Virtual World Asset Management

Virtual World Asset Management – The Journey So Far
NIA SPEN 0002
VWAM Project Introduction
Virtual World Asset
Management
Key Outputs Year 1
Updated Benefits Case
Year 2 Programme
Integrating VWAM into existing corporate
systems & policies
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
Virtual World Asset Management - Introduction
Project Funded
by NIA
LCNI 2016
Virtual World Asset Management - Introduction
 Register April 2015 and expected to last 34 months
 ~ £3.5M
 Primary objective is to quantify the benefits of using VWAM
compared to conventional programmes
 Key aim is to reduce costs and improve network resilience
through the development of 3D virtual Model.
(Network Innovation Allowance)
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
Developed by Ergon Energy to capture and efficiently process the
OHL network across its Australian Distribution Network
Raw
Data
 ~30% of network
 2 x Data Capture (2015
& 2016)
Original aim to deliver a Virtual World
of North Wales and Dumfries
districts OHL network
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
ROAMES – Remote Observation - Automated Modelling - Economic Solution
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 1 Key Outputs
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 1 Key Challenges
Prove ROAMES OHL Capture
Completeness
Asset Matching
Accuracy
Identification of New Asset Information
Identification of Areas for Improvement
Identification of Benefits Case for BaU Adoption
Year 2
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
1
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 1 Key Outputs
Good accuracy of network
modelled for higher voltages
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 1 Key Outputs
Less accurate
at lower voltages
132kV
33kV
11kV
LV Main
LV Service
SPEN (km)
643
1,211
8,241
2,511
979
ROAMES (km)
649
1,211
8,278
2,459
257
Accuracy
~100%
~100%
~100%
~98%
~26%
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
 Pole location verified using Camera Imagery layer
 ‘H’ and ‘Steel Tower’ poles counted as two separate
assets
 Errors in pole location with internal records
 Different network topography
 Improved QA process required
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
Virtual World Asset Management – ROAMES
VWAM LiDAR
 High accuracy for Higher
Voltages
 Low accuracy for LV
Services
 High confidence in the ability
to model network
High confidence in the overall accuracy of VWAM
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 1 Key Outputs
SP Energy Networks
 OHL Network is in good
shape – low levels of defects
identified
 Internal GIS pole locations
 Improved QA process
required
 Several benefits identified
Conclusion from Year 1
 Errors in LiDAR data which
need to be improved to
allow for BaU adoption
 Improved QA process
required
 Currently not an option for
the 100% detection of LV
Service Wire
Vegetation Management
 Intrusions linked to SPEN data
 Categorised intrusions
 ETR 132
 Data easy to interrogate
Year 1 Findings
 100+ raster layers in Google Earth
 Easy and simple to use
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
Spans with Vegetation
Clear Spans
40% ~ 5m
15% ~ 3m
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
LCNI 2016
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 1 Key Outputs
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 1 Key Outputs
Dumfries
LCNI 2016
Can LiDAR be used for to predict when vegetation management is required?
North Wales
Spans with Vegetation
LiDAR
Clear Spans
70% ~ 5m
17% ~ 3m
LCNI 2016





Detailed and accurate 3D model
Vegetation intrusions
Audit tool
Safety issues highlighted
Multiple flights ay be required




Reviewed past learning
Internal knowledge
Alternative contracts investigated
Annual growth will not always
reduce clearance
SPEN
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
Year 1
Year 2

Year 3
Year 4

LCNI 2016
2
Virtual World Asset Management – Vegetation Management
VWAM LiDAR



High levels of accuracy
detecting intrusions
Analytic spreadsheets
provide fast and effective
way to audit circuits
High confidence in the ability
to model and visually show
intrusions
SP Energy Networks



Vegetation impact the
networks to a greater extent
in SPM
Cost per SPAN contract
rates is unlikely to achieve
savings and may lead to
increased cost
Effective audit tool
Year 1 Findings
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 1 Key Outputs
ESQCR Programmes
Conclusion from Year 1




Limited benefit pursuing
growth rates in the context of
this project
VWAM unlikely to determine
tree species or localised
factors
Will not remove the need to
complete onsite survey
Unlikely that Growth Rates will
be determined in the short
term
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
 Identification of safety issues
 Pole lean link to SPEN assets
 Low Ground Clearance
 Road Crossings
 Data easy to interrogate
 Resources sent to site with tools
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
LCNI 2016
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 1 Key Outputs
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 1 Key Outputs
Line
Heightsmeasures ground clearance
Accurately
VWAM Examples Data
Network in general performing well
Botwnnog Primary, MW 83601
Will not be able to completely replace manual ESQCR inspections
Line Heights / Pole Lean









Linked to SPEN ID Reference
Easy to identify in analytics
Easy to verify in Google Earth
Leaning Poles
Attachment heights
Safety issues highlighted
Road or critical crossing heights
Single Point in time survey
Network conditions
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
Poorly performing circuit
with multiple transient
faults recorded during
first half of year
LCNI 2016
Virtual World Asset Management – ESQCR Programmes
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
Virtual World Asset Management – Benefits Case
VWAM LiDAR




Provides a detailed and accurate ‘network MOT’
Will not replace manual inspections
High confidence in measurement reported
Will provides greater knowledge on how assets change over time
Soft Benefits
 Operations
 Connections
 Wayleaves
 Vegetation Management
SP Energy Networks



Single point in time survey
Important to ensure internal policy are in place to mitigate volume of
data
Network is generally in a good shape
Conclusion from Year 1




Improved QA process required to removed LiDAR errors
Improvements in LV Service Wires required to identify all network issues
Further improvement required for automatic road crossing heights
Future proposed developments will enhance the solution
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
Year 1
Findings
LCNI 2016
Hard Benefits
 Improved Fault Performance
 Inspection Policy
Annual Biennial 3 year
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
4 year
6 year
8 year
LCNI 2016
3
Virtual World Asset Management – Benefits Case
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 2 Variation
Why?
Proposed Flight Plan
•
•
•
•
 3 year cycle covering equal
network length
Growth rates
Requirement to collect 100% asset base from one flight
Limited additional learning
Regional network topography difference
What Changed?
•
•
•
 Line Heights
 Vegetation and Construction
work audit
 Connections
 Improved data and location
accuracy
 Work prioritisation
Flying different areas of similar size
Using different flight patterns and improved QA process
Networks coverage rather than districts
What’s the aim?
•
•
•
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
Expected improvements

www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
Virtual World Asset Management
Virtual World Asset Management – Year 2




To validate the changes and determine whether it will be possible to gather 100%
network coverage
Establish whether VWAM can cope with varying network topography
Spread learning across multiple work centres to ensure business buy in and
smoother integration into BaU
For further information please contact
Improve conductor capture
Improve pole matching
H poles
Poles on wrong side of road or
boundary
ETR132 compliance – model and
heat map of circuits
[email protected]
LCNI 2016
www.spenergynetworks.co.uk
LCNI 2016
4