Sterile neutrinos at
the Neutrino Factory
IDS-NF plenary meeting
October 19-21, 2011
Arlington, VA, USA
Walter Winter
Universität Würzburg
Contents






Motivation
Steriles at near detectors
Steriles at far detectors
Simulation and general constraints
Dependence on assumptions
Summary
(mostly based on: Meloni, Tang, Winter,
Phys.Rev. D82 (2010) 093008, arXiv:1007.2419)
2
Motivation: eV2 sterile ns
(B. Fleming, TAUP 2011)
(arXiv:1007.1150)
 LSND/MiniBooNE antineutrinos
 Reactor anomaly
 Global fits
(Kopp, Maltoni, Schwetz,
1103.4570)
3
Arbitrary sterile ns
 Cosmology: upper bound O(1 eV)
 However: sterile neutrinos even preferred,
if light enough
 Cannot exclude
that light sterile
neutrinos “hide“
among the actives
m3
m4 ?
m2
m1
(Hamann et al, Phys.Rev.Lett. 105 (2010) 181301)
4
Steriles at near detectors
… focus on 3+1 framework in the following
(for the sake of simplicity)
Oscillation physics
 Can be described independent of
parameterization (with mixing matrix only)
 Probabilities for short baseline limit:
Observation:
Appearance probabilities
depend on two mixing matrix
entries, disappearance
probabilities on one
6
Choice of parameterization
 Why do I need a parameterization?
 Requirements for a parameterization:
 Our parameterization:
(Meloni, Tang, Winter, arXiv:1007.2419)
 Less parameters (unitarity assumed!)
 Convenient if long-baseline included (matter effects)
7
Oscillation physics (2)
 For small mixing angles: qualitatively
similar to param.-independent approach
(Meloni, Tang, Winter, arXiv:1007.2419)
 Parameterization dependent probabilities in
short baseline limit:
8
Performance indicators
 Discuss constraints for individual parameters
(sensitivity limits for q14, q24, q34)
 Requires marginalization over unknown other
parameters
 Renders appearance channels useless: always
sensitive to a combination of mixing matrix
elements/parameters
 Main sensitivities:
 q14: Pee (difficult at NuFact)
 q24: Pmm (leading at NuFact)
 q34: Ptt (currently impossible)
9
Sterile at far detectors
Oscillation physics
 Peculiarity: NC matter effect (affects only
active states)
 Probabilities to 2nd order:
q difficult at long baseline,
14
q24 easiest,
q34 by Pmt (discovery channel)?
[but: high enough statistics
compared to h.o.t. in other channels?]
(Meloni, Tang, Winter, arXiv:1007.2419; Discovery channel: Donini et al., arXiv:0812.3703)
11
Hierarchy dependence
 Characterized rel. to mass eigenstate 1:
 Case |Dm412| ~ |Dm312|:
 A+D: m3 and m4 on top of each other
 B+C: m3 and m4 different (Dm412 = - Dm312)
Easier to identify because of matter effects?
12
Simulation and general
constraints
Assumptions
 IDS-NF baseline 1.0 (50 kt + 50 kt)
 Near detectors:
 At d=2 km with 32 t each (far detector limit)
 Electron CID with 40% efficiency, 1% mis-ID
 NB: May in fact need
additional near-near
detectors to control
systematics in disappearance channels
 See my other talk
(+ Giunti, Laveder, Winter, arXiv:0907.5487)
 Also tested seperately: OPERA-inspired MECC at
same distance, hadronic channels, 10 kt
14
Generalized exclusion limits
… without any constraints on Dm412
90% CL,
2 d.o.f.
From ne
disppearance
From nm
disppearance
From LBL-nm
disppearance
(higher order effect)
(Meloni, Tang, Winter, arXiv:1007.2419)
15
Hierarchy dependence
 A+D: Sensitivity
at |Dm412| ~ |Dm312|
destroyed (correlations)
(Meloni, Tang, Winter, arXiv:1007.2419)
16
Dependence on assumptions
What special assumptions
often made?
 LSND-motivated Dm412
Fast oscillation averaged out at long L
 Special case Dm412  0
(MINOS, Adamson et al, arXiv:1003.0336)
Also no additional Dm412
See Meloni, Tang, Winter, arXiv:1007.2419
 Two-flavor limits, e.g.
(corresponds to same formula in our
parameterization with Dm2 = Dm412 , q = q14)
18
q24-q34 for LSND assump.
 Now if fast oscillations average out, twoparameter combinations can be tested:
(otherwise Dm412-marginalization
would lead to vanishing sensitivity)
 nt detection at long
baseline (Pmt) adds
only little if magic
baseline included
(higher statistics
in Pmm!)
(Meloni, Tang, Winter, arXiv:1007.2419; Discovery channel: Donini et al., arXiv:0812.3703)
19
Near detectors added
 Impact of ND
depends on
assumptions:
 Dm412 very large:
Oscillations in ND
averaged out
 Dm412 ~ 1 eV2:
ND sensitive to
spectral signature
Curve
from last
slide
(Meloni, Tang, Winter, arXiv:1007.2419)
20
Comparison to MINOS
 Also experimental
collaborations use
special assumptions,
e.g. additional
parameters fixed
 Comparison to
MINOS: Tremendous
increase of
sensitivity, especially
for large q13
 Is 3+N a physics
case for the Neutrino
Factory, even if q13
large?
(Meloni, Tang, Winter, arXiv:1007.2419;
compared to MINOS, Adamson et al, arXiv:1003.0336)
21
Summary and conclusions
 Sterile neutrinos may have Dm412 ~ 1 eV2,
but could also hide among the actives
Technically challenging, therefore hardly
tested?
 Neutrino factory can access some of the
sterile parameters very well, even at the
longer baselines Dm412 ~ 10-4 – 10-1 eV2
 Precision physics case even for large q13?
 So far, no physics case for nt found;
perhaps additional phases for steriles?
22