+
TBay & OCUL Weeding
Surveys
Summary of 2009 and 2010 OCUL Member
Survey Findings
School Participating
2009
2010
Participation
Trent
yes
no
yes
no
McMaster
yes
yes
Brock
yes
yes
Toronto
Yes (UTM and UTL)
no
UOIT
yes
yes
Western
yes
yes
RMC
yes
no
OCAD
yes
Windsor
yes
yes
Queens
yes
yes
York
yes
yes
Lakehead
no
yes
Laurier
no
yes
Laurentian
no
yes
Nipissing
no
yes
Waterloo
no
yes
Ryerson
+
yes
Weeding Activities Reported 2009 vs. 2010 2010
School
09 weeding
10 weeding
Brock
Weeded
Plans to weed
OCAD
No plans to weed
No plans to weed
Lakehead
No plans to weed
Laurentian
Plans to weed
Laurier
Plans to weed*
McMaster
Weeded
Weeded
Nippissing
Weeded
+
Queens
No plans to weed
RMC
Weeded
Ryerson
Weeded
Trent
Weeded
U of T
No plans to weed
U of T Mississauga
No plans to weed
UOIT
Weeded
Waterloo
Plans to weed
No plans to weed
Weeded
Western
No plans to weed
No plans to weed
Windsor
Plans to weed
Plans to weed
York
Weeded
Weeded
# Schools Weeded by Publisher
+
Publishers Weeded By School
School
Products Weeded
Brock
Academic Press, Cambridge, Elsevier, JSTOR, Oxford University Press, Royal Society of
Chemistry, Sage, Springer, Wiley Blackwell
Laurentian
Academic Press, American Chemical Society, American Mathematical Association,
Berkeley Electronic Press, Cambridge, Elsevier, Emerald, JSTOR, Kluwer, Oxford
University Press, PAO, Project Muse, Royal Society of Chemistry, Sage, Springer, Taylor &
Francis, Wiley Blackwell
McMaster
Annual Reviews, Elsevier, Institute of Physics, JSTOR, NRC, Oxford University Press, PAO,
Sage, Springer, Wiley Blackwell
Nippissing
JSTOR
RMC
American Chemical Society, Elsevier, Institute of Physics, Kluwer, Royal Society of
Chemistry, Springer
Ryerson
Cambridge, Elsevier, JSTOR, Oxford University Press, Wiley Blackwell
Trent
American Chemical Society, Institute of Physics, JSTOR, Oxford University Press, Royal
Society of Chemistry, Wiley Blackwell
UOIT
American Chemical Society, American Mathematical Association, Elsevier, Royal Society
of Chemistry
Waterloo
Cambridge, Elsevier, Kluwer, Oxford University Press, Project Muse, Royal Society of
Chemistry
York
Academic Press, American Chemical Society, American Institute of Physics, Cambridge,
Elsevier, Institute of Physics, JSTOR, Kluwer, Oxford University Press, PAO, Royal Society
of Chemistry, Sage, Springer, Taylor & Francis, Wiley Blackwell
+
Weeding By Publisher
Titles
Schools That Have Weeded
Academic Press
Brock, Laurentian, York
American Chemical Society
Laurentian, RMC, Trent, UOIT, York
American Institute of Physics
York
American Mathematical Association
Laurentian, UOIT
Berkley Electronic Press
Laurentian
Cambridge
Brock, Laurentian, Ryerson, Waterloo, York
Elsevier
Brock, Laurentian, RMC, Ryerson, UOIT, Waterloo, York
Emerald
Laurentian
Institute of Physics
McMaster, RMC, Trent, York
JSTOR
Brock, Laurentian, McMaster, Nippissing, Ryerson, Trent, York
Kluwer
Laurentian, RMC, Waterloo, York
Oxford University Press
Brock, Laurentian, McMaster, Trent, Waterloo, York
PAO
Laurentian, McMaster, York
Project Muse
Laurentian, Waterloo
Royal Society of Chemistry
Brock, Laurentian, RMC, Trent, UOIT, Waterloo, York
Sage
Brock, Laurentian, McMaster, York
Springer
Brock, Laurentian, McMaster, RMC, York
Taylor & Francis
Laurentian, York
Wiley Blackwell
Brock, Laurentian, McMaster, Ryerson, Trent, York
+
Publishers Weeded by School
Titles
Academic Press
B

L
M
N
RM
C
R
T
UOI
T
W

Y

B = Brock
American Chemical Society





L = Laurentian
M = McMaster
American Institute of Physics



N = Nippissing
R = Ryerson
American Mathematical
Association
+

T = Trent

W = Waterloo
Y = York
Berkley Electronic Press

Cambridge


Elsevier


Emerald










2010 Reponses to Questions on Last Copies

Do you intend to …
 …weed down to one copy? 2 libraries answered yes
 …retain a print copy if your location has the 2nd (or 3rd, or more) copy in
Ontario? 5 libraries answered yes

Out of the 5 libraries that intend retain a print copy,
 0 will do so at the package level
 4 will do so at the title level
 1 will use a mixture of both

How are you currently deciding whether
+ you have the last print copy?
Generalized Responses
Response Count
Checking against all OCUL members holdings.
3
Checking against some OCUL members’ holdings.
3
Not currently checking.
2
If it is part of perpetual access only.
1
ISSN list from the vendor used to create a Cognos report of holdings that is
manually compared to identify long runs that will be designated as the last
print copy holder.
1
Total # of Responses
10