Housing First in Europe – Matrix January 2012 Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] Table of Contents Section 1 - National Framework of Homelessness and Housing Policies ....................................... 3 1.1 1.2 Global Context regarding Homelessness ..................................................................... 3 1.1.1 Institutional context of homelessness policy ................................................... 3 1.1.2 Service providers and stakeholders ................................................................. 3 1.1.3 Financing .......................................................................................................... 4 1.1.4 Housing Services for the Public ........................................................................ 4 Housing Policy .............................................................................................................. 5 Section 2 - Housing First Strategy................................................................................................ 6 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 Global Context regarding Homelessness ..................................................................... 6 2.1.1 Institutional context of homelessness policy ................................................... 6 Principles ...................................................................................................................... 6 Link between Homelessness Services and Housing First Project ................................ 6 Housing First Project Content ...................................................................................... 7 2.4.1 Governance ...................................................................................................... 7 2.4.2 Financing .......................................................................................................... 8 2.4.3 Homeless People that Benefit from the Project/Service Users ....................... 8 2.4.4 Eligibility ........................................................................................................... 9 Section 3 - Missions/Services .................................................................................................... 10 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 Social Care .................................................................................................................. 10 Health Care................................................................................................................. 10 Employment Support ................................................................................................. 10 Food Aid ..................................................................................................................... 10 Financial Aid for rent etc. ........................................................................................... 11 Funding of Services .................................................................................................... 11 Section 4 - Social Support ......................................................................................................... 12 Section 5 - Housing Allocation .................................................................................................. 14 Section 6 - Perspective ............................................................................................................. 15 Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 2 Section 1 - National Framework of Homelessness and Housing Policies 1.1 Global Context regarding Homelessness 1.1.1 Institutional context of homelessness policy Local authorities have a duty to homeless households in their area as outlined in legislation passed at a national level. There are strong links between homelessness policy and other public policies in Scotland, particularly in relation to the prevention of homelessness. Examples of this cross sector approach can be found in the work of the Supported Accommodation Implementation Group and in the work to ensure the implementation of Health and Homelessness Standards across Health Boards. 1.1.2 Service providers and stakeholders In Glasgow there is a 24 hour statutory casework function provided by Glasgow City Council and delivered through 5 Community Casework Teams and the Hamish Allan Centre. Emergency accommodation ranges from Bed and Breakfast, hostels, self-contained flats through both socially rented housing sector and the Private Rented Sector. Temporary accommodation ranges from temporary furnished flats to supported accommodation (e.g. for young people, addictions, mental health, domestic abuse etc.) Outreach support services are provided to help people maintain tenancies following a period of homelessness. There is a specific outreach support service working with people who are currently, or are at risk of, sleeping rough. In addition for example Turning Point Scotland’s Link Up Service provides a crisis service – including residential – for rough sleepers or those who are homeless Glasgow has a specialist health centre where homeless people can access a full range of medical care. There are 3 day centres through religious organisations providing food, activities, support. There are a number of independent agencies delivering advice and information on legal rights. A number of statutory services are provided by the local authority in Glasgow. Many accommodation and support services are provided by NGO’s including Turning Point Scotland The local health board provides services to people affected by homelessness In Glasgow in 2010-11 the average length of time in temporary accommodation was 22 weeks (down from 24 weeks in 2009-10) Access to permanent housing is provided by the statutory casework service. Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 3 1.1.3 Financing Funding is provided from a mixture of national, state, regional city and private sources. Since the establishment of a Concordat between Central and Local Government and the subsequent Local Government Settlement in 2007, local authorities have been allocated a budget from central government without ring fencing for homelessness services, allowing greater freedom to make local funding decisions in light of local circumstances while working to high level outcomes and fulfilling their legislative duties. The Scottish Government also funds national homelessness service providers through funding initiatives such as the Housing Voluntary Grant Scheme. 1.1.4 Housing Services for the Public Definitions are outlined in legislation. Part II of the Housing (Scotland) Act 1987 (as amended by the 2001 and 2003 Acts) sets out the powers and duties of local authorities in dealing with applications from people seeking help on the grounds that they are homeless or threatened with homelessness. It is important to note that in Scotland homelessness is defined as more than ‘rooflessness’ or rough sleeping. Statistics are collected by local authorities and published by the Scottish Government. There were an estimated 55,227 applications to local authorities under the Homeless Persons legislation in 2010-11, a decrease of 3.3 per cent compared to the 57,122 applications during 2009-10. In 2010-11, 41,553 applications were assessed as homeless in Scotland, a decrease of 1,929 (4.4 per cent) since 2009-10. Statistics for 2010/11 were published in August 2011 http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2011/08/30083716/0 Support needs and the causes for homelessness are recorded by local authorities in the statistics highlighted above, which can be used to outline local homelessness profiles and inform local approaches to tackling and preventing homelessness. Young people (16-24) have been identified by policy makers as being over represented in homelessness figures and relationship breakdown (family or friends unwilling to accommodate) the main reason for homelessness applications to local authorities. This has been one of the factors in promoting the Housing Options approach through five regional local authority hubs which focuses on the prevention of homelessness through looking at an individual’s housing options in the broadest sense when they approach a local authority as homeless. This can include not just a choice of housing tenure but issues such as employability, need for mediation services etc. In 2000- 01, around 45,000 applied as homeless and 33,000 were assessed as being so. In 2010-11, this was around 55,000 and 41,000 respectively. Given the 2012 commitment (see the first answer in Housing Policy below) a higher proportion were assessed as priority need and therefore entitled to settled accommodation. Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 4 1.2 Housing Policy The 2012 homelessness commitment as established by the Homelessness Etc (Scotland) Act of 2003 states that local authorities should assess all homeless applicants as priority by 31st December 2012. Applicants assessed as priority have a right to settled accommodation as currently ‘non priority’ applicants only have a right to temporary accommodation and advice and assistance. Across Scotland, the proportion of homeless assessed as priority increased to 88 per cent (an increase of two percentage points) during 2010-11. More broadly than homelessness, those over 16 can join a social housing waiting list. The Scottish Government has pledged to building 30,000 affordable homes over the course of the current Parliament including the first programme of council house building for a number of years. There are specific Social Housing Policies and funding streams Detail can be found at the Scottish Government web-site noted below http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Topics/Built-Environment/Housing/16342 The social housing providers are the local authorities and registered social landlords/ housing associations. Local authorities make decisions on allocations based on local circumstances with guidance provided by the Scottish Government. Where a local authority has a duty to secure the provision of accommodation for an applicant in priority need, a Registered Social Landlord in its area must, within a reasonable period, comply with an authority's request to provide this accommodation unless it has a good reason for not doing so (section 5 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001). Housing Benefit. While administered locally, welfare policy including that on housing benefit is made by the UK Government at Westminster. Scottish Government Ministers have made a number of representations to UK Ministers noting their concern about proposed welfare reform and its potential impact on homelessness in Scotland. During the quarter ending March 31, 2011, a total of 5,768 notifications of households at risk of homelessness due to eviction were received by local authorities under section 11 of the Homelessness etc. (Scotland) Act 2003. Section 11 allows landlords to give an early indication to local authorities of intention to evict to allow interventions to be made. Both local authorities and many housing associations across Scotland work with homeless service providers to provide support at a local level. Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 5 Section 2 - Housing First Strategy 2.1 Global Context regarding Homelessness 2.1.1 Institutional context of homelessness policy Approaches in Glasgow Housing First – The Glasgow Housing First pilot is directed at those who are homeless and still using substances. Whilst initially referrals were for homeless individuals using drugs more recently the referral system has been widened to include those whose substance of misuse is alcohol. It is the only such service within Scotland is currently being implemented at a local level. Date of Implementation The first Housing First tenant moved into his accommodation in February 2011. Staff recruitment, induction and training took place from October 2010 2.2 Principles The Glasgow Housing First pilot aims to reduce re-occurring homelessness by supporting individuals who are still in active addiction. It follows the philosophy and principles of the American model – 2.3 independent accommodation no requirement regarding housing readiness harm reduction approach provision of permanent tenancy in individual’s name in self contained/scattered social housing with full tenancy rights, rent contract and unlimited lease Holistic support through 24/7 – multidisciplinary team available 7 days per week from 8 a.m. until 8 p.m. thereafter telephone contact/on-call system. Respect for service user choice re: location of apartment, levels of engagement and times of support Service targeted at the most vulnerable – those that have had difficulty coping with traditional service and/or resistant to service engagement Link between Homelessness Services and Housing First Project Glasgow City Council carried out a review of its former large single person hostels and as a consequence was able to close all male hostels (the one female hostel is currently in the process of being replaced). The 3 large scale male hostels (totaling just over 700 bed spaces) which formed part of the closure and reprovisioning programme were closed between 2005 and 2008: Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 6 Broad Street closed early in 2005, Peter McCann closed in July 2006 and Bell Street closed in March 2008. Among the resources replacing them were commissioned: 620 new supported accommodation places (e.g. SAMH Community Directions, Quarriers What If, Turning Point Scotland’s Moving On , Loretto Fordneuk Street (this service for individual’s with an alcohol dependency will permit harm reduced continuing drinking and is referred to in Professor Fitzpatrick research report) Gowrie’s Queen Mary Avenue and others 100 new emergency accommodation places through Aspire (Hillhead Street, Queen Margaret Drive, Copland Road), Turning Points Scotland’s Garscube House – a residential alcohol rehabilitation service and others. 1200 new temporary furnished flats through Glasgow Housing Association (taking the total to approximately 1800); and 24 new floating support services providing support to 4100 households in their own accommodation (e.g. Loretto, Gowrie, Aspire, SAMH, and Addaction among others). Whilst in the strictest sense there was no opposition from the shelters – since none exist – the first year was a struggle with Glasgow City Council Social Services/Homelessness Services to both understand and accept that the Housing First model had anything to offer in the Scotland/Glasgow context. Views expressed included ‘we’re already doing services like this’, ‘we don’t need ideas from America’, ‘our state benefits and social housing systems are sound and therefore there is no need for such in Scotland’. In addition they had difficulty understanding the justifiably slow pace of developing the Housing First pilot and appeared to give no cognisance of the need to not only bring housing associations/registered landlords on board but then involve such agencies in the assessment/implementation processes. More recently Glasgow City Council Social Services have indicated a changing view on the development of Housing First as one model of housing support services. A continuing dialogue is now taking place with senior officers in their Homelessness Services. 2.4 Housing First Project Content 2.4.1 Governance The Glasgow Housing First project is being piloted by Turning Point Scotland an N.G.O. and it is also responsible for the operational management of the service, The Housing First Service is currently in one city. In addition to the normal management arrangements for the Project, Turning Point Scotland created a Housing First Advisory Group. Chaired by an independent consultant with a career in homelessness and health responses to homeless people, the Group comprises stakeholders – Scottish Government Homelessness services officer, Glasgow City Council, Glasgow Housing Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 7 Association, Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board Strathclyde Police and a Turning Point Scotland Board member and an Operational Manager from Turning Point Scotland. Its remit includes:- 2.4.2 focussing on the strategic direction of the evolving Housing First service, overview of the 3 year longitudinal research being carried out by Heriot-Watt University being aware of other likely research links through FEANTSA and FNARS an overview of links developing with other Housing First services in other European countries support for the development of strategic level partnerships with the Scottish Government, the National Health Service, relevant local authorities and housing agencies seek to influence and inform Scottish and European homelessness policies through the promotion of Housing First and links established with FEANTSA and FNARS. Financing The Glasgow Housing First pilot is funded from Turning Point Scotland reserves. Funding for a part-time Occupational Therapist’s post comes from Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board and 1 years funding came from the Big Lottery Fund. There was no competitive tendering as the Pilot Project grew from an initiative and commitments from within Turning Point Scotland. Working relationships are maintained by Turning Point Scotland with a range of other stakeholders and services responding to the needs of homeless individuals. 2.4.3 Homeless People that Benefit from the Project/Service Users Currently the service does not target all the typologies of homeless people and was created to develop services for those still using substances. Whilst initially that was for drug users, in the past 6 months the target group has been expanded to include those who misuse alcohol. (In real terms individuals rarely have only one issue and concern. Therefore as the Housing Pilot service continues to grow and to ensure the provision of holistic support from a services network we will require broadening the target to all typologies of homeless people including families). Those who are assessed as potentially suitable for the service require to be registered as homeless with the local authority of Glasgow. We do not view Housing First as suitable for all individuals but as being one of a range of housing support services. In the first 10 months of the 69 individuals referred 26 individuals have been assessed as suitable for Housing First. Of these 19 are currently working with Glasgow Housing First and 7 are in the assessment stage. Of the 43 referrals found not suitable there was a range of reasons – no illicit drug/substance misuse, looking for supported accommodation not independent support, a requirement for personal care and daily support Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 8 needed, no live homelessness application. 12 referrals were withdrawn by the referrer – reasons included resettled in other accommodation, no interest in the localities in which Housing First works or given a substantial prison sentence. 6 were suspended at the referrer’s request or requiring new assessment. 2.4.4 Eligibility Individuals can be referred to Housing First from a number of sources such as the Community Addiction Teams, Glasgow Street Service, Homeless Accommodation, Persistent Offenders Projects, Community/ Prison Casework Teams. Prior to the project accepting referrals the team met with many services in Glasgow working with homeless individuals who continue to use substances to raise awareness about Housing First, its ethos, project description and entry to service criteria. Members of Housing First staff also spoke to individuals who were rough sleeping/ begging about the service and encouraged them to speak with the Glasgow Street Service should they have an interest in being referred. The entry criteria for Housing First is as follows: individual aged 18+, homeless (as defined by statutory agencies), current services do not meet individual’s need, current drug and/ or alcohol use, looking to sustain a tenancy. When referrals are received they are discussed by an Allocation Group consisting of Housing First Service Manager, Housing First Service Coordinator, Occupational Therapist and a representative from North Casework Team. From there a decision is made whether the individual will be assessed and when assessed whether they will be accepted into the service. When the individual is accepted into the service, the support they receive is holistic and person centred and is not tied to the tenancy. If an individual was unable to stay in a tenancy, then the Housing First staff team would support that individual to find a new tenancy and continue to provide support. Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 9 Section 3 - Missions/Services 3.1 Social Care Social care services are well developed both within Scotland as a whole and particularly within Glasgow. Example of these services are: Community/Homeless Addiction Teams, Community Casework Teams, Regeneration Agencies, Persistent Offenders Project, Scottish Association of Mental Health, Phoenix Futures – Rehabilitation and day services, City Mission/Marie Trust/Lodging House Day Services , Supported Accommodation: such as the Simon Community, Glasgow Street Service, Move On – homelessness and employability, needle exchanges, safe haven, 3.2 Health Care The United Kingdom has a National Health Service available to all citizens. In addition Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board some years ago developed a comprehensive Homelessness Health and Resources service and this is well used by those who are homeless. It has built up close working links with a number of NGOs including Turning Point Scotland. 3.3 Employment Support Our experiences suggest that as individuals move from either homelessness or rough sleeping into Housing First their first stage of ‘employability’ is undertaking meaningful activities as they begin to adjust to a structure for their lives. For many this may well represent the first time in years (or ever) where they have had such an opportunity. Some have never been in employment and therefore for them simply beginning by ensuring they generate meaningful activity is a crucial stage in their recovery journey. The reality is that in the current national financial situation, unemployment numbers have increased and finding employment is difficult. The British Government has developed a number of national employment initiatives.. In addition Turning Point Scotland has developed links with the Wise Group on local possible initiatives. Many of those for whom Housing First is a likely support resource will have opted out of the formal education system in their early teens. Therefore for them their recovery journey is likely to include their re-engaging with education, for some initially at least through ‘taster’ courses often held in the local community or further education college. We view engagement within their neighbourhood/community as important aspects of their establishing networks and such as consistencies with the work of Project Renewal in New York and the development of Recovery Communities. 3.4 Food Aid This is not an available resource within Glasgow other than those homeless individuals/roughsleepers will use the 3 ‘Mission’ day centres in the City and be provided with food at them. Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 10 3.5 Financial Aid for rent etc. The state benefit system within the United Kingdom includes a factor known as Housing Benefit. This is made available from Central Government through Local Authorities to individuals needing support to meet the costs of the rent and an element of the Council Tax for their house. There is currently a capacity for the rent aspect to be paid directly from Housing Benefit to the landlord. This does secure the property for that individual. Currently a review of Benefits being undertaken is recommending the removal of that factor resulting perhaps in future problems. The purchase of furniture is one of the major difficulties being experienced by potential tenants. Central Government Benefits include a factor termed Community Care Grant which people can apply for when being allocated a house. Unfortunately the process can take some 6 weeks or more and the numbers having a successful application have reduced considerably. Our belief is that by the provision of funding support for furnishings the individual can confidently feel that they have made ‘this house their home’. By not receiving such funding the individual may struggle to feel that this house is now their home. 3.6 Funding of Services As can be evidenced from the above paragraphs 2.4.2 and 3.5 funding of the service comes from a number of levels – central government, local government and in terms specifically of the Housing First Service, from charitable resources. Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 11 Section 4 - Social Support The Housing First staff team consists of part-time hours from a Turning Point Scotland Service Manager, 1 Service Coordinator, 2 Senior Practitioners, 4 Peer Support Workers and part time hours from an Occupational Therapist provided by Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board. During the development of the Housing First Service a number of meetings were held with key stakeholders of the service including community casework teams, community addiction teams, occupational therapy and housing associations in order to develop a method of best practice when working together to maximise communication and ensure effective support is delivered to each service user. Skills within the Team and its partners – Community Addiction Teams Community Casework Teams and Housing Officers – will include housing support, addiction support, issues relating to homelessness and mental health, The Housing First staff in addition to the above will also provide emotional support, signposting, peer support, (health care is provided by the occupational therapist), assertive outreach, motivational interviewing, The staff will engage with chaotic individuals who typically do not engage with services, and may never have considered harm reduction and have little or no overdose awareness. The service is provided 24 hours/7 days per week with staff available each day from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. From the hours of 8 p.m. to 8 a.m. service users have access to telephone support provided by Turning Point Scotland service and, if required by an ‘on-call system’. Thus on a day to day basis the service user will be supported by the staff team on rota but in addition will have assigned two named workers and a support coordinator (senior practitioner). The team will arrange regular reviews at not less than three monthly intervals with the service user and all the professionals involved in the individuals support. The Housing First staff team will also regularly keep in touch with the service user’s Care Manager and Housing Officer (due to the circumstances of some of the service users referred to Housing First not all of them will have a Care Manager). Whilst the support offered to the individual is not compulsory, during the assessment process (which can take up to 6 weeks) it is expected that the individual will show a motivation to work with the service and that they desire support to maintain a tenancy. The service user group which Housing First targets are those who typically do not engage with services and who are still actively using substances therefore it can be expected that engagement may be poor from time to time. The amount of times a service user is seen per week and the location of the visit is determined by that individual, however staff will also deliver assertive outreach if there is an increased risk (for example increased substance misuse, poor mental health and non-engagement). When engagement with the service is low the team will try to engage through assertive outreach and try to meet up with individuals in places they are known to attend, for example: community addiction teams, pharmacies, begging sites to name a few. Non engagement with the service will not result in the individual being discharged from the service. Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 12 During this time we will also keep in touch with any others involved in their support to ensure the safety of the individual (i.e. the addiction worker can check if the individual has been collecting their methadone). It is our experience that those service users who typically do not engage often will always contact Housing First by phone or drop into the office when a crisis does arise. The support is not time limited and is offered on a flexible basis responding to that individual’s recovery milestones and other factors in their life. The support is more often than not on a one to one basis and can take place in any location however generally is in the individual’s tenancy or for planned visits to colleges, regeneration agencies, support groups etc. Social isolation is recognised as a barrier to on-going recovery. Housing First attempts to support individuals with this by encouraging and sign posting to services in their local community and will also support the individual to orientate to their local area (nearest supermarket, post office, doctors surgery etc). The team will use their training in motivational interviewing skills as well as peer experience to discuss future short/ mid and long term goals and develop support plans with the individuals in order to achieve these (including social functioning). Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 13 Section 5 - Housing Allocation Within Scotland social housing stock has been traditionally developed through Local Councils with, from the 1980s, an increasing development of registered social landlords through housing associations. In the late 1990s Glasgow City Council passed all of their council housing over to new Registered Social Landlord, Glasgow Housing Association and a second phase of that process has seen some of that housing stock pass to local registered social landlords/housing associations. Both Glasgow Housing Association and a locally based R.S.L – Queens Cross Housing Association – have been in a close working relationship with Turning Point Scotland to create the Housing First Pilot and the first 10 houses for the service came from these landlords. More recently 2 further R.S.L’s – Southside Housing Association and Thenew Housing Association have come on board to develop partnerships with Turning Point Scotland and offer permanent tenancies to individuals coming into Housing First project. There is no one post within Housing First to find housing for the Project. Rather negotiations take place between Turning Point Scotland and individual or group meetings of housing associations to acquire appropriate accommodation. Within Scottish Government legislation (see above Section 2) there is a requirement for accommodation to be made available for homeless people and social landlords are bound to respond to what is known as a Section 5 referral Given the legislative framework, there are no financial inducements or tax reductions necessary to encourage housing providers to allocate accommodation. Tenancies in Scotland are given with either Short Assured Tenancy or Permanent Tenancy agreement. Given that we believe a key component of Housing First from New York is that individuals are given permanent accommodation we felt that such would be an essential aspect of the Glasgow Housing First service. In early negotiations with the Registered Social Landlords we all agreed that the service should be in individual scattered flats not in collective buildings. Initially they were all in the North West of Glasgow. More recently through the inclusion of Southside and Thenew Housing Associations the flats are scattered throughout Glasgow. The accommodation is not provided with furniture and in paragraph 3.5 above we share some of the problems that can create for people with homelessness background. The solvency of the people is not an issue and we provide some explanation again in paragraph 3.5 above. As indicated earlier within this Section, the Housing Associations provide the individual with a Permanent Tenancy Agreement which gives them the same rights as any tenant with a similar tenancy agreement. The lease is signed by that individual service user and their stay is permanent unless, like any other tenant they breach the conditions of that tenancy agreement. If such occurs the landlord is required to take legal proceedings and the issue would be decided within the formal Court setting. Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 14 Section 6 - Perspective The Housing First Glasgow pilot project Turning Point Scotland has funded to be be evaluated by Professor Suzanne Fitzpatrick and Dr Sarah Johnsen of Heriott Watt University, School of the Built Environment The methodology of the evaluation includes: literature review, stakeholder interviews and longitudinal study of service user outcomes. The evaluation commenced on 5th July 2010 with an interim report expected by June 2012 and final report to be submitted in 2013. The anticipated successful conditions of the Glasgow Housing First service reflect that from the USA and Canada namely that the vast majority of individuals remain in their tenancy and sense achievement of their targets in their recovery journey and an overall improvement in their perceived quality of life. Both our own experiences and the knowledge we have gained both from contacts with other Housing First services both in USA and Europe and from our research would suggest that Housing First will not be appropriate support for all homeless people; Housing First provides a sound housing support model. We believe that that it could be developed in response to wider than single homeless individuals e.g. homeless families (as per Vienna and Loa Angeles) but also as a strategy and methodology to prevent homelessness. Due to knowledge of the service being as yet generally limited to those professionals working in the field of addiction/ homelessness and civil servants/ politicians public opinion has not been expressed. Nevertheless the feedback regarding the model/ service during conferences and networking has been positive. Turning Point Scotland 54 Govan Road Glasgow, G51 1JL Email: [email protected] 15
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz