdown by person or group of resources. Salary Labor Non-salary labor Material Cost Work breakdown Travel Training Capital Other Totals Phase 1 0 0 0 0 Phase 2 Phase 3 0 Phase 4 0 0 0 TOTALS 1 (81919732 0 0 www.projectconnections.com ©NSW DET 2005 Page 36 of 41 0 0 0 0 4.2 Further references 4.2.1 General references Baker, S. The complete idiot's guide to project management, (2nd edition), Alpha Books, Indianapolis, IN. Davidson, J. P. 2000, 10 minute guide. Project management, Macmillan, Indianapolis, IN. Dobson, M. S. 2002, Streetwise project management: how to manage people, processes, and time to achieve the results you need, Adams Media Corp, Avon, MA. Greer, M. 2002, The project manager’s partner: a step-by-step guide to project management, (2nd edition)American Management Association, New York. Hartley, S. 2003, Project Management A Competency Based Approach, Pearson Education Australia, Sydney Heerkens, G.R. 2002, Project Management, McGraw Hill, New York. Martin, P. 2001, Getting started in project management, Wiley, New York ; Chichester [England]. Portny, S. E. Project Management for Dummies, Wiley Publishing, New York. Wren, A. 2003, The project management A-Z: a compendium of project management techniques and how to use them, Gower. Burlington, VT. Young, T.L., 1999, The Handbook of Project Management: A practical Guide to Effective Policies and Procedures, Kogan Page, London 4.2.2 Web references Australian Computer Society - Project Management Special Interest Group www.acs.org.au/nsw/sigs/index.html Australian Institute of Project Management www.aipm.com.au Gantthead www.gantthead.com The online community for Project Managers. White papers, directories and links Project Management Institute http://www.pmi.org/info/default.asp (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 37 of 41 UK Government, Office of Government Commerce, Successful Delivery Toolkit www.ogc.gov.uk/sdtoolkit/reference/ogc_library/partner_guidance/prog_projmgt/in dex.html www.projectconnections.com : Practical project know-how for people managing projects and teams. Users gain the wisdom of experts and project management professionals in just minutes from extensive collection of how-to bundles, downloadable templates, problem solving guides and references. www.projectmanagement.tas.gov.au : This site is the project management website for the Tasmanian State Government. It contains free information on the Tasmanian Government's project management guidelines, templates, fact sheets, faqs, glossary and knowledge base. Project management is a formalised and structured method of managing change, and this website provides information and tools all project managers, project officers and committee members may required to effectively manage or participate in a project." www.projectsmart.co.uk Project Smart is the Internet based project management resource that helps managers at all levels to improve their performance. This site provides an important knowledge base for those involved in managing projects of all kinds. With regular updates, it keeps you in touch with the latest project management thinking. (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 38 of 41 4.3 Key terms in Cost Management The introduction to this Kit of materials contains a comprehensive glossary. Particular terms that relate to cost management are provided below: Accepted The recorded decision or formal sign off by the customer, that an output or sub-output has satisfied the documented requirements and may be delivered to the customer or used in the next part of the process. Accountable business Provides the business rationale for undertaking the project, showing case that it represents value for money. Action Plan A plan that describes what needs to be done and when it needs to be completed. Project plans are action plants. Activity network A diagram that shows the workflow, milestones and task interrelationships of a project. Analogous estimating top down” estimating which involves using the actual costs of a previous similar project to make an estimate for a planned project Assumptions Factors related to a project that affect the environment within which a project is being implemented and which are taken as being true or correct for the project to be successful. Authorised The recorded decision that a deliverable or output has been cleared for use or action after having satisfied the quality standards for the project. Baseline Plan The initial approved plan to which deviations will be compared as the project proceeds. Bottom up estimating estimating the cost of individual activities and rolling these up to determine project costs Close out Tasks involved in closing down a project, including dealing with staffing matters, redistributing project infrastructure, debriefing the project team and others and celebrating achievements. (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 39 of 41 Constraints Factors or things that may impact on a project in some way, usually in terms of limiting or prescribing its direction or development. Consultant An organisation or individual contracted to provide high-level specialist or professional advice to assist decision-making by agency management. The consultant will be expected to exercise his/her own skills and judgement independently of the agency. Consultation Systems set up to facilitate communication between project mechanisms stakeholders. Contract A mutually binding agreement which obligates one or more parties to provide goods or services in exchange for payment from one or more separate parties. Fixed budget taking the total amount of money available to the project and dividing estimating it across project components to ascertain what you can and can’t afford Project budget A detailed, time phased estimate of all the costs of resources required for your project Time phased budget (81919732 A budget in which cost estimates are broken down by time periods ©NSW DET 2005 Page 40 of 41 Appendix 1 BSBPM504A Manage project costs (81919732 ©NSW DET 2005 Page 41 of 41
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz