What is a form factor?

Model Independent Nucleon results
Gerald A. Miller
University of Washington
“Everything that rises”, Martin Puryear
Blind men and the elephant
Physicists and the nucleon
Soliton
s
s
pion
gluon
d
u
Experimental Observables/outline
Tranverse Momentum Distributions
form
factors
TMDs
GPDs
Generalized Parton Distributions
Experimental Observables/outline
Nucleon
form
factors
TMDs
Shape
charge density
spin
GPDs
Aim: unified picture (including spin)
What is a form factor? How to tell
how big something is?
• Look
e’
q
e
Proton
P
Deep
Inelastic
Scattering
q(x)
What is a form factor? How to tell
how big something is?
Proton
• Look
P+q
Elastic
e’
Non rel form factor -old
q
e
Proton
P
Elastic electron scattering from a nucleon
j=<e’||e
>
J=<p’||p>
Deep inelastic
scattering
Nucleon vertex:
i
  p, p'    F (Q2)   F (Q2)
1
2M 2
Dirac
1990 Nobel Prize
Pauli
Cross section for scattering
from a point-like object
Form factors describing
nucleon shape/structure
1961 Nobel Prize
Expectations- Pre Jlab
Proton
QF2 /F1
GE/GM
Q2
old helicity conservation
Q2
Jlab
Jlab
QF2 /F1
GE/GM
QF2/F1
GE/GM
Q2
Q2
Proton
Meaning of elastic form factors-I
Old Interpretation- Breit frame
GE is helicity flip matrix element of J0
Interpretation: GE(Q2) = Fourier trans. of charge density
Relativistic : wave function is frame
dependent, initial and final states differ
interpretation of Sachs FF is wrong
Light cone coordinates/Infinite
momentum frame
Relativistic formalismkinematic subgroup of Poincare
• Lorentz transformation –transverse
velocity v
k- such that k2 not changed
Just like non-relativistic
+
with k as mass
Model- Impulse Approximation

carry orbital
angular
momentum
Frank,
Jennings,
Miller ‘95
Ratio of Pauli to Dirac Form Factors
Frank,Jennings, Miller theory1995, data
2000
Model flat curve due to orbital
ang. mom.
Orbital angular momentum and
proton shape
orbital angular momentum
Shape of proton??
Wigner Eckart-no quadrupole moment
spin dependent densities SDD
Non-relativistic example

s
r
Shapes of the proton
three vectors n, K, S
MODEL , HOW TO MEASURE?
Field theoretic SDD
•
Probability for momentum K, and spin direction n. Matrix elements
depend on three vectors n, K, S, equal time
Transverse Momentum Distributions TMDs
x=K+/P+ Mulders & Tangerman ’96
Polarized TMD Quark Distributions
Nucleon
Unpol.
Long.
Trans.
Quark
Unpol.
Long.
Trans.
Boer, Mulders, Tangerman (96&98)
Field theoretic SDD
•
Probability for momentum K, and spin direction n. Matrix elements
depend on three vectors n, K, S, equal time
Transverse Momentum Distributions TMDs
x=K+/P+ Mulders & Tangerman ‘96
i+5~+i ~ 0 i
Integrate: SDD over Kz ; TMD over x: non-
spherical nature of proton related to
Model-Transverse spindependent densities
n
n
S
Lattice calcs have done GPD, not TMD
:e, p  e’,  X
Measure
ST
e’
e

Cross section has term proportional to cos 3
Boer Mulders ‘98
Summary of SDD
• SDD are closely related to TMD’s
• If
is not 0, proton is not
round. Experiment can show
proton ain’t round.
The Proton
Journey to the center of the
neutron: charge density
πp
One gluon exchange also gives
positive central charge density
center is +
center is +
d u d
e-i q
b
Parameterizations of nucleon form factors
hep-ex/0602017
Results
BBBA
Kelly
Negative
Negative F1
means central
density negative
Why?
GeV2
Generalized Parton Distributions :
yield 3-dim quark structure of
nucleon
Elastic Scattering
transverse quark
distribution in
coordinate space
DIS
longitudinal
quark distribution
in momentum space
quark orbital angular momentum
Burkardt (2000,2003)
Belitsky,Ji,Yuan (2004)
DES (GPDs)
fully-correlated
quark distribution in
both coordinate and
momentum space
relate:high x, high Q2 , low b
Input distribution
x
Neutron- dv dominates at high x (b=0) ????
Neutron charge distribution vs x
u
x<0.1
x>0.5
d
high x: d dominates at small b
Neutron ρ(b,x)
x=0.3
x=0.1
x=0.5
d dominates at high x, low b
Neutron Interpretation
b
How does the proton spin?
Quark spin Crisis :
polarized (beam and target) DIS experiments
Total quark spin contribution is about 30%
Ultimate goal of spin physics
• Spin sum rule 30 %
Quark spin,
Best known
Gluon spin,
Poorly known
41
7/28/2017
Orbital Angular Momentum
of quarks and gluons,
Little known
World efforts for spin physics
Current
Lepton-nucleon
scattering
HERMES,
COMPASS,
RHIC@BNL
pp@200GeV
SLAC
E142-155
JLAB
– Polarized protonproton scattering,
RHIC
Future facilities
–
–
–
–
HERMES@ DESY
e--p @27GeV
EMC@
CERN
Jefferson Lab
e-p@6GeV
COMPASS@CERN
 p@160GeV
Jlab-12GeV
EIC
JPARC (Japan)
GSI-FAIR
(Germany)
All these experiments have their unique coverage on
q, g, Lq,g, and they are complementary
42
7/28/2017
Sea quark polarization
• One can measure the sea quark contribution to the
spin of the proton through fragmentation of the
polarized quark into mesons
HERMES, 2004
Semi-inclusive DIS
• Major topic at JLab 12GeV
43
7/28/2017
small, so far
GLUON SPIN From DIS
measurements
7/28/2017
44
Exciting results from RHICproton proton scattering
Double longitudinal spin asymmetry
STAR
•The gluon pol. is small, but the uncertainty is large.
Future data will improve!
arXiv:0710.2048 [hep-ex]
Hunting for Lq:
Generalised Parton Distributions (GPDs)


( H + E) x dx = Jq = 1/2 S  Lz
30%
GPDs



Ji,96
DIS
DVCS
Can be measured in deeply
virtual Compton scattering and
other hard exclusive processes
Related to form factors and
parton distributions
Comprehensive programs at
JLab,HERMES,COMPASS
Parton Distributions
Generalized
Parton Distributions
Mueller et al.,94;Ji,96; Radyushkin ,96
Lattice Simulation of GPDs
Ld + Lu cancel? Q2
evolution Thomas
‘08
Where are we now for the spin
puzzle
Quark spin 30 %
Gluon spin 0-70%, <0?
q
Lq
48
G
LG
Proton Spin
Summary and conclude
• Form factors reveal transverse charge density
(center of neutron negative)
• TMDs reveal momentum & spin distributionsproton not round if
≠0
• GPDs reveal x, b distributions- high x quarks are at
low b
• Spin of nucleon is not yet understood,
many try and this is solvable
• Thanks for slides to
• Roy Holt, Marc Vanderhaeghen, Feng Yuan
Total neutron charge distribution
x<0.23
total
x>0.23
d dominates at high x, low b
The spin puzzle in horizon
Gluon spin~ 0-70%, <0?
RHIC, EIC, …
Quark spin ~30%
DIS, and pp coll.
q
Lq
7/28/2017
G
LG
Deeply Virtual Compton Scattering,
Transverse spin physics, in DIS, pp coll.
51
Summary
• We are in the early stages of a very
exciting era of proton spin physics
studies, where the future RHIC, JLAB,
JPARC, FAIR, and EIC experiments will
certainly play very important roles
• We will learn more about QCD dynamics
and nucleon structure from these
studies, especially for the quark orbital
motion
52
ExpectationsJlab Pre Jlab
QF2 /F1
GE/GM
QF2/F1
GE/GM
Q2
Q2
Proton
Spin density operator: d(r-rp)  . n
Canted ferromagnetic
structure of UNiGe
high magnetic fields
• Neutron magnetic
scattering
• Neutron, B, crystal
PRB65, 144429
RHIC spin
u
unpol.
55
7/28/2017
Global fit constrains the gluon
spin from the RHIC data
Polarized sea and gluon distributions
RHIC spin asymmetries
de Florian, Sassot, Stratmann and Vogelsang (0804.0422)
Naive Model of Nucleon
Proton 2 u, 1 d,
Neutron 2 d, 1 u
Confined quarks move with zero
orbital angular momentum
“Spin Crisis”
Quarks carry only 30 % of proton spin
three ideasu,d quarks surrounded by s s
gluons carry angular momentum
quarks carry orbital angular momentum
Proton- connect x and b
x<0.1
x>.5
high x-low b
Naive Quark Model of Proton,
Neutron (nucleon)
Proton 2 u(2/3 ), 1 d
Neutron 2 d(-1/3) 1 u
Confined quarks move with zero
orbital angular momentum
Why study the nucleon?
•
•
•
•
Neutrons protons made of quarks, gluons
Quantum Chromodynamics QCD
CONFINEMENT
How does the nucleon stick together when
struck by photon?
• Where is charge and magnetization density
located? Origin of angular momentum?
• What is the shape of the proton?
How to study the proton?
• EXPERIMENTS
• Theory –numerical simulations lattice
masses + … low Q2
eventually exact
• Phenomenology- symmetries,
dynamical guesses, high Q2
• Model independent techniques
what the lattice will find
How proton holds together-high Q2
• pQCD
Feynman
Non perturbative
∞ gluon exch


width in Brel
~independent of x
DSSV spin content
• The gluon pol. is small, but the uncertainty is large.
Future data will improve this
DVCS with transversely
polarized target from HERMES & Jlab
JLab Hall A
Jq input parameter in the GPD ansatz, need
More sophisticted model
for GPDs
HERMES
Jlab Hall A, 0709.0450; HERMES, 0802.2499
Definitions and high Q2 predictions
2
old helicity conservation
ExpectationsJlab Pre Jlab
QF2 /F1
GE/GM
QF2/F1
GE/GM
Q2
Q2
Proton